Is this another example of a potentially crucial error by the VRD handler?

[G-Unit]

Grimes expert credentials;

I am a Subject Matter Expert registered with N.C.P.E.(National Center for Policing Excellence)
https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/MARTIN_GRIMES_PERSONAL.htm

[faithlilly]

What a conundrum that must be for those who think I am biased.

Not really. Needs must I suppose.

[Mr Gray]

Grimes expert credentials;

I am a Subject Matter Expert registered with N.C.P.E.(National Center for Policing Excellence)
https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/MARTIN_GRIMES_PERSONAL.htm

Have you ever read what a poster named... Poacher... said about Grime and his claims

I had never seen the posts and had made my own mind up... It was quite a surprise to read them

[Robittybob1]

I suppose they were hopeful of finding the missing child's blood and DNA somewhere.

Madeleine had been playing for the best part of a week in the apartment, you expect to find her DNA and possibly a speck of blood if she was prone to nose bleeds.

[Robittybob1]

Human remains

Finally you have answered the question, thank you. 

Where could the remains be found that would corroborate the cadaver alerts?  If the remains were found dumped in Huelva after the 3rd of August that might be evidential but if they had been there since the 4th of May what would be the connection to the apartment?

I think you are right but there would still need to be some evidence Madeleine was not alive when she was taken from the apartment. 

Like, and I'm sure you would agree, if she wandered (alive) and was subsequently killed by a car (dead), unless someone first brings her back home why would a cadaver have been in the apartment?

[Mr Gray]

Finally you have answered the question, thank you. 

Where could the remains be found that would corroborate the cadaver alerts?  If the remains were found dumped in Huelva after the 3rd of August that might be evidential but if they had been there since the 4th of May what would be the connection to the apartment?

I think you are right but there would still need to be some evidence Madeleine was not alive when she was taken from the apartment. 

Like, and I'm sure you would agree, if she wandered (alive) and was subsequently killed by a car (dead), unless someone first brings her back home why would a cadaver have been in the apartment?

Unlike you Rob I think the alerts are a total red herring

[slartibartfast]

Have you ever read what a poster named... Poacher... said about Grime and his claims

I had never seen the posts and had made my own mind up... It was quite a surprise to read them

Found a few quoted by nessling.

[Mr Gray]

Found a few quoted by nessling.

I think they make very interesting  reading...

[misty]

Unlike you Rob I think the alerts are a total red herring

IMO the alerts to the clothing would be very difficult to defend as anything other than cadaver dog error should someone other than the McCanns be prosecuted.

[Robittybob1]

Unlike you Rob I think the alerts are a total red herring

You've been telling me for about 2 and a half years that corroborating evidence was required and now claim they are a "red herring".

What does that mean?  "a clue or piece of information which is or is intended to be misleading or distracting."
"synonyms:   bluff, blind, ruse, feint, deception, subterfuge, hoax, trick, ploy, device, wile, sham, pretence, artifice, cover, smokescreen, distraction, expedient, contrivance, machination;"

Who would do such a thing?  Plenty of people have had access to the apartment in the meantime so it would be definitely possible to set someone up.  Is that what you mean someone set up a deception?

[Robittybob1]

IMO the alerts to the clothing would be very difficult to defend as anything other than cadaver dog error should someone other than the McCanns be prosecuted.

Apartment and the clothes who had access to both those?  Eddie didn't alert to the clothes while they were at the villa, but it was a different story after they had been boxed by the PJ.

[Mr Gray]

You've been telling me for about 2 and a half years that corroborating evidence was required and now claim they are a "red herring".

What does that mean?  "a clue or piece of information which is or is intended to be misleading or distracting."
"synonyms:   bluff, blind, ruse, feint, deception, subterfuge, hoax, trick, ploy, device, wile, sham, pretence, artifice, cover, smokescreen, distraction, expedient, contrivance, machination;"

Who would do such a thing?  Plenty of people have had access to the apartment in the meantime so it would be definitely possible to set someone up.  Is that what you mean someone set up a deception?

I'm referring to the alerts, as a distraction... Not a hoax
I don't believe  there was ever a cadaver in 5a

[Robittybob1]

I'm referring to the alerts, as a distraction... Not a hoax
I don't believe  there was ever a cadaver in 5a

I don't think belief are a legitimate method of sorting this out.  The alerts are visible on video, either they are real or they are a deception being played on the McCanns. 

[Mr Gray]

I don't think belief are a legitimate method of sorting this out.  The alerts are visible on video, either they are real or they are a deception being played on the McCanns.

I think I agree with you...was the alert to cuddle cat real

[Robittybob1]

I think I agree with you...was the alert to cuddle cat real

Grime talks of an alert on CC that I've yet to see on video tape.  Maybe we don't have the full story yet.