Has disgraced former cop Gonçalo Amaral appealed his conviction?

[ferryman]

11th post in the link.

http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=2853.msg99023#msg99023

As for cases being overturned, I don't remember any but that doesn't mean that there weren't any.

(Montclair)

[faithlilly]

It was a Portuguese national who used that phrase.  Is it the only miscarriage of justice in Portugal?  According to a poster on here there has NEVER been a miscarriage of justice in Portugal!

And an anonymous poster on this forum is the font of all knowledge, are they?

I have been involved in several horrendous miscarriages of justice in this country. Should we then also be considered ' a third world nation' ?

[Alfie]

And an anonymous poster on this forum is the font of all knowledge, are they?

I have been involved in several horrendous miscarriages of justice in this country. Should we then also be considered ' a third world nation' ?

You live in a country where miscarriages of justice have been identified and therefore measures can be taken to seek redress.  If you live in a country where it the concept "miscarriage of justice" doesn't even seem to be acknowledged then how does one ever know about it or seek redress? 
But maybe Montclair was wrong as you suggest and Portugal is full of miscarriages of justice that have been highlighted, and redress sought and won. 

[faithlilly]

You live in a country where miscarriages of justice have been identified and therefore measures can be taken to seek redress.  If you live in a country where it the concept "miscarriage of justice" doesn't even seem to be acknowledged then how does one ever know about it or seek redress? 
But maybe Montclair was wrong as you suggest and Portugal is full of miscarriages of justice that have been highlighted, and redress sought and won.

The whole basis of your argument seems to stems from one post on this forum. Is that correct?

[Alfie]

The whole basis of your argument seems to stems from one post on this forum. Is that correct?

I am not arguing, simply pointing out.   I have already conceded in my previous post that Montclair may have been talking out of his trumpet.  It wouldn't be the first time blatant misinformation has been posted on this forum!

[faithlilly]

I am not arguing, simply pointing out.   I have already conceded in my previous post that Montclair may have been talking out of his trumpet.  It wouldn't be the first time blatant misinformation has been posted on this forum!

Pointing out? Pointing out what? That a poster sometime ago claimed there was no miscarriages of justice in Portugal but you've found one?

Thank you Alfie. Your worth to this forum is immeasurable.

[Mr Gray]

So which is it?

Alfie "there has NEVER been a miscarriage of justice in Portugal".
Davel "no major case where a miscarriage of justice has been admitted".

And why are you filling in for Alfie?

Because it's a free forum and I can respond to any posts I wish
Do you have a problem with that

[Alfie]

Pointing out? Pointing out what? That a poster sometime ago claimed there was no miscarriages of justice in Portugal but you've found one?

Thank you Alfie. Your worth to this forum is immeasurable.

You're welcome, and I know 

[ShiningInLuz]

Because it's a free forum and I can respond to any posts I wish
Do you have a problem with that

"So which is it?

Alfie "there has NEVER been a miscarriage of justice in Portugal".
Davel "no major case where a miscarriage of justice has been admitted".

And why are you filling in for Alfie?"

Duck, swerve, dive.

Seemingly, upon no occasion is it fit and proper to answer the issue in question.

[Alfie]

"So which is it?

Alfie "there has NEVER been a miscarriage of justice in Portugal".
Davel "no major case where a miscarriage of justice has been admitted".

And why are you filling in for Alfie?"

Duck, swerve, dive.

Seemingly, upon no occasion is it fit and proper to answer the issue in question.

Why are you bullying Davel about something I said?

[Mr Gray]

"So which is it?

Alfie "there has NEVER been a miscarriage of justice in Portugal".
Davel "no major case where a miscarriage of justice has been admitted".

And why are you filling in for Alfie?"

Duck, swerve, dive.

Seemingly, upon no occasion is it fit and proper to answer the issue in question.

Whichever it is it's an absolute disgrace
The post is there
I can answer any post I want
Unless you have changed the rules

[Mr Gray]

Sil must understand she is new to the forum and some things have been discussed a million times
Another reason I answered the post is because the original post by Montclair was addressed to me