Is there more circumstantial evidence against the mccanns than there is CB

[barrier]

Theories are only Theories.  There is nothing else.  So please yourselves.  Sheesh, what happened to Logic?

Disappears once logged in.

[barrier]

Not according to Barrier.

A cite where I have said any such thing,you'll not find one so don't bother looking.

[G-Unit]

Rob, just in case you didn’t know it - Katie Hopkins is one of the most hateful and hated public figures in Britain.   Her above diatribe (whilst much admired by sceptics) is just one example of her hatefulness.  I brlieve she has been denied most media platforms now so is less able to spread her hate.

Katie Hopkins may not be popular, but she was right in the above cite. Leaving children home alone is not acceptable and people have been prosecuted for less.

[Eleanor]

An accusation of lying;

"some time after Eddies time on the Madeleine case, this so called enhanced dog went to the States.   There he was trained on human carcases.   But it is my belief that it was after 'The Madeleine case', not before."
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=11731.msg625589#msg625589

Grime quite clearly said he had been to America BEFORE he was called to PdL.

But I don't think he took Eddie with him.  Surely The South Yorkshire Police wouldn't have allowed this.  And Eddie did belong to them after all.

[Mr Gray]

An accusation of lying;

"some time after Eddies time on the Madeleine case, this so called enhanced dog went to the States.   There he was trained on human carcases.   But it is my belief that it was after 'The Madeleine case', not before."
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=11731.msg625589#msg625589

Grime quite clearly said he had been to America BEFORE he was called to PdL.

He had been to america...but one what basis. An informal discussion is not advising the FBI.

We dont need Ady to analyse Grimes statements...i'm quite capable of doing it myself.

It says in the court report that both grime and stockham opined that the dog alert was ..to a reasonable degree of scientific certainty


that is an untrue stateemnt

[Venturi Swirl]

An accusation of lying;

"some time after Eddies time on the Madeleine case, this so called enhanced dog went to the States.   There he was trained on human carcases.   But it is my belief that it was after 'The Madeleine case', not before."
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=11731.msg625589#msg625589

Grime quite clearly said he had been to America BEFORE he was called to PdL.

And yet the forum is littered with similar accusations about the Tapas Group not being straight about the times they did their checks and you don’t seem to have a problem with that!

[Venturi Swirl]

Katie Hopkins may not be popular, but she was right in the above cite. Leaving children home alone is not acceptable and people have been prosecuted for less.

Gosh, you don’t say?!  Well thanks to you and Katie Hopkins for pointing out the bleeding obvious for the eight millionth time in 13 years.

[Mr Gray]

Katie Hopkins may not be popular, but she was right in the above cite. Leaving children home alone is not acceptable and people have been prosecuted for less.

cite for...prosecuted for less

[Robittybob1]

In other words, it's your fault if a paedophile steals your child while it is left unattended as you encouraged the paedophile to do this.

I suppose that could be the case if everyone gets to know that you are leaving your kids alone.
It's the difference between it being kept a secret and broadcasting it. 

Kate became aware there was a note on the appointment book that was found in the file given to her.  So she must have thought it secret, but it was potentially broadcast, unbeknown to her at the time.

[Lace]

You seem to be accusing Martin Grime of telling lies. Isn't that what Brietta refers to as 'implied libel'? There's absolutely no reason to suppose Grime lied about his experience and knowledge. It would have been very foolish to risk destroying his own credibility at a time when he was retiring from the police and setting up his own business.

Pig is used as it has been proven in training and operationally over the last 20 years to be a reliable analogue for human remains detecting training for dogs...

In my role as advisor to the U.S. Justice Department I have facilitated assessment of numerous cadaver search dog teams in the United States.These dogs are exclusively trained using human cadaver sources. When I introduced decomposing pig cadavers into training assessments 100 % of the animals alerted to the medium. (The products were obtained from whole piglet cadaver not processed food for human consumption). The result from scientific experiments and research to date is suggestive that the scent of human and pig decomposing material is so similar that we are unable to 'train' the dog to distinguish between the two.
https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/MARTIN_GRIMES.htm

I read that at a certain state of decomposition there is a gas that the pig emits that smells the same as a human but it certainly isn't in the  'fresh stage'  of decomposition.   It is only in the second stage that the body emits gases.  Grime wouldn't have had fresh decomposing piglets to train his dog on.   They wouldn't be experimenting to see when a cadaver dog would be able to smell the scent of death in America,  all they would want is for a cadaver dog to alert to a dead body.   If the pig is so similar why are they still using human remains to train cadaver dogs and why are trainers bemoaning the fact that they can't train their dogs on cadavers in Britain?

[Lace]

Katie Hopkins may not be popular, but she was right in the above cite. Leaving children home alone is not acceptable and people have been prosecuted for less.

I think that the fact they were checking on them regularly was a factor in this case.   Social Services visited the McCann's and they were happy that they were responsible parents,  so are you saying our Social Services should be questioned?

[Eleanor]

I read that at a certain state of decomposition there is a gas that the pig emits that smells the same as a human but it certainly isn't in the  'fresh stage'  of decomposition.   It is only in the second stage that the body emits gases.  Grime wouldn't have had fresh decomposing piglets to train his dog on.   They wouldn't be experimenting to see when a cadaver dog would be able to smell the scent of death in America,  all they would want is for a cadaver dog to alert to a dead body.   If the pig is so similar why are they still using human remains to train cadaver dogs and why are trainers bemoaning the fact that they can't train their dogs on cadavers in Britain?

No were to put a Body Farm, perhaps.  And who in Britain would stand for that anyway?

The Bodies have to be Donated in the first instance.  Anybody up for that?

[Venturi Swirl]

I read that at a certain state of decomposition there is a gas that the pig emits that smells the same as a human but it certainly isn't in the  'fresh stage'  of decomposition.   It is only in the second stage that the body emits gases.  Grime wouldn't have had fresh decomposing piglets to train his dog on.   They wouldn't be experimenting to see when a cadaver dog would be able to smell the scent of death in America,  all they would want is for a cadaver dog to alert to a dead body.   If the pig is so similar why are they still using human remains to train cadaver dogs and why are trainers bemoaning the fact that they can't train their dogs on cadavers in Britain?

I wonder how many times Eddie was trained on detecting a cadaver thst had been dead for less than 90 minutes and in situ months previously.  Zero I would imagine. 

[Myster]

No were to put a Body Farm, perhaps.  And who in Britain would stand for that anyway?

The Bodies have to be Donated in the first instance.  Anybody up for that?

There's always a first time... https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-019-01436-8

[Wonderfulspam]

In other words, it's your fault if a paedophile steals your child while it is left unattended as you encouraged the paedophile to do this.

I agree.