Amaral and the dogs

[Mr Gray]

Amaral's theory has as much validy as any other at this moment in time. When someone proves that something else happened, then he is wrong.

try and keep up..it's not his theory we are criticising..it's his claims that the evidence proves his theory..it doesn't..he is lying

[G-Unit]

try and keep up..it's not his theory we are criticising..it's his claims that the evidence proves his theory..it doesn't..he is lying

I prefer to think he actually believed what he was saying; that the evidence proved his theory. I would imagine it happens a lot to policemen even here in the UK. They present the evidence they've gathered and the CPS says 'not good enough'.

[Brietta]

I prefer to think he actually believed what he was saying; that the evidence proved his theory. I would imagine it happens a lot to policemen even here in the UK. They present the evidence they've gathered and the CPS says 'not good enough'.

It is an elementary mistake to formulate a theory then try to make the evidence fit.  If you prefer to think he actually believed it what you are saying that he is unprofessional and a fool.

[Mr Gray]

I prefer to think he actually believed what he was saying; that the evidence proved his theory. I would imagine it happens a lot to policemen even here in the UK. They present the evidence they've gathered and the CPS says 'not good enough'.

The fact is amaral had no evidence. he can think what he wants and have what theories he wants...but when he says he can prove Maddie died in the apartment he is lying. He ignored the advice of the experts...Harrison and grime and continued to lie. that is a serious allegation..but it's true

[G-Unit]

It is an elementary mistake to formulate a theory then try to make the evidence fit.  If you prefer to think he actually believed it what you are saying that he is unprofessional and a fool.

I'm not saying he formulated a theory first. There were a lot of things done and said by the parents and their friends which made them look guilty. The dog alerts were the final piece in the jigsaw for the police. All circumstantial evidence, but I think he believed it all added up to proof. You may not like it, but it's a fact that lots of people began to wonder about the parent's story some time before the PJ Files were released.

[Mr Gray]

I'm not saying he formulated a theory first. There were a lot of things done and said by the parents and their friends which made them look guilty. The dog alerts were the final piece in the jigsaw for the police. All circumstantial evidence, but I think he believed it all added up to proof. You may not like it, but it's a fact that lots of people began to wonder about the parent's story some time before the PJ Files were released.

lots of people question the parents..fair enough. Amarael lied about the evidence...disgraceful

[stephen25000]

lots of people question the parents..fair enough. Amarael lied about the evidence...disgraceful

He misinterpreted the evidence dave.

 

[Mr Gray]

He misinterpreted the evidence dave.

Harrison and Grime have made it clear what the alerts signify...Amaral lied

[slartibartfast]

Harrison and Grime have made it clear what the alerts signify...Amaral lied

He selected a narrative that fitted the available evidence.

[stephen25000]

Harrison and Grime have made it clear what the alerts signify...Amaral lied

Did Amaral first read Harrison and Grimes full reports ?

Were they written in English and/or Portuguese ?

How many others in the PJ thought the same about the mccanns ?

[Mr Gray]

He selected a narrative that fitted the available evidence.

he lied...he stated he could prove maddie died in the apartment.....using the evidence of the dogs...he couldn't..he lied

[Mr Gray]

Did Amaral first read Harrison and Grimes full reports ?

Were they written in English and/or Portuguese ?

How many others in the PJ thought the same about the mccanns ?

Grimes rogatory would have been translated into Portuguese...amaral lied about the dogs

[Montclair]

He misinterpreted the evidence dave.

He didn't misinterpret the evidence either. He wasn't a one man team investigating the disappearance. That is a myth spread by the supporters in order to diss the evidence and the dogs, the worst enemies of the McCanns.

What would any police force think if these specialist dogs alerted 11 times to only articles, houses and a car related to the parents and did not give any alerts to any other "suspects" such as Robert Murat?

Davel, you seem obsessed with those dogs. They bother you, don't they?

[Mr Gray]

He didn't misinterpret the evidence either. He wasn't a one man team investigating the disappearance. That is a myth spread by the supporters in order to diss the evidence and the dogs, the worst enemies of the McCanns.

What would any police force think if these specialist dogs alerted 11 times to only articles, houses and a car related to the parents and did not give any alerts to any other "suspects" such as Robert Murat?

Davel, you seem obsessed with those dogs. They bother you, don't they?

You show how serious amaral's lies were and how they have convinced you. This is what Harrison said about the dogs and he's an expert..

However, it must be stated any such indications without any physical evidence to support them can not have any evidential value, being unconfirmed indications. Additionally I consider no inference can be drawn as to whether a human cadaver has previously been in any location without other supporting physical evidence.


Amaral lied about the dogs and you prove his lies have been believed

[Mr Gray]

He didn't misinterpret the evidence either. He wasn't a one man team investigating the disappearance. That is a myth spread by the supporters in order to diss the evidence and the dogs, the worst enemies of the McCanns.

What would any police force think if these specialist dogs alerted 11 times to only articles, houses and a car related to the parents and did not give any alerts to any other "suspects" such as Robert Murat?

Davel, you seem obsessed with those dogs. They bother you, don't they?

No one is dissing the dogs...I'm dissing amaral and you...you and amaral are ignoring what the experts say about the alerts