Strange Witness Statements

[pegasus]

Could you tell me openly who you are referring to when you say SY have already ruled this witness out

This was explained by the head of Op Grange in http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OZ8jmdWlB8Y

[Robittybob1]

This was explained by the head of Op Grange in http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OZ8jmdWlB8Y

Smithman
Crecheman
Smithman
Which one?

[pegasus]

Smithman
Crecheman
Smithman
Which one?

http://youtu.be/OZ8jmdWlB8Y?t=22m53s "we are almost certain now..."

[Robittybob1]

http://youtu.be/OZ8jmdWlB8Y?t=22m53s "we are almost certain now..."

Smithman is not the abductor - I'd worked that out.  To me it was a person carrying an unconscious child remember.

[pegasus]

Smithman is not the abductor - I'd worked that out.  To me it was a person carrying an unconscious child remember.

IMO the Smith sighting is irrelevant Robbity. It's absurd for the investigators to make the bizarre assumption, that the solution must involve a perp openly carrying a visible child through populated streets.

[pathfinder73]

IMO the Smith sighting is irrelevant Robbity. It's absurd for the investigators to make the bizarre assumption, that the solution must involve a perp openly carrying a visible child through populated streets.

When you understand the circumstances then the rest is simple. Smithman had to use his feet and there's nothing suspicious about carrying a sleeping child late a night in Luz.

[sadie]

IMO the Smith sighting is irrelevant Robbity. It's absurd for the investigators to make the bizarre assumption, that the solution must involve a perp openly carrying a visible child through populated streets.

OK, so what about if the "get away" vehicle was unable to pick up, frightened off because Gerry and Jez were so close and Jane Tanner had witnessed Madeleine being abducted ?    Have you disallowed that?

I think that the getaway vehicle was parked on the little parking area immediately opposite the Tapas reception .... and the driver would have had to pass Gerry, Jez and Jane to reach the abductor Tannerman.   Seeing them he took fright and drove off south down the road Rua Dr F.G.Martins, abandoning Tannerman with Madeleine.

[pegasus]

OK, so what about if the "get away" vehicle was unable to pick up, frightened off because Gerry and Jez were so close and Jane Tanner had witnessed Madeleine being abducted ?    Have you disallowed that?

I think that the getaway vehicle was parked on the little parking area immediately opposite the Tapas reception .... and the driver would have had to pass Gerry, Jez and Jane to reach the abductor Tannerman.   Seeing them he took fright and drove off south down the road Rua Dr F.G.Martins, abandoning Tannerman with Madeleine.

IMO no-one transported anyone or anything relevant that night by foot or vehicle.

[sadie]

IMO no-one transported anyone or anything relevant that night by foot or vehicle.

IYO..

OK, fair enough, stalemate.

You have a theory and I have a totally different theory .... and my guess is that unless you produce some pretty substantial stuff, that is the way it will remain.

[pegasus]

IYO..

OK, fair enough, stalemate.

You have a theory and I have a totally different theory .... and my guess is that unless you produce some pretty substantial stuff, that is the way it will remain.

I have absolutely no theory about any mode of transportation that night Sadie.

[Robittybob1]

IMO the Smith sighting is irrelevant Robbity. It's absurd for the investigators to make the bizarre assumption, that the solution must involve a perp openly carrying a visible child through populated streets.

No perps, just good caring people IMO.

[Robittybob1]

She could hold vital timeline information. Did she witness the alarm being raised? How long after the alarm did she leave? Did she know the time? It could take her about 5 minutes to walk that distance. The mother arrived at the night creche at 10:05 from JW statement informing them about the disappearance.

http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/JACQUELINE_WILLIAMS.htm 

[G-Unit]

Statement of Najoua Chekaya

09.30 she walked to Lagos from where she returned at about 11.30 and at about 11.45 went for lunch at the Tapas restaurant.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/NAJOUA_CHEKAYA.htm

According to Google Maps it takes between 2 and 2.5 hours to walk from Luz to Lagos.

[misty]

Statement of Najoua Chekaya

09.30 she walked to Lagos from where she returned at about 11.30 and at about 11.45 went for lunch at the Tapas restaurant.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/NAJOUA_CHEKAYA.htm

According to Google Maps it takes between 2 and 2.5 hours to walk from Luz to Lagos.

"caminhada" also means "outing" according to Google Translate.
https://translate.google.co.uk/#pt/en/caminhada

[G-Unit]

"caminhada" also means "outing" according to Google Translate.
https://translate.google.co.uk/#pt/en/caminhada

efectua um a caminhada até Lagos = take a walk to Lagos