What is the lie in Amarals book. The truth of the lie.

[Erngath]

I assume he is accusing someone of telling a lie?
And he is going to tell the truth about that lie.
So what is the lie?

104

[barrier]

I assume he is accusing someone of telling a lie?
And he is going to tell the truth about that lie.
So what is the lie?

Is not his opinion that Madeleine was not abducted as in the Parents claims there by his book in his opinion as backed by the courts is showing that claim to be a lie.

[Mr Gray]

Is not his opinion that Madeleine was not abducted as in the Parents claims there by his book in his opinion as backed by the courts is showing that claim to be a lie.

The abduction claim has not been shown to be a lie... Do you have a cite

What you are claiming is that amarals opinion is his opinion but the McCann opinion is a lie.... Which is patently  ridiculous

[Venturi Swirl]

Is not his opinion that Madeleine was not abducted as in the Parents claims there by his book in his opinion as backed by the courts is showing that claim to be a lie.

Did the courts back Amaral’s claim that abduction was a lie?  If so, kindly provde the cite.

[Erngath]

Is not his opinion that Madeleine was not abducted as in the Parents claims there by his book in his opinion as backed by the courts is showing that claim to be a lie.

Considering the "lie" has not been proven and he certainly can not do so, then the title of his book is outrageous and indeed libellous.IMO

[jassi]

Why this indignation so many years after the event?

[Eleanor]

Did anyone ever find his Ace?

[Erngath]

Did anyone ever find his Ace?

I doubt it ever existed or he's keeping it a closely guarded secret.
If he is, then he is guilty of perverting the course of justice.IMO

I started the thread because I have only read parts of the book and did wonder if someone who has read the entire book could reveal if he has accused the parents of only one lie or several lies.
And did he reveal "The Truth" to the satisfaction of anyone who has read it?

[G-Unit]

Did anyone ever find his Ace?

Like the McCann's claim that they knew things they couldn't reveal due to judicial secrecy. We still haven't been enlightened by them either.

[Eleanor]

Like the McCann's claim that they knew things they couldn't reveal due to judicial secrecy. We still haven't been enlightened by them either.

Not quite the same thing, is it.

[faithlilly]

I doubt it ever existed or he's keeping it a closely guarded secret.
If he is, then he is guilty of perverting the course of justice.IMO

I started the thread because I have only read parts of the book and did wonder if someone who has read the entire book could reveal if he has accused the parents of only one lie or several lies.
And did he reveal "The Truth" to the satisfaction of anyone who has read it?

If you haven’t read the whole book then you are commenting from an uninformed position. Could I respectfully suggest that you have full knowledge of what you are commenting on before commenting?

[Erngath]

If you haven’t read the whole book then you are commenting from an uninformed position. Could I respectfully suggest that you have full knowledge of what you are commenting on before commenting?

I was hoping that someone who had read the book would give me their opinion.
I really was commenting on the title of the book and expressing my opinion on that.
I do hope you are giving the same guidance to those who comment on the SY investigation who are also commenting from "an uniformed opinion" and should have " full knowledge" of the investigation before making any comment.

[Snowgirl]

I assume he is accusing someone of telling a lie?
And he is going to tell the truth about that lie.
So what is the lie?

Going to tell  ?
You’re a bit late to be asking about a book title  that’s back on sale, been online for years yet you say you havn’t read all of it but post as if you have  imo..
 

[Erngath]

For further clarification, I was  hoping a sceptic who had read the book and who believes  that there was indeed " a lie " told, did  on completion of the book  believe that there was indeed a lie and that he had explained "The truth of the lie" to their satisfaction.

[Erngath]

Going to tell  ?
You’re a bit late to be asking about a book title  that’s back on sale, been online for years yet you say you havn’t read all of it but post as if you have  imo..

I said I hadn't read all of the book.
Have you?