Author Topic: Former Portuguese detective Gonçalo Amaral wins appeal in damages trial.  (Read 533525 times)

0 Members and 5 Guests are viewing this topic.

Offline mercury

Re: Former Portuguese detective Gonçalo Amaral wins appeal in damages trial.
« Reply #1350 on: April 22, 2016, 09:50:05 PM »
The McCanns got it banned, overturned on Appeal, Supreme Court upheld the appeal.

And that has all happened, bar the second supreme court possible appeal, twice now. It all rsts if the supreme court a) bothers with it and b) if they do, whether they thnk the appeal court made a grave error in a point of law, as far as I understand it, but IIRC the appeal has t be based n a point of law to be heard in the frst place

stephen25000

  • Guest
Re: Former Portuguese detective Gonçalo Amaral wins appeal in damages trial.
« Reply #1351 on: April 22, 2016, 10:06:41 PM »
Oh yes, and then  just posed on some courthouse steps for effect. 8(0(*

They had the look of embarrassment combined with guilt.

Hardly surprising, bearing in mind they did the same as the mccanns and got away with it.

Offline mercury

Re: Former Portuguese detective Gonçalo Amaral wins appeal in damages trial.
« Reply #1352 on: April 22, 2016, 10:34:50 PM »
The money is not important to the mccanns

If it wasnt they wouldnt have asked for the grossly offensive sum of 1.2m euros. the first judge gave them half, the hgher judges gave them zero.

Offline G-Unit

Re: Former Portuguese detective Gonçalo Amaral wins appeal in damages trial.
« Reply #1353 on: April 22, 2016, 10:40:51 PM »
If it wasnt they wouldnt have asked for the grossly offensive sum of 1.2m euros. the first judge gave them half, the hgher judges gave them zero.

I wonder how they reached that figure? They got E250k each. If it had been E250k each person that would have been 1.25m Euros. Was there a cut-price person at E200k, I wonder?
Read and abide by the forum rules.
Result = happy posting.
Ignore and break the rules
Result = edits, deletions and unhappiness
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?board=2.0

Offline slartibartfast

Re: Former Portuguese detective Gonçalo Amaral wins appeal in damages trial.
« Reply #1354 on: April 22, 2016, 10:48:12 PM »
If it wasnt they wouldnt have asked for the grossly offensive sum of 1.2m euros. the first judge gave them half, the hgher judges gave them zero.

You do wonder what would have happened if they had only asked for 50k?
“Reasoning will never make a Man correct an ill Opinion, which by Reasoning he never acquired”.

Offline mercury

Re: Former Portuguese detective Gonçalo Amaral wins appeal in damages trial.
« Reply #1355 on: April 22, 2016, 10:53:20 PM »
I wonder how they reached that figure? They got E250k each. If it had been E250k each person that would have been 1.25m Euros. Was there a cut-price person at E200k, I wonder?

The breakdown is near the end of this article under the bolded heading what they are demanding

http://www.mccannfiles.com/id244.html



TORN APART BY HIS LIES Sunday Mirror (paper edition)
 
MADDIE PARENTS SUE COP FOR £1M BOOK PROFITS
 
EXCLUSIVE
 
By TOM WORDEN
July 12, 2009
 
Kate and Gerry McCann are suing the police chief who bungled the investigation into their daughter's disappearance - and blamed them for her death - for £1million.
 
In a 36-page writ handed to the Sunday Mirror, they lay bare in painful detail how Gonçalo Amaral's accusations left them "totally destroyed" and caused them "irreparable" damage.
 
It also gives a harrowing insight into the day-to-day life in the McCann household as they struggle to cope without Madeleine.
 
The writ - which the Sunday Mirror has had translated from Portuguese - outlines how the couple both suffer from "permanent anxiety, insomnia, lack of appetite, irritability and an indefinable fear". It also says Kate McCann is "steeped in a deep and serious depression".
 
Disgraced former police Amaral has pocketed £ 1million writing a lurid book and making a documentary full of cruel lies about Madeliene and her parents. And now they are suing him for every penny of it.
 
He accuses them of accidentally killing their three-year-old daughter and then covering up her death.
 
Amaral, who was thrown off case after five months, has repeatedly claimed Madeleine died in the holiday apartment on Algarve. In his book The Truth About The Lie he spouts his absurd theory that the couple hid their daughter's body.
 
The lawsuit also highlights their fears for four-year-old twins Sean and Amelie when they start school later this year and begin to hear rumours that Madeleine is dead.
 
And it accuses Amaral of being a self-obsessed, manipulative money-grabber with no morals.
 
The couple, both 41, have hired Portuguese lawyer Isabel Duarte to sue Amaral for defamation and for breaching their human rights. Mrs Duarte, 54, said: "Somebody has to stop him and shut him up. He is a rich man now, earning millions from the distress of this family. We believe he has made up to 1.2million euros (£1million) from the book and the video. We want the court to punish him by taking at least that much from him."
 
The McCanns have a good case for defamation as they have already been cleared by Portugal's Attorney General. The case will go to trial in Lisbon next summer and Amaral, 49, could force the McCanns to take the stand. Madeleine is named with Kate and Gerry and the twins as a complainant in the lawsuit, lodged on June 24.
 
The McCanns, both doctors from Rothley, Leics, claim Amaral's repeated insistence that their daughter is dead has stopped people looking for her. The lawsuit states: "Madeleine has been deprived of the possibility of a fair and adequate investigation into her disappearance, putting her moral and physical integrity at serious risk."
 
It says Gerry and Kate have been "totally destroyed from a moral, social, ethical, emotional and family point of view, beyond the pain that the absence of their eldest daughter causes them".
 
The couple want a minimum of £430,000 in damages for Madeleine, which will be used to keep the search for her going. They also want a minimum of £215,000 each for them, and another £86,000 each for the twins. It is thought any money they get will go to the Maddie fund.
 
Amaral's book has sold around 330,000 copies worldwide. The father-of-three has become a celeb in Portugal, and has a new Jaguar.
 
The McCanns say his "sole objectives" in writing the book were "to earn a lot of money", using "lies".
 
It says the book and his 50-minute documentary, which has been shown twice on Portuguese TV, are "manipulative, perverse, false, destructive, defamatory, deeply damaging and therefore illegal".
 
Amaral was in charge of the 30 detectives looking for Madeleine after she vanished in May 2007 on a family holiday in Praia da Luz.
 
He was largely responsible for making the McCanns "arguidos" - suspects - four months after Madeleine vanished. But he was kicked off the case in October 2007 days after the Sunday Mirror revealed he was working as little as four hours a day and was enjoying long, boozy lunches.
 
He was removed from the case on his 48th birthday. Amaral took early retirement shortly afterwards, ending 27 years on the force.
 
He began writing his book, promoting it by travelling around Europe giving newspaper interviews.
 
It went on sale in a blaze of publicity in July last year - three days after the McCanns' "arguido" status was removed. Earlier this month Amaral was charged with torturing a witness during a separate missing child case. He faces jail if convicted.
 
WHAT THEY ARE DEMANDING
 
£430,000 damages for Madeleine which will be used to continue the search for her.
 
£215,000 for each parent for the emotional distress the book has caused them. They say they suffer 'permanent anxiety, insomnia, lack of appetite, irritability and an indefinable fear'. The writ also says Kate McCann is 'steeped in a deep and serious depression'.
 
£86,000 for each of their twins Sean and Amelie, who could hear his allegations when they start school in September.
 
HOW HE MADE HIS MONEY
 
£500,000 from the book which has sold 180,000 copies in Portugal alone.
 
£430,000 from the extra 150,000 books which have been sold in Brazil, France, Germany, Italy, Spain and Holland.
 
£100,000 for a TV documentary watched by one in five people in Portugal - 75,000 copies have sold on DVD.
 
*
 
What follows is the online version, complete with grammatical mistakes as they appeared at the time. The article was removed within a few hours of appearing online but is available in cached version:
 
TORN APART BY HIS LIES Sunday Mirror (cached article)
 
By Tom Worden
12/07/2009
 
EXCLUSIVE: MADDIE PARENTS SUE COP FOR £1M BOOK PROFITS
 
Kate and Gerry McCann are suing the police chief who bungled the investigation into their daughter's disappearance - and blamed them for her death - for £1million.
 
In a 36-page writ handed to the Sunday Mirror, they lay bare in painful detail how Gonçalo Amaral's accusations left them "totally destroyed" and caused them "irreparable" damage.
 
It also gives a harrowing insight into the day-to-day life in the McCann household as they struggle to cope without Madeleine.
 
The writ - which the Sunday Mirror has had translated from Portuguese - outlines how the couple both suffer from "permanent anxiety, insomnia, lack of appetite, irritability and an indefinable It also says Kate McCann is "in a deep and serious depression".
 
'Disgraced former police Amaral has pocketed £ 1million writing a lurid book and making documentary full of cruel about Madeliene and her And now they are suing him every penny of it.
 
He accuses them of accidentally killing their three-year-old daughter and then covering up her death.
 
Amaral, who was thrown off case after five months, repeatedly claimed Madeleine in the holiday apartment on Algarve. In his book The About The Lie he spouts his theory that the couple hid daughter's body.
 
The lawsuit also highlights fears for four-year-old twins and Amelie when they start later this year and begin to hear rumours that Madeleine is dead.
 
And it accuses Amaral of being a self-obsessed, manipulative money-grabber with no morals.
 
The couple, both 41, have hired Portuguese lawyer Isabel Duarte to sue Amaral for defamation and for breaching their human rights. Mrs Duarte, 54, said: "Somebody has to stop him and shut him up. He is a rich man now, earning millions from the distress of this family. We believe he has made up to 1.2million euros (£1million) from the book and the video. We want the court to punish him by taking at least that much from him."
 
The McCanns have a good case for defamation as they have already been cleared by Portugal's Attorney General. The case will go to trial in Lisbon next summer and Amaral, 49, could force the McCanns to take the stand. Madeleine is named with Kate and Gerry and the twins as a complainant in the lawsuit, lodged on June 24.
 
The McCanns, both doctors from Rothley, Leics, claim Amaral's repeated insistence that their daughter is dead has stopped people looking for her. The lawsuit states: "Madeleine has been deprived of the possibility of a fair and adequate investigation into her disappearance, putting her moral and physical integrity at serious risk."
 
It says Gerry and Kate have been "totally destroyed from a moral, social, ethical, emotional and family point of view, beyond the pain that the absence of their eldest daughter causes them".
 
The couple want a minimum of £430,000 in damages for Madeleine, which will be used to keep the search for her going. They also want a minimum of £215,000 each for them, and another £86,000 each for the twins. It is thought any money they get will go to the Maddie fund.
 
Amaral's book has sold around 330,000 copies worldwide. The fatherof-three has become a celeb in Portugal, and has a new Jaguar.
 
The McCanns say his "sole objectives" in writing the book were "to earn a lot of money", using "lies". It says the book and his 50-minute documentary, which has been shown twice on Portuguese TV, are "manipulative, perverse, false, destructive, defamatory, deeply damaging and therefore illegal".
 
Amaral was in charge of the 30 detectives looking for Madeleine after she vanished in May 2007 on a family holiday in Praia da Luz.
 
He was largely responsible for making the McCanns "arguidos" - suspects - four months after Madeleine vanished. But he was kicked off the case in October 2007 days after the Sunday Mirror revealed he was working as little as four hours a day and was enjoying long, boozy lunches.
 
He was removed from the case on his 48th birthday. Amaral took early retirement shortly afterwards, ending 27 years on the force.
 
He began writing his book, promoting it by travelling around Europe giving newspaper interviews.
 
It went on sale in a blaze of publicity in July last year - three days after the McCanns' "arguido" status was removed. Earlier this month Amaral was charged with torturing a witness during a separate missing child case. He faces jail if convicted.
 
What they are demanding
 
£430,000 damages for Madeleine which will be used to continue the search for her.
 
£215,000 for each parent for the emotional distress the book has caused them. They say they suffer 'permanent anxiety, insomnia, lack of appetite, irritability and an indefinable fear'. The writ also says Kate McCann is 'steeped in a deep and serious depression'.
 
£86,000 for each of their twins Sean and Amelie, who could hear his allegations when they start school in September.
 
How he made his money
 
£500,000 from the book which has sold 180,000 copies in Portugal alone.
 
£430,000 from the extra 150,000 books which have been sold in Brazil, France, Germany, Italy, Spain and Holland.
 
£100,000 for a TV documentary watched by one in five people in Portugal - 75,000 copies have sold on DVD.
« Last Edit: April 22, 2016, 10:55:58 PM by mercury »

Offline mercury

Re: Former Portuguese detective Gonçalo Amaral wins appeal in damages trial.
« Reply #1356 on: April 22, 2016, 10:56:49 PM »
You do wonder what would have happened if they had only asked for 50k?

 &%+((£

No idea Slarti, errm

Offline Brietta

Re: Former Portuguese detective Gonçalo Amaral wins appeal in damages trial.
« Reply #1357 on: April 22, 2016, 11:00:52 PM »
&%+((£

No idea Slarti, errm

If they had asked for twenty million or one Euro it would not have made the slightest difference ... the appeal court judgement would have been exactly the same ... in my opinion.

Had the amount of the award offended the judges ... surely they had the power to reduce it.
"All I'm going to say is that we've conducted a very serious investigation and there's no indication that Madeleine McCann's parents are connected to her disappearance. On the other hand, we have a lot of evidence pointing out that Christian killed her," Wolter told the "Friday at 9"....

Offline slartibartfast

Re: Former Portuguese detective Gonçalo Amaral wins appeal in damages trial.
« Reply #1358 on: April 22, 2016, 11:03:47 PM »
If they had asked for twenty million or one Euro it would not have made the slightest difference ... the appeal court judgement would have been exactly the same ... in my opinion.

Had the amount of the award offended the judges ... surely they had the power to reduce it.

Not convinced. I think the amount claimed and proof  required must be linked.
“Reasoning will never make a Man correct an ill Opinion, which by Reasoning he never acquired”.

Offline Brietta

Re: Former Portuguese detective Gonçalo Amaral wins appeal in damages trial.
« Reply #1359 on: April 22, 2016, 11:15:20 PM »
Not convinced. I think the amount claimed and proof  required must be linked.

The amount claimed is an irrelevance.  In today's terms in certain sections of society, such as successful authors, it would be considered a pittance.

It will be very interesting to see what Mr Amaral calculates his wounded honour is worth should he take legal action against the McCanns as he has threatened to do.

I wonder how many will criticise him however much he might claim ~ which in my opinion will not be a peppercorn.
"All I'm going to say is that we've conducted a very serious investigation and there's no indication that Madeleine McCann's parents are connected to her disappearance. On the other hand, we have a lot of evidence pointing out that Christian killed her," Wolter told the "Friday at 9"....

Offline Alice Purjorick

Re: Former Portuguese detective Gonçalo Amaral wins appeal in damages trial.
« Reply #1360 on: April 22, 2016, 11:42:35 PM »
amaral instigated it by challenging the mccanns to sue him...what a fool he was

It's not a question of who started it.
I would imagine there was a lack of appreciation of the difference between suing the press and suing an individual. The press don't want to go to court and their "business model" is based on out of court settlements because if pitched right the plaintiff cannot afford to take the risk of turning it down and going to court for more because if the sum is reduced by the court then the plaintiff is liable for any costs incurred by the defendant from the date the original offer was rejected.
An individual cannot usually afford to do anything other than go the full trip through court or jack it in on day one.
Amaral was never going to do anything other than the full trip.
Stand on your dignity too much and the lawyers become richer while you become poorer.
"Navigating the difference between weird but normal grief and truly suspicious behaviour is the key for any detective worth his salt.". ….Sarah Bailey

Offline Alice Purjorick

Re: Former Portuguese detective Gonçalo Amaral wins appeal in damages trial.
« Reply #1361 on: April 22, 2016, 11:50:32 PM »
The breakdown is near the end of this article under the bolded heading what they are demanding

http://www.mccannfiles.com/id244.html



TORN APART BY HIS LIES Sunday Mirror (paper edition)
 
MADDIE PARENTS SUE COP FOR £1M BOOK PROFITS
 
EXCLUSIVE
 
By TOM WORDEN
July 12, 2009
 
Kate and Gerry McCann are suing the police chief who bungled the investigation into their daughter's disappearance - and blamed them for her death - for £1million.
 
In a 36-page writ handed to the Sunday Mirror, they lay bare in painful detail how Gonçalo Amaral's accusations left them "totally destroyed" and caused them "irreparable" damage.
 
It also gives a harrowing insight into the day-to-day life in the McCann household as they struggle to cope without Madeleine.
 
The writ - which the Sunday Mirror has had translated from Portuguese - outlines how the couple both suffer from "permanent anxiety, insomnia, lack of appetite, irritability and an indefinable fear". It also says Kate McCann is "steeped in a deep and serious depression".
 
Disgraced former police Amaral has pocketed £ 1million writing a lurid book and making a documentary full of cruel lies about Madeliene and her parents. And now they are suing him for every penny of it.
 
He accuses them of accidentally killing their three-year-old daughter and then covering up her death.
 
Amaral, who was thrown off case after five months, has repeatedly claimed Madeleine died in the holiday apartment on Algarve. In his book The Truth About The Lie he spouts his absurd theory that the couple hid their daughter's body.
 
The lawsuit also highlights their fears for four-year-old twins Sean and Amelie when they start school later this year and begin to hear rumours that Madeleine is dead.
 
And it accuses Amaral of being a self-obsessed, manipulative money-grabber with no morals.
 
The couple, both 41, have hired Portuguese lawyer Isabel Duarte to sue Amaral for defamation and for breaching their human rights. Mrs Duarte, 54, said: "Somebody has to stop him and shut him up. He is a rich man now, earning millions from the distress of this family. We believe he has made up to 1.2million euros (£1million) from the book and the video. We want the court to punish him by taking at least that much from him."
 
The McCanns have a good case for defamation as they have already been cleared by Portugal's Attorney General. The case will go to trial in Lisbon next summer and Amaral, 49, could force the McCanns to take the stand. Madeleine is named with Kate and Gerry and the twins as a complainant in the lawsuit, lodged on June 24.
 
The McCanns, both doctors from Rothley, Leics, claim Amaral's repeated insistence that their daughter is dead has stopped people looking for her. The lawsuit states: "Madeleine has been deprived of the possibility of a fair and adequate investigation into her disappearance, putting her moral and physical integrity at serious risk."
 
It says Gerry and Kate have been "totally destroyed from a moral, social, ethical, emotional and family point of view, beyond the pain that the absence of their eldest daughter causes them".
 
The couple want a minimum of £430,000 in damages for Madeleine, which will be used to keep the search for her going. They also want a minimum of £215,000 each for them, and another £86,000 each for the twins. It is thought any money they get will go to the Maddie fund.
 
Amaral's book has sold around 330,000 copies worldwide. The father-of-three has become a celeb in Portugal, and has a new Jaguar.
 
The McCanns say his "sole objectives" in writing the book were "to earn a lot of money", using "lies".
 
It says the book and his 50-minute documentary, which has been shown twice on Portuguese TV, are "manipulative, perverse, false, destructive, defamatory, deeply damaging and therefore illegal".
 
Amaral was in charge of the 30 detectives looking for Madeleine after she vanished in May 2007 on a family holiday in Praia da Luz.
 
He was largely responsible for making the McCanns "arguidos" - suspects - four months after Madeleine vanished. But he was kicked off the case in October 2007 days after the Sunday Mirror revealed he was working as little as four hours a day and was enjoying long, boozy lunches.
 
He was removed from the case on his 48th birthday. Amaral took early retirement shortly afterwards, ending 27 years on the force.
 
He began writing his book, promoting it by travelling around Europe giving newspaper interviews.
 
It went on sale in a blaze of publicity in July last year - three days after the McCanns' "arguido" status was removed. Earlier this month Amaral was charged with torturing a witness during a separate missing child case. He faces jail if convicted.
 
WHAT THEY ARE DEMANDING
 
£430,000 damages for Madeleine which will be used to continue the search for her.
 
£215,000 for each parent for the emotional distress the book has caused them. They say they suffer 'permanent anxiety, insomnia, lack of appetite, irritability and an indefinable fear'. The writ also says Kate McCann is 'steeped in a deep and serious depression'.
 
£86,000 for each of their twins Sean and Amelie, who could hear his allegations when they start school in September.
 
HOW HE MADE HIS MONEY
 
£500,000 from the book which has sold 180,000 copies in Portugal alone.
 
£430,000 from the extra 150,000 books which have been sold in Brazil, France, Germany, Italy, Spain and Holland.
 
£100,000 for a TV documentary watched by one in five people in Portugal - 75,000 copies have sold on DVD.
 
*
 
What follows is the online version, complete with grammatical mistakes as they appeared at the time. The article was removed within a few hours of appearing online but is available in cached version:
 
TORN APART BY HIS LIES Sunday Mirror (cached article)
 
By Tom Worden
12/07/2009
 
EXCLUSIVE: MADDIE PARENTS SUE COP FOR £1M BOOK PROFITS
 
Kate and Gerry McCann are suing the police chief who bungled the investigation into their daughter's disappearance - and blamed them for her death - for £1million.
 
In a 36-page writ handed to the Sunday Mirror, they lay bare in painful detail how Gonçalo Amaral's accusations left them "totally destroyed" and caused them "irreparable" damage.
 
It also gives a harrowing insight into the day-to-day life in the McCann household as they struggle to cope without Madeleine.
 
The writ - which the Sunday Mirror has had translated from Portuguese - outlines how the couple both suffer from "permanent anxiety, insomnia, lack of appetite, irritability and an indefinable It also says Kate McCann is "in a deep and serious depression".
 
'Disgraced former police Amaral has pocketed £ 1million writing a lurid book and making documentary full of cruel about Madeliene and her And now they are suing him every penny of it.
 
He accuses them of accidentally killing their three-year-old daughter and then covering up her death.
 
Amaral, who was thrown off case after five months, repeatedly claimed Madeleine in the holiday apartment on Algarve. In his book The About The Lie he spouts his theory that the couple hid daughter's body.
 
The lawsuit also highlights fears for four-year-old twins and Amelie when they start later this year and begin to hear rumours that Madeleine is dead.
 
And it accuses Amaral of being a self-obsessed, manipulative money-grabber with no morals.
 
The couple, both 41, have hired Portuguese lawyer Isabel Duarte to sue Amaral for defamation and for breaching their human rights. Mrs Duarte, 54, said: "Somebody has to stop him and shut him up. He is a rich man now, earning millions from the distress of this family. We believe he has made up to 1.2million euros (£1million) from the book and the video. We want the court to punish him by taking at least that much from him."
 
The McCanns have a good case for defamation as they have already been cleared by Portugal's Attorney General. The case will go to trial in Lisbon next summer and Amaral, 49, could force the McCanns to take the stand. Madeleine is named with Kate and Gerry and the twins as a complainant in the lawsuit, lodged on June 24.
 
The McCanns, both doctors from Rothley, Leics, claim Amaral's repeated insistence that their daughter is dead has stopped people looking for her. The lawsuit states: "Madeleine has been deprived of the possibility of a fair and adequate investigation into her disappearance, putting her moral and physical integrity at serious risk."
 
It says Gerry and Kate have been "totally destroyed from a moral, social, ethical, emotional and family point of view, beyond the pain that the absence of their eldest daughter causes them".
 
The couple want a minimum of £430,000 in damages for Madeleine, which will be used to keep the search for her going. They also want a minimum of £215,000 each for them, and another £86,000 each for the twins. It is thought any money they get will go to the Maddie fund.
 
Amaral's book has sold around 330,000 copies worldwide. The fatherof-three has become a celeb in Portugal, and has a new Jaguar.
 
The McCanns say his "sole objectives" in writing the book were "to earn a lot of money", using "lies". It says the book and his 50-minute documentary, which has been shown twice on Portuguese TV, are "manipulative, perverse, false, destructive, defamatory, deeply damaging and therefore illegal".
 
Amaral was in charge of the 30 detectives looking for Madeleine after she vanished in May 2007 on a family holiday in Praia da Luz.
 
He was largely responsible for making the McCanns "arguidos" - suspects - four months after Madeleine vanished. But he was kicked off the case in October 2007 days after the Sunday Mirror revealed he was working as little as four hours a day and was enjoying long, boozy lunches.
 
He was removed from the case on his 48th birthday. Amaral took early retirement shortly afterwards, ending 27 years on the force.
 
He began writing his book, promoting it by travelling around Europe giving newspaper interviews.
 
It went on sale in a blaze of publicity in July last year - three days after the McCanns' "arguido" status was removed. Earlier this month Amaral was charged with torturing a witness during a separate missing child case. He faces jail if convicted.
 
What they are demanding
 
£430,000 damages for Madeleine which will be used to continue the search for her.
 
£215,000 for each parent for the emotional distress the book has caused them. They say they suffer 'permanent anxiety, insomnia, lack of appetite, irritability and an indefinable fear'. The writ also says Kate McCann is 'steeped in a deep and serious depression'.
 
£86,000 for each of their twins Sean and Amelie, who could hear his allegations when they start school in September.
 
How he made his money
 
£500,000 from the book which has sold 180,000 copies in Portugal alone.
 
£430,000 from the extra 150,000 books which have been sold in Brazil, France, Germany, Italy, Spain and Holland.
 
£100,000 for a TV documentary watched by one in five people in Portugal - 75,000 copies have sold on DVD.

Looking at it in the light of recent events ............................. ?{)(**
"Navigating the difference between weird but normal grief and truly suspicious behaviour is the key for any detective worth his salt.". ….Sarah Bailey

Offline mercury

Re: Former Portuguese detective Gonçalo Amaral wins appeal in damages trial.
« Reply #1362 on: April 22, 2016, 11:52:53 PM »
Sent away with flea in ear and zero cents

Offline Brietta

Re: Former Portuguese detective Gonçalo Amaral wins appeal in damages trial.
« Reply #1363 on: April 22, 2016, 11:57:40 PM »
It's not a question of who started it.
I would imagine there was a lack of appreciation of the difference between suing the press and suing an individual. The press don't want to go to court and their "business model" is based on out of court settlements because if pitched right the plaintiff cannot afford to take the risk of turning it down and going to court for more because if the sum is reduced by the court then the plaintiff is liable for any costs incurred by the defendant from the date the original offer was rejected.
An individual cannot usually afford to do anything other than go the full trip through court or jack it in on day one.
Amaral was never going to do anything other than the full trip.
Stand on your dignity too much and the lawyers become richer while you become poorer.

I think it may be simpler than that.

One refers to British courts and one refers to Portuguese courts.

Robert Murat , Sergey Malinka and Michaela Walczuchs sued successfully and speedily in Britain for defamation ... I know that R Murat was awarded damages in Portugal ~ but only after having to go to appeal ~ from one media outlet.

Do you know how the other two did with the Portuguese courts?
"All I'm going to say is that we've conducted a very serious investigation and there's no indication that Madeleine McCann's parents are connected to her disappearance. On the other hand, we have a lot of evidence pointing out that Christian killed her," Wolter told the "Friday at 9"....

Offline Montclair

Re: Former Portuguese detective Gonçalo Amaral wins appeal in damages trial.
« Reply #1364 on: April 22, 2016, 11:59:13 PM »
If they had asked for twenty million or one Euro it would not have made the slightest difference ... the appeal court judgement would have been exactly the same ... in my opinion.

Had the amount of the award offended the judges ... surely they had the power to reduce it.

The judges stated in the acordão that the amount of compensation of € 500.000 was unjust considering the different financial situations of the parties involved.