Latest theory lands on Portuguese AG's desk

[Robittybob1]

If only someone had asked the twins when they last played with Maddie!

[Robittybob1]

They would also have to rubbish what Mrs Fenn was saying  for if she was dead there was no way it could be Madeleine crying on Tuesday night.

Were the twins not talking?  Surely they would have mentioned to someone that their sister no longer plays with them!  Just sits behind the sofa saying nothing!

Well instead of crying out for "Daddy", Amelie might have been crying out for "Maddie"?   Could Mrs Fenn have heard it wrong?

[John]

It says "Worked at Goldman Sachs" in the profile?

https://www.facebook.com/paulo.cristovaoppc.9

[Alice Purjorick]

You got it, but there was one major difference the McCanns pulled it off.

And there's me thinking it was "Curt Jurgens"* for them......

* It was actually Anton Diffring but that does not work.

[John]

Well instead of crying out for "Daddy", Amelie might have been crying out for "Maddie"?   Could Mrs Fenn have heard it wrong?

A distinct possibility Rob but that was the Tuesday night so not much direct relevance to the Thursday night?

[misty]

It says "Worked at Goldman Sachs" in the profile?

https://www.facebook.com/paulo.cristovaoppc.9

The account, which I believe is genuine, is on the friends list of Sophia Leal, Amaral's ex-wife.

[Carana]

Two things spring to my mind.
Albert RN    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=51Os6X-jhtI
ace peformance by Jack Warner a.k.a George Dixon who in the last knockings of Dixon of Dock Green was a collator a sort of forerunner of HOLMES.
and:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bOakMyALSDw

 

[Robittybob1]

A distinct possibility Rob but that was the Tuesday night so not much direct relevance to the Thursday night?

Under that new theory there was no Thursday night Madeleine had died on Monday so the twins could be crying for her on the Tuesday night.

[G-Unit]

I disagree.  I think if one is being honest and really seriously thinks about it and is not massively into convoluted conspiracy theories (as the author of this massive letter clearly is) then one would admit that it is pretty much impossible to put forward a credible theory as to how the McCanns might have faked an abduction and disposed of a corpse on the evening of the 3rd May, why they would have felt the need to do this in the first place, when did opportunity present itself and why they were able to carry it all out without leaving any compelling evidence at all. IMO.

Just as it's proved impossible to put forward a credible theory of abduction in my opinion. Some of those proposed are pretty convoluted too, and some are pure fantasy.

My honest opinion is that there are very many questions and very few answers which don't rely on opinion rather than evidence. .

[Eleanor]

Just as it's proved impossible to put forward a credible theory of abduction in my opinion. Some of those proposed are pretty convoluted too, and some are pure fantasy.

My honest opinion is that there are very many questions and very few answers which don't rely on opinion rather than evidence. .

Fortunately, Opinion won't do In Law.  There remains nothing to point to the involvement of The McCanns in the disappearance of their daughter.

[Lace]

If only someone had asked the twins when they last played with Maddie!

Madeleine was there all week Rob,  people saw her.    The Nanny spoke to Gerry and Kate,   Madeleine was practising for a dance that was supposed to be a surprise for the parents on the Friday.  Please don't start the nonsense of Madeleine not being there all week,  for that is what it is nonsense.   IMO

[G-Unit]

Fortunately, Opinion won't do In Law.  There remains nothing to point to the involvement of The McCanns in the disappearance of their daughter.

The stranger abduction theory is a matter of opinion.

[barrier]

Fortunately, Opinion won't do In Law.  There remains nothing to point to the involvement of The McCanns in the disappearance of their daughter.

Unless you are part of the investigation team and know this for certain a massive imo should be added to that.

[Eleanor]

The stranger abduction theory is a matter of opinion.

But the most likely one.

[slartibartfast]

But the most likely one.

I’m sure you can show your calculations and evidence?