Is Luke Mitchell guilty - your views

[Nicholas]

Probably because he was threatened with legal action if he gave his version of what he believed to be the truth.

What was Shane Mitchell's version of what he believed to be the truth?

[justsaying]

Why would the threat of legal action matter to him; he wasn't on trial for murder, his brother was!

Really? The threat of being charged and the possibility of a prison sentence should not matter to him? 

[Nicholas]

Witness statements can be added too if something relevant is remembered, but certain witness statements were not just added too, they were clearly changed to support the prosecution theory. For example, the dogs reaction at the V in the wall being changed to "it did not react at all" - So it was ok for others to change their statements, but not Luke's brother, who had simply forgot what they had for tea that night.

WHY did Shane Mitchell not corroborate his brothers alibi during trial?

[justsaying]

What was Shane Mitchell's version of what he believed to be the truth?

Why do you ask questions that you already know the answer too?

[Nicholas]

Really? The threat of being charged and the possibility of a prison sentence should not matter to him? 

Why would it if he were being truthful?

[Nicholas]

Really? The threat of being charged and the possibility of a prison sentence should not matter to him? 

What did Shane Mitchell tell the trial?

[justsaying]

Why would it if he were being truthful?

Simple really, because he had no evidence to support his version of the truth, he only had his word which had already been threatened with legal action.

[justsaying]

What did Shane Mitchell tell the trial?

Why do you ask questions that you already know the answer too?

[Nicholas]

Why do you ask questions that you already know the answer too?

Mores to the point, why do you avoid answering them?

The changing of witness statements, regardless of whether it were the Mitchell family statements changing or others, is irrelevant to evidence given at trial.

Shane Mitchell was asked to corroborate his brothers alibi.

WHY didn't he say; "YES Luke was home with me?

[jixy]

Simple really, because he had no evidence to support his version of the truth, he only had his word which had already been threatened with legal action.

Unlike anyone else connected to the case, who were free to change their minds, remember things quite differently or appear to change their whole story over time and be able to identify people they initially said they could not see as their back was turned . Strange that isnt it

[justsaying]

Why would certain people change their statements to support the prosecution theory?

[Nicholas]

Simple really, because he had no evidence to support his version of the truth, he only had his word which had already been threatened with legal action.

WHY then didn't he use his "word" regardless of any threat?

What was Shane Mitchell REALLY afraid of?

[jixy]

Mores to the point, why do you avoid answering them?

The changing of witness statements, regardless of whether it were the Mitchell family statements changing or others, is irrelevant to evidence given at trial.

Shane Mitchell was asked to corroborate his brothers alibi.

WHY didn't he say; "YES Luke was home with me?

The Mitchell statements or others? You seriously believe that it isnt an issue?

[justsaying]

Mores to the point, why do you avoid answering them?

The changing of witness statements, regardless of whether it were the Mitchell family statements changing or others, is irrelevant to evidence given at trial.

Shane Mitchell was asked to corroborate his brothers alibi.

WHY didn't he say; "YES Luke was home with me?

I have already answered them, just because you do not like the answer does not mean the questions have not been answered!

[Nicholas]

Unlike anyone else connected to the case, who were free to change their minds, remember things quite differently or appear to change their whole story over time and be able to identify people they initially said they could not see as their back was turned . Strange that isnt it

Luke Mitchell was on trial for murder NOT anyone else!