UK Justice Forum 🇬🇧

Disappeared and Abducted Children and Young Adults => Madeleine McCann (3) disappeared from her parent's holiday apartment at Ocean Club, Praia da Luz, Portugal on 3 May 2007. No trace of her has ever been found. => Topic started by: faithlilly on October 14, 2018, 05:39:51 PM

Title: Imagine This Case Happened in America.
Post by: faithlilly on October 14, 2018, 05:39:51 PM
If this case had happened in America where cadaver dog evidence is routinely presented at trial, even without a body, and the authorities are more versed in dealing with the media that a high profile case brings, would the result have been different ? Would the parents have been indicted ?
Title: Re: Imagine This Case Happened in America.
Post by: jassi on October 14, 2018, 06:27:14 PM
If this case had happened in America where cadaver dog evidence is routinely presented at trial, even without a body, and the authorities are more versed in dealing with the media that a high profile case brings, would the result have been different ? Would the parents have been indicted ?

Being America, they'd probably been sentenced to 199 year each with hard labour - that's if they hadn't been shot while resisting arrest.

It's the 'merkin way.
Title: Re: Imagine This Case Happened in America.
Post by: slartibartfast on October 14, 2018, 06:29:42 PM
Being America, they'd probably been sentenced to 199 year each with hard labour - that's if they hadn't been shot while resisting arrest.

It's the 'merkin way.


Ah the Merkins again...😉
Title: Re: Imagine This Case Happened in America.
Post by: barrier on October 14, 2018, 06:33:36 PM

Ah the Merkins again...😉

There is another meaning to a merkin, *%6^
Title: Re: Imagine This Case Happened in America.
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on October 14, 2018, 06:33:54 PM
Who knows?  Who cares?  It didn’t, nor did it happen in Afghanistan, Austria or Argentina.  Of course miscarriages of justice never happen in the good ol’ US of A though do they?  Fancy being convicted solely on the say so of a dog. 
Title: Re: Imagine This Case Happened in America.
Post by: Eleanor on October 14, 2018, 07:39:54 PM
Who knows?  Who cares?  It didn’t, nor did it happen in Afghanistan, Austria or Argentina.  Of course miscarriages of justice never happen in the good ol’ US of A though do they?  Fancy being convicted solely on the say so of a dog.

Woof once for No and twice for Yes.  Or is it the other way around?  Does it actually matter?
Title: Re: Imagine This Case Happened in America.
Post by: Robittybob1 on October 14, 2018, 07:58:36 PM
If this case had happened in America where cadaver dog evidence is routinely presented at trial, even without a body, and the authorities are more versed in dealing with the media that a high profile case brings, would the result have been different ? Would the parents have been indicted ?
In the States there is a strong case for finding the body.   I have a lot of respect for the US police.  They are pretty efficient.
Title: Re: Imagine This Case Happened in America.
Post by: pathfinder73 on October 14, 2018, 08:07:22 PM
Woof once for No and twice for Yes.  Or is it the other way around?  Does it actually matter?

Not really but the FBI would have been involved so the parents would have been first suspects.

(https://pbs.twimg.com/media/CgRQMJ9W4AEeHYs.jpg)
Title: Re: Imagine This Case Happened in America.
Post by: xtina on October 15, 2018, 09:38:04 AM
Who knows?  Who cares?  It didn’t, nor did it happen in Afghanistan, Austria or Argentina.  Of course miscarriages of justice never happen in the good ol’ US of A though do they?  Fancy being convicted solely on the say so of a dog.

Who knows?  Who cares?


Just shows your attitude really...

good job it happened in Portugal then...

as I doubt the UK could have bullied anyone else IMO
Title: Re: Imagine This Case Happened in America.
Post by: faithlilly on October 15, 2018, 09:54:13 AM
From State v Bailey

‘ the evidence showed the cadaver dog was trained to detect human cadaver scent, not simply to find dead human bodies. ‘
Title: Re: Imagine This Case Happened in America.
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on October 15, 2018, 05:42:44 PM
Who knows?  Who cares?


Just shows your attitude really...

good job it happened in Portugal then...

as I doubt the UK could have bullied anyone else IMO
@)(++(* You are funny sometimes.
Title: Re: Imagine This Case Happened in America.
Post by: Sunny on October 15, 2018, 07:33:56 PM
Yea Imagine this case was in the USA and Martin Grime said this in court in justification of his dogs alerts.

“I am interpreting what is happening within the dog’s brain, as soon as the dog entered the bedroom, he exhibited behavioral changes.”



Title: Re: Imagine This Case Happened in America.
Post by: pathfinder73 on October 15, 2018, 08:22:24 PM
What is interesting was the time it took Eddie to find the strongest scent source in the apartment after his immediate behavioural changes. He usually alerts straight away to the source but this was different. IMO there was so much cadaver scent in that apartment that it took him time to find the strongest scent source and make his first alert at the wardrobe (Keela didn't alert there). A body had been in that location IMO. Same with the car - so much scent emanating from it that he was chasing it around the car park.
Title: Re: Imagine This Case Happened in America.
Post by: Sunny on October 15, 2018, 08:30:50 PM
What is interesting was the time it took Eddie to find the strongest scent source in the apartment after his immediate behavioural changes. He usually alerts straight away to the source but this was different. IMO there was so much cadaver scent in that apartment that it took him time to find the strongest scent source and make his first alert at the wardrobe (Keela didn't alert there). A body had been in that location IMO. Same with the car - so much scent emanating from it that he was chasing it around the car park.

My quote was actually Martin Grime giving evidence in court regarding Morse alerting in the house of a murdered woman in the USA. The murdering ex husband was jailed.
Title: Re: Imagine This Case Happened in America.
Post by: misty on October 15, 2018, 08:53:24 PM
If this case had happened in America where cadaver dog evidence is routinely presented at trial, even without a body, and the authorities are more versed in dealing with the media that a high profile case brings, would the result have been different ? Would the parents have been indicted ?

Would Grime's evidence have been allowed in court in 2007 based on the application of the Daubert standard? His proven  body detection rate was only in single figures.
Title: Re: Imagine This Case Happened in America.
Post by: pathfinder73 on October 15, 2018, 09:23:32 PM
My quote was actually Martin Grime giving evidence in court regarding Morse alerting in the house of a murdered woman in the USA. The murdering ex husband was jailed.

Yes and the same at the apartment.

"My observation of the dog's behaviour in this instance was that the dog's behaviour changed immediately upon opening the front door to the apartment.

His behaviour was such that I believed him to be 'in scent' and I therefore allowed him to free search without direction to allow him to identify the source of his interest. He did so alerting in the rear bedroom."

http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/MARTIN_GRIMES.htm
Title: Re: Imagine This Case Happened in America.
Post by: Sunny on October 15, 2018, 09:25:45 PM
Yes and the same at the apartment.

"My observation of the dog's behaviour in this instance was that the dog's behaviour changed immediately upon opening the front door to the apartment.

His behaviour was such that I believed him to be 'in scent' and I therefore allowed him to free search without direction to allow him to identify the source of his interest. He did so alerting in the rear bedroom."

http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/MARTIN_GRIMES.htm

A bit more from the link

Stockham and Grime said Morse detected two areas of human decomposition, near the bathtub in the bathroom of the basement, where Michelle’s body was found, and the carpet at the foot of the bed in the master bedroom.

Grime testified that Morse’s sniff rate increased when in the bedroom and basement, notifying him that there was the possibility of human decomposition. “All I can really do is tell you whether the dog gave a positive or negative response,” he said. “He gave a positive response [to human decomposition] in the basement and bedroom.”

The defense countered, arguing that the positively identified odor in the bedroom may have been transferred by investigators, a possibility to which the handlers did not deny. Defense attorneys argued that it is impossible to determine whether Morse’s alert was accurate.
He
“If it’s not confirmed that there was a dead body, you don’t know if it’s right or wrong,” defense attorney Jonathan Shapiro said.

Grime stressed that people will challenge positive responses, but not negative ones. “I am interpreting what is happening within the dog’s brain,” he said.  “As soon as the dog entered the bedroom, he exhibited behavioral changes.”


Notice the last paragraph.

Here is the link https://loudounnow.com/2016/06/02/day-9-of-castillo-murder-trial-hones-in-on-phone-records/
Title: Re: Imagine This Case Happened in America.
Post by: Mr Gray on October 15, 2018, 09:34:29 PM
Yes and the same at the apartment.

"My observation of the dog's behaviour in this instance was that the dog's behaviour changed immediately upon opening the front door to the apartment.

His behaviour was such that I believed him to be 'in scent' and I therefore allowed him to free search without direction to allow him to identify the source of his interest. He did so alerting in the rear bedroom."

http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/MARTIN_GRIMES.htm

As we have said before...luminol had been used in the apt...the dog may have realised he was at a crime scene
Title: Re: Imagine This Case Happened in America.
Post by: John on October 16, 2018, 04:39:01 AM
If this case had happened in America where cadaver dog evidence is routinely presented at trial, even without a body, and the authorities are more versed in dealing with the media that a high profile case brings, would the result have been different ? Would the parents have been indicted ?

If it had occurred in the US I think the CSI would have been better.
Title: Re: Imagine This Case Happened in America.
Post by: Robittybob1 on October 16, 2018, 05:14:43 AM
If it had occurred in the US I think the CSI would have been better.
CSI = Crime Scene Investigation