UK Justice Forum 🇬🇧

Disappeared and Abducted Children and Young Adults => Madeleine McCann (3) disappeared from her parent's holiday apartment at Ocean Club, Praia da Luz, Portugal on 3 May 2007. No trace of her has ever been found. => Topic started by: Holly Goodhead on August 15, 2019, 02:55:16 PM

Title: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Holly Goodhead on August 15, 2019, 02:55:16 PM
A poster here has commented that he/she believes MM was placed in a bin and taken to landfill.  Is there any evidence for this? 

Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Mr Gray on August 15, 2019, 02:58:55 PM
A poster here has commented that he/she believes MM was placed in a bin and taken to landfill.  Is there any evidence for this?

did you know that Luz is surrounded by hundreds of wells that would basically be impossible to search
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Holly Goodhead on August 15, 2019, 03:01:58 PM
https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2017/dec/11/corrie-mckeague-landfill-search-fails-to-find-missing-airman

The above was undertaken over two periods lasting a total of 27 weeks.  I thought something similar was carried out in connection with this case?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Holly Goodhead on August 15, 2019, 03:05:53 PM
did you know that Luz is surrounded by hundreds of wells that would basically be impossible to search

Yes it was covered in the C4 Dispatches docu but I thought all these had been eliminated by what means I do not know.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Mr Gray on August 15, 2019, 03:12:55 PM
Yes it was covered in the C4 Dispatches docu but I thought all these had been eliminated by what means I do not know.

They can't be eliminates as far as I understand there are just too many
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: ShiningInLuz on August 15, 2019, 03:29:26 PM
https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2017/dec/11/corrie-mckeague-landfill-search-fails-to-find-missing-airman

The above was undertaken over two periods lasting a total of 27 weeks.  I thought something similar was carried out in connection with this case?

There was no landfill search in the MM case.

Over 180 bins in/around Luz were 'searched', but that was by a very small team, lasted a single day, and was not carried out until the Monday following Madeleine's disappearance.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Holly Goodhead on August 15, 2019, 03:36:19 PM
They can't be eliminates as far as I understand there are just too many

I don't know.  I'm just about to read the reports from search expert Mark Harrison.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Mr Gray on August 15, 2019, 03:38:44 PM
I don't know.  I'm just about to read the reports from search expert Mark Harrison.

Everything I've read has said that there are just far too many Wells around Luz to search them all... I don't think Harrison was involved in the search of any
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Holly Goodhead on August 15, 2019, 03:45:54 PM
There was no landfill search in the MM case.

Was this because nothing had been take to landfill prior to the bins searched or some other reason?

Over 180 bins in/around Luz were 'searched', but that was by a very small team, lasted a single day, and was not carried out until the Monday following Madeleine's disappearance.

I thought the bins in Luz were emptied every night?  When you say 'searched' do you mean by those acting in a professional capacity as opposed to volunteers who claim to have searched the bins on 3rd/4th May?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: ShiningInLuz on August 15, 2019, 04:09:57 PM
Was this because nothing had been take to landfill prior to the bins searched or some other reason?

I thought the bins in Luz were emptied every night?  When you say 'searched' do you mean by those acting in a professional capacity as opposed to volunteers who claim to have searched the bins on 3rd/4th May?

The Luz landfill site is the sole site for the whole of the Western Algarve.  By Monday (or Tuesday), thousands of tonnes of rubbish had been added to it.

The bins are not emptied every night.  The McCanns were in close proximity to 3 wheelie bins.  Those bins would only need to be emptied perhaps twice a week.  But the pickup schedules are more erratic.  We get local bins emptied 3 nights running, then nothing for 7-10 days.  The actual pickup schedule in Luz does not appear in the PJ Files.

The team on Monday was 2 PJ officers and 3 waste removal employees from Lagos council.

Despite comments appearing in tabloids, I cannot remember anything in a witness statement to say bins were searched overnight.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Miss Taken Identity on August 15, 2019, 04:42:36 PM
The Luz landfill site is the sole site for the whole of the Western Algarve.  By Monday (or Tuesday), thousands of tonnes of rubbish had been added to it.

The bins are not emptied every night.  The McCanns were in close proximity to 3 wheelie bins.  Those bins would only need to be emptied perhaps twice a week.  But the pickup schedules are more erratic.  We get local bins emptied 3 nights running, then nothing for 7-10 days.  The actual pickup schedule in Luz does not appear in the PJ Files.

The team on Monday was 2 PJ officers and 3 waste removal employees from Lagos council.

Despite comments appearing in tabloids, I cannot remember anything in a witness statement to say bins were searched overnight.



In your opinion SIL, where would be an ideal place for a body being dumped never to be found?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: ShiningInLuz on August 15, 2019, 05:05:17 PM


In your opinion SIL, where would be an ideal place for a body being dumped never to be found?

There was an interesting case a couple of years back.  A woman's body was found cemented within a pillar in an attic.  The attic was being renovated when the body was found.

It appeared to be murder, dating back to the 1980s.

The PJ could do nothing.  The statute of limitation on murder is 15 years, so the perpetrator got away with it.

Successfully disposing of a body depends on whether you are - a tourist, like the McCanns - an expat with several years knowledge - or a native with a lifetime of knowledge.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Miss Taken Identity on August 15, 2019, 05:09:40 PM
There was an interesting case a couple of years back.  A woman's body was found cemented within a pillar in an attic.  The attic was being renovated when the body was found.

It appeared to be murder, dating back to the 1980s.

The PJ could do nothing.  The statute of limitation on murder is 15 years, so the perpetrator got away with it.

Successfully disposing of a body depends on whether you are - a tourist, like the McCanns - an expat with several years knowledge - or a native with a lifetime of knowledge.


OK I am a tourist  who likes jogging...
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Mr Gray on August 15, 2019, 05:31:52 PM
I don't know.  I'm just about to read the reports from search expert Mark Harrison.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 15, 2019, 05:36:28 PM
A poster here has commented that he/she believes MM was placed in a bin and taken to landfill.  Is there any evidence for this?
No.  It is a belief, nothing more than that.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: ShiningInLuz on August 15, 2019, 05:44:06 PM

OK I am a tourist  who likes jogging...

The obvious place is a wheelie bin.

After that, there was a derelict building by Boa Vista, something that looks like a mine shaft half way up the hill, and more than one derelict farm on the old M537 road to Lagos.

Depends on where you go jogging!
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Anthro on August 15, 2019, 06:58:53 PM
She has not been found because it is easier to find a body than an alive person. Just my thinking.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 15, 2019, 07:14:38 PM
She has not been found because it is easier to find a body than an alive person. Just my thinking.
The lack of a body certainly rules out a straightforward woke and wandered IMO.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: G-Unit on August 15, 2019, 07:30:48 PM
The obvious place is a wheelie bin.

After that, there was a derelict building by Boa Vista, something that looks like a mine shaft half way up the hill, and more than one derelict farm on the old M537 road to Lagos.

Depends on where you go jogging!

Or the sea (Harrison).
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: ShiningInLuz on August 15, 2019, 07:50:36 PM
Or the sea (Harrison).

He said it would be washed up.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: G-Unit on August 15, 2019, 08:00:21 PM
He said it would be washed up.

He said;

a body would most likely trave1 eastwards in a re circulating motion along the
shoreline until it was trapped by the rock outcrop to the east of the beach or
consumed by marine life. ti the entry point was the rock outcrop itself to the
east of the beach then the body would most likely continue in a re circulating
motion along the shoreline until it again encountered a bamer to its passage,
the most eastward of this would be 5km away at Ponta Da Piedade near
Lagos.
https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/MARK_HARRISON.htm
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Anthro on August 15, 2019, 08:00:53 PM
Any thoughts on the building nr.5 right opposite the church?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: G-Unit on August 15, 2019, 08:26:40 PM
Any thoughts on the building nr.5 right opposite the church?

No, what about it?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 15, 2019, 08:41:22 PM
Was this because nothing had been take to landfill prior to the bins searched or some other reason?

I thought the bins in Luz were emptied every night?  When you say 'searched' do you mean by those acting in a professional capacity as opposed to volunteers who claim to have searched the bins on 3rd/4th May?
Commercial bins might be but who would generate so much rubbish as to clear bins every night. 
I'll admit pig waste bins need clearing daily.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: G-Unit on August 15, 2019, 08:48:39 PM
Commercial bins might be but who would generate so much rubbish as to clear bins every night. 
I'll admit pig waste bins need clearing daily.

They don't seem to have household bins in Portugal. They're communal as I understand it.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: barrier on August 15, 2019, 08:54:37 PM
Suzi Lamplugh went missing in 1986,no trace as ever been found,she's presumed dead by murder,if a adult can be made to disappear why should it be hard for a child?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 15, 2019, 08:56:04 PM
They don't seem to have household bins in Portugal. They're communal as I understand it.
Well I wonder if anyone has a photo of the type of bin we are talking about?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: ShiningInLuz on August 15, 2019, 08:56:30 PM
Commercial bins might be but who would generate so much rubbish as to clear bins every night. 
I'll admit pig waste bins need clearing daily.

I don't think Baptista has 'commercial' bins.

I lived beside Hugo Beatties and they used the communal bins.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 15, 2019, 09:06:48 PM
I don't think Baptista has 'commercial' bins.

I lived beside Hugo Beatties and they used the communal bins.
What were the dimensions of these bins? (Roughly will do)  I'm trying to work out if they could be tipped over by someone or would it need machinery?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 15, 2019, 09:15:42 PM
(https://image.irs.wisnz.co.nz/process_resize_550x550/nzspm-production/58f82d7d63ecd4.32915343.jpeg)

They called this bin a 240 litre bin.  I'd think that would still be too small to be called communal.  It would fill up too quick.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: ShiningInLuz on August 15, 2019, 09:23:26 PM
(https://image.irs.wisnz.co.nz/process_resize_550x550/nzspm-production/58f82d7d63ecd4.32915343.jpeg)

They called this bin a 240 litre bin.  I'd think that would still be too small to be called communal.  It would fill up too quick.

Check the C4 documentary.

Your bin is NOT a communal bin, it's far, far too small.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 15, 2019, 09:37:09 PM
https://youtu.be/khP0dEsZaug  I call that the Dispatches Documentary.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: ShiningInLuz on August 15, 2019, 09:46:33 PM
https://youtu.be/khP0dEsZaug  I call that the Dispatches Documentary.

Have a look through until they discuss the bins.  Despite what they say, those are bog-standard communal bins.  You'll get the size from that.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 15, 2019, 09:52:53 PM
Have a look through until they discuss the bins.  Despite what they say, those are bog-standard communal bins.  You'll get the size from that.
OK I found the spot https://youtu.be/khP0dEsZaug?t=1373  Probably 1 cubic metre capacity.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Holly Goodhead on August 15, 2019, 09:59:19 PM
Commercial bins might be but who would generate so much rubbish as to clear bins every night. 
I'll admit pig waste bins need clearing daily.

I was thinking smells/flies/health n safety/hygiene in warmer climes. 
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: G-Unit on August 15, 2019, 10:14:14 PM
Bins on Rua do Ramalhete;

https://geo0.ggpht.com/cbk?cb_client=maps_sv.tactile&authuser=0&hl=en&gl=uk&output=thumbnail&thumb=2&w=345&h=170&pitch=20.224926188345464&ll=37.08985653029642%2C-8.730505650344346&panoid=FmY6u5yM1uHNbQApei1tZg&yaw=1.5958805951967987

Bins near the Tapas complex;

https://geo0.ggpht.com/cbk?cb_client=maps_sv.tactile&authuser=0&hl=en&gl=uk&output=thumbnail&thumb=2&w=345&h=170&pitch=25.77490479851818&ll=37.08791002738424%2C-8.73092720451694&panoid=8BSWXSeTy4GUeEzMF6bg-Q&yaw=224.18689551830596
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 15, 2019, 11:24:55 PM
Well the searchers that night couldn't be expected to tip over that sized bins IMO.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: G-Unit on August 16, 2019, 07:31:38 AM
They weren't expected to. They were searching for a child who had wandered off.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 16, 2019, 07:59:31 AM
They weren't expected to. They were searching for a child who had wandered off.
Why were they doing that?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: barrier on August 16, 2019, 08:09:32 AM
Well the searchers that night couldn't be expected to tip over that sized bins IMO.

Maybe the  opportunity to find out what happened was lost that very night,12 yrs on its hard to argue against it.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Holly Goodhead on August 16, 2019, 09:16:07 AM
Maybe the  opportunity to find out what happened was lost that very night,12 yrs on its hard to argue against it.

Maybe but the scent dogs did not track beyond the immediate vicinity and certainly did not head towards any bins. 

The scent dogs fit with my theory about what happened.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 16, 2019, 09:29:39 AM
Maybe but the scent dogs did not track beyond the immediate vicinity and certainly did not head towards any bins. 

The scent dogs fit with my theory about what happened.
What part fits with your theory?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Holly Goodhead on August 16, 2019, 10:06:44 AM
What part fits with your theory?

That MM was placed in a car in the immediate vicinity.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: barrier on August 17, 2019, 08:03:51 PM
There was an interesting case a couple of years back.  A woman's body was found cemented within a pillar in an attic.  The attic was being renovated when the body was found.

It appeared to be murder, dating back to the 1980s.

The PJ could do nothing.  The statute of limitation on murder is 15 years, so the perpetrator got away with it.

Successfully disposing of a body depends on whether you are - a tourist, like the McCanns - an expat with several years knowledge - or a native with a lifetime of knowledge.

Is there a statute of limitations on the McCann case,no crime as been identified,save OG (Rowley) said its a missing persons case.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: ShiningInLuz on August 17, 2019, 08:42:54 PM
Is there a statute of limitations on the McCann case,no crime as been identified,save OG (Rowley) said its a missing persons case.

There is in Portugal.

It would depend on whether a prosecution could be brought in the UK, where there is no statute of limitation.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: barrier on August 17, 2019, 08:51:14 PM
There is in Portugal.

It would depend on whether a prosecution could be brought in the UK, where there is no statute of limitation.


That would only occur if a brit was involved in the crime what ever it is.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: ShiningInLuz on August 17, 2019, 09:12:52 PM

That would only occur if a brit was involved in the crime what ever it is.

I would assume so.  I doubt OG would try to prosecute a Portuguese national in a UK court after a Portuguese SOL had kicked in.

But as Amaral pointed out, if the McCanns carried out body occultation, they could also be charged in the UK for running a fraudulent fund.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Mr Gray on August 17, 2019, 09:16:11 PM
I would assume so.  I doubt OG would try to prosecute a Portuguese national in a UK court after a Portuguese SOL had kicked in.

But as Amaral pointed out, if the McCanns carried out body occultation, they could also be charged in the UK for running a fraudulent fund.

I  dont..in principle ...see why the uk...if it had sufficient evidence ...would not charge a portuguese national in such circumstances
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: ShiningInLuz on August 17, 2019, 09:34:21 PM
I  dont..in principle ...see why the uk...if it had sufficient evidence ...would not charge a portuguese national in such circumstances

What? On the off chance he might take casual work at Bernard Matthews turkey farm?

 *&^^&
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Mr Gray on August 17, 2019, 09:36:53 PM
What? On the off chance he might take casual work at Bernard Matthews turkey farm?

 *&^^&

ive given my opinion and you have given yours...we hve no way of knowing who is right
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: barrier on August 18, 2019, 06:42:27 AM
I  dont..in principle ...see why the uk...if it had sufficient evidence ...would not charge a portuguese national in such circumstances
Principles and law are entirely different.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Lace on August 18, 2019, 01:52:37 PM
I was thinking smells/flies/health n safety/hygiene in warmer climes.

Some say the McCann's dumped Madeleleine in a bin.   How would they know if the bins would be emptied that night?   
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Lace on August 18, 2019, 01:54:12 PM
Or the sea (Harrison).

Wasn't the tide out?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Holly Goodhead on August 18, 2019, 02:05:58 PM
Some say the McCann's dumped Madeleleine in a bin.   How would they know if the bins would be emptied that night?   

Well if the bins were emptied nightly then they might be aware of this fact given they were on night 6.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: G-Unit on August 18, 2019, 02:38:35 PM
Wasn't the tide out?

The optimum time was between 10pm and 4am according to Harrison.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: G-Unit on August 18, 2019, 02:40:22 PM
Well if the bins were emptied nightly then they might be aware of this fact given they were on night 6.

Assuming the plan was for a body to be taken.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Lace on August 18, 2019, 02:50:33 PM
Well if the bins were emptied nightly then they might be aware of this fact given they were on night 6.

Yet no one  mentions the bin men arriving,  none of the nannies who were searching or any of the other searchers say that in the middle of the search men came to empty the bins.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Holly Goodhead on August 18, 2019, 03:00:16 PM
Yet no one  mentions the bin men arriving,  none of the nannies who were searching or any of the other searchers say that in the middle of the search men came to empty the bins.

I read somewhere they are emptied around 4am. 
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: jassi on August 18, 2019, 03:01:44 PM
By which time everybody had given up for the night, I think
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Lace on August 18, 2019, 03:04:09 PM
I read somewhere they are emptied around 4am.

I wonder if they had been informed a child was missing.   They must have wondered why people were out at that time of the morning.   It beggars belief that they wouldn't know.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: ShiningInLuz on August 18, 2019, 03:13:45 PM
I read somewhere they are emptied around 4am.

C4 Dispatches stated 12 midnight to 4am.

Unless they completely revised the schedules by the time we got to Luz, that's cobblers.  I've seen bins being emptied mid-afternoon.

Before it gets raised again, there was no lichen on the windowsill to disturb.

Both ideas have no substance.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: barrier on August 18, 2019, 04:01:42 PM
C4 Dispatches stated 12 midnight to 4am.

Unless they completely revised the schedules by the time we got to Luz, that's cobblers.  I've seen bins being emptied mid-afternoon.

Before it gets raised again, there was no lichen on the windowsill to disturb.

Both ideas have no substance.

Unless you were out in Luz on the 3rd the first instance isn't cobbler's.As to the lichen? suggest's not much maintenance over the first spring month's,unlikley as you intimate.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: ShiningInLuz on August 18, 2019, 04:43:04 PM
Unless you were out in Luz on the 3rd the first instance isn't cobbler's.As to the lichen? suggest's not much maintenance over the first spring month's,unlikley as you intimate.

The C4 Dispatches team were not in Luz on 3rd.  By your logic, their claim is cobblers.  There is nothing in that programme to show they ascertained the 3 May 2007 schedule.  And there is nothing in witness statements to the effect that Luz was abuzz with bin lorries between midnight and 4AM.

What maintenance over the first spring months?  Nobody said they had responsibility for cleaning windowsills.  Marble windowsills don't build up lichen on the Algarve.  We've got the crime scene photos inside 5A (which Professor David Barclay didn't) and the video of the shutter being dusted on the outside (which he should have) and no lichen.  Also no mention of lichen in 3 relevant forensic reports.

It's another piece of speculation, one which contradicts the evidence.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 18, 2019, 05:23:34 PM
Some say the McCann's dumped Madeleleine in a bin.   How would they know if the bins would be emptied that night?   

They wouldn’t. The body just needed to be out of the apartment.

The body was meant to be found.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 18, 2019, 05:25:22 PM
I read somewhere they are emptied around 4am.
Imagine living in a small town where the bin men came around every morning at 4am.  I’d have to move.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 18, 2019, 05:27:57 PM
They wouldn’t. The body just needed to be out of the apartment.

The body was meant to be found.
In your opinion.  Why din’t they pick a more obvious location a bit closer to the apartment but away from the centre of town?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 18, 2019, 05:33:38 PM
In your opinion.  Why din’t they pick a more obvious location a bit closer to the apartment but away from the centre of town?

You’d have to ask them that.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 18, 2019, 05:35:51 PM
You’d have to ask them that.
Why would I ask them that?  I’m pretty certain they didn’t throw Madeleine’s body in a bin after parading it through the streets of the town.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 18, 2019, 07:24:19 PM
Why would I ask them that?  I’m pretty certain they didn’t throw Madeleine’s body in a bin after parading it through the streets of the town.

Then we’ll remain in the dark.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 18, 2019, 07:56:19 PM
Then we’ll remain in the dark.
I’m not in the dark about it, because I don’t think they did it.  You do however, so it’s something for you to try and rationalize, not me.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 18, 2019, 08:59:37 PM
I’m not in the dark about it, because I don’t think they did it.  You do however, so it’s something for you to try and rationalize, not me.

You do get rattled every time it comes up.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 18, 2019, 09:01:49 PM
You do get rattled every time it comes up.
Stupidity annoys me I guess.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 18, 2019, 09:07:58 PM
Stupidity annoys me I guess.

How do you live with yourself  8(0(*
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Holly Goodhead on August 18, 2019, 09:38:42 PM
They wouldn’t. The body just needed to be out of the apartment.

The body was meant to be found.

If the body was meant to be found then surely a post-mortem would reveal how said person died?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 18, 2019, 09:52:27 PM
If the body was meant to be found then surely a post-mortem would reveal how said person died?

It would indeed and if there was a head injury or sedatives present it could be blamed on the abductor.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Holly Goodhead on August 18, 2019, 09:53:48 PM
Imagine living in a small town where the bin men came around every morning at 4am.  I’d have to move.

But are we talking residential collection or commercial? 
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Holly Goodhead on August 18, 2019, 09:56:47 PM
It would indeed and if there was a head injury or sedatives present it could be blamed on the abductor.

Pathologists are usually a bit more savvy than that. 
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 18, 2019, 10:04:13 PM
How do you live with yourself  8(0(*
Perfectly well, because thankfully unlike some people I am not stupid.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 18, 2019, 10:06:51 PM
deleted
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 18, 2019, 10:07:28 PM
It would indeed and if there was a head injury or sedatives present it could be blamed on the abductor.
Why would it be blamed on an abductor?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 18, 2019, 10:08:30 PM
But are we talking residential collection or commercial?
Residential presumably.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 18, 2019, 10:43:38 PM
Pathologists are usually a bit more savvy than that.

Do you think that even pathologists can tell when a child was sedated to within a couple of hours or when they died died to within a couple of hours ? And if the death was due to trauma to the head or body how could they tell who had caused it ?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 18, 2019, 10:47:06 PM
Why would it be blamed on an abductor?

Because it was alleged she’d been abducted perhaps ?

I don’t know much about abducting children I’ll confess but I don’t think they usually go about abducting fatally injured or dead children.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 18, 2019, 10:59:59 PM
Because it was alleged she’d been abducted perhaps ?

I don’t know much about abducting children I’ll confess but I don’t think they usually go about abducting fatally injured or dead children.
What a bizarre post.  Firstly, do the police and forensic team simply accept the opinion of the parents?  Secondly, what are you on about??  Who claimed an abductor took a fatally injured or dead child?  I asked you why the police would assume a dead body in a bin was the work of an abductor not a parent but it seems you cannot give any logical response.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 19, 2019, 01:09:33 AM
What a bizarre post.  Firstly, do the police and forensic team simply accept the opinion of the parents?  Secondly, what are you on about??  Who claimed an abductor took a fatally injured or dead child?  I asked you why the police would assume a dead body in a bin was the work of an abductor not a parent but it seems you cannot give any logical response.

The police may not but that’s the case that would certainly be argued by the parents.....the case for the defence as it were.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 19, 2019, 06:50:50 AM
The police may not but that’s the case that would certainly be argued by the parents.....the case for the defence as it were.
So you must believe the McCanns are truly naive and stupid as well as everything else. 
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 19, 2019, 07:48:33 AM
But are we talking residential collection or commercial?
The bins were of a size I'd say they were communal. 
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Lace on August 19, 2019, 08:36:05 AM
Do you think that even pathologists can tell when a child was sedated to within a couple of hours or when they died died to within a couple of hours ? And if the death was due to trauma to the head or body how could they tell who had caused it ?

I would imagine they would know how long the sedation had been in the body.   What sort of sedation are we talking about?   Calpol which is what Amaral suggested would not have caused her to be groggy enough to topple off the sofa.   
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Holly Goodhead on August 19, 2019, 09:39:15 AM
Do you think that even pathologists can tell when a child was sedated to within a couple of hours or when they died died to within a couple of hours ? And if the death was due to trauma to the head or body how could they tell who had caused it ?

If I've read you correctly you claim MM sustained some sort of head injury in apartment 5A and was then subsequently moved by her parents to a location where they expected the body to be found?  If someone sustained a fatal head injury and was then subsequently moved then yes a competent pathologist would be able to determine.

Toxicology reports would be undertaken and identify any usual substances in the liver and blood.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 19, 2019, 09:54:07 AM
So you must believe the McCanns are truly naive and stupid as well as everything else.

No I think they may have been desperate.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 19, 2019, 09:55:37 AM
I would imagine they would know how long the sedation had been in the body.   What sort of sedation are we talking about?   Calpol which is what Amaral suggested would not have caused her to be groggy enough to topple off the sofa.

How would they know to within a couple of days ?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 19, 2019, 10:02:47 AM
If I've read you correctly you claim MM sustained some sort of head injury in apartment 5A and was then subsequently moved by her parents to a location where they expected the body to be found?  If someone sustained a fatal head injury and was then subsequently moved then yes a competent pathologist would be able to determine.

Toxicology reports would be undertaken and identify any usual substances in the liver and blood.

I agree but who moved her would be the question.....the abductor would be the parent’s defence.

As to substances in the blood and liver, of course they’d be identified but the question would be who administered them ? Maybe that’s why we were furnished with the nonsense about an intruder coming in the night before and Madeleine being very sleepy on the 3rd. Were the parents trying to put in place an explanation for the amount of sedation in the body ?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Holly Goodhead on August 19, 2019, 10:38:21 AM
I agree but who moved her would be the question.....the abductor would be the parent’s defence.

As to substances in the blood and liver, of course they’d be identified but the question would be who administered them ? Maybe that’s why we were furnished with the nonsense about an intruder coming in the night before and Madeleine being very sleepy on the 3rd. Were the parents trying to put in place an explanation for the amount of sedation in the body ?

But the chances are anyone who moved MM from 5A would leave tell-tale signs of DNA on MM's body or other such forensic evidence eg fibre transfer from clothes worn.  Had the body been found then other evidence might have been found at soc eg fingerprints or glove prints if a lid of a bin was lifted or footprints in sand on the beach.

Well toxicology tests would be very revealing in terms of what was administered and how it was administered.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: slartibartfast on August 19, 2019, 12:07:44 PM
I agree but who moved her would be the question.....the abductor would be the parent’s defence.

As to substances in the blood and liver, of course they’d be identified but the question would be who administered them ? Maybe that’s why we were furnished with the nonsense about an intruder coming in the night before and Madeleine being very sleepy on the 3rd. Were the parents trying to put in place an explanation for the amount of sedation in the body ?

Interesting idea.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 19, 2019, 12:10:12 PM
But the chances are anyone who moved MM from 5A would leave tell-tale signs of DNA on MM's body or other such forensic evidence eg fibre transfer from clothes worn.  Had the body been found then other evidence might have been found at soc eg fingerprints or glove prints if a lid of a bin was lifted or footprints in sand on the beach.

Well toxicology tests would be very revealing in terms of what was administered and how it was administered.

You do realise that I’m talking about a communal bin which would have probably hundreds of thousands if not millions of people’s DNA and fingerprints, gloved and ungloved, on it and in it ? As to footprints, if the body was placed in a bin why would there be footprints in the sand ?

And yes toxicology test would reveal what was administered and how but unfortunately not by who.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Lace on August 19, 2019, 12:15:07 PM
I agree but who moved her would be the question.....the abductor would be the parent’s defence.

As to substances in the blood and liver, of course they’d be identified but the question would be who administered them ? Maybe that’s why we were furnished with the nonsense about an intruder coming in the night before and Madeleine being very sleepy on the 3rd. Were the parents trying to put in place an explanation for the amount of sedation in the body ?

It makes no sense to me.   The McCann's giving Madeleine sedation [what sort of sedation?]   to make her sleep soundly,  yet she manages to wake up and fall off the sofa. 
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Lace on August 19, 2019, 12:18:55 PM
I agree but who moved her would be the question.....the abductor would be the parent’s defence.

As to substances in the blood and liver, of course they’d be identified but the question would be who administered them ? Maybe that’s why we were furnished with the nonsense about an intruder coming in the night before and Madeleine being very sleepy on the 3rd. Were the parents trying to put in place an explanation for the amount of sedation in the body ?


So,  if Kate was trying to put the idea that an intruder had tried to drug Madeleine the night before,  what sedation would leave a brown stain on Madeleine's pyjamas?    That stain was is what give Kate the idea that maybe someone tried to sedate Madeleine on the Wednesday night,  she thought it was tea but couldn't remember Madeleine drinking any tea.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 19, 2019, 12:20:12 PM

So,  if Kate was trying to put the idea that an intruder had tried to drug Madeleine the night before,  what sedation would leave a brown stain on Madeleine's pyjamas?    That stain was is what give Kate the idea that maybe someone tried to sedate Madeleine on the Wednesday night,  she thought it was tea but couldn't remember Madeleine drinking any tea.

No idea.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Lace on August 19, 2019, 12:44:48 PM
No idea.

I doubt if Kate would have given the description of a brown stain if she was hinting at someone trying to sedate Madeleine on the Wednesday night as you say she was.    If Madeleine's body was found sedated if the sedation didn't leave a brown stain then what Kate had said would be proven to be rubbish wouldn't it?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: pathfinder73 on August 19, 2019, 12:52:35 PM
Here's a clue for you. Gerry said David checked on Wed night.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 19, 2019, 01:01:45 PM
I doubt if Kate would have given the description of a brown stain if she was hinting at someone trying to sedate Madeleine on the Wednesday night as you say she was.    If Madeleine's body was found sedated if the sedation didn't leave a brown stain then what Kate had said would be proven to be rubbish wouldn't it?
No of course not.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Holly Goodhead on August 19, 2019, 01:02:31 PM
You do realise that I’m talking about a communal bin which would have probably hundreds of thousands if not millions of people’s DNA and fingerprints, gloved and ungloved, on it and in it ? As to footprints, if the body was placed in a bin why would there be footprints in the sand ?

And yes toxicology test would reveal what was administered and how but unfortunately not by who.

Yes I assumed a communal type bin.  Forensics can identify recent fingerprints/glove prints over older ones revealing who had lifted the bin most recently.

If MM was put in a bin and subsequently recovered her body/pj's would reveal all sorts eg fibre transference from the person doing the carrying and lifting.  We are told by the McCanns MM they last observed MM in bed asleep.  If she was subsequently found in a bin fibres would be found on her body/pj's indicative of her being recently carried and lifted.   

Re the footprint in the sand I was referring to another who believes MM's body was hastily hidden under a rock on the beach.

The McCanns luggage would have been screened at the airport for any uncontrolled substances.  How likely is it that they could obtain uncontrolled substances since arriving in Algarve? 
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 19, 2019, 01:03:58 PM
Here's a clue for you. Gerry said David checked on Wed night.
What are you believing Gerry now are you?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 19, 2019, 01:52:43 PM
Yes I assumed a communal type bin.  Forensics can identify recent fingerprints/glove prints over older ones revealing who had lifted the bin most recently.

If MM was put in a bin and subsequently recovered her body/pj's would reveal all sorts eg fibre transference from the person doing the carrying and lifting.  We are told by the McCanns MM they last observed MM in bed asleep.  If she was subsequently found in a bin fibres would be found on her body/pj's indicative of her being recently carried and lifted.   

Re the footprint in the sand I was referring to another who believes MM's body was hastily hidden under a rock on the beach.

The McCanns luggage would have been screened at the airport for any uncontrolled substances.  How likely is it that they could obtain uncontrolled substances since arriving in Algarve?

Any fingerprints that the SOC offices found would have a legitimate reason for being their, similarly any DNA found on her pyjamas..... that person had used the bin.

As to the McCann’s luggage...I’ve never been questioned about tablets I’ve had in my luggage, have you ? The parents could have had drugs that were legal to have, such as sleeping tablets, but are not meant to be given to children.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 19, 2019, 02:21:49 PM
You do realise that I’m talking about a communal bin which would have probably hundreds of thousands if not millions of people’s DNA and fingerprints, gloved and ungloved, on it and in it ? As to footprints, if the body was placed in a bin why would there be footprints in the sand ?

And yes toxicology test would reveal what was administered and how but unfortunately not by who.
Then the body did not need to be carried all the way across town, uncovered and for all to see did it?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 19, 2019, 02:30:34 PM
Then the body did not need to be carried all the way across town, uncovered and for all to see did it?

If you want to distance yourself from a body I’d assume that you’d take it as far from you as possible. I’m of the opinion that ‘the plan’ such as it was was fluid and changed with the circumstances. Perhaps one of those circumstances was the meeting with the Smiths?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 19, 2019, 02:48:54 PM
If you want to distance yourself from a body I’d assume that you’d take it as far from you as possible. I’m of the opinion that ‘the plan’ such as it was was fluid and changed with the circumstances. Perhaps one of those circumstances was the meeting with the Smiths?
Please explain further.  Where was Smithman heading when meeting the Smiths made him alter his plans?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 19, 2019, 03:13:20 PM
Please explain further.  Where was Smithman heading when meeting the Smiths made him alter his plans?

I don’t know that he did change his plan but it’s just one of several possibilities.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 19, 2019, 03:15:27 PM
I don’t know that he did change his plan but it’s just one of several possibilities.
Another possibility is that Smithman was not carrying Madeleine's body and that it wasn't Gerry.  In fact it's both plausible and logical and IMO highly likely that he wasn't. 
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 19, 2019, 03:17:51 PM
Another possibility is that Smithman was not carrying Madeleine's body and that it wasn't Gerry.  In fact it's both plausible and logical and IMO highly likely that he wasn't.

We have two witnesses, Martin Smith and his wife, who would argue that point....and unlike you, they were there.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 19, 2019, 03:18:42 PM
We have two witnesses, Martin Smith and his wife, who would argue that point....and unlike you, they were there.
They both 100% certain it was Gerry are they?  Who knew!
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: barrier on August 19, 2019, 04:18:26 PM
They both 100% certain it was Gerry are they?  Who knew!


I guess in your world,you being 100% certain who it wasn't and you weren't there holds sway over some one who was there and holds a 60/80% certainty of who it might be.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 19, 2019, 04:25:11 PM

I guess in your world,you being 100% certain who it wasn't and you weren't there holds sway over some one who was there and holds a 60/80% certainty of who it might be.
Perhaps you could point to the 100% certainty in my post?

"Another possibility is that Smithman was not carrying Madeleine's body and that it wasn't Gerry.  In fact it's both plausible and logical and IMO highly likely that he wasn't".

I consider the Smiths to be unreliable witnesses, just like you consider the McCanns and their friends to be unreliable.  I find the Smiths' behaviour puzzling just as you find the McCanns behaviour puzzling.  Who is right?  Time will tell, maybe...
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 19, 2019, 04:59:49 PM
They both 100% certain it was Gerry are they?  Who knew!

Did I say that ?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 19, 2019, 05:03:25 PM
Perhaps you could point to the 100% certainty in my post?

"Another possibility is that Smithman was not carrying Madeleine's body and that it wasn't Gerry.  In fact it's both plausible and logical and IMO highly likely that he wasn't".

I consider the Smiths to be unreliable witnesses, just like you consider the McCanns and their friends to be unreliable.  I find the Smiths' behaviour puzzling just as you find the McCanns behaviour puzzling.  Who is right?  Time will tell, maybe...

Unreliable witness ? OG didn’t seem to think so as they were questioned again as part of this investigation. The Smiths had no axe to grind and were independent witnesses, the parents weren’t.

Tell me, what reason would Martin Smith and his wife have to mislead an investigation into a missing child ?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 19, 2019, 05:07:47 PM
Did I say that ?
So they’re not certain it was Gerry?  My point stands then.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 19, 2019, 05:09:11 PM
Unreliable witness ? OG didn’t seem to think so as they were questioned again as part of this investigation. The Smiths had no axe to grind and were independent witnesses, the parents weren’t.

Tell me, what reason would Martin Smith and his wife have to mislead an investigation into a missing child ?
Did I say they had reason to mislead?  I said unreliable.  Most eyewitnesses are, nothing suspicious about it.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 19, 2019, 06:30:38 PM
Did I say they had reason to mislead?  I said unreliable.  Most eyewitnesses are, nothing suspicious about it.

Two unreliable witnesses saying the same thing ? Much like Wilkins and Tanner I suppose ?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 19, 2019, 06:34:44 PM
Two unreliable witnesses saying the same thing ? Much like Wilkins and Tanner I suppose ?
Do you have a link to Mrs Smith’s statement?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 19, 2019, 07:01:17 PM
Do you have a link to Mrs Smith’s statement?

Martin Smith mentions it in his statement.

‘ During that time I spoke to all my family members who were with me on the night of 3rd May 2007 about this and the only one who felt the same way as me was my wife. She had seen the video clip of Gerard McCann walking down the stairs of the plane earlier that day. We did not discuss this until some days later. This statement has been read over to me and is correct.’
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 19, 2019, 07:48:59 PM
Martin Smith mentions it in his statement.

‘ During that time I spoke to all my family members who were with me on the night of 3rd May 2007 about this and the only one who felt the same way as me was my wife. She had seen the video clip of Gerard McCann walking down the stairs of the plane earlier that day. We did not discuss this until some days later. This statement has been read over to me and is correct.’
Haha, ok, if that’s the best you can do...
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 19, 2019, 10:25:03 PM
Haha, ok, if that’s the best you can do...

So what are you saying ? That Martin Smith lied about his wife agreeing with him ?


http://www.belfasttelegraph.co.uk/news/ ... 97648.html


'Evidence provided at the time by members of the Smith family, from Maple Drive, Drogheda, Co Louth, was considered credible by the review officers.

'Martin Smith and his wife Mary revealed to investigators how they saw a man carrying a young child through the streets of Praia da Luz in Portugal on the night Madeleine went missing.'
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 19, 2019, 10:35:22 PM
So what are you saying ? That Martin Smith lied about his wife agreeing with him ?


http://www.belfasttelegraph.co.uk/news/ ... 97648.html


'Evidence provided at the time by members of the Smith family, from Maple Drive, Drogheda, Co Louth, was considered credible by the review officers.

'Martin Smith and his wife Mary revealed to investigators how they saw a man carrying a young child through the streets of Praia da Luz in Portugal on the night Madeleine went missing.'
Lying?  No.  Unreliable?  Yes IMO, especially as we have never heard the woman give her own opinion in her own words.  Perhaps she prefers her husband to speak for her?  Another strange feature of their contribution to this case IMO.  Incidentally when did MSM reports without verbatim quotes beccome a valid source of information in your book?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 20, 2019, 12:18:42 AM
Lying?  No.  Unreliable?  Yes IMO, especially as we have never heard the woman give her own opinion in her own words.  Perhaps she prefers her husband to speak for her?  Another strange feature of their contribution to this case IMO.  Incidentally when did MSM reports without verbatim quotes beccome a valid source of information in your book?

It would appear that OG don’t think he’s unreliable as they questioned him twice ( plenty of direct quotes here )

https://www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/madeleine-mccann-key-witness-accuses-2433328


Mr Smith, a former Unilever executive, made a statement along with his wife Mary, daughter Aoife and son Peter soon after Madeleine vanished on May 3, 2007.

He helped compile e-fits a year later – but the images were not released at the time and were only made public for the first time earlier this week.

Speaking from his home in Drogheda, Co Louth, Mr Smith said that the Portuguese police did not seem to think his sighting was significant.

He added: “It looked as if they put 90% credence on the Jane Tanner sighting, maybe that wrong-footed them and they didn’t take our sighting as seriously. I was surprised it took six years to rule out the other sighting.”

He said he has met with Scotland Yard detectives twice over the past 18 months to help them with the new probe. He added: “We‘d all love to see the police get to the bottom of what happened.”

“We think about Madeleine a lot and we would love to see a conclusion to this case.

Mr Smith was with his wife, daughter, son, daughter-in-law and two grandchildren on the night that the three year old vanished.

The family described the man they saw as white, with short brown hair and of average build and height, aged between 20 and 40.

 
Commenting on the Crimewatch documentary which was broadcast on Monday night he added: “The only new thing in the investigation is the elimination of Jane Tanner’s sighting.

“Apart from that from our point of view everything else remains the same in relation to what we said to the police and the media at the time. We have nothing more to add.”

At least two callers who responded to the TV appeal gave the same name for the two e-fits provided by the Smiths
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 20, 2019, 07:10:07 AM
It would appear that OG don’t think he’s unreliable as they questioned him twice ( plenty of direct quotes here )

https://www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/madeleine-mccann-key-witness-accuses-2433328


Mr Smith, a former Unilever executive, made a statement along with his wife Mary, daughter Aoife and son Peter soon after Madeleine vanished on May 3, 2007.

He helped compile e-fits a year later – but the images were not released at the time and were only made public for the first time earlier this week.

Speaking from his home in Drogheda, Co Louth, Mr Smith said that the Portuguese police did not seem to think his sighting was significant.

He added: “It looked as if they put 90% credence on the Jane Tanner sighting, maybe that wrong-footed them and they didn’t take our sighting as seriously. I was surprised it took six years to rule out the other sighting.”

He said he has met with Scotland Yard detectives twice over the past 18 months to help them with the new probe. He added: “We‘d all love to see the police get to the bottom of what happened.”

“We think about Madeleine a lot and we would love to see a conclusion to this case.

Mr Smith was with his wife, daughter, son, daughter-in-law and two grandchildren on the night that the three year old vanished.

The family described the man they saw as white, with short brown hair and of average build and height, aged between 20 and 40.

 
Commenting on the Crimewatch documentary which was broadcast on Monday night he added: “The only new thing in the investigation is the elimination of Jane Tanner’s sighting.

“Apart from that from our point of view everything else remains the same in relation to what we said to the police and the media at the time. We have nothing more to add.”

At least two callers who responded to the TV appeal gave the same name for the two e-fits provided by the Smiths
If they thought he was reliable they would have arrested Gerry McCann, or at the very least requested that the PJ make Gerry an arguido again so that he could be re-questioned about his movements that night.  Why didn’t this happen, in your opinion?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 20, 2019, 09:45:06 AM
If they thought he was reliable they would have arrested Gerry McCann, or at the very least requested that the PJ make Gerry an arguido again so that he could be re-questioned about his movements that night.  Why didn’t this happen, in your opinion?

Questioning him twice in 18 months suggests that OG certainly thinks his sighting has merit.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Lace on August 20, 2019, 09:53:56 AM
Mr Smith was only going by the way Gerry held his son in his arms.   It was he said how the person he saw held the child.   Now,  not being funny how many people hold their children like that?

Gerry was at the Tapas Bar when the Smith's saw their man.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 20, 2019, 10:02:54 AM
Mr Smith was only going by the way Gerry held his son in his arms.   It was he said how the person he saw held the child.   Now,  not being funny how many people hold their children like that?

Gerry was at the Tapas Bar when the Smith's saw their man.

Martin Smith had been questioned by OG at the time of the article. This suggests that he had interesting information to impart. Further there is no independent witness that puts Gerry in the tapas at the time of the Smith sighting.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 20, 2019, 10:05:56 AM
Questioning him twice in 18 months suggests that OG certainly thinks his sighting has merit.
So what have Op Grange done with this important information to advance the case?  Why has Gerry not been questioned under caution? Did you know that police can question people more than once without necessarily believing the witness’s statement to be truthful or accurate?  Just a thought for you to ponder...
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Lace on August 20, 2019, 10:08:23 AM
Martin Smith had been questioned by OG at the time of the article. This suggests that he had interesting information to impart. Further there is no independent witness that puts Gerry in the tapas at the time of the Smith sighting.

Work the times out Faithlilly, Gerry met Jez about 10 15 minutes past 9,  went back to the Tapas,  ordered dinner,  ate dinner.  How long do you think it takes for your dinner to arrive?   Kate went to check the children at 10  why would she go any earlier when they had been checked at half past nine?    Kate came back and said 'Madeleine's gone Gerry'   Gerry was at the table when the alarm was raised.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Lace on August 20, 2019, 10:10:16 AM
Amaral himself said Gerry was at the Tapas bar.  So has he worked the times out wrongly?   Did he have access to the waiters order and the time the dinner was served?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: pathfinder73 on August 20, 2019, 10:16:54 AM
Mr Smith was only going by the way Gerry held his son in his arms.   It was he said how the person he saw held the child.   Now,  not being funny how many people hold their children like that?

Gerry was at the Tapas Bar when the Smith's saw their man.

It was the way he lowered his head which was the same i.e. his body language. The timeline is key.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 20, 2019, 10:27:08 AM
Work the times out Faithlilly, Gerry met Jez about 10 15 minutes past 9,  went back to the Tapas,  ordered dinner,  ate dinner.  How long do you think it takes for your dinner to arrive?   Kate went to check the children at 10  why would she go any earlier when they had been checked at half past nine?    Kate came back and said 'Madeleine's gone Gerry'   Gerry was at the table when the alarm was raised.

Wilkins, an independent witness, wasn’t sure of the time he met Gerry...anything from 8.45 until 9.15. If Gerry went at 9pm to check ( that would certainly explain why Diane Webster was so positive that she did not see Oldfield on the way to the tapas or Gerry when she got there) and Gerry checked again at 9.30 ( Oldfield’s check is rather sketchy and was the first time he went in to the apartment the whole week, why just that night ? ) it is possible that he found Madeleine then. It certainly explains the calls of Madeleine’s name being heard by Carpenter’s wife as she went home and Gerry’s normal behaviour at the Wilkin’s meeting.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 20, 2019, 10:27:38 AM
Amaral himself said Gerry was at the Tapas bar.  So has he worked the times out wrongly?   Did he have access to the waiters order and the time the dinner was served?

Cite please ?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 20, 2019, 05:19:50 PM
Wilkins, an independent witness, wasn’t sure of the time he met Gerry...anything from 8.45 until 9.15. If Gerry went at 9pm to check ( that would certainly explain why Diane Webster was so positive that she did not see Oldfield on the way to the tapas or Gerry when she got there) and Gerry checked again at 9.30 ( Oldfield’s check is rather sketchy and was the first time he went in to the apartment the whole week, why just that night ? ) it is possible that he found Madeleine then. It certainly explains the calls of Madeleine’s name being heard by Carpenter’s wife as she went home and Gerry’s normal behaviour at the Wilkin’s meeting.
Who said Gerry did another check at 9.30pm?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Lace on August 20, 2019, 07:37:46 PM
Cite please ?

'Further on this issue, the testimony of MARTIN SMITH was considered, pages 1606 and following, reporting the sighting of an individual carrying a child, in one of the streets that lead to the beach. It was said that the child could be MADELEINE McCANN, although it was never peremptorily stated. Some time later, the witness alleged that, by its stance, the individual who carried the child could be GERALD McCANN, which was concluded when he saw him descending the stairs from an airplane, pages 2871, 3991 and following and 4135 and following. It was established that at the time that was being mentioned, GERALD McCANN was sitting at the table, in the Tapas Restaurant.'
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: pathfinder73 on August 20, 2019, 08:09:57 PM
 If you start with wrong times then don't expect it to fit. Many presume the 10pm check time is correct as it came from Kate "I'm not lying about that" McCann  @)(++(*
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 20, 2019, 08:15:26 PM
'Further on this issue, the testimony of MARTIN SMITH was considered, pages 1606 and following, reporting the sighting of an individual carrying a child, in one of the streets that lead to the beach. It was said that the child could be MADELEINE McCANN, although it was never peremptorily stated. Some time later, the witness alleged that, by its stance, the individual who carried the child could be GERALD McCANN, which was concluded when he saw him descending the stairs from an airplane, pages 2871, 3991 and following and 4135 and following. It was established that at the time that was being mentioned, GERALD McCANN was sitting at the table, in the Tapas Restaurant.'

So it was in the archiving report. Who was the coordinator then ?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 20, 2019, 08:49:42 PM
So it was in the archiving report. Who was the coordinator then ?
It’s also the in the Rent-A-Gob’s book, he admits Smithman could not be Gerry.

ETA: Unable to provide a cite, as cannot find an English language version of the book online.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Mr Gray on August 20, 2019, 08:51:29 PM
It’s also the in the Rent-A-Gob’s book, he admits Smithman could not be Gerry.

is that the book of Little Truth and Many Lies
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 20, 2019, 10:27:20 PM
It’s also the in the Rent-A-Gob’s book, he admits Smithman could not be Gerry.

You’ll have a cite ?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 20, 2019, 10:43:25 PM
You’ll have a cite ?
If you can find a link to the book in English I’ll see if I can find it.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 20, 2019, 11:14:53 PM
If you can find a link to the book in English I’ll see if I can find it.

That’s not how it works. You make a claim, you provide a cite.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 20, 2019, 11:19:22 PM
That’s not how it works. You make a claim, you provide a cite.
You claimed Gerry did a check at 9.30 pm, did you provide a cite?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 20, 2019, 11:27:01 PM
You claimed Gerry did a check at 9.30 pm, did you provide a cite?

Notice the word ‘if’ at the beginning of the sentence. The scenario was hypothetical.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 20, 2019, 11:30:34 PM
Notice the word ‘if’ at the beginning of the sentence. The scenario was hypothetical.
It was such a long-winded sentence it was hard to make sense of but I accept your explanation that it was invented by you.  As for the cite you requested I cannot supply it as Amaral’s book appears to have been pulled from the internet, certainly the version I used to refer to has gone.  Therefore I withdraw my claim, I hope this puts your mind at rest.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 20, 2019, 11:38:39 PM
It was such a long-winded sentence it was hard to make sense of but I accept your explanation that it was invented by you.  As for the cite you requested I cannot supply it as Amaral’s book appears to have been pulled from the internet, certainly the version I used to refer to has gone.  Therefore I withdraw my claim, I hope this puts your mind at rest.

Thank you for the withdrawal of your claim.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Lace on August 21, 2019, 08:25:06 AM
So it was in the archiving report. Who was the coordinator then ?

Amaral was the coordinator when the Smiths reported their sighting,  Amaral was the coordinator when Mr Smith reported he was 60/80% sure he saw Gerry.   The PJ came to the conclusion that it couldn't be Gerry as he was sat in the Tapas Bar.   What ever Amaral says after he left the PJ I would take with a pinch of salt,  he likes to believe he would have done this and would have done that,  but I believe they didn't take it further with the Smith family as Gerry was at the Tapas Bar. The PJ no doubt used the reports that Amaral had written to do with the Smith sighting otherwise they would have carried on and asked the Smiths back to be interviewed again,  they didn't.  Strange that isn't it?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Lace on August 21, 2019, 08:29:20 AM
If you start with wrong times then don't expect it to fit. Many presume the 10pm check time is correct as it came from Kate "I'm not lying about that" McCann  @)(++(*

I suppose you know the exact times do you?   I go by the times others got to hear that Madeleine was missing,  they were quickly gathering a search party.    You think Gerry McCann came out of 5a carrying Madeleine with all the crowds outside and ran off to the beach,   only weeks later to revisit the beach and take Madeleine's body somewhere else?    Or ran off and hid Madeleine before he went back to the Tapas?   Chatting afterwards [normally] to Jez?    Sorry that is so hard to believe.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 21, 2019, 08:36:25 AM
I suppose you know the exact times do you?   I go by the times others got to hear that Madeleine was missing,  they were quickly gathering a search party.    You think Gerry McCann came out of 5a carrying Madeleine with all the crowds outside and ran off to the beach,   only weeks later to revisit the beach and take Madeleine's body somewhere else?    Or ran off and hid Madeleine before he went back to the Tapas?   Chatting afterwards [normally] to Jez?    Sorry that is so hard to believe.
I think Pathfinder believes the body was hidden on the beach (after being hidden somewhere else beforehand) and then later that night after all the searchers  had retired for the night (having failed to find the body) it was moved for a third time, to some mysterious fridge owned by some obliging acquaintances.  I’m sure I will receive a Pathfinder scold if I am wrong.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Lace on August 21, 2019, 09:16:02 AM
I think Pathfinder believes the body was hidden on the beach (after being hidden somewhere else beforehand) and then later that night after all the searchers  had retired for the night (having failed to find the body) it was moved for a third time, to some mysterious fridge owned by some obliging acquaintances.  I’m sure I will receive a Pathfinder scold if I am wrong.

Amazing what the McCann's could do,  not knowing the area.   I mean the first hiding of the body must have been done when it was quite light outside and many people still out and about.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 21, 2019, 09:23:27 AM
Amazing what the McCann's could do,  not knowing the area.   I mean the first hiding of the body must have been done when it was quite light outside and many people still out and about.
As I have said many, many times no one has been able to come up with a remotely logical or plausible theory of parental involvement and Pathfinder is no different IMO.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 21, 2019, 11:12:51 AM
Amaral was the coordinator when the Smiths reported their sighting,  Amaral was the coordinator when Mr Smith reported he was 60/80% sure he saw Gerry.   The PJ came to the conclusion that it couldn't be Gerry as he was sat in the Tapas Bar.   What ever Amaral says after he left the PJ I would take with a pinch of salt,  he likes to believe he would have done this and would have done that,  but I believe they didn't take it further with the Smith family as Gerry was at the Tapas Bar. The PJ no doubt used the reports that Amaral had written to do with the Smith sighting otherwise they would have carried on and asked the Smiths back to be interviewed again,  they didn't.  Strange that isn't it?

OG interviewed the Smiths, twice. They certainly took their witness accounts seriously.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 21, 2019, 11:16:18 AM
Amazing what the McCann's could do,  not knowing the area.   I mean the first hiding of the body must have been done when it was quite light outside and many people still out and about.

You could say that about the abductor. Why abduct Madeleine when it was still light when, if they had been watching the group, they would know that they didn’t come back to their apartments to at least 11pm and therefore could have carried out the abduction when it was very dark and few people about ?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: G-Unit on August 21, 2019, 11:25:34 AM
Amazing what the McCann's could do,  not knowing the area.   I mean the first hiding of the body must have been done when it was quite light outside and many people still out and about.

The McCanns were joggers. Do you know where they jogged during their holiday? If not, then they may have known the area quite well. Kate knew how to run out of the village as she did that with Matthew Oldfield on 2nd.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 21, 2019, 11:26:57 AM
OG interviewed the Smiths, twice. They certainly took their witness accounts seriously.
Perhaps they found their account suspicious or inconsistent, or puzzling, ever thought of that?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 21, 2019, 11:29:05 AM
You could say that about the abductor. Why abduct Madeleine when it was still light when, if they had been watching the group, they would know that they didn’t come back to their apartments to at least 11pm and therefore could have carried out the abduction when it was very dark and few people about ?
We're talking about the McCanns hiding a dead body when it was still light and then going about their usual business, not making off with a live child never to be seen again.  Big difference.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 21, 2019, 12:23:12 PM
Perhaps they found their account suspicious or inconsistent, or puzzling, ever thought of that?

So they called them back twice ? Surely any discrepancies would have been ironed out in the first interview?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 21, 2019, 12:23:54 PM
We're talking about the McCanns hiding a dead body when it was still light and then going about their usual business, not making off with a live child never to be seen again.  Big difference.

No difference at all. Both would want to avoid being recognised.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 21, 2019, 12:31:34 PM
No difference at all. Both would want to avoid being recognised.
  Really?  So how come Gerry made no attempt whatsoever to avoid being recognised as he allegedly paraded his dead daughter's body through town then? 
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 21, 2019, 12:32:53 PM
So they called them back twice ? Surely any discrepancies would have been ironed out in the first interview?
Is that what happened when the PJ interviewed the McCanns and friends then?  All discrepancies ironed out in the first interviews?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: misty on August 21, 2019, 01:11:58 PM
OG interviewed the Smiths, twice. They certainly took their witness accounts seriously.

Do you have a cite for that claim, please?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: pathfinder73 on August 21, 2019, 01:51:59 PM
Amazing what the McCann's could do,  not knowing the area.   I mean the first hiding of the body must have been done when it was quite light outside and many people still out and about.

If you didn't know the area and wanted to hide and  later retrieve then the dark deserted beach was the nearest and obvious place to go. Searches didn't have many torches so it would be like finding a needle in a haystack. If a body  was there then it had to be moved again IMO. Anybody out searching alone at unusual times should be of interest to any investigator.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 21, 2019, 01:55:23 PM
If you didn't know the area and wanted to hide and  later retrieve then the dark deserted beach was the nearest and obvious place to go. Searches didn't have many torches so it would be like finding a needle in a haystack. If a body  was there then it had to be moved again IMO.
Unless you had one of them there genius dogs that can find a speck of blood in the whole of the Pacific Ocean.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 21, 2019, 01:59:53 PM
  Really?  So how come Gerry made no attempt whatsoever to avoid being recognised as he allegedly paraded his dead daughter's body through town then?

What was he supposed to do....wear a wig, a false moustache or a balaclava ?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 21, 2019, 02:01:22 PM
Is that what happened when the PJ interviewed the McCanns and friends then?  All discrepancies ironed out in the first interviews?

Obviously not but they were not independent witnesses, the Smiths were.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 21, 2019, 02:02:57 PM
Do you have a cite for that claim, please?

I posted it a few pages back.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 21, 2019, 02:23:23 PM
I posted it a few pages back.
Can you recall a keyword in the post you mention?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 21, 2019, 02:38:26 PM
Obviously not but they were not independent witnesses, the Smiths were.
As we're constantly being reminded, no one who was there in PdL that night has been cleared of involvement.  That must therefore include the Smiths, right?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 21, 2019, 02:48:21 PM
As we're constantly being reminded, no one who was there in PdL that night has been cleared of involvement.  That must therefore include the Smiths, right?

Constantly reminded by who....certainly not me....but let’s go with that analysis, if you believe that no one has been cleared, even the Smiths then that includes the parents, right ?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 21, 2019, 03:01:39 PM
Constantly reminded by who....certainly not me....but let’s go with that analysis, if you believe that no one has been cleared, even the Smiths then that includes the parents, right ?
That’s the argument I am referring to. I’m surprised you’ve never heard it before.  If the McCanns haven’t been cleared, then neither has Murat or anyone who was in the vicinity could have been involved, that includes the Tapas staff, the nannies, the OC staff, all the residents, all the holidaymakers, all the witnessses including the Smths.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: misty on August 21, 2019, 03:10:19 PM
Obviously not but they were not independent witnesses, the Smiths were.

The Smiths were familiar with the 1st arguido so they were not independent either, as MS's statement clearly proved.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 21, 2019, 04:55:26 PM
That’s the argument I am referring to. I’m surprised you’ve never heard it before.  If the McCanns haven’t been cleared, then neither has Murat or anyone who was in the vicinity could have been involved, that includes the Tapas staff, the nannies, the OC staff, all the residents, all the holidaymakers, all the witnessses including the Smths.

So do you agree with this argument?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 21, 2019, 04:57:09 PM
The Smiths were familiar with the 1st arguido so they were not independent either, as MS's statement clearly proved.

Familiar as much as they would recognise each other if they met in the street. That’s hardly the same as friendship.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 21, 2019, 05:27:43 PM
Familiar as much as they would recognise each other if they met in the street. That’s hardly the same as friendship.
Oh, you totally believe the Smiths version of events do you?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 21, 2019, 05:29:06 PM
What was he supposed to do....wear a wig, a false moustache or a balaclava ?
Carrying the body in a bag and not through the centre of town would have been a start.  But yes, if you like, to all of those facetious suggestions.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 21, 2019, 05:30:52 PM
So do you agree with this argument?
I believe the McCanns have been cleared so no, you don’t believe they have been, therefore technically you must agree with this argument, if not why not?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: jassi on August 21, 2019, 05:33:32 PM
As far as I'm concerned, nobody has been cleared until someone else has been   convicted
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 21, 2019, 05:39:39 PM
As far as I'm concerned, nobody has been cleared until someone else has been   convicted
Then you must concede the Smiths haven’t been cleared, thanks for helping to make my point.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: jassi on August 21, 2019, 05:58:33 PM
Then you must concede the Smiths haven’t been cleared, thanks for helping to make my point.

No problem at all. I have no fixation on claiming anyone is cleared.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 21, 2019, 06:01:42 PM
Oh, you totally believe the Smiths version of events do you?

Yes, absolutely. I have no reason not to.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 21, 2019, 06:05:39 PM
Carrying the body in a bag and not through the centre of town would have been a start.  But yes, if you like, to all of those facetious suggestions.

What bag ? Even if he could find a bag that wouldn’t be traced back to him, he may still be recognised carrying a bag at a time when his daughter went missing. Tell me where do you find a wig, false moustache or balaclava in a Portuguese seaside town at night ?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 21, 2019, 06:06:00 PM
Yes, absolutely. I have no reason not to.
Here’s a word of advice:  accept nothing, believe no one, confirm everything.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 21, 2019, 06:08:31 PM
I believe the McCanns have been cleared so no, you don’t believe they have been, therefore technically you must agree with this argument, if not why not?

So the argument doesn’t hold true so why bring it up ?

(Pssst I have already said that I don’t agree with the argument that no one in PDL on the 3rd of May have been ruled out )
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 21, 2019, 06:11:24 PM
Then you must concede the Smiths haven’t been cleared, thanks for helping to make my point.

But you have driven a horse and cart through your argument when you say that you believe the parents have been cleared.

You can’t have it both ways.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 21, 2019, 06:12:12 PM
What bag ? Even if he could find a bag that wouldn’t be traced back to him, he may still be recognised carrying a bag at a time when his daughter went missing. Tell me where do you find a wig, false moustache or balaclava in a Portuguese seaside town at night ?
I suggested that he avoid being recognised.  He could have done this by not walking through town at a time when there were likely to be people about, whilst carrying a corpse.  The daft suggestions were yours.  Perhaps he could have got his wife to hastily knit a balaclava while she was pretending to check on the kids, and fashion a wig and a moustache out of cuddle cat, too.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 21, 2019, 06:13:10 PM
But you have driven a horse and cart through your argument when you say that you believe the parents have been cleared.

You can’t have it both ways.
I can have it any way I want.  Who has been cleared of this crime and why?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 21, 2019, 06:20:57 PM
I suggested that he avoid being recognised.  He could have done this by not walking through town at a time when there were likely to be people about, whilst carrying a corpse.  The daft suggestions were yours.  Perhaps he could have got his wife to hastily knit a balaclava while she was pretending to check on the kids, and fashion a wig and a moustache out of cuddle cat, too.

Gerry said that the only time he had seen anyone that week when he was checking was on the Thursday night. He was obviously under the assumption that PDL was quiet.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 21, 2019, 06:22:23 PM
I can have it any way I want.  Who has been cleared of this crime and why?

Of course you can...if you don’t mind your credibility taking a knock.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 21, 2019, 06:22:54 PM
Gerry said that the only time he had seen anyone that week when he was checking was on the Thursday night. He was obviously under the assumption that PDL was quiet.
Anyone where?  Did he go walking through town every night?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 21, 2019, 06:27:29 PM
Anyone where?  Did he go walking through town every night?

The road that runs by the parent’s apartment is a main road used to get to the beach, Baptista and the town. If that was quiet perhaps he thought that the whole of PDL was just as quiet.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 21, 2019, 06:39:58 PM
The road that runs by the parent’s apartment is a main road used to get to the beach, Baptista and the town. If that was quiet perhaps he thought that the whole of PDL was just as quiet.
So he was a damn fool along with everything else. “I need to dispose of this inconvenient body...hmm...I know, I’ll just carry it through town, there’s  bound to be no one around.  I’ll  dump it in the bin furthest from the apartment in the hope that someone finds it very quicklyand blames the death on an abductor.  Sorted!”
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 21, 2019, 06:44:15 PM
Of course you can...if you don’t mind your credibility taking a knock.
I don’t have any credibility with sceptics so I really don’t mind that at all.  Now do tell us who has been cleared of involvement in Madeleine’s disappearance and why.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Miss Taken Identity on August 21, 2019, 06:56:08 PM
The road that runs by the parent’s apartment is a main road used to get to the beach, Baptista and the town. If that was quiet perhaps he thought that the whole of PDL was just as quiet.

It is easy to establish Gerry is not the sharpest tool in the box. I think KATE is the smarter of the two. It must have been very difficult living with him. He was not a hands on dad like the others, and they had 3 children under 4. real hard work! and she had a difficult Job as a GP. He was calling rhe shots- don't expect an elaborate plan to dispose of a body by him if he was involved!

There was Kate checking the bins...
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 21, 2019, 07:12:48 PM
It is easy to establish Gerry is not the sharpest tool in the box. I think KATE is the smarter of the two. It must have been very difficult living with him. He was not a hands on dad like the others, and they had 3 children under 4. real hard work! and she had a difficult Job as a GP. He was calling rhe shots- don't expect an elaborate plan to dispose of a body by him if he was involved!

There was Kate checking the bins...
And yet dimwit that he so obviously is (most well regarded professors of cardiology are not all that bright as we well know), the McCanns got away with the most infamous child disappearance of all time.  Amazing.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Miss Taken Identity on August 21, 2019, 07:19:10 PM
And yet dimwit that he so obviously is (most well regarded professors of cardiology are not all that bright as we well know), the McCanns got away with the most infamous child disappearance of all time.  Amazing.

Yeah, Amazing! and you are well to celebrate such a fete.

 As my sig lines says    'be careful of stupid people in a crowd'
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: G-Unit on August 21, 2019, 07:26:31 PM
And yet dimwit that he so obviously is (most well regarded professors of cardiology are not all that bright as we well know), the McCanns got away with the most infamous child disappearance of all time.  Amazing.

There are different kinds of cleverness. That's why the saying about geniuses not having the sense to come in out of the rain arose.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 21, 2019, 07:46:10 PM
So he was a damn fool along with everything else. “I need to dispose of this inconvenient body...hmm...I know, I’ll just carry it through town, there’s  bound to be no one around.  I’ll  dump it in the bin furthest from the apartment in the hope that someone finds it very quicklyand blames the death on an abductor.  Sorted!”

I’m sure ‘the plan’ what there was of it was formulated on the hoof with not a lot of thought given to the outcomes of those decisions. That’s why there was so much retrofitting later.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Mr Gray on August 21, 2019, 07:50:29 PM
There are different kinds of cleverness. That's why the saying about geniuses not having the sense to come in out of the rain arose.

Anyone who describes Gerry as not the sharpest tool in the box isn't very bright imo.. And I love being out in the rain... Water is a life source
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 21, 2019, 08:05:37 PM
Anyone who describes Gerry as not the sharpest tool in the box isn't very bright imo.. And I love being out in the rain... Water is a life source

As they say in Scotland, he has all his gripping senses.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 21, 2019, 08:06:14 PM
I’m sure ‘the plan’ what there was of it was formulated on the hoof with not a lot of thought given to the outcomes of those decisions. That’s why there was so much retrofitting later.
Plans that are put together “on the hoof” tend to u ravel pdq.  Ever heard the saying about proper planning and preparation?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 21, 2019, 08:07:09 PM
There are different kinds of cleverness. That's why the saying about geniuses not having the sense to come in out of the rain arose.
Is Gerry a genius then?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 21, 2019, 08:08:47 PM
Yeah, Amazing! and you are well to celebrate such a fete.

 As my sig lines says    'be careful of stupid people in a crowd'
Fete?  I do love a good fete, especially the coconut shy.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Erngath on August 21, 2019, 08:17:35 PM
Is Gerry a genius then?

No, just a fairly clever man who has worked and studied with dedication and has obtained recognition for his achievements in his chosen field.
IMO.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 21, 2019, 10:38:53 PM
No, just a fairly clever man who has worked and studied with dedication and has obtained recognition for his achievements in his chosen field.
IMO.

So did Harold Shipman.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 21, 2019, 10:39:45 PM
Plans that are put together “on the hoof” tend to u ravel pdq.  Ever heard the saying about proper planning and preparation?

Not always.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Erngath on August 21, 2019, 10:47:36 PM
So did Harold Shipman.

Perhaps on reflection you might regret making that post.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 21, 2019, 10:48:31 PM
Not always.
Oh?  Give me some examples then please.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 21, 2019, 10:50:19 PM
So did Harold Shipman.
What recognition for his achievements did Harold Shipman achieve, apart from life imprisonment?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 21, 2019, 10:52:51 PM
Perhaps on reflection you might regret making that post.

I very much doubt that.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 21, 2019, 10:55:24 PM
Oh?  Give me some examples then please.

Examples where on the hoof plans haven’t unravelled pdq....now let me think....ah they haven’t unravelled so how would we know how they were planned ?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 21, 2019, 10:56:53 PM
What recognition for his achievements did Harold Shipman achieve, apart from life imprisonment?

He became a very well respected doctor...a bit like Kate....at least until they both fell from grace.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Erngath on August 21, 2019, 10:59:29 PM
I very much doubt that.

If you have no regrets about comparing Gerry McCann's achievements with Harold Shipman's, then so be it.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 21, 2019, 11:00:39 PM
Examples where on the hoof plans haven’t unravelled pdq....now let me think....ah they haven’t unravelled so how would we know how they were planned ?
So how can you say with authority that on the hoof plans sometimes don’t unravel pdq?  Surely you’re not just making it up?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 21, 2019, 11:01:39 PM
If you have no regrets about comparing Gerry McCann's achievements with Harold Shipman's, then so be it.

They both gained success in their chosen field. Why should I regret pointing that out ?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 21, 2019, 11:02:39 PM
So how can you say with authority that on the hoof plans sometimes don’t unravel pdq?  Surely you’re not just making it up?

Sometimes...of course....always....no.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 21, 2019, 11:03:51 PM
He became a very well respected doctor...a bit like Kate....at least until they both fell from grace.
We were discussing Gerry and the recognition he has received in his chosen field.  He is not simply a common or garden GP like Harold Shipman was, or Kate McCann for that matter.
Incidentally I do find your continued insistence on comparing the McCanns to a mass murderer rather strange - do you believe the McCanns to be evil murderers?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 21, 2019, 11:04:33 PM
Sometimes...of course....always....no.
Sometimes you make stuff up but not always?  Oh, well thanks for the admission anyway.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Erngath on August 21, 2019, 11:05:25 PM
He became a very well respected doctor...a bit like Kate....at least until they both fell from grace.

Time to perhaps stop the comparison with both the McCann doctors and Harold Shipman.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Erngath on August 21, 2019, 11:07:56 PM
They both gained success in their chosen field. Why should I regret pointing that out ?

If you feel the comparison is valid, then feel free to point out the validity of that comparison.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 21, 2019, 11:12:52 PM
We were discussing Gerry and the recognition he has received in his chosen field.  He is not simply a common or garden GP like Harold Shipman was, or Kate McCann for that matter.
Incidentally I do find your continued insistence on comparing the McCanns to a mass murderer rather strange - do you believe the McCanns to be evil murderers?

No but because you reach great heights in your chosen field doesn’t make you exempt from making very bad decisions.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 21, 2019, 11:15:07 PM
If you feel the comparison is valid, then feel free to point out the validity of that comparison.
Faithlilly is obsessed with Harold Shipman, she has many times compared him with the McCanns, you can see for yourself by doing a forum search.  It’s the kind of thing that was discussed on that podcast about the trolls that Misty posted earlier - the vile insinuations made about victims’ families by online trolls masquerading as “justice seekers”.  Hardly a day goes by on twitter when the McCanns aren’t compared to a serial killer or convicted paedophile. 
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 21, 2019, 11:15:15 PM
Sometimes you make stuff up but not always?  Oh, well thanks for the admission anyway.

Dear oh dear.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 21, 2019, 11:15:44 PM
No but because you reach great heights in your chosen field doesn’t make you exempt from making very bad decisions.
Who said that it did?  Would you describe deliberately murdering loads of people as nothing more than a bad decision?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 21, 2019, 11:17:07 PM
Dear oh dear.
Read back, it’s what you posted.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 21, 2019, 11:17:18 PM
Time to perhaps stop the comparison with both the McCann doctors and Harold Shipman.

I will compare whosoever I please as long as I break no forum rules.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 21, 2019, 11:20:34 PM
I will compare whosoever I please as long as I break no forum rules.
May I compare thee to a summer’s day?  A really windy, wet one, the sort that just makes you feel depressed and sad.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Erngath on August 21, 2019, 11:21:25 PM
I will compare whosoever I please as long as I break no forum rules.

Feel free to continue your comparison of both Madeleine's parents with Harold Shipman.
Good night.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 21, 2019, 11:26:18 PM
Faithlilly is obsessed with Harold Shipman, she has many times compared him with the McCanns, you can see for yourself by doing a forum search.  It’s the kind of thing that was discussed on that podcast about the trolls that Misty posted earlier - the vile insinuations made about victims’ families by online trolls masquerading as “justice seekers”.  Hardly a day goes by on twitter when the McCanns aren’t compared to a serial killer or convicted paedophile.

Obsessed ? I was interested in your claim so I did a search and I have mentioned Harold Shipman 4 times and before tonight the last time was 2013 so hardly obsessed but hey, don’t let the truth get on the way of a good story.

Of course there’s no use searching for your obsessions as you’ve changed your name so often.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 21, 2019, 11:28:20 PM
Read back, it’s what you posted.

No it wasn’t...but of course you already know that.

Still, anything to keep my attention.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 21, 2019, 11:46:14 PM
Obsessed ? I was interested in your claim so I did a search and I have mentioned Harold Shipman 4 times and before tonight the last time was 2013 so hardly obsessed but hey, don’t let the truth get on the way of a good story.

Of course there’s no use searching for your obsessions as you’ve changed your name that often.
Then there’s all the times you made the comparison and the posts were (rightly) removed.  So, on four separate occasions that we have proof of you have mentioned Shipman in relation to the McCanns.  Time to change the record dear, you’ve made your point.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 21, 2019, 11:59:31 PM
Then there’s all the times you made the comparison and the posts were (rightly) removed.  So, on four separate occasions that we have proof of you have mentioned Shipman in relation to the McCanns.  Time to change the record dear, you’ve made your point.

You have no proof that I ever made any comparisons other than those I have just discussed and as the four I did discuss remain for all to see it makes a nonsense of your claim that others have been removed.

That you are searching my posts at all is the real cause for concern and illustrates the real obsession being displayed on these boards.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 22, 2019, 07:25:03 AM
You have no proof that I ever made any comparisons other than those I have just discussed and as the four I did discuss remain for all to see it makes a nonsense of your claim that others have been removed.

That you are searching my posts at all is the real cause for concern and illustrates the real obsession being displayed on these boards.
May I ask why it is a cause for concern?  Perhaps if you don’t want to be reminded of your previous posting history you could ask John to disable the search function whilst simultaneously reinstating the ignore function.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: G-Unit on August 22, 2019, 08:13:20 AM
Then there’s all the times you made the comparison and the posts were (rightly) removed.  So, on four separate occasions that we have proof of you have mentioned Shipman in relation to the McCanns.  Time to change the record dear, you’ve made your point.

Context is important. Some on here have suggested that the McCann's jobs had some bearing on the likelihood of them being involved in their daughter's disappearance. That's why other doctors who broke the law have been mentioned. I myself have mentioned Myles Bradbury for the same reason.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 22, 2019, 08:34:54 AM
Context is important. Some on here have suggested that the McCann's jobs had some bearing on the likelihood of them being involved in their daughter's disappearance. That's why other doctors who broke the law have been mentioned. I myself have mentioned Myles Bradbury for the same reason.
I think that’s a lie.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Mr Gray on August 22, 2019, 08:40:07 AM
Context is important. Some on here have suggested that the McCann's jobs had some bearing on the likelihood of them being involved in their daughter's disappearance. That's why other doctors who broke the law have been mentioned. I myself have mentioned Myles Bradbury for the same reason.

I think you are imagining things... Cite required
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: G-Unit on August 22, 2019, 08:53:20 AM
I think you are imagining things... Cite required

Snip/

Quote from: Davel on April 27, 2019, 09:24:55 AM
I think you need to reassess your logic... Can you give sone examples of normal respectable successful people doing such things... You will find people you think are such have past behaviour problems... Such as, Shipman..
Once, again you are presenting your opinion as, fact

G-Unit; Myles Bradbury. Respected doctor, devout Christian, family man.
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=10634.msg523246#msg523246

Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 22, 2019, 08:54:03 AM
Harold Shipman, Ted Bundy, Myles Bradbury, Fred and Rosemary West, Ian Brady and Myra Hindley, all have been used in comparison with the McCanns either here or elsewhere on the net.  All classic strawmen, I’m only surprised no one has yet mention Joseph Mengele, or perhaps they have?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Mr Gray on August 22, 2019, 08:59:01 AM
Snip/

Quote from: Davel on April 27, 2019, 09:24:55 AM
I think you need to reassess your logic... Can you give sone examples of normal respectable successful people doing such things... You will find people you think are such have past behaviour problems... Such as, Shipman..
Once, again you are presenting your opinion as, fact

G-Unit; Myles Bradbury. Respected doctor, devout Christian, family man.
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=10634.msg523246#msg523246

Never mentioned doctors.... I said ..normal respectable people... People with no history if wrongdoing
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: G-Unit on August 22, 2019, 09:07:07 AM
Never mentioned doctors.... I said ..normal respectable people... People with no history if wrongdoing

Which I supplied. A 'normal respectable person' who also happened to be a doctor. Being normal, respectable and having a good job is irrelevant.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: ShiningInLuz on August 22, 2019, 09:08:43 AM
The 'internet troll' thread is replete with references to the 'Drs McCann', as if such a title confers immunity from suspicion.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Mr Gray on August 22, 2019, 09:09:34 AM
Which I supplied. A 'normal respectable person' who also happened to be a doctor. Being normal, respectable and having a good job is irrelevant.

Being respectable isnt
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Mr Gray on August 22, 2019, 09:13:24 AM
It seems only police dog handlers are exempt from criticism in some peoples eyes
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Holly Goodhead on August 22, 2019, 10:02:44 AM
Being respectable isnt

How can it be determined whether or not one is 'respectable'?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Mr Gray on August 22, 2019, 10:08:02 AM
How can it be determined whether or not one is 'respectable'?

based on any history of non respectable behaviour. Shipman had a history of drug abuse
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: G-Unit on August 22, 2019, 10:34:52 AM
How can it be determined whether or not one is 'respectable'?
   

Is one "reputable, of good repute, upright, honest, honourable, trustworthy, above board, worthy, decent, good, virtuous, admirable, well bred, clean-living, proper, decorous?" Then one is supposedly respectable.

People have been seen as respectable but have then been revealed as anything but. Ernest Saunders and Jeffrey Archer, for example.

Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Holly Goodhead on August 22, 2019, 10:51:01 AM
   

Is one "reputable, of good repute, upright, honest, honourable, trustworthy, above board, worthy, decent, good, virtuous, admirable, well bred, clean-living, proper, decorous?" Then one is supposedly respectable.

People have been seen as respectable but have then been revealed as anything but. Ernest Saunders and Jeffrey Archer, for example.

The best example is probably child abuse committed by nuns, priests etc.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 22, 2019, 11:02:22 AM
It’s not just the McCanns (both of them) who would have had to act in an illegal “unrespectable” manner but also most or all of their friends.   So basically you’re talking about 9 Harold Shipmans who went on holiday together.  I guess some people are happy to believe this, despite the fact that they have all been investigated and a complete absence of evidence found to point to any illegal past actions.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Holly Goodhead on August 22, 2019, 11:05:26 AM
Anyone who describes Gerry as not the sharpest tool in the box isn't very bright imo.. And I love being out in the rain... Water is a life source

Well his decision, jointly formed with KM, about leaving the children alone in an unlocked apartment whilst they wined and dined out every night (other than night of arrival) isn't indicative of the sharpest tool in the box imo.  Nor was the campaign he spearheaded to 'Find Madeleine' imo.

Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Lace on August 22, 2019, 11:13:54 AM
It is easy to establish Gerry is not the sharpest tool in the box. I think KATE is the smarter of the two. It must have been very difficult living with him. He was not a hands on dad like the others, and they had 3 children under 4. real hard work! and she had a difficult Job as a GP. He was calling rhe shots- don't expect an elaborate plan to dispose of a body by him if he was involved!

There was Kate checking the bins...

So you suddenly know that,  Gerry wasn't the sharpest tool in the box,  he wasn't a hands on Dad and that he was calling the shots.   Amazing,   how do you know all that?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Holly Goodhead on August 22, 2019, 11:16:34 AM
It’s not just the McCanns (both of them) who would have had to act in an illegal “unrespectable” manner but also most or all of their friends.   So basically you’re talking about 9 Harold Shipmans who went on holiday together.  I guess some people are happy to believe this, despite the fact that they have all been investigated and a complete absence of evidence found to point to any illegal past actions.

I think the idea T9 were in any way involved in MM's disappearance (other than the crazy "childcare arrangements") is a non-starter but I think its folly in the extreme to say just because a person is this, that or the other it puts them/him/her above reproach.  We only have to consider events over the last decade or two to know its folly: church child abuse, MP's expenses, financial crisis caused by greed and recklessness, Hillsborough, Savile, VW emissions scandal, etc, etc. 
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: G-Unit on August 22, 2019, 11:17:27 AM
The best example is probably child abuse committed by nuns, priests etc.

Respectability lasts until someone is found out imo.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 22, 2019, 11:24:02 AM
May I ask why it is a cause for concern?  Perhaps if you don’t want to be reminded of your previous posting history you could ask John to disable the search function whilst simultaneously reinstating the ignore function.

I care not one jot who knows what I posted previously, I stand by every word I’ve said. What concerns me is posters misrepresenting what I have posted.

[reported]

Why was this reported ?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 22, 2019, 11:26:08 AM
Never mentioned doctors.... I said ..normal respectable people... People with no history if wrongdoing

No one is a criminal...until they are caught.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 22, 2019, 11:27:47 AM
It’s not just the McCanns (both of them) who would have had to act in an illegal “unrespectable” manner but also most or all of their friends.   So basically you’re talking about 9 Harold Shipmans who went on holiday together.  I guess some people are happy to believe this, despite the fact that they have all been investigated and a complete absence of evidence found to point to any illegal past actions.

But no one who was in PDL has been cleared...your argument.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 22, 2019, 05:35:11 PM
But no one who was in PDL has been cleared...your argument.
So?  Address my point.  We’re talking about the possibility of not one Harold Shipman, not two Harold Shipmans, but 9 Harold Shipmans (outwardly respectable pillars of the community with a deep dark secret) all on holiday together, acting in a criminal manner.  Is this your belief? 
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Holly Goodhead on August 22, 2019, 06:02:30 PM
So?  Address my point.  We’re talking about the possibility of not one Harold Shipman, not two Harold Shipmans, but 9 Harold Shipmans (outwardly respectable pillars of the community with a deep dark secret) all on holiday together, acting in a criminal manner.  Is this your belief?

Can an anology be drawn with what the so-called sceptics claim and a serial killer?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: sadie on August 22, 2019, 06:19:10 PM
Respectability lasts until someone is found out imo.

It is usually covered up by the Church.  The evildoing priest etc, is ticked off gently then moved geographically to some place that no-one knows about his  paedophilic past ... where it starts all over again ... and the offender often gets promoted into the bargain

Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 22, 2019, 06:19:28 PM
Can an anology be drawn with what the so-called sceptics claim and a serial killer?
So-called sceptics frequently compare the McCanns with serial killers, child murderers, etc - apparently it’s OK to do so on this forum so the answer has to be yes they can!
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 22, 2019, 06:28:21 PM
So?  Address my point.  We’re talking about the possibility of not one Harold Shipman, not two Harold Shipmans, but 9 Harold Shipmans (outwardly respectable pillars of the community with a deep dark secret) all on holiday together, acting in a criminal manner.  Is this your belief?

We are talking about successful, outwardly respectable people hiding a dark secret or to a greater or lesser degree facilitating the suppression of the truth.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 22, 2019, 06:30:27 PM
We are talking about successful, outwardly respectable people hiding a dark secret or to a greater or lesser degree facilitating the suppression of the truth.
That’s what I said isn’t it?  Nine of them.  All on holiday together.  All seemingly prepared to embrace criminality at the drop of a hat.  What are the chances, eh?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: sadie on August 22, 2019, 06:48:24 PM
That’s what I said isn’t it?  Nine of them.  All on holiday together.  All seemingly prepared to embrace criminality at the drop of a hat.  What are the chances, eh?

Nil
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Holly Goodhead on August 22, 2019, 06:53:52 PM
So-called sceptics frequently compare the McCanns with serial killers, child murderers, etc - apparently it’s OK to do so on this forum so the answer has to be yes they can!

Sorry I think there's been a misunderstanding.  I thought you were saying if the T9, many of whom were medi doctors, conspired to cover something up they would need to be as evil as Harold Shipman? 

I'm surprised anyone anywhere refers to the McCanns as serial killers, child murderers?  I thought those who believe the McCanns are involved also believe MM died as a result of an accident in 5A probably caused by drowsiness through being sedated to ensure the parents were able to have a carefree night out?  If this is the case it would be a case of manslaughter and perverting the course of justice or similar?

Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: barrier on August 22, 2019, 07:35:50 PM
Sorry I think there's been a misunderstanding.  I thought you were saying if the T9, many of whom were medi doctors, conspired to cover something up they would need to be as evil as Harold Shipman? 

I'm surprised anyone anywhere refers to the McCanns as serial killers, child murderers?  I thought those who believe the McCanns are involved also believe MM died as a result of an accident in 5A probably caused by drowsiness through being sedated to ensure the parents were able to have a carefree night out?  If this is the case it would be a case of manslaughter and perverting the course of justice or similar?

Which is where the statute of limitations would kick in,SIL posted about murder being 15 yrs,I'd venture less for lesser crimes.


Discussed previously.

http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=7626.0
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 22, 2019, 07:49:55 PM
Sorry I think there's been a misunderstanding.  I thought you were saying if the T9, many of whom were medi doctors, conspired to cover something up they would need to be as evil as Harold Shipman? 

I'm surprised anyone anywhere refers to the McCanns as serial killers, child murderers?  I thought those who believe the McCanns are involved also believe MM died as a result of an accident in 5A probably caused by drowsiness through being sedated to ensure the parents were able to have a carefree night out?  If this is the case it would be a case of manslaughter and perverting the course of justice or similar?

Certainly no one here believes the parents are serial killers or child murderers. I can’t comment on elsewhere.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 22, 2019, 08:31:04 PM
Certainly no one here believes the parents are serial killers or child murderers. I can’t comment on elsewhere.
Wrong.  At least one person thinks the parents killed Madeleine and another thinks the parents covered up sex abuse and/or a beating which resulted in death, from what I can gather.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: G-Unit on August 22, 2019, 08:52:17 PM
Wrong.  At least one person thinks the parents killed Madeleine and another thinks the parents covered up sex abuse and/or a beating which resulted in death, from what I can gather.

Providing cites would show if people actually said that or if it's how you interpreted their words.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 22, 2019, 09:02:58 PM
Providing cites would show if people actually said that or if it's how you interpreted their words.
”from what I can gather...”.  Of course, one of them is a self-confessed WUM and and the other speaks in riddles but if you’ve been following their posts carefully over the years I’m fairly sure you’d gather the same.  And as for you, don’t tell me you’ve ruled out sex abuse or murder by the parents either?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: ShiningInLuz on August 22, 2019, 09:12:48 PM
”from what I can gather...”.  Of course, one of them is a self-confessed WUM and and the other speaks in riddles but if you’ve been following their posts carefully over the years I’m fairly sure you’d gather the same.  And as for you, don’t tell me you’ve ruled out sex abuse or murder by the parents either?

Over how many years have you carefully followed their posts?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 22, 2019, 09:22:14 PM
Over how many years have you carefully followed their posts?
a few.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 22, 2019, 09:30:24 PM
a few.

Phew I glad it’s not just mine.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Miss Taken Identity on August 22, 2019, 09:58:02 PM
So-called sceptics frequently compare the McCanns with serial killers, child murderers, etc - apparently it’s OK to do so on this forum so the answer has to be yes they can!

OK why not name and shame those who you claim are comparing the McCanns to serial killers.

I read people claiming that being a doctor is not a valid reasons for being suspected of a crime- any crime.

"Wrong.  At least one person thinks the parents killed Madeleine and another thinks the parents covered up sex abuse and/or a beating which resulted in death, from what I can gather"

What fanciful claims -you gathered up the wrong rubbish!

No one has claimed the McCanns murdered their child or are serial killers.  Wih regards to the sex abuse / beating claims- that probably would be offerd as part of a reason for hiding a body- as I  have read similar posts in reply to questions from supporters in that regard.

Having said that - you and I do not know what happened to MBM- the parents claimed they were drugged and one was kidnapped by a paedo gang! They are NOT sure what happened they are guessing like everyone else sleuthing.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 22, 2019, 10:10:56 PM
Phew I glad it’s not just mine.
You flatter yourself.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 22, 2019, 10:12:05 PM
You flatter yourself.

You think it’s flattering to be stalked ?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 22, 2019, 10:12:10 PM
OK why not name and shame those who you claim are comparing the McCanns to serial killers.

I read people claiming that being a doctor is not a valid reasons for being suspected of a crime- any crime.

"Wrong.  At least one person thinks the parents killed Madeleine and another thinks the parents covered up sex abuse and/or a beating which resulted in death, from what I can gather"

What fanciful claims -you gathered up the wrong rubbish!

No one has claimed the McCanns murdered their child or are serial killers.  Wih regards to the sex abuse / beating claims- that probably would be offerd as part of a reason for hiding a body- as I  have read similar posts in reply to questions from supporters in that regard.

Having said that - you and I do not know what happened to MBM- the parents claimed they were drugged and one was kidnapped by a paedo gang! They are NOT sure what happened they are guessing like everyone else sleuthing.
Yawn.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 22, 2019, 10:13:47 PM
You think it’s flattering to be stalked ?
In what way am I stalking you? You seem to be under the misguided impression that you are my sole focus on this forum.  Get a grip woman, you’re not all that fascinating.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Miss Taken Identity on August 22, 2019, 10:20:29 PM
You think it’s flattering to be stalked ?


He and Alfie (remember him) both stalk you and hang onto your every word... Both boring and perhaps lonely.

He will refuse to reply to most of my posts because He doesn't have a real answer!

The real reason MBM has not been found is. those looking for her don't know what happened to her.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 22, 2019, 10:22:02 PM

He and Alfie (remember him) both stalk you and hang onto your every word... Both boring and perhaps lonely.

He will refuse to reply to most of my posts because He doesn't have a real answer!

The real reason MBM has not been found is. those looking for her don't know what happened to her.
You are stalking me - help!!
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: misty on August 23, 2019, 12:34:19 AM
Sorry I think there's been a misunderstanding.  I thought you were saying if the T9, many of whom were medi doctors, conspired to cover something up they would need to be as evil as Harold Shipman? 

I'm surprised anyone anywhere refers to the McCanns as serial killers, child murderers?  I thought those who believe the McCanns are involved also believe MM died as a result of an accident in 5A probably caused by drowsiness through being sedated to ensure the parents were able to have a carefree night out?  If this is the case it would be a case of manslaughter and perverting the course of justice or similar?

Harold Shipman never hid the bodies of his victims. IMO I suspect a Portuguese pathologist wouldn't even bother with toxicology tests if initial findings showed an accidental death caused by a fall.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 23, 2019, 03:16:26 AM
Providing cites would show if people actually said that or if it's how you interpreted their words.
VS has already explained that it is his interpretation.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 23, 2019, 03:20:09 AM
You think it’s flattering to be stalked ?
You seem to ask for it.  Did you really need to say: "Phew I glad it’s not just mine"?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: slartibartfast on August 23, 2019, 10:20:08 AM
It is usually covered up by the Church.  The evildoing priest etc, is ticked off gently then moved geographically to some place that no-one knows about his  paedophilic past ... where it starts all over again ... and the offender often gets promoted into the bargain

Paedophiles usually resurface.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: barrier on August 23, 2019, 10:27:53 AM
Recently on bbc there was a case in Scotland where cameras were allowed to follow an investigation into a disappearance also with the victms family's permission,to get to the crux of the matter,a body was only discovered after a man was sentenced to a womans murder and he called the officer in charge of the investigation  a month after sentencing to tell them where to look,the location was just outside of their search parameters in the investigation.So it can be done with adult bodies.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Miss Taken Identity on August 23, 2019, 06:50:59 PM
Harold Shipman never hid the bodies of his victims. IMO I suspect a Portuguese pathologist wouldn't even bother with toxicology tests if initial findings showed an accidental death caused by a fall.

And why would they? the Uk pathologists never questioned HS patients either.

 He was found out by an ex Mayors daughter and backed up by funeral houses who had noticed a larger than usual amount of one sig death certs from that surgery.

The PJ and Amaral were NOT responsible for Maddie going missing so why keep on about them. It was/ is the parents responsibility -her fate lies on their hands!
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Miss Taken Identity on August 23, 2019, 06:54:04 PM
OK why not name and shame those who you claim are comparing the McCanns to serial killers.

I read people claiming that being a doctor is not a valid reasons for being suspected of a crime- any crime.

"Wrong.  At least one person thinks the parents killed Madeleine and another thinks the parents covered up sex abuse and/or a beating which resulted in death, from what I can gather"

What fanciful claims -you gathered up the wrong rubbish!

No one has claimed the McCanns murdered their child or are serial killers.  Wih regards to the sex abuse / beating claims- that probably would be offerd as part of a reason for hiding a body- as I  have read similar posts in reply to questions from supporters in that regard.

Having said that - you and I do not know what happened to MBM- the parents claimed they were drugged and one was kidnapped by a paedo gang! They are NOT sure what happened they are guessing like everyone else sleuthing.

"OK why not name and shame those who you claim are comparing the McCanns to serial killers."


Obviously  you cannot answer because you were talking your  usual rubbish.

So no one has called the McCanns serial killers/paedophile child killers.

Glad we got that cleared up.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: misty on August 24, 2019, 12:18:53 PM
And why would they? the Uk pathologists never questioned HS patients either.

 He was found out by an ex Mayors daughter and backed up by funeral houses who had noticed a larger than usual amount of one sig death certs from that surgery.

The PJ and Amaral were NOT responsible for Maddie going missing so why keep on about them. It was/ is the parents responsibility -her fate lies on their hands!

The point I was trying to make is - if Harold Shipman saw no need to hide the bodies of patients he'd killed in the UK, why on earth would 2 doctors holidaying abroad have hypothetically hidden the body of their child after she'd suffered a fatal accident? If the pathology report on Jacinta Rees is anything to go by, it demonstrated that Portuguese authorities haven't the time, money or inclination to investigate possible crimes against foreign citizens.
All IMO.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 24, 2019, 12:22:37 PM
The point I was trying to make is - if Harold Shipman saw no need to hide the bodies of patients he'd killed in the UK, why on earth would 2 doctors holidaying abroad have hypothetically hidden the body of their child after she'd suffered a fatal accident? If the pathology report on Jacinta Rees is anything to go by, it demonstrated that Portuguese authorities haven't the time, money or inclination to investigate possible crimes against foreign citizens.
All IMO.
What a gamble to take?  Would that be the end of it?  When they got back to England would the UK police take over?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: barrier on August 24, 2019, 12:45:28 PM
What a gamble to take?  Would that be the end of it?  When they got back to England would the UK police take over?
[/b]

Theres not alot OG can do,but that would be one of them.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: ShiningInLuz on August 24, 2019, 04:13:21 PM
The point I was trying to make is - if Harold Shipman saw no need to hide the bodies of patients he'd killed in the UK, why on earth would 2 doctors holidaying abroad have hypothetically hidden the body of their child after she'd suffered a fatal accident? If the pathology report on Jacinta Rees is anything to go by, it demonstrated that Portuguese authorities haven't the time, money or inclination to investigate possible crimes against foreign citizens.
All IMO.

As Jacinta Rees means absolutely nothing to me, do you have any evidence that the McCanns were aware of the case, and more importantly, of the pathology report?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: misty on August 24, 2019, 04:40:56 PM
As Jacinta Rees means absolutely nothing to me, do you have any evidence that the McCanns were aware of the case, and more importantly, of the pathology report?

The Rees death occurred after Madeleine's disappearance.
https://www.news.com.au/national/jacinta-rees-murdered-covered-up-by-portugal-police/news-story/5d908a385cb28bbf63c5279d83668cee

https://www.heraldsun.com.au/ipad/call-to-review-model-murder/news-story/2ab8b261919dcae901207bdcdde26105
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 24, 2019, 04:47:58 PM
The Rees death occurred after Madeleine's disappearance.
https://www.news.com.au/national/jacinta-rees-murdered-covered-up-by-portugal-police/news-story/5d908a385cb28bbf63c5279d83668cee

https://www.heraldsun.com.au/ipad/call-to-review-model-murder/news-story/2ab8b261919dcae901207bdcdde26105

And that the McCanns were aware of it ?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 24, 2019, 07:17:35 PM
The Rees death occurred after Madeleine's disappearance.
https://www.news.com.au/national/jacinta-rees-murdered-covered-up-by-portugal-police/news-story/5d908a385cb28bbf63c5279d83668cee

https://www.heraldsun.com.au/ipad/call-to-review-model-murder/news-story/2ab8b261919dcae901207bdcdde26105
"Jacinta Rees, an Australian woman who was found dead at her home near São Brás de Alportel in March 2008 was murdered, according to a autopsy report carried out in her home country. The victim's family are now trying to uncover the truth surrounding her death, which was filed by Portuguese authorities as suicide."
https://www.facebook.com/PortugalNews/posts/160770357287416/
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 24, 2019, 07:55:46 PM
"Jacinta Rees, an Australian woman who was found dead at her home near São Brás de Alportel in March 2008 was murdered, according to a autopsy report carried out in her home country. The victim's family are now trying to uncover the truth surrounding her death, which was filed by Portuguese authorities as suicide."
https://www.facebook.com/PortugalNews/posts/160770357287416/
Was that the woman who managed to axe herself to death according to the Portuguese?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Eleanor on August 24, 2019, 08:00:06 PM
Was that the woman who managed to axe herself to death according to the Portuguese?

That was the one.  She hit herself over the head with an axe four times.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: misty on August 24, 2019, 11:19:14 PM
That was the one.  She hit herself over the head with an axe four times.

Do you think toxicology tests were carried out? ^*&&
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 25, 2019, 02:27:59 AM
Do you think toxicology tests were carried out? ^*&&
If she had asked for them they would do it.  $6(&
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 25, 2019, 09:12:03 AM
That was the one.  She hit herself over the head with an axe four times.
Obviously one determined lady.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Eleanor on August 25, 2019, 09:16:45 AM
Obviously one determined lady.

And she did it while running around her garden.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 25, 2019, 09:23:27 AM
And she did it while running around her garden.
Call me zenophobic (sic) but I really don’t think the Portuguese authorities give a stuff about justice when it comes to those pesky foreigners who probably asked for it anyway, drunken idiots that they are.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Eleanor on August 25, 2019, 09:34:56 AM
Call me zenophobic (sic) but I really don’t think the Portuguese authorities give a stuff about justice when it comes to those pesky foreigners who probably asked for it anyway, drunken idiots that they are.

And what are these pesky foreigners doing living in a village on a known slave trade route?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: G-Unit on August 25, 2019, 10:19:47 AM
There is mention of a 'Victorian Coroner's Report' but none is recorded in the Coroner's Court of Victoria.

https://www.gerrymccannsblogs.co.uk/press/45jan11/HERALDSUN_03_01_11.htm
https://www.coronerscourt.vic.gov.au/inquests-findings/findings
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Eleanor on August 25, 2019, 10:53:14 PM
There is mention of a 'Victorian Coroner's Report' but none is recorded in the Coroner's Court of Victoria.

https://www.gerrymccannsblogs.co.uk/press/45jan11/HERALDSUN_03_01_11.htm
https://www.coronerscourt.vic.gov.au/inquests-findings/findings

So you think it never happened?

I don't know what has come over you lately.  You weren't ever an unkind person before.  But now you are.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: G-Unit on August 25, 2019, 11:15:23 PM
So you think it never happened?

I don't know what has come over you lately.  You weren't ever an unkind person before.  But now you are.

As there's no record of it there's reason to wonder why not? Now I'm unkind as well as stupid? My you are busy tonight.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Eleanor on August 25, 2019, 11:19:43 PM
As there's no record of it there's reason to wonder why not? Now I'm unkind as well as stupid? My you are busy tonight.

Even I get a bit fed up with this rubbish now and again.  I simply don't understand the unkindness.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: misty on August 25, 2019, 11:25:23 PM
There is mention of a 'Victorian Coroner's Report' but none is recorded in the Coroner's Court of Victoria.

https://www.gerrymccannsblogs.co.uk/press/45jan11/HERALDSUN_03_01_11.htm
https://www.coronerscourt.vic.gov.au/inquests-findings/findings

That's possibly because the Coroner was unable to order further police investigation into the cause of death.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 25, 2019, 11:29:32 PM
Even I get a bit fed up with this rubbish now and again.  I simply don't understand the unkindness.

Unkindness or unwillingness to buy into the bullsh*t....take you pick.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: sadie on August 25, 2019, 11:32:27 PM
Was that the woman who managed to axe herself to death according to the Portuguese?

Well they had good go at trying to make Jacintha Rees into a Mad woman.

Her car broke down on a mountain road and according to them they found her sitting in a circle of lit candles ... so must be mad ???  Erm, I think not.



Mountain roads are usually unlit, and they are usually narrow and winding. Some cars go too fast.'


Such a sensible thing to do, to illuminate herself and her car to prevent some one crashing into them, but if reports were correct, The PJ twisted it into Jacinta was obviously mad sitting on a mountain surrounded by lit candles.


To help justify their proclaimed assessment of suicide ?   Dunno.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 25, 2019, 11:35:40 PM
There is mention of a 'Victorian Coroner's Report' but none is recorded in the Coroner's Court of Victoria.

https://www.gerrymccannsblogs.co.uk/press/45jan11/HERALDSUN_03_01_11.htm
https://www.coronerscourt.vic.gov.au/inquests-findings/findings
What are you suggesting exactly?
https://www.heraldsun.com.au/ipad/call-to-review-model-murder/news-story/2ab8b261919dcae901207bdcdde26105
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Eleanor on August 25, 2019, 11:39:56 PM
Unkindness or unwillingness to buy into the bullsh*t....take you pick.

How can you decide that it's bulls hi*t if you don't know?  Is there never to be any benefit of doubt?

I have been doing this for a very long time and I am a bit weary now.  But don't worry about me.  I will be fine again tomorrow.  If only it were just about me.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 25, 2019, 11:43:26 PM
Surely you know by now Eleanor that it won’t do to highlight anything at all that casts the amazing Portuguese judicial system in a bad light?  It is perfect in every way and there has never been a miscarriage of justice.  Obviously in the case of Jacinta Rees the Portuguese were right and the Australian autopsy and Jacinta’s family were paid by the McCanns to tell great big lies about it all.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 25, 2019, 11:49:38 PM
How can you decide that it's bulls hi*t if you don't know?  Is there never to be any benefit of doubt?

I have been doing this for a very long time and I am a bit weary now.  But don't worry about me.  I will be fine again tomorrow.  If only it were just about me.

If benefit of the doubt is to be used it needs to be used in all circumstances and not only when it suits.

Disillusionment comes with the territory I think and sometimes it’s good to step but and give yourself time to reassess what really matters. Take care Eleanor.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Eleanor on August 26, 2019, 12:00:39 AM
Surely you know by now Eleanor that it won’t do to highlight anything at all that casts the amazing Portuguese judicial system in a bad light?  It is perfect in every way and there has never been a miscarriage of justice.  Obviously in the case of Jacinta Rees the Portuguese were right and the Australian autopsy and Jacinta’s family were paid by the McCanns to tell great big lies about it all.

I really don't know how The Portuguese Justice System has survived for as long as it has.  It is no better now than it was before The Glorious Revolutions, both of them.

I am not all that interested in definitions of Freedom of Speech or The Right to an Opinion, but I do mind when the lead Investigator uses his internal knowledge to make money from a tragedy.  This grossly offends me, and should offend everyone.

No one even knows if Madeleine is dead, and none of us have the right to assume that she is.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Eleanor on August 26, 2019, 12:02:41 AM
If benefit of the doubt is to be used it needs to be used in all circumstances and not only when it suits.

Disillusionment comes with the territory I think and sometimes it’s good to step but and give yourself time to reassess what really matters. Take care Eleanor.

Toi aussi.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Brietta on August 26, 2019, 12:22:15 AM
What are you suggesting exactly?
https://www.heraldsun.com.au/ipad/call-to-review-model-murder/news-story/2ab8b261919dcae901207bdcdde26105

My suggestion is that it is highly highly unusual to commit suicide by using blows from an axe to the head while at the same time defending oneself as attested by the defensive wounds recorded at the autopsy.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 26, 2019, 12:28:40 AM
Well they had good go at trying to make Jacintha Rees into a Mad woman.

Her car broke down on a mountain road and according to them they found her sitting in a circle of lit candles ... so must be mad ???  Erm, I think not.



Mountain roads are usually unlit, and they are usually narrow and winding. Some cars go too fast.'


Such a sensible thing to do, to illuminate herself and her car to prevent some one crashing into them, but if reports were correct, The PJ twisted it into Jacinta was obviously mad sitting on a mountain surrounded by lit candles.


To help justify their proclaimed assessment of suicide ?   Dunno.
Are you getting two cases muddled up?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Eleanor on August 26, 2019, 12:28:52 AM
My suggestion is that it is highly highly unusual to commit suicide by using blows from an axe to the head while at the same time defending oneself as attested by the defensive wounds recorded at the autopsy.

It is quite obvious that this woman was murdered.  What remains indefensible is that The Portuguese Police tried to say that it was suicide.  Why for God's sake?  Was there something to hide?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Brietta on August 26, 2019, 12:37:31 AM
Surely you know by now Eleanor that it won’t do to highlight anything at all that casts the amazing Portuguese judicial system in a bad light?  It is perfect in every way and there has never been a miscarriage of justice.  Obviously in the case of Jacinta Rees the Portuguese were right and the Australian autopsy and Jacinta’s family were paid by the McCanns to tell great big lies about it all.

The first autopsy carried out by the Portuguese authorities suggested murder not suicide.



Autopsy points to homicide

Extreme violence, very hard to attribute to herself. Probable signs of defense and suggestive of murder. "These are the findings of the first body autopsy of Jacinta Rees, a former Australian model found dead in her backyard in Sao Brás de Alportel, Algarve, in 2004.

The report, which the CM had access to when consulting the inquiry process opened by the Faro Public Prosecution Service, contradicts the Judicial Police, for whom the death of the victim "had no third party intervention, excluding criminal action".

After several months of investigation, the PJ men became convinced that the Australian had a "very disturbing mental picture" and thrust three axes at herself "to get the Devil out of her head." Forensic examination reveals that Jacinta suffered three strikes, three centimeters each, two vertical and one tilted to the right, which raises the question of how she managed to thrust three axes in the head without falling at the first. The PJ says that "any aggression from a third party willing to kill would cause more serious injuries."

The former model was found dead in the backyard after a stormy night. Indoors, the PJ found traces of blood and the ax in a carrycot. In the yard, if there was any clue, it was destroyed by the storm.

Although the autopsy suggests homicide, as a second forensic examination carried out months later in Australia, at the request of the family, the Judiciary Police stresses that "the victim's personal life and the whole scenario around death must be taken care of."

There was much evidence of Australian mental disturbance. A friend of the victim, for example, said she "constantly talked to angels and demons."

The lawsuit was filed for lack of evidence, but the prosecutor was also not convinced by the PJ version. The case was classified as "unusual". Jacinta's family also does not accept the theory of suicide.

https://www.cmjornal.pt/portugal/detalhe/autopsia-aponta-para-homicidio?ref=Mais%20Sobre_BlocoMaisSobre
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: G-Unit on August 26, 2019, 07:08:06 AM
That's possibly because the Coroner was unable to order further police investigation into the cause of death.

Can Coroners do that? I thought their job was to find the cause of a death.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: barrier on August 26, 2019, 07:13:03 AM
I really don't know how The Portuguese Justice System has survived for as long as it has.  It is no better now than it was before The Glorious Revolutions, both of them.

I am not all that interested in definitions of Freedom of Speech or The Right to an Opinion, but I do mind when the lead Investigator uses his internal knowledge to make money from a tragedy.  This grossly offends me, and should offend everyone.

No one even knows if Madeleine is dead, and none of us have the right to assume that she is.

OG didn't dig up the Portuguese countryside for the fun of it.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 26, 2019, 07:47:58 AM
It is quite obvious that this woman was murdered.  What remains indefensible is that The Portuguese Police tried to say that it was suicide.  Why for God's sake?  Was there something to hide?
Either that or they are simply bone idle and don’t give a stuff about what happens to foreigners on their own soil.  Whatever the reason, it doesn’t reflect very well on the Portuguese justice system.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: G-Unit on August 26, 2019, 08:23:44 AM
Either that or they are simply bone idle and don’t give a stuff about what happens to foreigners on their own soil.  Whatever the reason, it doesn’t reflect very well on the Portuguese justice system.

Let's do a bit of Greece bashing, just for a change;

The Greek authorities have re-opened the inquiry into the the death of Jean Hanlon, following a TV documentary.

A post-mortem examination concluded Jean Hanlon, 53, drowned but information released later suggested injuries consistent with a struggle.
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-south-scotland-49470796
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 26, 2019, 08:33:24 AM
Let's do a bit of Greece bashing, just for a change;

The Greek authorities have re-opened the inquiry into the the death of Jean Hanlon, following a TV documentary.

A post-mortem examination concluded Jean Hanlon, 53, drowned but information released later suggested injuries consistent with a struggle.
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-south-scotland-49470796
Why?  It’s not relevant to this case and your post is most definitely deflection from the incompetence of the Portuguese.  The question is why you would wish to do that?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: G-Unit on August 26, 2019, 08:47:09 AM
Why?  It’s not relevant to this case and your post is most definitely deflection from the incompetence of the Portuguese.  The question is why you would wish to do that?

How is the death of an Australian woman relevant to the thread topic? All police forces make mistakes and those combing the news to find cases in Portugal to criticise clearly have an agenda imo. The Portuguese can't be blamed for failing to find Madeleine's body, if such exists, any more than the UK police can be blamed for the same failure.

The fact that no body was found doesn't, of course, mean that Madeleine is alive. She is missing and as yet no-one knows why, how or who.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 26, 2019, 08:54:46 AM
How is the death of an Australian woman relevant to the thread topic? All police forces make mistakes and those combing the news to find cases in Portugal to criticise clearly have an agenda imo. The Portuguese can't be blamed for failing to find Madeleine's body, if such exists, any more than the UK police can be blamed for the same failure.

The fact that no body was found doesn't, of course, mean that Madeleine is alive. She is missing and as yet no-one knows why, how or who.
It’s relevant because it happened in Portugal and is a further example of Portuguese lack of rigour in getting to the truth regarding a crime against a foreign national.  Cases that occurred in Greece (which you brought up) are therefore completely irrelevant.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: G-Unit on August 26, 2019, 09:03:15 AM
It’s relevant because it happened in Portugal and is a further example of Portuguese lack of rigour in getting to the truth regarding a crime against a foreign national.  Cases that occurred in Greece (which you brought up) are therefore completely irrelevant.

No it isn't. What happens in one case has nothing to do with what happens in another, and it's clearly off topic on this thread.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 26, 2019, 09:25:44 AM
No it isn't. What happens in one case has nothing to do with what happens in another, and it's clearly off topic on this thread.
I didn’t see you raising the same objections when Harold Shipman’s name was introduced to the thread, in fact I seem to recall you mentioning the name of another murderer to justify its relevance, funny that.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 26, 2019, 09:43:07 AM
Context is important. Some on here have suggested that the McCann's jobs had some bearing on the likelihood of them being involved in their daughter's disappearance. That's why other doctors who broke the law have been mentioned. I myself have mentioned Myles Bradbury for the same reason.

“What happens in one case has nothing to do with what happens in another” - G-Unit

So which is it G?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: G-Unit on August 26, 2019, 09:51:28 AM
“What happens in one case has nothing to do with what happens in another” - G-Unit

So which is it G?

Pointing out that being a doctor doesn't preclude committing a crime isn't the same as continually trying to suggest that a country's judicial system is unfit for purpose.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 26, 2019, 09:58:44 AM
Pointing out that being a doctor doesn't preclude committing a crime isn't the same as continually trying to suggest that a country's judicial system is unfit for purpose.
I knew it would be one rule for the sceptics and one for the supporters.  Are you saying it was not possible to make the case that being a doctor does not preclude one from committing a crime without mentioning Harold Shipman or other murderers?  Why is it not equally as acceptable to point out that the Portuguese justice system does not always get it right by pointing to other obvious failings on their part?  Please explain the fundamental differences as you see them.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: pathfinder73 on August 26, 2019, 10:15:37 AM
It was British police dogs that changed the McCann case not Portugal. They have to finish what they started so enter SY looking for the body in PDL. Ask SY why they haven't found a body.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Miss Taken Identity on August 26, 2019, 10:21:42 AM
Pointing out that being a doctor doesn't preclude committing a crime isn't the same as continually trying to suggest that a country's judicial system is unfit for purpose.


Madeleines case is differnent. as all cases are.


The Police arrive to claims a child was missing, the it became an abduction. No initial evidence of a break in or abduction was apparent, then came the time lines... no wonder the police didn't believe them. That is why they have not found the child. not much help from the T9. Smoke and mirrors come to mind!
People need to look at what the PJ did to facilitate Maddies disappearance.= Nothing.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Angelo222 on August 26, 2019, 10:51:02 AM
It was British police dogs that changed the McCann case not Portugal. They have to finish what they started so enter SY looking for the body in PDL. Ask SY why they haven't found a body.

The area around PdL is pockmarked with natural drainage holes and to search every single one would be an impossible task.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 26, 2019, 10:56:55 AM

Madeleines case is differnent. as all cases are.


The Police arrive to claims a child was missing, the it became an abduction. No initial evidence of a break in or abduction was apparent, then came the time lines... no wonder the police didn't believe them. That is why they have not found the child. not much help from the T9. Smoke and mirrors come to mind!
People need to look at what the PJ did to facilitate Maddies disappearance.= Nothing.
People need to look at what the PJ did to find Madeleine.  Not much, is the answer.  They abandoned the search after a week iirc.  A very poor effort indeed IMO.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: G-Unit on August 26, 2019, 11:09:08 AM
People nee to look at what the PJ did to find Madeleine.  Not much, is the answer.  They abandoned the search after a week iirc.  A very poor effort indeed IMO.

The teams available and deployed by Major Seqeuira were drawn from unit of the GNR, Civil Protection, Fire Brigade, Red Cross and Urban Police. Each team numbered
around 10 and between 80 to 100 personnel were involved in search activity...

The search was split into 3 zones radiating out from Praia Da Luz in a northward direction. The first zone extended 3km to the EN125 road at Espiche. W?hin this zone, sectors were drawn using the natural boundaries that exist and included the entire village. Officers were briefed and debriefed before and after deployments and records of activity collected. Each sector was repeatedly searched on 3 separate occasions over the 7 days using officers conducting line searches and supported by air scenting dogs.

The next Zone 2 was extended out to a radius of 7km to the boundary of the N120 road at Bensafrim. As the sectors were larger and in order to support the line searches 2 GNR officers on motorcycles and 6 GNR officers on horse-back were deployed. These sectors were all searched on 2 separate occasions over the 7 day period.
The outer zone 3 was extended to 15km at Barragem de Odiaxere a dammed lake. This zone is in a mountainous region subject to flash forest fires.
Therefore Fire officers who routinely patrol and have local knowledge of the area were tasked to drive the tracks, visit empty properties to look for the missing girl. Additionally the fire brigade used a boat to visually inspect the surface water of the lake.
https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/MARK_HARRISON.htm
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 26, 2019, 02:15:16 PM
The teams available and deployed by Major Seqeuira were drawn from unit of the GNR, Civil Protection, Fire Brigade, Red Cross and Urban Police. Each team numbered
around 10 and between 80 to 100 personnel were involved in search activity...

The search was split into 3 zones radiating out from Praia Da Luz in a northward direction. The first zone extended 3km to the EN125 road at Espiche. W?hin this zone, sectors were drawn using the natural boundaries that exist and included the entire village. Officers were briefed and debriefed before and after deployments and records of activity collected. Each sector was repeatedly searched on 3 separate occasions over the 7 days using officers conducting line searches and supported by air scenting dogs.

The next Zone 2 was extended out to a radius of 7km to the boundary of the N120 road at Bensafrim. As the sectors were larger and in order to support the line searches 2 GNR officers on motorcycles and 6 GNR officers on horse-back were deployed. These sectors were all searched on 2 separate occasions over the 7 day period.
The outer zone 3 was extended to 15km at Barragem de Odiaxere a dammed lake. This zone is in a mountainous region subject to flash forest fires.
Therefore Fire officers who routinely patrol and have local knowledge of the area were tasked to drive the tracks, visit empty properties to look for the missing girl. Additionally the fire brigade used a boat to visually inspect the surface water of the lake.
https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/MARK_HARRISON.htm
7 whole days.  Even the Malaysian police were still searching after 7 days in the Nora Quoirin case.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: ShiningInLuz on August 26, 2019, 03:57:21 PM
7 whole days.  Even the Malaysian police were still searching after 7 days in the Nora Quoirin case.

Whereas Harrison et al and OG focused 100% on Zone 1.

Damn poor effort by the Brits?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 26, 2019, 06:08:19 PM
Whereas Harrison et al and OG focused 100% on Zone 1.

Damn poor effort by the Brits?
Did the UK police have free rein to search anywhere they wanted and for any length of time?  And let’s not forget the reason they were there in the first place - the damn poor effort by the Portuguese.  IMO.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: ShiningInLuz on August 26, 2019, 06:20:22 PM
Did the UK police have free rein to search anywhere they wanted and for any length of time?  And let’s not forget the reason they were there in the first place - the damn poor effort by the Portuguese.  IMO.

Is there reason to believe Harrison was restricted?  No!

Is there reason to believe OG with its £12m budget was restricted?  No!

Damn poor effort by the Brits, according to your logic!
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 26, 2019, 07:00:33 PM
Is there reason to believe Harrison was restricted?  No!

Is there reason to believe OG with its £12m budget was restricted?  No!

Damn poor effort by the Brits, according to your logic!
Are you telling me there are no restrictions on visiting police forces from investigating anywhere they like for as long as they like?  Why are you so defensive of the Portuguese police? 
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Brietta on August 26, 2019, 07:04:52 PM
Is there reason to believe Harrison was restricted?  No!

Is there reason to believe OG with its £12m budget was restricted?  No!

Damn poor effort by the Brits, according to your logic!

"Is there reason to believe Harrison was restricted?  No!"  Why was Harrison there in the first place?  Could it have been because the Portuguese had failed miserably to progress Madeleine's case in any meaningful way and were at a loss regarding basic techniques in a missing child case?

Is there reason to believe OG with its £12m budget was restricted?  No!  The Brits didn't have a £12 million budget.  The money spent on Madeleine's case evolved along with the amount of work necessary and it is obviously still evolving along with the finance available which keeps her case an active one ... so still work to be done in my opinion.

Damn poor effort by the Brits, according to your logic!  Damn puerile argument considering that Scotland yard and the Policia Judiciaria are both still working on the criminal investigation into Madeleine's case which could be easily described by use of the interesting word "Oikophobia" which seems to fit the tone of many of your posts about the Brits.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: ShiningInLuz on August 26, 2019, 08:45:37 PM
"Is there reason to believe Harrison was restricted?  No!"  Why was Harrison there in the first place?  Could it have been because the Portuguese had failed miserably to progress Madeleine's case in any meaningful way and were at a loss regarding basic techniques in a missing child case?

Is there reason to believe OG with its £12m budget was restricted?  No!  The Brits didn't have a £12 million budget.  The money spent on Madeleine's case evolved along with the amount of work necessary and it is obviously still evolving along with the finance available which keeps her case an active one ... so still work to be done in my opinion.

Damn poor effort by the Brits, according to your logic!  Damn puerile argument considering that Scotland yard and the Policia Judiciaria are both still working on the criminal investigation into Madeleine's case which could be easily described by use of the interesting word "Oikophobia" which seems to fit the tone of many of your posts about the Brits.

As long as puerile xenophobia is pumped out about all things Portuguese, I am free to respond in like kind about the UK investigation.

If this breaches forum rules, then no doubt you will take action to curb the blatant xenophobia.

Since you haven't, your viewpoint is worth no more than that of any poster on this forum.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 26, 2019, 08:48:03 PM
As long as puerile xenophobia is pumped out about all things Portuguese, I am free to respond in like kind about the UK investigation.

If this breaches forum rules, then no doubt you will take action to curb the blatant xenophobia.

Since you haven't, your viewpoint is worth no more than that of any poster on this forum.
It is rather childish IMO to defend the Portuguese police without question and to only offer criticism of the British police in return.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 26, 2019, 09:04:01 PM
oikophobia
Xenophobia is fear of the alien; oikophobia is fear of the familiar: "the disposition, in any conflict, to side with 'them' against 'us', and the felt need to denigrate the customs, culture and institutions that are identifiably 'ours.' " British philosopher Roger Scruton
Left-leaning Americans often are driven by conscious and subconscious oikophobia.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: G-Unit on August 26, 2019, 09:07:41 PM
It is rather childish IMO to defend the Portuguese police without question and to only offer criticism of the British police in return.

You obviously don't find it boring and repetitive to keep criticising the Portuguese police. Why shouldn't the UK police be criticised too? Neither country is superior to the other.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 26, 2019, 10:38:30 PM
You obviously don't find it boring and repetitive to keep criticising the Portuguese police. Why shouldn't the UK police be criticised too? Neither country is superior to the other.
No I don’t find it boring and repetitive to keep criticisng the Portuguese police, in much the same way that you don’t find it boring or repetitive to pick holes in every word and deed by the McCanns.  IMO the initial police investigation was very poor. 
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: barrier on August 27, 2019, 06:36:37 AM
No I don’t find it boring and repetitive to keep criticisng the Portuguese police, in much the same way that you don’t find it boring or repetitive to pick holes in every word and deed by the McCanns. IMO the initial police investigation was very poor.


Yet an assistant commissioner to the met in the guise of Mark Rowley gives a ringing endorsement into the investigation of the parents by saying there is no need to reopen that,it was dealt with in the first investigation,go figure.I wonder whose opinion carry's more worth
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: G-Unit on August 27, 2019, 07:20:18 AM
No I don’t find it boring and repetitive to keep criticisng the Portuguese police, in much the same way that you don’t find it boring or repetitive to pick holes in every word and deed by the McCanns.  IMO the initial police investigation was very poor.

Strangely Kate McCann felt a need to criticise the Portuguese police from the very beginning too.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 27, 2019, 07:50:57 AM
Strangely Kate McCann felt a need to criticise the Portuguese police from the very beginning too.
And if anyone is entitled to do so it’s her.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 27, 2019, 07:55:00 AM

Yet an assistant commissioner to the met in the guise of Mark Rowley gives a ringing endorsement into the investigation of the parents by saying there is no need to reopen that,it was dealt with in the first investigation,go figure.I wonder whose opinion carry's more worth
Of course he had to keep the Portuguese on side, it wouldn’t have done to criticise on them whllst relying in them to be cooperative in the current investigation.  It’s called diplomacy.  In any case I think that is a veiled criticism.  The PJ focused all their efforts on trying to pin it on the parents, found nothng and therefore let the real perpetrator (s) off the hook for years.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: G-Unit on August 27, 2019, 08:33:46 AM
Of course he had to keep the Portuguese on side, it wouldn’t have done to criticise on them whllst relying in them to be cooperative in the current investigation.  It’s called diplomacy.  In any case I think that is a veiled criticism.  The PJ focused all their efforts on trying to pin it on the parents, found nothng and therefore let the real perpetrator (s) off the hook for years.

I think Rowley was deadly serious. OG began with the assumption that the parents had been cleared of involvement by the Portuguese. That's called a mistake.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 27, 2019, 08:49:41 AM
I think Rowley was deadly serious. OG began with the assumption that the parents had been cleared of involvement by the Portuguese. That's called a mistake.
I think it’s you making assumptions here.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: G-Unit on August 27, 2019, 09:03:18 AM
I think it’s you making assumptions here.

According to Rowley the Portuguese had 'dealt with' parental involvement and there was no need to revisit the possibility. If he was simply being diplomatic then surely OG did need to revisit it, but they didn't. In other words they didn't do a full investigation.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Angelo222 on August 27, 2019, 09:13:16 AM
According to Rowley the Portuguese had 'dealt with' parental involvement and there was no need to revisit the possibility. If he was simply being diplomatic then surely OG did need to revisit it, but they didn't. In other words they didn't do a full investigation.

Hasn't he already admitted very publicly that the Maddie brief was very restricted in that SY were not allowed to pursue every investigative opportunity?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: jassi on August 27, 2019, 09:20:20 AM
I thought that was Sutton, but maybe Rowley said that as well.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 27, 2019, 09:26:53 AM
According to Rowley the Portuguese had 'dealt with' parental involvement and there was no need to revisit the possibility. If he was simply being diplomatic then surely OG did need to revisit it, but they didn't. In other words they didn't do a full investigation.
So is it likely in your view that the PJ did not thoroughly investigate the McCanns at the time and then failed to do so again when the investigation was re-opened, yet we mustn’t criticise the PJ?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Eleanor on August 27, 2019, 09:35:49 AM
According to Rowley the Portuguese had 'dealt with' parental involvement and there was no need to revisit the possibility. If he was simply being diplomatic then surely OG did need to revisit it, but they didn't. In other words they didn't do a full investigation.

The PJ did their utmost to pin this on The McCanns.  No one could have done better on that score.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 27, 2019, 09:36:52 AM
Hasn't he already admitted very publicly that the Maddie brief was very restricted in that SY were not allowed to pursue every investigative opportunity?
No he most certainly has not!
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: G-Unit on August 27, 2019, 10:27:04 AM
So is it likely in your view that the PJ did not thoroughly investigate the McCanns at the time and then failed to do so again when the investigation was re-opened, yet we mustn’t criticise the PJ?

I have never said the PJ thoroughly investigated the McCanns or that we mustn't criticise the PJ.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 27, 2019, 11:09:34 AM
I have never said the PJ thoroughly investigated the McCanns or that we mustn't criticise the PJ.
So what areas of their lives and actions in PdL that holiday did they neglect to investigate in your view?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Brietta on August 27, 2019, 11:55:30 PM
I have never said the PJ thoroughly investigated the McCanns or that we mustn't criticise the PJ.

I think you are stifling debate with disclaimers in your posts this one being an example.  I find the apparent need you feel to adopt this tactic of negativity very boring if not rather odd but certainly designed to stifle discussion.

There is a logic to the thread which questions Amaral's assertion of Madeleine's death which even he recognised in his unhinged theories written about in his book and interviews.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 28, 2019, 01:01:32 AM
I have never said the PJ thoroughly investigated the McCanns or that we mustn't criticise the PJ.
In your opinion did "the PJ thoroughly investigate the McCanns"?
In your opinion is it acceptable to "criticise the PJ"?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: ShiningInLuz on August 28, 2019, 01:25:20 AM
In your opinion did "the PJ thoroughly investigate the McCanns"?
In your opinion is it acceptable to "criticise the PJ"?

Were the PJ wise to allow Gerry to sit in on Kate's interview on 4 May 2007?

Were the PJ wise to not re-interview Kate on 10 May?

 *%87
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: G-Unit on August 28, 2019, 06:49:53 AM
I think you are stifling debate with disclaimers in your posts this one being an example.  I find the apparent need you feel to adopt this tactic of negativity very boring if not rather odd but certainly designed to stifle discussion.

There is a logic to the thread which questions Amaral's assertion of Madeleine's death which even he recognised in his unhinged theories written about in his book and interviews.

I will clarify what I have said every time someone suggests I said something I didn't say. Despite the endless criticisms of the PJ here Rowley was clear; OG didn't revisit what the PJ had done. Therefore OG must have been satisfied with their work.

Did the PJ fully investigate the McCanns? If so, they did it without any help from the UK, where the couple lived and worked imo.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 28, 2019, 07:36:29 AM
I will clarify what I have said every time someone suggests I said something I didn't say. Despite the endless criticisms of the PJ here Rowley was clear; OG didn't revisit what the PJ had done. Therefore OG must have been satisfied with their work.

Did the PJ fully investigate the McCanns? If so, they did it without any help from the UK, where the couple lived and worked imo.
To say that OG didn’t revisit what the PJ had done is absolutely ridiculous IMO.  What was the invesigative review reviewing, in your opinion?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: slartibartfast on August 28, 2019, 07:43:53 AM
To say that OG didn’t revisit what the PJ had done is absolutely ridiculous IMO.  What was the invesigative review reviewing, in your opinion?

So your opinion trumps what the police said?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 28, 2019, 07:47:38 AM
So your opinion trumps what the police said?
No, my opinion trumps what G-Unit said.  What was the investigative review reviewing Slarti?  Please give me a logical answer that isn’t another question, much obliged.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Mr Gray on August 28, 2019, 08:02:25 AM
I will clarify what I have said every time someone suggests I said something I didn't say. Despite the endless criticisms of the PJ here Rowley was clear; OG didn't revisit what the PJ had done. Therefore OG must have been satisfied with their work.

Did the PJ fully investigate the McCanns? If so, they did it without any help from the UK, where the couple lived and worked imo.

You need to look at what Rowley said..... He said that the parents involvement was dealt with at the time ...and they looked at all the material.  So they did revisit what the PJ had done...

It really us pathetic going over the same thing time after time and trying to make it mean something else
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: G-Unit on August 28, 2019, 08:55:47 AM
You need to look at what Rowley said..... He said that the parents involvement was death with at the time ...and they looked at all the material.  So they did revisit what the PJ had done...

It really us pathetic going over the same thing time after time and trying to make it mean something else

They 'forensically' examined the timeline then swallowed it hook, line and sinker.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Mr Gray on August 28, 2019, 09:05:18 AM
They 'forensically' examined the timeline then swallowed it hook, line and sinker.

In your opinion ...please try to remember that
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 28, 2019, 09:56:28 AM
They 'forensically' examined the timeline then swallowed it hook, line and sinker.
Whereas you've "forensically" examined the timeline and decided the parents dunnit (though you will never admit to it).  Who's best place to make that judgement call?  I guess that's you, isn't it?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: G-Unit on August 28, 2019, 10:01:51 AM
In your opinion ...please try to remember that

I can't imagine how else Commander Foy could conclude that the McCanns were where they said they were. Not one independant witness confirmed that.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Mr Gray on August 28, 2019, 10:06:16 AM
I can't imagine how else Commander Foy could conclude that the McCanns were where they said they were. Not one independant witness confirmed that.

So it's your opinion as I said
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: G-Unit on August 28, 2019, 10:59:04 AM
So it's your opinion as I said

They had the same evidence that I have, taken from the PJ files. They accepted a timeline which was provided by those who are statistically the most likely perps. They ignored evidence which cast doubt on the reliability of that timeline. They used it as an alibi for the parents (Foy) and as the basis of a new theory of when an abductor may have pounced (Redwood). All based on something impossible to verify. Had the PJ done that they would quite rightly have been heavily criticised imo.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Mr Gray on August 28, 2019, 11:20:27 AM
They had the same evidence that I have, taken from the PJ files. They accepted a timeline which was provided by those who are statistically the most likely perps. They ignored evidence which cast doubt on the reliability of that timeline. They used it as an alibi for the parents (Foy) and as the basis of a new theory of when an abductor may have pounced (Redwood). All based on something impossible to verify. Had the PJ done that they would quite rightly have been heavily criticised imo.

The McCann's are not statistically the likeliest perps imo

There is no real evidence that casts doubt on the timeline.. Imo..
You are just giving your opinion which in the, real world us if little or no value. 
What it appears to me is that both police police forces do not consider the parents to be involved
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 28, 2019, 11:24:19 AM
They had the same evidence that I have, taken from the PJ files. They accepted a timeline which was provided by those who are statistically the most likely perps. They ignored evidence which cast doubt on the reliability of that timeline. They used it as an alibi for the parents (Foy) and as the basis of a new theory of when an abductor may have pounced (Redwood). All based on something impossible to verify. Had the PJ done that they would quite rightly have been heavily criticised imo.
Statistics have nothing to do with it, but if they did what do the statistics have to say about 7 individuals all conspiring to cover up the accidental death of a friend’s child?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Mr Gray on August 28, 2019, 11:28:57 AM
They had the same evidence that I have, taken from the PJ files. They accepted a timeline which was provided by those who are statistically the most likely perps. They ignored evidence which cast doubt on the reliability of that timeline. They used it as an alibi for the parents (Foy) and as the basis of a new theory of when an abductor may have pounced (Redwood). All based on something impossible to verify. Had the PJ done that they would quite rightly have been heavily criticised imo.

Could you supply sone reasoning for the parents being the most likely perps
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: G-Unit on August 28, 2019, 11:49:20 AM
Could you supply sone reasoning for the parents being the most likely perps

Jim Gamble;

"statistically it’s likely to be the parents or somebody who’s in close proximity with the child."
https://www.thescottishsun.co.uk/news/4055161/madeleine-mccann-dad-gerry-investigator-messages-disappearance-netflix/

Perhaps in return you can explain whether you think the timeline can be relied on?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 28, 2019, 11:51:01 AM
Jim Gamble;

"statistically it’s likely to be the parents or somebody who’s in close proximity with the child."
https://www.thescottishsun.co.uk/news/4055161/madeleine-mccann-dad-gerry-investigator-messages-disappearance-netflix/

Perhaps in return you can explain whether you think the timeline can be relied on?
Why has he dismissed the statistics as irrelevant in your view?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: G-Unit on August 28, 2019, 12:23:29 PM
Why has he dismissed the statistics as irrelevant in your view?

He hasn't explained that afaik.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 28, 2019, 12:27:07 PM
He hasn't explained that afaik.
Don’t you agree he must have a good reason, or do you think he’s a brainwashed sheeple in the pay of the McCanns?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: G-Unit on August 28, 2019, 12:58:49 PM
Don’t you agree he must have a good reason, or do you think he’s a brainwashed sheeple in the pay of the McCanns?

It seems he was still harbouring suspicions in August 2007, when he claims he encouraged Gerry to write that strange blog entry on 28th of that month. I always thought Gerry was aiming that at someone he suspected, but it was aimed at Gerry by Gamble. 
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 28, 2019, 01:09:13 PM
It seems he was still harbouring suspicions in August 2007, when he claims he encouraged Gerry to write that strange blog entry on 28th of that month. I always thought Gerry was aiming that at someone he suspected, but it was aimed at Gerry by Gamble.
August 2007 is an awful long time ago and he has definitely changed his mind since.  Why?  Is it because he is stupid or covering up in your view?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: G-Unit on August 28, 2019, 01:32:32 PM
August 2007 is an awful long time ago and he has definitely changed his mind since.  Why?  Is it because he is stupid or covering up in your view?

Harbouring suspicion from May to August was a long time.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 28, 2019, 01:38:41 PM
Harbouring suspicion from May to August was a long time.
All the more reason to feel fairly confident he has very good reasons for not harbouring suspicions now, IMO, unless you believe he had a sudden and very prolonged attack of stupid, or got bribed to change his mind.  Do you?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 28, 2019, 06:26:30 PM
It seems he was still harbouring suspicions in August 2007, when he claims he encouraged Gerry to write that strange blog entry on 28th of that month. I always thought Gerry was aiming that at someone he suspected, but it was aimed at Gerry by Gamble.
Could you quote the words you are referring to please?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: G-Unit on August 28, 2019, 07:10:25 PM
Could you quote the words you are referring to please?

Day 117, 28/08/2007

https://www.gerrymccannsblogs.co.uk/DAYS_101_to_200.htm
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Mr Gray on August 28, 2019, 07:14:12 PM
Day 117, 28/08/2007

https://www.gerrymccannsblogs.co.uk/DAYS_101_to_200.htm

I didn't realise you had so much belief in Gambles opinion
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 28, 2019, 07:22:14 PM
I didn't realise you had so much belief in Gambles opinion
But only up to August 2007, after that it seems he's not to be trusted.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Mr Gray on August 28, 2019, 07:38:46 PM
But only up to August 2007, after that it seems he's not to be trusted.

LOL
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: G-Unit on August 28, 2019, 07:53:37 PM
I didn't realise you had so much belief in Gambles opinion

Don't worry, I don't. I was merely pointing out that he wasn't at all sure about Gerry McCann for quite a while.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 28, 2019, 07:56:28 PM
Don't worry, I don't. I was merely pointing out that he wasn't at all sure about Gerry McCann for quite a while.
But he changed his mind.  Unlike some people he didn’t make up his mind straight away and stick with it for 12 years. 
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: ShiningInLuz on August 28, 2019, 08:00:49 PM
But he changed his mind.  Unlike some people he didn’t make up his mind straight away and stick with it for 12 years.

Who are these 'some people'?  Unless you identify these 'some people' your comment is between meaningless to propaganda.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 28, 2019, 08:02:26 PM
Who are these 'some people'?  Unless you identify these 'some people' your comment is between meaningless to propaganda.
Stop stalking me.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: G-Unit on August 28, 2019, 08:21:24 PM
But he changed his mind.  Unlike some people he didn’t make up his mind straight away and stick with it for 12 years.

Like you, you mean?

Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Mr Gray on August 28, 2019, 08:31:43 PM
Who are these 'some people'?  Unless you identify these 'some people' your comment is between meaningless to propaganda.

Are you under the misapprehension that some posts here, are meaningful... I find that quite funny
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Mr Gray on August 28, 2019, 08:36:41 PM
Who are these 'some people'?  Unless you identify these 'some people' your comment is between meaningless to propaganda.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Mr Gray on August 28, 2019, 08:42:07 PM
Don't worry, I don't. I was merely pointing out that he wasn't at all sure about Gerry McCann for quite a while.

You dont need to point anything out to me...afaiac .. I'm way ahead of you.  Jim Gamble considered all possibilities ..and eventually realised the parents were not involved
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: ShiningInLuz on August 28, 2019, 08:52:16 PM
Stop stalking me.

As you are posting 6 times faster than I am, I would need to get a buddy or 5 to help.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: G-Unit on August 28, 2019, 09:01:58 PM
You dont need to point anything out to me...afaiac .. I'm way ahead of you.  Jim Gamble considered all possibilities ..and eventually realised the parents were not involved

He told you that, did he?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: ShiningInLuz on August 28, 2019, 09:08:50 PM
Are you under the misapprehension that some posts here, are meaningful... I find that quite funny

I am under no doubt that there are posts on here that are both meaningful and informative.

Unfortunately, they get drowned by posters who insist that their posts are drivel but who also insist on posting vast quantities of the same.

I find that very disingenuous.

 &^^&*
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Mr Gray on August 28, 2019, 09:20:46 PM
I am under no doubt that there are posts on here that are both meaningful and informative.

Unfortunately, they get drowned by posters who insist that their posts are drivel but who also insist on posting vast quantities of the same.

I find that very disingenuous.

 &^^&*
All your opinion.. The fact that you have no doubt is meaningless imo... It's totally laughable afaiac
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 28, 2019, 09:35:36 PM
Like you, you mean?
No, not like me at all.  I have changed my mind three times about this case.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Miss Taken Identity on August 29, 2019, 11:15:01 AM
It seems he was still harbouring suspicions in August 2007, when he claims he encouraged Gerry to write that strange blog entry on 28th of that month. I always thought Gerry was aiming that at someone he suspected, but it was aimed at Gerry by Gamble.


Yes, I wondered about that when I read it. lol. I thought it was a 'subliminal confession' ?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 29, 2019, 12:22:36 PM

Yes, I wondered about that when I read it. lol. I thought it was a 'subliminal confession' ?
It is strange but I don't get it.
"We, like everyone else, await the results of the forensics from the recent searches. We do not know who has taken Madeleine or why. Sometimes people do things for reasons that even they cannot understand. An act of madness, an accident or sudden impulse can lead to consequences that people may never have imagined or intended. Faced with such a situation we believe any human soul will ultimately suffer torment and feelings of guilt and fear.

If you have done something you regret, if you find yourself in a situation you never intended, it is not too late to do the right thing. Please come forward, return Madeleine, leave her in a place of safety. At the very least, help us by letting us know what has happened to our beautiful little girl." https://www.gerrymccannsblogs.co.uk/DAYS_101_to_200.htm#d117
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: G-Unit on August 29, 2019, 01:03:00 PM

Yes, I wondered about that when I read it. lol. I thought it was a 'subliminal confession' ?

Just Gamble muddying the waters, it seems.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Miss Taken Identity on August 29, 2019, 09:33:36 PM
It is strange but I don't get it.
"We, like everyone else, await the results of the forensics from the recent searches. We do not know who has taken Madeleine or why. Sometimes people do things for reasons that even they cannot understand. An act of madness, an accident or sudden impulse can lead to consequences that people may never have imagined or intended. Faced with such a situation we believe any human soul will ultimately suffer torment and feelings of guilt and fear.

If you have done something you regret, if you find yourself in a situation you never intended, it is not too late to do the right thing. Please come forward, return Madeleine, leave her in a place of safety. At the very least, help us by letting us know what has happened to our beautiful little girl." https://www.gerrymccannsblogs.co.uk/DAYS_101_to_200.htm#d117

"we believe any human soul will ultimately suffer torment and feelings of guilt and fear. "
Ofcourse, that would not apply to psychopaths/Narcissists.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: G-Unit on August 30, 2019, 04:14:53 PM
"we believe any human soul will ultimately suffer torment and feelings of guilt and fear. "
Ofcourse, that would not apply to psychopaths/Narcissists.

Or even to a pragmatist, which Gerry McCann clearly was.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Mr Gray on August 30, 2019, 04:21:20 PM
Or even to a pragmatist, which Gerry McCann clearly was.

In your opinion
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 30, 2019, 05:48:47 PM
In your opinion

That he was willing for the alleged abductor to damage his daughter’s eye as a result of using it as a ‘marketing ploy’ illustrates his pragmatism perfectly.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Eleanor on August 30, 2019, 05:50:30 PM
That he was willing for the alleged abductor to damage his daughter’s eye as a result of using it as a ‘marketing ploy’ illustrates his pragmatism perfectly.

This is absolute nonsense.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Erngath on August 30, 2019, 05:55:55 PM
This is absolute nonsense.

Your restraint is admirable.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: G-Unit on August 30, 2019, 07:18:52 PM
In your opinion

In Fiona Payne's opinion;

that's why he's good at his job, you know, he's, he's a very pragmatic person, in an emergency he's the person you'd want to call on because he thinks straight and he thinks clearly, whereas not all of us do'.
https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/FIONA-PAYNE-ROGATORY.htm
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Mr Gray on August 30, 2019, 07:24:54 PM
In Fiona Payne's opinion;

that's why he's good at his job, you know, he's, he's a very pragmatic person, in an emergency he's the person you'd want to call on because he thinks straight and he thinks clearly, whereas not all of us do'.
https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/FIONA-PAYNE-ROGATORY.htm

then you should make it clear whos opinion you are stating rather than state something as a fact
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 30, 2019, 07:26:35 PM
This is absolute nonsense.

What part ?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 30, 2019, 07:27:31 PM
Your restraint is admirable.

I don’t think it’s good form to shoot the messenger.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Eleanor on August 30, 2019, 07:43:30 PM
What part ?

Sorry.  I don't think there is any point in me trying to explain.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Erngath on August 30, 2019, 07:52:13 PM
I don’t think it’s good form to shoot the messenger.

I'm sure this post has some relevance.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 30, 2019, 08:52:17 PM
Or even to a pragmatist, which Gerry McCann clearly was.
Are you suggesting that someone who is pragmatic does not suffer torment or feelings of guilt and fear??  What bilge.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 30, 2019, 09:10:28 PM
I'm sure this post has some relevance.

There is, and it’s this, I didn’t say this

“Gerry understood that. But, he says, the iris “is Madeleine’s only true distinctive feature. Certainly we thought it was possible that this could potentially hurt her or”—he grimaces—“her abductor might do something to her eye.… But in terms of marketing, it was a good ploy.”

Gerry did. I’m only the messenger.

Now can you show me any better example of pragmatism than that ?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 30, 2019, 09:11:11 PM
Sorry.  I don't think there is any point in me trying to explain.

Oh do try.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Erngath on August 30, 2019, 09:16:16 PM
There is, and it’s this, I didn’t say this

“Gerry understood that. But, he says, the iris “is Madeleine’s only true distinctive feature. Certainly we thought it was possible that this could potentially hurt her or”—he grimaces—“her abductor might do something to her eye.… But in terms of marketing, it was a good ploy.”

Gerry did. I’m only the messenger.

Now can you show me any better example of pragmatism than that ?

He has only ever appeared to me as a father desperate to find his missing child.

Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Eleanor on August 30, 2019, 09:18:40 PM
Oh do try.

I don't think you meant to be as unkind as your comment suggested.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 30, 2019, 09:19:08 PM
I don't think you meant to be as unkind as your comment suggested.
I really wouldn’t be sure about that.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Eleanor on August 30, 2019, 09:21:47 PM
I really wouldn’t be sure about that.

Tis just my opinion.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 30, 2019, 09:23:10 PM
Tis just my opinion.
If I posted my opinion my warning level would probably go up to 40%
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 30, 2019, 09:28:36 PM
I don't think you meant to be as unkind as your comment suggested.

What is unkind about saying Gerry is a pragmatist and illustrating my opinion ?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 30, 2019, 09:33:49 PM
There is, and it’s this, I didn’t say this

“Gerry understood that. But, he says, the iris “is Madeleine’s only true distinctive feature. Certainly we thought it was possible that this could potentially hurt her or”—he grimaces—“her abductor might do something to her eye.… But in terms of marketing, it was a good ploy.”

Gerry did. I’m only the messenger.

Now can you show me any better example of pragmatism than that ?
Where did that quote come from?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Eleanor on August 30, 2019, 09:34:11 PM
What is unkind about saying Gerry is a pragmatist and illustrating my opinion ?

It wasn't the Pragmatism that was the problem.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 30, 2019, 09:38:15 PM
It wasn't the Pragmatism that was the problem.

So what was ?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Erngath on August 30, 2019, 09:39:20 PM
If I posted my opinion my warning level would probably go up to 40%

Mine would be way beyond that!
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 30, 2019, 09:41:13 PM
Where did that quote come from?
I see this article explains some of that.  http://madeleinemythsexposed.pbworks.com/w/page/39078141/Rebuttal%20of%20%22Fact%22%2035

Also discussed on this forum years back http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=7041.0
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Eleanor on August 30, 2019, 09:43:29 PM
So what was ?

I often say that it's what you don't say that matters.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Brietta on August 30, 2019, 09:45:22 PM
Where did that quote come from?
The quote is from MMRG and is inaccurate like many statements from that source..

Summary of Verifiable Facts
http://madeleinemythsexposed.pbworks.com/w/page/39078141/Rebuttal%20of%20%22Fact%22%2035
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Brietta on August 30, 2019, 09:47:29 PM
I see this article explains some of that.  http://madeleinemythsexposed.pbworks.com/w/page/39078141/Rebuttal%20of%20%22Fact%22%2035
You beat me to it Rob.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 30, 2019, 09:49:26 PM
The quote is from MMRG and is inaccurate like many statements from that source..

Summary of Verifiable Facts
  • The quote originates from an interview with Vanity Fair Magazine dated 10th January 2008, NOT an unnamed source dated 15th July 2009.
  • The quote is inaccurate and incomplete and gives a different impression from the actual interview.
  • The Portuguese Judiciary themselves released the details of Madeleine's distinctive mark on her eye in a press release dated 5th May, 2007.
  • Withholding information about such a distinctive feature is completely at odds with the advice given by the National Center for Missing and Exploited Children.
http://madeleinemythsexposed.pbworks.com/w/page/39078141/Rebuttal%20of%20%22Fact%22%2035

MMRG = (Madeleine McCann Research Group)
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 30, 2019, 09:51:31 PM
I often say that it's what you don't say that matters.

Eh ?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 30, 2019, 09:53:36 PM
The quote is from MMRG and is inaccurate like many statements from that source..

Summary of Verifiable Facts
  • The quote originates from an interview with Vanity Fair Magazine dated 10th January 2008, NOT an unnamed source dated 15th July 2009.
  • The quote is inaccurate and incomplete and gives a different impression from the actual interview.
  • The Portuguese Judiciary themselves released the details of Madeleine's distinctive mark on her eye in a press release dated 5th May, 2007.
  • Withholding information about such a distinctive feature is completely at odds with the advice given by the National Center for Missing and Exploited Children.
http://madeleinemythsexposed.pbworks.com/w/page/39078141/Rebuttal%20of%20%22Fact%22%2035

My quote comes directly from the Vanity Fair article.

https://www.vanityfair.com/news/2008/02/mccanns200802

“Gerry understood that. But, he says, the iris “is Madeleine’s only true distinctive feature. Certainly we thought it was possible that this could potentially hurt her or”—he grimaces—“her abductor might do something to her eye.… But in terms of marketing, it was a good ploy.”



Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Eleanor on August 30, 2019, 09:54:30 PM
Eh ?

I am using the word "You" collectively.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 30, 2019, 09:57:11 PM
I am using the word "You" collectively.

That aside you have still failed to illustrate why my post was unkind and not merely factual.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Eleanor on August 30, 2019, 10:00:47 PM
That aside you have still failed to illustrate why my post was unkind and not merely factual.

I don't have to.

I didn't Delete it, so what is the problem?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 30, 2019, 10:06:12 PM
I don't have to.

I didn't Delete it, so what is the problem?

Of course you don’t have to but it would be mannerly. You said my post was unkind yet don’t seem to be able to say why.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Eleanor on August 30, 2019, 10:13:24 PM
Of course you don’t have to but it would be mannerly. You said my post was unkind yet don’t seem to be able to say why.

That is not what I said.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 30, 2019, 10:16:23 PM
That is not what I said.

This is what you said

‘I don't think you meant to be as unkind as your comment suggested.’

So what was unkind and not merely factually correct ?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 30, 2019, 10:17:34 PM
Eleanor, Faithlilly appears to be stalking you now. I’m concerned on your behalf.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Eleanor on August 30, 2019, 10:24:10 PM
Eleanor, Faithlilly appears to be stalking you now. I’m concerned on your behalf.

Thanks for your concern.  I think you might be right.  But it's not exactly scary, is it.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 30, 2019, 10:35:28 PM
Thanks for your concern.  I think you might be right.  But it's not exactly scary, is it.

You say I’ve been unkind. It’s not unreasonable for me to ask why. That is not stalking.

It was obviously an off the cuff remark that with further thought you wouldn’t have made.

Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 30, 2019, 10:38:34 PM
deleted

He knew the risks that publicising his daughter’s eye defect would open her to but was willing to take that risk.

That’s what I find reprehensible. We obviously have different values.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Eleanor on August 30, 2019, 10:40:43 PM
He knew the risks that publicising his daughter’s eye defect would open her to but was willing to take that risk.

That’s what I find reprehensible. We obviously have different values.

You forget.  The PJ published a description of Madeleine's eye defect before anyone else did.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 30, 2019, 10:45:13 PM
You forget.  The PJ published a description of Madeleine's eye defect before anyone else did.

Gerry accepted responsibility for publicising it widely. Who are we to argue ?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 30, 2019, 10:45:17 PM
He knew the risks that publicising his daughter’s eye defect would open her to but was willing to take that risk.

That’s what I find reprehensible. We obviously have different values.
Willing?  Willing?  What is the willingness of which you speak?  How about reluctantly prepared to?  How about “agonized over the decision and decided it was better to get Madeleine back alive with or without injury than to never get her back at all”.  The irony is, you believe Gerry knew her little body was languishing under 10 tonnes of stinky Portuguese rubbish by then, so what you are really saying is you believe Gerry to be a supremely evil, cynical b.........  How kind.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Erngath on August 30, 2019, 10:56:29 PM
Willing?  Willing?  What is the willingness of which you speak?  How about reluctantly prepared to?  How about “agonized over the decision and decided it was better to get Madeleine back alive with or without injury than to never get her back at all”.  The irony is, you believe Gerry knew her little body was languishing under 10 tonnes of stinky Portuguese rubbish by then, so what you are really saying is you believe Gerry to be a supremely evil, cynical b.........  How kind.

And ever so " pragmatic"
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Brietta on August 30, 2019, 10:57:18 PM
He knew the risks that publicising his daughter’s eye defect would open her to but was willing to take that risk.

That’s what I find reprehensible. We obviously have different values.

From the PJ

To: The Assistant Prosecutor
Public Ministry


Date: 04-05-2007



Subject: Request for Divulgation by means of the Press


As it is of clear interest to the investigation of the case in reference, I have the honour to ask you to authorise the divulgation of the disappearance of the young girl Madeleine McCann by means of the organs of the press, with the aim of obtaining information leading to her whereabouts.

I enclose a model for divulgation.

With best compliments

The Coordinator of the Investigation.

G. Amaral


Page 33 is a confirmation of this fax.

https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/MADELINE.htm


01 Processos Vol I Page 33 B

Press Release

Disappearance of Minor


The Policia Judiciaria requests information about the whereabouts of Madeleine Beth McCann, born on 12-05-2003 (three years old) with the following physical characteristics: 90 cm in height, light chestnut/blond hair, blue/green left eye and a green right eye with a brown mark in the pupil.

She disappeared from Praia da Luz, Lagos on 03-05-2007 wearing pyjamas with white coloured bottoms with a floral design and a blue and grey figure on the front with the inscription 'EEYORE'.

Any information should be directed to the Head of the Faro PJ telephone number 289 884 500 or to the Portimao DIC tel 282 405 400.

05 May 2007


Goncalo Amaral requested the issue of a press release to publicise Madeleine's disappearance ... permission was granted ... Madeleine's description included the mark in her eye.

Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Erngath on August 30, 2019, 10:58:31 PM
Willing?  Willing?  What is the willingness of which you speak?  How about reluctantly prepared to?  How about “agonized over the decision and decided it was better to get Madeleine back alive with or without injury than to never get her back at all”.  The irony is, you believe Gerry knew her little body was languishing under 10 tonnes of stinky Portuguese rubbish by then, so what you are really saying is you believe Gerry to be a supremely evil, cynical b.........  How kind.

Such is the willingness of some to believe.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 30, 2019, 11:00:01 PM
Such is the willingness of some to believe.
Steer clear of ad hom arguments please.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 30, 2019, 11:00:22 PM
From the PJ

To: The Assistant Prosecutor
Public Ministry


Date: 04-05-2007



Subject: Request for Divulgation by means of the Press


As it is of clear interest to the investigation of the case in reference, I have the honour to ask you to authorise the divulgation of the disappearance of the young girl Madeleine McCann by means of the organs of the press, with the aim of obtaining information leading to her whereabouts.

I enclose a model for divulgation.

With best compliments

The Coordinator of the Investigation.

G. Amaral


Page 33 is a confirmation of this fax.

https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/MADELINE.htm


01 Processos Vol I Page 33 B

Press Release

Disappearance of Minor


The Policia Judiciaria requests information about the whereabouts of Madeleine Beth McCann, born on 12-05-2003 (three years old) with the following physical characteristics: 90 cm in height, light chestnut/blond hair, blue/green left eye and a green right eye with a brown mark in the pupil.

She disappeared from Praia da Luz, Lagos on 03-05-2007 wearing pyjamas with white coloured bottoms with a floral design and a blue and grey figure on the front with the inscription 'EEYORE'.

Any information should be directed to the Head of the Faro PJ telephone number 289 884 500 or to the Portimao DIC tel 282 405 400.

05 May 2007


Goncalo Amaral requested the issue of a press release to publicise Madeleine's disappearance ... permission was granted ... Madeleine's description included the mark in her eye.

And ?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: John on August 30, 2019, 11:03:22 PM
Could we cease the silliness please and get back to sensible debate. Cheers!
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Erngath on August 30, 2019, 11:07:35 PM
Steer clear of ad hom arguments please.

I will try not to but it is very difficult to see which posts deserved points.
Some seem in my opinion to be deserved of warning points and some do not.
Have I made an ad hom argument?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 30, 2019, 11:12:38 PM
I will try not to but it is very difficult to see which posts deserved points.
Some seem in my opinion to be deserved of warning points and some do not.
Have I made an ad hom argument?
IMO if you "like" a post that is clearly an ad hom, I would like a way of giving the approving person warning points too.
Are you questioning me as to whether "Such is the willingness of some to believe", is an ad hom or not?

Well you are clearly picking fault in someone, and not their argument aren't you?   That to me is what an ad hom is "picking fault in someone, and not their argument".
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Erngath on August 30, 2019, 11:14:55 PM
IMO if you "like" a post that is clearly an ad hom, I would like a way of giving the approving person warning points too.
Are you questioning me as to whether "Such is the willingness of some to believe", is an ad hom or not?

Well you are clearly picking fault in someone, and not their argument aren't you?   That to me is what an ad hom is "picking fault in someone, and not their argument".

I suggest you take a look at previous posts today and you may find one a little more worthy of your scrutiny!
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 30, 2019, 11:18:48 PM
I suggest you take a look at previous posts today and you may find one a little more worthy of your scrutiny!
If I had to do that a moderators job would be endless.  I start off reading whats "New".  You could well be right but then where would the task end?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Erngath on August 30, 2019, 11:26:34 PM
If I had to do that a moderators job would be endless.  I start off reading whats "New".  You could well be right but then where would the task end?

Perhaps that's the inherent weakness of the moderation.
There was a post today which included insults, goading and ad homs directed at supporters which has not been deleted, not modified, nor the poster given warning points.
Perhaps you should  read back and see what has been allowed to be posted before you begin to moderate.

ETA.
Just checked to be sure and yes the poster who posted unwarranted jibes and goading  has nil points but VS has ten.
There has to be consistenty.
I appreciate it may be a difficult task but it can at times be unfair!
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 31, 2019, 06:02:22 AM
Perhaps that's the inherent weakness of the moderation.
There was a post today which included insults, goading and ad homs directed at supporters which has not been deleted, not modified, nor the poster given warning points.
Perhaps you should  read back and see what has been allowed to be posted before you begin to moderate.

ETA.
Just checked to be sure and yes the poster who posted unwarranted jibes and goading  has nil points but VS has ten.
There has to be consistenty.
I appreciate it may be a difficult task but it can at times be unfair!
You could be absolute right but I'll just continue doing as I do reading "New".  On some threads I'll review the lot but  after a while posts get quoted so many times it becomes difficult to tidy up.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: G-Unit on August 31, 2019, 07:18:06 AM
Are you suggesting that someone who is pragmatic does not suffer torment or feelings of guilt and fear??  What bilge.

Not at all, but they don't waste their energy dwelling on the past. As Gerry said, he regretted not being there to protect his daughter, but he couldn't change that. So he concentrated on doing everything he could think of which might help to find her.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 31, 2019, 07:24:22 AM
Not at all, but they don't waste their energy dwelling on the past. As Gerry said, he regretted not being there to protect his daughter, but he couldn't change that. So he concentrated on doing everything he could think of which might help to find her.
Nice sentiment, which of course you don’t actually believe.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: G-Unit on August 31, 2019, 08:31:05 AM
Nice sentiment, which of course you don’t actually believe.

I'm sure that Gerry McCann is a pragmatist, which is what we were discussing.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Brietta on August 31, 2019, 08:34:16 AM
You could be absolute right but I'll just continue doing as I do reading "New".  On some threads I'll review the lot but  after a while posts get quoted so many times it becomes difficult to tidy up.

I had a bit of time off during the summer and found it necessary to catch up on all the threads which had been started during my absence before restarting to moderate.
Quite a daunting task due to the myriad at that time and of course falling further behind as fresh contributions continued.
Also I find it useful to run a check on reported posts.  That said it is incredibly easy to miss really blatant outrages; perhaps being immured to the frequency, constant repetition and just plain silliness of them or just missing some posts altogether.

I think it is for the editors to take the overall view and do the general tidying up and for we mods to keep it going on a daily basis so that they have less to do.  But basically there should be little complaint if everyone resolved to put us out of a job by sticking to forum protocol.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 31, 2019, 08:42:23 AM
I'm sure that Gerry McCann is a pragmatist, which is what we were discussing.
This is what you wrote:

we believe any human soul will ultimately suffer torment and feelings of guilt and fear. "
Ofcourse, that would not apply to psychopaths/Narcissists.

Or even to a pragmatist, which Gerry McCann clearly was.

Shame on you for suggesting Gerry has no torment, or feelings of guilt or fear and is akin to a psychopath or narcissist.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Brietta on August 31, 2019, 08:44:04 AM
I'm sure that Gerry McCann is a pragmatist, which is what we were discussing.

Actually we should be discussing "if Madeleine is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?" not the pragmatism of her father and mother whose dogged determination and if you must pragmatism, is entirely responsible for the fact that the Judicial Police and Scotland Yard have been assiduously searching for her since 2013 and continue so to do.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 31, 2019, 08:56:53 AM
Actually we should be discussing "if Madeleine is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?" not the pragmatism of her father and mother whose dogged determination and if you must pragmatism, is entirely responsible for the fact that the Judicial Police and Scotland Yard have been assiduously searching for her since 2013 and continue so to do.

No it’s Rebecca Brooks threatening the PM that is responsible for the current investigation.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Mr Gray on August 31, 2019, 08:59:35 AM
No it’s Rebecca Brooks threatening the PM that is responsible for the current investigation.

In your opinion... Or has the necessity for that caveat been abandoned
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: G-Unit on August 31, 2019, 09:04:00 AM
Actually we should be discussing "if Madeleine is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?" not the pragmatism of her father and mother whose dogged determination and if you must pragmatism, is entirely responsible for the fact that the Judicial Police and Scotland Yard have been assiduously searching for her since 2013 and continue so to do.

I don't think Madeleine's mother is a pragmatist at all. Neither do I accept that the Judicial Police are searching for Madeleine, assiduously or otherwise.

There's no guarantee that bodies will be found in any case; that's why the police in the UK keep digging up parts of the UK looking for Susie Lamplugh. We might as well discuss why, if Madeleine is alive, she hasn't been found.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Brietta on August 31, 2019, 09:16:24 AM
No it’s Rebecca Brooks threatening the PM that is responsible for the current investigation.

Thank you for your opinion which is "Off Topic"
All future off topic posts will be deleted.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Brietta on August 31, 2019, 09:20:41 AM
I don't think Madeleine's mother is a pragmatist at all. Neither do I accept that the Judicial Police are searching for Madeleine, assiduously or otherwise.

There's no guarantee that bodies will be found in any case; that's why the police in the UK keep digging up parts of the UK looking for Susie Lamplugh. We might as well discuss why, if Madeleine is alive, she hasn't been found.

That at least would be a continuation of the thread topic and therefore a wee change from the subtle and otherwise vilification of Madeleine's family which is a recurring theme but one which is definitely Off Topic.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 31, 2019, 09:31:07 AM
In your opinion... Or has the necessity for that caveat been abandoned

It’s not opinion. It’s common knowledge that RB ‘facilitated’ the opening of the investigation by threatening the then PM with front page articles regarding Theresa May, who, you will remember, wasn’t greatly keen on the idea of an investigation.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Mr Gray on August 31, 2019, 09:36:30 AM
It’s not opinion. It’s common knowledge that RB ‘facilitated’ the opening of the investigation by threatening the then PM with front page articles regarding Theresa May, who, you will remember, wasn’t greatly keen on the idea of an investigation.
Off topic too... Brookes may have been partly responsible... So your post is opinion not fact
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Eleanor on August 31, 2019, 09:41:12 AM
I'm sure that Gerry McCann is a pragmatist, which is what we were discussing.

Is there something wrong with being a pragmatist?  I can be one as well, when it suits me.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 31, 2019, 09:46:27 AM
Off topic too... Brookes may have been partly responsible... So your post is opinion not fact

2.49pm: Brooks is asked about the serialisation in the Sunday Times and the Sun of a book by Kate McCann, the mother of Madeleine.

Gerry McCann told the inquiry that they were initially "horrified" about the serialisation, but were later convinced after News International pledged to back their campaign if they agreed to the serialisation.

Brooks can't remember how much News International paid for the book serialisation.

"Hundreds of thousands. It wasn't £1m. Half a million maybe?"

She adds: "I had always got on very well with Gerry and Kate McCann. I think if asked they would be very positive about the Sun. In this case I thought Dominic Mohan's idea to run the campaign, this review of Madeleine's case by the home secretary, was the right thing to do … I don't think I spoke to Theresa May directly. Dominic [Mohan] may have done."

12.52pm: Brooks says she did not take the McCann issue up with Downing Street.

Editor Dominic Mohan or Tom Newton-Dunn, the Sun's political editor, will have spoken to No 10 or the Home Office about reopening the Madeleine investigation after the Sun's campaign, she says.

Was there an ultimatum or threat to the home secretary?

"I'm pretty sure there will not have been a threat, but you will have to ask Dominic Mohan," she says.

Jay says he has been told that Brooks intervened personally with the prime minister and said the Sun would put Theresa May on the front page every day until the paper's demands were met.

Brooks says that is not true. "I did not say to the prime minister we would put Theresa May on the front page every day. If I'd had any conversations with No 10 directly they would not have been particularly about that," she adds.

12.55pm: Lord Justice Leveson intervenes. He asks whether Brooks was involved in a strategy to threaten No 10 in order to obtain a review of the Madeleine investigation.

"I was certainly part of a strategy to launch a campaign in order to get a review for the McCanns," Brooks says, disputing that it was a "threat".

Leveson: "Give me another word for it, would you?"

Brooks: "Persuade?"

Leveson appears unconvinced.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 31, 2019, 09:47:36 AM
Is there something wrong with being a pragmatist?  I can be one as well, when it suits me.

We all can. Fortunately our pragmatism doesn’t impact on the welfare of our loved ones.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Eleanor on August 31, 2019, 09:59:01 AM
I had a bit of time off during the summer and found it necessary to catch up on all the threads which had been started during my absence before restarting to moderate.
Quite a daunting task due to the myriad at that time and of course falling further behind as fresh contributions continued.
Also I find it useful to run a check on reported posts.  That said it is incredibly easy to miss really blatant outrages; perhaps being immured to the frequency, constant repetition and just plain silliness of them or just missing some posts altogether.

I think it is for the editors to take the overall view and do the general tidying up and for we mods to keep it going on a daily basis so that they have less to do.  But basically there should be little complaint if everyone resolved to put us out of a job by sticking to forum protocol.

I usually pick up where I left off.  There are tools to help Moderators to do this.  But we can only do our best.  Most Members don't want us here at all.

But as I have said, this is not a Democracy.  Someone has got to be In Charge at some level. 

John always has the last word and does sometimes countermand what Moderators do.  There isn't a much more fair way to run what is effectively a Dictatorship.

And this is still the only McCann Forum where everyone has the right to express their views within reason.

Ideally Moderators probably shouldn't express opinions, but who would put up with the interminable boredom of that?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Brietta on August 31, 2019, 10:01:19 AM
2.49pm: Brooks is asked about the serialisation in the Sunday Times and the Sun of a book by Kate McCann, the mother of Madeleine.

Gerry McCann told the inquiry that they were initially "horrified" about the serialisation, but were later convinced after News International pledged to back their campaign if they agreed to the serialisation.

Brooks can't remember how much News International paid for the book serialisation.

"Hundreds of thousands. It wasn't £1m. Half a million maybe?"

She adds: "I had always got on very well with Gerry and Kate McCann. I think if asked they would be very positive about the Sun. In this case I thought Dominic Mohan's idea to run the campaign, this review of Madeleine's case by the home secretary, was the right thing to do … I don't think I spoke to Theresa May directly. Dominic [Mohan] may have done."

12.52pm: Brooks says she did not take the McCann issue up with Downing Street.

Editor Dominic Mohan or Tom Newton-Dunn, the Sun's political editor, will have spoken to No 10 or the Home Office about reopening the Madeleine investigation after the Sun's campaign, she says.

Was there an ultimatum or threat to the home secretary?

"I'm pretty sure there will not have been a threat, but you will have to ask Dominic Mohan," she says.

Jay says he has been told that Brooks intervened personally with the prime minister and said the Sun would put Theresa May on the front page every day until the paper's demands were met.

Brooks says that is not true. "I did not say to the prime minister we would put Theresa May on the front page every day. If I'd had any conversations with No 10 directly they would not have been particularly about that," she adds.

12.55pm: Lord Justice Leveson intervenes. He asks whether Brooks was involved in a strategy to threaten No 10 in order to obtain a review of the Madeleine investigation.

"I was certainly part of a strategy to launch a campaign in order to get a review for the McCanns," Brooks says, disputing that it was a "threat".

Leveson: "Give me another word for it, would you?"

Brooks: "Persuade?"

Leveson appears unconvinced.

Is there something about "OFF TOPIC" which is beyond your understanding?  Please open a new thread if you wish to discuss Rebecca Brooks.  This one is clear that the topic is ..."If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?"
I will be deleting this post shortly in accordance with my previous warning post regarding OT posts.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 31, 2019, 10:12:48 AM
Is there something about "OFF TOPIC" which is beyond your understanding?  Please open a new thread if you wish to discuss Rebecca Brooks.  This one is clear that the topic is ..."If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?"
I will be deleting this post shortly in accordance with my previous warning post regarding OT posts.

Fair enough but can I ask if you could even pretend to be a bit more evenhanded when admonishing posters for going off topic.....no, scrub that, you have already proved on numerous occasions that you are incapable of being fair.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: G-Unit on August 31, 2019, 10:34:58 AM
Is there something wrong with being a pragmatist?  I can be one as well, when it suits me.

Not in the least, I think I'm one too. The context was Jim Gamble thinking that his wording might prompt Gerry to confess if he was involved in Madeleine's disapearance. A pragmatist wouldn't be affected because they have dealt with whatever happened in the past and moved on, imo.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Eleanor on August 31, 2019, 10:41:51 AM
Not in the least, I think I'm one too. The context was Jim Gamble thinking that his wording might prompt Gerry to confess if he was involved in Madeleine's disapearance. A pragmatist wouldn't be affected because they have dealt with whatever happened in the past and moved on, imo.

Is there any other way to deal with what happened in the past?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 31, 2019, 11:45:06 AM
Not at all, but they don't waste their energy dwelling on the past. As Gerry said, he regretted not being there to protect his daughter, but he couldn't change that. So he concentrated on doing everything he could think of which might help to find her.
And do you accept what you have just said?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 31, 2019, 12:12:18 PM
There is, and it’s this, I didn’t say this

“Gerry understood that. But, he says, the iris “is Madeleine’s only true distinctive feature. Certainly we thought it was possible that this could potentially hurt her or”—he grimaces—“her abductor might do something to her eye.… But in terms of marketing, it was a good ploy.”

Gerry did. I’m only the messenger.

Now can you show me any better example of pragmatism than that ?
If Gerry is taking the gamble that Madeleine has been abducted as a replacement child, could the child she replaced also have a coloboma defect?  Therefore the risk of being injured is less since the family already had a child with a coloboma defect.  Same eye?  Same severity?

A family could come back and say they had a miracle, they've been to Fatima and received a blessing the coloboma is also healed, its now only a mark on the iris.
(https://as1.ftcdn.net/jpg/01/48/91/56/500_F_148915615_3cBtu5oqv7c3DEFGVAWSA4ykNKsMJr1D.jpg)

Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: jassi on August 31, 2019, 12:19:33 PM
If Gerry is taking the gamble that Madeleine has been abducted as a replacement child, could the child she replaced also have a coloboma defect?  Therefore the risk of being injured is less since the family already had a child with a coloboma defect.  Same eye?  Same severity?

A family could come back and say they had a miracle, they've been to Fatima and received a blessing the coloboma is also healed, its now only a mark on the iris.
(https://www.google.co.nz/url?sa=i&source=images&cd=&ved=2ahUKEwiywYn9_azkAhXTbSsKHdB4B4gQjRx6BAgBEAQ&url=https%3A%2F%2Fstock.adobe.com%2Fee%2Feditorial%2Fgerry-mccann-and-his-wife-kate-parents-of-missing-child-madeleine-mccann-leave-the-catholic-shrine-in-fatima%2F148915615&psig=AOvVaw13HR5vVpVPZjfQwHknRZ7n&ust=1567336577180614)

Surely that's a bit wacky, even for you.  Any evidence to support it ?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 31, 2019, 12:26:44 PM
Surely that's a bit wacky, even for you.  Any evidence to support it ?
All day we've been thinking Gerry is a bit cold for taking the risk that Madeleine's captives might hurt her, damage her eye or even kill her now that her details were published. 
Then this "wacky" idea dawned on me; what if the replaced child had a similar or worse defect.  The McCanns did go to Fatima and to the Pope.  What was the purpose behind that?  Was it just more marketing ploy?

That means in that scenario she was taken primarily because she had a coloboma defect, a "targeted abduction"!
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: G-Unit on August 31, 2019, 02:13:01 PM
Is there any other way to deal with what happened in the past?

Some people can't move on, like Sarah Payne's father.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on August 31, 2019, 06:08:34 PM
Not in the least, I think I'm one too. The context was Jim Gamble thinking that his wording might prompt Gerry to confess if he was involved in Madeleine's disapearance. A pragmatist wouldn't be affected because they have dealt with whatever happened in the past and moved on, imo.
Pragmatists are not affected by whatever happened in the past?  What nonsense.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 31, 2019, 07:38:24 PM
All day we've been thinking Gerry is a bit cold for taking the risk that Madeleine's captives might hurt her, damage her eye or even kill her now that her details were published. 
Then this "wacky" idea dawned on me; what if the replaced child had a similar or worse defect.  The McCanns did go to Fatima and to the Pope.  What was the purpose behind that?  Was it just more marketing ploy?

That means in that scenario she was taken primarily because she had a coloboma defect, a "targeted abduction"!

I’m not really one for emoticons but  *%87
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Eleanor on August 31, 2019, 07:57:17 PM
Some people can't move on, like Sarah Payne's father.

That is a terrible thing to say.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 31, 2019, 07:57:39 PM
I’m not really one for emoticons but  *%87
Was she targeted?  What reason was she targeted?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Eleanor on August 31, 2019, 07:59:51 PM
I’m not really one for emoticons but  *%87
.
So probably a pragmatist.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 31, 2019, 08:08:41 PM
Some people can't move on, like Sarah Payne's father.
The name has slipped my memory - Sarah Payne?  This one https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-england-29830106?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 31, 2019, 08:11:18 PM
.
So probably a pragmatist.

It would appear so.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Brietta on August 31, 2019, 08:12:55 PM
That is a terrible thing to say.
Sarah Payne's father died after a long illness.  I agree that using him or any other parent of a missing or murdered child in this petty fashion is reprehensible.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 31, 2019, 08:13:17 PM
It would appear so.
Very pragmatic answer.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: faithlilly on August 31, 2019, 08:15:14 PM
Was she targeted?  What reason was she targeted?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Eleanor on August 31, 2019, 08:18:23 PM
The name has slipped my memory - Sarah Payne?

Poor little girl.  If this is all that Sceptics have to say then count me out.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: jassi on August 31, 2019, 08:43:01 PM
Sarah Payne's father died after a long illness.  I agree that using him or any other parent of a missing or murdered child in this petty fashion is reprehensible.



He suffered from  alcoholism and depression

https://www.mirror.co.uk/tv/tv-news/sarah-paynes-father-who-is-10824526
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Admin on August 31, 2019, 10:17:03 PM
Please stay on topic.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Miss Taken Identity on September 01, 2019, 11:52:35 AM
If Madeleine is dead her body would have been well disposed of. as in NO trace what so ever.  So this looks like it was not a planned abduction.

The OG team stopped digging, It is a wonder as to why. My guess would be they were perhaps following a scenario of MBM being grabbed from the street then 'flung' away. or a very shallow grave was hurried to cover tracks- suspecting a local perhaps?

I doubt very much that we will ever see a recovered body of MBM from the 'abduction'.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Robittybob1 on September 01, 2019, 11:59:52 AM
If Madeleine is dead her body would have been well disposed of. as in NO trace what so ever.  So this looks like it was not a planned abduction.

The OG team stopped digging, It is a wonder as to why. My guess would be they were perhaps following a scenario of MBM being grabbed from the street then 'flung' away. or a very shallow grave was hurried to cover tracks- suspecting a local perhaps?

I doubt very much that we will ever see a recovered body of MBM from the 'abduction'.
But IMO she is alive. 
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Miss Taken Identity on September 01, 2019, 12:03:09 PM
But IMO she is alive.

Yes but the thread topic is bout her body if she was dead. stay with the topic...  8)-)))
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Robittybob1 on September 01, 2019, 12:06:38 PM
Yes but the thread topic is bout her body if she was dead. stay with the topic...  8)-)))
Yes, If she was dead, yeah but IMO she is alive, so that is the reason they don't find her body.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Miss Taken Identity on September 01, 2019, 12:14:23 PM
Yes, If she was dead, yeah but IMO she is alive, so that is the reason they don't find her body.

OK let's do this your way.  why have they NOT found her alive body?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Robittybob1 on September 01, 2019, 12:43:31 PM
OK let's do this your way.  why have they NOT found her alive body?
As I figured today, SHE could be filling the role of a perfect lookalike.   That would mean it was a very specific targeted abduction, based either on looks or looks and genetics combined.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Miss Taken Identity on September 01, 2019, 12:56:31 PM
As I figured today, SHE could be filling the role of a perfect lookalike.   That would mean it was a very specific targeted abduction, based either on looks or looks and genetics combined.

Right.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Robittybob1 on September 01, 2019, 01:04:53 PM
Right.
OK it is a long shot but one that still remains a possibility.  The words that Gerry said on the bus still bug me: David Payne says to Gerry: "Cheer up Gerry , you're on holiday" and Gerry answers:  "..do you think I've come to enjoy myself..."  or words to that effect.

What was on his mind?  Did he know there was trouble brewing?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: ShiningInLuz on September 01, 2019, 01:07:26 PM
As I figured today, SHE could be filling the role of a perfect lookalike.   That would mean it was a very specific targeted abduction, based either on looks or looks and genetics combined.

Perhaps we should have another Cody while we think this through?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Robittybob1 on September 01, 2019, 01:08:45 PM
Perhaps we should have another Cody while we think this through?
What's that?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Miss Taken Identity on September 01, 2019, 01:14:11 PM
OK it is a long shot but one that still remains a possibility.  The words that Gerry said on the bus still bug me: David Payne says to Gerry: "Cheer up Gerry , you're on holiday" and Gerry answers:  "..do you think I've come to enjoy myself..."  or words to that effect.

What was on his mind?  Did he know there was trouble brewing?

Perhaps. who knows.  We just don't know , what we do know it they did not pay for a baby sitter or pay to have their children in a night creché.OR take their children with them  to dinner. Plently of opportunity for trouble to be brewed- in fact ,sadly it was.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: jassi on September 01, 2019, 01:28:06 PM
Perhaps. who knows.  We just don't know , what we do know it they did not pay for a baby sitter or pay to have their children in a night creché.OR take their children with them  to dinner. Plently of opportunity for trouble to be brewed- in fact ,sadly it was.

I would say requisites rather than opportunities.
If any of those measures had been in place, an abduction ( if there was one) could not have taken place in the manner claimed
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: John on September 01, 2019, 01:29:00 PM
Posters are reminded of the forum rules and should not engage in any conduct which breaches those rules. Sniping, goading, use of inappropriate language, posting insulting comments and unnecessary criticism of other members should be avoided. Moderators are also reminded of the need to lead by example and should avoid inappropriate comment or unnecessary moderation.

Members can message me at any time if necessary.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Robittybob1 on September 01, 2019, 07:47:02 PM
I would say requisites rather than opportunities.
If any of those measures had been in place, an abduction ( if there was one) could not have taken place in the manner claimed
That is right, so was it encouraged?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Robittybob1 on September 01, 2019, 09:28:41 PM
OK it is a long shot but one that still remains a possibility.  The words that Gerry said on the bus still bug me: David Payne says to Gerry: "Cheer up Gerry , you're on holiday" and Gerry answers:  "..do you think I've come to enjoy myself..."  or words to that effect.

What was on his mind?  Did he know there was trouble brewing?
No parents in their right mind would go on holiday if they knew their child was going to be kidnapped.  So I'm going to modify the targeted abduction idea, to more of a planned meeting and the unplanned end result was the abduction.
A situation where the abduction wasn't planned but the meeting was.
So in this scenario Gerry might have feared the meeting, and that took away the joy of going on holiday.

Looking at the words there seems to be something that was a creating anxiety.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Miss Taken Identity on September 08, 2019, 09:59:01 PM
No parents in their right mind would go on holiday if they knew their child was going to be kidnapped.  So I'm going to modify the targeted abduction idea, to more of a planned meeting and the unplanned end result was the abduction.
A situation where the abduction wasn't planned but the meeting was.
So in this scenario Gerry might have feared the meeting, and that took away the joy of going on holiday.

Looking at the words there seems to be something that was a creating anxiety.

IMO he was being sarcastic. bad joke...
He had every intention of enjoying himself without the burden of chidlcare placed upon him by all accounts.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: The General on September 11, 2019, 12:21:36 PM
IMO he was being sarcastic. bad joke...
He had every intention of enjoying himself without the burden of chidlcare placed upon him by all accounts.
In fairness I think it was a throwaway comment, but maybe more to do with the total mission that is mobilising 3 little kids through the travelling process - it's not fun at all.
I can't believe that video is still referred to as in some way possible indication of an antecedent. Just a grumpy dad asked to get in the holiday mood after 6-7 hours of logistics and travel.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: puglove on September 11, 2019, 12:44:07 PM
In fairness I think it was a throwaway comment, but maybe more to do with the total mission that is mobilising 3 little kids through the travelling process - it's not fun at all.
I can't believe that video is still referred to as in some way possible indication of an antecedent. Just a grumpy dad asked to get in the holiday mood after 6-7 hours of logistics and travel.

I wouldn't be too cheery if he said "f*ck off" in front of my grandchildren.

 %56&
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: The General on September 11, 2019, 12:51:10 PM
I wouldn't be too cheery if he said "f*ck off" in front of my grandchildren.

 %56&
I think the foxtrot oscar was in response to being asked to 'cheer up', or words to that affect.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: G-Unit on September 11, 2019, 01:42:03 PM
In fairness I think it was a throwaway comment, but maybe more to do with the total mission that is mobilising 3 little kids through the travelling process - it's not fun at all.
I can't believe that video is still referred to as in some way possible indication of an antecedent. Just a grumpy dad asked to get in the holiday mood after 6-7 hours of logistics and travel.

Wimps! My husband and I got three children under 5 from Lancashire to London by train, then to Hendon by tube. We had a pushchair and 2 large suitcases, plus hand luggage. I still remember my husband going down the escalator with the cases, which he had to leave at the bottom. Then he came up and carried the pushchair with child down while I took the walking children down. After an overnight stay we caught a flight to Germany the following day. On landing we loaded everything onto a coach, then into a Landrover to travel to our new home. The only person who got grumpy was a city gent when I ran over his polished shoe with the pushchair on the tube.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Mr Gray on September 11, 2019, 01:54:07 PM
Wimps! My husband and I got three children under 5 from Lancashire to London by train, then to Hendon by tube. We had a pushchair and 2 large suitcases, plus hand luggage. I still remember my husband going down the escalator with the cases, which he had to leave at the bottom. Then he came up and carried the pushchair with child down while I took the walking children down. After an overnight stay we caught a flight to Germany the following day. On landing we loaded everything onto a coach, then into a Landrover to travel to our new home. The only person who got grumpy was a city gent when I ran over his polished shoe with the pushchair on the tube.

You were lucky. .train.. Land rover.. We had to walk ....had to start out, a week before the holiday to get there in time... Spend five minutes on the beach then walk back as dad had to be ready for his next shift down mine... You try telling that to the kids today.. They wont believe you
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: The General on September 11, 2019, 01:57:19 PM
You were lucky. .train.. Land rover.. We had to walk ....had to start out, a week before the holiday to get there in time... Spend five minutes on the beach then walk back as dad had to be ready for his next shift down mine... You try telling that to the kids today.. They wont believe you
Luxury! We had a cardboard box int middle of ruuurd.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on September 11, 2019, 04:01:03 PM
You guys had holidays???!  Sheesh.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: G-Unit on September 11, 2019, 06:10:00 PM
You were lucky. .train.. Land rover.. We had to walk ....had to start out, a week before the holiday to get there in time... Spend five minutes on the beach then walk back as dad had to be ready for his next shift down mine... You try telling that to the kids today.. They wont believe you

I wasn't going on holiday, just moving home military style. How wide is the boat your son lives on?
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Mr Gray on September 11, 2019, 06:29:40 PM
I wasn't going on holiday, just moving home military style. How wide is the boat your son lives on?

It just about fits in a lock... So quite narrow... A standard narrowboat I would think
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Mr Gray on September 11, 2019, 08:24:45 PM
It just about fits in a lock... So quite narrow... A standard narrowboat I would think

its odd...you ask me twice how wide my sons barge is...and when I answer you dont reply...what was your point
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: G-Unit on September 12, 2019, 06:12:30 AM
its odd...you ask me twice how wide my sons barge is...and when I answer you dont reply...what was your point

Sorry! I was interested because we used to have one. Some canals have wide locks which take 2 narrowoats, side by side. If less than 7 feet wide, strictly speaking it's a narrowboat, not a barge. I understand why he enjoys it; it's like entering another slower, friendlier world.  Beautiful scenery and tons of wildlife.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: Mr Gray on September 12, 2019, 07:59:27 AM
Sorry! I was interested because we used to have one. Some canals have wide locks which take 2 narrowoats, side by side. If less than 7 feet wide, strictly speaking it's a narrowboat, not a barge. I understand why he enjoys it; it's like entering another slower, friendlier world.  Beautiful scenery and tons of wildlife.

They hold their value well too so rather than rent buy a boat and when its paid for theyve got the deposit for a house.
Title: Re: If MM is no longer alive then why hasn't a body been found?
Post by: G-Unit on September 12, 2019, 08:25:54 AM
They hold their value well too so rather than rent buy a boat and when its paid for theyve got the deposit for a house.

Along with a lovely experience; it's win/win. We met many interesting people from all over the world cruising the canals.