UK Justice Forum 🇬🇧
Disappeared and Abducted Children and Young Adults => Madeleine McCann (3) disappeared from her parent's holiday apartment at Ocean Club, Praia da Luz, Portugal on 3 May 2007. No trace of her has ever been found. => Topic started by: Holly Goodhead on September 03, 2019, 11:08:22 AM
-
ie relationship between anyone who caused MM harm whether a stranger or those known to her.
A poster on another thread has recently made comment about MM snatched by one of the many ubiquitous predators lurking in each hedge.
The fact is MM was not in the age range paedophiles are normally attracted to. This cannot be totally ruled out as unfortunately we know of cases where children around MM's age and younger have been the victims of sexual assaults but statistically it is unlikely.
None of the holiday makers with young children, T9 and/or others, detected anyone acting suspiciously by lurking around, staring etc. The 4 efits of 'suspicious' men were just seen hanging around in the vicinity of 5A as opposed to 'perving' on the children.
PDL is home to two schools and afaik no reports of any individual hanging around or attempting to abduct children, entice them away etc.
According to KM's book she was told by Bill Henderson, British consulate for the Algarve, about cases of men (or a man) getting into bed with children. I think I recall some other place in the book she claims to have received contact from the families involved.
-
ie relationship between anyone who caused MM harm whether a stranger or those known to her.
A poster on another thread has recently made comment about MM snatched by one of the many ubiquitous predators lurking in each hedge.
The fact is MM was not in the age range paedophiles are normally attracted to. This cannot be totally ruled out as unfortunately we know of cases where children around MM's age and younger have been the victims of sexual assaults but statistically it is unlikely.
None of the holiday makers with young children, T9 and/or others, detected anyone acting suspiciously by lurking around, staring etc. The 4 efits of 'suspicious' men were just seen hanging around in the vicinity of 5A as opposed to 'perving' on the children.
PDL is home to two schools and afaik no reports of any individual hanging around or attempting to abduct children, entice them away etc.
According to KM's book she was told by Bill Henderson, British consulate for the Algarve, about cases of men (or a man) getting into bed with children. I think I recall some other place in the book she claims to have received contact from the families involved.
The random paedophile narrative never stacked up.
The random, brazen paedophile narrative never stacked up.
The random, brazen, calculating paedophile narrative never stacked up.
The random, brazen, calculating, highly successful paedophile narrative never stacked up.
-
The random paedophile narrative never stacked up.
The random, brazen paedophile narrative never stacked up.
The random, brazen, calculating paedophile narrative never stacked up.
The random, brazen, calculating, highly successful paedophile narrative never stacked up.
It seems unlikely but is it a case that paedophiles are not attracted to children MM's age range or the fact they are usually so closely supervised that they're in the main inaccessible? By this I mean if all the stats show children under the age of say 8/9 yoa are not usually victims of stranger sexual assault this might be because they are are more difficult to access as opposed to paedophiles not attracted to them.
-
It seems unlikely but is it a case that paedophiles are not attracted to children MM's age range or the fact they are usually so closely supervised that they're in the main inaccessible? By this I mean if all the stats show children under the age of say 8/9 yoa are not usually victims of stranger sexual assault this might be because they are are more difficult to access as opposed to paedophiles not attracted to them.
There are outliers in every case; exceptions to the rule. But looking at the balance of probabilities (yes, I know the term is incongruous with a criminal law standpoint), it's unlikely to be the cause in this case. 'Stolen to order' or 'stolen as a result of serendipitous circumstances', whilst still unlikely, are more likely than our 'nonce in the hedge' scenario.
-
It seems unlikely but is it a case that paedophiles are not attracted to children MM's age range or the fact they are usually so closely supervised that they're in the main inaccessible? By this I mean if all the stats show children under the age of say 8/9 yoa are not usually victims of stranger sexual assault this might be because they are are more difficult to access as opposed to paedophiles not attracted to them.
Which is perhaps why very young children are victimised by those close to them or those who have befriended their parents.
-
There are outliers in every case; exceptions to the rule. But looking at the balance of probabilities (yes, I know the term is incongruous with a criminal law standpoint), it's unlikely to be the cause in this case. 'Stolen to order' or 'stolen as a result of serendipitous circumstances', whilst still unlikely, are more likely than our 'nonce in the hedge' scenario.
The 'stolen to order' is a non-starter imo as there wasn't enough time to identify, plan and execute. Plus there haven't been any cases of young British children on holiday in Algarve 'stolen to order' since or before.
-
The 'stolen to order' is a non-starter imo as there wasn't enough time to identify, plan and execute. Plus there haven't been any cases of young British children on holiday in Algarve 'stolen to order' since or before.
The circumstances on 28 April 2007 were unique. Plenty of time to prepare, plan and execute.
-
Which is perhaps why very young children are victimised by those close to them or those who have befriended their parents.
Yes of course but in my post I referred to 'stranger sexual assault'. In the case of MM I think we can all agree and rule out sexual assault at the hands of her friends (T7), family and those who befriended her at PDL eg nannies at creche?
-
The circumstances on 28 April 2007 were unique. Plenty of time to prepare, plan and execute.
I agree if someone happened to be on the balcony night after night and observed McCanns exiting for tapas via the patio doors (which can't be locked from outside) and this someone also happened to have an unhealthy interest in females MM's age he/she might seize the opportunity but this would not amount to being 'stolen to order'? What are the chances of such an individual hanging out on the balcony night after night who just happened to observe the McCanns patterns, spot the opportunity and also knew someone who was looking for a child in MM's age range and who was willing and able to offer some sort of incentive for the would be abductor? The pair would then need to conspire to plan and execute leaving no footprint behind by way of money exchanging hands, telecommunications. And no one breaking ranks in an attempt to claim the reward money. Almost anything is possible but it isn't plausible imo.
-
I agree if someone happened to be on the balcony night after night and observed McCanns exiting for tapas via the patio doors (which can't be locked from outside) and this someone also happened to have an unhealthy interest in females MM's age he/she might seize the opportunity but this would not amount to being 'stolen to order'? What are the chances of such an individual hanging out on the balcony night after night who just happened to observe the McCanns patterns, spot the opportunity and also knew someone who was looking for a child in MM's age range and who was willing and able to offer some sort of incentive for the would be abductor? The pair would then need to conspire to plan and execute leaving no footprint behind by way of money exchanging hands, telecommunications. And no one breaking ranks in an attempt to claim the reward money. Almost anything is possible but it isn't plausible imo.
You are missing the point entirely.
I don't mean to be rude, but I hope your submission to OG/PJ is of higher quality.
The clock starts ticking when MW purchased the OC. From memory, that was Jan 2007. But please consult G-Unit, who has already provided the takeover date.
-
When one looks at the MW guest lists, it seems that most parents had two small children. Is it possible that the person/s responsible for Madeleine’s disappearance made the observation early on that the family had three small children and decided to take her as opposed to a child from the smaller families, un/intentionally showing some ‘compassion’?
-
You are missing the point entirely.
I don't mean to be rude, but I hope your submission to OG/PJ is of higher quality.
The clock starts ticking when MW purchased the OC. From memory, that was Jan 2007. But please consult G-Unit, who has already provided the takeover date.
Please elucidate as I've no idea what possible connection can exist between MW purchasing OC and MM's disappearance?
-
When one looks at the MW guest lists, it seems that most parents had two small children. Is it possible that the person/s responsible for Madeleine’s disappearance made the observation early on that the family had three small children and decided to take her as opposed to a child from the smaller families, un/intentionally showing some ‘compassion’?
Is it possible MM's abductor (I do believe there was one) was aware she (and the twins) was left 'home alone' night after night in the unsecured apartment and according to Mrs Fenn on 1st May MM was crying for 1.25 hours calling 'daddy, daddy'. Did the abductor(s) justify the abduction on the basis in his/her mind MM was neglected and/or the McCanns were unable to cope with MM and the twins?
-
Hi Holly, yes I think through observation someone would have been able to gather enough information. I did not mean what you mention in your last sentence re. Madeleine. What I did mean was that if a child had to be taken, rather take one from a larger family where 2 children will be left and still be part of the family.
-
Hi Holly, yes I think through observation someone would have been able to gather enough information. I did not mean what you mention in your last sentence re. Madeleine. What I did mean was that if a child had to be taken, rather take one from a larger family where 2 children will be left and still be part of the family.
Yes I understood your post but apologise as I just went off on a bit of a tangent! Well my theory put to OG is kind of connected with what you are suggesting. It appears that my suspect(s) nuclear family reflects that of the McCanns: 2 parents, opposite sex twins and a female sibling. Firstly is my suspect(s)/theory correct? Secondly if it is correct what relevance if any does the fact the size and shape of the nuclear families of abductor and McCanns are duplicated have? Did the duplication spark something in the abductor? Maybe it is just a coincidence and the abduction was justified on the basis the abductor believed MM was neglected as she was the one heard crying and calling out for her daddy.
-
Yes I understood your post but apologise as I just went off on a bit of a tangent! Well my theory put to OG is kind of connected with what you are suggesting. It appears that my suspect(s) nuclear family reflects that of the McCanns: 2 parents, opposite sex twins and a female sibling. Firstly is my suspect(s)/theory correct? Secondly if it is correct what relevance if any does the fact the size and shape of the nuclear families of abductor and McCanns are duplicated have? Did the duplication spark something in the abductor? Maybe it is just a coincidence and the abduction was justified on the basis the abductor believed MM was neglected as she was the one heard crying and calling out for her daddy.
That is interesting because on another thread I proposed it was a targeted abduction. Here you also propose a targeted abduction but for a different reason. Both have the idea that this other couple have some interest in the McCann family.
-
I agree if someone happened to be on the balcony night after night and observed McCanns exiting for tapas via the patio doors (which can't be locked from outside) and this someone also happened to have an unhealthy interest in females MM's age he/she might seize the opportunity but this would not amount to being 'stolen to order'? What are the chances of such an individual hanging out on the balcony night after night who just happened to observe the McCanns patterns, spot the opportunity and also knew someone who was looking for a child in MM's age range and who was willing and able to offer some sort of incentive for the would be abductor? The pair would then need to conspire to plan and execute leaving no footprint behind by way of money exchanging hands, telecommunications. And no one breaking ranks in an attempt to claim the reward money. Almost anything is possible but it isn't plausible imo.
have you considered that Madeleine might have been identified, before she left the UK, for her bloodline?
-
have you considered that Madeleine might have been identified, before she left the UK, for her bloodline?
This would be the first time a "bloodline " person was chosen from an IVF situation.
But even if you are wrong, you too are proposing a type of targeted abduction.
-
Please elucidate as I've no idea what possible connection can exist between MW purchasing OC and MM's disappearance?
Step 1. MW purchases OC.
Step 2. MW actively promotes OC as an MW resort.
The resort appears to be a compound, separated from Luz. That is 100% incorrect. But tough to tell until you get to Luz, and find out most of it is public.
MW resorts normally offer a child listening service. It isn't made clear on the marketing that no such service is on offer in the OC.
MW possibly or probably implements new systems and processes within the OC. This point has still to be confirmed by OC or MW staff.
Summary - all in all a standard MW resort. Until one makes a booking. That's step 3.
-
Step 1. MW purchases OC.
Step 2. MW actively promotes OC as an MW resort.
The resort appears to be a compound, separated from Luz. That is 100% incorrect. But tough to tell until you get to Luz, and find out most of it is public.
MW resorts normally offer a child listening service. It isn't made clear on the marketing that no such service is on offer in the OC.
MW possibly or probably implements new systems and processes within the OC. This point has still to be confirmed by OC or MW staff.
Summary - all in all a standard MW resort. Until one makes a booking. That's step 3.
I don't think it was a standard MW resort at all. Mark Warner Ltd took bookings, but it didn't own the resort. The resort was bought by European Leisure Holdings which then sold it to Greentrust SA. Greentrust employed the local Portuguese staff and MW the English summer staff. Greentrust dealt with placing clients in the accomodation for MW, Thomas Cook, the Travel Club and Jonathan Markson. Clients were told they could request certain accomodation, but there were no guarantees that they would get what they wanted.
Then along came the T9. They didn't realise that there was no baby listening service until after they'd booked. Instead of accepting they got it wrong they blamed MW for a lack of clarity. They asked to be placed together, but MW couldn't deliver that; it was decided in Portugal by OC staff. By persevering they got what they wanted; just as well, as the Oldfields and Kate McCann were threatening to pull out.
Furthermore, he wishes to make clear that while making the aforementioned reservations the operator had told them that a 'baby listening' service was not in place in the Ocean Club Garden.
That fact had made some of the couples - and himself in particular - reluctant to come to Portugal because all the families have minor children.
As far as he [MO] is concerned, he wishes at this time to add that, in conversation with DP on a date he does not recall with certainty but likely to have been on 7 or 8 May, he [DP] confided in him that that, at that time, KH had been particularly reluctant about coming to Portugal because she had had a bad feeling [presentiment] about the children of the group and the non-existence of the 'baby sitting' service.
Nevertheless, he relates that, they had discussed this problem resolving to make the trip since the operator had assured them accommodation sufficiently close together that, collectively, they had managed to assure the checking and supervision of their respective progeny.
https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/MATTHEW-OLDFIELD-10MAY.htm
So the members of the group knew before they left England that they were planning to check the children. In my opinion not many people in Luz knew about their plan. It was normal for Luis Duarte, the reservations manager and his staff to assign clients to apartments, but in the case of the T9 booking he wasn't involved.
https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/LUIS_DUARTE.htm
It was his boss, Vitor Santos, who dealt with that booking. In my opinion that was because they were insisting on being placed together;
in this case in concrete a request was made that the four families should be accommodated close to each other and a ground floor apartment was requested enabling easy access for the families with small children.
https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/VITOR-SANTOS.htm
It seems to me that the T9, some office based MW employees in England and the Housing Manager in Portugal knew what was being planned before the holiday began.
-
Step 1. MW purchases OC.
Step 2. MW actively promotes OC as an MW resort.
The resort appears to be a compound, separated from Luz. That is 100% incorrect. But tough to tell until you get to Luz, and find out most of it is public.
MW resorts normally offer a child listening service. It isn't made clear on the marketing that no such service is on offer in the OC.
MW possibly or probably implements new systems and processes within the OC. This point has still to be confirmed by OC or MW staff.
Summary - all in all a standard MW resort. Until one makes a booking. That's step 3.
Thanks but I'm still struggling to see the connection. Imo the key to solving the case is the unlocked patio door which only a finite number of people knew about ie those who saw or heard McCanns exit and enter. No one could foresee the McCanns leaving this door unlocked. And no one could know whether or not the McCanns/T7 would bring along their own baby listening services by way of monitors which the Paynes did.
-
Thanks but I'm still struggling to see the connection. Imo the key to solving the case is the unlocked patio door which only a finite number of people knew about ie those who saw or heard McCanns exit and enter. No one could foresee the McCanns leaving this door unlocked. And no one could know whether or not the McCanns/T7 would bring along their own baby listening services by way of monitors which the Paynes did.
Have you proved that the patio doors were left unlocked all week? I think not.
-
That is interesting because on another thread I proposed it was a targeted abduction. Here you also propose a targeted abduction but for a different reason. Both have the idea that this other couple have some interest in the McCann family.
I believe MM was abducted based on the fact she was accessible. Had the patio door been locked then I do not believe the abductor(s) would have taken the risk in forcing entry.
I believe the abductor(s) was aware the McCanns were leaving the children home alone in an unlocked apartment every night whilst they wined and dined at tapas. Mrs Fenn claimed on 1st May she heard MM crying for 1.25 hours and calling out 'Daddy, daddy'. If this is accurate who else heard and who else did Mrs Fenn discuss with? The abductor may well have justified the abduction on the basis he/she perceived that MM was being neglected. Maybe the abductor had some idea about teaching the McCanns a lesson but with all the police/media presence felt unable to return MM.
Imagine if you are situated in some accommodation, whether holiday or otherwise, and you know 3 small children are being left alone night after night whilst the parents wine and dine at a nearby restaurant. You also appreciate the parents are exiting via a door that can't be locked from outside. Worse still you then hear the child crying for some 1.25 hours calling 'daddy, daddy' what action would you take? Well I certainly would not consider entering the accommodation. I might go along to the tapas bar and explain what was happening but then I do not know anything about these people; they might thank me or they might tell me to fook off and mind my own business! I would probably report the incident to MW reception and ask them to deal with it and keep me out of it.
People often do things on hol they would not consider doing at home. Imagine some couple in England doing what the McCanns did above. Neighbours would probably have the advantage of knowing something about the parents and how best to handle them ie approach them direct or phone up social services.
-
Have you proved that the patio doors were left unlocked all week? I think not.
I'm happy to rely on Mrs Fenn coupled with the McCanns/RO's testimony they were entering and exiting via the patio doors.
-
I believe MM was abducted based on the fact she was accessible. Had the patio door been locked then I do not believe the abductor(s) would have taken the risk in forcing entry.
I believe the abductor(s) was aware the McCanns were leaving the children home alone in an unlocked apartment every night whilst they wined and dined at tapas. Mrs Fenn claimed on 1st May she heard MM crying for 1.25 hours and calling out 'Daddy, daddy'. If this is accurate who else heard and who else did Mrs Fenn discuss with? The abductor may well have justified the abduction on the basis he/she perceived that MM was being neglected. Maybe the abductor had some idea about teaching the McCanns a lesson but with all the police/media presence felt unable to return MM.
Imagine if you are situated in some accommodation, whether holiday or otherwise, and you know 3 small children are being left alone night after night whilst the parents wine and dine at a nearby restaurant. You also appreciate the parents are exiting via a door that can't be locked from outside. Worse still you then hear the child crying for some 1.25 hours calling 'daddy, daddy' what action would you take? Well I certainly would not consider entering the accommodation. I might go along to the tapas bar and explain what was happening but then I do not know anything about these people; they might thank me or they might tell me to fook off and mind my own business! I would probably report the incident to MW reception and ask them to deal with it and keep me out of it.
People often do things on hol they would not consider doing at home. Imagine some couple in England doing what the McCanns did above. Neighbours would probably have the advantage of knowing something about the parents and how best to handle them ie approach them direct or phone up social services.
When you say "I believe MM was abducted based on the fact she was accessible. Had the patio door been locked then I do not believe the abductor(s) would have taken the risk in forcing entry"
, I personally feel your theory is in error, for I understand that Madeleine left via the front door.
OK had that front door been double locked Madeleine would not have been able to leave that way, so you are right IMO about the unlocked patio door being an issue.
-
When you say "I believe MM was abducted based on the fact she was accessible. Had the patio door been locked then I do not believe the abductor(s) would have taken the risk in forcing entry"
, I personally feel your theory is in error, for I understand that Madeleine left via the front door.
OK had that front door been double locked Madeleine would not have been able to leave that way, so you are right IMO about the unlocked patio door being an issue.
I don't think there is the slightest doubt that the patio door was unlocked on the third of May. Whether or not that was the entry point for an intruder is not known.
-
I don't think there is the slightest doubt that the patio door was unlocked on the third of May. Whether or not that was the entry point for an intruder is not known.
IMO whoever comes through that patio door doesn't have to be an intruder, or an abductor.
OK if someone comes through that door it could be for reasons such as checking on the kids. Anyone checking on the kids "intrudes", but falls outside the description of intruder.
But anyone other than Mum or Dad could appear to be an intruder as far as Madeleine is concerned.
-
have you considered that Madeleine might have been identified, before she left the UK, for her bloodline?
No I haven't considered the above as I don't believe anyone could have foreseen what would happen in PDL ie McCanns dining at tapas Sun - Thu and exiting/entering via the unlocked patio door along with Mrs Fenn's claims of MM crying for 1.25 hours and calling out 'daddy, daddy' all of which amounted to a green light for the abductor(s) imo.
What evidence exists supporting the idea MM is from special bloodline? According to KM's book MM hails from working class Irish Catholics.
If the abductor(s) are who I think they are I guess its possible they may have been incentivised by the fact MM was/is healthy and cute looking coupled with the fact her parents are slim and attractive and were holidaying in a middle class resort. This might have aligned with their perception of themselves ie a cuckoo not out of kilter.
-
I believe MM was abducted based on the fact she was accessible. Had the patio door been locked then I do not believe the abductor(s) would have taken the risk in forcing entry.
I believe the abductor(s) was aware the McCanns were leaving the children home alone in an unlocked apartment every night whilst they wined and dined at tapas. Mrs Fenn claimed on 1st May she heard MM crying for 1.25 hours and calling out 'Daddy, daddy'. If this is accurate who else heard and who else did Mrs Fenn discuss with? The abductor may well have justified the abduction on the basis he/she perceived that MM was being neglected. Maybe the abductor had some idea about teaching the McCanns a lesson but with all the police/media presence felt unable to return MM.
Imagine if you are situated in some accommodation, whether holiday or otherwise, and you know 3 small children are being left alone night after night whilst the parents wine and dine at a nearby restaurant. You also appreciate the parents are exiting via a door that can't be locked from outside. Worse still you then hear the child crying for some 1.25 hours calling 'daddy, daddy' what action would you take? Well I certainly would not consider entering the accommodation. I might go along to the tapas bar and explain what was happening but then I do not know anything about these people; they might thank me or they might tell me to fook off and mind my own business! I would probably report the incident to MW reception and ask them to deal with it and keep me out of it.
People often do things on hol they would not consider doing at home. Imagine some couple in England doing what the McCanns did above. Neighbours would probably have the advantage of knowing something about the parents and how best to handle them ie approach them direct or phone up social services.
I've never heard anyone say they did something on holiday that they wouldn't do at home. Where does this idea originate?
-
When you say "I believe MM was abducted based on the fact she was accessible. Had the patio door been locked then I do not believe the abductor(s) would have taken the risk in forcing entry"
, I personally feel your theory is in error, for I understand that Madeleine left via the front door.
OK had that front door been double locked Madeleine would not have been able to leave that way, so you are right IMO about the unlocked patio door being an issue.
Do you believe MM left 5A via the front door by her own actions or she was abducted and carried out by her abductor?
-
I've never heard anyone say they did something on holiday that they wouldn't do at home. Where does this idea opriginate?
People do all sorts of crazy things on holiday that they wouldn't do at home eg indulge in casual sex with multiple partners; drink themselves stupid and then decide to jump off a 5th floor balcony into a swimming pool; get emotionally involved with locals eg a middle aged man falling for a local Thai girl half his age or a middle aged professional woman falling for a Turkish waiter young enough to be her grandson.
Think Shirley Valentine 8)-)))
-
I don't think there is the slightest doubt that the patio door was unlocked on the third of May. Whether or not that was the entry point for an intruder is not known.
A bit of a coincidence if it wasn't?
-
People do all sorts of crazy things on holiday that they wouldn't do at home eg indulge in casual sex with multiple partners; drink themselves stupid and then decide to jump off a 5th floor balcony into a swimming pool; get emotionally involved with locals eg a middle aged man falling for a local Thai girl half his age or a middle aged professional woman falling for a Turkish waiter young enough to be her grandson.
Think Shirley Valentine 8)-)))
True, me and my son were very tempted by the cannabis cookies on sale in Amsterdam this summer. nearly succumbed but my parental responsibility kicked in at the last minute.
-
Do you believe MM left 5A via the front door by her own actions or she was abducted and carried out by her abductor?
I tend to believe she was frightened by the likes of Matt and possibly Russell checking on the McCann kids. So yes IMO in a state of fear "MM left 5A via the front door by her own actions".
What is surprising is that there was someone on the outside of the apartment who abducts her in my theory. But really if someone was planning an abduction it is rather a bonus if the abductee runs into them, rather than that person needing to enter the apartment.
-
People do all sorts of crazy things on holiday that they wouldn't do at home eg indulge in casual sex with multiple partners; drink themselves stupid and then decide to jump off a 5th floor balcony into a swimming pool; get emotionally involved with locals eg a middle aged man falling for a local Thai girl half his age or a middle aged professional woman falling for a Turkish waiter young enough to be her grandson.
Think Shirley Valentine 8)-)))
Most of those people were daft at home too imo.
-
Most of those people were daft at home too imo.
Everyone has done daft things at some point in their lives, even you I expect.
-
I tend to believe she was frightened by the likes of Matt and possibly Russell checking on the McCann kids. So yes IMO in a state of fear "MM left 5A via the front door by her own actions".
What is surprising is that there was someone on the outside of the apartment who abducts her in my theory. But really if someone was planning an abduction it is rather a bonus if the abductee runs into them, rather than that person needing to enter the apartment.
Did ROB make a physical check inside the apartment?
If MM left the front door of her own accord how do you explain the raised shutter, assuming it was raised as KM claims it was?
Someone got very lucky if they were planning to enter the apartment to abduct MM but she just happened to leave of her own accord and her path then crossed with her abductor.
-
True, me and my son were very tempted by the cannabis cookies on sale in Amsterdam this summer. nearly succumbed but my parental responsibility kicked in at the last minute.
I remember succumbing... Then eating every biscuit, chocolate, crisp and nut in the mini bar
-
Did ROB make a physical check inside the apartment?
If MM left the front door of her own accord how do you explain the raised shutter, assuming it was raised as KM claims it was?
Someone got very lucky if they were planning to enter the apartment to abduct MM but she just happened to leave of her own accord and her path then crossed with her abductor.
Extraordinary odds at play again. The Child Catcher, having waited in a hedge for over an hour, could not believe his good fortune when his quarry literally walked out of the front door and in to his clutches. Quite how nobody witnessed the horse-drawn trailer-mounted cage trundling up the street remains to be seen, but his good fortune continued with the realisation that he was now one giant, swirly lollipop in credit.
-
I remember succumbing... Then eating every biscuit, chocolate, crisp and nut in the mini bar
Reminds me of my time on covert ops in the Chihuahuan Desert back in '92.
Our in-country bushcraft tutor warned us not to be tempted by the little, pink fruits, but after 13 days in country, on the point of desperation, we succumbed.
I personally spent 4 days and nights being led to The Divine Mountain by my spirit guide Jose, where a celestial ceremony was performed by 6 ethereal beings who occupied my consciousness throughout the process, while a shape shifting coyote painted a star map mural on the ground with his tail - this was the map of the inner cosmos.
One of my squadron had the shits for 2 days straight - had to be medi-vacced out on a Merlin.
-
Reminds me of my time on covert ops in the Chihuahuan Desert back in '92.
Our in-country bushcraft tutor warned us not to be tempted by the little, pink fruits, but after 13 days in country, on the point of desperation, we succumbed.
I personally spent 4 days and nights being led to The Divine Mountain by my spirit guide Jose, where a celestial ceremony was performed by 6 ethereal beings who occupied my consciousness throughout the process, while a shape shifting coyote painted a star map mural on the ground with his tail - this was the map of the inner cosmos.
One of my squadron had the shits for 2 days straight - had to be medi-vacced out on a Merlin.
What is that stuff called?
-
Reminds me of my time on covert ops in the Chihuahuan Desert back in '92.
Our in-country bushcraft tutor warned us not to be tempted by the little, pink fruits, but after 13 days in country, on the point of desperation, we succumbed.
I personally spent 4 days and nights being led to The Divine Mountain by my spirit guide Jose, where a celestial ceremony was performed by 6 ethereal beings who occupied my consciousness throughout the process, while a shape shifting coyote painted a star map mural on the ground with his tail - this was the map of the inner cosmos.
One of my squadron had the shits for 2 days straight - had to be medi-vacced out on a Merlin.
I’ll have what he’s having.
-
What is that stuff called?
Peyote. I'm told it's best dried out, then imbibed as a sweet tea. Transcendental sojourn guaranteed.
-
Step 1. MW purchases OC.
Step 2. MW actively promotes OC as an MW resort.
Step 3a. David Payne makes the booking. This is when a very critical clock starts ticking.
Payne requested that all 4 families be placed together. He also seems to have found out there was no child listening service, and asked that the families could be near enough to a restaurant that the families could implement their own version.
That cuts it to block 4, block 5 and block 6 near to the Tapas zone.
That information appears on the MW booking form.
MW (check Wayback) offered an early bird discount to 28 Feb 2007, and a late-booking discount from 8 April 2007. Payne requested and got a discount, suggesting his booking was made in between these dates.
Everyone with access to the MW booking system in the OC had a long head start.
-
Step 3a. David Payne makes the booking. This is when a very critical clock starts ticking.
Payne requested that all 4 families be placed together. He also seems to have found out there was no child listening service, and asked that the families could be near enough to a restaurant that the families could implement their own version.
That cuts it to block 4, block 5 and block 6 near to the Tapas zone.
That information appears on the MW booking form.
MW (check Wayback) offered an early bird discount to 28 Feb 2007, and a late-booking discount from 8 April 2007. Payne requested and got a discount, suggesting his booking was made in between these dates.
Everyone with access to the MW booking system in the OC had a long head start.
That would depend on whether the person taking the booking wrote an explanation or not. If not, it was just four families booked into block 5.
-
That would depend on whether the person taking the booking wrote an explanation or not. If not, it was just four families booked into block 5.
I've been on a lot of hols with family and friends where we've asked to be placed in accommodation close to one another. It makes sense for all sorts of logistical reasons rather than just wanting to be close in the holding hands sense! When groups travel together overseas they are usually seated together, or in close proximity, on the flight.
-
Step 3a. David Payne makes the booking. This is when a very critical clock starts ticking.
Payne requested that all 4 families be placed together. He also seems to have found out there was no child listening service, and asked that the families could be near enough to a restaurant that the families could implement their own version.
That cuts it to block 4, block 5 and block 6 near to the Tapas zone.
That information appears on the MW booking form.
MW (check Wayback) offered an early bird discount to 28 Feb 2007, and a late-booking discount from 8 April 2007. Payne requested and got a discount, suggesting his booking was made in between these dates.
Everyone with access to the MW booking system in the OC had a long head start.
The brochure doesn't mention the child listening service at OC so why would any of the party be under the impression it was available? From KM's book it doesn't seem like the group had any pre-conceived ideas about how they would spend the evenings.
-
I've been on a lot of hols with family and friends where we've asked to be placed in accommodation close to one another. It makes sense for all sorts of logistical reasons rather than just wanting to be close in the holding hands sense! When groups travel together overseas they are usually seated together, or in close proximity, on the flight.
The T9 weren't alone in making requests, but unlike others they made a fuss and got what they wanted. The Berrys asked for a ground-floor apartment, were told by MW that they couldn't guarantee that, and they were placed upstairs.
https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/P2/02_VOLUME_IIa_Page_334.jpg
-
The brochure doesn't mention the child listening service at OC so why would any of the party be under the impression it was available? From KM's book it doesn't seem like the group had any pre-conceived ideas about how they would spend the evenings.
That book is Kate McCann's version of events. Others describe things differently.
As far as he [MO] is concerned, he wishes at this time to add that, in conversation with DP on a date he does not recall with certainty but likely to have been on 7 or 8 May, he [DP] confided in him that that, at that time, KH had been particularly reluctant about coming to Portugal because she had had a bad feeling [presentiment] about the children of the group and the non-existence of the 'baby sitting' service.
https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/MATTHEW-OLDFIELD-10MAY.htm
-
That book is Kate McCann's version of events. Others describe things differently.
As far as he [MO] is concerned, he wishes at this time to add that, in conversation with DP on a date he does not recall with certainty but likely to have been on 7 or 8 May, he [DP] confided in him that that, at that time, KH had been particularly reluctant about coming to Portugal because she had had a bad feeling [presentiment] about the children of the group and the non-existence of the 'baby sitting' service.
https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/MATTHEW-OLDFIELD-10MAY.htm
Non verbatim twice translated
-
That book is Kate McCann's version of events. Others describe things differently.
As far as he [MO] is concerned, he wishes at this time to add that, in conversation with DP on a date he does not recall with certainty but likely to have been on 7 or 8 May, he [DP] confided in him that that, at that time, KH had been particularly reluctant about coming to Portugal because she had had a bad feeling [presentiment] about the children of the group and the non-existence of the 'baby sitting' service.
https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/MATTHEW-OLDFIELD-10MAY.htm
Well KM states in her book she did not know if such a holiday was for them in terms of the practicalities eg taking 3 children under the age of 4 to Portugal and also thought it expensive. She does however specifically state that she did not have any bad feeling/premonition about the holiday (Page 60).
The baby sitting service was available if booked in advance.
-
Well KM states in her book she did not know if such a holiday was for them in terms of the practicalities eg taking 3 children under the age of 4 to Portugal and also thought it expensive. She does however specifically state that she did not have any bad feeling/premonition about the holiday (Page 60).
The baby sitting service was available if booked in advance.
Kate had said, when I rang up, she said 'I don't know why I've just got an uneasy feeling about it'
https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/FIONA-PAYNE-ROGATORY.htm
Kate had got an uneasy feeling
https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/DAVID-PAYNE-ROGATORY.htm
-
Kate had said, when I rang up, she said 'I don't know why I've just got an uneasy feeling about it'
https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/FIONA-PAYNE-ROGATORY.htm
Kate had got an uneasy feeling
https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/DAVID-PAYNE-ROGATORY.htm
I'm not sure where we're going with this? KM acknowledges herself she had reservations about taking 3 children under the age of 4 to Portugal:
Gerry was quite keen on the Portugal idea, attracted by the sporting facilities, children's clubs and activities on offer. I was more reluctant. It wasn't that I didn't fancy the resort - and it certainly wasn't that I had some kind of premonition, because I didn't. My reservations were more practical. The holiday was quite pricey, and although Madeleine, Sean and Amelie were good travellers, I just wasn't sure that it was worth all the packing and hassle involved in flying three children under the age of four to Portugal when there were plenty of alternatives in the UK. We'd had two great breaks at Center Parcs the previous year and I was sorely tempted to stick with something similar this time. (Page 60).
-
I'm not sure where we're going with this? KM acknowledges herself she had reservations about taking 3 children under the age of 4 to Portugal:
Gerry was quite keen on the Portugal idea, attracted by the sporting facilities, children's clubs and activities on offer. I was more reluctant. It wasn't that I didn't fancy the resort - and it certainly wasn't that I had some kind of premonition, because I didn't. My reservations were more practical. The holiday was quite pricey, and although Madeleine, Sean and Amelie were good travellers, I just wasn't sure that it was worth all the packing and hassle involved in flying three children under the age of four to Portugal when there were plenty of alternatives in the UK. We'd had two great breaks at Center Parcs the previous year and I was sorely tempted to stick with something similar this time. (Page 60).
My impression of KM through reading her book is that she is someone who likes a lot of control and order. This might have come about through her being an only child. It's not meant as a criticism. We're all a product of our upbringing. But if you contrast KM's upbringing as an only child growing up in a 2/3 bed property with say GM's upbringing of 4 siblings in a 1 bed property it was very different. I would imagine for KM a smallish holiday apartment with 3 children under the age of 4 and all their paraphernalia would grate whereas for GM it would be business as usual.
-
My impression of KM through reading her book is that she is someone who likes a lot of control and order. This might have come about through her being an only child. It's not meant as a criticism. We're all a product of our upbringing. But if you contrast KM's upbringing as an only child growing up in a 2/3 bed property with say GM's upbringing of 4 siblings in a 1 bed property it was very different. I would imagine for KM a smallish holiday apartment with 3 children under the age of 4 and all their paraphernalia would grate whereas for GM it would be business as usual.
Lots if supposition...one of my sons brought up in a large house now lives on a barge and loves it
-
I'm not sure where we're going with this? KM acknowledges herself she had reservations about taking 3 children under the age of 4 to Portugal:
Gerry was quite keen on the Portugal idea, attracted by the sporting facilities, children's clubs and activities on offer. I was more reluctant. It wasn't that I didn't fancy the resort - and it certainly wasn't that I had some kind of premonition, because I didn't. My reservations were more practical. The holiday was quite pricey, and although Madeleine, Sean and Amelie were good travellers, I just wasn't sure that it was worth all the packing and hassle involved in flying three children under the age of four to Portugal when there were plenty of alternatives in the UK. We'd had two great breaks at Center Parcs the previous year and I was sorely tempted to stick with something similar this time. (Page 60).
Yep. She says she had practical concerns, no premonitions. Others say different. Take your pick.
-
The T9 weren't alone in making requests, but unlike others they made a fuss and got what they wanted. The Berrys asked for a ground-floor apartment, were told by MW that they couldn't guarantee that, and they were placed upstairs.
https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/P2/02_VOLUME_IIa_Page_334.jpg
But did T9 get exactly what they wanted? They were not all side by side on the ground floor:
Ground floor:
McCanns 5A
Oldfields 5B
JT/ROB 5D
First floor:
Paynes: 5H
-
Yep. She says she had practical concerns, no premonitions. Others say different. Take your pick.
Who says she had premonitions... Or is that a bit of poetic licence
-
Yep. She says she had practical concerns, no premonitions. Others say different. Take your pick.
It probably just boils down to perception and interpretation and tbh I don't think any of it has much, if any, relevance to MM's disappearance?
-
Lots if supposition...one of my sons brought up in a large house now lives on a barge and loves it
But that's your son not KM.
-
Lots if supposition...one of my sons brought up in a large house now lives on a barge and loves it
Is it wider than seven feet?
-
But that's your son not KM.
As you say you imagine how Kate would feel... It doesn't mean it's, anywhere near the truth
-
As you say you imagine how Kate would feel... It doesn't mean it's, anywhere near the truth
I don't recall stating it was factual. I said it was my impression.
-
I don't recall stating it was factual. I said it was my impression.
As, I said it's opinion... And may be nowhere near the truth
-
As, I said it's opinion... And may be nowhere near the truth
Well that's good.
-
I'm not sure where we're going with this? KM acknowledges herself she had reservations about taking 3 children under the age of 4 to Portugal:
Gerry was quite keen on the Portugal idea, attracted by the sporting facilities, children's clubs and activities on offer. I was more reluctant. It wasn't that I didn't fancy the resort - and it certainly wasn't that I had some kind of premonition, because I didn't. My reservations were more practical. The holiday was quite pricey, and although Madeleine, Sean and Amelie were good travellers, I just wasn't sure that it was worth all the packing and hassle involved in flying three children under the age of four to Portugal when there were plenty of alternatives in the UK. We'd had two great breaks at Center Parcs the previous year and I was sorely tempted to stick with something similar this time. (Page 60).
"
Kate had said, when I rang up, she said 'I don't know why I've just got an uneasy feeling about it'
https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/FIONA-PAYNE-ROGATORY.htm
Why would two people mention this at all?
AND why would Kate distance her self from it later in a book?
"and it certainly wasn't that I had some kind of premonition, because I didn't"
enbolden words seem to be a rebuke.
It does read like Kate knew she was going to be stuck with the organisation and childcare duties throughout the holiday, and she did take to mentioning that Gerry wasn't as much a 'hands on' dad as the other there.
I actually agree with Kate it is a huge undertaking especially if your left mostly with all the hard work! It does come across as 'Gerrys holiday' with wifie and kids on tow.
-
"
Kate had said, when I rang up, she said 'I don't know why I've just got an uneasy feeling about it'
https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/FIONA-PAYNE-ROGATORY.htm
Why would two people mention this at all?
AND why would Kate distance her self from it later in a book?
"and it certainly wasn't that I had some kind of premonition, because I didn't"
enbolden words seem to be a rebuke.
It does read like Kate knew she was going to be stuck with the organisation and childcare duties throughout the holiday, and she did take to mentioning that Gerry wasn't as much a 'hands on' dad as the other there.
I actually agree with Kate it is a huge undertaking especially if your left mostly with all the hard work! It does come across as 'Gerrys holiday' with wifie and kids on tow.
She was left behind the previous evening too. Gerry went to the Tapas with Russell;
https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/JEREMY-WILKINS.htm
-
She was left behind the previous evening too. Gerry went to the Tapas with Russell;
https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/JEREMY-WILKINS.htm
What are the words you are referring to?
-
What are the words you are referring to?
The bit where Jes says Gerry and Russell arrived at the Tapas at around 8.15.
-
The bit where Jes says Gerry and Russell arrived at the Tapas at around 8.15.
It is also worth noting that it was Kate who wasn't too keen to leave the children after that conversation with Madeleine, But Gerry took command and so it came to pass...
-
It is also worth noting that it was Kate who wasn't too keen to leave the children after that conversation with Madeleine, But Gerry took command and so it came to pass...
Her anxiety levels weren't that high imo. She left at 8.30pm and didn't return until 10pm. She has also stated publicly that she had no qualms whatsoever about leaving her children home alone.
According to her friends it was leaving the patio door unlocked that she was unsure about on 3rd. According to them it was to allow Madeleine to get out and find her parents if she and her siblings cried as they reportedly had the previous evening.
No-one ever reported that Madeleine had been instructed to do that, however. Was it really a realistic expectation? Not in my opinion, but who knows what the McCanns thought was possible and plausible.
-
Her anxiety levels weren't that high imo. She left at 8.30pm and didn't return until 10pm. She has also stated publicly that she had no qualms whatsoever about leaving her children home alone.
According to her friends it was leaving the patio door unlocked that she was unsure about on 3rd. According to them it was to allow Madeleine to get out and find her parents if she and her siblings cried as they reportedly had the previous evening.
No-one ever reported that Madeleine had been instructed to do that, however. Was it really a realistic expectation? Not in my opinion, but who knows what the McCanns thought was possible and plausible.
Victimology defines as really quite an interesting word.
Victimology- the study of the victims of crime and the psychological effects of their experience.
"specialists in victimology will gather to consider how best to help the victims of crime recover" - a mental attitude which tends to indulge and perpetuate the feeling of being a victim.
"conservatives reject victimology and the idea that state-sanctioned victim groups are entitled to compensatory privileges"
With a posting history which reflects a concentration on the dissection of the minutia of Kate McCann's existence that could be considered entirely superfluous ... you enter into the spirit of the word by recognition that Kate McCann is a victim of crime. But I think that is as far as meeting the definition goes in your posts, quite simply because in my opinion you are not in possession of the necessary information.
Interestingly the second part of the definition referring to the perpetuation of feeling like a victim is also in my opinion covered by the content of your many posts in which you use Kate as your exemplar.
Particularly when replicated by many others when in many various places on a daily basis.
Certainly an interesting word worth looking at in depth ... but I think that point may have been missed by some posters to this thread who correctly have grasped that Kate is a victim but who unfortunately exacerbate that for her.
-
I have no idea why the thread was named 'The Victimology', but the thread's creator says;
snip/
ie relationship between anyone who caused MM harm whether a stranger or those known to her.
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=11007.msg554924#msg554924
Why discussion about the meaning of the thread topic is being raised only on page 5, and that in answer to my post I can't imagine. All I was doing was continuing a discussion.
-
Her anxiety levels weren't that high imo. She left at 8.30pm and didn't return until 10pm. She has also stated publicly that she had no qualms whatsoever about leaving her children home alone.
According to her friends it was leaving the patio door unlocked that she was unsure about on 3rd. According to them it was to allow Madeleine to get out and find her parents if she and her siblings cried as they reportedly had the previous evening.
No-one ever reported that Madeleine had been instructed to do that, however. Was it really a realistic expectation? Not in my opinion, but who knows what the McCanns thought was possible and plausible.
to allow Madeleine to get out and find her parents only makes sense if Madeleine was told where she would find her parents. It is not like she had to walk and walk forever searching.
-
Her anxiety levels weren't that high imo. She left at 8.30pm and didn't return until 10pm. She has also stated publicly that she had no qualms whatsoever about leaving her children home alone.
According to her friends it was leaving the patio door unlocked that she was unsure about on 3rd. According to them it was to allow Madeleine to get out and find her parents if she and her siblings cried as they reportedly had the previous evening.
No-one ever reported that Madeleine had been instructed to do that, however. Was it really a realistic expectation? Not in my opinion, but who knows what the McCanns thought was possible and plausible.
Where are references made to the patio door left unlocked to enable MM to access her parents?
KM was adamant MM would not leave 5A by her own actions. I've no idea whether her reasons for saying this are that in her opinion MM would be unable to master the doors/gates or psychologically she would not be up for venturing out alone?
Again this is where I find T9 unreliable. I think post MM's disappearance they quickly came to understand their decision to leave their children unsupervised, all of whom were under the age of 4, was wrong in every sense of the word and went on a massive damage limitation exercise.
-
It is also worth noting that it was Kate who wasn't too keen to leave the children after that conversation with Madeleine, But Gerry took command and so it came to pass...
Where did she state this? I thought she just said on the basis of what MM said they decided to be more vigilant about making regular checks?
-
Where are references made to the patio door left unlocked to enable MM to access her parents?
KM was adamant MM would not leave 5A by her own actions. I've no idea whether her reasons for saying this are that in her opinion MM would be unable to master the doors/gates or psychologically she would not be up for venturing out alone?
Again this is where I find T9 unreliable. I think post MM's disappearance they quickly came to understand their decision to leave their children unsupervised, all of whom were under the age of 4, was wrong in every sense of the word and went on a massive damage limitation exercise.
Its primarily in Fiona's rogatory statement. Kate basically was saying Madeleine woulds have left at least a clue she had gone through the door and the gates, one of them would have been left open. But she found them all closed. OK someone else could have gone and closed them after Madeleine left.
Well that is bordering on my theory, the front door IMO had to be closed from the inside.
-
Where did she state this? I thought she just said on the basis of what MM said they decided to be more vigilant about making regular checks?
It's worth noting when this conversation with MM was first mentioned. And why.
-
to allow Madeleine to get out and find her parents only makes sense if Madeleine was told where she would find her parents. It is not like she had to walk and walk forever searching.
It clearly doesn't make sense if she wasn't given clear instructions about how to get out and where to find them. If such instructions were given then why was the idea of her leaving so vehemently rejected?
-
Where are references made to the patio door left unlocked to enable MM to access her parents?
KM was adamant MM would not leave 5A by her own actions. I've no idea whether her reasons for saying this are that in her opinion MM would be unable to master the doors/gates or psychologically she would not be up for venturing out alone?
Again this is where I find T9 unreliable. I think post MM's disappearance they quickly came to understand their decision to leave their children unsupervised, all of whom were under the age of 4, was wrong in every sense of the word and went on a massive damage limitation exercise.
A lot of things were said at various times. The conversation with her friends wasn't reported until their rog. interviews, a year after it took place.
-
Its primarily in Fiona's rogatory statement. Kate basically was saying Madeleine woulds have left at least a clue she had gone through the door and the gates, one of them would have been left open. But she found them all closed. OK someone else could have gone and closed them after Madeleine left.
Well that is bordering on my theory, the front door IMO had to be closed from the inside.
Who would be likely to close the door/gates and not then come forward to admit to doing it other than MM or her abductor?
What do you mean by the front door had to be closed from the inside?
-
It's worth noting when this conversation with MM was first mentioned. And why.
Indeed.
I found this to be quite disturbing for two reasons, maybe more, but two important ones:
1. The reason why they mention it at all- then it flounders under questioning ad hoc in intervews they seem reluctant to even discuss it and brush it off.
2.It opens the question we are discussing. why the doors on that particular evening was left unlocked, and the denial that Madeleine could have left via that route and why would she leave if not to 'confront' seek her parents.
IMO it leads to the 'staged abduction' theory- Jemmied shutters,door slamming- curtains whooshing etc
Quote from Holly "Again this is where I find T9 unreliable. I think post MM's disappearance they quickly came to understand their decision to leave their children unsupervised, all of whom were under the age of 4, was wrong in every sense of the word and went on a massive damage limitation exercise."
I agree. Hence the reason for the media offensive to get the abductor story out there first. And the PR wheels to get a good run!
-
Indeed.
I found this to be quite disturbing for two reasons, maybe more, but two important ones:
1. The reason why they mention it at all- then it flounders under questioning ad hoc in intervews they seem reluctant to even discuss it and brush it off.
2.It opens the question we are discussing. why the doors on that particular evening was left unlocked, and the denial that Madeleine could have left via that route and why would she leave if not to 'confront' seek her parents.
IMO it leads to the 'staged abduction' theory- Jemmied shutters,door slamming- curtains whooshing etc
Quote from Holly "Again this is where I find T9 unreliable. I think post MM's disappearance they quickly came to understand their decision to leave their children unsupervised, all of whom were under the age of 4, was wrong in every sense of the word and went on a massive damage limitation exercise."
I agree. Hence the reason for the media offensive to get the abductor story out there first. And the PR wheels to get a good run!
It may be that the T7 didn't fully understood what they were signing up to; the fear of being accused of simple 'child neglect' may have been compelling enough in itself to instigate a revisionism / justification exercise. It may be that the T7 were oblivious to anything more sinister playing out.
All supposition of course and all discussed in detail previously.
-
Indeed.
I found this to be quite disturbing for two reasons, maybe more, but two important ones:
1. The reason why they mention it at all- then it flounders under questioning ad hoc in intervews they seem reluctant to even discuss it and brush it off.
2.It opens the question we are discussing. why the doors on that particular evening was left unlocked, and the denial that Madeleine could have left via that route and why would she leave if not to 'confront' seek her parents.
IMO it leads to the 'staged abduction' theory- Jemmied shutters,door slamming- curtains whooshing etc
Quote from Holly "Again this is where I find T9 unreliable. I think post MM's disappearance they quickly came to understand their decision to leave their children unsupervised, all of whom were under the age of 4, was wrong in every sense of the word and went on a massive damage limitation exercise."
I agree. Hence the reason for the media offensive to get the abductor story out there first. And the PR wheels to get a good run!
Well I believe they were leaving every evening for tapas via the back/patio doors and carrying out the checks via this route. We have independent witnesses to this effect by way of PF hearing the patio doors open on 1st May when the crying ceased - crying she thought came from MM. Then we have JW on 3rd May who seems to say he thought GM had just left 5A via the steps/gate?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oFpmLwS2FEE
-
It clearly doesn't make sense if she wasn't given clear instructions about how to get out and where to find them. If such instructions were given then why was the idea of her leaving so vehemently rejected?
It is combining that with the open window and raised shutter. Madeleine wouldn't do that, so that has to be explained too.
-
Who would be likely to close the door/gates and not then come forward to admit to doing it other than MM or her abductor?
What do you mean by the front door had to be closed from the inside?
In my understanding the latch was an one that prevented the door slamming closed in a breeze. If someone went outside via the front door it would remain open unless you had a key to close it, or it was closed by someone else from the inside.
I've said this many times now.
-
Step 3a. David Payne makes the booking. This is when a very critical clock starts ticking.
Step 3b. The information on the MW booking system is more detailed than that on the Thomas Cook system, giving a 'better' breakdown of the 7 girls and 1 boy in the T9 party.
You can test this out by seeing how the 8 children would appear on the Thomas Cook system. Children under the age of two would be the same on both. Children who had already reached their second birthday would not. In the Thomas Cook system they would go into a bucket system for 2-18 year olds, their ages removed and simply replaced with the title of Master or Miss.
The McCann children were all 2+, so on TC they would have become Miss Madeleine McCann (no age), Miss Amelie McCann (no age), Master Sean McCann (no age).
Other children in the T9 group would have undergone a similar cleansing.
The menu of children available would have looked quite different.
With the MW booking in hand, OC staff with access to that system were well placed to initiate a stake-out of blocks 4, 5 and 6 and the surrounds. It is speculation, but it may explain odd characters casing the joint in the run-up to the McCanns arrival.
-
Step 3b. The information on the MW booking system is more detailed than that on the Thomas Cook system, giving a 'better' breakdown of the 7 girls and 1 boy in the T9 party.
You can test this out by seeing how the 8 children would appear on the Thomas Cook system. Children under the age of two would be the same on both. Children who had already reached their second birthday would not. In the Thomas Cook system they would go into a bucket system for 2-18 year olds, their ages removed and simply replaced with the title of Master or Miss.
The McCann children were all 2+, so on TC they would have become Miss Madeleine McCann (no age), Miss Amelie McCann (no age), Master Sean McCann (no age).
Other children in the T9 group would have undergone a similar cleansing.
The menu of children available would have looked quite different.
With the MW booking in hand, OC staff with access to that system were well placed to initiate a stake-out of blocks 4, 5 and 6 and the surrounds. It is speculation, but it may explain odd characters casing the joint in the run-up to the McCanns arrival.
I didn't know we could see the Thomas Cook bookings? I've seen the MW ones and the OC ones.
-
I didn't know we could see the Thomas Cook bookings? I've seen the MW ones and the OC ones.
From memory, the TC booking sheets are close to the MW ones in the PJ Files, I'll have a look later.
I don't know what you mean by the OC ones. So perhaps we are talking about the same thing.
-
From memory, the TC booking sheets are close to the MW ones in the PJ Files, I'll have a look later.
I don't know what you mean by the OC ones. So perhaps we are talking about the same thing.
Good Morning fellow early riser! Mark Warner used a booking system named BlueSky itour, which they implemented in 2004. Read all about it here;
http://www.blueskyts.co.uk/newsroom_preleases_mwarner.htm
So the Arrivals list is from that MW system; you can see the name of their system on the top left of each page.
https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/ARRIVALS.htm
Who could access those details isn't known, but they were MW details, not OC. When it came to getting the apartments prepared, MW took responsibilty for cot placement. Maria da Silva, the 5A cleaner, says all she was told was that 5 people were booked into the apartment. Only when MW personnel arrived with cots did she learn that children were involved. Apparently the OC placed the cots for all the other bookings, but not for MW.
https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/5A_CLEANER.htm
What the cleaner says tells me that anyone with access to the OC system would be able to see the number of children in each apartment and their ages no matter which travel agency the booking came from. As you can see, everyone appeared on the OC system together;
(https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/T/03_VOLUME_IIIa_Page_611.jpg)
-
In my understanding the latch was an one that prevented the door slamming closed in a breeze. If someone went outside via the front door it would remain open unless you had a key to close it, or it was closed by someone else from the inside.
I've said this many times now.
I agree if someone opened the front door from within it would not close in a breeze or even strong winds because the brass piece (apologies I am not familiar with the intricacies and terminology of locks) pops out. But if someone on the inside opened the door and then from outside gave the door a sharp tug or held the brass piece with a finger or some object and pulled the door releasing the finger/object at the last moment this would also close the door shut imo.
-
I agree if someone opened the front door from within it would not close in a breeze or even strong winds because the brass piece (apologies I am not familiar with the intricacies and terminology of locks) pops out. But if someone on the inside opened the door and then from outside gave the door a sharp tug or held the brass piece with a finger or some object and pulled the door releasing the finger/object at the last moment this would also close the door shut imo.
Well it could be done with a sheet of stiff plastic, but I'd think you'd lose your finger if you tried using your fingers.
-
Well it could be done with a sheet of stiff plastic, but I'd think you'd lose your finger if you tried using your fingers.
I think we're on the wrong thread! I'll catch you on the 'Front Door' thread.
-
Step 3b. The information on the MW booking system is more detailed than that on the Thomas Cook system, giving a 'better' breakdown of the 7 girls and 1 boy in the T9 party.
You can test this out by seeing how the 8 children would appear on the Thomas Cook system. Children under the age of two would be the same on both. Children who had already reached their second birthday would not. In the Thomas Cook system they would go into a bucket system for 2-18 year olds, their ages removed and simply replaced with the title of Master or Miss.
The McCann children were all 2+, so on TC they would have become Miss Madeleine McCann (no age), Miss Amelie McCann (no age), Master Sean McCann (no age).
Other children in the T9 group would have undergone a similar cleansing.
The menu of children available would have looked quite different.
With the MW booking in hand, OC staff with access to that system were well placed to initiate a stake-out of blocks 4, 5 and 6 and the surrounds. It is speculation, but it may explain odd characters casing the joint in the run-up to the McCanns arrival.
If the above happened it would be somewhat of a coincidence that the apartment a child disappeared from just happened to be unsecured. Imo MM's disappearance is based on someone either observing directly or learning second-hand that she was being left alone night after night in the unsecured apartment. The abduction might even have been justified on this basis especially given that by many accounts MM was crying for considerable periods of time.
Afaik no other holidaymaker to Portugal or elsewhere in Europe has been abducted from holiday accommodation despite all the behind the scenes paper trails perhaps indicating which accommodation contained small children. Plus you have all the creche records and daytime play groups etc, etc.
We don't know that the 'odd characters' were casing the joint or that they were would be abductors. Tannerman was thought to have been MM's abductor until he was identified as a medi doctor who was holidaying with his family.
I've found in other cases witnesses come forward after the event wanting to be helpful but in reality more often than not they just offer up red herrings.
Based on my theory/suspect(s) I don't believe any of the efits, Tannerman or Smithman have any connection with MM's disappearance.
-
If the above happened it would be somewhat of a coincidence that the apartment a child disappeared from just happened to be unsecured. Imo MM's disappearance is based on someone either observing directly or learning second-hand that she was being left alone night after night in the unsecured apartment. The abduction might even have been justified on this basis especially given that by many accounts MM was crying for considerable periods of time.
Afaik no other holidaymaker to Portugal or elsewhere in Europe has been abducted from holiday accommodation despite all the behind the scenes paper trails perhaps indicating which accommodation contained small children. Plus you have all the creche records and daytime play groups etc, etc.
We don't know that the 'odd characters' were casing the joint or that they were would be abductors. Tannerman was thought to have been MM's abductor until he was identified as a medi doctor who was holidaying with his family.
I've found in other cases witnesses come forward after the event wanting to be helpful but in reality more often than not they just offer up red herrings.
Based on my theory/suspect(s) I don't believe any of the efits, Tannerman or Smithman have any connection with MM's disappearance.
In R5 you stated "there wasn't enough time to identify, plan and execute" an abduction.
I am demonstrating that quite the opposite was true.
-
In R5 you stated "there wasn't enough time to identify, plan and execute" an abduction.
I am demonstrating that quite the opposite was true.
Only if your assumptions about the booking systems are correct, which may well not be. It's possible that the MW bookings were only visible to MW employees, and that it was an MW employee who printed off the arrivals list for the PJ. We haven't seen the Thomas Cook system, just how all bookings appeared on the OC system;
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=11007.msg555572#msg555572
-
Only if your assumptions about the booking systems are correct, which may well not be. It's possible that the MW bookings were only visible to MW employees, and that it was an MW employee who printed off the arrivals list for the PJ. We haven't seen the Thomas Cook system, just how all bookings appeared on the OC system;
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=11007.msg555572#msg555572
The OC reception says it dealt with the booking of the Payne group.
-
In R5 you stated "there wasn't enough time to identify, plan and execute" an abduction.
In R5 I stated:
The 'stolen to order' is a non-starter imo as there wasn't enough time to identify, plan and execute. Plus there haven't been any cases of young British children on holiday in Algarve 'stolen to order' since or before.
I am demonstrating that quite the opposite was true.
Since the advent of mass tourism afaik no other child holidaying in Europe has even been abducted let alone 'stolen to order' whether pre-arranged prior to arrival or not.
In the case of MM she was by all accounts home alone in an unsecured apartment from Sun - Thu eve incl. Numerous individuals were aware of this either through their own observations or learning about the situation second-hand. It surely stands to reason MM was abducted by an indiviudual(s) with this knowledge rather than 'stolen to order'.
If you believe MM was 'stolen to order' what do you believe the motive was and who placed the order and who stole her?
-
In R5 I stated:
The 'stolen to order' is a non-starter imo as there wasn't enough time to identify, plan and execute. Plus there haven't been any cases of young British children on holiday in Algarve 'stolen to order' since or before.
Since the advent of mass tourism afaik no other child holidaying in Europe has even been abducted let alone 'stolen to order' whether pre-arranged prior to arrival or not.
In the case of MM she was by all accounts home alone in an unsecured apartment from Sun - Thu eve incl. Numerous individuals were aware of this either through their own observations or learning about the situation second-hand. It surely stands to reason MM was abducted by an indiviudual(s) with this knowledge rather than 'stolen to order'.
If you believe MM was 'stolen to order' what do you believe the motive was and who placed the order and who stole her?
I have no theory.
I am simply pointing out facts.
-
The OC reception says it dealt with the booking of the Payne group.
Vitor Santos, head of accomodation and the boss of reception dealt with the booking. Normally it would have been Luis Duarte, whose job was to deal with reservations.
In my opinion that was because of Payne's insistence on a guarantee that their apartments would be close to each other.
-
In R5 I stated:
The 'stolen to order' is a non-starter imo as there wasn't enough time to identify, plan and execute. Plus there haven't been any cases of young British children on holiday in Algarve 'stolen to order' since or before.
Since the advent of mass tourism afaik no other child holidaying in Europe has even been abducted let alone 'stolen to order' whether pre-arranged prior to arrival or not.
In the case of MM she was by all accounts home alone in an unsecured apartment from Sun - Thu eve incl. Numerous individuals were aware of this either through their own observations or learning about the situation second-hand. It surely stands to reason MM was abducted by an indiviudual(s) with this knowledge rather than 'stolen to order'.
If you believe MM was 'stolen to order' what do you believe the motive was and who placed the order and who stole her?
'by all accounts home alone in an unsecured apartment from Sun - Thu eve incl.'?
Not by 'all' accounts. Gerry McCann says the apartment was locked on Sunday evening.
-
'by all accounts home alone in an unsecured apartment from Sun - Thu eve incl.'?
Not by 'all' accounts. Gerry McCann says the apartment was locked on Sunday evening.
"Beggar this for a game of soldiers" sez Gerry on Sunday night, " from now on we'll leave the sliding door open, rather than trailing round to the front door"
Purely hypothetical, of course 8)--))
-
Good Morning fellow early riser! Mark Warner used a booking system named BlueSky itour, which they implemented in 2004. Read all about it here;
http://www.blueskyts.co.uk/newsroom_preleases_mwarner.htm
So the Arrivals list is from that MW system; you can see the name of their system on the top left of each page.
https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/ARRIVALS.htm
Who could access those details isn't known, but they were MW details, not OC. When it came to getting the apartments prepared, MW took responsibilty for cot placement. Maria da Silva, the 5A cleaner, says all she was told was that 5 people were booked into the apartment. Only when MW personnel arrived with cots did she learn that children were involved. Apparently the OC placed the cots for all the other bookings, but not for MW.
https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/5A_CLEANER.htm
What the cleaner says tells me that anyone with access to the OC system would be able to see the number of children in each apartment and their ages no matter which travel agency the booking came from. As you can see, everyone appeared on the OC system together;
(https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/T/03_VOLUME_IIIa_Page_611.jpg)
I think you are partly right. There are no Thomas Cook booking details in the PJ Files, though a TC booking details system must have existed. The OC could not have managed the various travel agencies and their own direct bookings unless they fed into one point.
I remembered when you challenged this how I came to the conclusion I made about the TC system. It was yonks ago, but I ran dummy bookings online to see what I got. 2 year olds and 3 year olds went to Master and Miss. Whether that would appear on a TC booking sheet, who knows.
-
I think you are partly right. There are no Thomas Cook booking details in the PJ Files, though a TC booking details system must have existed. The OC could not have managed the various travel agencies and their own direct bookings unless they fed into one point.
I remembered when you challenged this how I came to the conclusion I made about the TC system. It was yonks ago, but I ran dummy bookings online to see what I got. 2 year olds and 3 year olds went to Master and Miss. Whether that would appear on a TC booking sheet, who knows.
Thomas Cook began to implement the same system as Mark Warner in July 2007. It should have been finished in Europe by the end of 2008, so you were probably using the same booking software as David Payne used to book the group's holidays with Mark Warner.
http://www.blueskyts.co.uk/pdf/T_W_Article002.pdf
Moving on to the Ocean Club. They say they can't guarantee a particular apartment (such as 'ground floor') will be provided. That raises the question of why not. The answer, in my opinion, is that they can't allocate an apartment in February for a holiday due to take place in May. That's because they don't own the apartments. If they allocated G5A to the McCanns in February for their holiday the owner could decide in March that she or some friends wanted it for the same week.
Therefore, in my opinion, the allocations were made as late as possible so they didn't keep having to change them. Probably the week before the holiday began. No wonder the boss had to get involved so David Payne could get what he was demanding; early apartment allocation.
-
Thomas Cook began to implement the same system as Mark Warner in July 2007. It should have been finished in Europe by the end of 2008, so you were probably using the same booking software as David Payne used to book the group's holidays with Mark Warner.
http://www.blueskyts.co.uk/pdf/T_W_Article002.pdf
Moving on to the Ocean Club. They say they can't guarantee a particular apartment (such as 'ground floor') will be provided. That raises the question of why not. The answer, in my opinion, is that they can't allocate an apartment in February for a holiday due to take place in May. That's because they don't own the apartments. If they allocated G5A to the McCanns in February for their holiday the owner could decide in March that she or some friends wanted it for the same week.
Therefore, in my opinion, the allocations were made as late as possible so they didn't keep having to change them. Probably the week before the holiday began. No wonder the boss had to get involved so David Payne could get what he was demanding; early apartment allocation.
I will get onto allocation in my next step, but for the moment, do you have any view as to why the Payne's were given 5H rather than a ground floor unit?
-
I will get onto allocation in my next step, but for the moment, do you have any view as to why the Payne's were given 5H rather than a ground floor unit?
According to the cleaner these apartments were available to the Ocean Club in block 5; A, B, C, D, H, I, K, L, M and P, and also states that when the child disappeared only apartments A, B, D, G, H and K were occupied. I don't know what size G5C was, but after that it was upstairs for them.
An extra bed was requested by the Paynes, I asssume for Dianne, but she slept on a bed settee in the end. So it could have been because 5H had a bed settee in it, which meant there was no need for another bed.
I have wondered why the O'Briens only booked a T1 plus a cot. That left their eldest child with no bed. Was the plan for their eldest daughter to sleep with her friend, the Payne's daughter? In the end, of course, the O'Briens were upgraded to a T2.
-
Allocating apartments to guests wasn't easy, because the Ocean Club didn't own them. The fact that they couldn't guarantee to have a certain type of apartment available suggests that they couldn't plan ahead. So in my opinion the allocations were done only when the staff were reasonably sure which apartments would be free at the required time.
Guests were accomodated in the apartments available, which led to an anomaly pointed out by Testusa. The Ocean Club had, according to the booking sheets, 46 T1, 151 T2, 19 T3, 1 T3F, 1 T4, 2 T3FP and T3FB. A total of 223 apartments.
How then, Textusa asks, were 63 T1 apartments occupied at times when only 46 were available? Why do certain apartments appear as T1 on one sheet and T2 on another?
The answer is simple. Guests were allocated to a 'T1' apartment if they had booked a T1 apartment, because that's what they were paying for. Sometimes they were placed in a T2, like the O'Briens, but listed as being in a T1.
http://textusa.blogspot.com/2015/05/definite-proof.html
My proof is that I know the O'Briens had two bedrooms, but they are listed as having a T1 (one bedroom) on the sheets because that's what they booked and paid for.
(https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/T/03_VOLUME_IIIa_Page_617.jpg)
-
Allocating apartments to guests wasn't easy, because the Ocean Club didn't own them. The fact that they couldn't guarantee to have a certain type of apartment available suggests that they couldn't plan ahead. So in my opinion the allocations were done only when the staff were reasonably sure which apartments would be free at the required time.
Guests were accomodated in the apartments available, which led to an anomaly pointed out by Testusa. The Ocean Club had, according to the booking sheets, 46 T1, 151 T2, 19 T3, 1 T3F, 1 T4, 2 T3FP and T3FB. A total of 223 apartments.
How then, Textusa asks, were 63 T1 apartments occupied at times when only 46 were available? Why do certain apartments appear as T1 on one sheet and T2 on another?
The answer is simple. Guests were allocated to a 'T1' apartment if they had booked a T1 apartment, because that's what they were paying for. Sometimes they were placed in a T2, like the O'Briens, but listed as being in a T1.
http://textusa.blogspot.com/2015/05/definite-proof.html
My proof is that I know the O'Briens had two bedrooms, but they are listed as having a T1 (one bedroom) on the sheets because that's what they booked and paid for.
(https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/T/03_VOLUME_IIIa_Page_617.jpg)
Those sheets are to be treated with a pinch of salt due to obvious anomalies.
The McCann party is shown as 5 adults and no children.
The Payne party also appears that way.
-
Those sheets are to be treated with a pinch of salt due to obvious anomalies.
The McCann party is shown as 5 adults and no children.
The Payne party also appears that way.
What makes you think they are being described as adults?
-
What makes you think they are being described as adults?
5 under adultos and 0 under crianças. 5 adults, no children.
-
According to the cleaner these apartments were available to the Ocean Club in block 5; A, B, C, D, H, I, K, L, M and P, and also states that when the child disappeared only apartments A, B, D, G, H and K were occupied. I don't know what size G5C was, but after that it was upstairs for them.
An extra bed was requested by the Paynes, I asssume for Dianne, but she slept on a bed settee in the end. So it could have been because 5H had a bed settee in it, which meant there was no need for another bed.
I have wondered why the O'Briens only booked a T1 plus a cot. That left their eldest child with no bed. Was the plan for their eldest daughter to sleep with her friend, the Payne's daughter? In the end, of course, the O'Briens were upgraded to a T2.
I thought they all booked and paid for 2 bed apartments apart from the Oldfields who only had 1 child under the age of 2 and she was in a cot in the parents bedroom?
-
I thought they all booked and paid for 2 bed apartments apart from the Oldfields who only had 1 child under the age of 2 and she was in a cot in the parents bedroom?
No, the O'Briens booked a one bedroomed apartment with 1 cot.
https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/P2/02_VOLUME_IIa_Page_334.jpg
-
No, the O'Briens booked a one bedroomed apartment with 1 cot.
https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/P2/02_VOLUME_IIa_Page_334.jpg
That's not the way it reads to me? 1 Bed apt for Oldfields and 2 bed apt for O'Briens?
-
5 under adultos and 0 under crianças. 5 adults, no children.
That would explain why the cleaner just knew there would be 5 occupants, but not if children were included. There are some entries under crianças, but even those are not correct. The Carpenters had 2 adults and 2 children, but the sheets say 3 adults and one child. The Weinburgers are the same. The Totman's are shown as 4 adults but 2 of them were children.
So is that the whole story or is it just that those reports were printed for one purpose; to show where the family were staying and how many 'bodies' had been booked in. Was it possible to produce different reports showing different details? It's difficult to know unless one is an expert on hotel booking systems used in Portugal.
-
That's not the way it reads to me? 1 Bed apt for Oldfields and 2 bed apt for O'Briens?
If you begin at the top of the page you will see that the type of apartment booked is above the names of the people.
The 2 bed you're seeing below the O'Brien's names actually belongs on page 2 and relates to the Payne booking.
-
If you begin at the top of the page you will see that the type of apartment booked is above the names of the people.
The 2 bed you're seeing below the O'Brien's names actually belongs on page 2 and relates to the Payne booking.
Oh yes I see, thanks. What is we're trying to achieve by reviewing the paperwork relating to the bookings?
-
Oh yes I see, thanks. What is we're trying to achieve by reviewing the paperwork relating to the bookings?
SiL posted about pre-planning, if you recall. In my opinion that wasn't necessarily possible by looking at bookings, it was apartment allocations that were significant.