UK Justice Forum 🇬🇧

Disappeared and Abducted Children and Young Adults => Madeleine McCann (3) disappeared from her parent's holiday apartment at Ocean Club, Praia da Luz, Portugal on 3 May 2007. No trace of her has ever been found. => Topic started by: Holly Goodhead on September 05, 2019, 10:20:52 AM

Title: Efits incl Smithman and Tannerman
Post by: Holly Goodhead on September 05, 2019, 10:20:52 AM
From the wit stat of Bridget O'Donnell and Jeremy Wilkins:

He then went on to explain that the children could be left with the staff during the evening and that most would be picked up before 10pm. It was not an unusual sight to see people walking through the site at night with a child in their arms asleep.

Given the above can someone please tell me the significance of 'Tannerman' and 'Smithman'?

In all probability 'Tannerman' can be written off as Dr Totman.  According to the Totmans they claim to have contacted the police long before they were contacted by MPS based on creche records.
Title: Re: Efits incl Smithman and Tannerman
Post by: Holly Goodhead on September 05, 2019, 10:21:38 AM
The 'Find Madeleine' site still features:

- Tannerman *
- Smithman
- Efit produced by Tasmin Sillence *
- Efit produced by young woman with child *
- Efit produced by Carole Anne Tranmer *
- Efit produced by ? depicting woman with short dark spiky hair. 
- Efit produced by ? depicting charity worker?
- Efit produced by ? depicting charity worker?

* Also appear in KM's book.  A couple also produced an efit which features in KM's book but is no longer on the 'Find Madeleine' site.

All efits were based on individuals observed during the day other than Tannerman, Smithman and the woman with spiky hair.

Apart from Tannerman/Dr Totman no one has come forward  suggesting the identify of the efits/sightings and/or self-eliminated.  Why? 

- Efits are figments of imaginations!?
- Efits are poor quality and do not reflect those observed
- Despite all the publicity appeals are not reaching target audience
- Some other reason(s)
Title: Re: Efits incl Smithman and Tannerman
Post by: Holly Goodhead on September 05, 2019, 10:30:24 AM
Imo (and based on my theory/suspect(s)) the above are all red herrings.  For those who believe otherwise clearly not all these individuals can be connected to MM's disappearance therefore what is it about your particular efit/theory do you believe is relevant over the others?  By this I mean some seem to place a lot of weight on the fact 'Smithman' has not come forward but how do you explain none of the others have either?   
Title: Re: Efits incl Smithman and Tannerman
Post by: G-Unit on September 05, 2019, 10:36:47 AM
Carole Tranmer saw someone leaving 5B, probably Matthew Oldfield.
Title: Re: Efits incl Smithman and Tannerman
Post by: Anthro on September 05, 2019, 10:41:12 AM
The person I find of interest to this case and currently awaiting trial in the Netherlands for the murder of NV, was able to evade police and authorities for 20 years. Even though he had been present, was asked questions etc. the following day when the child’s body was discovered.
Title: Re: Efits incl Smithman and Tannerman
Post by: Holly Goodhead on September 05, 2019, 10:53:29 AM
Carole Tranmer saw someone leaving 5B, probably Matthew Oldfield.

She claims it might have been either mid-morning or mid-afternoon.  Was MO around 5B at these times?
Title: Re: Efits incl Smithman and Tannerman
Post by: G-Unit on September 05, 2019, 11:11:01 AM
She claims it might have been either mid-morning or mid-afternoon.  Was MO around 5B at these times?

He left 5B to go to the beach after 3pm according to his wife.
https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/RACHAEL-OLDFIELD-11-MAY07.htm
Title: Re: Efits incl Smithman and Tannerman
Post by: Holly Goodhead on September 05, 2019, 11:13:52 AM
The person I find of interest to this case and currently awaiting trial in the Netherlands for the murder of NV, was able to evade police and authorities for 20 years. Even though he had been present, was asked questions etc. the following day when the child’s body was discovered.

I assume you are referring to Joseph Brech?  If so this is off-topic unless you believe he is depicted in one of the efits/sightings?  If you think there's some evidence JB was involved I can start up a new thread?
Title: Re: Efits incl Smithman and Tannerman
Post by: Holly Goodhead on September 05, 2019, 11:21:19 AM
He left 5B to go to the beach after 3pm according to his wife.
https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/RACHAEL-OLDFIELD-11-MAY07.htm

Thanks.  Does MO's wit stat/police interview corroborate with RO's in this regard?  Was this the occasion he went sailing with ROB? 
Title: Re: Efits incl Smithman and Tannerman
Post by: pathfinder73 on September 05, 2019, 11:47:21 AM
Late afternoon on 3 May 2007 Matt went sailing with Russell.

Title: Re: Efits incl Smithman and Tannerman
Post by: Holly Goodhead on September 05, 2019, 11:59:21 AM
Late afternoon on 3 May 2007 Matt went sailing with Russell.

Thanks.  Yes I just checked his rog and it seems he went sailing mid-afternoon so it was probably him who Carole Anne Tranmer observed leaving 5B in what she described as a stealthy manner.  If this is the case it was probably stealthy on the basis GO was sleeping. 
Title: Re: Efits incl Smithman and Tannerman
Post by: Holly Goodhead on September 05, 2019, 12:17:22 PM
I assume you are referring to Joseph Brech?  If so this is off-topic unless you believe he is depicted in one of the efits/sightings?  If you think there's some evidence JB was involved I can start up a new thread?

I see from the other thread you have likened the efit produced by the mother who was walking with her young child to JB.  The mother observed this guy hanging around RDM during the day.  How would he know MM was home alone every evening in the unsecured apartment?  Is there any evidence JB was in the area at the time?
Title: Re: Efits incl Smithman and Tannerman
Post by: Robittybob1 on September 05, 2019, 01:07:27 PM
Thanks.  Yes I just checked his rog and it seems he went sailing mid-afternoon so it was probably him who Carole Anne Tranmer observed leaving 5B in what she described as a stealthy manner.  If this is the case it was probably stealthy on the basis GO was sleeping.
GO?  Who's that? 
Since you ask Anthro "Is there any evidence JB was in the area at the time?", I'll ask you is there any evidence GO was sleeping at the time?
Title: Re: Efits incl Smithman and Tannerman
Post by: Holly Goodhead on September 05, 2019, 01:10:32 PM
GO?  Who's that?

Daughter of Rachael and Matthew Oldfield.  I will refrain from posting up the names of minors.
Title: Re: Efits incl Smithman and Tannerman
Post by: Robittybob1 on September 05, 2019, 01:15:50 PM
Daughter of Rachael and Matthew Oldfield.  I will refrain from posting up the names of minors.
I wish you'd spend a bit more time and write names in full.  Grace Oldfield probably is rarely mentioned on the forum.
Search for Grace Oldfield got only 1 result.  http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=7805.msg368448#msg368448
Title: Re: Efits incl Smithman and Tannerman
Post by: Holly Goodhead on September 05, 2019, 01:29:55 PM
GO?  Who's that? 
Since you ask Anthro "Is there any evidence JB was in the area at the time?", I'll ask you is there any evidence GO was sleeping at the time?

Well we don't know exactly what time CAT saw the man acting in a stealthy manner but according to MO GO was put down to sleep in the afternoon. 
Title: Re: Efits incl Smithman and Tannerman
Post by: barrier on September 05, 2019, 02:02:19 PM
What I think is significant is that the MET aren't appealing for information regarding any one.
Title: Re: Efits incl Smithman and Tannerman
Post by: Holly Goodhead on September 05, 2019, 03:40:31 PM
What I think is significant is that the MET aren't appealing for information regarding any one.

Would they normally appeal for info some 12 years after a crime has been committed? 
Title: Re: Efits incl Smithman and Tannerman
Post by: Brietta on September 05, 2019, 04:31:25 PM
I wish you'd spend a bit more time and write names in full.  Grace Oldfield probably is rarely mentioned on the forum.
Search for Grace Oldfield got only 1 result.  http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=7805.msg368448#msg368448

I'm finding it a bit tiresome having to work out what or whom the initials represent to the extent of losing interest in the post.
I was going to mention this in response to one of Holly's posts but thought instead to reinforce yours.
Call me lazy if needs be, I just find the proliferation of initials distracting. 
I think the convention is that the full wording is applied followed subsequently when mentioned by initials if they are thought necessary.
Title: Re: Efits incl Smithman and Tannerman
Post by: barrier on September 05, 2019, 04:50:11 PM
Would they normally appeal for info some 12 years after a crime has been committed?

If there was some one of interest left to be identified then yes.imo this is not the case,all players have been accounted for but its the evidence that remains lacking imo again.
Title: Re: Efits incl Smithman and Tannerman
Post by: Eleanor on September 05, 2019, 05:06:23 PM
I'm finding it a bit tiresome having to work out what or whom the initials represent to the extent of losing interest in the post.
I was going to mention this in response to one of Holly's posts but thought instead to reinforce yours.
Call me lazy if needs be, I just find the proliferation of initials distracting. 
I think the convention is that the full wording is applied followed subsequently when mentioned by initials if they are thought necessary.

I couldn't agree more.  I often don't know who anyone is talking about.

Is this laziness or an inability to spell?
Title: Re: Efits incl Smithman and Tannerman
Post by: Mr Gray on September 05, 2019, 05:12:30 PM
Well we don't know exactly what time CAT saw the man acting in a stealthy manner but according to MO GO was put down to sleep in the afternoon.

Who is MOGO
Title: Re: Efits incl Smithman and Tannerman
Post by: Holly Goodhead on September 05, 2019, 05:20:48 PM
If there was some one of interest left to be identified then yes.imo this is not the case,all players have been accounted for but its the evidence that remains lacking imo again.

Yes I guess all the efits/sightings have been accounted otherwise they would be appealing for info? 

But we know another 300k has been sanctioned by HO for OG so what exactly are they doing?  Maybe time for another thread.
Title: Re: Efits incl Smithman and Tannerman
Post by: Holly Goodhead on September 05, 2019, 05:47:06 PM
Who is MOGO

There's a space between MO and GO.
Title: Re: Efits incl Smithman and Tannerman
Post by: Robittybob1 on September 05, 2019, 08:48:10 PM
Who is MOGO
Its not MOGO but MO and GO. 
Matthew Oldfield and Grace Oldfield.
HO OG MO GO
Title: Re: Efits incl Smithman and Tannerman
Post by: Holly Goodhead on September 05, 2019, 09:29:15 PM
Its not MOGO but MO and GO. 
Matthew Oldfield and Grace Oldfield.
HO OG MO GO

Maybe we could have a thread: glossary of terms  8)-)))
Title: Re: Efits incl Smithman and Tannerman
Post by: Robittybob1 on September 05, 2019, 09:38:34 PM
Maybe we could have a thread: glossary of terms  8)-)))
Certainly PJ is well known  in fact I don't think I could spell Policia Judiciare correctly if I tried.

I was close: policia judiciaria.   Policia Judiciaria = PJ.
Title: Re: Efits incl Smithman and Tannerman
Post by: Brietta on September 05, 2019, 09:45:06 PM
Maybe we could have a thread: glossary of terms  8)-)))

I rather think not when it might be considered courteous to those of us with limited ability to decipher code just to give us a break and give us a clue who is being referred to.
For example MO could be anyone or anything (Modus Operandi) whereas M Oldfield narrows it down a bit.  Isn't it a pity also to name names when children who are now young adults are identified by name and their parents' names abbreviated or not, being bandied about by anonymous internet posters.
Title: Re: Efits incl Smithman and Tannerman
Post by: Brietta on September 05, 2019, 09:47:47 PM
Certainly PJ is well known  in fact I don't think I could spell Policia Judiciare correctly if I tried.

I was close: policia judiciaria.   Policia Judiciaria = PJ.

I think I've cracked that one, Rob.  Judicial Police is easier 😃
Title: Re: Efits incl Smithman and Tannerman
Post by: Holly Goodhead on September 05, 2019, 09:54:39 PM
I rather think not when it might be considered courteous to those of us with limited ability to decipher code just to give us a break and give us a clue who is being referred to.
For example MO could be anyone or anything (Modus Operandi) whereas M Oldfield narrows it down a bit.

The context is usually a bit of a giveaway. 

Isn't it a pity also to name names when children who are now young adults are identified by name and their parents' names abbreviated or not, being bandied about by anonymous internet posters.

Exactly that's what I said earlier about not naming minors hence GO.  Using abbreviations avoids those being referred to dragged up by search engines.  It's the way to go!   8((()*/
Title: Re: Efits incl Smithman and Tannerman
Post by: Brietta on September 05, 2019, 10:16:41 PM
The context is usually a bit of a giveaway. 

Exactly that's what I said earlier about not naming minors hence GO.  Using abbreviations avoids those being referred to dragged up by search engines.  It's the way to go!   8((()*/

Why raise their names at all?  One person's recreational activity is another person's life which they might like to get on with without continual reference to past events.
Title: Re: Efits incl Smithman and Tannerman
Post by: Robittybob1 on September 05, 2019, 10:23:13 PM
Why raise their names at all?  One person's recreational activity is another person's life which they might like to get on with without continual reference to past events.
The disappearance of Madeleine McCann is a mystery.
Title: Re: Efits incl Smithman and Tannerman
Post by: Holly Goodhead on September 05, 2019, 11:11:42 PM
Why raise their names at all? One person's recreational activity is another person's life which they might like to get on with without continual reference to past events.

For the same reasons you do. 
Title: Re: Efits incl Smithman and Tannerman
Post by: Brietta on September 05, 2019, 11:14:39 PM
The disappearance of Madeleine McCann is a mystery.
I think it has been made far more of a mystery than it needs to be.
Title: Re: Efits incl Smithman and Tannerman
Post by: Brietta on September 05, 2019, 11:15:44 PM
For the same reasons you do.
I doubt it.
Title: Re: Efits incl Smithman and Tannerman
Post by: Holly Goodhead on September 05, 2019, 11:17:08 PM
I doubt it.

What is you're doubting?
Title: Re: Efits incl Smithman and Tannerman
Post by: Brietta on September 05, 2019, 11:25:25 PM
What is you're doubting?
I am doubting that you have the slightest idea regarding my cognitive processes.
Title: Re: Efits incl Smithman and Tannerman
Post by: Robittybob1 on September 05, 2019, 11:36:06 PM
I am doubting that you have the slightest idea regarding my cognitive processes.
Well there is a challenge if there ever was one.
Title: Re: Efits incl Smithman and Tannerman
Post by: Holly Goodhead on September 05, 2019, 11:38:05 PM
I am doubting that you have the slightest idea regarding my cognitive processes.

What I do have a good idea about is that many of your posts make reference to the protagonists and others by name so why are you criticising others for doing the same?
Title: Re: Efits incl Smithman and Tannerman
Post by: Brietta on September 05, 2019, 11:44:41 PM
What I do have a good idea about is that many of your posts make reference to the protagonists and others by name so why are you criticising others for doing the same?
How do you propose I go about sanitising the ordure prevalent on the internet ... could you guarantee it would go away go away if I do?
Title: Re: Efits incl Smithman and Tannerman
Post by: G-Unit on September 06, 2019, 08:18:29 AM
The 'Find Madeleine' site still features:

- Tannerman *
- Smithman
- Efit produced by Tasmin Sillence *
- Efit produced by young woman with child *
- Efit produced by Carole Anne Tranmer *
- Efit produced by ? depicting woman with short dark spiky hair. 
- Efit produced by ? depicting charity worker?
- Efit produced by ? depicting charity worker?

* Also appear in KM's book.  A couple also produced an efit which features in KM's book but is no longer on the 'Find Madeleine' site.

All efits were based on individuals observed during the day other than Tannerman, Smithman and the woman with spiky hair.

Apart from Tannerman/Dr Totman no one has come forward  suggesting the identify of the efits/sightings and/or self-eliminated.  Why? 

- Efits are figments of imaginations!?
- Efits are poor quality and do not reflect those observed
- Despite all the publicity appeals are not reaching target audience
- Some other reason(s)

I wonder who gave Kate McCann the efit produced by Carol Tranmer?
Title: Re: Efits incl Smithman and Tannerman
Post by: Holly Goodhead on September 06, 2019, 09:13:06 AM
How do you propose I go about sanitising the ordure prevalent on the internet ... could you guarantee it would go away go away if I do?

But as moderators and users of this forum we do not need to concern ourselves with sanitising the ordure prevalent on the internet.  We only need concern ourselves with what goes on here and it is perfectly acceptable to discuss and debate the case by using the names of the main protagonists and others if we so wish whether in full or abbreviated to initials.  If some feel uncomfortable with this, whether users or guests, then I suggest they stop reading the forum.  Simple. 
Title: Re: Efits incl Smithman and Tannerman
Post by: Holly Goodhead on September 06, 2019, 10:26:02 AM
I wonder who gave Kate McCann the efit produced by Carol Tranmer?

It appears from CAT's police interview (2008) that she was first show an e-fit produced by Tasmin Sillence (TS) which the interviewing officer thought was the efit produced  by CAT in 2007 until she pointed out it wasn't.  The officer then left the room and returned with the correct efit.  So I assume CAT's police interview and the efit was all packaged up and sent to PJ all of which were made available to the public in 2008 as per Portuguese law and hence KM accessed it this way.  I guess any additional paperwork generated from her 2007 contact with the police was retained in the UK as this wasn't something PJ requested. 
Title: Re: Efits incl Smithman and Tannerman
Post by: G-Unit on September 06, 2019, 10:54:20 AM
It appears from CAT's police interview (2008) that she was first show an e-fit produced by Tasmin Sillence (TS) which the interviewing officer thought was the efit produced  by CAT in 2007 until she pointed out it wasn't.  The officer then left the room and returned with the correct efit.  So I assume CAT's police interview and the efit was all packaged up and sent to PJ all of which were made available to the public in 2008 as per Portuguese law and hence KM accessed it this way.  I guess any additional paperwork generated from her 2007 contact with the police was retained in the UK as this wasn't something PJ requested.

I can't find it in the PJ files.
Title: Re: Efits incl Smithman and Tannerman
Post by: John on September 07, 2019, 08:48:41 PM
I have removed the last posts as they were off topic. If members want to discuss forum etiquette please post in the relevant sections. TY
Title: Re: Efits incl Smithman and Tannerman
Post by: Miss Taken Identity on September 08, 2019, 01:43:31 PM
How do you propose I go about sanitising the ordure prevalent on the internet ... could you guarantee it would go away go away if I do?

Taking the thread off topic to pontficate is becoming boring.
Title: Re: Efits incl Smithman and Tannerman
Post by: Brietta on September 08, 2019, 01:57:18 PM
Taking the thread off topic to pontficate is becoming boring.
EOOIAPADWSEMS seems to be par for the course as you demonstrate in your post.
Title: Re: Efits incl Smithman and Tannerman
Post by: Miss Taken Identity on September 08, 2019, 02:57:12 PM
EOOIAPADWSEMS seems to be par for the course as you demonstrate in your post.

Back on topic...
" So I assume CAT's police interview and the efit was all packaged up and sent to PJ all of which were made available to the public in 2008 as per Portuguese law and hence KM accessed it this way."

It would be good to know for sure though...
Title: Re: Efits incl Smithman and Tannerman
Post by: Brietta on September 08, 2019, 05:43:41 PM
Back on topic...
" So I assume CAT's police interview and the efit was all packaged up and sent to PJ all of which were made available to the public in 2008 as per Portuguese law and hence KM accessed it this way."

It would be good to know for sure though...

I have removed the quote from the above post which you mistakenly assigned to me: although I do agree it leaves a lot to be desired and is not really something worth posting good the author can see what you really think.
Didn't you "like" it?
Title: Re: Efits incl Smithman and Tannerman
Post by: G-Unit on September 08, 2019, 06:24:45 PM
Back on topic...
" So I assume CAT's police interview and the efit was all packaged up and sent to PJ all of which were made available to the public in 2008 as per Portuguese law and hence KM accessed it this way."

It would be good to know for sure though...

Well I can't find it in the files. Maybe someone else can.
Title: Re: Efits incl Smithman and Tannerman
Post by: Angelo222 on September 09, 2019, 06:38:21 PM
Could we stay on topic please.
Title: Re: Efits incl Smithman and Tannerman
Post by: Holly Goodhead on October 14, 2019, 09:17:36 AM
Going off the efits we are all familiar with and the so-called 'Smithman' and 'Tannerman' sightings I was thinking about the following:

- All were observed by either lone women (or women with very small children) or couples/groups which include women.  None involve lone men or couples/groups of men?

- All were observed by British/Irish ex-pats or holidaymakers ie no Portuguese or anyone from outside UK/Eire?

Title: Re: Efits incl Smithman and Tannerman
Post by: Holly Goodhead on October 14, 2019, 10:22:37 AM
The other thing to note, to my mind anyway, is that excl 'Smithman' who looks average and Tannerman we only get a side view, the men have a menacing look about them.

We don't get 'I would describe him as attractive looking and he was wearing Lacoste tennis whites'. 

And we don't get 'He looked professional'.  Instead they are considered rogues of sorts: bogus charity collectors, beachcombers.   

So just how reliable are these efits/'sightings'?  Are they simply based on prejudice about the type of person who would abduct a small child ie the undesirables: the aesthetically challenged with pimples, large nose and described as 'ugly' to those with buck teeth along with those attempting to make a living from bogus charity collecting and beach combing? 

What about the ordinary, the physically attractive and/or those operating at the upper echelons of society?  Are these types able to slip under the radar more easily because they don't fit the idea of the archetypal child abductor?!
Title: Re: Efits incl Smithman and Tannerman
Post by: G-Unit on October 14, 2019, 10:55:09 AM
Going off the efits we are all familiar with and the so-called 'Smithman' and 'Tannerman' sightings I was thinking about the following:

- All were observed by either lone women (or women with very small children) or couples/groups which include women.  None involve lone men or couples/groups of men?

- All were observed by British/Irish ex-pats or holidaymakers ie no Portuguese or anyone from outside UK/Eire?

The other interesting fact is that the PJ don't seem to have known about many of the sightings. Statements made to UK police weren't passed on and some of those involved claimed to have been ignored by the British police.

Title: Re: Efits incl Smithman and Tannerman
Post by: barrier on October 14, 2019, 10:55:15 AM
The other thing to note, to my mind anyway, is that excl 'Smithman' who looks average and Tannerman we only get a side view, the men have a menacing look about them.

We don't get 'I would describe him as attractive looking and he was wearing Lacoste tennis whites'. 

And we don't get 'He looked professional'.  Instead they are considered rogues of sorts: bogus charity collectors, beachcombers.   

So just how reliable are these efits/'sightings'?  Are they simply based on prejudice about the type of person who would abduct a small child ie the undesirables: the aesthetically challenged with pimples, large nose and described as 'ugly' to those with buck teeth along with those attempting to make a living from bogus charity collecting and beach combing? 

What about the ordinary, the physically attractive and/or those operating at the upper echelons of society?  Are these types able to slip under the radar more easily because they don't fit the idea of the archetypal child abductor?!

Personally I wouldn't have put Robert Black nor Roy Whiting in those prejudices.
Title: Re: Efits incl Smithman and Tannerman
Post by: Holly Goodhead on October 14, 2019, 10:59:08 AM
The other interesting fact is that the PJ don't seem to have known about many of the sightings. Statements made to UK police weren't passed on and some of those involved claimed to have been ignored by the British police.

Yes I agree but was this just down to a lack of oversight and poor management of the case over different jurisdictions or something else? 
Title: Re: Efits incl Smithman and Tannerman
Post by: Holly Goodhead on October 14, 2019, 11:08:04 AM
Personally I wouldn't have put Robert Black nor Roy Whiting in those prejudices.

Well neither are oil paintings imo. 

The fact is paedophiles and those who wish to cause small children harm come in all shapes and sizes.
Title: Re: Efits incl Smithman and Tannerman
Post by: barrier on October 14, 2019, 11:23:27 AM
Well neither are oil paintings imo. 

The fact is paedophiles and those who wish to cause small children harm come in all shapes and sizes.





Yes and none of them have been to be shown to have any thing to do with Madeleine's disappearance.
Title: Re: Efits incl Smithman and Tannerman
Post by: Holly Goodhead on October 14, 2019, 11:46:35 AM



Yes and none of them have been to be shown to have any thing to do with Madeleine's disappearance.

But if MM was abducted it doesn't necessarily follow that the motive was sexual or malevolent save for the inevitable initial trauma of being separated from her family. 
Title: Re: Efits incl Smithman and Tannerman
Post by: G-Unit on October 14, 2019, 12:33:40 PM
Yes I agree but was this just down to a lack of oversight and poor management of the case over different jurisdictions or something else?

There was certainly poor management. The UK police used HOLMES and say the PJ were allowed full access to it's contents. They didn't use it though, so why wasn't that sorted out?
Title: Re: Efits incl Smithman and Tannerman
Post by: Brietta on October 14, 2019, 12:43:07 PM
The other thing to note, to my mind anyway, is that excl 'Smithman' who looks average and Tannerman we only get a side view, the men have a menacing look about them.

We don't get 'I would describe him as attractive looking and he was wearing Lacoste tennis whites'. 

And we don't get 'He looked professional'.  Instead they are considered rogues of sorts: bogus charity collectors, beachcombers.   

So just how reliable are these efits/'sightings'?  Are they simply based on prejudice about the type of person who would abduct a small child ie the undesirables: the aesthetically challenged with pimples, large nose and described as 'ugly' to those with buck teeth along with those attempting to make a living from bogus charity collecting and beach combing? 

What about the ordinary, the physically attractive and/or those operating at the upper echelons of society?  Are these types able to slip under the radar more easily because they don't fit the idea of the archetypal child abductor?!

Jane Tanner didn't think there was anything odd about the man she saw carrying a child ... her main concern at the time was for the child's bare feet.
Title: Re: Efits incl Smithman and Tannerman
Post by: Holly Goodhead on October 14, 2019, 12:49:14 PM
There was certainly poor management. The UK police used HOLMES and say the PJ were allowed full access to it's contents. They didn't use it though, so why wasn't that sorted out?

Many large organisations whether they be private or public become too unwieldy to manage properly.

The Ripper was apprehended a couple of times and released because intelligence wasn't managed properly.  Huntley should have been on the radar because of his previous but again police intelligence failed to connect.  In this case with multiple UK forces involved along with overseas it was probably only ever going to be a disaster in terms of data management.
Title: Re: Efits incl Smithman and Tannerman
Post by: The General on October 14, 2019, 12:55:32 PM
Many large organisations whether they be private or public become too unwieldy to manage properly.

The Ripper was apprehended a couple of times and released because intelligence wasn't managed properly.  Huntley should have been on the radar because of his previous but again police intelligence failed to connect.  In this case with multiple UK forces involved along with overseas it was probably only ever going to be a disaster in terms of data management.
True. I can't remember the case, but two police forces admitted lack of information sharing and poor communication cross-county led to something occurring only last week....high profile case, but not high-profile enough for me to remember the details. I was in the gym at the time, trying to sort my bluetooth headphones out, so........
Title: Re: Efits incl Smithman and Tannerman
Post by: Holly Goodhead on October 14, 2019, 01:33:33 PM
True. I can't remember the case, but two police forces admitted lack of information sharing and poor communication cross-county led to something occurring only last week....high profile case, but not high-profile enough for me to remember the details. I was in the gym at the time, trying to sort my bluetooth headphones out, so........

I like a well toned bod  8**8:/: 8(>((
Title: Re: Efits incl Smithman and Tannerman
Post by: The General on October 14, 2019, 01:41:52 PM
I like a well toned bod  8**8:/: 8(>((
There's loads of them in the gym; none of which belong to me. But then I am incorrigibly modest.
Title: Re: Efits incl Smithman and Tannerman
Post by: Anthro on October 30, 2019, 07:03:36 PM
Re. a much younger Martin Ney and Derek Flack’s e-fit. Ney has been reported as being in the Algarve in 2007, working at an evangelical church. Any thoughts?

[attachment deleted by admin]
Title: Re: Efits incl Smithman and Tannerman
Post by: Anthro on October 30, 2019, 07:06:22 PM
.

[attachment deleted by admin]
Title: Re: Efits incl Smithman and Tannerman
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on October 30, 2019, 07:16:22 PM
Very similar.
Title: Re: Efits incl Smithman and Tannerman
Post by: John on October 30, 2019, 09:10:07 PM
Good evening everyone, hope you are all well.

A gentle reminder to keep debates civil please and to refrain from making condescending or unconstructive remarks towards fellow users. TY
Title: Re: Efits incl Smithman and Tannerman
Post by: Anthro on November 09, 2019, 05:40:16 PM
To me, these two e-fits look like it might be of the same person, except the hair of course. To the left, as witnessed by Anna Stam in Amsterdam in early May 2007 (perhaps some member here knows the exact date?). To the right is the Barcelona sighting at 2:am on 7 May 2007.

[attachment deleted by admin]
Title: Re: Efits incl Smithman and Tannerman
Post by: misty on November 09, 2019, 06:56:22 PM
.

The efit on the right is an Ocean Club employee. If you would like a link I can DM it to you.
Title: Re: Efits incl Smithman and Tannerman
Post by: Anthro on November 09, 2019, 07:15:56 PM
Thank you, Misty.
Title: Re: Efits incl Smithman and Tannerman
Post by: G-Unit on November 09, 2019, 09:22:28 PM
To me, these two e-fits look like it might be of the same person, except the hair of course. To the left, as witnessed by Anna Stam in Amsterdam in early May 2007 (perhaps some member here knows the exact date?). To the right is the Barcelona sighting at 2:am on 7 May 2007.

The sketch, of course, wasn't produced until Anna Stam came to the UK (paid for by the Daily Mirror), along with a sketch of a man. The woman spoke French, the man Portuguese. The woman in Barcelona was described as Australian.
https://www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/madeleine-mccann-dossier-did-this-dutch-couple-325131
Title: Re: Efits incl Smithman and Tannerman
Post by: Anthro on November 10, 2019, 07:16:11 AM
Hi G-Unit, the woman at the Marina in Barcelona was also heard speaking Spanish to a man shortly after the businessman’s encounter with her.