UK Justice Forum 🇬🇧
Disappeared and Abducted Children and Young Adults => Madeleine McCann (3) disappeared from her parent's holiday apartment at Ocean Club, Praia da Luz, Portugal on 3 May 2007. No trace of her has ever been found. => Topic started by: Holly Goodhead on October 29, 2019, 11:09:10 AM
-
GM's testimony is arguably among the most important, if not the most important, since he was first to communicate with GNR officers at OC main reception via OC employee, Silvia Batista, who acted as an interpreter.
There's no reason to believe GNR officers didn't act on the info provided AND pass it on to others which then sets in motion a train of events.
If GM subsequently changed all or part of his testimony when there was no reason for him not to have the full facts at the time, eg whether or not he entered the apartment via the front door or patio doors at circa 9 pm this raises suspicion and would have been unhelpful to first respondents and the first phase of the investigation.
-
In my opinion the thread title is libellous and if not in itself will incite libellous posts.
-
4th May
As usual, every half hour and as the restaurant was near, the witness or his wife, would check whether the children were all right. In this way, at about 21.05 the witness came to the Club, entered the room using his respective key, the door being locked, went to his children's bedroom and checked that the twins were fine, as was Madeleine. He then went to the WC" where he remained for a few moments, left, and bumped into a person he had played tennis with and who had a child's push chair, he was also British, he had a short conversation with him, "returning after that to the restaurant.
10th May
He followed the normal route up to the rear door, which being open he only had to move [slide] it, that being the way in which he entered [was entering] the lounge, he noted that the children's bedroom door was not ajar as he had left it but half-way open, which he thought strange, having then put together the thought of MADELEINE having got up to go to sleep in his bedroom so as to avoid the noise produced [created] by her siblings. In this way he entered the children's bedroom and established visual contact with each of them, checking and is certain of this, that the three were sleeping deeply. He left the children's bedroom returning to place the door how he had already previously described, [then] going to the bathroom. Everything else was normal, the blinds, curtains and windows closed, very dark, there only being the light that came from the lounge.
----- He adds that he never entered any other part of the residence [his bedroom or the kitchen] where he was for only two or three minutes, leaving yet again through the rear door that he closed but did not lock.
-
In my opinion the thread title is libellous and if not in itself will incite libellous posts.
If such is the case, will McCann lawyers not issue a writ ?
-
10th May
Despite what he said in his previous statements, he states now and with certainty, that he left with KATE by the rear door which he consequently closed but did not lock given that that is only possible from the inside. Referring to the front door, while he is certain that it was closed it is unlikely that it was locked as [because] they had left by the rear door.
-
If such is the case, will McCann lawyers not issue a writ ?
I doubt it because its on such a small forum its unlikely to cause any serious harm to his reputation
-
10th May
He is certain that, before leaving home the children's bedroom was totally dark, with the window closed, but he does not know it was locked, the external blinds closed but with some slats open, and the curtains also drawn closed. Asked, he relates that during the night the artificial light coming in from the outside is very weak, because, without a light being on in the lounge or the kitchen, the visibility inside the bedroom is much reduced.
-
10th May
Despite what he said in his previous statements, he states now and with certainty, that he left with KATE by the rear door which he consequently closed but did not lock given that that is only possible from the inside. Referring to the front door, while he is certain that it was closed it is unlikely that it was locked as [because] they had left by the rear door.
1. those are not Gerrys actual words
2.there are no previous staements just one statement
3. There is nothing in his previous statement saying which door he left by
-
(https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/P1/01_VOLUME_Ia_Page_41.jpg)
(https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/P4/04_VOLUME_IVa_Page_903.jpg)
-
10th May
He is certain that, before leaving home the children's bedroom was totally dark, with the window closed, but he does not know it was locked, the external blinds closed but with some slats open, and the curtains also drawn closed. Asked, he relates that during the night the artificial light coming in from the outside is very weak, because, without a light being on in the lounge or the kitchen, the visibility inside the bedroom is much reduced.
KM interviewed by Piers Morgan where she describes the moment she realised MM was missing:
I just glanced at MM's bed which was by the wall and it was really dark and I couldn't quite make her out but I just kept looking for what felt like minutes thinking where is she you know. And it seems daft now because normally you'd think put the light on but its that inbuilt thing of don't wake the kids up hmmm and then I looked and realised she wasn't there.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JGuaMZF6k6g
GM describes the last time he observed MM when he carried out his circa 9 pm check:
I'd actually stuck my head around the door and I I lingered for a few seconds and thought how beautiful she was.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MvFmfW5Z1v4
1. At circa 8.30 pm GM's written testimony describes the children's room as "totally dark".
2. At circa 9.00 pm GM describes, as above, sticking his head around the door and thinking how beautiful MM was.
3. At circa 10.00 pm KM describes how the room was "really dark" she was unable to determine whether or not MM was in her bed.
If 1 and 3 are true how can 2 be true?
If 2 is true how can 1 and 3 be true?
-
GM's Testimony 10th May
At 20H35, they left the apartment in the direction of the TAPAS. Before they left and because the children's bedroom door was ajar as always, he opened it a little more, listening from the outside and, as there was complete silence he did not enter, returning the door to its previous position, with a space of about 10cm.
At 21H05 MATHEW returned, the time at which the deponent left the table to go to check how his children were.
He followed the normal route up to the rear door, which being open he only had to move [slide] it, that being the way in which he entered [was entering] the lounge, he noted that the children's bedroom door was not ajar as he had left it but half-way open, which he thought strange, having then put together the thought of MADELEINE having got up to go to sleep in his bedroom so as to avoid the noise produced [created] by her siblings. In this way he entered the children's bedroom and established visual contact with each of them, checking and is certain of this, that the three were sleeping deeply. He left the children's bedroom returning to place the door how he had already previously described, [then] going to the bathroom. Everything else was normal, the blinds, curtains and windows closed, very dark, there only being the light that came from the lounge.
KM's Testimony 4th May
At around 10 pm, the interviewee went to check on the children. She went into the apartment by the side door, which was closed but not locked, as she said before. She noticed that the door to her children's bedroom was completely open, the window was also open, the shutters raised and the curtains open, while she was certain of having closed them all as she always did.
So given MM asked on morning of 3rd May 'Why didn't you come when Sean and I cried last night' and the McCanns agreeing they needed to be extra vigilant with their checking in case one or more woke between checks why:
1. Did GM not mention to KM the bedroom door had moved which at the time he put down to MM moving about?
2. Why did GM/KM allow MO to carry out the circa 9.30 check?
3. Given 1 and 2 above why did GM/KM not brief MO about the position of the door in order to establish whether there had been any further movement of it between GM leaving and MO arriving?
4. Why did GM not mention the door moving in his testimony of 4th May?
-
KM's PB Page 82:
At breakfast time, Madeleine had a question for us. 'Why didn't you come when Sean and I cried last night?'
KM's PB Page 91:
We mentioned to the others what Madeleine had said that morning. Obviously, we didn't want any of our children waking and wondering where we were even for a few minutes, and if the chances of that happening seemed remote, it was enough of a concern to make us absolutely prompt with our checks on the kids. That is why Gerry and I were subsequently able to be so accurate about timings.
If the above is so why didn't GM let KM know after his first check that the bedroom door had moved which he put down to MM moving around? Why did they both allow MO to check at circa 9.30 pm if they thought MM might have been up and about? And why was MO oblivious to how he should find the door which GM acknowledges he used to determine whether or not MM was up and about?
-
2. Why did GM/KM allow MO to carry out the circa 9.30 check?
Now THAT is a very pertinent question, for more than one reason.
-
Now THAT is a very pertinent question, for more than one reason.
Care to elaborate? *&(+(+
-
GM's testimony is arguably among the most important, if not the most important, since he was first to communicate with GNR officers at OC main reception via OC employee, Silvia Batista, who acted as an interpreter.
There's no reason to believe GNR officers didn't act on the info provided AND pass it on to others which then sets in motion a train of events.
If GM subsequently changed all or part of his testimony when there was no reason for him not to have the full facts at the time, eg whether or not he entered the apartment via the front door or patio doors at circa 9 pm this raises suspicion and would have been unhelpful to first respondents and the first phase of the investigation.
(ty6e[
I think we can see that GM did not impart the full facts to the GNR officers as eventually told.
-
Care to elaborate? *&(+(+
Well......one theory, to which I don't necessarily subscribe, was that MO was the patsy, set up to stumble across the 'missing child'. Controversial, I know right?!
-
KM's PB Page 82:
At breakfast time, Madeleine had a question for us. 'Why didn't you come when Sean and I cried last night?'
KM's PB Page 91:
We mentioned to the others what Madeleine had said that morning. Obviously, we didn't want any of our children waking and wondering where we were even for a few minutes, and if the chances of that happening seemed remote, it was enough of a concern to make us absolutely prompt with our checks on the kids. That is why Gerry and I were subsequently able to be so accurate about timings.
If the above is so why didn't GM let KM know after his first check that the bedroom door had moved which he put down to MM moving around? Why did they both allow MO to check at circa 9.30 pm if they thought MM might have been up and about? And why was MO oblivious to how he should find the door which GM acknowledges he used to determine whether or not MM was up and about?
on the morning of Thursday May 3rd, Madeleine asked the interviewee why she had not come to look in the bedroom when the twins were crying.
https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/KATE-MCCANN.htm
on the morning of the 3rd May, when Madeleine asked the witness the reason why they had not gone to her room when the twins were crying.
https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/GERRY-MCCANN.htm
-
It seems since Holly’s interest in this case it’s been ok to accuse the McCanns of anything you like. I wonder if I can claim a refund on all the points I got for posting “libel”, most of them kindly bestowed on me by Slartibartifart.
Ditto several other protagonists. It would seem.
I see what you did there btw.
-
Ditto several other protagonists. It would seem.
I see what you did there btw.
Aargh, me and my fat fingers.
-
(ty6e[
I think we can see that GM did not impart the full facts to the GNR officers as eventually told.
You raised an extremely valid point yesterday Holly which I haven't seen posted here previously. You reminded us that Gerry McCann, in stating that he entered the apartment by the front door using a key, inadvertently or otherwise, led the first police responders to believe that Madeleine could only have left the apartment via the bedroom window.
-
He cannot say exactly, but he thinks that on Monday or Tuesday MADELEINE had slept for some time in his bedroom with KATE as she [K] had told him that one or both twins had cried making much noise.
https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/GERRY-MCCANN-10MAY.htm
When asked, he says that on one night, he cannot say which, Madeleine slept in his room in his bed. He thinks it might have been shortly after their arrival at the apartment. Madeleine came to his room saying that Amelie was crying and she couldn't sleep. He thinks that he hadn't heard crying before, and was alerted to this by Madeleine. He does not know if he or his wife comforted Amelie. That night Madeleine slept in his bed.
https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/GERRY-MCCANN-ARGUIDO.htm
So did Kate tell him about this crying, or was it Madeleine who told him? Did Madeleine sleep with him or with her mother?
-
You raised an extremely valid point yesterday Holly which I haven't seen posted here previously. You reminded us that Gerry McCann, in stating that he entered the apartment by the front door using a key, inadvertently or otherwise, led the first police responders to believe that Madeleine could only have left the apartment via the bedroom window.
Imagine the father of a missing child made an inadvertently or otherwise wrong statement to the police first responders and that led the entire police investigation off course.
Really?
-
He cannot say exactly, but he thinks that on Monday or Tuesday MADELEINE had slept for some time in his bedroom with KATE as she [K] had told him that one or both twins had cried making much noise.
https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/GERRY-MCCANN-10MAY.htm
When asked, he says that on one night, he cannot say which, Madeleine slept in his room in his bed. He thinks it might have been shortly after their arrival at the apartment. Madeleine came to his room saying that Amelie was crying and she couldn't sleep. He thinks that he hadn't heard crying before, and was alerted to this by Madeleine. He does not know if he or his wife comforted Amelie. That night Madeleine slept in his bed.
https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/GERRY-MCCANN-ARGUIDO.htm
So did Kate tell him about this crying, or was it Madeleine who told him? Did Madeleine sleep with him or with her mother?
Do you believe that NSY are asking these questions?
-
Imagine the father of a missing child made an inadvertently or otherwise wrong statement to the police first responders and that led the entire police investigation off course.
Really?
Yes really. As has been pointed out ad infinitum previously, the first hour is the golden hour in any missing child case. Giving police erroneous facts from the outset was inexcusable. In fact, one could be forgiven for thinking it was intentional.
-
Yes really. As has been pointed out ad infinitum previously, the first hour is the golden hour in any missing child case. Giving police erroneous facts from the outset was inexcusable. In fact, one could be forgiven for thinking it was intentional.
Can you explain to me the difference that Gerry's deliberate or accidental account altered the "golden hour" investigation.
-
Yes really. As has been pointed out ad infinitum previously, the first hour is the golden hour in any missing child case. Giving police erroneous facts from the outset was inexcusable. In fact, one could be forgiven for thinking it was intentional.
I agree.
John, I posted this self-same scenario in a post 2/3 years ago it was swiped as libel.
My point was: why did they not mention the unlocked door at the first instance, it would send the police off on a wrong footing- and why was the abduction via a window the only version we got told by family on TV.
I can't recall when the unlocked door was brought to the public domain. The other misleading parts were noted as; they could see the apartment as if sitting in the garden. They could only see the roof. not the children’s window, and who has a garden with a road cutting through it and a swimming pool for that matter, in the UK?
The PJ seemed to be very suspicious early on about abduction via window, and as Amaral said in his book the PJ dismissed this as a 'fake abduction scene'. I described it imo as a red herring. I stick by that opinion.
-
The difference was the Police were told about a 'missing girl' not an abducted one.
Because, why would a crowd of 'intelligent', articulate, very bloody clever people, go back to search an apartment for an abductor and MBM. Is it normal practice for abductors carrying their prey to wander around an apartment waiting to be caught?
-
I agree.
John, I posted this self-same scenario in a post 2/3 years ago it was swiped as libel.
My point was: why did they not mention the unlocked door at the first instance, it would send the police off on a wrong footing- and why was the abduction via a window the only version we got told by family on TV.
I can't recall when the unlocked door was brought to the public domain. The other misleading parts were noted as; they could see the apartment as if sitting in the garden. They could only see the roof. not the children’s window, and who has a garden with a road cutting through it and a swimming pool for that matter, in the UK?
The PJ seemed to be very suspicious early on about abduction via window, and as Amaral said in his book the PJ dismissed this as a 'fake abduction scene'. I described it imo as a red herring. I stick by that opinion.
Do you believe that NSY also see these inconsistencies ?
-
The difference was the Police were told about a 'missing girl' not an abducted one.
Because, why would a crowd of 'intelligent', articulate, very bloody clever people, go back to search an apartment for an abductor and MBM. Is it normal practice for abductors carrying their prey to wander around an apartment waiting to be caught?
My first thought was to respond to your post but after further reading and a serious attempt to decipher and respond.
Perhaps not.
-
I agree.
John, I posted this self-same scenario in a post 2/3 years ago it was swiped as libel.
My point was: why did they not mention the unlocked door at the first instance, it would send the police off on a wrong footing- and why was the abduction via a window the only version we got told by family on TV.
I can't recall when the unlocked door was brought to the public domain. The other misleading parts were noted as; they could see the apartment as if sitting in the garden. They could only see the roof. not the children’s window, and who has a garden with a road cutting through it and a swimming pool for that matter, in the UK?
The PJ seemed to be very suspicious early on about abduction via window, and as Amaral said in his book the PJ dismissed this as a 'fake abduction scene'. I described it imo as a red herring. I stick by that opinion.
Gerry McCann 4th May https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/GERRY-MCCANN.htm
"At about 21.30 his friend Matt (member of the group) went to the apartment, where his children were and on his way went to the witness' apartment, entering by means of a glass sliding door that was always unlocked and was located laterally to the building".
Locals knew the following morning the patio door was unlocked.
http://www.gerrymccannsblogs.co.uk/press/1may7/Express_05_05_2007.htm
*snipped*
Another friend, Pat Perkins, 61, said: “Gerry and Kate are fantastic parents and could see the bedroom from the hotel restaurant.
“Madeleine’s a beautiful little girl. It’s her fourth birthday soon. They were supposed to be flying home tomorrow (*proving article written on the Friday) to celebrate. We can’t believe what’s happening. We’re sat by the phone waiting to hear news. We’re all going through hell.”
Praia da Luz resident Mark McCarrick said the girl might have simply walked out of her room.
“The parents left the door ajar so they could keep going over and looking at her,” he said. “We are hoping that because the door was open, she just walked out.”
There is zero evidence Gerry told the GNR, who were the force in attendance on May 3rd, that the patio doors were locked.
-
Gerry McCann 4th May https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/GERRY-MCCANN.htm
"At about 21.30 his friend Matt (member of the group) went to the apartment, where his children were and on his way went to the witness' apartment, entering by means of a glass sliding door that was always unlocked and was located laterally to the building".
Locals knew the following morning the patio door was unlocked.
http://www.gerrymccannsblogs.co.uk/press/1may7/Express_05_05_2007.htm
*snipped*
Another friend, Pat Perkins, 61, said: “Gerry and Kate are fantastic parents and could see the bedroom from the hotel restaurant.
“Madeleine’s a beautiful little girl. It’s her fourth birthday soon. They were supposed to be flying home tomorrow (*proving article written on the Friday) to celebrate. We can’t believe what’s happening. We’re sat by the phone waiting to hear news. We’re all going through hell.”
Praia da Luz resident Mark McCarrick said the girl might have simply walked out of her room.
“The parents left the door ajar so they could keep going over and looking at her,” he said. “We are hoping that because the door was open, she just walked out.”
There is zero evidence Gerry told the GNR, who were the force in attendance on May 3rd, that the patio doors were locked. [unquote]
reply...
"At about 21.30 his friend Matt (member of the group) went to the apartment, where his children were and on his way went to the witness' apartment, entering by means of a glass sliding door that was always unlocked and was located laterally to the building".
I am sure it wasn't always unlocked as kate had a conversation asking /wondering if she did the right thing.
Locals knew the following morning the patio door was unlocked.
http://www.gerrymccannsblogs.co.uk/press/1may7/Express_05_05_2007.htm
*snipped*
Another friend, Pat Perkins, 61, said: “Gerry and Kate are fantastic parents and could see the bedroom from the hotel restaurant.
No they couldn't see the bedroom!
“Madeleine’s a beautiful little girl. It’s her fourth birthday soon. They were supposed to be flying home tomorrow (*proving article written on the Friday) to celebrate. We can’t believe what’s happening. We’re sat by the phone waiting to hear news. We’re all going through hell.”
Praia da Luz resident Mark McCarrick said the girl might have simply walked out of her room.
“The parents left the door ajar so they could keep going over and looking at her,” he said. “We are hoping that because the door was open, she just walked out.”
it is not clear which door they are talking about.
There is zero evidence Gerry told the GNR, who were the force in attendance on May 3rd, that the patio doors were locked.
I never said he did.Cross wires?
-
Do you believe that NSY also see these inconsistencies ?
Seeing them is one thing but we know their hands are tied.
-
Seeing them is one thing but we know their hands are tied.
By whom?
-
@Miss Taken Identity
I based my reply on your response to John. Please point out what I have misunderstood.
-
Gerry McCann 4th May https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/GERRY-MCCANN.htm
"At about 21.30 his friend Matt (member of the group) went to the apartment, where his children were and on his way went to the witness' apartment, entering by means of a glass sliding door that was always unlocked and was located laterally to the building".
Locals knew the following morning the patio door was unlocked.
http://www.gerrymccannsblogs.co.uk/press/1may7/Express_05_05_2007.htm
*snipped*
Another friend, Pat Perkins, 61, said: “Gerry and Kate are fantastic parents and could see the bedroom from the hotel restaurant.
“Madeleine’s a beautiful little girl. It’s her fourth birthday soon. They were supposed to be flying home tomorrow (*proving article written on the Friday) to celebrate. We can’t believe what’s happening. We’re sat by the phone waiting to hear news. We’re all going through hell.”
Praia da Luz resident Mark McCarrick said the girl might have simply walked out of her room.
“The parents left the door ajar so they could keep going over and looking at her,” he said. “We are hoping that because the door was open, she just walked out.”
There is zero evidence Gerry told the GNR, who were the force in attendance on May 3rd, that the patio doors were locked.
By telling police he walked all the way around the block to gain entry via the locked front door he inferred that the much closer patio door was locked. By the 4th May it was too late, what mattered was what he told police at 11pm on the night the child disappeared.
-
I based my reply on your response to John. Please point out what I have misunderstood.
you inserted my quote, I thought you were replying to me. cross wires.
But as it happens these witneses are 'friends'. and they offer only opinions.
-
By telling police he walked all the way around the block to gain entry via the locked front door he inferred that the much closer patio door was locked. By the 4th May it was too late, what mattered was what he told police at 11pm on the night the child disappeared.
Where have you uncovered what Gerry actually said to the GNR on night 3rd May?
-
I based my reply on your response to John. Please point out what I have misunderstood.
Why do you mess up the quoting procedure!!!! Grrr!!!!
-
you inserted my quote, I thought you were replying to me. cross wires.
But as it happens these witneses are 'friends'. and they offer only opinions.
I WAS replying to you. See my response to Angelo - how do you know what Gerry said to GNR on night 3rd in the Golden Hours?
-
Why do you mess up the quoting procedure!!!! Grrr!!!!
I posted my reply after the closed bracket....but I will go back & amend.
-
I WAS replying to you. See my response to Angelo - how do you know what Gerry said to GNR on night 3rd in the Golden Hours?
It is not the role of the GNR to investigate so I doubt if they asked Gerry what he did between 9:00 - 10:00 PM
-
I posted my reply after the closed bracket....but I will go back & amend.
I often go and tidy these situations up, but someone has put "unquote" rather than "/quote" between the square brackets.
-
I WAS replying to you. See my response to Angelo - how do you know what Gerry said to GNR on night 3rd in the Golden Hours?
LOL my apologies Misty- It got all mixed up.
I never said I KNEW or quoted GM. I was describing what they said they did upon hearing from Kate that MBM was 'missing' NOT abducted just missing.
If it was an alert of an abducted child why would they search the apartment? None of their behavour makes any sense at all.
-
It is not the role of the GNR to investigate so I doubt if they asked Gerry what he did between 9:00 - 10:00 PM
I agree. So why are some posters blaming Gerry for misleading the GNR based on a comment he allegedly made to PJ in a statement the following day?
-
I often go and tidy these situations up, but someone has put "unquote" rather than "/quote" between the square brackets.
Guilty as charged. It was me sorry. 8**8:/:
-
LOL my apologies Misty- It got all mixed up.
I never said I KNEW or quoted GM. I was describing what they said they did upon hearing from Kate that MBM was 'missing' NOT abducted just missing.
If it was an alert of an abducted child why would they search the apartment? None of their behavour makes any sense at all.
If the group hadn't all attempted to obtain the best case scenario, what would everyone's reaction have been?
-
Yes really. As has been pointed out ad infinitum previously, the first hour is the golden hour in any missing child case. Giving police erroneous facts from the outset was inexcusable. In fact, one could be forgiven for thinking it was intentional.
But the police were not fooled for a minute were they?
JOSE MANUEL OLIVEIRA
Crime reporter, 'Diario de Noticias'
Information started circulating from sources connected to the Portuguese police that the story was full of holes from the side of the McCanns and their friends. Indeed within two days of Madeleine disappearing, this crime correspondent was filing this piece in the Portuguese Daily: Diario of the Noticias: "Headline: a badly told story." We started to receive information according to which the police suspected the theory they had apprehensions, didn't believe the theory that she had been kidnapped. To conclude, the police started to suspect the parents from the word go. http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/programmes/panorama/7106086.stm
But despite having their finger on the pulse right from the word go they still managed to make a monumental screw up of actually finding out what happened to the little three year old child who should have been the focal point of their endeavours.
Could that possibly be because those suspected by the police from the word go were actually as innocent as the absolute absence of evidence against them confirmed ... and while the police were flaffing around the real criminal or criminals were confidently consolidating their position during and long after the golden hours were incompetently frittered away confident of the police inability to touch them.
-
Do you believe that NSY are asking these questions?
I'm afraid I have decided not to answer off-topic posts as I have done that recently and been the one to get told off.
-
I'm afraid I have decided not to answer off-topic posts as I have done that recently and been the one to get told off.
If you cannot reply to a question regarding your post because you consider it Off Topic ... does that mean you think your original post is Off Topic?
-
Gerry McCann 4th May https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/GERRY-MCCANN.htm
"At about 21.30 his friend Matt (member of the group) went to the apartment, where his children were and on his way went to the witness' apartment, entering by means of a glass sliding door that was always unlocked and was located laterally to the building".
Locals knew the following morning the patio door was unlocked.
http://www.gerrymccannsblogs.co.uk/press/1may7/Express_05_05_2007.htm
*snipped*
Another friend, Pat Perkins, 61, said: “Gerry and Kate are fantastic parents and could see the bedroom from the hotel restaurant.
“Madeleine’s a beautiful little girl. It’s her fourth birthday soon. They were supposed to be flying home tomorrow (*proving article written on the Friday) to celebrate. We can’t believe what’s happening. We’re sat by the phone waiting to hear news. We’re all going through hell.”
Praia da Luz resident Mark McCarrick said the girl might have simply walked out of her room.
“The parents left the door ajar so they could keep going over and looking at her,” he said. “We are hoping that because the door was open, she just walked out.”
There is zero evidence Gerry told the GNR, who were the force in attendance on May 3rd, that the patio doors were locked.
"I was aware of them swapping their arrangement at some point, because I know they had been coming, using the front door, erm, which is the door with the key, to go in and check the children."
https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/FIONA-PAYNE-ROGATORY.htm
According to Fiona the patio door wasn't always unlocked. Gerry said he used a key which suggests the patio door was locked when he checked.
-
"I was aware of them swapping their arrangement at some point, because I know they had been coming, using the front door, erm, which is the door with the key, to go in and check the children."
https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/FIONA-PAYNE-ROGATORY.htm
According to Fiona the patio door wasn't always unlocked. Gerry said he used a key which suggests the patio door was locked when he checked.
Gerry's statement of 10th May indicted he used the front door on some nights prior to May 3rd. Using the front door for some checks doesn't invalidate remarks that the patio door was always unlocked.
-
If you cannot reply to a question regarding your post because you consider it Off Topic ... does that mean you think your original post is Off Topic?
No.
-
Gerry's statement of 10th May indicted he used the front door on some nights prior to May 3rd. Using the front door for some checks doesn't invalidate remarks that the patio door was always unlocked.
Page 212 KM's PB:
It was the following evening, Sunday 3rd June - exactly a month after Madeleine's abduction - that Gerry and I opened up a little more to each other and shared some of the thoughts and anxieties that had been quietly tormenting us both; thoughts and anxieties that perhaps we hadn't felt able or ready to voice up to now.
We'd been sitting alone at the table, working at our computers. It was quiet and the lights were low. Though I can't remember how the conversation started, I'm glad it did. We'd talked through the guilt we felt about not having been in that apartment with the children; about having left the patio doors unlocked. How we found it hard to comprehend that we could have been so naive. We acknowledged the possibility that Madeleine might no longer be alive; the possibility that we might never find out what had happened to her. Would we ever be able to return to our home, the home we had shared with her? Maybe we should move elsewhere. Where? We discussed the need we felt to do our utmost to prevent this from happening to another child; to prevent another family going through what we going through. We have to ensure that something positive for someone, even if it wasn't us, came out of this horrific experience.
For me, the honest exposure of this buried poison was like lancing a boil. Admitting these secret fears and concerns, bringing them out into the open and sharing them with the only other person who was persecuted in the same way, made them suddenly a little easier to understand and to manage. Strengthened and comforted, I fell asleep that night more peacefully than I had in many days.
I think it is safe to say the McCanns were not exactly forthcoming during the all important 'golden hour' re the fact the patio doors were unlocked given that up until 3rd June they found it difficult to voice to each other.
-
Page 212 KM's PB:
It was the following evening, Sunday 3rd June - exactly a month after Madeleine's abduction - that Gerry and I opened up a little more to each other and shared some of the thoughts and anxieties that had been quietly tormenting us both; thoughts and anxieties that perhaps we hadn't felt able or ready to voice up to now.
We'd been sitting alone at the table, working at our computers. It was quiet and the lights were low. Though I can't remember how the conversation started, I'm glad it did. We'd talked through the guilt we felt about not having been in that apartment with the children; about having left the patio doors unlocked. How we found it hard to comprehend that we could have been so naive. We acknowledged the possibility that Madeleine might no longer be alive; the possibility that we might never find out what had happened to her. Would we ever be able to return to our home, the home we had shared with her? Maybe we should move elsewhere. Where? We discussed the need we felt to do our utmost to prevent this from happening to another child; to prevent another family going through what we going through. We have to ensure that something positive for someone, even if it wasn't us, came out of this horrific experience.
For me, the honest exposure of this buried poison was like lancing a boil. Admitting these secret fears and concerns, bringing them out into the open and sharing them with the only other person who was persecuted in the same way, made them suddenly a little easier to understand and to manage. Strengthened and comforted, I fell asleep that night more peacefully than I had in many days.
I think it is safe to say the McCanns were not exactly forthcoming during the all important 'golden hour' re the fact the patio doors were unlocked given that up until 3rd June they found it difficult to voice to each other.
Very strange logic if I may say so.
-
But the police were not fooled for a minute were they?
JOSE MANUEL OLIVEIRA
Crime reporter, 'Diario de Noticias'
Information started circulating from sources connected to the Portuguese police that the story was full of holes from the side of the McCanns and their friends. Indeed within two days of Madeleine disappearing, this crime correspondent was filing this piece in the Portuguese Daily: Diario of the Noticias: "Headline: a badly told story." We started to receive information according to which the police suspected the theory they had apprehensions, didn't believe the theory that she had been kidnapped. To conclude, the police started to suspect the parents from the word go. http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/programmes/panorama/7106086.stm
But despite having their finger on the pulse right from the word go they still managed to make a monumental screw up of actually finding out what happened to the little three year old child who should have been the focal point of their endeavours.
Could that possibly be because those suspected by the police from the word go were actually as innocent as the absolute absence of evidence against them confirmed ... and while the police were flaffing around the real criminal or criminals were confidently consolidating their position during and long after the golden hours were incompetently frittered away confident of the police inability to touch them.
The little three year old should also have been the focal point of her parents endeavours unfortunately she wasn't and a very devious mind(s) spotted an opportunity in the lackadaisical childcare arrangements.
Once the authorities became involved the McCanns put all the emphasis on the open window and raised shutter and were adamant MM's disappearance was an abduction. There appears to have been a downplaying of the unsecured patio doors. Given 5A showed no signs of forced entry what evidence existed at the time to support the abduction theory over any other?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0XhNk2Lz594
-
Very strange logic if I may say so.
Not really, no. I think once KM found MM missing it hit the McCanns instantly and very hard that the idea to leave the children in the unsecured apartment without any sort of adult supervision was absolute madness. Were they reticent about the unsecured patio doors due to overwhelming feelings of guilt and/or pride, fear of what others might think, embarrassment, shame etc.
-
Not really, no. I think once KM found MM missing it hit the McCanns instantly and very hard that the idea to leave the children in the unsecured apartment without any sort of adult supervision was absolute madness. Were they reticent about the unsecured patio doors due to overwhelming feelings of guilt and/or pride, fear of what others might think, embarrassment, shame etc.
That MAY be the case.. It's one explanation... So if it was... What's, the big deal... Do you think you should send letters to SY and the PJ
-
Without knowing what the McCann's were asked during their statements it is difficult to work out the confusion as to the replies.
What I think is, Gerry was asked how he left the apartment, now usually during the day Kate and the children left through the patio doors, which Gerry locked and then left through the front door, when they arrived back Gerry would unlock the front door [using his key] then unlock the patio doors for the Kate and the children to enter.
Maybe this is what Gerry was explaining [we don't know what the question was] Then noticing the discrepancy in his statement, as he was asked 'how did you leave the apartment, on the evening of the 3rd of May' he changed it to entering through the patio doors. Kate had already said this in her statement.
Remember the questions had to be translated from Portuguese to English.
-
That MAY be the case.. It's one explanation... So if it was... What's, the big deal... Do you think you should send letters to SY and the PJ
The big deal imo was a breakdown in communication which impeded the investigation during the early days.
-
Without knowing what the McCann's were asked during their statements it is difficult to work out the confusion as to the replies.
What I think is, Gerry was asked how he left the apartment, now usually during the day Kate and the children left through the patio doors, which Gerry locked and then left through the front door, when they arrived back Gerry would unlock the front door [using his key] then unlock the patio doors for the Kate and the children to enter.
Maybe this is what Gerry was explaining [we don't know what the question was] Then noticing the discrepancy in his statement, as he was asked 'how did you leave the apartment, on the evening of the 3rd of May' he changed it to entering through the patio doors. Kate had already said this in her statement.
Remember the questions had to be translated from Portuguese to English.
The witness statements afforded the McCanns the opportunity to provide investigators with as much info as possible to help determine MM's whereabouts.
I don't see the relevance of the daytime arrangements in terms of which doors were locked/unlocked and which doors the occupants left by? The McCanns knew full well what they did every eve Sun - Thu: exited via patio doors and re-entered and exited to carry out their checks.
-
The little three year old should also have been the focal point of her parents endeavours unfortunately she wasn't and a very devious mind(s) spotted an opportunity in the lackadaisical childcare arrangements.
Once the authorities became involved the McCanns put all the emphasis on the open window and raised shutter and were adamant MM's disappearance was an abduction. There appears to have been a downplaying of the unsecured patio doors. Given 5A showed no signs of forced entry what evidence existed at the time to support the abduction theory over any other?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0XhNk2Lz594
Is there anything at all in Kate McCann's paperback book which would lead you to presume that she is ignorant of the fact that the children were on their own?
Can you explain why those with devious minds perhaps lurking in the background are the fault of the families who were holidaying in the resort?
Kate makes reference in her book to the children who were subjected to assault by a stranger who had accessed the sleeping homes where they were in their beds. In what way do you suppose those parents are more blameworthy than others whose children slept safely without being subject to an evil visited upon them by one who fits your loose definition of having a 'devious mind'.
Might I remind you that the fact that a serial abuser on the loose was ridiculed much along the lines Tweedles and plummy voices et al were ridiculed when Kate's book was published.
Sorry wrong topic. Probably comes along with the territory that every topic visited is nothing but a McCann bashing exercise making one as repetitive as the next.
-
Not really, no. I think once KM found MM missing it hit the McCanns instantly and very hard that the idea to leave the children in the unsecured apartment without any sort of adult supervision was absolute madness. Were they reticent about the unsecured patio doors due to overwhelming feelings of guilt and/or pride, fear of what others might think, embarrassment, shame etc.
What evidence do you have that they were reticent about the unsecured patio doors and did not tell the police that the doors were unlocked?
-
The big deal imo was a breakdown in communication which impeded the investigation during the early days.
Explain clearly and precisely how it did that, many thanks.
-
The witness statements afforded the McCanns the opportunity to provide investigators with as much info as possible to help determine MM's whereabouts.
I don't see the relevance of the daytime arrangements in terms of which doors were locked/unlocked and which doors the occupants left by? The McCanns knew full well what they did every eve Sun - Thu: exited via patio doors and re-entered and exited to carry out their checks.
Why do you think any information the McCanns were able to supply would assist in determining Madeleine's whereabouts?
You are convinced Madeleine was abducted ??? Shouldn't finding the abductor have been the top priority ... perhaps even using the only witness statement they had instead of disregarding, ridiculing it and apparently going out of their way to disprove it?
-
Is there anything at all in Kate McCann's paperback book which would lead you to presume that she is ignorant of the fact that the children were on their own?
Can you explain why those with devious minds perhaps lurking in the background are the fault of the families who were holidaying in the resort?
Kate makes reference in her book to the children who were subjected to assault by a stranger who had accessed the sleeping homes where they were in their beds. In what way do you suppose those parents are more blameworthy than others whose children slept safely without being subject to an evil visited upon them by one who fits your loose definition of having a 'devious mind'.
Might I remind you that the fact that a serial abuser on the loose was ridiculed much along the lines Tweedles and plummy voices et al were ridiculed when Kate's book was published.
Sorry wrong topic. Probably comes along with the territory that every topic visited is nothing but a McCann bashing exercise making one as repetitive as the next.
When did this totally real, factually verified serial abuser come to light, during the holiday or after?
-
Is there anything at all in Kate McCann's paperback book which would lead you to presume that she is ignorant of the fact that the children were on their own?
Can you explain why those with devious minds perhaps lurking in the background are the fault of the families who were holidaying in the resort?
Kate makes reference in her book to the children who were subjected to assault by a stranger who had accessed the sleeping homes where they were in their beds. In what way do you suppose those parents are more blameworthy than others whose children slept safely without being subject to an evil visited upon them by one who fits your loose definition of having a 'devious mind'.
Might I remind you that the fact that a serial abuser on the loose was ridiculed much along the lines Tweedles and plummy voices et al were ridiculed when Kate's book was published.
Sorry wrong topic. Probably comes along with the territory that every topic visited is nothing but a McCann bashing exercise making one as repetitive as the next.
I don't see my posts as 'McCann bashing' rather dealing with the facts of the case objectively. The investigation into MM's disappearance might well have been hindered by the McCanns surrounding themselves with 'yes' people.
I would want to see hard data about claims of men getting into bed with children etc before making any comment.
The McCanns evening childcare arrangements were an abberation. Yes some parents do leave children in secured holiday properties but afaik they do not leave them in unsecured holiday properties. And I doubt many leave their small children night after night.
-
The witness statements afforded the McCanns the opportunity to provide investigators with as much info as possible to help determine MM's whereabouts.
I don't see the relevance of the daytime arrangements in terms of which doors were locked/unlocked and which doors the occupants left by? The McCanns knew full well what they did every eve Sun - Thu: exited via patio doors and re-entered and exited to carry out their checks.
What I am saying is Gerry could have misheard what was being asked of him.
-
What I am saying is Gerry could have misheard what was being asked of him.
'Mate, which door did you use?'. Not much room for error there, not even as a question from a stupid, Portuguese plod. Thick as mince, the lot of 'em.
-
I don't see my posts as 'McCann bashing' rather dealing with the facts of the case objectively. The investigation into MM's disappearance might well have been hindered by the McCanns surrounding themselves with 'yes' people.
I would want to see hard data about claims of men getting into bed with children etc before making any comment.
The McCanns evening childcare arrangements were an abberation. Yes some parents do leave children in secured holiday properties but afaik they do not leave them in unsecured holiday properties.
Madeleine McCann vanished from her bed in a holiday apartment well over twelve years ago. Presently her case is live and open and has followed an investigative route since 2013 which was neglected over the years since she vanished in 2007.
The only reason her case is being investigated at all is due to the unceasing efforts of her parents to have it so.
It may not be your intention to indulge in 'Mcann bashing' in your posts. But if you wish to massage each and every sceptic shibboleth from start to finish using them ... please allow me to make my own judgement about them, which really hasn't changed but has been confirmed from the early days of 'when you knew nothing'.
-
Madeleine McCann vanished from her bed in a holiday apartment well over twelve years ago. Presently her case is live and open and has followed an investigative route since 2013 which was neglected over the years since she vanished in 2007.
The only reason her case is being investigated at all is due to the unceasing efforts of her parents to have it so.
It may not be your intention to indulge in 'Mcann bashing' in your posts. But if you wish to massage each and every sceptic shibboleth from start to finish using them ... please allow me to make my own judgement about them, which really hasn't changed but has been confirmed from the early days of 'when you knew nothing'.
I said when I joined in the discussion here I wouldn't be pigeon holed into the supporter/sceptic thing which I see as immature and unhelpful in getting to the truth. My posts are based on a careful analysis of the facts as I perceive them and if 'supporters' find some or all of my posts uncomfortable reading then that's a matter for them.
-
I said when I joined in the discussion here I wouldn't be pigeon holed into the supporter/sceptic thing which I see as immature and unhelpful in getting to the truth. My posts are based on a careful analysis of the facts as I perceive them and if 'supporters' find some or all of my posts uncomfortable reading then that's a matter for them.
Are you ignoring me Holly? I've asked two perfectly pertinent and on-topic questions which you have failed to reply to. If you are then fine, just wanted to know where I stand.
-
I said when I joined in the discussion here I wouldn't be pigeon holed into the supporter/sceptic thing which I see as immature and unhelpful in getting to the truth. My posts are based on a careful analysis of the facts as I perceive them and if 'supporters' find some or all of my posts uncomfortable reading then that's a matter for them.
You post; those who may take time to read your posts assess the content accordingly and in context. I think your post above, shows you seem to be unable to examine critical analysis of what you are posting.
As a reader I can identify traits of which you appear ignorant most of which I find are inimical to the ethos of the forum. That is my opinion for what it is worth and I expect it to make not one whit of difference to the mind set in which you post.
-
I said when I joined in the discussion here I wouldn't be pigeon holed into the supporter/sceptic thing which I see as immature and unhelpful in getting to the truth. My posts are based on a careful analysis of the facts as I perceive them and if 'supporters' find some or all of my posts uncomfortable reading then that's a matter for them.
You think your posts are based on careful analysis of the facts... I think you've reached totally the wrong conclusion.
You are I'm my eyes a supporter... That means you don't think the mccanns covered up maddies disappearance.
-
I don't see my posts as 'McCann bashing' rather dealing with the facts of the case objectively. The investigation into MM's disappearance might well have been hindered by the McCanns surrounding themselves with 'yes' people.
I would want to see hard data about claims of men getting into bed with children etc before making any comment.
The McCanns evening childcare arrangements were an abberation. Yes some parents do leave children in secured holiday properties but afaik they do not leave them in unsecured holiday properties. And I doubt many leave their small children night after night.
I think your claims are, subjective not objective
-
You think your posts are based on careful analysis of the facts... I think you've reached totally the wrong conclusion.
You are I'm my eyes a supporter... That means you don't think the mccanns covered up maddies disappearance.
That has got me confused. Being a supporter is the totally wrong conclusion! I thought you too are a supporter.
-
That has got me confused. Being a supporter is the totally wrong conclusion! I thought you too are a supporter.
I didn't say being a supporter was totally the wrong conclusion but I would say hollys solid belief in her theory is totally misguided
-
You think your posts are based on careful analysis of the facts... I think you've reached totally the wrong conclusion.
You are I'm my eyes a supporter... That means you don't think the mccanns covered up maddies disappearance.
I said "my posts are based on a careful analysis of the facts as I perceive them."
The fact you think I've reached totally the wrong conclusion doesn't make it so and in any event although you might have the gist of my theory you do not have all the detail. And why are you always bringing up my theory sent to OG?
I really don't care how you and/or others here perceive me. If you perceive me as a 'supporter' so be it. I perceive myself as someone capable of independent thought and critically analysing the facts of the case as I perceive them. This whole 'sceptic' 'supporter' thing is beyond infantile and extremely unhelpful to a mature debate and discussion of the facts of the case as we perceive them.
-
I said "my posts are based on a careful analysis of the facts as I perceive them."
The fact you think I've reached totally the wrong conclusion doesn't make it so and in any event although you might have the gist of my theory you do not have all the detail. And why are you always bringing up my theory sent to OG?
I really don't care how you and/or others here perceive me. If you perceive me as a 'supporter' so be it. I perceive myself as someone capable of independent thought and critically analysing the facts of the case as I perceive them. This whole 'sceptic' 'supporter' thing is beyond infantile and extremely unhelpful to a mature debate and discussion of the facts of the case as we perceive them.
I perceive myself as highly intelligent and an ability to exmine evidence in order to reach correct conclusions...it doesnt really matter how we perceive ourselves....
The sceptic supporter is a useful...simple label. I think your reference to it being infantile is totally unimportant.
perhaps you think you are the only person able to have a mature debate...thats shows a lack of understanding...imo
-
I perceive myself as highly intelligent and an ability to exmine evidence in order to reach correct conclusions...it doesnt really matter how we perceive ourselves....
The sceptic supporter is a useful...simple label. I think your reference to it being infantile is totally unimportant.
perhaps you think you are the only person able to have a mature debate...thats shows a lack of understanding...imo
I would suggest they way we perceive ourselves is actually quite important.
If I'm a 'sceptic' or 'supporter' on this board what am I on the other boards here: Bamber, Rettendon murders, Jill Dando murder.
-
I would suggest they way we perceive ourselves is actually quite important.
If I'm a 'sceptic' or 'supporter' on this board what am I on the other boards here: Bamber, Rettendon murders, Jill Dando murder.
If you really were a mature debater you wouldn't deliberately write things to wind up some of your readers.
-
Gerry's statement of 10th May indicted he used the front door on some nights prior to May 3rd. Using the front door for some checks doesn't invalidate remarks that the patio door was always unlocked.
You would never use the front key door if the nearest back entrance was open. If Gerry said that he is talking shite! Why the patio door was locked is more interesting......
-
'Mate, which door did you use?'. Not much room for error there, not even as a question from a stupid, Portuguese plod. Thick as mince, the lot of 'em.
'Mate which door did you use' The front door during the day and the patio door at night. What was the question we don't know what or how it was said.
-
I would suggest they way we perceive ourselves is actually quite important.
If I'm a 'sceptic' or 'supporter' on this board what am I on the other boards here: Bamber, Rettendon murders, Jill Dando murder.
It might be important to ourselves... But not to others.. Then if someone perceives themselves as being highly intelligent.... And they're thick.... Then their perception doesn't matter eithet
-
If you really were a mature debater you wouldn't deliberately write things to wind up some of your readers.
Care to elucidate?
-
Care to elucidate?
What, again???
-
What, again???
Yes please.
-
If you really were a mature debater you wouldn't deliberately write things to wind up some of your readers.
Like misspelling another member's name, you mean?
-
I said when I joined in the discussion here I wouldn't be pigeon holed into the supporter/sceptic thing which I see as immature and unhelpful in getting to the truth. My posts are based on a careful analysis of the facts as I perceive them and if 'supporters' find some or all of my posts uncomfortable reading then that's a matter for them.
Well said Holly I agree. You are caught in the gray area of the supporters thinking. It is either you belive everything or nothing.
I don't have a theory, I don't know if the paernts are involved or not- i wasn't there. But just asking questions and challenging the McCanns is crime- Brenda L is testament to that.
You have indeed questioned the facts and discovered the fiction that some of us share.
-
Like misspelling another member's name, you mean?
Pardon?
-
Well said Holly I agree. You are caught in the gray area of the supporters thinking. It is either you belive everything or nothing.
I don't have a theory, I don't know if the paernts are involved or not- i wasn't there. But just asking questions and challenging the McCanns is crime- Brenda L is testament to that.
You have indeed questioned the facts and discovered the fiction that some of us share.
Hollys convinced Maddie was abducted.
-
Good evening everyone, hope you are all well.
A gentle reminder to keep debates civil please and to refrain from making condescending or unconstructive remarks towards fellow users. TY
-
None of the statements from GNR officers make reference to the patio doors.
-
The point I'm making is that the law is imprecise.. And it's a pretty pointeless discussion... So I'll leave it there
-
The point I'm making is that the law is imprecise.. And it's a pretty pointeless discussion... So I'll leave it there
No idea how the above relates to my post sandwiched between John and yourself?!
-
No idea how the above relates to my post sandwiched between John and yourself?!
It doesn't have to.
-
It doesn't have to.
Unless you are making a meal out of it.