UK Justice Forum 🇬🇧

Alleged Miscarriages of Justice => Jeremy Bamber and the callous murder of his father, mother, sister and twin nephews. Case effectively CLOSED by CCRC on basis of NO APPEAL REFERRAL. => Topic started by: Inspector Gadget on February 16, 2020, 07:08:46 PM

Title: Question to members
Post by: Inspector Gadget on February 16, 2020, 07:08:46 PM
Question to members :
Is there anyone on here who previously thought Jeremy was innocent but how now changed their mind? If so, WHY? What was it specifically that made you change your view? Was there one particular thing or piece of evidence or was it a gradual thing?

Would be very interested to hear any views.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Geordie on February 17, 2020, 10:41:52 AM
I only started recently reading the forum as a result of watching the recent drama White House Farm. I was shocked by the case all those years ago and had not kept up with the news about the appeals over the years and knew nothing of the details of the crime.

At first I assumed he was guilty because that was the verdict but had no opinion of my own based on the evidence which I knew nothing off.

However, I am now convinced beyond any reasonable doubt that he is guilty. I suppose I have studied a lot of the evidence in one go over recent weeks but it is several factors that convinced me.

01) The difficulty of Sheila carrying out the act and needing to reload the rifle at least twice.

02) The lack of congruence between someone having a psychotic episode and the efficient methodical sequence of events.

03) The lack of forensic evidence on Sheila.

04) The fact her body was moved after her death into a more horizontal position on her back.

05) The struggle in the kitchen that I am sure Sheila would not have found so easy.

06) The impossibility of Nevill making the call to Jeremy if he had been shot in the mouth.

07) The lack of credulity of Sheila committing suicide in the main bedroom.

08) Jeremy's behaviour after the murders.

I go on but it was many factors and taking the weight of the body of evidence I now find it difficult to understand how anyone could conclude Jeremy was innocent.

Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: barrier on February 17, 2020, 11:09:42 AM
I've never had much interest in the case until now,there are far more knowledgeable people on here than I can ever be concerning the case.I trust the judicial system and they have got the right perpetrator,oh I know there have been miscarriages of justice but for me at least I can't see what evidence the JB supporters can show that he didn't do it.The police initially especially Taff Jones and his superiors it seems thought murder/suicide,but thanks to the other Jones, he wasn't having it and to think that there is some how some piece of evidence kept back when his superiors thought he was on the wrong track and then have it locked away is fanciful imo.Geordie pretty much covers it for me as well.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: steve_trousers on February 17, 2020, 11:28:37 AM
I too once believed Sheila was the culprit, for many years until I became familiarised with the facts. Without doubt it was the telephone call, that I kept coming back to. Again and again and again, looking at all the details surrounding the house of cards that is the alleged telephone call. It's clearly an invention to enable him to be first on the scene and get the police to accept his narrative of the deranged sister.

Here in the real world, Nevill would clearly simply disarm Sheila had she got hold of a gun. At a stretch you can see him dialling 999, not Jeremy and certainly not leafing through the yellow pages looking for the police telephone number

Why was the bedroom telephone moved prior to the murders? it was found hidden under some newspapers in the kitchen. Because Jeremy couldn't risk Nevill dialling 999 from his bed once his sick operation was under way.

The absurdity of penthouse model Sheila duffing up a strong farmer in a life or death struggle, battering him to death without so much as breaking a fingernail.

The scene of chaos in the kitchen, with raw sugar spilled and crockery all over the floor. Yet the soles of Sheila's feet were clean as if she had just got out of bed (Jeremy's fans explain this with bubble bath before suicide)

The fiction of Sheila loosing off shots with a semi automatic rifle in the first place, reloading and the absence of forensic evidence on her, coupled with Jeremy's lame excuse about shooting bunny's and leaving the gun out the night before.

Boy racer Jeremy being overtaken by the police on his way to WHF where according to the phone call Sheila is running amok with a gun. Here in the real world Jeremy would be rushing to the scene.

The discrepancies in time between when Jeremy called Julie telling her all is going well so far, and when Jeremy claims the call was made. The time given by Julie's housemate casts further doubt
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Geordie on February 17, 2020, 12:32:38 PM
If I had to decide on the main factor it would be the lack of credulity of someone diagnosed as schizophrenic who was having a psychotic episode remaining controlled enough to reload the magazine twice while in such an extreme situation without even dropping a single bullet on the floor and not a single shot missed. I have family in the Army who have been trained and experienced combat who would find that difficult to achieve efficiently under stress.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Inspector Gadget on February 17, 2020, 12:51:12 PM
I only started recently reading the forum as a result of watching the recent drama White House Farm. I was shocked by the case all those years ago and had not kept up with the news about the appeals over the years and knew nothing of the details of the crime.

At first I assumed he was guilty because that was the verdict but had no opinion of my own based on the evidence which I knew nothing off.

However, I am now convinced beyond any reasonable doubt that he is guilty. I suppose I have studied a lot of the evidence in one go over recent weeks but it is several factors that convinced me.

01) The difficulty of Sheila carrying out the act and needing to reload the rifle at least twice.

02) The lack of congruence between someone having a psychotic episode and the efficient methodical sequence of events.

03) The lack of forensic evidence on Sheila.

04) The fact her body was moved after her death into a more horizontal position on her back.

05) The struggle in the kitchen that I am sure Sheila would not have found so easy.

06) The impossibility of Nevill making the call to Jeremy if he had been shot in the mouth.

07) The lack of credulity of Sheila committing suicide in the main bedroom.

08) Jeremy's behaviour after the murders.

I go on but it was many factors and taking the weight of the body of evidence I now find it difficult to understand how anyone could conclude Jeremy was innocent.

Very well put Geordie and agree with all of that 👍🏻👏🏻
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Eleanor on February 17, 2020, 12:55:38 PM

I still think that there is a reasonable doubt.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Inspector Gadget on February 17, 2020, 01:05:16 PM
Agree with those points too Steve.

For me I was genuinely open minded when I come into this case. I had read about his appeal and that he was innocent from his loud supporters so started studying some years back.

Looking at his police interviews was all I needed tbh. He is lying through his teeth and they aren’t even good lies. The call to Julie and local police instead of 999 is bordering on laughable. The evasive nature of answers after your family has been slaughtered was disturbing , the accuracy and stealth of the attack with a complex rifle also meant it was a skilled marksman who must have done this and the fact he was the sole inheritance to the entire estate and fortune gave him a clear motive. Although JM must have been more complicit than what she let on, she knew too many facts in her statement around the murder which even the police didn’t know which made her statement true.

Once that was established I started looking at facts around how it could have been him but it always points to why it wasn’t Sheila which, by default of his fake phone call, makes him guilty.

The lack of forensics on Sheila, the immaculate nails, feet and length of silencer made it clear to me it wasn’t her. And when you read that Nevill was 6ft4 and she was 5ft 7 it almost becomes a farce to even assume she massacred 5 people including her children and herself, with nothing but one fingerprint and a splash of blood.

Then as you say there was the circumstantial evidence like the moved phone, last one to hold the rifle , a mystery bike that appeared just before the murders giving him a means to and from the target quickly and quietly, and all of a sudden you have a huge stack of reasons why it was JB and why it couldn’t have been Sheila.

I respect people’s views but how on Earth people can protest a child killers innocence looking at the mountain of evidence against him makes me feel uncomfortable.

I truly do believe they have the right man and I hope one day he has the guts to come clean to give peace to everyone concerned.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: steve_trousers on February 17, 2020, 01:58:17 PM
A very good post Inspector, I agree wholeheartedly.

It's too easy to dismiss Mugford's testimony as a rejected woman scorned, without the facts I can understand that angle but as you say, there are too many details in her testimony and her diary which have the ring of truth about it. I would urge any new members or guests having a hard time believing her to take a closer look at her interviews and diary. Revealing insights such as "it's good that dogs can't talk"

When the lights go out at night, lying in his bunk, How Bamber must bitterly regret his actions that night, with crocodile tears on his cheeks and all. 
And he can't confide in anyone about it, he can only humour his warped followers, whom he detests for their stupidity. What a well deserved, miserable existence.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: APRIL on February 17, 2020, 02:13:55 PM
A very good post Inspector, I agree wholeheartedly.

It's too easy to dismiss Mugford's testimony as a rejected woman scorned, without the facts I can understand that angle but as you say, there are too many details in her testimony and her diary which have the ring of truth about it. I would urge any new members or guests having a hard time believing her to take a closer look at her interviews and diary. Revealing insights such as "it's good that dogs can't talk"

When the lights go out at night, lying in his bunk, How Bamber must bitterly regret his actions that night, with crocodile tears on his cheeks and all. 
And he can't confide in anyone about it, he can only humour his warped followers, whom he detests for their stupidity. What a well deserved, miserable existence.


Mmm. I'd be inclined to put it more like "It's too easy to dismiss Mugford's testimony as JUST a rejected woman scorned".................although I have no doubt that it played a big part in it. Had he put a ring on her her finger, she'd probably have kept quiet until his second affair.

I think the crocodile tears he sheds in the wee small hours are more about his bitter regrets about being caught.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: adam on February 17, 2020, 02:29:41 PM
A month after the massacre Bamber would have felt safe in treating Julie badly.

He would not expect Julie to approach the police. If she did she would not be believed as the police had nothing else. He was not aware the police were gathering other evidence.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: adam on February 17, 2020, 02:43:11 PM
Julie knowing about the lockable from outside window, put Bamber in a no win situation.

Saying he did not know about it is clearly a lie.

He could have said he knew about it & used to use it when having to enter/exit WHF when it was empty. Which would just incriminate him.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: ISpyWithMyEye on March 24, 2020, 03:50:52 PM
Julie knowing about the lockable from outside window, put Bamber in a no win situation.

Saying he did know about it is clearly a lie.

He could have said he knew about it & used to use it when having to enter/exit WHF when it was empty. Which would just incriminate him.


He also tripped up when the police told him they’d found a blade which proved it had been used to break in to the window which had been painted earlier that summer.

Jeremy knew he couldn’t deny it, so said he’d broken in to get his car documents to go to St Tropez — and that was AFTER he’d first been arrested.

But on the night he claimed he’d broken into WHF he was under 24/7 surveillance, and police knew for a fact he was in London when he claimed to have broken in to WHF.

Amazingly, that wasn’t brought up in court, but it’s on file, so if he ever wants to give an explanation as to why he lied Im sure the police will be happy to make note of it 😌
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: G-Unit on March 24, 2020, 05:02:10 PM

He also tripped up when the police told him they’d found a blade which proved it had been used to break in to the window which had been painted earlier that summer.

Jeremy knew he couldn’t deny it, so said he’d broken in to get his car documents to go to St Tropez — and that was AFTER he’d first been arrested.

But on the night he claimed he’d broken into WHF he was under 24/7 surveillance, and police knew for a fact he was in London when he claimed to have broken in to WHF.

Amazingly, that wasn’t brought up in court, but it’s on file, so if he ever wants to give an explanation as to why he lied Im sure the police will be happy to make note of it 😌

Please could you provide a link to the source of the information I have bolded.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Miss Taken Identity on March 24, 2020, 05:18:10 PM
I only started recently reading the forum as a result of watching the recent drama White House Farm. I was shocked by the case all those years ago and had not kept up with the news about the appeals over the years and knew nothing of the details of the crime.

At first I assumed he was guilty because that was the verdict but had no opinion of my own based on the evidence which I knew nothing off.

However, I am now convinced beyond any reasonable doubt that he is guilty. I suppose I have studied a lot of the evidence in one go over recent weeks but it is several factors that convinced me.

01) The difficulty of Sheila carrying out the act and needing to reload the rifle at least twice.

02) The lack of congruence between someone having a psychotic episode and the efficient methodical sequence of events.

03) The lack of forensic evidence on Sheila.

04) The fact her body was moved after her death into a more horizontal position on her back.

05) The struggle in the kitchen that I am sure Sheila would not have found so easy.

06) The impossibility of Nevill making the call to Jeremy if he had been shot in the mouth.

07) The lack of credulity of Sheila committing suicide in the main bedroom.

08) Jeremy's behaviour after the murders.

I go on but it was many factors and taking the weight of the body of evidence I now find it difficult to understand how anyone could conclude Jeremy was innocent.



Those are my sentiments also.


However, I agree with another poster who highlighted that IF JB had NOT ditched/fell out with/upset his GF then would she ever have come forward?  Having said that I do believe her testimony. In particular about the window and the latch. How could she possibly know?

I have no problem agreeing with the jury.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: ISpyWithMyEye on March 25, 2020, 01:27:30 AM
Please could you provide a link to the source of the information I have bolded.

Chapter 39 of CAL’s book

Part Quote:  DI Cook, DS Davidson & forensic scientist Brian Elliot scrutinised the downstairs shower room window and observed scratches and marks on the paintwork and brass catch ‘consistent with a thin blade having been inserted between the closely fitting sashes in an effort to force the window open’.

That same window had been freshly painted just a few months previously.

They found a blade outside tucked amongst overgrowth which bore smears of brass from the window catch, including the same paint from the window frame.

The blade was proven to belong to Jeremy.

When under caution, Jeremy admitted he’d used it, claiming he’d broken into WHF on the weekend after his release from custody, claiming he’d left his car documents at WHF.

Records proved that on that weekend — 15 and 16 September — the surveillance team placed Jeremy squarely in LONDON.

THE discrepancy didn’t come to light until some while afterwards, sparing Jeremy and his defence at trial a troubling cross-examination...

G-Unit, I’ve done that this once, but in future do your own research, then you won’t look so unknowledgeable about the true facts.

Just a suggestion
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: ISpyWithMyEye on March 25, 2020, 01:50:17 AM


Those are my sentiments also.


However, I agree with another poster who highlighted that IF JB had NOT ditched/fell out with/upset his GF then would she ever have come forward?  Having said that I do believe her testimony. In particular about the window and the latch. How could she possibly know?

I have no problem agreeing with the jury.



I absolutely agree too.

And Julie’s statements, taken over several days, proved that she knew things she couldn’t have possibly known without the killer telling her.  Besides Jeremy telling her about the window, he also told her how Nevill had fought ferociously, where Nevill lay in the kitchen, how many times Nevill was shot (although he told her it was one bullet less, or more, as he’d probably forgotten or threw her a red herring).

She also knew exactly how the twins were lying in bed, and where both June and Sheila were.  She also knew how he’d made his escape through the kitchen window, including several other details, even down to the fingerprints on the gun which concerned Jeremy...he’d dropped a glove in the violent struggle with Nevill and although he’d found it, that concerned him for some reason.

I don’t think she would have kept quiet for long, even if they hadn’t split up.  For one thing, he didn’t actually ditch her as such. Their relationship was in a terrible state for various reasons, one being she couldn’t let him touch her after the murders.  Yes, she felt hurt when he started flirting with women and then told her he wasn’t sure how he felt, but it was actually she who walked out on him. And as he’d been such a pig to her, it simply brought her revelation forward.

I believe she’d have confessed eventually, anyway. She said it was making her ill knowing he’d killed them all. At first he told her he’d hired a hitman (which is just as evil), but by detaching himself and pretending it wasn’t him who fired those bullets possibly made him seem less evil to her.

Whatever, she would have confessed eventually — he was just too arrogant to think she ever would, and he’d warned her that if she did the police wouldn’t believe her, and she’d incriminate herself.

He’s just an evil psychopath.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: adam on March 25, 2020, 04:31:30 AM
The only person I know of who changed from hardcore guilter to supporter is David.

He initially claimed he had found a forensic evidence breakthrough, but refused to say what it was.

He said he changed his mind as there was no blood on Nevill's side of the bed & found an alternative source regarding expected back splatter on the rifle nozzle if the silencer had not been used.

He says the relatives acted alone. Putting Sheila's menstural blood which was in a bucket of water,  into the silencer.

He has not said where the other evidence the relatives had no control over,  has come from.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: ISpyWithMyEye on March 25, 2020, 08:51:40 AM
The only person I know of who changed from hardcore guilter to supporter is David.

He initially claimed he had found a forensic evidence breakthrough, but refused to say what it was.

He said he changed his mind as there was no blood on Nevill's side of the bed & found an alternative source regarding expected back splatter on the rifle nozzle if the silencer had not been used.

He says the relatives acted alone. Putting Sheila's menstural blood which was in a bucket of water,  into the silencer.

He has not said where the other evidence the relatives had no control over,  has come from.


I don’t know who David is, Adam?

It’s very telling that so many of Jeremy’s few supporters eventually do a volte face after realising he is indeed guilty, yet only one person, David, has been brainwashed by Jeremy into believing he’s innocent.

ALL his supporters claim they have groundbreaking new evidence, but it never is. They never come up with anything of substance, and it’s all old evidence rehashed as “new”. And that’s why they can never reveal this “breakthrough evidence”; because it doesn’t exist.

As for there being no blood on Nevill’s side of the bed: how does that make Jeremy innocent?  All that strongly suggests is that Nevill woke up startled when Jeremy came into the room, jumped out of bed to try and tackle him by the door which resulted in them struggling on the landing — and then Jeremy probably pushed Nevill and fired four bullets into his face. Nevill obviously tried to get downstairs to either arm himself too or call 999, and that’s when the violent struggle happened in the kitchen before Jeremy shot him dead.

This “alternative source” David can’t name, who he claims found back spatter on the barrel is complete nonsense. The rifle was thoroughly tested by forensic scientists in the laboratory and there was NO back spatter in/on the barrel. So David is talking BS.

Nor did the relatives act alone: they frequently went to the police expressing their concerns, and DS Jones and his D.C. , including other police officers too, made searches of WHF and carried out other investigations and enquiries. Which is just as well, as DCI Jones refused to listen to anyone who disagreed with him; was bullying, aggressive, unstable, and seemed to lack the most basic of detective skills. Everyone agrees how sloppily he ran the case from the first few seconds, and thank goodness they got rid of him....

As for the laughable story that Sheila’s menstrual blood (which was watered down inside a bucket) was planted deep inside the silencer, in EXACTLY the same pattern that back spatter makes is impossible. Menstrual blood is not like normal blood. It doesn’t coagulate, for one thing. It also contains tissue and mucous from the uterus, has different cells, and has fewer platelets, less haemoglobin and is completely different. The forensic team would have immediately seen just by looking at it that it was menstrual blood.

So as far as David is concerned, he’s completely clueless.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: adam on March 25, 2020, 09:26:48 AM
David is on the Blue forum.

The experts said if the silencer had not been used, the rifle barrel would have had back splatter. He found an alternative source saying the rifle barrel would not produce back splatter.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: APRIL on March 25, 2020, 09:39:20 AM
David is on the Blue forum.

The experts said if the silencer had not been used, the rifle barrel would have had back splatter. He found an alternative source saying the rifle barrel would not produce back splatter.


How I long for the 'good ol' days' when experts stuck together and agreed, and we didn't dare question their decisions. As it stands, we're always going to find opposing views even when the obvious answer, ie the one WE believe, is staring us in the face.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: ISpyWithMyEye on March 25, 2020, 10:08:28 AM
David is on the Blue forum.

The experts said if the silencer had not been used, the rifle barrel would have had back splatter. He found an alternative source saying the rifle barrel would not produce back splatter.


I read ballistic experts saying back spatter would only occur if shot at by a specific close distance.

Sounds to me that whoever this so-called expert was, he was only giving an opinion...

And as David can’t name him it all sounds rather dubious
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: ISpyWithMyEye on March 25, 2020, 10:13:17 AM

How I long for the 'good ol' days' when experts stuck together and agreed, and we didn't dare question their decisions. As it stands, we're always going to find opposing views even when the obvious answer, ie the one WE believe, is staring us in the face.


All the “experts” Jeremy uses seem useless

One of his solicitor’s turned out to be a fake and ended up in prison himself 🤪

Besides, it’s been proven that the silencer was used, so none of this is even worth discussing
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: G-Unit on March 25, 2020, 10:14:40 AM
Chapter 39 of CAL’s book

Part Quote:  DI Cook, DS Davidson & forensic scientist Brian Elliot scrutinised the downstairs shower room window and observed scratches and marks on the paintwork and brass catch ‘consistent with a thin blade having been inserted between the closely fitting sashes in an effort to force the window open’.

That same window had been freshly painted just a few months previously.

They found a blade outside tucked amongst overgrowth which bore smears of brass from the window catch, including the same paint from the window frame.

The blade was proven to belong to Jeremy.

When under caution, Jeremy admitted he’d used it, claiming he’d broken into WHF on the weekend after his release from custody, claiming he’d left his car documents at WHF.

Records proved that on that weekend — 15 and 16 September — the surveillance team placed Jeremy squarely in LONDON.

THE discrepancy didn’t come to light until some while afterwards, sparing Jeremy and his defence at trial a troubling cross-examination...

G-Unit, I’ve done that this once, but in future do your own research, then you won’t look so unknowledgeable about the true facts.

Just a suggestion

Thank you.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: adam on March 25, 2020, 11:00:53 AM
Bamber said in his police interviews he knew how to get in & out of WHF through windows.

He could have just said 'yes that is my blade'. I used it when I needed to & left it near WHF'.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: ISpyWithMyEye on March 26, 2020, 10:38:46 PM
David is on the Blue forum.

The experts said if the silencer had not been used, the rifle barrel would have had back splatter. He found an alternative source saying the rifle barrel would not produce back splatter.

What “experts”?

If they actually exist, which I doubt as David can’t name them, they should know back spatter doesn’t occur unless the the rifle is on or close to the victim’s skin.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: ISpyWithMyEye on March 26, 2020, 10:57:38 PM
Bamber said in his police interviews he knew how to get in & out of WHF through windows.

He could have just said 'yes that is my blade'. I used it when I needed to & left it near WHF'.

Yes, he did indeed admit it t was his blade — he had no choice as forensics proved it was his.

But that raises more questions:

If he needed it why did he hide it? Why not keep it in his tool box?

Secondly, why did he have to break into WHF prior to him murdering his family? Why didn’t he just knock on the door?

He was the Bambers’ son and should have had a key, but Nevill didn’t give him one — and there’s a reason for that. Nevill obviously didn’t trust Jeremy and knew he was a thief. The Bambers’ were respectable and tried to protect their children from local gossip, so you can almost guarantee Jeremy did many things that Nevill and June tried to hush up.

He probably stole cash frequently, and he snooped. He’d searched through Nevill and June’s private papers and read their wills  — he unwittingly admitted that when he told police what was in their wills. One needs to ask why he had such an interest in their wills, enough to search for them and read them...
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: adam on March 27, 2020, 12:01:07 PM

I don’t know who David is, Adam?

It’s very telling that so many of Jeremy’s few supporters eventually do a volte face after realising he is indeed guilty, yet only one person, David, has been brainwashed by Jeremy into believing he’s innocent.

ALL his supporters claim they have groundbreaking new evidence, but it never is. They never come up with anything of substance, and it’s all old evidence rehashed as “new”. And that’s why they can never reveal this “breakthrough evidence”; because it doesn’t exist.

As for there being no blood on Nevill’s side of the bed: how does that make Jeremy innocent?  All that strongly suggests is that Nevill woke up startled when Jeremy came into the room, jumped out of bed to try and tackle him by the door which resulted in them struggling on the landing — and then Jeremy probably pushed Nevill and fired four bullets into his face. Nevill obviously tried to get downstairs to either arm himself too or call 999, and that’s when the violent struggle happened in the kitchen before Jeremy shot him dead.

This “alternative source” David can’t name, who he claims found back spatter on the barrel is complete nonsense. The rifle was thoroughly tested by forensic scientists in the laboratory and there was NO back spatter in/on the barrel. So David is talking BS.

Nor did the relatives act alone: they frequently went to the police expressing their concerns, and DS Jones and his D.C. , including other police officers too, made searches of WHF and carried out other investigations and enquiries. Which is just as well, as DCI Jones refused to listen to anyone who disagreed with him; was bullying, aggressive, unstable, and seemed to lack the most basic of detective skills. Everyone agrees how sloppily he ran the case from the first few seconds, and thank goodness they got rid of him....

As for the laughable story that Sheila’s menstrual blood (which was watered down inside a bucket) was planted deep inside the silencer, in EXACTLY the same pattern that back spatter makes is impossible. Menstrual blood is not like normal blood. It doesn’t coagulate, for one thing. It also contains tissue and mucous from the uterus, has different cells, and has fewer platelets, less haemoglobin and is completely different. The forensic team would have immediately seen just by looking at it that it was menstrual blood.

So as far as David is concerned, he’s completely clueless.

You would find the Blue forum very interesting. David, Mike, Lookout & Nugs have very interesting theories on why Jeremy is innocent. There are also some guilters.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Myster on March 27, 2020, 12:19:59 PM
I doubt it.  He'd be bored stiff arguing with the clueless.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: ISpyWithMyEye on March 27, 2020, 01:32:21 PM
You would find the Blue forum very interesting. David, Mike, Lookout & Nugs have very interesting theories on why Jeremy is innocent. There are also some guilters.


What is the name of the Blue forum, please?
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Myster on March 27, 2020, 01:34:56 PM

What is the name of the Blue forum, please?
https://jeremybamberforum.co.uk/index.php (https://jeremybamberforum.co.uk/index.php)
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: adam on March 27, 2020, 02:04:20 PM
I doubt it.  He'd be bored stiff arguing with the clueless.

Maybe Ispywithmybigeye will change stance.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: mrswah on March 27, 2020, 08:35:11 PM
Maybe Ispywithmybigeye will change stance.


Now, that would be hilarious!
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: adam on March 27, 2020, 10:41:12 PM
Scipio did not change stance. But you never know.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: ISpyWithMyEye on March 28, 2020, 04:38:49 AM
 (&^& (&^&
Maybe Ispywithmybigeye will change stance.

 (&^& (&^& (&^&
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: barrier on March 28, 2020, 09:11:53 AM
https://jeremybamberforum.co.uk/index.php (https://jeremybamberforum.co.uk/index.php)

I clicked on the link out of interest,got a warning not to proceed cause it ain't secure and passwords and the like could be half inched.

Warning: Potential Security Risk Ahead

Firefox detected a potential security threat and did not continue to jeremybamberforum.co.uk. If you visit this site, attackers could try to steal information like your passwords, emails, or credit card details.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: adam on March 28, 2020, 09:25:28 AM
G-Unit joined recently. So the forum must be open for newbies.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Myster on March 28, 2020, 09:28:35 AM
I clicked on the link out of interest,got a warning not to proceed cause it ain't secure and passwords and the like could be half inched.

Warning: Potential Security Risk Ahead

Firefox detected a potential security threat and did not continue to jeremybamberforum.co.uk. If you visit this site, attackers could try to steal information like your passwords, emails, or credit card details.

I've just clicked on it without any problem.  ISWMBE probably did the same and hasn't reported any either.  The site owner might not have updated security signatures or maybe your browser is being extra cautious.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: G-Unit on March 28, 2020, 11:00:44 AM
G-Unit joined recently. So the forum must be open for newbies.

It's 'not secure', but so is this forum.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Caroline on March 28, 2020, 12:44:53 PM
It's 'not secure', but so is this forum.

You intending on making a payment?  @)(++(*
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: ISpyWithMyEye on March 28, 2020, 07:03:46 PM
I've just clicked on it without any problem.  ISWMBE probably did the same and hasn't reported any either.  The site owner might not have updated security signatures or maybe your browser is being extra cautious.


Actually, I clicked on the long at two different times, and both times nothing came up

Maybe it’s my browser or maybe their site has a glitch? Oh dear. :)
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Myster on March 28, 2020, 07:14:14 PM

Actually, I clicked on the long at two different times, and both times nothing came up

Maybe it’s my browser or maybe their site has a glitch? Oh dear. :)
Try the following google link, click on the top entry. It works for me in Firefox...

https://www.google.com/search?client=firefox-b-d&q=jeremy+bamber+forum (https://www.google.com/search?client=firefox-b-d&q=jeremy+bamber+forum)
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: ISpyWithMyEye on March 28, 2020, 08:38:48 PM
Try the following google link, click on the top entry. It works for me in Firefox...

https://www.google.com/search?client=firefox-b-d&q=jeremy+bamber+forum (https://www.google.com/search?client=firefox-b-d&q=jeremy+bamber+forum)

Thank you:)
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Caroline on March 28, 2020, 08:47:47 PM
I clicked on the link out of interest,got a warning not to proceed cause it ain't secure and passwords and the like could be half inched.

Warning: Potential Security Risk Ahead

Firefox detected a potential security threat and did not continue to jeremybamberforum.co.uk. If you visit this site, attackers could try to steal information like your passwords, emails, or credit card details.


Don't worry about it, it's perfectly safe. Just needs an updated certificate. This site also has 'not secure' in the address bar.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: ISpyWithMyEye on March 28, 2020, 08:47:58 PM
Wow, there’s lots of other sites discussing him too, no doubt all started by his “team”

It’s quite depressing to realise we have some really thick people in this country  ^*&&

I suspect many of them weren’t even born when it happened, or were too young to remember, and know zilch about the facts. They’ve certainly not read any books or even glanced at the court documents

They just go by the rubbish his team spout online, and take it as fact &^^&*
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Caroline on March 28, 2020, 08:50:32 PM
I've just clicked on it without any problem.  ISWMBE probably did the same and hasn't reported any either.  The site owner might not have updated security signatures or maybe your browser is being extra cautious.

It needs an updated certificate. I got half way to updating but the help desk are useless. Now I have time on my hands I'll sort it out. IT's perfectly safe though.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Caroline on March 28, 2020, 09:36:49 PM
Wow, there’s lots of other sites discussing him too, no doubt all started by his “team”

It’s quite depressing to realise we have some really thick people in this country  ^*&&

I suspect many of them weren’t even born when it happened, or were too young to remember, and know zilch about the facts. They’ve certainly not read any books or even glanced at the court documents

They just go by the rubbish his team spout online, and take it as fact &^^&*

Not all do Ispy - I was pretty young when it happened, I remember it but not in any great detail and it wasn't in my area. I became interested when I watched Crimes That Shook Britain and thought there was a chance he could be innocent and was fooled for a while (although never felt compelled to join in any campaign). However, I was uneasy about the phone call but other things seemed (on the surface) as though there might be something in them. However, it didn't take long to realise it was all smoke and mirrors. I wrote to Bamber for a while - he helped me make up my mind!

I have read most of the books/statements/documents and transcripts.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: mrswah on March 28, 2020, 10:45:21 PM
Wow, there’s lots of other sites discussing him too, no doubt all started by his “team”

It’s quite depressing to realise we have some really thick people in this country  ^*&&

I suspect many of them weren’t even born when it happened, or were too young to remember, and know zilch about the facts. They’ve certainly not read any books or even glanced at the court documents

They just go by the rubbish his team spout online, and take it as fact &^^&*


No, definitely not ALL started by his team.

I have discussed the case on a couple of other sites, and neither were run by his campaign team.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Caroline on March 28, 2020, 11:09:58 PM

No, definitely not ALL started by his team.

I have discussed the case on a couple of other sites, and neither were run by his campaign team.

The blue forum isn't run by the CT either. They don't like to engage in dialogue which is why you can even comment on those silly video's they make on Youtube.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: ISpyWithMyEye on March 29, 2020, 06:24:24 AM
Not all do Ispy - I was pretty young when it happened, I remember it but not in any great detail and it wasn't in my area. I became interested when I watched Crimes That Shook Britain and thought there was a chance he could be innocent and was fooled for a while (although never felt compelled to join in any campaign). However, I was uneasy about the phone call but other things seemed (on the surface) as though there might be something in them. However, it didn't take long to realise it was all smoke and mirrors. I wrote to Bamber for a while - he helped me make up my mind!

I have read most of the books/statements/documents and transcripts.


Ooh, that’s interesting, Caroline!

I know he wouldn’t have admitted anything (he never does for obvious reasons), but what was it that convinced you of his guilt? I know he’s sly and side-steps awkward questions...

I guess he tried to manipulate you, too 😌
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: ISpyWithMyEye on March 29, 2020, 06:27:33 AM

No, definitely not ALL started by his team.

I have discussed the case on a couple of other sites, and neither were run by his campaign team.

The sites may not all be run by his team, but I guarantee his team all congregate onto those same sites under different guises. They’re completely obsessed.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: APRIL on March 29, 2020, 08:16:54 AM
The sites may not all be run by his team, but I guarantee his team all congregate onto those same sites under different guises. They’re completely obsessed.


And they INFILTRATE!!!!! There could very well be one of their number lurking among us, and, like the virus, trying to infect us &^^&*
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: steve_trousers on March 29, 2020, 02:15:56 PM
The blue forum isn't run by the CT either. They don't like to engage in dialogue which is why you can even comment on those silly video's they make on Youtube.

Stay away from the blue forum Ispy, that’s my advice. It really is a grubby and terrible corner of the net. One can imagine them all sitting there at home In their underpants, trolling away at their keyboards.
I committed the cardinal trusting sin of putting my email address on my profile and very quickly the abuse started. My YouTube videos on my spuds and tomatoes even my cliff Richard lp collection were subjected to a torrent of abuse.



Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Caroline on March 29, 2020, 03:35:12 PM

Ooh, that’s interesting, Caroline!

I know he wouldn’t have admitted anything (he never does for obvious reasons), but what was it that convinced you of his guilt? I know he’s sly and side-steps awkward questions...

I guess he tried to manipulate you, too 😌

He did exactly that - he avoided answering awkward questions - even when I asked him more than once. I know some people don't think this is important but I DO! When he returned to WHF and Ann walked him through, he was supposed to be upset at first (great actor) but once the dust has settled on that, he went straight up stairs on his own, came running down and said 'where is dads wallet, there was £400 - £500 ponds in that + credit cards. How did he know? In all the years I lived and worked with my dad, I never knew at ANY time, how much was in his wallet. So I asked him how he knew, I asked him a long list of question in the same letter, he answered ever single question EXCEPT that one. So I asked him again. He response was "I know you asked me a specific question but I can't remember what it was but I think the answer was 'no' or 'I didn't'. If he didn't remember the question, he only had to read the letter again. This is only one example, but there are a few things that I haven't discussed on the forum which are highly suspicious. I'll sit on those for now!

The wallet thing is an example of when Bamber turned on and off the grief, who goes looking for money on a return to a scene where your parents and whole family have been killed? It's almost like he bided his time, having previously counted it!
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: ISpyWithMyEye on March 30, 2020, 08:24:23 AM
Stay away from the blue forum Ispy, that’s my advice. It really is a grubby and terrible corner of the net. One can imagine them all sitting there at home In their underpants, trolling away at their keyboards.
I committed the cardinal trusting sin of putting my email address on my profile and very quickly the abuse started. My YouTube videos on my spuds and tomatoes even my cliff Richard lp collection were subjected to a torrent of abuse.


I imagine it’s a bit like walking into a zoo and finding all the cages have been left open...

Bit mean of them to take their spite out on your spuds and Cliff!😤😂
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: ISpyWithMyEye on March 30, 2020, 08:33:45 AM
He did exactly that - he avoided answering awkward questions - even when I asked him more than once. I know some people don't think this is important but I DO! When he returned to WHF and Ann walked him through, he was supposed to be upset at first (great actor) but once the dust has settled on that, he went straight up stairs on his own, came running down and said 'where is dads wallet, there was £400 - £500 ponds in that + credit cards. How did he know? In all the years I lived and worked with my dad, I never knew at ANY time, how much was in his wallet. So I asked him how he knew, I asked him a long list of question in the same letter, he answered ever single question EXCEPT that one. So I asked him again. He response was "I know you asked me a specific question but I can't remember what it was but I think the answer was 'no' or 'I didn't'. If he didn't remember the question, he only had to read the letter again. This is only one example, but there are a few things that I haven't discussed on the forum which are highly suspicious. I'll sit on those for now!

The wallet thing is an example of when Bamber turned on and off the grief, who goes looking for money on a return to a scene where your parents and whole family have been killed? It's almost like he bided his time, having previously counted it!


We all know he’s putrid, but don’t you think he’s a tad thick too? It sounds like he thinks people can’t see through him😳

Only an idiot would think everyone else was stupid.

I’ve always believed he probably stole the odd £20 or so out of Nevill’s wallet and June’s purse. I bet he did it for YEARS. They probably knew too, but couldn’t prove it.

For him to know the amount of cash Nevill had in his wallet proves he’d snooped previously, just like he snooped at the will — which was probably when he decided he had to kill the twins ASAP.

It’s astonishing that he admitted he knew how much was in Nevill’s wallet: he’s admitting he sneakily looked inside. That’s why I’m convinced he’s thick in many ways.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Caroline on March 30, 2020, 12:59:23 PM

We all know he’s putrid, but don’t you think he’s a tad thick too? It sounds like he thinks people can’t see through him😳

Only an idiot would think everyone else was stupid.

I’ve always believed he probably stole the odd £20 or so out of Nevill’s wallet and June’s purse. I bet he did it for YEARS. They probably knew too, but couldn’t prove it.

For him to know the amount of cash Nevill had in his wallet proves he’d snooped previously, just like he snooped at the will — which was probably when he decided he had to kill the twins ASAP.

It’s astonishing that he admitted he knew how much was in Nevill’s wallet:
he’s admitting he sneakily looked inside. That’s why I’m convinced he’s thick in many ways.

I suspect it was a slip of the tongue in the panic off looking for it. Funny how he knew exactly where to look. Anyone else would have searched a few places first. He knew it wasn't there from the off.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: adam on March 30, 2020, 01:19:09 PM
£400 - £500 in a wallet. That will buy a few Cadbury's Cream Eggs.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Miss Taken Identity on March 30, 2020, 06:34:51 PM
I suspect it was a slip of the tongue in the panic off looking for it. Funny how he knew exactly where to look. Anyone else would have searched a few places first. He knew it wasn't there from the off.

Hi Caroline,

As a newbie, I see you have had communication with the drama king JB. I found your posts about the wallet  to be very significant. I hope you share other snippets with us.  He knew how much and where it was kept- very observant. Then 'forgot'.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Caroline on March 30, 2020, 07:57:24 PM
Hi Caroline,

As a newbie, I see you have had communication with the drama king JB. I found your posts about the wallet  to be very significant. I hope you share other snippets with us.  He knew how much and where it was kept- very observant. Then 'forgot'.

I wrote to him for about 3 years - the final few letters were uncomfortable because I had more or less changed my mind. Once it was cemented, I stopped - however, someone must have wrote and told him because I had a letter out of the blue asking why. As part of the explanation I told him about how he avoided the wallet question - he replied by saying that he just didn't remember the question, however, later in the same letter he said he didn't answer the question because he didn't think it was important - two excuses - once letter  @)(++(* @)(++(* I didn't reply and I haven't heard from him since.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: barrier on March 31, 2020, 06:12:14 PM
I wrote to him for about 3 years - the final few letters were uncomfortable because I had more or less changed my mind. Once it was cemented, I stopped - however, someone must have wrote and told him because I had a letter out of the blue asking why. As part of the explanation I told him about how he avoided the wallet question - he replied by saying that he just didn't remember the question, however, later in the same letter he said he didn't answer the question because he didn't think it was important - two excuses - once letter  @)(++(* @)(++(* I didn't reply and I haven't heard from him since.

He sounds manipulative,if allowed to be.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Caroline on March 31, 2020, 09:02:27 PM
He sounds manipulative,if allowed to be.

Oh I agree, I didn't allow it, some have. He deems to drop people when they are no longer useful. Quite a few people have those stories.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: The General on April 02, 2020, 01:01:58 PM
He did exactly that - he avoided answering awkward questions - even when I asked him more than once. I know some people don't think this is important but I DO! When he returned to WHF and Ann walked him through, he was supposed to be upset at first (great actor) but once the dust has settled on that, he went straight up stairs on his own, came running down and said 'where is dads wallet, there was £400 - £500 ponds in that + credit cards. How did he know? In all the years I lived and worked with my dad, I never knew at ANY time, how much was in his wallet. So I asked him how he knew, I asked him a long list of question in the same letter, he answered ever single question EXCEPT that one. So I asked him again. He response was "I know you asked me a specific question but I can't remember what it was but I think the answer was 'no' or 'I didn't'. If he didn't remember the question, he only had to read the letter again. This is only one example, but there are a few things that I haven't discussed on the forum which are highly suspicious. I'll sit on those for now!

The wallet thing is an example of when Bamber turned on and off the grief, who goes looking for money on a return to a scene where your parents and whole family have been killed? It's almost like he bided his time, having previously counted it!

Totally new to this forum, so apologies for the total lack of knowledge - but what's the significance of the wallet? He went looking for it on a subsequent visit with whom and for what purpose was the visit?


Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Caroline on April 02, 2020, 01:41:55 PM
Totally new to this forum, so apologies for the total lack of knowledge - but what's the significance of the wallet? He went looking for it on a subsequent visit with whom and for what purpose was the visit?

I don't have time to reply to this now, but before I do, what is your standing on the case? Guilty? Innocent? 'Fence sitter'?
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: The General on April 02, 2020, 02:07:20 PM
I don't have time to reply to this now, but before I do, what is your standing on the case? Guilty? Innocent? 'Fence sitter'?
I have read the reference material available on the forum, but haven't watched the TV series.
He's as guilty as anybody can be, in my opinion. Super guilty. OJ guilty.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on April 02, 2020, 02:50:55 PM
I have read the reference material available on the forum, but haven't watched the TV series.
He's as guilty as anybody can be, in my opinion. Super guilty. OJ guilty.
Something we can agree on.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: The General on April 02, 2020, 03:08:39 PM
Something we can agree on.
Hey, we agree all the time.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: puglove on April 02, 2020, 03:24:10 PM
I have read the reference material available on the forum, but haven't watched the TV series.
He's as guilty as anybody can be, in my opinion. Super guilty. OJ guilty.

OJ, Oscar, Huntley and Bridger guilty.


 %56&
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Caroline on April 02, 2020, 03:41:34 PM
I have read the reference material available on the forum, but haven't watched the TV series.
He's as guilty as anybody can be, in my opinion. Super guilty. OJ guilty.

Well, we're on the same page there.

OK - the wallet. I will say from the off, that this is just my opinion, you may think it's valid, you may not. I certainly do.

After the murders, Bamber was apprehensive to return to the farm. On Wednesday 14th August, AE called Jeremy and suggested he some to the farm, basically, to get it over with. He initially seemed physically shaken while Ann took him around the house and explained what happened where. They eventually returned o the kitchen where Jeremy suddenly became his old self again. He then went back upstairs and returned complaining that he fathers wallet was missing. He said there was £400.00 - £500.00 in it, plus credit cards and other items. The rang EP asking for 'Jones' to complain. The point is, how did he A. know what the wallet contained and how did he actually know it was missing and not just in another place? The only way he would know it was missing, is if he knew where it was on the night of the murders.

I used to think Bamber was innocent but I did have a few niggles, the wallet being one of them. I asked him about it via letter along with quite a few other questions - he answered every question except that one. So I asked him again, he didn't reply for quite some time, so I wrote again. This time he did reply and he said "I know you asked me a specific question but I don't recall was it was, however, I think the answer was no or I didn't". Clearly it was an attempt to avoid the issue. The stupid thing is, that in another letter, he actually talked about not being able to find the wallet!

Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on April 02, 2020, 04:39:32 PM
Well, we're on the same page there.

OK - the wallet. I will say from the off, that this is just my opinion, you may think it's valid, you may not. I certainly do.

After the murders, Bamber was apprehensive to return to the farm. On Wednesday 14th August, AE called Jeremy and suggested he some to the farm, basically, to get it over with. He initially seemed physically shaken while Ann took him around the house and explained what happened where. They eventually returned o the kitchen where Jeremy suddenly became his old self again. He then went back upstairs and returned complaining that he fathers wallet was missing. He said there was £400.00 - £500.00 in it, plus credit cards and other items. The rang EP asking for 'Jones' to complain. The point is, how did he A. know what the wallet contained and how did he actually know it was missing and not just in another place? The only way he would know it was missing, is if he knew where it was on the night of the murders.

I used to think Bamber was innocent but I did have a few niggles, the wallet being one of them. I asked him about it via letter along with quite a few other questions - he answered every question except that one. So I asked him again, he didn't reply for quite some time, so I wrote again. This time he did reply and he said "I know you asked me a specific question but I don't recall was it was, however, I think the answer was no or I didn't". Clearly it was an attempt to avoid the issue. The stupid thing is, that in another letter, he actually talked about not being able to find the wallet!
So he would have seen the wallet after the killings, looked inside and seen the money, thought "I'm having that but better not take it now, in case questions are asked about where the money went (assuming it had been withdrawn from the bank recently) but will come back and collect it after the event"??
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: The General on April 02, 2020, 04:42:23 PM
Well, we're on the same page there.

OK - the wallet. I will say from the off, that this is just my opinion, you may think it's valid, you may not. I certainly do.

After the murders, Bamber was apprehensive to return to the farm. On Wednesday 14th August, AE called Jeremy and suggested he some to the farm, basically, to get it over with. He initially seemed physically shaken while Ann took him around the house and explained what happened where. They eventually returned o the kitchen where Jeremy suddenly became his old self again. He then went back upstairs and returned complaining that he fathers wallet was missing. He said there was £400.00 - £500.00 in it, plus credit cards and other items. The rang EP asking for 'Jones' to complain. The point is, how did he A. know what the wallet contained and how did he actually know it was missing and not just in another place? The only way he would know it was missing, is if he knew where it was on the night of the murders.

I used to think Bamber was innocent but I did have a few niggles, the wallet being one of them. I asked him about it via letter along with quite a few other questions - he answered every question except that one. So I asked him again, he didn't reply for quite some time, so I wrote again. This time he did reply and he said "I know you asked me a specific question but I don't recall was it was, however, I think the answer was no or I didn't". Clearly it was an attempt to avoid the issue. The stupid thing is, that in another letter, he actually talked about not being able to find the wallet!
So, at the first available opportunity JB drew attention to the missing wallet. Where did he expect to find it post a forensic search? One explanation for drawing attention to it was perhaps to attempt to cast aspersions on the honesty of the investigating officers?
Again, please excuse my ignorance, but where was it found and what did it contain?
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Caroline on April 02, 2020, 05:44:46 PM
So, at the first available opportunity JB drew attention to the missing wallet. Where did he expect to find it post a forensic search? One explanation for drawing attention to it was perhaps to attempt to cast aspersions on the honesty of the investigating officers?
Again, please excuse my ignorance, but where was it found and what did it contain?

I think he was genuinely pissed off because the wallet wasn't where he knew it should be and he lost his cool and let his guard down. The relatives had collected it along with June's handbags and jewellery the previous Saturday to give to the executor. Ann Eaton didn't actually say how much was in the wallet but she doesn't indicate that he was incorrect. Not sure why she didn't just say that they had taken it.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Brietta on April 02, 2020, 06:48:06 PM
I think he was genuinely pissed off because the wallet wasn't where he knew it should be and he lost his cool and let his guard down. The relatives had collected it along with June's handbags and jewellery the previous Saturday to give to the executor. Ann Eaton didn't actually say how much was in the wallet but she doesn't indicate that he was incorrect. Not sure why she didn't just say that they had taken it.
Maybe she was disgusted at where his priorities seemed to lie.  I think a few hundred pounds would have paled into insignificance for most people if their family had just been slaughtered.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: APRIL on April 02, 2020, 07:08:07 PM
Maybe she was disgusted at where his priorities seemed to lie.  I think a few hundred pounds would have paled into insignificance for most people if their family had just been slaughtered.


Maybe she'd had prior experience of what a thwarted Jeremy was capable of.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Brietta on April 02, 2020, 07:39:39 PM

Maybe she'd had prior experience of what a thwarted Jeremy was capable of.

I'm forgetting what this guy was convicted of; knowing him, his family must have been on their guard around him particularly as their suspicion of him hardened.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: G-Unit on April 02, 2020, 08:06:27 PM
I think he was genuinely pissed off because the wallet wasn't where he knew it should be and he lost his cool and let his guard down. The relatives had collected it along with June's handbags and jewellery the previous Saturday to give to the executor. Ann Eaton didn't actually say how much was in the wallet but she doesn't indicate that he was incorrect. Not sure why she didn't just say that they had taken it.

I found out why Ann and her father 'almost felt guilty'. It was because her father 'had checked the wallet and Uncle Nevill's trouser pockets on Saturday for Mr Cock'. [Ann Eaton's statement to SY 14/05/91 page 45]

So was Jeremy right? Was there four or five hundred pounds in it? Mr Cock mentions as cash in hand what was found in June's purse, but doesn't mention Nevill's wallet or any cash belonging to him being found.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: APRIL on April 02, 2020, 08:27:32 PM
I'm forgetting what this guy was convicted of; knowing him, his family must have been on their guard around him particularly as their suspicion of him hardened.


Or their suspicion became hardened because they'd always felt the need to be on their guard against him? Incidences, having nothing to do with the crimes he was convicted for, levied against him don't make him a murderer, any more than does the odd coincidence which goes against him. However, when there's a plethora of  crime related coincidences combined with non crime related 'incidences' noted over the years by the family............
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Caroline on April 02, 2020, 09:21:16 PM
I found out why Ann and her father 'almost felt guilty'. It was because her father 'had checked the wallet and Uncle Nevill's trouser pockets on Saturday for Mr Cock'. [Ann Eaton's statement to SY 14/05/91 page 45]

So was Jeremy right? Was there four or five hundred pounds in it? Mr Cock mentions as cash in hand what was found in June's purse, but doesn't mention Nevill's wallet or any cash belonging to him being found.

I already told you that AE gave the wallet to BC. AE said that Jeremy mentioned how much was in the wallet and she doesn't mention that he was wrong. However, again, you have missed the point but as you have gone off on the direction that supporters predictably do, it's not worth the effort.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: G-Unit on April 02, 2020, 09:41:40 PM
I already told you that AE gave the wallet to BC. AE said that Jeremy mentioned how much was in the wallet and she doesn't mention that he was wrong. However, again, you have missed the point but as you have gone off on the direction that supporters predictably do, it's not worth the effort.

You also said it was in the exhibits list, suggesting that it had been given to the police. I agree with something DS Jones is reported to have said when Ann Eaton was complaining that Jeremy was taking large items from WHF to sell, when Basil Cock had told her he had given Jeremy permission to sell only small items. He said 'Is it yours?' 'No' replied Ann. 'What's it got to do with you then?' [Ann Eaton statement 14/05/91 page 58]
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Caroline on April 02, 2020, 09:45:58 PM
You also said it was in the exhibits list, suggesting that it had been given to the police. I agree with something DS Jones is reported to have said when Ann Eaton was complaining that Jeremy was taking large items from WHF to sell, when Basil Cock had told her he had given Jeremy permission to sell only small items. He said 'Is it yours?' 'No' replied Ann. 'What's it got to do with you then?' [Ann Eaton statement 14/05/91 page 58]

It is in the exhibits list and once again you have completely MISSED the point in order to shift the blame to AE - it's a typical supporter ploy.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: G-Unit on April 02, 2020, 10:58:15 PM
It is in the exhibits list and once again you have completely MISSED the point in order to shift the blame to AE - it's a typical supporter ploy.

It's unlikely to be in the list if it were given to Mr Cock. You may find it unsavoury for Jeremy to be asking about his murdered father's wallet, but it's equally unsavoury to almost immediately ask for your murdered aunt's engagement ring in my opinion.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on April 02, 2020, 11:21:32 PM
It's unlikely to be in the list if it were given to Mr Cock. You may find it unsavoury for Jeremy to be asking about his murdered father's wallet, but it's equally unsavoury to almost immediately ask for your murdered aunt's engagement ring in my opinion.
Do you think a wallet full of cash has the same sentimental value as a dead woman’s engagement ring?
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Caroline on April 02, 2020, 11:41:24 PM
It's unlikely to be in the list if it were given to Mr Cock. You may find it unsavoury for Jeremy to be asking about his murdered father's wallet, but it's equally unsavoury to almost immediately ask for your murdered aunt's engagement ring in my opinion.

It IS in the list - You'll have to search for it. The contents would have been given to BC or are you suggesting that AE pocketed the money? Almost immediately? It would have needed to be before the funerals - Ann asked for the ring for her mother - June's sister, she was well within her rights to want a keep sake - it would have been odd if she'd asked for June's purse and the cash there within though!
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Caroline on April 02, 2020, 11:41:54 PM
Do you think a wallet full of cash has the same sentimental value as a dead woman’s engagement ring?

I thought the same thing!
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on April 03, 2020, 12:05:58 AM
It IS in the list - You'll have to search for it. The contents would have been given to BC or are you suggesting that AE pocketed the money? Almost immediately? It would have needed to be before the funerals - Ann asked for the ring for her mother - June's sister, she was well within her rights to want a keep sake - it would have been odd if she'd asked for June's purse and the cash there within though!
Exactly!
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: ISpyWithMyEye on April 03, 2020, 05:53:10 AM
Well, we're on the same page there.

OK - the wallet. I will say from the off, that this is just my opinion, you may think it's valid, you may not. I certainly do.

After the murders, Bamber was apprehensive to return to the farm. On Wednesday 14th August, AE called Jeremy and suggested he some to the farm, basically, to get it over with. He initially seemed physically shaken while Ann took him around the house and explained what happened where. They eventually returned o the kitchen where Jeremy suddenly became his old self again. He then went back upstairs and returned complaining that he fathers wallet was missing. He said there was £400.00 - £500.00 in it, plus credit cards and other items. The rang EP asking for 'Jones' to complain. The point is, how did he A. know what the wallet contained and how did he actually know it was missing and not just in another place? The only way he would know it was missing, is if he knew where it was on the night of the murders.

I used to think Bamber was innocent but I did have a few niggles, the wallet being one of them. I asked him about it via letter along with quite a few other questions - he answered every question except that one. So I asked him again, he didn't reply for quite some time, so I wrote again. This time he did reply and he said "I know you asked me a specific question but I don't recall was it was, however, I think the answer was no or I didn't". Clearly it was an attempt to avoid the issue. The stupid thing is, that in another letter, he actually talked about not being able to find the wallet!


Exactly

Jeremy Bamber was the last person to see them alive inside the house, and the first person to see them all dead — so he knew EXACTLY where Nevill’s wallet was and how much it contained.

As Nevill lay dead in the kitchen, Jeremy went back upstairs to kill Sheila, then stepped over his dead mother and looked through Nevill’s wallet quickly counting the money with his evil filthy paws — probably stole £100 for his champagne the next day (hence why he said there was £400 - £500 in there: already blaming someone else of stealing some cash in case it got discovered), then cleared off home with that sickly upturned smirk on his gob.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: APRIL on April 03, 2020, 08:22:50 AM
It's unlikely to be in the list if it were given to Mr Cock. You may find it unsavoury for Jeremy to be asking about his murdered father's wallet, but it's equally unsavoury to almost immediately ask for your murdered aunt's engagement ring in my opinion.

It's a strange sense of values which can claim money as having equal worth to the incalculable sentimental value of a piece of family jewellery, whatever it's financial worth. It may be erroneous, but the story goes that Jeremy had requested that June was cremated wearing her jewellery. It's said that the undertaker returned it to Basil Cock. That being so, I can only hope that Pamela did, eventually get it as a memento of her sister.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: G-Unit on April 03, 2020, 10:09:07 AM
It's a strange sense of values which can claim money as having equal worth to the incalculable sentimental value of a piece of family jewellery, whatever it's financial worth. It may be erroneous, but the story goes that Jeremy had requested that June was cremated wearing her jewellery. It's said that the undertaker returned it to Basil Cock. That being so, I can only hope that Pamela did, eventually get it as a memento of her sister.

I made no such claim. I merely pointed out that Jeremy Bamber wasn't the only family member showing an interest in 'the spoils'. I assume Nevill bought or acquired June's engagement ring, so it had nothing to do with June's family.

Colin Caffell mentions Jeremy's feelings; he described his relatives as 'a load of f*****g magpies' nattering about his mother's jewellery and the farm. [In Search...page 64-5] According to Mr Cock in his w/s dated 16/09/85 Ann requested his presence at WHF on 10th, saying Jeremy had asked her to arrange it. [CAL page 222] I think that's unlikely, given his vews as expressed to Colin on the same weekend.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: mrswah on April 03, 2020, 10:17:12 AM
It's a strange sense of values which can claim money as having equal worth to the incalculable sentimental value of a piece of family jewellery, whatever it's financial worth. It may be erroneous, but the story goes that Jeremy had requested that June was cremated wearing her jewellery. It's said that the undertaker returned it to Basil Cock. That being so, I can only hope that Pamela did, eventually get it as a memento of her sister.

The undertaker probably did return it. When my mum died, I remember being told told that she could not be cremated in her rings.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: G-Unit on April 03, 2020, 10:40:55 AM
The undertaker probably did return it. When my mum died, I remember being told told that she could not be cremated in her rings.

What can you put in a coffin for cremation?

Items such as wooden rosary beads, flowers, soft toys and written messages can be placed inside someone’s coffin for cremation.

Jewellery items can also be cremated, but cannot be recovered after a cremation has happened. If you want to keep items of sentimental value placed in the coffin, be sure to let your funeral director know, so these can be recovered before the cremation and returned to you.
https://www.funeralguide.co.uk/help-resources/arranging-a-funeral/funeral-guides/what-can-you-put-in-a-coffin
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: The General on April 03, 2020, 10:43:57 AM

Exactly

Jeremy Bamber was the last person to see them alive inside the house, and the first person to see them all dead — so he knew EXACTLY where Nevill’s wallet was and how much it contained.

As Nevill lay dead in the kitchen, Jeremy went back upstairs to kill Sheila, then stepped over his dead mother and looked through Nevill’s wallet quickly counting the money with his evil filthy paws — probably stole £100 for his champagne the next day (hence why he said there was £400 - £500 in there: already blaming someone else of stealing some cash in case it got discovered), then cleared off home with that sickly upturned smirk on his gob.
What was the point in the acting to the contrary then?
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: APRIL on April 03, 2020, 11:00:23 AM
I made no such claim. I merely pointed out that Jeremy Bamber wasn't the only family member showing an interest in 'the spoils'. I assume Nevill bought or acquired June's engagement ring, so it had nothing to do with June's family.

Colin Caffell mentions Jeremy's feelings; he described his relatives as 'a load of f*****g magpies' nattering about his mother's jewellery and the farm. [In Search...page 64-5] According to Mr Cock in his w/s dated 16/09/85 Ann requested his presence at WHF on 10th, saying Jeremy had asked her to arrange it. [CAL page 222] I think that's unlikely, given his vews as expressed to Colin on the same weekend.


And you know this how? It is PERFECTLY probable that in families such as the Speakmans and Bambers, items such as jewellery were generational and had huge sentimental value. Jeremy would neither have known nor cared, other than it's monetary value which could have been added to his own coffers -perhaps you can find evidence of him presenting the proceeds of his sellings off to BC to set against the death duties it's claimed he was doing it for- and it's highly unlikely that Colin would have had the remotest idea of/interest in how jewellery became handed down through families. But even had this NOT been the case, and Nevill, as a young man just starting out on a career, hadn't been able to afford to buy June a spectacular piece, I see absolutely nothing wrong in her sister wanting a small and insignificant ring as a keepsake.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: puglove on April 03, 2020, 11:34:53 AM
I made no such claim. I merely pointed out that Jeremy Bamber wasn't the only family member showing an interest in 'the spoils'. I assume Nevill bought or acquired June's engagement ring, so it had nothing to do with June's family.

Colin Caffell mentions Jeremy's feelings; he described his relatives as 'a load of f*****g magpies' nattering about his mother's jewellery and the farm. [In Search...page 64-5] According to Mr Cock in his w/s dated 16/09/85 Ann requested his presence at WHF on 10th, saying Jeremy had asked her to arrange it. [CAL page 222] I think that's unlikely, given his vews as expressed to Colin on the same weekend.

Bamber has always been motivated by greed, and still is. If you read through Daisy's posts on here you'll get an insight into his true character.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: G-Unit on April 03, 2020, 11:51:40 AM
Bamber has always been motivated by greed, and still is. If you read through Daisy's posts on here you'll get an insight into his true character.

Quite possibly, but it seems the wider family were hardly uninterested. Didn't Barbara Wilson make some accusations about Peter Easton's behaviour?
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: APRIL on April 03, 2020, 11:59:23 AM
Quite possibly, but it seems the wider family were hardly uninterested. Didn't Barbara Wilson make some accusations about Peter Easton's behaviour?


Just because one family member is a murderer doesn't automatically make every other family member pure as driven snow.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Angelo222 on April 03, 2020, 12:31:57 PM

Just because one family member is a murderer doesn't automatically make every other family member pure as driven snow.

Always keeping in mind of course that Jeremy Bamber had no blood links to anyone else in the family.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: APRIL on April 03, 2020, 12:38:10 PM
Always keeping in mind of course that Jeremy Bamber had no blood links to anyone else in the family.



Indeed..................and Peter Eaton was only one of them by marriage.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Caroline on April 03, 2020, 01:35:39 PM
Quite possibly, but it seems the wider family were hardly uninterested. Didn't Barbara Wilson make some accusations about Peter Easton's behaviour?

How does that exonerate Bamber?
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Caroline on April 03, 2020, 01:39:00 PM
It's a strange sense of values which can claim money as having equal worth to the incalculable sentimental value of a piece of family jewellery, whatever it's financial worth. It may be erroneous, but the story goes that Jeremy had requested that June was cremated wearing her jewellery. It's said that the undertaker returned it to Basil Cock. That being so, I can only hope that Pamela did, eventually get it as a memento of her sister.

I'm not sure that June's ring was returned but Sheila's was.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: G-Unit on April 03, 2020, 02:24:15 PM
How does that exonerate Bamber?

I don't think I said it did.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: APRIL on April 03, 2020, 02:32:35 PM
I don't think I said it did.


Then why the comparisons between Jeremy and his wider family?
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: G-Unit on April 03, 2020, 02:40:08 PM

Then why the comparisons between Jeremy and his wider family?

It needs to be taken into account imo.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: APRIL on April 03, 2020, 02:48:39 PM
It needs to be taken into account imo.


Why? None of them were ever on trial for murder, and whilst they may not have been totally squeaky clean -who of us is?- Jeremy, it seems, was much less so, but he had a choice, which, whilst not being an acceptable one, would have left his family alive.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on April 03, 2020, 03:52:25 PM
I don't think I said it did.
Then what exactly are you saying?  Is it another of the many “just because”s to add to the long list of Jeremy’s cold and calculating behaviours that you are seeking to excuse away? 
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Angelo222 on April 03, 2020, 04:18:47 PM
Then what exactly are you saying?  Is it another of the many “just because”s to add to the long list of Jeremy’s cold and calculating behaviours that you are seeking to excuse away?

Bamber's crime is off the scale.  To effectively execute two children as they slept in bed deserves the noose imo and that is why he can never be released.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Brietta on April 03, 2020, 05:39:42 PM
Bamber's crime is off the scale.  To effectively execute two children as they slept in bed deserves the noose imo and that is why he can never be released.

I don't think he was motivated by anything other than greed.  If he had any real issues at all with his parents why on earth was he still there living off them?
His sister and her twins were impediments between him and what he thought was his rightful inheritance at the time he had decided his parents had outlived their usefulness.  The horror he visited on the adults is bad enough but to slaughter two innocent boys full of life and love really does mark his crime as off the scale.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: G-Unit on April 03, 2020, 06:10:21 PM
Bamber's crime is off the scale.  To effectively execute two children as they slept in bed deserves the noose imo and that is why he can never be released.

The crime was indeed terrible but so was the investigation into it and the trial evidence in my opinion.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on April 03, 2020, 06:18:38 PM
The crime was indeed terrible but so was the investigation into it and the trial evidence in my opinion.
Why do you think two appeals have failed then?
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Caroline on April 03, 2020, 06:38:55 PM
I don't think I said it did.

Isn't that the point of supporting him? Showing ways why either he is innocent or Sheila is guilty?
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Caroline on April 03, 2020, 06:42:16 PM
It needs to be taken into account imo.

Bamber goes to collect his dads wallet knowing where it is and what's in it on his every first visit back to WHF - he must have known where it was to know it was missing but that is the same as Ann asking for a keepsake for her mum during a discussion on things being valued for sale? Seriously? You're going with that?
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Caroline on April 03, 2020, 06:44:11 PM
Then what exactly are you saying?  Is it another of the many “just because”s to add to the long list of Jeremy’s cold and calculating behaviours that you are seeking to excuse away?

Funny thing is, I knew the avenue that G Unit would go down as soon as I posted about the wallet - it's a typical response. from supporters
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Caroline on April 03, 2020, 06:45:54 PM
The crime was indeed terrible but so was the investigation into it and the trial evidence in my opinion.

So you'd have been happy if he'd walked?
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on April 03, 2020, 06:48:15 PM
So you'd have been happy if he'd walked?
One would assume so, as she seems to feel he has been the victim in this.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: mrswah on April 03, 2020, 06:53:17 PM
Why do you think two appeals have failed then?


Either because he's guilty, or because nobody would ever dare release him.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Caroline on April 03, 2020, 06:57:24 PM
One would assume so, as she seems to feel he has been the victim in this.

As soon as he made his first return to WHF, he bundled his mum and dads clothes onto a farm trailer and they where burned in the farm fire pit - that in itself is totally heartless and shows a complete lack of empathy and decency but did he use that to burn other things? We'll never know.

Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Caroline on April 03, 2020, 06:57:54 PM

Either because he's guilty, or because nobody would ever dare release him.

They won't dare release him because he's guilty.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on April 03, 2020, 06:58:00 PM

Either because he's guilty, or because nobody would ever dare release him.
On what grounds would someone not dare release him?
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on April 03, 2020, 06:59:04 PM
As soon as he made his first return to WHF, he bundled his mum and dads clothes onto a farm trailer and they where burned in the farm fire pit - that in itself is totally heartless and shows a complete lack of empathy and decency but did he use that to burn other things? We'll never know.
He was (is) an absolute git, of that there can be no doubt whatsoever.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Nicholas on April 03, 2020, 07:02:34 PM
On what grounds would someone not dare release him?

How are offenders released on licence being managed under MAPPA currently?
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: mrswah on April 03, 2020, 07:03:38 PM
On what grounds would someone not dare release him?


Just imagine how embarrassing it would be if it were to be discovered that someone had spent 35 years in prison for something he didn't do.  Imagine what a fuss the "supporters" would make!
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Caroline on April 03, 2020, 07:12:57 PM

Just imagine how embarrassing it would be if it were to be discovered that someone had spent 35 years in prison for something he didn't do.  Imagine what a fuss the "supporters" would make!

You would have to imagine it because it isn't reality.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on April 03, 2020, 07:20:02 PM
How are offenders released on licence being managed under MAPPA currently?
I have absolutely no idea, how does that relate to my question? 
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on April 03, 2020, 07:20:56 PM

Just imagine how embarrassing it would be if it were to be discovered that someone had spent 35 years in prison for something he didn't do.  Imagine what a fuss the "supporters" would make!
It wouldn’t be the first time.  Are you suggesting our judicial system is really that corrupt? 
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Holly Goodhead on April 03, 2020, 08:06:18 PM
It wouldn’t be the first time.  Are you suggesting our judicial system is really that corrupt?

I would suggest it is incompetent rather than corrupt on the basis of what appeal court judges said about other moj's

Stefan Kizsko

"We can find no grounds whatsoever to condemn the jury's verdict of murder as in any way safe or unsatisfactory.  The appeal is dismissed".  Lord Justice Bridge.

Stephen Downing

"The court felt that her evidence was not credible and secure enough to allow an appeal against the conviction".

Sally Clarke

"Despite recognition of the flaws in Meadow's statistical evidence, the convictions were upheld at appeal in October 2000."

Guildford Four

"Both the Guildford Four and the Maguire Seven unsuccessfully sought leave to appeal their convictions immediately".

"The Guildford Four tried to obtain from the Home Secretary a reference to the Court of Appeal under Section 17 of Criminal Appeal Act 1968 (later repeled) but were unsuccessful.

Birmingham 6

"In March 1976 their first application for leave to appeal was dismissed by the Court of Appeal, presided over by Lord Widgery CJ".

"In January 1988 after a six week hearing (at that time the longest criminal hearing ever held), the convictions were ruled to be safe and satisfactory.  The Court of Appeal, presided over by the Lord Chief Justice Lord Lane dismissed the appeals".
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on April 03, 2020, 08:20:29 PM
I would suggest it is incompetent rather than corrupt on the basis of what appeal court judges said about other moj's

Stefan Kizsko

"We can find no grounds whatsoever to condemn the jury's verdict of murder as in any way safe or unsatisfactory.  The appeal is dismissed".  Lord Justice Bridge.

Stephen Downing

"The court felt that her evidence was not credible and secure enough to allow an appeal against the conviction".

Sally Clarke

"Despite recognition of the flaws in Meadow's statistical evidence, the convictions were upheld at appeal in October 2000."

Guildford Four

"Both the Guildford Four and the Maguire Seven unsuccessfully sought leave to appeal their convictions immediately".

"The Guildford Four tried to obtain from the Home Secretary a reference to the Court of Appeal under Section 17 of Criminal Appeal Act 1968 (later repeled) but were unsuccessful.

Birmingham 6

"In March 1976 their first application for leave to appeal was dismissed by the Court of Appeal, presided over by Lord Widgery CJ".

"In January 1988 after a six week hearing (at that time the longest criminal hearing ever held), the convictions were ruled to be safe and satisfactory.  The Court of Appeal, presided over by the Lord Chief Justice Lord Lane dismissed the appeals".
Thanks for showing that no amount of embarrassment would prevent a court from overturning an unsafe judgement if evidence is presented to show that it is unsafe.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Holly Goodhead on April 03, 2020, 08:20:50 PM
Bamber goes to collect his dads wallet knowing where it is and what's in it on his every first visit back to WHF - he must have known where it was to know it was missing but that is the same as Ann asking for a keepsake for her mum during a discussion on things being valued for sale? Seriously? You're going with that?

As I understand it the relatives had already established NB's empty wallet along with an absence of cash in June's handbags and any cash anywhere within WHF?  This doesn't ring true especially mid 80's:

- JB

- Dishonest police officer(s)

- Relatives
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: G-Unit on April 03, 2020, 08:24:10 PM
So you'd have been happy if he'd walked?

I'd have been happy to see an efficient investigation and a trial with more dependable evidence.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Nicholas on April 03, 2020, 08:28:46 PM
I have absolutely no idea, how does that relate to my question?

When I read your post, “On what grounds would someone not dare release him?” I wrongly thought you were a supporter suggesting Bamber be released due to the Covid-19 crisis.



Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on April 03, 2020, 09:01:52 PM
When I read your post, “On what grounds would someone not dare release him?” I wrongly thought you were a supporter suggesting Bamber be released due to the Covid-19 crisis.
Haha.  Nope.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: ISpyWithMyEye on April 03, 2020, 09:11:49 PM
I made no such claim. I merely pointed out that Jeremy Bamber wasn't the only family member showing an interest in 'the spoils'. I assume Nevill bought or acquired June's engagement ring, so it had nothing to do with June's family.

Colin Caffell mentions Jeremy's feelings; he described his relatives as 'a load of f*****g magpies' nattering about his mother's jewellery and the farm. [In Search...page 64-5] According to Mr Cock in his w/s dated 16/09/85 Ann requested his presence at WHF on 10th, saying Jeremy had asked her to arrange it. [CAL page 222] I think that's unlikely, given his vews as expressed to Colin on the same weekend.


Have you got a link for that, G-Unit?

I’ve read Colin Caffell’s book and don’t recall ever seeing him using the F word...nor calling the family “F**** Magpies”
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: ISpyWithMyEye on April 03, 2020, 09:15:01 PM
What can you put in a coffin for cremation?

Items such as wooden rosary beads, flowers, soft toys and written messages can be placed inside someone’s coffin for cremation.

Jewellery items can also be cremated, but cannot be recovered after a cremation has happened. If you want to keep items of sentimental value placed in the coffin, be sure to let your funeral director know, so these can be recovered before the cremation and returned to you.
https://www.funeralguide.co.uk/help-resources/arranging-a-funeral/funeral-guides/what-can-you-put-in-a-coffin

G-Unit, the funeral directors did indeed remive the jewellery’s Jeremy insisted be burnt with them, and gave then to their loved ones...
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: ISpyWithMyEye on April 03, 2020, 09:18:52 PM
What was the point in the acting to the contrary then?

Sorry, I don't understand your question...

Contrary to what?



Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: ISpyWithMyEye on April 03, 2020, 09:27:02 PM
Quite possibly, but it seems the wider family were hardly uninterested. Didn't Barbara Wilson make some accusations about Peter Easton's behaviour?


If you mean the family were disinterested in Jeremy Bamber’s behaviour, that was possibly due to respect for Nevill and June who tried to hide his appalling and disgusting doings.


Barbara Wilson mentioned a family argument YEARS after Jeremy Bamber killed his family, which involved petty quarrels over the sale of spuds, some old tractor part and a couple of other minor things... it had nothing to do with Jeremy Bamber shooting dead all his family
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: ISpyWithMyEye on April 03, 2020, 09:44:16 PM
I made no such claim. I merely pointed out that Jeremy Bamber wasn't the only family member showing an interest in 'the spoils'. I assume Nevill bought or acquired June's engagement ring, so it had nothing to do with June's family.

Colin Caffell mentions Jeremy's feelings; he described his relatives as 'a load of f*****g magpies' nattering about his mother's jewellery and the farm. [In Search...page 64-5] According to Mr Cock in his w/s dated 16/09/85 Ann requested his presence at WHF on 10th, saying Jeremy had asked her to arrange it. [CAL page 222] I think that's unlikely, given his vews as expressed to Colin on the same weekend.

I’d hardly call expensive antiques: medals Nevill won in the RAF; paintings commissioned for the Speakman’s etc as “spoils”!

These weren’t “tat” — Sotheby’s bought them!

Nevill came from a wealthy family too, dear, so I doubt he gave her a cheap little engagement ring. Maybe you can’t see or feel the connection, but as June wore that ring for around 40 years, it was very much a part of her...which made it precious to her very close family.

Strange, eh, that Jeremy didn’t want that — just as Prince Willian cherished Princess Diana’s ring which he gave to Kate on their engagement?

You may not understand sentimentality, but it’s almost unheard of to have a loved one cremated wearing precious jewellery..

Colin Caffell made a good point: he suggested that Jeremy wanted all their jewellery burnt too as he was wary about psychics who “read” jewellery...Jeremy rubbed his hands with glee when he thought all three had been burnt with their jewellery.

Don’t you find that strange?






 
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: ISpyWithMyEye on April 03, 2020, 09:57:14 PM
I don't think he was motivated by anything other than greed.  If he had any real issues at all with his parents why on earth was he still there living off them?
His sister and her twins were impediments between him and what he thought was his rightful inheritance at the time he had decided his parents had outlived their usefulness.  The horror he visited on the adults is bad enough but to slaughter two innocent boys full of life and love really does mark his crime as off the scale.

Absolutely!

And what a coincidence that it was soon after June and Nevill had added the twins’ to their will, that Jeremy began plotting to kill them all...

He even asked Colin (albeit casually) if he would inherit from his sons!



Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Caroline on April 03, 2020, 10:24:21 PM
As I understand it the relatives had already established NB's empty wallet along with an absence of cash in June's handbags and any cash anywhere within WHF?  This doesn't ring true especially mid 80's:

- JB

- Dishonest police officer(s)

- Relatives

Where have they stated the wallet was empty?
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: ISpyWithMyEye on April 03, 2020, 10:25:24 PM
So you'd have been happy if he'd walked?


Anyone who’s happy to see a mass murderer  get off must have “difficulties”...

Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: ISpyWithMyEye on April 03, 2020, 10:32:20 PM

Either because he's guilty, or because nobody would ever dare release him.

He IS guilty, Myster — have you forgotten?

If he wasn’t guilty and the authorities knew, they wouldn’t DARE not release him...

Fact is, the evidence against him was SO overwhelming the courts ignore his petty complaints ...they’d listen to new fresh concrete evidence that suggested he WAS innocent, but in 35 years if him hunting through thousands of documents he’s come up with zilch.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: ISpyWithMyEye on April 03, 2020, 10:40:59 PM

Just imagine how embarrassing it would be if it were to be discovered that someone had spent 35 years in prison for something he didn't do.  Imagine what a fuss the "supporters" would make!

And imagine how embarrassed they’d be if they released him knowing he’s guilty !

Listen dear, you can moo ‘til the cows come home, but he ain’t ever gonna be released.

He’s guilty. Full stop.

Move on, live...stop daydreaming. And let me tell you something — IF he ever got released (won’t happen) you’d NEVER see him. He’d drop all his supporters who he secretly laughs at and would be OFF...
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Caroline on April 03, 2020, 10:48:16 PM
And imagine how embarrassed they’d be if they released him knowing he’s guilty !

Listen dear, you can moo ‘til the cows come home, but he ain’t ever gonna be released.

He’s guilty. Full stop.

Move on, live...stop daydreaming. And let me tell you something — IF he ever got released (won’t happen) you’d NEVER see him. He’d drop all his supporters who he secretly laughs at and would be OFF...

He would do his best to try and make celebrity status - he just loves attenntion!
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: ISpyWithMyEye on April 04, 2020, 09:27:21 AM
He would do his best to try and make celebrity status - he just loves attenntion!

Indeed!

But he’d drop all the soppy groupies who he secretly laughs at...he’d be trying his luck with some Z-lister Reality star

First he’d get an agent: have a ghostwriter do his autobiography while instructing a lawyer to sling the family out of WHF, Vaulty, the Caravan Site and sue them for back rent.

He’d have a nip & tuck (last reporter who went to interview him said Jeremy looked older than his years, was very jowly, and had a grey type skin tone) so, being vain, he’d have a N&T, botox/fillers, veneers, hair dye etc...the works...probably have laser treatment to get rid of his spectacles...

Lease a Ferrari, but would need driving lessons again and wouldn’t have a clue you press a start button instead of using a key...

He’d need to learn computer basics, how mobiles work...as far as technology goes he’s still in the last century. Oh, how frustrating he must feel when he sees those computer screens but has no internet access ! He’s already started complaining about that; saying it’s a handicap. Well, he can complain on...cos it ain’t gonna happen.

But yes, he’d relish being in the limelight, playing the “oh, woe is me, what a hero I am” as he told press/TV to submit their bids for his time on GMTV, This Morning, Loose Women etc...

And I guarantee he wouldn’t visit June and Nevill’s grave unless a camera crew came along...





Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: ISpyWithMyEye on April 04, 2020, 09:32:20 AM
I would suggest it is incompetent rather than corrupt on the basis of what appeal court judges said about other moj's

Stefan Kizsko

"We can find no grounds whatsoever to condemn the jury's verdict of murder as in any way safe or unsatisfactory.  The appeal is dismissed".  Lord Justice Bridge.

Stephen Downing

"The court felt that her evidence was not credible and secure enough to allow an appeal against the conviction".

Sally Clarke

"Despite recognition of the flaws in Meadow's statistical evidence, the convictions were upheld at appeal in October 2000."

Guildford Four

"Both the Guildford Four and the Maguire Seven unsuccessfully sought leave to appeal their convictions immediately".

"The Guildford Four tried to obtain from the Home Secretary a reference to the Court of Appeal under Section 17 of Criminal Appeal Act 1968 (later repeled) but were unsuccessful.

Birmingham 6

"In March 1976 their first application for leave to appeal was dismissed by the Court of Appeal, presided over by Lord Widgery CJ".

"In January 1988 after a six week hearing (at that time the longest criminal hearing ever held), the convictions were ruled to be safe and satisfactory.  The Court of Appeal, presided over by the Lord Chief Justice Lord Lane dismissed the appeals".


Holly, these cases were incompetent, and in some cases corrupt.

Equally, there are people walking free due to the incompetence of the police...it works both ways.

But the cases you’ve highlighted are extreme, and they all had CONCRETE evidence that they were innocent, hence why they were released.

Jeremy Bamber doesn’t fall into their camp — and they’d be insulted you've lumped his in with them!

Jeremy has not a SHRED of evidence that he didn’t kill all his family — I suggest you refresh yourself with the FACTS
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Holly Goodhead on April 04, 2020, 10:20:44 AM
Where have they stated the wallet was empty?

The relatives sought out all cash within WHF at the request of BC.  NB's wallet was found along with June's handbags and no cash was found including elsewhere in WHF.  I find it impossible to conceive that NB/June had no cash in wallets/purses/handbags which leaves 3 possibilities:

- JB

- Dishonest police officers

- Relatives

Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Holly Goodhead on April 04, 2020, 10:21:30 AM
The relatives sought out all cash within WHF at the request of BC.  NB's wallet was found along with June's handbags and no cash was found including elsewhere in WHF.  I find it impossible to conceive that NB/June had no cash in wallets/purses/handbags which leaves 3 possibilities:

- JB

- Dishonest police officers

- Relatives

Attachment
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Holly Goodhead on April 04, 2020, 10:37:12 AM

Holly, these cases were incompetent, and in some cases corrupt.

Equally, there are people walking free due to the incompetence of the police...it works both ways.

But the cases you’ve highlighted are extreme, and they all had CONCRETE evidence that they were innocent, hence why they were released.

Jeremy Bamber doesn’t fall into their camp — and they’d be insulted you've lumped his in with them!

Jeremy has not a SHRED of evidence that he didn’t kill all his family — I suggest you refresh yourself with the FACTS

Corruption and incompetence are at the heart of most MOJ's.  JB's too imo.

I am well versed with the facts of the case thank you.

If the above cases were as easy to rectify as you seem to think then how come it took so long and why did they go  back and forth to appeal courts?

Bearing in mind the above had the best possible advocates by way of family.  JB has been handicapped by the likes of Mike Tesko and various others.

Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: mrswah on April 04, 2020, 10:49:14 AM
And imagine how embarrassed they’d be if they released him knowing he’s guilty !

Listen dear, you can moo ‘til the cows come home, but he ain’t ever gonna be released.

He’s guilty. Full stop.

Move on, live...stop daydreaming. And let me tell you something — IF he ever got released (won’t happen) you’d NEVER see him. He’d drop all his supporters who he secretly laughs at and would be OFF...


I am not your "dear", thank you, and  I don't "moo" , unless I'm reading baby books with my grandchildren.

 Daydreaming---well there, I'm guilty, but I wouldn't say I spend much time daydreaming about Jeremy Bamber.

I did say that I don't believe JB will ever be released, and I don't know what  gave you the idea that I would ever want to see him. If I did, i'd have tried to arrange it before now---I've certainly had enough time.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: barrier on April 04, 2020, 10:54:02 AM
Corruption and incompetence are at the heart of most MOJ's.  JB's too imo.

I am well versed with the facts of the case thank you.

If the above cases were as easy to rectify as you seem to think then how come it took so long and why did they go  back and forth to appeal courts?

Bearing in mind the above had the best possible advocates by way of family.  JB has been handicapped by the likes of Mike Tesko and various others.

Holly in the past you've alluded to other miscarriages such as the Stefan Kizko one as some kind of  bellwether,this case in particular was a right stitch up,with the most damning being he was infertile which never matched the sample of semen on the victim,what clear evidence after the conviction of Bamber some 34 yrs later is there that can clear him? remembering in his haste the forensics were destroyed,its his word and word only.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: ISpyWithMyEye on April 04, 2020, 11:07:12 AM
Corruption and incompetence are at the heart of most MOJ's.  JB's too imo.

I am well versed with the facts of the case thank you.

If the above cases were as easy to rectify as you seem to think then how come it took so long and why did they go  back and forth to appeal courts?

Bearing in mind the above had the best possible advocates by way of family.  JB has been handicapped by the likes of Mike Tesko and various others.

They didn’t REPEATEDLY go back and forth — some appealed twice — and then won their appeal on CONCRETE evidence

Jeremy Bamber has gone to appeal twice — and failed due to ludicrous allegations which were batted out of court in less than an hour

Jeremy has also tried (unsuccessfully) to get Leave to Appeal — and that’s failed too due to his ridiculous “evidence” that doesn’t exist

Jeremy went to the European Court of Human Rights — and failed there too

He has NEVER presented ONE shred of evidence to even SUGGEST he’s innocent. Never.

Furthermore, there’s actually MORE damning evidence AGAINST him that wasn’t heard in court the first time

This is going round in circles...
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Holly Goodhead on April 04, 2020, 11:10:32 AM
Holly in the past you've alluded to other miscarriages such as the Stefan Kizko one as some kind of  bellwether,this case in particular was a right stitch up,with the most damning being he was infertile which never matched the sample of semen on the victim,what clear evidence after the conviction of Bamber some 34 yrs later is there that can clear him? remembering in his haste the forensics were destroyed,its his word and word only.

I've posted a range of MOJ's which show they are difficult to rectify even when an individual such as Stefan Kizsko was manifestly innocent.  Unlike other MOJ's JB has been severely handicapped by lack of family support and having to rely on the likes of Mike Tesko.

I'm not aware of any forensic evidence that was destroyed pre trial?

Post trial exhibits have been destroyed against all protocols which could potentially have assisted JB advance his case or conversely seal his fate.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Holly Goodhead on April 04, 2020, 11:18:53 AM
They didn’t REPEATEDLY go back and forth — some appealed twice — and then won their appeal on CONCRETE evidence

Jeremy Bamber has gone to appeal twice — and failed due to ludicrous allegations which were batted out of court in less than an hour

Jeremy has also tried (unsuccessfully) to get Leave to Appeal — and that’s failed too due to his ridiculous “evidence” that doesn’t exist

Jeremy went to the European Court of Human Rights — and failed there too

He has NEVER presented ONE shred of evidence to even SUGGEST he’s innocent. Never.

Furthermore, there’s actually MORE damning evidence AGAINST him that wasn’t heard in court the first time

This is going round in circles...

All the cases I have referred to were long running and went to the appeal courts at least twice before they were overturned.  These cases also benefitted from strong family support whereas JB has had to rely on idiots.

A recent example is that of Amanda Knox who served a lengthy prison sentence and case went back and forth to the appeal courts until it was finally overturned with no chance of appeal for the prosecution.  Not only did AK have family support but she had an incredible bunch of people around her by way of 'judges for justice'. 

An appellants success or failure is very much dependent on the individuals on the outside supporting him/her.

The ECHR related to his sentence not the case against him.

Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on April 04, 2020, 11:20:27 AM
I've posted a range of MOJ's which show they are difficult to rectify even when an individual such as Stefan Kizsko was manifestly innocent.  Unlike other MOJ's JB has been severely handicapped by lack of family support and having to rely on the likes of Mike Tesko.

I'm not aware of any forensic evidence that was destroyed pre trial?

Post trial exhibits have been destroyed against all protocols which could potentially have assisted JB advance his case or conversely seal his fate.
Do you believe there is evidence that proves Bamber is manifestly innocent?  If so what is it?
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: ISpyWithMyEye on April 04, 2020, 11:25:42 AM
I've posted a range of MOJ's which show they are difficult to rectify even when an individual such as Stefan Kizsko was manifestly innocent.  Unlike other MOJ's JB has been severely handicapped by lack of family support and having to rely on the likes of Mike Tesko.

I'm not aware of any forensic evidence that was destroyed pre trial?

Post trial exhibits have been destroyed against all protocols which could potentially have assisted JB advance his case or conversely seal his fate.


Had Jeremy not shod dead all his close family, he’d have them here now, Holly

And he wouldn’t be cooped up in a cell, either

It was Jeremy who ASKED police to destroy evidence — have you forgotten that, too?

And it was Jeremy who insisted they all be cremated — which was against their wishes.

Finally, JB has NOTHING to show that he was innocent. NOTHING. in fact, the deeper you delve into it the more you see how guilty he is!
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Holly Goodhead on April 04, 2020, 11:32:01 AM

Had Jeremy not shod dead all his close family, he’d have them here now, Holly

And he wouldn’t be cooped up in a cell, either

It was Jeremy who ASKED police to destroy evidence — have you forgotten that, too?

And it was Jeremy who insisted they all be cremated — which was against their wishes.

Finally, JB has NOTHING to show that he was innocent. NOTHING. in fact, the deeper you delve into it the more you see how guilty he is!

What evidence was destroyed pre trial that could either have supported the defence or prosecution? 
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: ISpyWithMyEye on April 04, 2020, 11:46:13 AM
The carpets

I guarantee there were footprints/handprints (albeit gloved), a few bloodied hairs, skin traces from scratches all matching and belonging to Jeremy somewhere on that bedroom carpet, and possibly the beds

Had Jeremy been so certain Sheila commuted the murders, he’d have asked the police to take them away and forensically examine them. Sheila’s footprints would have been ALL OVER the carpet, and certainly the kitchen

There wasn’t ONE. NOT one.

But you’ll ignore that.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Holly Goodhead on April 04, 2020, 11:56:00 AM
The carpets

I guarantee there were footprints/handprints (albeit gloved), a few bloodied hairs, skin traces from scratches all matching and belonging to Jeremy somewhere on that bedroom carpet, and possibly the beds

Had Jeremy been so certain Sheila commuted the murders, he’d have asked the police to take them away and forensically examine them. Sheila’s footprints would have been ALL OVER the carpet, and certainly the kitchen

There wasn’t ONE. NOT one.

But you’ll ignore that.

SOC officer DC Hammersly confirmed at trial that everything of evidential value was collected which is confirmed in the following where all exhibits are detailed.

Why would SC's footprints be all over?  Where were JB's footprints?

http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=165.0
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Holly Goodhead on April 04, 2020, 12:15:11 PM
Do you believe there is evidence that proves Bamber is manifestly innocent?  If so what is it?

The criminal justice system isn't about proving innonecence.  At trial it's for the prosecution to prove beyond reasonable doubt the defendant is guilty.  At appeal it's for the defence to undermine the prosecutions case to an extent 3 appeal court judges deem its unsafe.

I believe new forensic tests will result in JB's conviction being overturned. 
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: ISpyWithMyEye on April 04, 2020, 12:15:40 PM
I have things to do so can’t keep answering questions that should be obvious

Of course Sheila’s footprints would have been all over the kitchen; it was strewn with blood, sugar and glass

They’d have also been on the staircase

And her feet would have been covered....

They weren’t, were they? How do you account for that, Holly?

As for Jeremy, he’d have made sure to have worn shoe covers, and would have also made sure to have wiped/smudged any traces of his footprints — that’s obvious. He’d have also removed his shoe covers before tiptoeing back upstairs in his socks...even he would have thought of that.

It’s a shame the police didn’t immediately lockdown Goldhanger and search it.

As it happens, and you’ll ask me again for a link (but you’ll have to wait as I’m busy now) but police did indeed find some of his clothing with tiny traces of blood on at Goldhanger, but there wasn’t enough for it to be tested. He’d obviously put them through the washing machine as soon as he got home...

He definitely wore his wetsuit to carry out the murders, but after showering at WHF, drying his WS, stuffing it in his old bedroom, he most likely got contaminated by the odd speck of blood on the clothes he wore when he climbed out the kitchen window

There was talk he may have dressed as a woman...but that’s just rumour as he was seen around the village dressed as woman on occasion.

He also, slyly, upturned the dishwasher drainer in an attempt to make it look like the area hadn’t been disturbed. It’s very noticeable. I haven’t used a drainer in decades, but when I did I never stood mine on its end. And June didn’t seem the fastidious type...so I bet he did that purposely.

He’s very transparent.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: ISpyWithMyEye on April 04, 2020, 12:19:05 PM
The criminal justice system isn't about proving innonecence.  At trial it's for the prosecution to prove beyond reasonable doubt the defendant is guilty.  At appeal it's for the defence to undermine the prosecutions case to an extent 3 appeal court judges deem its unsafe.

I believe new forensic tests will result in JB's conviction being overturned.

Oh dear

Considering there is no forensic evidence, how’s he going to do that? Whip some up?🤪
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Holly Goodhead on April 04, 2020, 12:40:52 PM
Oh dear

Considering there is no forensic evidence, how’s he going to do that? Whip some up?🤪

There doesn't need to be any existing forensic evidence to undermine test results presented at trial.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Caroline on April 04, 2020, 12:55:53 PM

Holly, these cases were incompetent, and in some cases corrupt.

Equally, there are people walking free due to the incompetence of the police...it works both ways.

But the cases you’ve highlighted are extreme, and they all had CONCRETE evidence that they were innocent, hence why they were released.

Jeremy Bamber doesn’t fall into their camp — and they’d be insulted you've lumped his in with them!

Jeremy has not a SHRED of evidence that he didn’t kill all his family — I suggest you refresh yourself with the FACTS

No, there is no evidence, that's why Holly wants to create some but she's starting from a biased position.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on April 04, 2020, 01:00:36 PM
The criminal justice system isn't about proving innonecence.  At trial it's for the prosecution to prove beyond reasonable doubt the defendant is guilty.  At appeal it's for the defence to undermine the prosecutions case to an extent 3 appeal court judges deem its unsafe.

I believe new forensic tests will result in JB's conviction being overturned.
What will the new forensic tests reveal, and when do you expect them to take place?  I thought Jeremy’s latest explosive piece of evidence that would prove Sheila dunnit was that there was someone alive in the house while he was sat in the police car?
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Caroline on April 04, 2020, 01:02:44 PM
There doesn't need to be any existing forensic evidence to undermine test results presented at trial.

One set of test result with a different outcome won't cut it I'm afraid.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Caroline on April 04, 2020, 01:09:22 PM
What will the new forensic tests reveal, and when do you expect them to take place?  I thought Jeremy’s latest explosive piece of evidence that would prove Sheila dunnit was that there was someone alive in the house while he was sat in the police car?

They won't reveal anything and in order to be valid, the tests would have to be conducted with the exact criteria as that of the murder situation and would need to be repeated numerous times for consistency. Holly has been brainwashed by the AI forum where they all seem to think they're scientists. It's possibly the worst forum on this subject that I have ever read - Holly used to be objective until becoming a member of that rubbish.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Holly Goodhead on April 04, 2020, 01:10:07 PM
No, there is no evidence, that's why Holly wants to create some but she's starting from a biased position.

My position is no different from that which you held for many years until you decided JB is guilty as charged. 

Anyway let's desist from making any comments whatsoever  of a personal nature otherwise it has the potential to sow discord and disrupt the forum.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Holly Goodhead on April 04, 2020, 01:11:53 PM
They won't reveal anything and in order to be valid, the tests would have to be conducted with the exact criteria as that of the murder situation and would need to be repeated numerous times for consistency. Holly has been brainwashed by the AI forum where they all seem to think they're scientists. It's possibly the worst forum on this subject that I have ever read - Holly used to be objective until becoming a member of that rubbish.

I haven't seen the two tests discussed on any Internet forum.

Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on April 04, 2020, 01:18:22 PM
I haven't seen the two tests discussed on any Internet forum.
S this secret information that only a select few (including yourself) are in the know about?
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Caroline on April 04, 2020, 01:20:38 PM
I haven't seen the two tests discussed on any Internet forum.

You're starting to sound like someone we both know Holly.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Caroline on April 04, 2020, 01:23:15 PM
My position is no different from that which you held for many years until you decided JB is guilty as charged. 

Anyway let's desist from making any comments whatsoever  of a personal nature otherwise it has the potential to sow discord and disrupt the forum.

I'm not trying to be personal Holly, you used to be objective until the AI board - that's just an observation. In general you are one of the most level headed supporters but there are issues where I believe your judgment (not matter how genuine) is clouded.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Caroline on April 04, 2020, 01:25:51 PM
I haven't seen the two tests discussed on any Internet forum.

Discussed or. not, my post still stands! Any scientific test has to be valid and that only comes from repeating and using the same conditions and criteria. What happened on the night of the murders is an unknown quantity which means the same conditions can't be repeated.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Holly Goodhead on April 04, 2020, 01:25:54 PM
You're starting to sound like someone we both know Holly.

Can we desist with the personal comments please.

Do you really believe what was presented at trial by the likes of Malcolm Fletcher some 34 years ago is incapable of being undermined by experts using 21st century science and technology?
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Holly Goodhead on April 04, 2020, 01:30:21 PM
I'm not trying to be personal Holly, you used to be objective until the AI board - that's just an observation. In general you are one of the most level headed supporters but there are issues where I believe your judgment (not matter how genuine) is clouded.

The tests have nothing to do with any discussions that took place on IA or any other internet forum. 
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: barrier on April 04, 2020, 01:58:23 PM
I've posted a range of MOJ's which show they are difficult to rectify even when an individual such as Stefan Kizsko was manifestly innocent.  Unlike other MOJ's JB has been severely handicapped by lack of family support and having to rely on the likes of Mike Tesko.

I'm not aware of any forensic evidence that was destroyed pre trial?

Post trial exhibits have been destroyed against all protocols which could potentially have assisted JB advance his case or conversely seal his fate.

Indeed you have but what evidence can release him from his bonds?

What of the bedding,soon burnt weren't they?
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Holly Goodhead on April 04, 2020, 02:26:25 PM
Indeed you have but what evidence can release him from his bonds?

What of the bedding,soon burnt weren't they?

New forensic tests.

Nothing of evidential value was lost.  It's a myth that evidence was destroyed pre-trial.

Please refer to soc officer DC Hammersley's trial testimony which covers all soc exhibits:

http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=165.0


Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: barrier on April 04, 2020, 02:55:21 PM
New forensic tests.

Nothing of evidential value was lost.  It's a myth that evidence was destroyed pre-trial.

Please refer to soc officer DC Hammersley's trial testimony which covers all soc exhibits:

http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=165.0

So we're getting somewhere,nothing new in forensics will avail Bamber of his internment,so just what is the evidence not supplied in the last 35 yrs that will?
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Holly Goodhead on April 04, 2020, 04:14:36 PM
So we're getting somewhere,nothing new in forensics will avail Bamber of his internment,so just what is the evidence not supplied in the last 35 yrs that will?

Are you asking me or telling me?
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: barrier on April 04, 2020, 04:29:03 PM
Are you asking me or telling me?

I'm asking,I think,no I know they have the perpetrator where he belongs,forgive me if I'm wrong but are you not of the thought he is innocent,what will release from his bonds that as not been already declared? and why and where is it hidden.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Caroline on April 04, 2020, 04:41:29 PM
Can we desist with the personal comments please.

Do you really believe what was presented at trial by the likes of Malcolm Fletcher some 34 years ago is incapable of being undermined by experts using 21st century science and technology?

I think it probably could be if that is the intention, just as another set of experts could undermine their results. The purpose of such research isn't supposed to 'undermine' - that's the point, it's supposed to be unbiased, that's what makes it valid.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Caroline on April 04, 2020, 04:42:17 PM
The tests have nothing to do with any discussions that took place on IA or any other internet forum.

I'm not sure what difference that makes?
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Caroline on April 04, 2020, 04:44:24 PM
So we're getting somewhere,nothing new in forensics will avail Bamber of his internment,so just what is the evidence not supplied in the last 35 yrs that will?

Absolutely nothing.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: ISpyWithMyEye on April 04, 2020, 06:51:49 PM
There doesn't need to be any existing forensic evidence to undermine test results presented at trial.

But you said “new” forensic evidence will undermine his guilt, Holly

There isn’t any “new” evidence; there never has been; and there never will be
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: ISpyWithMyEye on April 04, 2020, 06:54:01 PM
What will the new forensic tests reveal, and when do you expect them to take place?  I thought Jeremy’s latest explosive piece of evidence that would prove Sheila dunnit was that there was someone alive in the house while he was sat in the police car?


Yes, that lasted all of two minutes until police proved Jeremy was lying

Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: ISpyWithMyEye on April 04, 2020, 07:07:24 PM
My position is no different from that which you held for many years until you decided JB is guilty as charged. 

Anyway let's desist from making any comments whatsoever  of a personal nature otherwise it has the potential to sow discord and disrupt the forum.


You don’t like it when you’re cornered, that’s the truth of it

You don’t have one shred of new/old evidence that even suggests one part of the investigation gave a wrong result

What you’re conveniently forgetting, Holly, is that Jeremy was proven to be guilty due to SEVERAL factors, all of which reinforced the obvious: only JEREMY BAMBER could have murdered his family.

You refuse to accept those facts, but that’s OK....no-one is remotely interested in your views or indeed Jeremy Bamber’s ludicrous weak claims. The courts are sick to death of him. They graciously allowed him his first appeal, and after hearing the evidence INCREASED his term to Life Without Parole.

In his second attempt to worm his way out, by which time forensics had moved forwards in leaps and bounds, it was established that the blood in the silencer contained 17 of Sheila’s markers, rather than the 13 markers which was good enough to prove in 1986 that it was Sheila’s blood. So when they discovered it actually contained SEVENTEEN markers of Sheila’s blood, the pathologist said the chances of that blood belonging to anyone else was a TRILLION to ONE. Big odds, Holly!

Good luck with that.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: ISpyWithMyEye on April 04, 2020, 07:31:15 PM
New forensic tests.

Nothing of evidential value was lost.  It's a myth that evidence was destroyed pre-trial.

Please refer to soc officer DC Hammersley's trial testimony which covers all soc exhibits:

http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=165.0


Not sure why you posted that long diatribe, Holly...

All it proves is that the police took swabs, as they would have

It also proves they weren’t particularly thorough, otherwise they’d have found the silencer Jeremy hid in the cupboard


There’s nothing of any significance in there at all. We all know they took samples...so what’s your point?
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Holly Goodhead on April 05, 2020, 07:58:27 AM

Not sure why you posted that long diatribe, Holly...

All it proves is that the police took swabs, as they would have

It also proves they weren’t particularly thorough, otherwise they’d have found the silencer Jeremy his in the cupboard


There’s nothing ig any significance in there at all. We all know they took samples...so what’s your point?

Some here new to the case were under the misguided idea that much forensic evidence was lost which isn't the case as evidenced by DC Hammersley's trial testimony which comprehensively covers all the seized exhibits.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Holly Goodhead on April 05, 2020, 08:10:49 AM

You don’t like it when you’re cornered, that’s the truth if it

You don’t have one shred of new/old evidence that even suggests one part of the investigation gave a wrong result

What you’re conveniently forgetting, Holly, is that Jeremy was proven to be guilty due to SEVERAL factors, all of which reinforced the obvious: only JEREMY BAMBER could have murdered his family.

You refuse to accept those facts, but that’s OK....no-one is remotely interested in your views or indeed Jeremy Bamber’s ludicrous weak claims. The courts are sick to death of him. They graciously allowed him his first appeal, and after hearing the evidence INCREASED his term to Life Without Parole.

In his second attempt to worm his way out, by which time forensics had moved forwards in leaps and bounds, it was established that the blood in the silencer contained 17 of Sheila’s markers, rather than the 13 markers which was good enough to prove in 1986 that it was Sheila’s blood. So when they discovered it actually contained SEVENTEEN markers of Sheila’s blood, the pathologist said the chances of that blood belonging to anyone else was a TRILLION to ONE. Big odds, Holly!

Good luck with that.

You are posting up way too much misinformation.  If you want to post up facts please check and provide cites and sources.

At the 2002 appeal the court determined the following which has no bearing on your assertions above:

497. We, therefore, consider the matter on the basis that the conclusions to be drawn from the DNA evidence are:

i) June Bamber's DNA was in the sound moderator at the time of the DNA examination;

ii) Sheila Caffell's DNA may have been in the sound moderator but it was not possible to conclude one way or the other whether it was; and

iii) there was evidence of DNA from at least one male.

Point 497 of the following:

http://www.homepage-link.to/justice/judgements/Bamber/index.html
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: ISpyWithMyEye on April 05, 2020, 10:59:19 AM
You are posting up way too much misinformation.  If you want to post up facts please check and provide cites and sources.

At the 2002 appeal the court determined the following which has no bearing on your assertions above:

497. We, therefore, consider the matter on the basis that the conclusions to be drawn from the DNA evidence are:

i) June Bamber's DNA was in the sound moderator at the time of the DNA examination;

ii) Sheila Caffell's DNA may have been in the sound moderator but it was not possible to conclude one way or the other whether it was; and

iii) there was evidence of DNA from at least one male.

Point 497 of the following:

http://www.homepage-link.to/justice/judgements/Bamber/index.html


You’re quoting from Jeremy Bamber’s campaign team, who cherry pick quotes — that’s kind of biased, I’d say

Of course June’s blood was possibly in the silencer too — Jeremy shot her point blank range between her eyes. In fact, forensics thought it possible both a mixture of June and Nevill’s blood was inside, which is to be expected — but there wasn’t enough to establish it was theirs. However, sense tells you it most likely was.

But what was established was that Sheila’s blood was most certainly inside the silencer. And the reason the appeal court judges made reference to the test taken in 1985 is that’s what the appeal was about. They were discussing the case that took place in 1986, and discussing the results from that case.

However, 13 markers of Sheila’s blood was found back then, which was sufficient proof that in all likelihood the blood was Sheila’s.

Remember, years later forensics retested that same blood as advances in analysis had moved on, and they discovered that SEVENTEEN markers of Sheila’s blood was in that sample — which proved beyond doubt it was Sheila’s blood. A forensic specialist tested that blood and supplied concrete evidence, so I don’t see how anyone can refute that...



Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Holly Goodhead on April 05, 2020, 11:08:09 AM

You’re quoting from Jeremy Bamber’s campaign team, who cherry pick quotes — that’s kind of biased, I’d say

Of course June’s blood was possibly in the silencer too — Jeremy shot her point blank range between her eyes. In fact, forensics thought it possible both a mixture of June and Nevill’s blood was inside, which is to be expected — but there wasn’t enough to establish it was theirs. However, sense tells you it most likely was.

But what was established was that Sheila’s blood was most certainly inside the silencer. And the reason the appeal court judges made reference to the test taken in 1985 that’s what the appeal was about. They were discussing the case that took place in 1986, and discussing the results from that case.

However, 13 markers of Sheila’s blood was found back then, which was sufficient proof to that in all likelihood the blood was Sheila’s.

Remember, years later forensics retested that same blood as advances in analysis had moved on, and they discovered that SEVENTEEN markers of Sheila’s blood was in that sample — which proved beyond doubt it was Sheila’s blood. A forensic specialist tested that blood and supplied concrete evidence, so I don’t see how anyone can refute that...

I am quoting from a doc produced by the three appeal court judges who make clear at point 497:

ii) Sheila Caffell's DNA may have been in the sound moderator but it was not possible to conclude one way or the other whether it was

http://www.homepage-link.to/justice/judgements/Bamber/index.html
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: APRIL on April 05, 2020, 11:20:01 AM
I am quoting from a doc produced by the three appeal court judges who make clear at point 497:

ii) Sheila Caffell's DNA may have been in the sound moderator but it was not possible to conclude one way or the other whether it was

http://www.homepage-link.to/justice/judgements/Bamber/index.html


But we can't pick out just one point and claim it to be the definitive of guilt or innocence of either Jeremy or Sheila. It's about the total and subsequent balance of ALL pointers.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Holly Goodhead on April 05, 2020, 11:25:59 AM

But we can't pick out just one point and claim it to be the definitive of guilt or innocence of either Jeremy or Sheila. It's about the total and subsequent balance of ALL pointers.

I'm not suggesting we can just pointing out the conclusions of the appeal court judges with regard to whether or not SC's DNA was in the silencer. 
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: ISpyWithMyEye on April 05, 2020, 04:39:57 PM
I am quoting from a doc produced by the three appeal court judges who make clear at point 497:

ii) Sheila Caffell's DNA may have been in the sound moderator but it was not possible to conclude one way or the other whether it was

http://www.homepage-link.to/justice/judgements/Bamber/index.html


If you read my previous reply, Holly, you’ll understand that the appeal court judges were examining the trial that took place in 1986.

I repeat: in 1986 forensics discovered 13 markers in the blood sample which belonged to Sheila, and 13 markers were evidence enough that the blood was Sheila’s.

However, when that same blood was tested years later, by which time forensic evidence had moved forward, the sample showed 17 markers that matched Sheila’s. The court was told that the likelihood of that blood belonging to anyone else was a trillion to one, which Im sure you’ll agree is huge odds.

I feel you’re trying to turn this into something that doesn’t exist...it’s been established it’s Sheila’s blood and by you trying to cast doubts is doing the opposite of what you’re desperately trying to achieve.

Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Caroline on April 05, 2020, 05:20:18 PM
What will the new forensic tests reveal, and when do you expect them to take place?  I thought Jeremy’s latest explosive piece of evidence that would prove Sheila dunnit was that there was someone alive in the house while he was sat in the police car?

Don't forget the suicide note!  @)(++(*

Jeremy hasn't sanctioned whatever Holly is doing, he never would because he's not in control of it. Whatever the tests are, they are done from the standpoint of bias - that's not how science works or is it an acceptable practice.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: G-Unit on April 05, 2020, 05:41:26 PM

If you read my previous reply, Holly, you’ll understand that the appeal court judges were examining the trial that took place in 1986.

I repeat: in 1986 forensics discovered 13 markers in the blood sample which belonged to Sheila, and 13 markers were evidence enough that the blood was Sheila’s.

However, when that same blood was tested years later, by which time forensic evidence had moved forward, the sample showed 17 markers that matched Sheila’s. The court was told that the likelihood of that blood belonging to anyone else was a trillion to one, which Im sure you’ll agree is huge odds.

I feel you’re trying to turn this into something that doesn’t exist...it’s been established it’s Sheila’s blood and by you trying to cast doubts is doing the opposite of what you’re desperately trying to achieve.

Are you saying that 13 of Sheila's DNA markers were found in blood 1986?
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: ISpyWithMyEye on April 05, 2020, 06:22:51 PM
Are you saying that 13 of Sheila's DNA markers were found in blood 1986?

Yes.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: ISpyWithMyEye on April 05, 2020, 06:32:35 PM
I am quoting from a doc produced by the three appeal court judges who make clear at point 497:

ii) Sheila Caffell's DNA may have been in the sound moderator but it was not possible to conclude one way or the other whether it was

http://www.homepage-link.to/justice/judgements/Bamber/index.html


You’re ignoring EVIDENCE again, Holly

For someone who keeps saying they only want people to post factual evidence rather than assumptions, when evidence is presented to you, you ignore it.

The blood test you’re referring to  — and which the appeal court judges discussed — was the first one carried out in 1985

That test showed that in all likelihood the blood was Sheila’s as it contained 13 of her markers, and her blood group was rare.

But when they repeated that test some years later, it showed that actually there were SEVENTEEN markers of Sheilas blood, meaning, it was a trillion to one that the blood could have belonged to anyone else.

It’s straightforward and isn’t hard to comprehend. I don’t see why you’re having difficulty with it...
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: G-Unit on April 05, 2020, 06:59:54 PM

You’re ignoring EVIDENCE again, Holly

For someone who keeps saying they only want people to post factual evidence rather than assumptions, when evidence is presented to you, you ignore it.

The blood test you’re referring to  — and which the appeal court judges discussed — was the first one carried out in 1985

That test showed that in all likelihood the blood was Sheila’s as it contained 13 of her markers, and her blood group was rare.

But when they repeated that test some years later, it showed that actually there were SEVENTEEN markers of Sheilas blood, meaning, it was a trillion to one that the blood could have belonged to anyone else.

It’s straightforward and isn’t hard to comprehend. I don’t see why you’re having difficulty with it...

490. Samples obtained from Sheila Caffell's natural mother and from other sources enabled the scientists to say with confidence that the major component did not come from Sheila Caffell. Because the blood sample of June Bamber no longer exists, it has not been possible to do a direct comparison between her DNA and that of the major component. However, it has been possible to obtain a sample from June Bamber's sister, Pamela Boutflour, which because closely related relatives are statistically more likely to have shared components than unrelated individuals, has enabled conclusions to be drawn. That evidence shows that it is about 3,500 times more likely that the major source of DNA was from a full sister of Pamela Boutflour, i.e. June Bamber, compared to it being from an unrelated female. Both Mr Clayton and Miss Tomlinson, the DNA experts from whom we have heard, assessed this as strong evidenced that the major component therefore comes from June Bamber.

497. We, therefore, consider the matter on the basis that the conclusions to be drawn from the DNA evidence are:

i) June Bamber's DNA was in the sound moderator at the time of the DNA examination;

ii) Sheila Caffell's DNA may have been in the sound moderator but it was not possible to conclude one way or the other whether it was; and

iii) there was evidence of DNA from at least one male.
http://www.homepage-link.to/justice/judgements/Bamber/index.html
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Miss Taken Identity on April 05, 2020, 07:27:16 PM
The criminal justice system isn't about proving innonecence.  At trial it's for the prosecution to prove beyond reasonable doubt the defendant is guilty.  At appeal it's for the defence to undermine the prosecutions case to an extent 3 appeal court judges deem its unsafe.

I believe new forensic tests will result in JB's conviction being overturned.


And do you think that will happen anytime soon holly?

Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on April 05, 2020, 07:30:27 PM
What possible reason would there have been for any human blood to be inside the silencer, never mind female blood, if it hadn’t been used in the murders?
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Miss Taken Identity on April 05, 2020, 07:36:38 PM
What possible reason would there have been for any human blood to be inside the silencer, never mind female blood, if it hadn’t been used in the murders?

Blood from the person removing the silencer? or the silencer being removed while being placed onto Sheilas body, and removed again.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Caroline on April 05, 2020, 07:38:18 PM
The criminal justice system isn't about proving innonecence.  At trial it's for the prosecution to prove beyond reasonable doubt the defendant is guilty.  At appeal it's for the defence to undermine the prosecutions case to an extent 3 appeal court judges deem its unsafe.

I believe new forensic tests will result in JB's conviction being overturned.

If you are talking abut tests that you have paid for then there would be a lot more to it than that. Firstly, how seriously do you think that the results would be taken when it becomes known that they were paid for by an Bamber is innocent suporter? They would need a lot more than one set of results that were significantly consistent not just something that you present and that's IF such tests showed what you were hoping for.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Myster on April 05, 2020, 08:16:57 PM

And do you think that will happen anytime soon holly?
As soon as her chief suspect in the McCann case is arrested no doubt.  8((()*/
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: clockend on April 05, 2020, 10:11:03 PM
490. Samples obtained from Sheila Caffell's natural mother and from other sources enabled the scientists to say with confidence that the major component did not come from Sheila Caffell. Because the blood sample of June Bamber no longer exists, it has not been possible to do a direct comparison between her DNA and that of the major component. However, it has been possible to obtain a sample from June Bamber's sister, Pamela Boutflour, which because closely related relatives are statistically more likely to have shared components than unrelated individuals, has enabled conclusions to be drawn. That evidence shows that it is about 3,500 times more likely that the major source of DNA was from a full sister of Pamela Boutflour, i.e. June Bamber, compared to it being from an unrelated female. Both Mr Clayton and Miss Tomlinson, the DNA experts from whom we have heard, assessed this as strong evidenced that the major component therefore comes from June Bamber.

497. We, therefore, consider the matter on the basis that the conclusions to be drawn from the DNA evidence are:

i) June Bamber's DNA was in the sound moderator at the time of the DNA examination;

ii) Sheila Caffell's DNA may have been in the sound moderator but it was not possible to conclude one way or the other whether it was; and

iii) there was evidence of DNA from at least one male.
http://www.homepage-link.to/justice/judgements/Bamber/index.html

IF my understanding is correct the court elucidates further and goes on to question if any of the DNA
Is from blood.
Mr Hayward, Mr Fletcher, Dr Lincoln for the defence, Mr Ismail, and Mr Mark Webster defence expert
all examined the sound moderator for the presence of blood.
To quote the court they said
Thus it is clear that no blood was ever seen by any of those who had examined the baffles on any baffle beyond the eighth one from the bullet exiting end and nor have any tests revealed the presence of blood beyond this point. Dr Lincoln in April 1986 specifically tested all the baffles for blood and found no trace of any beyond the eighth baffle.
They go on to say that the (ccrc) conclusion that the DNA was likely to have come from blood found in the silencer at the time was said to be justified because it was found deep within the silencer,
cannot be sustained.
They then considered how the DNA could get inside the sound moderator other than back splattering during the killings.
They considered contamination to be a significant possibility.
To quote they said
That conclusion certainly ignores, at the very least, the examination by Dr Lincoln who removed all the baffles and tested them all so that contamination of baffles, whether deep inside or not, was a possibility. Even more importantly it failed to consider the use made of the moderator as an exhibit at trial where no sort of precautions would have been taken.
They then considered Mr Webster the defence expert on his report dated 22/9/2002
on the risk of contamination where he put forth many points.
Mr Webster concluded,
"The CCRC, in their statement of reasons, more or less excluded the possibility of contamination. In my opinion, the Commission was wrong to do so."
The appeal court felt that the DNA results were rendered completely meaningless.
they concluded
 Thus we are satisfied that the DNA evidence does not lead to any conclusion that the verdicts were unsafe. They do not in any way establish how June Bamber's DNA came to be found in the moderator many years after the trial. Even if one were to reject the possibility of contamination and conclude that June Bamber's blood got into the moderator during the shooting, THAT WOULD NOT MEAN SHEILA CAFFELLS BLOOD WAS NOT IN THE SILENCER. THE FLAKE OF BLOOD THAT WAS GROUP TESTED WAS INDEPENDENT OF THE DNA FOUND ON THE BAFFLES ATTRIBUTED TO JUNE BAMBER. The evidence about the blood testing is not, in our judgment, in any way diminished by the DNA findings, even if one ignored the whole issue of contamination at a later date.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Holly Goodhead on April 06, 2020, 07:56:10 PM
IF my understanding is correct the court elucidates further and goes on to question if any of the DNA
Is from blood.
Mr Hayward, Mr Fletcher, Dr Lincoln for the defence, Mr Ismail, and Mr Mark Webster defence expert
all examined the sound moderator for the presence of blood.
To quote the court they said
Thus it is clear that no blood was ever seen by any of those who had examined the baffles on any baffle beyond the eighth one from the bullet exiting end and nor have any tests revealed the presence of blood beyond this point. Dr Lincoln in April 1986 specifically tested all the baffles for blood and found no trace of any beyond the eighth baffle.
They go on to say that the (ccrc) conclusion that the DNA was likely to have come from blood found in the silencer at the time was said to be justified because it was found deep within the silencer,
cannot be sustained.
They then considered how the DNA could get inside the sound moderator other than back splattering during the killings.
They considered contamination to be a significant possibility.
To quote they said
That conclusion certainly ignores, at the very least, the examination by Dr Lincoln who removed all the baffles and tested them all so that contamination of baffles, whether deep inside or not, was a possibility. Even more importantly it failed to consider the use made of the moderator as an exhibit at trial where no sort of precautions would have been taken.
They then considered Mr Webster the defence expert on his report dated 22/9/2002
on the risk of contamination where he put forth many points.
Mr Webster concluded,
"The CCRC, in their statement of reasons, more or less excluded the possibility of contamination. In my opinion, the Commission was wrong to do so."
The appeal court felt that the DNA results were rendered completely meaningless.
they concluded
 Thus we are satisfied that the DNA evidence does not lead to any conclusion that the verdicts were unsafe. They do not in any way establish how June Bamber's DNA came to be found in the moderator many years after the trial. Even if one were to reject the possibility of contamination and conclude that June Bamber's blood got into the moderator during the shooting, THAT WOULD NOT MEAN SHEILA CAFFELLS BLOOD WAS NOT IN THE SILENCER. THE FLAKE OF BLOOD THAT WAS GROUP TESTED WAS INDEPENDENT OF THE DNA FOUND ON THE BAFFLES ATTRIBUTED TO JUNE BAMBER. The evidence about the blood testing is not, in our judgment, in any way diminished by the DNA findings, even if one ignored the whole issue of contamination at a later date.

I don't believe Mr Ismail was involved with the blood/dna/silencer?

The court concluded the DNA evidence was "completely meaningless".

506. We have no doubt at all that if this evidence had been placed before a jury, they would have concluded, as we do, that in accordance with the emphasised part of Mr Webster's report quoted above, the DNA testing results were rendered "completely meaningless".

http://www.homepage-link.to/justice/judgements/Bamber/index.html
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Holly Goodhead on April 06, 2020, 07:57:33 PM
I don't believe Mr Ismail was involved with the blood/dna/silencer?

The court concluded the DNA evidence was "completely meaningless".

506. We have no doubt at all that if this evidence had been placed before a jury, they would have concluded, as we do, that in accordance with the emphasised part of Mr Webster's report quoted above, the DNA testing results were rendered "completely meaningless".

http://www.homepage-link.to/justice/judgements/Bamber/index.html

Bearing in mind Mr Webster was the defence expert.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: clockend on April 06, 2020, 09:02:34 PM
I don't believe Mr Ismail was involved with the blood/dna/silencer?

The court concluded the DNA evidence was "completely meaningless".

506. We have no doubt at all that if this evidence had been placed before a jury, they would have concluded, as we do, that in accordance with the emphasised part of Mr Webster's report quoted above, the DNA testing results were rendered "completely meaningless".

http://www.homepage-link.to/justice/judgements/Bamber/index.html

Hi Holly.
498v v) On 29 March 1999, Mr Martyn Ismail, another forensic scientist and Mr Mark Webster, the defence expert, examined the sound moderator for the presence of blood. No visible signs of blood were found and a number of discrete tests for blood were performed but no blood was detected. More extensive chemical tests were not performed because they might have reduced the chance of obtaining DNA profiles.

Yes i agree with you that the court found the DNA evidence completely meaningless.
What they reiterated though was that the flake of blood that was group tested was independent of the DNA
found on the baffles attributed to June Bamber,
The evidence about the blood testing is not, in our judgment, in any way diminished by the DNA findings, even if one ignored the whole issue of contamination at a later date.  (507)


So as i understand it the court found the flake of blood  tested by Mr Hayward was not diminished by the DNA
evidence, and that it was independent of the DNA evidence, meaning it stands alone.
This is what the court said about the evidence given by Mr Hayward of Sheilas blood in situ of the sound moderator
481
. The evidence of Mr Hayward was not to the effect that all the blood in the moderator had been tested but rather that some of that blood had been tested. Thus this was not a case where the scientist was saying that the only blood in the moderator came from Sheila Caffell. His evidence was that the blood tested came from Sheila Caffell although he acknowledged the remote possibility that even that blood was a mixture of blood from Nevill Bamber and June Bamber.

So he found sheilas blood in the moderator with only a remote possibility of it being a mixture of Nevills and Junes
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Holly Goodhead on April 06, 2020, 10:37:29 PM
Hi Holly.
498v v) On 29 March 1999, Mr Martyn Ismail, another forensic scientist and Mr Mark Webster, the defence expert, examined the sound moderator for the presence of blood. No visible signs of blood were found and a number of discrete tests for blood were performed but no blood was detected. More extensive chemical tests were not performed because they might have reduced the chance of obtaining DNA profiles.

Yes i agree with you that the court found the DNA evidence completely meaningless.
What they reiterated though was that the flake of blood that was group tested was independent of the DNA
found on the baffles attributed to June Bamber,
The evidence about the blood testing is not, in our judgment, in any way diminished by the DNA findings, even if one ignored the whole issue of contamination at a later date.  (507)


So as i understand it the court found the flake of blood  tested by Mr Hayward was not diminished by the DNA
evidence, and that it was independent of the DNA evidence, meaning it stands alone.
This is what the court said about the evidence given by Mr Hayward of Sheilas blood in situ of the sound moderator
481
. The evidence of Mr Hayward was not to the effect that all the blood in the moderator had been tested but rather that some of that blood had been tested. Thus this was not a case where the scientist was saying that the only blood in the moderator came from Sheila Caffell. His evidence was that the blood tested came from Sheila Caffell although he acknowledged the remote possibility that even that blood was a mixture of blood from Nevill Bamber and June Bamber.

So he found sheilas blood in the moderator with only a remote possibility of it being a mixture of Nevills and Junes

Martyn Ismail was an expert for the prosecution at 2002 appeal re SC being moved at soc. I haven't seen anything about him being involved with the blood/dna/silencer.

I agree with what you've posted other than the last sentence.  The tests carried out in 1985 were based on blood serology and incapable of identifying an individual.  The test results will be shared by others.  Dr Lincoln said 8% of the white British population.

Assuming blood was found in the silencer as FSS claimed it still begs the question how it came to be there:

- out of all the blood stained exhibits only the flake inside the silencer was capable of yielding the results produced by FSS.

- only the blood flake inside the silencer was exposed to environmental conditions which would be expected to degrade blood (for serology tests) rendering it incapable of yielding results: hot firearm discharge gases and cyanoacrylate fuming chamber.

- drawback would not be expected with the small calibre rifle, low velocity ammo, silencer and neck shots

- when drawback does occur tissue would be expected to present with the blood - none was present.

- when drawback does occur it normally presents with headshots.

- Nicholas sustained a contact headshot but his blood groups were not found.

- FSS had quality issues during the 80's and imo therein lies the problem. 
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Holly Goodhead on April 06, 2020, 10:43:48 PM
I better practice what I preach and add cites/sources:

Quality issues at 3.3.1

https://publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm201011/cmselect/cmsctech/writev/forensic/m61.htm
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: G-Unit on April 06, 2020, 10:54:43 PM

If you read my previous reply, Holly, you’ll understand that the appeal court judges were examining the trial that took place in 1986.

I repeat: in 1986 forensics discovered 13 markers in the blood sample which belonged to Sheila, and 13 markers were evidence enough that the blood was Sheila’s.

However, when that same blood was tested years later, by which time forensic evidence had moved forward, the sample showed 17 markers that matched Sheila’s. The court was told that the likelihood of that blood belonging to anyone else was a trillion to one, which Im sure you’ll agree is huge odds.

I feel you’re trying to turn this into something that doesn’t exist...it’s been established it’s Sheila’s blood and by you trying to cast doubts is doing the opposite of what you’re desperately trying to achieve.

It has taken me a while to find, but here it is;

At the date of the investigation into this case DNA testing was not available for consideration of the source of body fluids. Hence the blood samples and blood staining was not subjected to such testing and was only subjected to the much less sensitive blood group testing to which we have already referred.
http://www.homepage-link.to/justice/judgements/Bamber/index.html

Your claim that DNA evidence was involved in the 1986 trial is false.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Holly Goodhead on April 06, 2020, 11:23:56 PM
I better practice what I preach and add cites/sources:

Quality issues at 3.3.1

https://publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm201011/cmselect/cmsctech/writev/forensic/m61.htm

Here's the confirmation from Dr Lincoln that the blood flake supposedly found inside the silencer represents blood groups shared by 8% of the white British population. 
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: ISpyWithMyEye on April 07, 2020, 10:27:46 AM
Here's the confirmation from Dr Lincoln that the blood flake supposedly found inside the silencer represents blood groups shared by 8% of the white British population.


Whatever are you talking about, Holly?

What do you mean by “the blood flake SUPPOSEDLY found inside the silencer”?

There was nothing “supposedly” about it: the blood flake was found, hence why you’re able to quote what forensics discovered by that flake: the blood group is shared by 8% of the white British population.

What a strange thing for you to say 😳

I myself share that same blood group (please don’t try and pin it on me), but what WAS compelling was that besides the blood group being rare — and matching  Sheila’s — ultimately, after the second DNA testing carried out years later, SEVENTEEN of Sheila’s DNA markers were found to be in that blood sample, which meant the chances of that blood belonging to anyone else was a TRILLION to one. HUGE ODDS, eh?

I also believe (though I need to check) the maximum amount of markers are just 20: so in the first trial when they’d discovered 13 markers, although it was HIGHLY likely it was Sheila’s blood, it wasn’t absolute. However, after further analysis years later they discovered SEVENTEEN markers, which corroborated their initial beliefs — that blood flake came from Sheila Caffell.

ADDED to that is the damning evidence that the blood splattered back deep down into the silencer in only the way back spatter from a gunshot can. Thus, the pattern of blood deep inside the silencer is concrete proof that it came from Sheila Caffell when Jeremy Bamber shot her.

Any suggestion by JB’s “team” that the blood was planted is not only ridiculous, but scientifically impossible.

So all this talk that the blood isn’t Sheila’s highlights the desperation and stupidity of Jeremy Bamber and his small team of campaigners who clearly struggle with scientific facts.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: G-Unit on April 07, 2020, 10:41:01 AM

Whatever are you talking about, Holly?

What do you mean by “the blood flake SUPPOSEDLY found inside the silencer”?

There was nothing “supposedly” about it: the blood flake was found, hence why you’re able to quote what forensics discovered by that flake: the blood group is shared by 8% of the white British population.

What a strange thing for you to say 😳

I myself share that same blood group (please don’t try and pin it on me), but what WAS compelling was that besides the blood group being rare — and matching  Sheila’s — ultimately, after the second DNA testing carried out years later, SEVENTEEN of Sheila’s DNA markers were found to be in that blood sample, which meant the chances of that blood belonging to anyone else was a TRILLION to one. HUGE ODDS, eh?

I also believe (though I need to check) the maximum amount of markers are just 20: so in the first trial when they’d discovered 13 markers, although it was HIGHLY likely it was Sheila’s blood, it wasn’t absolute. However, after further analysis years later they discovered SEVENTEEN markers, which corroborated their initial beliefs — that blood flake came from Sheila Caffell.

ADDED to that is the damning evidence that the blood splattered back deep down into the silencer in only the way back spatter from a gunshot can. Thus, the pattern of blood deep inside the silencer is concrete proof that it came from Sheila Caffell when Jeremy Bamber shot her.

Any suggestion by JB’s “team” that the blood was planted is not only ridiculous, but scientifically impossible.

So all this talk that the blood isn’t Sheila’s highlights the desperation and stupidity of Jeremy Bamber and his small team of campaigners who clearly struggle with scientific facts.

Members might like to read this;

http://www.homepage-link.to/justice/judgements/Bamber/index.html

It makes it clear that no DNA tests were performed at the time of the first trial, and no DNA tests were performed on the 'blood flake'

Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: clockend on April 07, 2020, 01:06:12 PM
Martyn Ismail was an expert for the prosecution at 2002 appeal re SC being moved at soc. I haven't seen anything about him being involved with the blood/dna/silencer.

I agree with what you've posted other than the last sentence.  The tests carried out in 1985 were based on blood serology and incapable of identifying an individual.  The test results will be shared by others.  Dr Lincoln said 8% of the white British population.

Assuming blood was found in the silencer as FSS claimed it still begs the question how it came to be there:

- out of all the blood stained exhibits only the flake inside the silencer was capable of yielding the results produced by FSS.

- only the blood flake inside the silencer was exposed to environmental conditions which would be expected to degrade blood (for serology tests) rendering it incapable of yielding results: hot firearm discharge gases and cyanoacrylate fuming chamber.

- drawback would not be expected with the small calibre rifle, low velocity ammo, silencer and neck shots

- when drawback does occur tissue would be expected to present with the blood - none was present.

- when drawback does occur it normally presents with headshots.

- Nicholas sustained a contact headshot but his blood groups were not found.

- FSS had quality issues during the 80's and imo therein lies the problem.

Hi Holly
Taken from the court of Appeal 2002 posted below.
http://www.homepage-link.to/justice/judgements/Bamber/index.html

Your first question regarding Martyn Ismail,
498v v) On 29 March 1999, Mr Martyn Ismail, another forensic scientist and Mr Mark Webster, the defence expert, examined the sound moderator for the presence of blood. No visible signs of blood were found and a number of discrete tests for blood were performed but no blood was detected. More extensive chemical tests were not performed because they might have reduced the chance of obtaining DNA profiles.


Your next question regarding Dr Patrick Lincoln for the defence though not used at trial,
(thanks for posting Dr Lincolns questioning i found interesting)

point 460)
On the 29/4/1986 Dr Lincoln visited the forensic science lab and examined the material.
He said according to the appeal court
 He agreed with Mr Hayward's conclusion that the combination of blood groups revealed in his testing of the inside of the moderator could have come solely from Sheila Caffell but did not come from any one of the other individuals. He said that it was not clear from Mr Hayward's statement that he had obtained the blood from which the different group testings had been done from the same area of the moderator. If they were not from the same area, then the results could have originated from more than one individual.

These were his concerns as outlined in your post.
He again went to the laboratory to speak with Mr Hayward,
After this meeting
point 461)
In a letter to the defence solicitors, Dr Lincoln said that Mr Hayward "used this single flake to produce a solution from which he was able to determine the groups". He said that this meant that the possible explanation he had earlier suggested as to a combination of more than one persons blood no longer applied.

Your point about the tests showing  8 per cent of the white British population would share them, as postulated by Dr lincoln,
seems to me a misnomer,  As Essex police considered it to be only Sheila at first, then Jeremy Bamber,
as there was no forced entry to commit the heinous crime.
The forensic and ballistic experts concurred regarding how the blood was purchased into the sound moderator
Mr Fletcher said according to the appeals justice court
point (457)
457. Mr Fletcher, the firearms expert, gave evidence to explain how blood got into the moderator if it was attached, or into the barrel if there was no moderator attached. He said that the mechanism was complicated and not then fully appreciated. However, the expanding gas when the bullet left the muzzle was under normal circumstances distributed into the atmosphere. However with a contact shot there was no opportunity for this escape and the gas would follow the bullet into the wound as it expanded. Back pressure would then build up forcing the gas back out of the wound taking with it blood and tissue which would in effect be blasted back into the barrel if there was no moderator or into the moderator if one was attached. He said that even without direct contact, the same effect might occur but only if the gap between the end of the barrel, or the moderator if attached, and the skin was less than one millimetre. He said that the likelihood of such an occurrence was to an extent dependent on the part of the body to which the shot was delivered and the amount of blood present at that point.

458. If the shot to Shelia Caffell, which was a contact shot to the throat, had been fired without the moderator in place, he would have expected to find blood in the barrel of the gun. If the moderator was attached it was "virtually certain" that Sheila Caffell's blood would get into the moderator. There was, he said "a very slight possibility of it not happening, but very slight".

So the Ballistics expert was virtually certain that Sheilas blood would get in to the moderator
with only a slight possibility of it not happening.

Yes i have read literature that you and others have posted regarding drawback issues,
And yes i am sure allegedly mistakes have been made at some time by the FSS, allegedly in the
 Damiola Taylor case i read,
but i am convinced by the expert testimony, of the Forensics and Ballistics expert,
as was the court.
Of course Holly you are free to disagree,  by the way i am impressed by how much literature you have regarding this case



Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: ISpyWithMyEye on April 07, 2020, 01:20:09 PM
It has taken me a while to find, but here it is;

At the date of the investigation into this case DNA testing was not available for consideration of the source of body fluids. Hence the blood samples and blood staining was not subjected to such testing and was only subjected to the much less sensitive blood group testing to which we have already referred.
http://www.homepage-link.to/justice/judgements/Bamber/index.html

Your claim that DNA evidence was involved in the 1986 trial is false.


You’re WRONG, G-Unit


Since the advent of DNA testing in 1985, biological material (skin, hair, blood and other bodily fluids) has emerged as the most reliable physical evidence at a crime scene, particularly those involving sexual assaults and murders . DNA, or deoxyribonucleic acid, contains the complex genetic blueprint that distinguishes each individual person. Forensic testing can determine if distinctive patterns in the genetic material found at a crime scene matches the DNA in a potential perpetrator with better than 99% accuracy.


G-Unit, please desist from accusing me of being wrong, when it’s actually you who’s posting wrong information.

I’m becoming weary of this forum; constantly having to bat away ridiculous lies made by people who either have an agenda, or are simply devoid of knowledge.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: The General on April 07, 2020, 01:26:53 PM

You’re WRONG, G-Unit


Since the advent of DNA testing in 1985, biological material (skin, hair, blood and other bodily fluids) has emerged as the most reliable physical evidence at a crime scene, particularly those involving sexual assaults and murders . DNA, or deoxyribonucleic acid, contains the complex genetic blueprint that distinguishes each individual person. Forensic testing can determine if distinctive patterns in the genetic material found at a crime scene matches the DNA in a potential perpetrator with better than 99% accuracy.


G-Unit, please desist from accusing me of being wrong, when it’s actually you who’s posting wrong information.

I’m becoming weary of this forum; constantly having to bat away ridiculous lies made by people who either have an agenda, or are simply devoid of knowledge.
Chill out our kid. Let's not have a barney about it. Just keep at it with polite discourse; I'm enjoying reading these exchanges and learning a lot.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: ISpyWithMyEye on April 07, 2020, 01:32:37 PM
As soon as her chief suspect in the McCann case is arrested no doubt.  8((()*/

Off-topic, I know...but who does Holly think is responsible for MM’s disappearance?

I don’t follow that case, but know about it, obviously

Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: The General on April 07, 2020, 01:34:13 PM
Off-topic, I know...but who does Holly think is responsible for MM’s disappearance?

I don’t follow that case, but know about it, obviously
I'll let Holly explain. I don't agree, although, as usual, Holly's research and rigour is not in question.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: G-Unit on April 07, 2020, 02:28:31 PM

You’re WRONG, G-Unit


Since the advent of DNA testing in 1985, biological material (skin, hair, blood and other bodily fluids) has emerged as the most reliable physical evidence at a crime scene, particularly those involving sexual assaults and murders . DNA, or deoxyribonucleic acid, contains the complex genetic blueprint that distinguishes each individual person. Forensic testing can determine if distinctive patterns in the genetic material found at a crime scene matches the DNA in a potential perpetrator with better than 99% accuracy.


G-Unit, please desist from accusing me of being wrong, when it’s actually you who’s posting wrong information.

I’m becoming weary of this forum; constantly having to bat away ridiculous lies made by people who either have an agenda, or are simply devoid of knowledge.

All you need to do to prove me wrong is to disclose where you found the information you have quoted. If DNA testing was used in 1985/6 and 13 markers from Sheila Caffell's DNA were found where is the evidence of this?
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: ISpyWithMyEye on April 07, 2020, 05:40:57 PM
All you need to do to prove me wrong is to disclose where you found the information you have quoted. If DNA testing was used in 1985/6 and 13 markers from Sheila Caffell's DNA were found where is the evidence of this?


DNA testing was indeed used in 1985, G-Unit

Regarding the 13 markers found in Sheila’s blood in the first court case, it’s all there in the exhibits

I’ve seen them, everyone who’s read them has seen them, and if you care to look you’ll see them too

Here’s a link to DNA testing in 1985

https://www.sciencedirect.com/topics/neuroscience/dna-profiling

All this is in black and white , so what can’t you grasp about it?
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: ISpyWithMyEye on April 07, 2020, 06:16:48 PM
Just to save you trawling through the scientific information, I’ve attached an extract to show you that DNA was used in 1985

I hope this helps you, G-Unit

I do wonder, though, how the forensic team managed to identify 13 of Sheila’s DNA markers in the blood sample from the silencer, back in 1985 if, according to you, it wasn’t possible...

How do you think they did that?

🤨



[attachment deleted by admin]
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: G-Unit on April 07, 2020, 06:31:27 PM

DNA testing was indeed used in 1985, G-Unit

Regarding the 13 markers found in Sheila’s blood in the first court case, it’s all there in the exhibits

I’ve seen them, everyone who’s read them has seen them, and if you care to look you’ll see them too

Here’s a link to DNA testing in 1985

https://www.sciencedirect.com/topics/neuroscience/dna-profiling

All this is in black and white , so what can’t you grasp about it?

Where have you seen this evidence about 13 markers? Do you have a link?
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Holly Goodhead on April 07, 2020, 07:54:16 PM
Just to save you trawling through the scientific information, I’ve attached an extract to show you that DNA was used in 1985

I hope this helps you, G-Unit

I do wonder, though, how the forensic team managed to identify 13 of Sheila’s DNA markers in the blood sample from the silencer, back in 1985 if, according to you, it wasn’t possible...

How do you think they did that?

🤨

DNA evidence was not used in this case until the 2002 appeal.

Colin Pitchfork's case was the first in the UK to use DNA evidence and this was 1987.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Holly Goodhead on April 07, 2020, 07:57:53 PM
DNA evidence was not used in this case until the 2002 appeal.

Colin Pitchfork's case was the first in the UK to use DNA evidence and this was 1987.

Ground 15 is the sole ground upon which this case was referred to the Court by the CCRC. It is based upon the testing of the sound moderator for DNA, a technique that was not available at trial.

http://www.homepage-link.to/justice/judgements/Bamber/index.html
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: ISpyWithMyEye on April 07, 2020, 08:39:37 PM
Where have you seen this evidence about 13 markers? Do you have a link?

It’s in the official court exhibits which were carried out by forensics.

If you don’t find it, I shall look for you – but I’d rather not as it’s time consuming

It’s definitely there, G-Unit, and is a crucial piece of evidence, hence why I assumed you’d know about it...

Like I say, trawl through, and if you can’t find it I guess I’ll have to add that to my list of tasks...

Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: ISpyWithMyEye on April 07, 2020, 08:53:01 PM
Ground 15 is the sole ground upon which this case was referred to the Court by the CCRC. It is based upon the testing of the sound moderator for DNA, a technique that was not available at trial.

http://www.homepage-link.to/justice/judgements/Bamber/index.html


Look, I’ll find the evidence for you, Holly, but this shall be the last time

As I advised you previously, I feel a refresher course would help you immensely as you seem to have either forgotten much of the trial details, or perhaps you’d never read them through thoroughly at the beginning

Please, go through them all, so we can avoid these cumbersome posts where you keep asking me to provide evidence

This is so tiresome...


Soon as I get it (and I will) I’ll post it...but please refrain from constantly asking for evidence when you know full well it’s true!

I don’t ask you for evidence, but the reason for that is I know you can’t provide it, so I don’t bother.

Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Holly Goodhead on April 07, 2020, 09:08:26 PM

Look, I’ll find the evidence for you, Holly, but this shall be the last time

As I advised you previously, I feel a refresher course would help you immensely as you seem to have either forgotten much of the trial details, or perhaps you’d never read them through thoroughly at the beginning

Please, go through them all, so we can avoid these cumbersome posts where you keep asking me to provide evidence

This is so tiresome...


Soon as I get it (and I will) I’ll post it...but please refrain from constantly asking for evidence when you know full well it’s true!

I don’t ask you for evidence, but the reason for that is I know you can’t provide it, so I don’t bother.

I think you're having a  @)(++(*

I'm still waiting for the evidence that SC had her nails professionally manicured and polished in Maida Vale.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: ISpyWithMyEye on April 07, 2020, 09:46:56 PM
I think you're having a  @)(++(*

I'm still waiting for the evidence that SC had her nails professionally manicured and polished in Maida Vale.


Gosh, I’d forgotten all about that...it is true, though 😊

It’s also true that Jeremy didn’t visit the same establishment...he painted his fingernails himself 💅🏼

Or maybe Brett helped him...🥰

Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Caroline on April 07, 2020, 09:59:04 PM
DNA evidence was not used in this case until the 2002 appeal.

Colin Pitchfork's case was the first in the UK to use DNA evidence and this was 1987.

Pitchfork was indeed the first case to use DNA profiling;

https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2016/jun/07/killer-dna-evidence-genetic-profiling-criminal-investigation
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: G-Unit on April 07, 2020, 10:00:57 PM
It’s in the official court exhibits which were carried out by forensics.

If you don’t find it, I shall look for you – but I’d rather not as it’s time consuming

It’s definitely there, G-Unit, and is a crucial piece of evidence, hence why I assumed you’d know about it...

Like I say, trawl through, and if you can’t find it I guess I’ll have to add that to my list of tasks...

Thank you. It is, of course, a rule of the forum that evidence should be provided when claiming a fact, which I comply with. I have no intention of looking for the evidence to uphold your many unsubstantiated claims.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Caroline on April 07, 2020, 10:19:33 PM
Just to save you trawling through the scientific information, I’ve attached an extract to show you that DNA was used in 1985

I hope this helps you, G-Unit

I do wonder, though, how the forensic team managed to identify 13 of Sheila’s DNA markers in the blood sample from the silencer, back in 1985 if, according to you, it wasn’t possible...

How do you think they did that?

🤨

It was first described in 1985 by Alec Jeffreys, however, it wasn't actually used in a real life case until 1987 when Jeffery's helped the police find the killer of Lynda Mann and Dawn Ashworth by extracting a DNA profile from semen samples found on both victims, The police canvassed the local area taking blood and saliva from from over 5000 local men. Initially no matches were made however, it came to light that Colin Pitchfork had asked someone else to take his test offering some BS excuse and he was subsequently caught - his sample matched the profile and he admitted to the crimes.
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: ISpyWithMyEye on April 07, 2020, 11:46:55 PM
DNA evidence was not used in this case until the 2002 appeal.

Colin Pitchfork's case was the first in the UK to use DNA evidence and this was 1987.


So why did forensics bother to test the markers in the blood in 1985?
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: G-Unit on April 08, 2020, 09:41:33 AM

So why did forensics bother to test the markers in the blood in 1985?

Did they? Prove it!
Title: Re: Question to members
Post by: Holly Goodhead on April 08, 2020, 01:51:26 PM

So why did forensics bother to test the markers in the blood in 1985?

The blood tests carried out in 1985/6 were based on blood serology which identifies enzymes and proteins.  But the enzymes and proteins groups are not statistically individualising unlike DNA results. According to Dr Lincoln who was a senior lecturer in blood group serology, 8% of the white British population share the same enzyme and protein groups:

                                ABO     PGM.             EAP.           AK.     HP

Nevill Bamber       O     PGM1+         EAP BA     AK1     Hp2-1
June Bamber        A     PGM1+         EAP BA     AK2-1  Hp2-1
Daniel Caffell        O     PGM2+1+    EAP B        AK1      Hp2
Nicholas Caffell    O     PGM2+1+    EAP B       AK1      Hp2
Sheila Caffell         A     PGM1+         EAP BA    AK1      Hp2-1

ABO = Blood Group System (Antigens)

PGM = Phosphoglucomutase (Enzyme)

EAP = Erythrocyte Acid Phosphatase (Enzyme)

AK = Adenylate Kinase (Enzyme)

HP = Haptoglobin (Protein)