UK Justice Forum 🇬🇧
Disappeared and Abducted Children and Young Adults => Madeleine McCann (3) disappeared from her parent's holiday apartment at Ocean Club, Praia da Luz, Portugal on 3 May 2007. No trace of her has ever been found. => Topic started by: icabodcrane on April 07, 2013, 02:05:18 AM
-
... was asked by the police to prepare a report on the McCann case
The report was produced in court ( McCann v's Amaral re book banning )
(http://www.liv.ac.uk/media/livacuk/schoolofpsychology/cip/lee-rainbow.jpg)
Lee Rainbow stated in his report that he felt discrepancies in Gerry McCann's statement were of sufficient concern that a possible homicide involving the parents should be investigated with the same vigour that had previously been given to the abduction theory
He added that the McCann's behaviour was compatible with that of a couple covering up a tragedy
What does the forum make of his expert opinion ?
-
... was asked by the police to prepare a report on the McCann case
The report was produced in court ( McCann v's Amaral re book banning )
Lee Rainbow stated in his report that he felt discrepancies in Gerry McCann's statement were of sufficient concern that a possible homicide involving the parents should be investigated with the same vigour that had previously been given to the abduction theory
He added that the McCann's behaviour was compatible with that of a couple covering up a tragedy
What does the forum make of his expert opinion ?
THis:
In the summary of the 30-page report Mr Rainbow wrote: “The potential involvement of the family in the disappearance of Madeleine McCann cannot be discarded, and it can be considered that, when pondering the basis for research, this hypothesis deserves as much attention as the criminal with sexual motivations that has been previously prioritised.
“It should be stressed that there is no evidence to directly support an involvement of the family, yet given the absence of decisive evidence to prove the contrary, such a scenario has to be explored.” At court last week, Mr Amaral’s lawyer, Antonio Cabrita, read out a section of 37-year-old Mr Rainbow’s report which said: “The family is a lead that should be followed.”
http://justice4mccannfam.5forum.biz/t2450-what-lee-rainbow-actually-said
-
... was asked by the police to prepare a report on the McCann case
The report was produced in court ( McCann v's Amaral re book banning )
Lee Rainbow stated in his report that he felt discrepancies in Gerry McCann's statement were of sufficient concern that a possible homicide involving the parents should be investigated with the same vigour that had previously been given to the abduction theory
He added that the McCann's behaviour was compatible with that of a couple covering up a tragedy
What does the forum make of his expert opinion ?
THis:
In the summary of the 30-page report Mr Rainbow wrote: “The potential involvement of the family in the disappearance of Madeleine McCann cannot be discarded, and it can be considered that, when pondering the basis for research, this hypothesis deserves as much attention as the criminal with sexual motivations that has been previously prioritised.
“It should be stressed that there is no evidence to directly support an involvement of the family, yet given the absence of decisive evidence to prove the contrary, such a scenario has to be explored.” At court last week, Mr Amaral’s lawyer, Antonio Cabrita, read out a section of 37-year-old Mr Rainbow’s report which said: “The family is a lead that should be followed.”
http://justice4mccannfam.5forum.biz/t2450-what-lee-rainbow-actually-said
Thanks for the exact transcript
It appears that up until the British police got involved ( and Lee Rainbow in particular ) the 'abductor theory had been 'prioritised'
-
Yes, it was the UK police who suggested to the PJ to investigate parental involvement.
-
Yes, it was the UK police who suggested to the PJ to investigate parental involvement.
AGreed factually, but look at the emotional load given to the 'news'.
-
Yes, it was the UK police who suggested to the PJ to investigate parental involvement.
Isn't it normal practice for the police to clear the ground under their feet?
-
"Criminal profiling" has NOT a scientific basis.
It is a false science. So it can not be used to make statements which support one or another theory.
Heri.
-
@ debunker
So a cut and paste job by the Daily Express, replicated on a rabidly pro McCann forum, passes muster as evidence of the content of a 30 page document, does it ?
-
@ debunker
So a cut and paste job by the Daily Express, replicated on a rabidly pro McCann forum, passes muster as evidence of the content of a 30 page document, does it ?
Hello Faithlilly.
I asked a question further up.
Isn't it normal practice for the police to clear the ground under their feet?
-
@ debunker
So a cut and paste job by the Daily Express, replicated on a rabidly pro McCann forum, passes muster as evidence of the content of a 30 page document, does it ?
Hello Faithlilly.
I asked a question further up.
Isn't it normal practice for the police to clear the ground under their feet?
It is indeed but the point being made is Lee Rainbow, a man at the top of his profession in the UK, cited discrepancies in Gerry McCann's statement as grounds to make him a suspect. Those discrepancies have not simply vanished.
-
I was shocked at his conclusion that :
"The McCann's behaviour is consistant with that of a couple united in covering up a tragedy"
This is the top profiler in the land, remember, working for the police
-
I was shocked at his conclusion that :
"The McCann's behaviour is consistant with that of a couple united in covering up a tragedy"
This is the top profiler in the land, remember, working for the police
Ah the current 'top profiler in the land' - remind me, what happened to the previous 'top profiler in the land'?
Yep, one Paul Britton
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sciencetech/article-1311800/Real-life-police-Crackers-solve-cases-par-fortune-tellers.html
-
I was shocked at his conclusion that :
"The McCann's behaviour is consistant with that of a couple united in covering up a tragedy"
This is the top profiler in the land, remember, working for the police
Ah the current 'top profiler in the land' - remind me, what happened to the previous 'top profiler in the land'?
Yep, one Paul Britton
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sciencetech/article-1311800/Real-life-police-Crackers-solve-cases-par-fortune-tellers.html
Totally agree, registrar. Heri.
-
I was shocked at his conclusion that :
"The McCann's behaviour is consistant with that of a couple united in covering up a tragedy"
This is the top profiler in the land, remember, working for the police
Ah the current 'top profiler in the land' - remind me, what happened to the previous 'top profiler in the land'?
Yep, one Paul Britton
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sciencetech/article-1311800/Real-life-police-Crackers-solve-cases-par-fortune-tellers.html
Yet another professional who must be discredited in the McCann case then ? ... how many does that make now ?
-
I was shocked at his conclusion that :
"The McCann's behaviour is consistant with that of a couple united in covering up a tragedy"
This is the top profiler in the land, remember, working for the police
Ah the current 'top profiler in the land' - remind me, what happened to the previous 'top profiler in the land'?
Yep, one Paul Britton
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sciencetech/article-1311800/Real-life-police-Crackers-solve-cases-par-fortune-tellers.html
Yet another professional who must be discredited in the McCann case then ? ... how many does that make now ?
It is not the professional but the technique of "criminal profiling", a pseudoscience which never solved a single case explaining the mecanisms implied ... ie, if it resolves something, it is by chance as the fortune tellers ... Heri
-
I was shocked at his conclusion that :
"The McCann's behaviour is consistant with that of a couple united in covering up a tragedy"
This is the top profiler in the land, remember, working for the police
Ah the current 'top profiler in the land' - remind me, what happened to the previous 'top profiler in the land'?
Yep, one Paul Britton
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sciencetech/article-1311800/Real-life-police-Crackers-solve-cases-par-fortune-tellers.html
Yet another professional who must be discredited in the McCann case then ? ... how many does that make now ?
Nah, too much praise - Britton discredited himself - but I have a box set of 'Cracker' going cheap at 10 squid
If fantasy floats your boat
-
@ debunker
So a cut and paste job by the Daily Express, replicated on a rabidly pro McCann forum, passes muster as evidence of the content of a 30 page document, does it ?
Hello Faithlilly.
I asked a question further up.
Isn't it normal practice for the police to clear the ground under their feet?
It is indeed but the point being made is Lee Rainbow, a man at the top of his profession in the UK, cited discrepancies in Gerry McCann's statement as grounds to make him a suspect. Those discrepancies have not simply vanished.
Remind me, isn't there another top profiler involved in this case? An American?
I am sure after her in-depth studies she also concluded that the McCanns were involved in the cover-up too.
Didn't she go as far as to claim that Gerry brought Madeleine back to England (after she had been buried in a tourist spot down a few kilometres down the Algarve coast) in a knapsack on his back as he flew from Portugal to Heathrow and nobody spotted the corpse or sensed it in any way?
Profiling is hardly a reliable tool is it?
-
I was shocked at his conclusion that :
"The McCann's behaviour is consistant with that of a couple united in covering up a tragedy"
This is the top profiler in the land, remember, working for the police
Ah the current 'top profiler in the land' - remind me, what happened to the previous 'top profiler in the land'?
Yep, one Paul Britton
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sciencetech/article-1311800/Real-life-police-Crackers-solve-cases-par-fortune-tellers.html
Yet another professional who must be discredited in the McCann case then ? ... how many does that make now ?
It is not the professional but the technique of "criminal profiling", a pseudoscience which never solved a single case explaining the mecanisms implied ... ie, if it resolves something, it is by chance as the fortune tellers ... Heri
AFter the Rachel Nickell debacle, criminal profiling is not used in the UK. IIRC
-
Yes, it was the UK police who suggested to the PJ to investigate parental involvement.
Amaral states in his book that on the 4th of May 2007 that he suspected the parents might be involved. This would suggest that he did not prioritise abduction.
-
Yes, it was the UK police who suggested to the PJ to investigate parental involvement.
Amaral states in his book that on the 4th of May 2007 that he suspected the parents might be involved. This would suggest that he did not prioritise abduction.
There are also Portuguese newspaper reports which specifically state from police sources that the PJ suspected the parents on the first day of the investigation.
http://themaddiecasefiles.com/topic133.html#p1252
-
Believing in criminal profiling as a science (akin to physics or chemistry)
Is like a gambler believing in God - if the gambler joins the heavenly choir - he will get a warm welcome
If he dies and there ain't no heavenly choir - just a void - he's lost nothing.
He hedges his bets in other words.
Criminal profiling is as scientific as Krügel's 'quantum sniffing machine' is scientific
-
Lee Rainbow is not exactly an efficient kind of person.
The NPIA closed down at the end of last year but...
http://uk.linkedin.com/pub/lee-rainbow/45/760/879
Lee Rainbow's Overview
Current
BIA - Head of Profession at NPIA
and
http://www.liv.ac.uk/psychology/centres/centre-for-investigative-psychology/alumni/lee-rainbow/
Lee Rainbow
MSc in 1996
Lee Rainbow is currently the Head of Profession for Behavioural Investigative Advice within the National Policing Improvements Agency and secretary of the ACPO Sub-Committee for Behavioural Science.
Links
http://www.npia.police.uk/en/6852.htm
-
@ debunker
So a cut and paste job by the Daily Express, replicated on a rabidly pro McCann forum, passes muster as evidence of the content of a 30 page document, does it ?
Hello Faithlilly.
I asked a question further up.
Isn't it normal practice for the police to clear the ground under their feet?
It is indeed but the point being made is Lee Rainbow, a man at the top of his profession in the UK, cited discrepancies in Gerry McCann's statement as grounds to make him a suspect. Those discrepancies have not simply vanished.
Remind me, isn't there another top profiler involved in this case? An American?
I am sure after her in-depth studies she also concluded that the McCanns were involved in the cover-up too.
Didn't she go as far as to claim that Gerry brought Madeleine back to England (after she had been buried in a tourist spot down a few kilometres down the Algarve coast) in a knapsack on his back as he flew from Portugal to Heathrow and nobody spotted the corpse or sensed it in any way?
Profiling is hardly a reliable tool is it?
How do you mean 'involved' in the investigation ?
As far as I am aware, Lee Rainbow, the country's leading expert, who works exclusively for the police, was the only profiler to be given access to police information and evidence before coming to the conclusion that :
"The McCann's behaviour is consistant with that of a couple united in covering up a tragedy"
-
Yes, it was the UK police who suggested to the PJ to investigate parental involvement.
Amaral states in his book that on the 4th of May 2007 that he suspected the parents might be involved. This would suggest that he did not prioritise abduction.
Lee Rainbow, having access to the investigation, said the abductor theory had been prioritised ... and that that should change
Whether Amaral suspected the parents as early as the 4th of May or not, the fact remains that they were not investigated with the same vigour as a possible abduction had been ... until the British police advised otherwise
-
@ debunker
So a cut and paste job by the Daily Express, replicated on a rabidly pro McCann forum, passes muster as evidence of the content of a 30 page document, does it ?
Hello Faithlilly.
I asked a question further up.
Isn't it normal practice for the police to clear the ground under their feet?
It is indeed but the point being made is Lee Rainbow, a man at the top of his profession in the UK, cited discrepancies in Gerry McCann's statement as grounds to make him a suspect. Those discrepancies have not simply vanished.
Remind me, isn't there another top profiler involved in this case? An American?
I am sure after her in-depth studies she also concluded that the McCanns were involved in the cover-up too.
Didn't she go as far as to claim that Gerry brought Madeleine back to England (after she had been buried in a tourist spot down a few kilometres down the Algarve coast) in a knapsack on his back as he flew from Portugal to Heathrow and nobody spotted the corpse or sensed it in any way?
Profiling is hardly a reliable tool is it?
How do you mean 'involved' in the investigation ?
As far as I am aware, Lee Rainbow, the country's leading expert, who works exclusively for the police, was the only profiler to be given access to police information and evidence before coming to the conclusion that :
"The McCann's behaviour is consistant with that of a couple united in covering up a tragedy"
Please provide a link to that quote so that I can read it in context. It is a forum rule that you should provide links to support your claims. It is also simply polite to do so.
Quotes out of context are meaningless.
-
Yes, it was the UK police who suggested to the PJ to investigate parental involvement.
Amaral states in his book that on the 4th of May 2007 that he suspected the parents might be involved. This would suggest that he did not prioritise abduction.
Lee Rainbow, having access to the investigation, said the abductor theory had been prioritised ... and that that should change
Whether Amaral suspected the parents as early as the 4th of May or not, the fact remains that they were not investigated with the same vigour as a possible abduction had been ... until the British police advised otherwise
-
I have seen all too well what so-called experts are capable of in the UK. You only need to look at the Shirley McKie case in Scotland when WPC McKie was accused of leaving her finger prints at a murder scene yet she wasn't even there. The entire band of Scottish fingerprint experts came out against her yet in the final analysis they were shown to be WRONG. What a bunch of idiots! Experts? pah
Criminal Profilers can only give an opinion, nothing else!
-
@ debunker
So a cut and paste job by the Daily Express, replicated on a rabidly pro McCann forum, passes muster as evidence of the content of a 30 page document, does it ?
Hello Faithlilly.
I asked a question further up.
Isn't it normal practice for the police to clear the ground under their feet?
It is indeed but the point being made is Lee Rainbow, a man at the top of his profession in the UK, cited discrepancies in Gerry McCann's statement as grounds to make him a suspect. Those discrepancies have not simply vanished.
Remind me, isn't there another top profiler involved in this case? An American?
I am sure after her in-depth studies she also concluded that the McCanns were involved in the cover-up too.
Didn't she go as far as to claim that Gerry brought Madeleine back to England (after she had been buried in a tourist spot down a few kilometres down the Algarve coast) in a knapsack on his back as he flew from Portugal to Heathrow and nobody spotted the corpse or sensed it in any way?
Profiling is hardly a reliable tool is it?
How do you mean 'involved' in the investigation ?
As far as I am aware, Lee Rainbow, the country's leading expert, who works exclusively for the police, was the only profiler to be given access to police information and evidence before coming to the conclusion that :
"The McCann's behaviour is consistant with that of a couple united in covering up a tragedy"
Please provide a link to that quote so that I can read it in context. It is a forum rule that you should provide links to support your claims. It is also simply polite to do so.
Quotes out of context are meaningless.
There is nothing 'meaningless' about that quote, and you know it
You also know that it was read out publicly in a court of law and reported back via twitter from the Sky reporter present
There is no direct link because the Rainbow report does not appear in the translated police files ... but you know that too
I suppose the next step is to confine the 'known' opinion of Lee Rainbow to the 'Myths' section ....
*sigh*
-
@ debunker
So a cut and paste job by the Daily Express, replicated on a rabidly pro McCann forum, passes muster as evidence of the content of a 30 page document, does it ?
Hello Faithlilly.
I asked a question further up.
Isn't it normal practice for the police to clear the ground under their feet?
It is indeed but the point being made is Lee Rainbow, a man at the top of his profession in the UK, cited discrepancies in Gerry McCann's statement as grounds to make him a suspect. Those discrepancies have not simply vanished.
Remind me, isn't there another top profiler involved in this case? An American?
I am sure after her in-depth studies she also concluded that the McCanns were involved in the cover-up too.
Didn't she go as far as to claim that Gerry brought Madeleine back to England (after she had been buried in a tourist spot down a few kilometres down the Algarve coast) in a knapsack on his back as he flew from Portugal to Heathrow and nobody spotted the corpse or sensed it in any way?
Profiling is hardly a reliable tool is it?
How do you mean 'involved' in the investigation ?
As far as I am aware, Lee Rainbow, the country's leading expert, who works exclusively for the police, was the only profiler to be given access to police information and evidence before coming to the conclusion that :
"The McCann's behaviour is consistant with that of a couple united in covering up a tragedy"
Please provide a link to that quote so that I can read it in context. It is a forum rule that you should provide links to support your claims. It is also simply polite to do so.
Quotes out of context are meaningless.
There is nothing 'meaningless' about that quote, and you know it
You also know that it was read out publicly in a court of law and reported back via twitter from the Sky reporter present
There is no direct link because the Rainbow report does not appear in the translated police files ... but you know that too
I suppose the next step is to confine the 'known' opinion of Lee Rainbow to the 'Myths' section ....
*sigh*
Sorry I stand by my contention that a tiny quote from a 30 page document is largely meaningless when not seen in the context of the whole document.
For example this is a direct quote from the same document as you are quoting from. Not a single word changed.
“It should be stressed that there is no evidence to directly support an involvement of the family"
And an interesting comment from Goncalo Amaral's book, Ch 7.
All the same, according to the English profilers, there is a 90% chance that he [MURAT] is the guilty party.
You can sigh as much as you like but the fact remains that quotation you provide without context is meaningless.
-
I have seen all too well what so-called experts are capable of in the UK. You only need to look at the Shirley McKie case in Scotland when WPC McKie was accused of leaving her finger prints at a murder scene yet she wasn't even there. The entire band of Scottish fingerprint experts came out against her yet in the final analysis they were shown to be WRONG. What a bunch of idiots! Experts? pah
Criminal Profilers can only give an opinion, nothing else!
That's what I invited the forum to do ... discuss Lee Rainbow's opinion
So far, that invitation has not been taken up
Instead of just dismissing it out of hand by discrediting his profession ... doesn't anyone what to discuss the substance of his opinion ?
He felt that the McCann's behaviour was consistant with that of a couple united in covering up a tragedy
That must be worthy of some debate, surely ?
-
His opinion is probably consistent with what he has gleaned from reading the statements. It doesn't prove anything however as many other conclusions can also be drawn form the same statements.
-
I have seen all too well what so-called experts are capable of in the UK. You only need to look at the Shirley McKie case in Scotland when WPC McKie was accused of leaving her finger prints at a murder scene yet she wasn't even there. The entire band of Scottish fingerprint experts came out against her yet in the final analysis they were shown to be WRONG. What a bunch of idiots! Experts? pah
Criminal Profilers can only give an opinion, nothing else!
That's what I invited the forum to do ... discuss Lee Rainbow's opinion
So far, that invitation has not been taken up
Instead of just dismissing it out of hand by discrediting his profession ... doesn't anyone what to discuss the substance of his opinion ?
He felt that the McCann's behaviour was consistant with that of a couple united in covering up a tragedy
That must be worthy of some debate, surely ?
I have actually discussed his opinion if you care to notice. I didn't like to be rude about the man but he seems confused and inconsistent because he also states in the same report that
“It should be stressed that there is no evidence to directly support an involvement of the family"
My own view is similar to John's. Rainbow has formed an opinion (consistent or confused) based on what he has read. The opinion he has formed is his own.
I have also formed an opinion based on what I have read. My opinion is that there is no evidence which would stand up in any court anywhere which could prove exactly what happened that night and who was involved.
-
I have seen all too well what so-called experts are capable of in the UK. You only need to look at the Shirley McKie case in Scotland when WPC McKie was accused of leaving her finger prints at a murder scene yet she wasn't even there. The entire band of Scottish fingerprint experts came out against her yet in the final analysis they were shown to be WRONG. What a bunch of idiots! Experts? pah
Criminal Profilers can only give an opinion, nothing else!
That's what I invited the forum to do ... discuss Lee Rainbow's opinion
So far, that invitation has not been taken up
Instead of just dismissing it out of hand by discrediting his profession ... doesn't anyone what to discuss the substance of his opinion ?
He felt that the McCann's behaviour was consistant with that of a couple united in covering up a tragedy
That must be worthy of some debate, surely ?
Nomore worthy of debate than the views of diviners or mystics.
OF course the McCanns should have been suspects. An adequate interpretation of the evidence should have closed that line of enquiry, but instead the PJ fell for thepseudo science of the dogs and totally misunderstood the DNA results.
-
His opinion is probably consistent with what he has gleaned from reading the statements. It doesn't prove anything however as many other conclusions can also be drawn form the same statements.
Well I think it presents a fresh angle on that well worn claim ... 'If the McCanns were not telling the truth, they would just keep quiet and out of the public eye'
Frequently, their high profile campaigning has been presented as 'proof' of their lack of involement in their child's disappearance
Lee Rainbow, however, saw that behaviour as being consistant with a couple united in covering up a tragedy, which is interesting
-
His opinion is probably consistent with what he has gleaned from reading the statements. It doesn't prove anything however as many other conclusions can also be drawn form the same statements.
Quite - it's that blurring of opinion pieces, with oftentimes badly translated pieces from the PT media and genuine
fact that has the armchair detectives in a tizzy.
I'm of the opinion my horse should have won the Grand National - however it didn't - and I got over that particularly emotional hurdle.
Last time I checked all 3 ex-arguidos were free and innocent people in their respective countries.
-
His opinion is probably consistent with what he has gleaned from reading the statements. It doesn't prove anything however as many other conclusions can also be drawn form the same statements.
Well I think it presents a fresh angle on that well worn claim ... 'If the McCanns were not telling the truth, they would just keep quiet and out of the public eye'
Frequently, their high profile campaigning has been presented as 'proof' of their lack of involement in their child's disappearance
Lee Rainbow, however, saw that behaviour as being consistant with a couple united in covering up a tragedy, which is interesting
Again just one man's opinion.
Not mine though.
I can fully understand why any parents whose daughter is missing would want the search for their daughter to continue. It seems the most natural thing in the world reaction in the world to me. Nothing to do with covering up a tragedy, simply parental instinct.
-
His opinion is probably consistent with what he has gleaned from reading the statements. It doesn't prove anything however as many other conclusions can also be drawn form the same statements.
Well I think it presents a fresh angle on that well worn claim ... 'If the McCanns were not telling the truth, they would just keep quiet and out of the public eye'
Frequently, their high profile campaigning has been presented as 'proof' of their lack of involement in their child's disappearance
Lee Rainbow, however, saw that behaviour as being consistant with a couple united in covering up a tragedy, which is interesting
They could well have just been united in a tragedy. We now know all too well of what happens every time they open their mouths. No wonder they need a spokesman. But even he is torn to shreds on nothing much at all. And he didn't even know The McCanns beforehand.
-
His opinion is probably consistent with what he has gleaned from reading the statements. It doesn't prove anything however as many other conclusions can also be drawn form the same statements.
Quite - it's that blurring of opinion pieces, with oftentimes badly translated pieces from the PT media and genuine
fact that has the armchair detectives in a tizzy.
I'm of the opinion my horse should have won the Grand National - however it didn't - and I got over that particularly emotional hurdle.
Last time I checked all 3 ex-arguidos were free and innocent people in their respective countries.
And the Portuguese guy who was supposed to be in charge of investigating them has a criminal conviction hanging over his head. What does that say? 8)-)))
I wonder what Lee Rainbow would say about Mr Amaral's conduct?
-
I have seen all too well what so-called experts are capable of in the UK. You only need to look at the Shirley McKie case in Scotland when WPC McKie was accused of leaving her finger prints at a murder scene yet she wasn't even there. The entire band of Scottish fingerprint experts came out against her yet in the final analysis they were shown to be WRONG. What a bunch of idiots! Experts? pah
Criminal Profilers can only give an opinion, nothing else!
That's what I invited the forum to do ... discuss Lee Rainbow's opinion
So far, that invitation has not been taken up
Instead of just dismissing it out of hand by discrediting his profession ... doesn't anyone what to discuss the substance of his opinion ?
He felt that the McCann's behaviour was consistant with that of a couple united in covering up a tragedy
That must be worthy of some debate, surely ?
I have actually discussed his opinion if you care to notice. I didn't like to be rude about the man but he seems confused and inconsistent because he also states in the same report that
“It should be stressed that there is no evidence to directly support an involvement of the family"
My own view is similar to John's. Rainbow has formed an opinion (consistent or confused) based on what he has read. The opinion he has formed is his own.
I have also formed an opinion based on what I have read. My opinion is that there is no evidence which would stand up in any court anywhere which could prove exactly what happened that night and who was involved.
Well, comparing your own opinion with that of the top police profiler who had access to information you are, without doubt, not even aware of, is ... well ... your perogative I suppose
-
His opinion is probably consistent with what he has gleaned from reading the statements. It doesn't prove anything however as many other conclusions can also be drawn form the same statements.
Quite - it's that blurring of opinion pieces, with oftentimes badly translated pieces from the PT media and genuine
fact that has the armchair detectives in a tizzy.
I'm of the opinion my horse should have won the Grand National - however it didn't - and I got over that particularly emotional hurdle.
Last time I checked all 3 ex-arguidos were free and innocent people in their respective countries.
And the Portuguese guy who was supposed to be in charge of investigating them has a criminal conviction hanging over his head. What does that say? 8)-)))
And the person responsible for the Interim (Intercalary) Report which people like Hideho and Bennett depend on so much was convicted of actual torture of a suspect.
http://www.cmjornal.xl.pt/detalhe/noticias/nacional/portugal/pena-suspensa-para-dupla-da-pj-condenada-por-tortura
Two chief inspectors of the PJ were sentenced on Friday to two years and six months imprisonment with suspended sentence for torture against official Virgolino CP Borges, the victim's lawyer told Lusa.
The news of the sentencing of two inspectors of the Judicial Police was advanced by SIC Notícias.
The collective of judges of the 3rd stick criminal Lisbon condemned the torture inspectors Chief Joseph Diamantino Santos and Vitor Tavares de Almeida and the payment of a fine of 80 euros / month for the same period, attorney Jerónimo Martins told Lusa.
-
I have seen all too well what so-called experts are capable of in the UK. You only need to look at the Shirley McKie case in Scotland when WPC McKie was accused of leaving her finger prints at a murder scene yet she wasn't even there. The entire band of Scottish fingerprint experts came out against her yet in the final analysis they were shown to be WRONG. What a bunch of idiots! Experts? pah
Criminal Profilers can only give an opinion, nothing else!
That's what I invited the forum to do ... discuss Lee Rainbow's opinion
So far, that invitation has not been taken up
Instead of just dismissing it out of hand by discrediting his profession ... doesn't anyone what to discuss the substance of his opinion ?
He felt that the McCann's behaviour was consistant with that of a couple united in covering up a tragedy
That must be worthy of some debate, surely ?
I have actually discussed his opinion if you care to notice. I didn't like to be rude about the man but he seems confused and inconsistent because he also states in the same report that
“It should be stressed that there is no evidence to directly support an involvement of the family"
My own view is similar to John's. Rainbow has formed an opinion (consistent or confused) based on what he has read. The opinion he has formed is his own.
I have also formed an opinion based on what I have read. My opinion is that there is no evidence which would stand up in any court anywhere which could prove exactly what happened that night and who was involved.
Well, comparing your own opinion with that of the top police profiler who had access to information you are, without doubt, not even aware of, is ... well ... your perogative I suppose
Correct, it is. No 'suppose' about it.
-
AFter the Rachel Nickell debacle, criminal profiling is not used in the UK. IIRC
This reminds me that Lee Rainbow suggested to "question" the twins, as Rachel Nickell's son's talk, about the same age, was helpful.
Are you sure Lee Rainbow said "The McCann's behaviour is consistant with that of a couple united in covering up a tragedy" ?
-
A closed mind is a dangerous thing
And in my opinion Amaral's mind was closed within hours of getting the call to co-ordinate the investigation.
Don't they call it the 'golden hour' or somesuch - after a person disappears - the actions that are carried out within that timeframe often determine the outcome of said investigation.
Giving Amaral the benefit of the doubt for a mo - he might have genuinely believed the girl had woken and wandered - and all will be well in the morn
- which at best makes him a very optimistic chap - at worst a lazy and negligent cop.
-
There are also Portuguese newspaper reports which specifically state from police sources that the PJ suspected the parents on the first day of the investigation.
http://themaddiecasefiles.com/topic133.html#p1252
No, this article only speaks of a story badly told. Just remember the shutters and window forced according some and not forced according others.
-
There are also Portuguese newspaper reports which specifically state from police sources that the PJ suspected the parents on the first day of the investigation.
http://themaddiecasefiles.com/topic133.html#p1252
No, this article only speaks of a story badly told. Just remember the shutters and window forced according some and not forced according others.
Not sure I am following you. That news article quotes the police as already being suspicious of the people who had given the statements. Thats the point.
-
My opinion is that there is no evidence which would stand up in any court anywhere which could prove exactly what happened that night and who was involved.
Sure ! As it was the Public Ministry's opinion too, a reconstruction was planned, being the only hope to understand likely not what happened but at least what didn't !
-
Frequently, their high profile campaigning has been presented as 'proof' of their lack of involvement in their child's disappearance
Yes, this is the argument of those who deeply feel a shadow of a doubt.
Let's imagine for a second they're involved, wouldn't that precisely be the smartest thing to do?
-
My opinion is that there is no evidence which would stand up in any court anywhere which could prove exactly what happened that night and who was involved.
Sure ! As it was the Public Ministry's opinion too, a reconstruction was planned, being the only hope to understand likely not what happened but at least what didn't !
And yet the PJ determined that no reconstruction would take place early on in the case because it would upset the holidaymakers and they would have to close air space. That shows real commitment to finding a little missing girl, I don't think.
-
Frequently, their high profile campaigning has been presented as 'proof' of their lack of involvement in their child's disappearance
Yes, this is the argument of those who deeply feel a shadow of a doubt.
Let's imagine for a second they're involved, wouldn't that precisely be the smartest thing to do?
And lets imagine for a moment that they are not involved, wouldn't that be the most instinctive and natural and smartest thing to do?
They are parents against whom no evidence of a crime was found after lengthy investigation by two police forces, seeking their missing child or had that fact passed you by?
-
Don't they call it the 'golden hour' or somesuch - after a person disappears - the actions that are carried out within that timeframe often determine the outcome of said investigation.
Yes but the "golden hour" (Mark Harrison's expression) was wasted by their not calling immediately (when Mrs McCann hurryied back to the Tapas Bar) on their cell phones the European alert nb 112 that answers in English and would have sent the PJ right away.
-
Frequently, their high profile campaigning has been presented as 'proof' of their lack of involvement in their child's disappearance
Yes, this is the argument of those who deeply feel a shadow of a doubt.
Let's imagine for a second they're involved, wouldn't that precisely be the smartest thing to do?
And lets imagine for a moment that they are not involved, wouldn't that be the most instinctive and natural and smartest thing to do?
They are parents against whom no evidence of a crime was found after lengthy investigation by two police forces, seeking their missing child or had that fact passed you by?
Oh I said "let's imagine", nothing more ! And just to suggest this is no argument for the McCanns' innocence (evidence needed a reconstruction, as the PR said in his report).
-
Frequently, their high profile campaigning has been presented as 'proof' of their lack of involvement in their child's disappearance
Yes, this is the argument of those who deeply feel a shadow of a doubt.
Let's imagine for a second they're involved, wouldn't that precisely be the smartest thing to do?
And lets imagine for a moment that they are not involved, wouldn't that be the most instinctive and natural and smartest thing to do?
They are parents against whom no evidence of a crime was found after lengthy investigation by two police forces, seeking their missing child or had that fact passed you by?
Oh I said "let's imagine", nothing more ! And just to suggest this is no argument for the McCanns' innocence (evidence needed a reconstruction, as the PR said in his report).
SWo why did Amaral refuse to do a Reconstruction when it might have been of some use?
-
Don't they call it the 'golden hour' or somesuch - after a person disappears - the actions that are carried out within that timeframe often determine the outcome of said investigation.
Yes but the "golden hour" (Mark Harrison's expression) was wasted by their not calling immediately (when Mrs McCann hurryied back to the Tapas Bar) on their cell phones the European alert nb 112 that answers in English and would have sent the PJ right away.
Do you really think that the Tapas group would have been aware of the 112 number which was almost wholly unknown in the UK in 2007? Do you really think they would have known as you state that they would have got an answer in English on that number? (Incidentally I am not certain that this is true. My understanding is that the operator will have understanding of English but will respond in their own language. Can you clarify?)
Here is a report from three years after the disappearance which specifies that only 10% of English people even then were aware of the 112 number.
http://ec.europa.eu/news/justice/100211_en.htm
I know that I was not aware of the 112 number in 2007. A specific incident in mid 2008 brought it to my attention and I know that I would have had no idea what number to use to call the police directly in Portugal. I suspect the McCanns did the best thing they could by getting the reception to contact the police for them.
-
Cos it would have interfered with flight paths and things
-
Cos it would have interfered with flight paths and things
So what was the difference in April/May 2008?
-
Don't they call it the 'golden hour' or somesuch - after a person disappears - the actions that are carried out within that timeframe often determine the outcome of said investigation.
Yes but the "golden hour" (Mark Harrison's expression) was wasted by their not calling immediately (when Mrs McCann hurryied back to the Tapas Bar) on their cell phones the European alert nb 112 that answers in English and would have sent the PJ right away.
Do you really think that the Tapas group would have been aware of the 112 number which was almost wholly unknown in the UK in 2007? Do you really think they would have known as you state that they would have got an answer in English on that number? (Incidentally I am not certain that this is true. My understanding is that the operator will have understanding of English but will respond in their own language. Can you clarify?)
Here is a report from three years after the disappearance which specifies that only 10% of English people even then were aware of the 112 number.
http://ec.europa.eu/news/justice/100211_en.htm
I know that I was not aware of the 112 number in 2007. A specific incident in mid 2008 brought it to my attention and I know that I would have had no idea what number to use to call the police directly in Portugal. I suspect the McCanns did the best thing they could by getting the reception to contact the police for them.
Everybody knew that nb in Portugal and dialing this nb you're attended at least in Basic English (experiment !). Don't you realize that all Tapas employees, except for the gardeners may be, speak English and don't you realize the McCann knew it after spending 5 days in the resort ? The Tapas employees would have given the alert nb if they had been told the shutters/window had been forced. The main reception guy called first the OC manager... And calling the GNR instead of the PJ he showed he didn't suspect an abduction.
-
Frequently, their high profile campaigning has been presented as 'proof' of their lack of involvement in their child's disappearance
Yes, this is the argument of those who deeply feel a shadow of a doubt.
Let's imagine for a second they're involved, wouldn't that precisely be the smartest thing to do?
And lets imagine for a moment that they are not involved, wouldn't that be the most instinctive and natural and smartest thing to do?
They are parents against whom no evidence of a crime was found after lengthy investigation by two police forces, seeking their missing child or had that fact passed you by?
Oh I said "let's imagine", nothing more ! And just to suggest this is no argument for the McCanns' innocence (evidence needed a reconstruction, as the PR said in his report).
SWo why did Amaral refuse to do a Reconstruction when it might have been of some use?
Exactly, why did the PJ put the safety of a missing little girl ahead of the convenience of the holidaymakers whose holidays would be disturbed by a reconstruction just days after the disappearance when it would have been of real value in assisting with that search?
-
Cos it would have interfered with flight paths and things
So what was the difference in April/May 2008?
planes flew higher
-
Cos it would have interfered with flight paths and things
So what was the difference in April/May 2008?
planes flew higher
ORLY.
-
Don't they call it the 'golden hour' or somesuch - after a person disappears - the actions that are carried out within that timeframe often determine the outcome of said investigation.
Yes but the "golden hour" (Mark Harrison's expression) was wasted by their not calling immediately (when Mrs McCann hurryied back to the Tapas Bar) on their cell phones the European alert nb 112 that answers in English and would have sent the PJ right away.
Do you really think that the Tapas group would have been aware of the 112 number which was almost wholly unknown in the UK in 2007? Do you really think they would have known as you state that they would have got an answer in English on that number? (Incidentally I am not certain that this is true. My understanding is that the operator will have understanding of English but will respond in their own language. Can you clarify?)
Here is a report from three years after the disappearance which specifies that only 10% of English people even then were aware of the 112 number.
http://ec.europa.eu/news/justice/100211_en.htm
I know that I was not aware of the 112 number in 2007. A specific incident in mid 2008 brought it to my attention and I know that I would have had no idea what number to use to call the police directly in Portugal. I suspect the McCanns did the best thing they could by getting the reception to contact the police for them.
Everybody knew that nb in Portugal and dialing this nb you're attended at least in Basic English (experiment !). Don't you realize that all Tapas employees, except for the gardeners may be, speak English and don't you realize the McCann knew it after spending 5 days in the resort ? The Tapas employees would have given the alert nb if they had been told the shutters/window had been forced. The main reception guy called first the OC manager... And calling the GNR instead of the PJ he showed he didn't suspect an abduction.
Please give evidence for your claim that "everybody knew that nb in Portugal". I think you are exaggerating. The report I have posted does not even in 2010 have 50% of the population there knowing it. It lists only Czech Republic, Luxembourg, Poland, Slovakia and Finland where more than 50% knew the number.
As for your suggestion that I experiment/play with the 112 number I find that an appalling thing for you to say. I don't know about Portugal but here in the UK it is rightly a criminal offence to play games with that emergency number.
A quote from the report I posted regarding language (remember this is 3 years after 2007)
Language continues to be a problem. One in 10 respondents who had called 112 abroad complained they had difficulty communicating with the operator. In most cases the calls were handled in the language of the country they were visiting.
I maintain that the McCanns would almost certainly not have known that number and even more certainly would not have been aware that having been answered in Portuguese they would have been able to converse with the person in basic English.
I maintain that they did the logical and most natural thing in the circumstances. They approached the reception of the complex where they were staying. It is exactly what I would have done at the time and exactly what I did in mid 2008 when I had need of police assistance while abroad. It was after that that I learned of the 112 number.
-
Cos it would have interfered with flight paths and things
So what was the difference in April/May 2008?
planes flew higher
ORLY.
sorry - my reply was a little flippant - what I meant to say say was - read a little and learn a lot.
In other words - bollocks
-
So what was the difference in April/May 2008?
Much less media, hopefully none !
Up to the middle of May they were looking for an alive Madeleine, then Robert M became arguido but, unfortunately, Martin S stated RM wasn't the carrier of the little girl. Then it was June, the TP7 had gone and lots of tourists arrived. They should have done it then, even if the climatic and light conditions and also state of vegetation were different. Doing it a year after would have been better than nothing, at least for the McCann, as the PR said.
-
why did the PJ put the safety of a missing little girl ahead of the convenience of the holidaymakers whose holidays would be disturbed by a reconstruction just days after the disappearance when it would have been of real value in assisting with that search?
You wouldn't write this if you knew this country, which is not mine but where I live. In Portugal children are princes and treated this way ! (Holidaymakers aren't : it's clear they come here only because of the sun and the sea).
-
I maintain that they did the logical and most natural thing in the circumstances. They approached the reception of the complex where they were staying. It is exactly what I would have done at the time and exactly what I did in mid 2008 when I had need of police assistance while abroad. It was after that that I learned of the 112 number.
So you had the same awful experience of a missing child ? Did you wait half an hour before sending someone to a five minutes walking distance place, whereas you had a cell phone and a local nearby knowing the alert nb (taught in primary school here in Portugal) ? I suppose everything ended well.
Do you need a link proving every employee in the OC speaks English ?
-
Don't they call it the 'golden hour' or somesuch - after a person disappears - the actions that are carried out within that timeframe often determine the outcome of said investigation.
Yes but the "golden hour" (Mark Harrison's expression) was wasted by their not calling immediately (when Mrs McCann hurryied back to the Tapas Bar) on their cell phones the European alert nb 112 that answers in English and would have sent the PJ right away.
Do you really think that the Tapas group would have been aware of the 112 number which was almost wholly unknown in the UK in 2007? Do you really think they would have known as you state that they would have got an answer in English on that number? (Incidentally I am not certain that this is true. My understanding is that the operator will have understanding of English but will respond in their own language. Can you clarify?)
Here is a report from three years after the disappearance which specifies that only 10% of English people even then were aware of the 112 number.
http://ec.europa.eu/news/justice/100211_en.htm
I know that I was not aware of the 112 number in 2007. A specific incident in mid 2008 brought it to my attention and I know that I would have had no idea what number to use to call the police directly in Portugal. I suspect the McCanns did the best thing they could by getting the reception to contact the police for them.
Everybody knew that nb in Portugal and dialing this nb you're attended at least in Basic English (experiment !). Don't you realize that all Tapas employees, except for the gardeners may be, speak English and don't you realize the McCann knew it after spending 5 days in the resort ? The Tapas employees would have given the alert nb if they had been told the shutters/window had been forced. The main reception guy called first the OC manager... And calling the GNR instead of the PJ he showed he didn't suspect an abduction.
Who initially responds to a 112 call in Portugal?
-
why did the PJ put the safety of a missing little girl ahead of the convenience of the holidaymakers whose holidays would be disturbed by a reconstruction just days after the disappearance when it would have been of real value in assisting with that search?
You wouldn't write this if you knew this country, which is not mine but where I live. In Portugal children are princes and treated this way ! (Holidaymakers aren't : it's clear they come here only because of the sun and the sea).
I wrote that because it is actually the excuse that Goncalo Amaral (I believe he is PORTUGUESE) gave. Would you like the reference?
-
Don't they call it the 'golden hour' or somesuch - after a person disappears - the actions that are carried out within that timeframe often determine the outcome of said investigation.
Yes but the "golden hour" (Mark Harrison's expression) was wasted by their not calling immediately (when Mrs McCann hurryied back to the Tapas Bar) on their cell phones the European alert nb 112 that answers in English and would have sent the PJ right away.
Do you really think that the Tapas group would have been aware of the 112 number which was almost wholly unknown in the UK in 2007? Do you really think they would have known as you state that they would have got an answer in English on that number? (Incidentally I am not certain that this is true. My understanding is that the operator will have understanding of English but will respond in their own language. Can you clarify?)
Here is a report from three years after the disappearance which specifies that only 10% of English people even then were aware of the 112 number.
http://ec.europa.eu/news/justice/100211_en.htm
I know that I was not aware of the 112 number in 2007. A specific incident in mid 2008 brought it to my attention and I know that I would have had no idea what number to use to call the police directly in Portugal. I suspect the McCanns did the best thing they could by getting the reception to contact the police for them.
Everybody knew that nb in Portugal and dialing this nb you're attended at least in Basic English (experiment !). Don't you realize that all Tapas employees, except for the gardeners may be, speak English and don't you realize the McCann knew it after spending 5 days in the resort ? The Tapas employees would have given the alert nb if they had been told the shutters/window had been forced. The main reception guy called first the OC manager... And calling the GNR instead of the PJ he showed he didn't suspect an abduction.
Who initially responds to a 112 call in Portugal?
PSP in urban areas and GNR in more rural areas like the far corner of the Algarve
acc to this:
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/europe/6634283.stm
-
I maintain that they did the logical and most natural thing in the circumstances. They approached the reception of the complex where they were staying. It is exactly what I would have done at the time and exactly what I did in mid 2008 when I had need of police assistance while abroad. It was after that that I learned of the 112 number.
So you had the same awful experience of a missing child ? Did you wait half an hour before sending someone to a five minutes walking distance place, whereas you had a cell phone and a local nearby knowing the alert nb (taught in primary school here in Portugal) ? I suppose everything ended well.
Do you need a link proving every employee in the OC speaks English ?
At no point have I ever said I had the same awful experience as a missing child. Your claim that I have is ludicrous.
I have no idea at all what your claim about the staff in the OC speaking English is about. They used the staff in the OC to deal with the situation.
And as to your earlier comment that everyone in Portugal knows the 112 number that simply is not true.
A January 2013 study tells us that only 29% of the Portuguese population know that EU wide number six years after 2007.
According to the latest Eurobarometer Survey on 112, 29% of Portuguese people know they can use 112 everywhere in the EU.
https://ec.europa.eu/digital-agenda/en/112-portugal
And yes in my instance in 2008 my possessions were recovered from the taxi driver who had stolen them.
-
Don't they call it the 'golden hour' or somesuch - after a person disappears - the actions that are carried out within that timeframe often determine the outcome of said investigation.
Yes but the "golden hour" (Mark Harrison's expression) was wasted by their not calling immediately (when Mrs McCann hurryied back to the Tapas Bar) on their cell phones the European alert nb 112 that answers in English and would have sent the PJ right away.
Do you really think that the Tapas group would have been aware of the 112 number which was almost wholly unknown in the UK in 2007? Do you really think they would have known as you state that they would have got an answer in English on that number? (Incidentally I am not certain that this is true. My understanding is that the operator will have understanding of English but will respond in their own language. Can you clarify?)
Here is a report from three years after the disappearance which specifies that only 10% of English people even then were aware of the 112 number.
http://ec.europa.eu/news/justice/100211_en.htm
I know that I was not aware of the 112 number in 2007. A specific incident in mid 2008 brought it to my attention and I know that I would have had no idea what number to use to call the police directly in Portugal. I suspect the McCanns did the best thing they could by getting the reception to contact the police for them.
Everybody knew that nb in Portugal and dialing this nb you're attended at least in Basic English (experiment !). Don't you realize that all Tapas employees, except for the gardeners may be, speak English and don't you realize the McCann knew it after spending 5 days in the resort ? The Tapas employees would have given the alert nb if they had been told the shutters/window had been forced. The main reception guy called first the OC manager... And calling the GNR instead of the PJ he showed he didn't suspect an abduction.
Who initially responds to a 112 call in Portugal?
PSP in urban areas and GNR in more rural areas like the far corner of the Algarve
acc to this:
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/europe/6634283.stm
So that answers the AnneGuedes question as to why they contacted the GNR and not the PJ. Because the emergency number which the OC staff used presumably reached the GNR. Nothing suspicious there then.
-
Don't they call it the 'golden hour' or somesuch - after a person disappears - the actions that are carried out within that timeframe often determine the outcome of said investigation.
Yes but the "golden hour" (Mark Harrison's expression) was wasted by their not calling immediately (when Mrs McCann hurryied back to the Tapas Bar) on their cell phones the European alert nb 112 that answers in English and would have sent the PJ right away.
Do you really think that the Tapas group would have been aware of the 112 number which was almost wholly unknown in the UK in 2007? Do you really think they would have known as you state that they would have got an answer in English on that number? (Incidentally I am not certain that this is true. My understanding is that the operator will have understanding of English but will respond in their own language. Can you clarify?)
Here is a report from three years after the disappearance which specifies that only 10% of English people even then were aware of the 112 number.
http://ec.europa.eu/news/justice/100211_en.htm
I know that I was not aware of the 112 number in 2007. A specific incident in mid 2008 brought it to my attention and I know that I would have had no idea what number to use to call the police directly in Portugal. I suspect the McCanns did the best thing they could by getting the reception to contact the police for them.
Everybody knew that nb in Portugal and dialing this nb you're attended at least in Basic English (experiment !). Don't you realize that all Tapas employees, except for the gardeners may be, speak English and don't you realize the McCann knew it after spending 5 days in the resort ? The Tapas employees would have given the alert nb if they had been told the shutters/window had been forced. The main reception guy called first the OC manager... And calling the GNR instead of the PJ he showed he didn't suspect an abduction.
Who initially responds to a 112 call in Portugal?
PSP in urban areas and GNR in more rural areas like the far corner of the Algarve
acc to this:
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/europe/6634283.stm
So that answers the AnneGuedes question as to why they contacted the GNR and not the PJ. Because the emergency number which the OC staff used presumably reached the GNR. Nothing suspicious there then.
Quite, GNR were the designated first responders
-
Does 112 work in France? I've been here 20 years and I've never heard that it does.
-
Does 112 work in France? I've been here 20 years and I've never heard that it does.
https://ec.europa.eu/digital-agenda/en/112-france
112 works in all the following countries
https://ec.europa.eu/digital-agenda/en/112-your-country
-
Don't they call it the 'golden hour' or somesuch - after a person disappears - the actions that are carried out within that timeframe often determine the outcome of said investigation.
Yes but the "golden hour" (Mark Harrison's expression) was wasted by their not calling immediately (when Mrs McCann hurryied back to the Tapas Bar) on their cell phones the European alert nb 112 that answers in English and would have sent the PJ right away.
Do you really think that the Tapas group would have been aware of the 112 number which was almost wholly unknown in the UK in 2007? Do you really think they would have known as you state that they would have got an answer in English on that number? (Incidentally I am not certain that this is true. My understanding is that the operator will have understanding of English but will respond in their own language. Can you clarify?)
Here is a report from three years after the disappearance which specifies that only 10% of English people even then were aware of the 112 number.
http://ec.europa.eu/news/justice/100211_en.htm
I know that I was not aware of the 112 number in 2007. A specific incident in mid 2008 brought it to my attention and I know that I would have had no idea what number to use to call the police directly in Portugal. I suspect the McCanns did the best thing they could by getting the reception to contact the police for them.
Everybody knew that nb in Portugal and dialing this nb you're attended at least in Basic English (experiment !). Don't you realize that all Tapas employees, except for the gardeners may be, speak English and don't you realize the McCann knew it after spending 5 days in the resort ? The Tapas employees would have given the alert nb if they had been told the shutters/window had been forced. The main reception guy called first the OC manager... And calling the GNR instead of the PJ he showed he didn't suspect an abduction.
Who initially responds to a 112 call in Portugal?
PSP in urban areas and GNR in more rural areas like the far corner of the Algarve
acc to this:
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/europe/6634283.stm
The Algarve cost is now mainly a urban area. The GNR would have been alerted by the 112 if the child had been reported as likely wandering off (since there was no sign of intruder and the door wasn't locked). But, if told shutters and window were forced and a child was missing, the 112 would have certainly alerted the PJ. Matthew Oldfield only said a child was missing.
-
Lee Rainbow, the foremost Criminal Profiler in Britain
112 discussion - wow
-
Soooo....
Someone in a panic informs the reception that a child is missing.
A protocol was put in place, wasn't it?
On the night of 3rd May, after having finished work, I planned to meet a group of colleagues at 22.30 to go out. At about 22.17 I received a call from Lyndsey Johnson, the creche Manager, informing me that the girl had gone missing. I met Lyndsey and the Service Manager, Amy Tierney, near to the Tapas Bar and we initiated the 'Mark Warner procedures for the search of a missing child'.
(snip)
The hotel manager, John Hill arrived at the location from which the searches were being organised and I can confirm that he called the police. John stayed at the location and I several times went to search the grounds. I went with Amy and we searched the highest part of the complex behind the apartments. The search lasted for about 10 minutes and then we returned. At that moment John asked me to go to the apartment the girl had disappeared from and, on behalf of Mark Warner, provide all the help the family might need.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/EMMA-LOUISE.htm
-
Don't they call it the 'golden hour' or somesuch - after a person disappears - the actions that are carried out within that timeframe often determine the outcome of said investigation.
Yes but the "golden hour" (Mark Harrison's expression) was wasted by their not calling immediately (when Mrs McCann hurryied back to the Tapas Bar) on their cell phones the European alert nb 112 that answers in English and would have sent the PJ right away.
Do you really think that the Tapas group would have been aware of the 112 number which was almost wholly unknown in the UK in 2007? Do you really think they would have known as you state that they would have got an answer in English on that number? (Incidentally I am not certain that this is true. My understanding is that the operator will have understanding of English but will respond in their own language. Can you clarify?)
Here is a report from three years after the disappearance which specifies that only 10% of English people even then were aware of the 112 number.
http://ec.europa.eu/news/justice/100211_en.htm
I know that I was not aware of the 112 number in 2007. A specific incident in mid 2008 brought it to my attention and I know that I would have had no idea what number to use to call the police directly in Portugal. I suspect the McCanns did the best thing they could by getting the reception to contact the police for them.
Everybody knew that nb in Portugal and dialing this nb you're attended at least in Basic English (experiment !). Don't you realize that all Tapas employees, except for the gardeners may be, speak English and don't you realize the McCann knew it after spending 5 days in the resort ? The Tapas employees would have given the alert nb if they had been told the shutters/window had been forced. The main reception guy called first the OC manager... And calling the GNR instead of the PJ he showed he didn't suspect an abduction.
Who initially responds to a 112 call in Portugal?
PSP in urban areas and GNR in more rural areas like the far corner of the Algarve
acc to this:
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/europe/6634283.stm
The Algarve cost is now mainly a urban area. The GNR would have been alerted by the 112 if the child had been reported as likely wandering off (since there was no sign of intruder and the door wasn't locked). But, if told shutters and window were forced and a child was missing, the 112 would have certainly alerted the PJ. Matthew Oldfield only said a child was missing.
fluff and you being bitter for having been found out again for spreading falsehoods
-
Does 112 work in France? I've been here 20 years and I've never heard that it does.
https://ec.europa.eu/digital-agenda/en/112-france
112 works in all the following countries
https://ec.europa.eu/digital-agenda/en/112-your-country
Thank you. That rather proves your point.
-
oh - and I've been to Luz - unlike you
it's not high rise flats/urbanization - like most of the Algarve coast
it's a village - in the countryside
pipe/smoke it time methinks - or maybe not
-
Don't they call it the 'golden hour' or somesuch - after a person disappears - the actions that are carried out within that timeframe often determine the outcome of said investigation.
Yes but the "golden hour" (Mark Harrison's expression) was wasted by their not calling immediately (when Mrs McCann hurryied back to the Tapas Bar) on their cell phones the European alert nb 112 that answers in English and would have sent the PJ right away.
Do you really think that the Tapas group would have been aware of the 112 number which was almost wholly unknown in the UK in 2007? Do you really think they would have known as you state that they would have got an answer in English on that number? (Incidentally I am not certain that this is true. My understanding is that the operator will have understanding of English but will respond in their own language. Can you clarify?)
Here is a report from three years after the disappearance which specifies that only 10% of English people even then were aware of the 112 number.
http://ec.europa.eu/news/justice/100211_en.htm
I know that I was not aware of the 112 number in 2007. A specific incident in mid 2008 brought it to my attention and I know that I would have had no idea what number to use to call the police directly in Portugal. I suspect the McCanns did the best thing they could by getting the reception to contact the police for them.
Everybody knew that nb in Portugal and dialing this nb you're attended at least in Basic English (experiment !). Don't you realize that all Tapas employees, except for the gardeners may be, speak English and don't you realize the McCann knew it after spending 5 days in the resort ? The Tapas employees would have given the alert nb if they had been told the shutters/window had been forced. The main reception guy called first the OC manager... And calling the GNR instead of the PJ he showed he didn't suspect an abduction.
Who initially responds to a 112 call in Portugal?
PSP in urban areas and GNR in more rural areas like the far corner of the Algarve
acc to this:
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/europe/6634283.stm
The Algarve cost is now mainly a urban area. The GNR would have been alerted by the 112 if the child had been reported as likely wandering off (since there was no sign of intruder and the door wasn't locked). But, if told shutters and window were forced and a child was missing, the 112 would have certainly alerted the PJ. Matthew Oldfield only said a child was missing.
No he didn't. If you read the Statement he gave, he said, "You've got to phone the Police, ... a child's been taken."
-
So that answers the AnneGuedes question as to why they contacted the GNR and not the PJ. Because the emergency number which the OC staff used presumably reached the GNR. Nothing suspicious there then.
Quite, GNR were the designated first responders
[/quote]
The GNR are not the "designated first responders" at all in a urban area like Praia da Luz. Anyhow if called and told a child is missing from her bed, the door being locked and the window having been forced, they immediately call the PJ because it's obviously a criminal case.
-
So that answers the AnneGuedes question as to why they contacted the GNR and not the PJ. Because the emergency number which the OC staff used presumably reached the GNR. Nothing suspicious there then.
Quite, GNR were the designated first responders
The GNR are not the "designated first responders" at all in a urban area like Praia da Luz. Anyhow if called and told a child is missing from her bed, the door being locked and the window having been forced, they immediately call the PJ because it's obviously a criminal case.
[/quote]
busted and protesting too much for having been caught out 8)-)))
-
So that answers the AnneGuedes question as to why they contacted the GNR and not the PJ. Because the emergency number which the OC staff used presumably reached the GNR. Nothing suspicious there then.
Quite, GNR were the designated first responders
The GNR are not the "designated first responders" at all in a urban area like Praia da Luz. Anyhow if called and told a child is missing from her bed, the door being locked and the window having been forced, they immediately call the PJ because it's obviously a criminal case.
busted and protesting too much for having been caught out 8)-)))
[/quote]
So why did the GNR (who are the first responders there) not "immediately" call the PJ then?
-
So that answers the AnneGuedes question as to why they contacted the GNR and not the PJ. Because the emergency number which the OC staff used presumably reached the GNR. Nothing suspicious there then.
Quite, GNR were the designated first responders
The GNR are not the "designated first responders" at all in a urban area like Praia da Luz. Anyhow if called and told a child is missing from her bed, the door being locked and the window having been forced, they immediately call the PJ because it's obviously a criminal case.
busted and protesting too much for having been caught out 8)-)))
So why did the GNR (who are the first responders there) not "immediately" call the PJ then?
[/quote]
You would have to ask the GNR that I'm afraid
Guessing - in the first minutes after arriving on the scene - the guys could not establish a 'crime' had been commited
-
If you read the Statement he gave, he said, "You've got to phone the Police, ... a child's been taken."
You're right, that's what he said, one year after, but not in his first two statements.
Anyhow neither the GNR nor the PJ were told the shutters and window had been forced.
-
If you read the Statement he gave, he said, "You've got to phone the Police, ... a child's been taken."
You're right, that's what he said, one year after, but not in his first two statements.
Anyhow neither the GNR nor the PJ were told the shutters and window had been forced.
No there is no reference at all in the first two statements because the PJ never asked him what he said or what he did regarding the phone call in those two statements. In a Police interview you answer questions. If the Police don't ask then you don't give the information.
Now please tell us how you categorically know that neither the PJ nor the GNR were told the shutters had been forced or are you just guessing?
-
fluff and you being bitter for having been found out again for spreading falsehoods
Quoting you : Ad hominems add nothing to debate ;)
-
fluff and you being bitter for having been found out again for spreading falsehoods
Quoting you : Ad hominems add nothing to debate ;)
Not ad hominems - statement of fact
-
you don't have mods to cry to on here
and get the reasonable posters banned
shame - seems you can't have your cake and eat it
-
If you read the Statement he gave, he said, "You've got to phone the Police, ... a child's been taken."
You're right, that's what he said, one year after, but not in his first two statements.
Anyhow neither the GNR nor the PJ were told the shutters and window had been forced.
I repeat, please tell us how you categorically know that neither the PJ nor the GNR were told the shutters had been forced or are you just guessing?
-
If you read the Statement he gave, he said, "You've got to phone the Police, ... a child's been taken."
You're right, that's what he said, one year after, but not in his first two statements.
Anyhow neither the GNR nor the PJ were told the shutters and window had been forced.
No there is no reference at all in the first two statements because the PJ never asked him what he said or what he did regarding the phone call in those two statements. In a Police interview you answer questions. If the Police don't ask then you don't give the information.
Now please tell us how you categorically know that neither the PJ nor the GNR were told the shutters had been forced or are you just guessing?
I suppose "you don't give an information if the police don't ask", except if you have to complain that 1) the call was made (10:41), sort of twenty minutes (or more) after asked for and 2) the PJ wasn't called because the GNR wasn't informed of the "taken".
I read the statements in the files, as you likely did, and found no mention of someone speaking of forced shutters and window. That detail being crucial, I guess it would have been reported in any case (even if the shutters and the window hadn't been forced).
-
By the way, in case of a missing child, remember the European Alert Hotline : 116 000 !
-
I can't make head nor tail of that post.
Oldfield didn't say anything about the call to the GNR/PJ etc because he wasn't asked. Simple.
The fact that the windows and shutters were open, when previously closed is reported in the interviews by both Gerry and Kate McCann. The word forced is not used here but the meaning is clear, that it had been opened without their knowledge.
-
you don't have mods to cry to on here
and get the reasonable posters banned
shame - seems you can't have your cake and eat it
Can you ?
-
By the way, in case of a missing child, remember the European Alert Hotline : 116 000 !
By the way did you apologise for your claim that 100% of Portuguese know the 112 number as the EU emergency number as you claimed?
-
I can't make head nor tail of that post.
Oldfield didn't say anything about the call to the GNR/PJ etc because he wasn't asked. Simple.
The fact that the windows and shutters were open, when previously closed is reported in the interviews by both Gerry and Kate McCann. The word forced is not used here but the meaning is clear, that it had been opened without their knowledge.
Mr and Mrs McCann reported they found shutters and window open. Not forced (this is what they told only to their family and friends).
-
By the way, in case of a missing child, remember the European Alert Hotline : 116 000 !
By the way did you apologise for your claim that 100% of Portuguese know the 112 number as the EU emergency number as you claimed?
Did I say 100% ? 112 was the first number on the first page of useful numbers in the phone book. Where do you think the receptionist found the GNR number (282 770 010) ? Do you think he knew it by heart ?
-
By the way, in case of a missing child, remember the European Alert Hotline : 116 000 !
By the way did you apologise for your claim that 100% of Portuguese know the 112 number as the EU emergency number as you claimed?
Did I say 100% ? 112 was the first number on the first page of useful numbers in the phone book. Where do you think the receptionist found the GNR number (282 770 010) ? Do you think he knew it by heart ?
Yes you did say 100%. The word 'everybody' is fully inclusive and means 100% of the people.
Everybody knew that nb in Portugal and dialing this nb you're attended at least in Basic English (experiment !). Don't you realize that all Tapas employees, except for the gardeners may be, speak English and don't you realize the McCann knew it after spending 5 days in the resort ? The Tapas employees would have given the alert nb if they had been told the shutters/window had been forced. The main reception guy called first the OC manager... And calling the GNR instead of the PJ he showed he didn't suspect an abduction.
And yes in the job of receptionist at a very busy tourist complex I would presume that the person who made the phone call would know such a useful number off by heart.
-
And yes in the job of receptionist at a very busy tourist complex I would presume that the person who made the phone call would know such a useful number off by heart.
Are you kidding ? He would know a 9 digits nb and not a 3 digits one, valid for any kind of alert ? Do you presume as well that the receptionist didn't understand the word "police", since he did call the "army" ?
-
And yes in the job of receptionist at a very busy tourist complex I would presume that the person who made the phone call would know such a useful number off by heart.
Are you kidding ? He would know a 9 digits nb and not a 3 digits one, valid for any kind of alert ? Do you presume as well that the receptionist didn't understand the word "police", since he did call the "army" ?
Why would he know a nine digit number when any normal person calls the three digit one. You are posting absolute nonsense.
The receptionist would have called 112 or 115 and been routed to the GNR.
If as a Portuguese citizen you do not know that then I am afraid you don't really deserve my time in debate.
-
And yes in the job of receptionist at a very busy tourist complex I would presume that the person who made the phone call would know such a useful number off by heart.
Are you kidding ? He would know a 9 digits nb and not a 3 digits one, valid for any kind of alert ? Do you presume as well that the receptionist didn't understand the word "police", since he did call the "army" ?
Why would he know a nine digit number when any normal person calls the three digit one. You are posting absolute nonsense.
The receptionist would have called 112 or 115 and been routed to the GNR.
If as a Portuguese citizen you do not know that then I am afraid you don't really deserve my time in debate.
I'm sorry I understood your "such a useful number off by heart" as referring to the GNR nb I quoted just above.
I'm not Portuguese.
-
Your apology accepted and in return I apologise for presuming your nationality.
My presumption was based on your claim to know about the area and its police resourcing.
-
Your apology accepted and in return I apologise for presuming your nationality.
My presumption was based on your claim to know about the area and its police resourcing.
You don't have to apologise about my nationality. In fact I live in Portugal most of the time.
-
Like Almeida's interim report, the Rainbow report has been supersed by the AG's findings in the Final Report. Discussing something that no longer applies (and hasn't done for years) is a pointless exercise.