UK Justice Forum 🇬🇧
Alleged Miscarriages of Justice => Jeremy Bamber and the callous murder of his father, mother, sister and twin nephews. Case effectively CLOSED by CCRC on basis of NO APPEAL REFERRAL. => Topic started by: John on November 02, 2025, 01:22:11 PM
-
This week, audio footage was released by the New Yorker magazine, which seemed to exonerate Bamber, who has been in prison for 40 years. Could this lead to his release?
In the millions of pages disclosed to Jeremy Bamber over the decades, in his bid to prove his innocence of one of the 20th century’s most notorious crimes, PC Nick Milbank is barely mentioned. But this week, new evidence emerged that the late police officer held an essential clue to what happened on the night of the massacre at Whitehouse Farm on 7 August 1985.
Read more...
https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2025/nov/02/the-jeremy-bamber-twist-does-britains-most-notorious-murderer-finally-have-an-alibi
(https://i.guim.co.uk/img/media/4382459cc7c0584d464812c1be619bb3ad219a10/0_227_1364_1091/master/1364.jpg?width=465&dpr=2&s=none&crop=none)
-
I never have been sure of his guilt. But what is likely to happen now?
-
I don’t see how a call made at 6.09am in which no one actually speaks exonerates JB, can someone please explain?
-
I don’t see how a call made at 6.09am in which no one actually speaks exonerates JB, can someone please explain?
Someone was still alive in that house. Bamber was outside in police custody.
-
Someone was still alive in that house. Bamber was outside in police custody.
He wasn’t in custody at that point but he was with them outside the house. However, the call (if one were actually made) could have been made by a victim who momentarily regained consciousness before collapsing again and dying. No gunshot was heard while police were outside the house so all shots had already been fired by the time they arrived. I don’t see how this alleged phone call proves Bamber is innocent. I thought it all hinged on the alleged aga burns anyway? Where’s Blogs?
-
He wasn’t in custody at that point but he was with them outside the house. However, the call (if one were actually made) could have been made by a victim who momentarily regained consciousness before collapsing again and dying. No gunshot was heard while police were outside the house so all shots had already been fired by the time they arrived. I don’t see how this alleged phone call proves Bamber is innocent. I thought it all hinged on the alleged aga burns anyway? Where’s Blogs?
Yes, I certainly believe the Aga evidence is important for Bamber if accepted, Vertigo!
As far as the phone call at 6.09 is concerned, only Sheila could have made it before shooting herself, Nevill and June had too many head shots to try calling anyone. Besides, June was found upstairs where there was no phone.
So no, if a call was made, the only person that could have made it was Sheila before shooting herself, Vertigo!
-
Yes, I certainly believe the Aga evidence is important for Bamber if accepted, Vertigo!
As far as the phone call at 6.09 is concerned, only Sheila could have made it before shooting herself, Nevill and June had too many head shots to try calling anyone. Besides, June was found upstairs where there was no phone.
So no, if a call was made, the only person that could have made it was Sheila before shooting herself, Vertigo!
If it was Sheila 1)why make the call in the first place? 2) why make the call but then say nothing discernable 3) why did noone hear the final gunshot?
-
If it was Sheila 1)why make the call in the first place? 2) why make the call but then say nothing discernable 3) why did noone hear the final gunshot?
I cant answer any of you're three points, Vertigo!
But the fact remains, Sheila and only Sheila could have made a phone call from inside WHF at 6.09!
-
I cant answer any of you're three points, Vertigo!
But the fact remains, Sheila and only Sheila could have made a phone call from inside WHF at 6.09!
None of it makes sense. The only thing that does make sense is that 40 years after the event Milbank got his facts wrong. If he’d known all those years that Bamber could not have committed the crime because of the phone call why on earth didn’t he speak up sooner?
-
None of it makes sense. The only thing that does make sense is that 40 years after the event Milbank got his facts wrong. If he’d known all those years that Bamber could not have committed the crime because of the phone call why on earth didn’t he speak up sooner?
Thats what we all want to know, Vertigo!
Hopefully Heidi Blake got to the bottom of things in her interview, lets see what she comes up with!
-
I’m afraid I find Milbank’s account hard to make sense of. Someone within the house calls 999, then says nothing distinctive but moves away from the phone to apparently move the furniture, and maybe switch on the radio. No sound of gunshot is heard either over the phone or by the numerous individuals outside the house. Moreover if this was Sheila, she would have been dead only an hour or so before the police discovered her body and it would probably still have been warm, was this observed by anybody at the crime scene? Is there an actual log for this 6.09am call? If not, why not? So many questions, and no logical answers.
-
I’m afraid I find Milward’s account hard to make sense of. Someone within the house calls 999, then says nothing distinctive but moves away from the phone to apparently move the furniture, and maybe switch on the radio. No sound of gunshot is heard either over the phone or by the numerous individuals outside the house. Moreover if this was Sheila, she would have been dead only an hour or so before the police discovered her body and it would probably still have been warm, was this observed by anybody at the crime scene? Is there an actual log for this 6.09am call? If not, why not? So many questions, and no logical answers.
Yes, there are many points that need clarifying regarding the Milbank call.
Why do you think a gunshot would be heard over the phone, Vertigo?
-
Yes, there are many points that need clarifying regarding the Milbank call.
Why do you think a gunshot would be heard over the phone, Vertigo?
Why not? The phone was supposedly left off the hook wasn’t it?
Think about it. This alleged 6.09am phonecall would have been a massive piece of evidence. Why does it not feature as an aspect of the early investigation before JB was even in the frame for the murders? How did Milbank manage not to mention this to any of his superiors when they were investigating the apparent murder / suicide committed by Sheila Bamber? You might have thought he’d mention the fact that he’d taken a call from her to someone at some point, but no, it takes 17 years before this apparently enormous clue is revealed.
-
The whole investigation was such a mess that I had trouble sorting out what was going on. And of course, The Police were far too keen on stitching people up in those days.
This is definitely cause to reopen the Investigation, In My Opinion.
-
Yes, I certainly believe the Aga evidence is important for Bamber if accepted, Vertigo!
As far as the phone call at 6.09 is concerned, only Sheila could have made it before shooting herself, Nevill and June had too many head shots to try calling anyone. Besides, June was found upstairs where there was no phone.
So no, if a call was made, the only person that could have made it was Sheila before shooting herself, Vertigo!
Could she have shot herself prior to this but not died immediately ?
-
The whole investigation was such a mess that I had trouble sorting out what was going on. And of course, The Police were far too keen on stitching people up in those days.
This is definitely cause to reopen the Investigation, In My Opinion.
But initially they were convinced it was a murder suicide and there would have been no need to pretend this alleged 6.09am call didn’t happen. The house was surrounded by people all intent on discovering what was going on in it, yet none of them noticed the final shotgun blast? Unlikely imo.
-
Could she have shot herself prior to this but not died immediately ?
Do you mean shot herself twice, then got up again to make a phonecall before returning to her final resting place to cradle the gun in her arms?
-
Could she have shot herself prior to this but not died immediately ?
Unlikely, Jassi, the blood would have run right down her body if she was standing and there was no trail of blood back up to the bedroom from the kitchen either.
-
But initially they were convinced it was a murder suicide and there would have been no need to pretend this alleged 6.09am call didn’t happen. The house was surrounded by people all intent on discovering what was going on in it, yet none of them noticed the final shotgun blast? Unlikely imo.
Remember it was a relatively quiet weapon even without the silencer, Vertigo, and Sheila shot herself upstairs at the far side of the bed in the main bedroom.
-
Why not? The phone was supposedly left off the hook wasn’t it?
Think about it. This alleged 6.09am phonecall would have been a massive piece of evidence. Why does it not feature as an aspect of the early investigation before JB was even in the frame for the murders? How did Milward manage not to mention this to any of his superiors when they were investigating the apparent murder / suicide committed by Sheila Bamber? You might have thought he’d mention the fact that he’d taken a call from her to someone at some point, but no, it takes 17 years before this apparently enormous clue is revealed.
Yes, thats why everyone is skeptical at the moment before seeing/hearing the Milbank interview!
-
Remember it was a relatively quiet weapon even without the silencer, Vertigo, and Sheila shot herself upstairs at the far side of the bed in the main bedroom.
Relatively quiet compared to what? An AK47? The house was surrounded by professionals on high alert for any signs of activity within and not one of them heard anything resembling a shotgun going off? I don’t think that’s likely myself. Even Bamber himself who would have been very familiar with the noise of that gun going off didn’t hear it.
-
Relatively quiet compared to what? An AK47? The house was surrounded by professionals on high alert for any signs of activity within and not one of them heard anything resembling a shotgun going off? I don’t think that’s likely myself. Even Bamber himself who would have been very familiar with the noise of that gun going off didn’t hear it.
It was an Anschutz rifle and it fired little .22 bullets from a magazine. A shotgun to me is a weapon that fires cartridges with balls of shot inside.
JB wasn't allowed near the house, he was put into the barn for safety,
BUT!! The bedroom window in the main bedroom where Sheila was found was open three inches, so you may have a point, Vertigo!
-
If the police received a call at 6.09am then why didn't they attempt to enter the house at that point?
Yet it takes 17 years for this to be revealed, the whole thing sounds fishy to me.
-
If the police received a call at 6.09am then why didn't they attempt to enter the house at that point?
Yet it takes 17 years for this to be revealed, the whole thing sounds fishy to me.
Presumably because the person who took the call decided to keep it to themselves rather than inform their colleagues who were waiting outside the house at the time.
-
Is this his new my Dad called the police, when it was two logs of West speaking to MB at HQIR. Is the 999 call in-fact the GPO switching the open house phone to the 999 system to HQIR so they could listen in. As stated in the logs at 06:06, so how could a 999 call be made on an open system that is being monitored ??
-
Burrell's 1985 WS says Millbank took over the monitoring of the open line at WHF at 6.09am.
The New Yorker is twisting it to say Millbank took a call from WHF at 6.09am. The caller then not speaking.
Been dismissed by the CCRC but has given The New Yorker publicity & got the CT excited again.
-
Burrell's 1985 WS says Millbank took over the monitoring of the open line at WHF at 6.09am.
The New Yorker is twisting it to say Millbank took a call from WHF at 6.09am. The caller then not speaking.
Been dismissed by the CCRC but has given The New Yorker publicity & got the CT excited again.
I'm a bit rusty on the facts after so many years but I tend to agree.
-
I haven't read the New Yorker article, and have only scan read this thread.
but the common theme coming up again and again is the 6.09 phone call from WHF to emergency services (999)
But this fact is recorded on the phone logs where the open line in WHF which was being monitored by a BT operative from around 4:00 am, until 6:09, when the Police asked BT to divert the line to HQIR (999).
HQIR (999) stands for Headquarters Information room, and it's where 999 calls are received, and where emergencies are co-ordinated from.
This is clearly documented on 2 of the phone logs, both of which I believe are hosted on this website.
Before I got banned from the Blue Forum, I stumbled across an old post from 2013 where Mike Tesko (I believe that was his name) had uploaded the witness statement of the police officer who instructed the divert on the line, and it was very clear in that statement that the 6:09 emergency call was executed when the BT engineer diverted the open line from WTF to HQIR (999) so that the police could monitor it rather than the BT engineer (or as well as the BT engineer)
And that is backed up by the call logs that were written live as the situation unfolded on the night.
The New Yorker magazine will be in cahoots with Jeremy Bambers Campaign team, and will have zero access to the official evidence held by the police.
Jeremy Bamber has in the past, via his legal representation and campaign team, created fake wet blood photos in his attempt to 'prove' that Sheila was still alive when the police entered the building.
So he has 40 years of experience in faking evidence from his police cell.
We know that anyone that supports Jeremy Bamber, including Peter Tatchell, tends to blindly repeat Jeremy Bambers lies, making them sound like the gospel truth. But they are still lies.
The CCRC have access to all the evidence, and they will have all the witness statements from that time, and they will correctly interpret the entries on those call logs.
The BT staff who were involved will also have given statements and probably appeared as witnesses to. That will all be available to the CCRC.
These are facts that cannot be denied. They are written in stone and unmovable. At least as far as the law is concerned.
The 6:09 call is just another Bamber lie, based on a nugget of truth.
-
Oh dear. This does put rather a dent in the New Yorker’s credibility as a serious investigative journal. Time to roll out the aga burns again and sweep the 6.09am 999 call under the carpet, nothing to see here…
-
Oh dear. This does put rather a dent in the New Yorker’s credibility as a serious investigative journal. Time to roll out the aga burns again and sweep the 6.09am 999 call under the carpet, nothing to see here…
Well lets just wait and see exactly what Milbank said in the interview before we attack anyone's credibility, Vertigo!
I thought about subscribing to the New Yorker to hear it right now, BUT!! Greed kept me allright there!
-
I've listened to PC Milbanks audio on this, mainly because I was working as a BT operator at the time and knew the procedure. PC Milbank should have known himself that a 999 call wasn't just passed to the police without information about the situation, the address if known and who the caller was from the BT operator, he would never have just picked up a 999 call and be left without any clue as to what it was about.The document attached to this "999 call" states clearly "Open '999' line set up (direct link to house with phone off hook)". At 4am BT was contacted to listen in to the line at White House Farm which, when dialled was engaged. The 999 emergency desk would have dialled into the line to see if they could hear anything, the operator reported that the phone appeared to be off the hook, there were sounds of movement and a dog barking. BT tried again at 4:30 and 5:40, still only slight movement and a barking dog. At 5:50 the operator patched into Essex Police HQ so that they could monitor the line as BT can't continually do this, it ties up emergency lines. Essex Police then assigned PC Milbank to monitor the line at 6:09, as he recorded no information about what he heard then we can assume he heard nothing of any use. Technically he did get a call from the 999 line but it was the BT operator patching through the line for monitoring. I don't know why PC Milbank didn't realise this, was he even told at the time that this was what the call he answered was? it doesn't sound as though he'd given it any thought, even at the time. I imagine being caught on the hop by a reporter years after the event may have caused him to say something that later he realised wasn't exactly true and recanted it, he sounded unsure about admitting he heard voices or a radio, maybe carried away at being interviewed by a journalist. Given the terrible performance of the Essex Police throughout this investigation I'm not really surprised. I understand there will be people that want this to be the evidence they've been looking for but the whole family died at approx 3am, nothing has disproved that. Nobody in the house was found near a phone so they could not have dialled it, I see people saying it was Sheila but then she would have had to shoot herself twice, the gun may not be the loudest but the farm was surrounded by police who were straining to hear anything at all, also PC Milbank did not record that gunshot had been heard. I hope this helps.
.
-
I've listened to PC Milbanks audio on this, mainly because I was working as a BT operator at the time and knew the procedure. PC Milbank should have known himself that a 999 call wasn't just passed to the police without information about the situation, the address if known and who the caller was from the BT operator, he would never have just picked up a 999 call and be left without any clue as to what it was about.The document attached to this "999 call" states clearly "Open '999' line set up (direct link to house with phone off hook)". At 4am BT was contacted to listen in to the line at White House Farm which, when dialled was engaged. The 999 emergency desk would have dialled into the line to see if they could hear anything, the operator reported that the phone appeared to be off the hook, there were sounds of movement and a dog barking. BT tried again at 4:30 and 5:40, still only slight movement and a barking dog. At 5:50 the operator patched into Essex Police HQ so that they could monitor the line as BT can't continually do this, it ties up emergency lines. Essex Police then assigned PC Milbank to monitor the line at 6:09, as he recorded no information about what he heard then we can assume he heard nothing of any use. Technically he did get a call from the 999 line but it was the BT operator patching through the line for monitoring. I don't know why PC Milbank didn't realise this, was he even told at the time that this was what the call he answered was? it doesn't sound as though he'd given it any thought, even at the time. I imagine being caught on the hop by a reporter years after the event may have caused him to say something that later he realised wasn't exactly true and recanted it, he sounded unsure about admitting he heard voices or a radio, maybe carried away at being interviewed by a journalist. Given the terrible performance of the Essex Police throughout this investigation I'm not really surprised. I understand there will be people that want this to be the evidence they've been looking for but the whole family died at approx 3am, nothing has disproved that. Nobody in the house was found near a phone so they could not have dialled it, I see people saying it was Sheila but then she would have had to shoot herself twice, the gun may not be the loudest but the farm was surrounded by police who were straining to hear anything at all, also PC Milbank did not record that gunshot had been heard. I hope this helps.
.
Very few people think that Sheila made a 999call at 6.09, Red!
I think that Philip Boyce's Aga evidence is better proof of JBs innocence.
-
Very few people think that Sheila made a 999call at 6.09, Red!
I think that Philip Boyce's Aga evidence is better proof of JBs innocence.
It's a documented fact that the so called 999 call was in reality the open line (phone was off the hook) in the house being diverted (or repatched) to the Information Room at Chelmsford Police Headquarters (HQIR)
This cannot be legally disputed in any meaningful sense, because it has been proven by evidence, and agreed on in the original court case.
But Jeremy Bamber and his legal representatives, as well as the Guardian newspaper, the New Yorker magazine and JB's Campaign team...have all recently - and wrongly - said that the innocent diversion of the call by a BT operator to HQIR, was in fact an emergence 999 call made by someone inside the house.
It is a long proven fact that it was not an emergency call from someone inside the house.
The truth is this:
Jeremy Bamber (deliberately?) left the phone off the hook at Whitehouse Farm so that no one from that point onwards, would be able to get through to the house. It ensured that confusion and suspicion was aroused and maintained when Jeremy Bamber got home after murdering his family, got cleaned up and then rang the police.
Having the phone off the hook at 3 in the morning, would enhance the feeling that there was something wrong going on in the house, whilst Jeremy Bamber was at his own house.
Under cross examination, during the actual court case in 1986, Jeremy Bamber confirmed that he took a call from his father to say that his sister had got the guns and gone crazy. Bamber then said the line went dead as if the actual phone cable had been cut with a pair of scissors.
Jeremy Bamber then confirmed that he himself hung up by pressing the two buttons on those old phones, which would have disconnected the call, thus allowing him to make another call.
He then claims to have immediately rang his father up again but got the engaged signal. i.e. the phone at white house farm is now off the hook, which could then be confirmed by the police, therefore heightening the feeling that there really was something wrong....whilst Jeremy Bamber was 3 miles away at his own house.
But it was confirmed by BT engineers at the time, and in court in 1986, that Jeremy Bamber would not have been able to phone back for at least another 2 minutes (apparantly up to 10 minutes) due to the mechanical nature of the phone system in 1986.
The phone at Jeremy Bambers house would have been completely non-functioning for several minutes, whilst the mechanics at the various exchanges unlocked themselves.
Therefore Jeremy Bamber did not phone his dad back when he said he did. It did not happen. And yet that was a huge part of Jeremy Bambers story at the time, and one that he repeated.
But it factually never happened.
And that was his alibi.
And now he is twisting it around, along with his supporters that the subsequent redirect to HQIR at 06:09, was a 999 call from inside the house. Which is provably untrue.
And what I've just written are the actual known facts, and those facts are undefeatable by anyone anywhere.
Every aspect of Jeremy Bambers case is like that, once you delve a bit deeper and stay neutral.
Neither Simon Hattenstone or Heidi Blake would ever dare to come on here and try and defeat my arguments because they know I'd tear their own arguments to shreds.
They know they are emotionally attached to the case. They are both consumed by that emotion.
This is a known psychology, where people will promote lies and fiction in order to protect something they have become emotionally attached to. This was Eric Allisons weakness too. And deep down they all know it, but are unable to confront it, or defeat it. The emotion is too strong.
-
It's a documented fact that the so called 999 call was in reality the open line (phone was off the hook) in the house being diverted (or repatched) to the Information Room at Chelmsford Police Headquarters (HQIR)
This cannot be legally disputed in any meaningful sense, because it has been proven by evidence, and agreed on in the original court case.
But Jeremy Bamber and his legal representatives, as well as the Guardian newspaper, the New Yorker magazine and JB's Campaign team...have all recently - and wrongly - said that the innocent diversion of the call by a BT operator to HQIR, was in fact an emergence 999 call made by someone inside the house.
It is a long proven fact that it was not an emergency call from someone inside the house.
The truth is this:
Jeremy Bamber (deliberately?) left the phone off the hook at Whitehouse Farm so that no one from that point onwards, would be able to get through to the house. It ensured that confusion and suspicion was aroused and maintained when Jeremy Bamber got home after murdering his family, got cleaned up and then rang the police.
Having the phone off the hook at 3 in the morning, would enhance the feeling that there was something wrong going on in the house, whilst Jeremy Bamber was at his own house.
Under cross examination, during the actual court case in 1986, Jeremy Bamber confirmed that he took a call from his father to say that his sister had got the guns and gone crazy. Bamber then said the line went dead as if the actual phone cable had been cut with a pair of scissors.
Jeremy Bamber then confirmed that he himself hung up by pressing the two buttons on those old phones, which would have disconnected the call, thus allowing him to make another call.
He then claims to have immediately rang his father up again but got the engaged signal. i.e. the phone at white house farm is now off the hook, which could then be confirmed by the police, therefore heightening the feeling that there really was something wrong....whilst Jeremy Bamber was 3 miles away at his own house.
But it was confirmed by BT engineers at the time, and in court in 1986, that Jeremy Bamber would not have been able to phone back for at least another 2 minutes (apparantly up to 10 minutes) due to the mechanical nature of the phone system in 1986.
The phone at Jeremy Bambers house would have been completely non-functioning for several minutes, whilst the mechanics at the various exchanges unlocked themselves.
Therefore Jeremy Bamber did not phone his dad back when he said he did. It did not happen. And yet that was a huge part of Jeremy Bambers story at the time, and one that he repeated.
But it factually never happened.
And that was his alibi.
And now he is twisting it around, along with his supporters that the subsequent redirect to HQIR at 06:09, was a 999 call from inside the house. Which is provably untrue.
And what I've just written are the actual known facts, and those facts are undefeatable by anyone anywhere.
Every aspect of Jeremy Bambers case is like that, once you delve a bit deeper and stay neutral.
Neither Simon Hattenstone or Heidi Blake would ever dare to come on here and try and defeat my arguments because they know I'd tear their own arguments to shreds.
They know they are emotionally attached to the case. They are both consumed by that emotion.
This is a known psychology, where people will promote lies and fiction in order to protect something they have become emotionally attached to. This was Eric Allisons weakness too. And deep down they all know it, but are unable to confront it, or defeat it. The emotion is too strong.
What do you make of Philip Boyces Aga burn evidence, colsville?
-
What do you make of Philip Boyces Aga burn evidence, colsville?
I haven't visited this for a couple of years....so my knowledge is from 2 or 3 years ago...but back then, the theory didn't amount in any way whatsoever as evidence.
So the argument falls down straight away.
And then if you could show through some actual scientific method that the burn marks came from the aga, it still doesn't shed any light on what happened that night, therefore it still wouldn't count for anything.
Evidence has to point to something specific happening, so even if you can prove the burn marks came from the aga (which wasn't the case 2 or 3 years ago), it in no way incriminates the police any more than it incriminates Jeremy Bamber, or anyone else.
-
I haven't visited this for a couple of years....so my knowledge is from 2 or 3 years ago...but back then, the theory didn't amount in any way whatsoever as evidence.
So the argument falls down straight away.
And then if you could show through some actual scientific method that the burn marks came from the aga, it still doesn't shed any light on what happened that night, therefore it still wouldn't count for anything.
Evidence has to point to something specific happening, so even if you can prove the burn marks came from the aga (which wasn't the case 2 or 3 years ago), it in no way incriminates the police any more than it incriminates Jeremy Bamber, or anyone else.
As far as I know, the Aga evidence hasn't been rejected yet by the CCRC, colsville.
-
As far as I know, the Aga evidence hasn't been rejected yet by the CCRC, colsville.
The CCRC is just an investigative body, you could submit the Oxford English Dictionary to them and claim that it was new evidence, and the CCRC would be obliged to investigate.
So submitting 'new evidence' to the CCRC in itself is meaningless. It only means something when they decide that the claimed new evidence actually turns out to be new evidence. And even then it only passes, if it had the possibility of changing a guilty verdict to not guilty at the original court case.
The aga theory doesn't come close. Even if the CCRC accept that Nevill Bambers burn marks came from the aga, it doesn't incriminate anyone. Nothing changes. So how would it have a chance of changing the verdict of the original jury in 1986?
That's why it will fail, if it has been submitted.
But the submission in itself is meaningless. I think some people, and some newspapers think that the CCRC is the actual appeals service itself, when it is no such thing.
-
The CCRC is just an investigative body, you could submit the Oxford English Dictionary to them and claim that it was new evidence, and the CCRC would be obliged to investigate.
So submitting 'new evidence' to the CCRC in itself is meaningless. It only means something when they decide that the claimed new evidence actually turns out to be new evidence. And even then it only passes, if it had the possibility of changing a guilty verdict to not guilty at the original court case.
The aga theory doesn't come close. Even if the CCRC accept that Nevill Bambers burn marks came from the aga, it doesn't incriminate anyone. Nothing changes. So how would it have a chance of changing the verdict of the original jury in 1986?
That's why it will fail, if it has been submitted.
But the submission in itself is meaningless. I think some people, and some newspapers think that the CCRC is the actual appeals service itself, when it is no such thing.
OK, thanks, colsville!