Disappeared and Abducted Children and Young Adults => Madeleine McCann (3) disappeared from her parent's holiday apartment at Ocean Club, Praia da Luz, Portugal on 3 May 2007. No trace of her has ever been found. => Topic started by: Redblossom on October 16, 2013, 03:12:31 AM
Title: The Mccanns PIs sat on the Smiths efits for years
Post by: Redblossom on October 16, 2013, 03:12:31 AM
Until SY discovered them whilst trawling through all the files they had recovered and now have made them public...Discus
Title: Re: The Mccanns PIs sat on the Smiths efits for years
Post by: Mr Gray on October 16, 2013, 07:49:37 AM
why didn't the pj get an e fit 6 years ago...that's a more pertinent question
The question here is, why did the McCanns keep the e fit the Smiths had given out of the public domain for five years
... and why, for those five years did they insist that the Smiths had seen the same that Jane Tanner had seen 45 minutes before ... when the images they were keeping private clearly showed he was not
Title: Re: The Mccanns PIs sat on the Smiths efits for years
Post by: Mr Gray on October 16, 2013, 07:58:25 AM
The question here is, why did the McCanns keep the e fit the Smiths had given out of the public domain for five years
... and why, for those five years did they insist that the Smiths had seen the same that Jane Tanner had seen 45 minutes before ... when the images they were keeping private clearly showed he was not
They obviously didn't realise the significance of it as the pj didn't..thank heavens for SY
Title: Re: The Mccanns PIs sat on the Smiths efits for years
Post by: icabodcrane on October 16, 2013, 08:17:54 AM
They obviously didn't realise the significance of it as the pj didn't..thank heavens for SY
Didn't realise the significance ?
They have always said they believe the man Jane saw and the man the Smiths saw were the 'same' man
Jane did not see the man's face ... the Smiths did
If the McCanns genuinely believed it was the same man that the witnesses had seen, then it is inconceivable that they would fail to release the e fits which were detailed ( the Smiths ) and keep emphasising the one that was not detailed ( Jane's ) l
Title: Re: The Mccanns PIs sat on the Smiths efits for years
Post by: Mr Gray on October 16, 2013, 08:20:12 AM
They have always said they believe the man Jane saw and the man the Smiths saw were the 'same' man
Jane did not see the man's face ... the Smiths did
If the McCanns genuinely believed it was the same man that the witnesses had seen, then it is inconceivable that they would fail to release the e fits which were detailed ( the Smiths ) and keep emphasising the one that was not detailed ( Jane's ) l
No they haven't..they said the two had similarities..you are utterly wrong as you have shown yourself to be
Title: Re: The Mccanns PIs sat on the Smiths efits for years
Post by: sadie on October 16, 2013, 08:44:13 AM
The question here is, why did the McCanns keep the e fit the Smiths had given out of the public domain for five years
... and why, for those five years did they insist that the Smiths had seen the same that Jane Tanner had seen 45 minutes before ... when the images they were keeping private clearly showed he was not
Hang on a bit. Those eFit images were both given by the Smiths, so why are you saying that? Jane didn't see enough of her mans face to make an eFit. Dont you remember scoffing at eggman.
You are just obfusctaing, it seems
Another effort at putting the boot in? Blame the Mccanns for something they haven't done
Whip up suspicions?
Title: Re: The Mccanns PIs sat on the Smiths efits for years
Post by: icabodcrane on October 16, 2013, 08:53:37 AM
When the McCanns produced their own 'reconstruction' they went as far as to alter the Smith family's police statements ... they 'changed' the manner in which the Smiths had said the child was being carried, and had him carrying the child in the manner in which Jane Tanner had described
My impression was that an 'illusion' that both sightings ( Jane's and the Smiths ) had been of the same man was being presented
Certainly, no mention was made during that documentary that the man the Smiths saw could be an entirely 'different' man and that their sighting should be treated as significant in it's own right ... regardless of, and seperate from, Jane's
Come to think of it, I don't recall the McCanns ever saying that the Smith sighting should be viewed as important in it's own right because it might alter the time at which an abduction may have occured
( Which is precisely what Scotland Yard are now saying )
Title: Re: The Mccanns PIs sat on the Smiths efits for years
Post by: Wonderfulspam on October 16, 2013, 08:53:44 AM
LMAO at McCann supporters, I apreciate it may be difficult for you all to admit but you have fallen for McCann bullshit since 2007.
Title: Re: The Mccanns PIs sat on the Smiths efits for years
Post by: icabodcrane on October 16, 2013, 09:05:05 AM
Hang on a bit. Those eFit images were both given by the Smiths, so why are you saying that? Jane didn't see enough of her mans face to make an eFit. Dont you remember scoffing at eggman.
You are just obfusctaing, it seems
Another effort at putting the boot in? Blame the Mccanns for something they haven't done
Whip up suspicions?
I don't even know what that post means
Are you saying that the McCanns did NOT keep the e fits given by the Smith family out of the public domain for five years ?
Title: Re: The Mccanns PIs sat on the Smiths efits for years
Post by: DCI on October 16, 2013, 09:36:55 AM
The Sun newspaper reported that a holidaying Irish family saw the man at 10pm on the night of May 3 2008 carrying a child.
'Revelation moment'
They said the girl was wearing pink or light-coloured pyjamas similar to the ones Madeleine was wearing, and that she was slumped against him.
Martin Smith, his wife Aoife and son Peter said they gave a description of the man to Portuguese police but no picture was ever released.
If you are saying that it was wrong of the Portuguese police not to make public the descriptions the Smith family gave of the man they had seen, then I agree with you ... that information should have been put into the public domain
By the same reasoning, though, you must accept that the McCanns should have released the e fits the Smith gave to their private detectives into the public domain too
The Portugeuse police work under the restraint of 'secrecy laws' I believe ... what reason did the McCannns have, though, for keeping those e fit images away from the public ?
Title: Re: The Mccanns PIs sat on the Smiths efits for years
Post by: Montclair on October 16, 2013, 10:21:08 AM
Hang on a bit. Those eFit images were both given by the Smiths, so why are you saying that? Jane didn't see enough of her mans face to make an eFit. Dont you remember scoffing at eggman.
You are just obfusctaing, it seems
Another effort at putting the boot in? Blame the Mccanns for something they haven't done
Whip up suspicions?
In accordance with a report from the Drogheda, the Smiths stated that they did not give any statements to anyone nor did they give any e-fits. So, where did these e-fits come from?
Title: Re: The Mccanns PIs sat on the Smiths efits for years
Post by: faithlilly on October 16, 2013, 12:02:37 PM
In accordance with a report from the Drogheda, the Smiths stated that they did not give any statements to anyone nor did they give any e-fits. So, where did these e-fits come from?
That was what I was thinking Montclair. Were the efits simply drawn up from the descriptions in the Smith's statements ?
Title: Re: The Mccanns PIs sat on the Smiths efits for years
Post by: Redblossom on October 16, 2013, 12:24:29 PM
why didn't the pj get an e fit 6 years ago...that's a more pertinent question
You dont know why the PJ did not create an efit..maybe the Smiths told them they couldnt see his face properly in the dark.....maybe it was part of their way of doing things not putting out things to the media..... point is, as of today, we know, and as reported on channel 4 news...the Mccanns PIs got these efits done some time in 2008, did not pass the onto the PJ, did not publicise them ever, did not even mention them, did not mention or publicise the smiths sightings hardly at all all these years,and it took SY trawling through their files to find them, and today they seem to be ultra important....meanwhile the Mccanns their PIs and PR adviser in their wisdom thought it important to make press conferences and efits of people not even connected to anything happening on that night or even in the same country as opposed to the Smiths efit which was..... do you seriously think a woman in spain in a bar days later thinking she heard something vague and te man who reported thts coming forward two yrs later or a charity man nowhere near the place a week earlier creeping out mrs cooper were so more important?? Than a whole family seeing a 3 yr old blonde girl being carried by a man nearby to the abduction? Pull the other one.....seems to me they turned unlikely stones and not likely ones let alone all of them!
Title: Re: The Mccanns PIs sat on the Smiths efits for years
Post by: Mr Gray on October 16, 2013, 12:33:53 PM
I don't believe that the Smiths were ever persuaded to collaborate with the PIs and provide e-fits. Here in Portugal, the Smith sighting was publicised on the tv and the PJ was hoping that someone would come forward to eliminate themselves but noone ever came forward. And the McCanns never made commented on that sighting until much later and they had no choice.
Title: Re: The Mccanns PIs sat on the Smiths efits for years
Post by: jassi on October 16, 2013, 02:10:16 PM
I don't believe that the Smiths were ever persuaded to collaborate with the PIs and provide e-fits. Here in Portugal, the Smith sighting was publicised on the tv and the PJ was hoping that someone would come forward to eliminate themselves but noone ever came forward. And the McCanns never made commented on that sighting until much later and they had no choice.
Theres no evidence they did is there? But someone produced them all very odd
Title: Re: The Mccanns PIs sat on the Smiths efits for years
Post by: Montclair on October 16, 2013, 02:11:27 PM
therefore the efits must have been produced for, and hidden by, the Portuguese police.
It's great watching a thread by devoted [ censored word] develop.
You read things that don't exist. No e-fit was done by the PJ. If one had been done it would have been in the files and anyway everyone is reporting that Metodo 3 did them. I have no idea where they got their information to do them.
Title: Re: The Mccanns PIs sat on the Smiths efits for years
Post by: imustpointout on October 16, 2013, 02:22:01 PM
You read things that don't exist. No e-fit was done by the PJ. If one had been done it would have been in the files and anyway everyone is reporting that Metodo 3 did them. I have no idea where they got their information to do them.
it will be very interesting to see how accurate your statement turns out to be.
Title: Re: The Mccanns PIs sat on the Smiths efits for years
Post by: DCI on October 16, 2013, 03:09:28 PM
If you are saying that it was wrong of the Portuguese police not to make public the descriptions the Smith family gave of the man they had seen, then I agree with you ... that information should have been put into the public domain
By the same reasoning, though, you must accept that the McCanns should have released the e fits the Smith gave to their private detectives into the public domain too
The Portugeuse police work under the restraint of 'secrecy laws' I believe ... what reason did the McCannns have, though, for keeping those e fit images away from the public ?
Yes that is exactly what I'm saying. amaral had the Smith description from May 2007. Doesn't release it, but has the cheek to use the photofit details, the McCann's had done of Jane's sighting, in his book. Which was actually sent to Paiva in October 2007, by Bob Small courtesy of Gerry. So how did amaral get his mitts on it?
It wasn't the McCann's place to release the Smith sighting, they didn't have it till 2008. According to amaral, "Their coming to Portugal as well as their statements are kept secret".
Why isn't the Estrela CCTV mentioned in the files, or his book? He's now saying this could have shown the abductor carrying Madeleine.
Hello! He thought Madeleine had been harmed and her parents, disposed of her, he wants to make his mind up. Concidering its got FA do to with him now, he can't keep his neb out, can he?
If I remember correctly, the PJ didn't want anything from the PI's, and ignored it all.
Its no good Amaral prattling on about SY, not finding anything till now, when they have had to sort his mess out, to find crucial evidence that he should have done 6 years ago.
Title: Re: The Mccanns PIs sat on the Smiths efits for years
Post by: icabodcrane on October 16, 2013, 03:32:14 PM
Yes that is exactly what I'm saying. amaral had the Smith description from May 2007. Doesn't release it, but has the cheek to use the photofit details, the McCann's had done of Jane's sighting, in his book. Which was actually sent to Paiva in October 2007, by Bob Small courtesy of Gerry. So how did amaral get his mitts on it?
It wasn't the McCann's place to release the Smith sighting, they didn't have it till 2008. According to amaral, "Their coming to Portugal as well as their statements are kept secret".
Why isn't the Estrela CCTV mentioned in the files, or his book? He's now saying this could have shown the abductor carrying Madeleine.
Hello! He thought Madeleine had been harmed and her parents, disposed of her, he wants to make his mind up. Concidering its got FA do to with him now, he can't keep his neb out, can he?
If I remember correctly, the PJ didn't want anything from the PI's, and ignored it all.
Its no good Amaral prattling on about SY, not finding anything till now, when they have had to sort his mess out, to find crucial evidence that he should have done 6 years ago.
In all of that you still havn't given an explanation as to WHY the McCanns kept the Smiths' e fits from the public for five years
It is not enough to say '"it wasn't their place" to release them ... that is no explanation !
Scotland Yard found the e fits in the private detectives files and clearly thought they were extremely important
Why did the McCanns keep something so important, and potentially crucial in the search for their daughter, hidden ?
Title: Re: The Mccanns PIs sat on the Smiths efits for years
Post by: Wonderfulspam on October 16, 2013, 03:36:14 PM
I struggle to understand sitting on the e-fits whilst claiming to "leave no stone unturned". They deliberately ignored evidence & I believe they had their own motives for that. They have constantly highlighted the Tanner sighting in order to supress the real sighting.
Title: Re: The Mccanns PIs sat on the Smiths efits for years
Post by: DCI on October 16, 2013, 03:45:46 PM
I struggle to understand sitting on the e-fits whilst claiming to "leave no stone unturned". They deliberately ignored evidence & I believe they had their own motives for that. They have constantly highlighted the Tanner sighting in order to supress the real sighting.
You should be asking amaral the question, dear!
What were his motives for deliberately ignoring Smiths evidence, he had that evidence in May 2007, well before the McCann's did, why didn't he get his own efit done?
Title: Re: The Mccanns PIs sat on the Smiths efits for years
Post by: imustpointout on October 16, 2013, 03:50:44 PM
What were his motives for deliberately ignoring Smiths evidence, he had that evidence in May 2007, well before the McCann's did, why didn't he get his own efit done?
he (or the Portuguese Police) did get an efit done.
The reason it wasn't published is for an obvious reason - it didn't fir with the theory at the time and would have distracted from the Portuguese Police investigation.
And - if people could look in the official files - it will be there, or reference to it will be there even if the efits were destroyed as a cover up.
Title: Re: The Mccanns PIs sat on the Smiths efits for years
Post by: DCI on October 16, 2013, 03:57:14 PM
he (or the Portuguese Police) did get an efit done.
The reason it wasn't published is for an obvious reason - it didn't fir with the theory at the time and would have distracted from the Portuguese Police investigation.
And - if people could look in the official files - it will be there, or reference to it will be there even if the efits were destroyed as a cover up.
Sounds about right,
"The e-fit images were generated for private investigators in 2008. The Yard declined to comment on why they were not released until yesterday".
You read things that don't exist. No e-fit was done by the PJ. If one had been done it would have been in the files and anyway everyone is reporting that Metodo 3 did them. I have no idea where they got their information to do them.
Why not? They were Amaral's key witnesses?
Title: Re: The Mccanns PIs sat on the Smiths efits for years
Post by: DCI on October 16, 2013, 08:11:52 PM
Madeleine McCann: Key witness accuses Portuguese police of not taking his vital prime suspect evidence seriously 16 Oct 2013 07:59
Retired businessman Martin Smith provided details for an e-fit of the prime suspect after spotting the mystery man close to where Maddie vanished
A key witness in the Madeleine McCann case claimed yesterday that Portuguese police failed to take his evidence seriously.
Retired businessman Martin Smith, 64, provided details for an e-fit of the prime suspect after spotting the mystery man carrying a child at 10pm close to where the three-year-old vanished more than six years ago.
But he said his information was virtually ignored by local officers because they were too busy chasing up another sighting of a man near Kate and Gerry McCanns holiday apartment in Praia da Luz 45 minutes earlier.
Scotland Yard detectives reinvestigating the case after six years have now established that the suspect Portuguese police were so keen to trace spotted by holidaymaker Jane Tanner at 9.20pm was just an innocent British tourist returning his own child from a crèche.
the question in the OP is why the Mccanns and or their PIs sat on this for five years..............
Title: Re: The Mccanns PIs sat on the Smiths efits for years
Post by: jassi on October 16, 2013, 08:17:07 PM
The PJ should certainly have followed this up straight away, bit I seem to recall that they were under pressure, from embassy staff and perhaps others, not to look too closely at the McCanns, but to follow the abduction line.
Title: Re: The Mccanns PIs sat on the Smiths efits for years
Post by: stephen25000 on October 16, 2013, 08:39:54 PM
The PJ should certainly have followed this up straight away, bit I seem to recall that they were under pressure, from embassy staff and perhaps others, not to look too closely at the McCanns, but to follow the abduction line.
Now what happened to the UK ambassador to Portugal at the time ?
He said if I recall correctly there were 'discrepencies' in the groups stories. >@@(*&)
Title: Re: The Mccanns PIs sat on the Smiths efits for years
Post by: Victoria on October 16, 2013, 08:42:22 PM
The PJ should certainly have followed this up straight away, bit I seem to recall that they were under pressure, from embassy staff and perhaps others, not to look too closely at the McCanns, but to follow the abduction line.
The only person I'm aware of to make that claim is convicted criminal Amaral.
Title: Re: The Mccanns PIs sat on the Smiths efits for years
Post by: DCI on October 16, 2013, 08:43:57 PM
Madeleine McCann: Key witness accuses Portuguese police of not taking his vital prime suspect evidence seriously 16 Oct 2013 07:59
Retired businessman Martin Smith provided details for an e-fit of the prime suspect after spotting the mystery man close to where Maddie vanished
A key witness in the Madeleine McCann case claimed yesterday that Portuguese police failed to take his evidence seriously.
Retired businessman Martin Smith, 64, provided details for an e-fit of the prime suspect after spotting the mystery man carrying a child at 10pm close to where the three-year-old vanished more than six years ago.
But he said his information was virtually ignored by local officers because they were too busy chasing up another sighting of a man near Kate and Gerry McCann’s holiday apartment in Praia da Luz 45 minutes earlier.
Scotland Yard detectives reinvestigating the case after six years have now established that the suspect Portuguese police were so keen to trace – spotted by holidaymaker Jane Tanner at 9.20pm – was just an innocent British tourist returning his own child from a crèche.
Madeleine McCann: Key witness accuses Portuguese police of not taking his vital prime suspect evidence seriously 16 Oct 2013 07:59
Retired businessman Martin Smith provided details for an e-fit of the prime suspect after spotting the mystery man close to where Maddie vanished
A key witness in the Madeleine McCann case claimed yesterday that Portuguese police failed to take his evidence seriously.
Retired businessman Martin Smith, 64, provided details for an e-fit of the prime suspect after spotting the mystery man carrying a child at 10pm close to where the three-year-old vanished more than six years ago.
But he said his information was virtually ignored by local officers because they were too busy chasing up another sighting of a man near Kate and Gerry McCann’s holiday apartment in Praia da Luz 45 minutes earlier.
Scotland Yard detectives reinvestigating the case after six years have now established that the suspect Portuguese police were so keen to trace – spotted by holidaymaker Jane Tanner at 9.20pm – was just an innocent British tourist returning his own child from a crèche.
The Portuguese investigation failed to give priority to the most credible witness statement ( that of the Smith family ) ... and put all resources into Jane Tanner's ( less credible ) witness statement instead
Why ?
I might be wrong, but I seem to remember that the emphasis was put on Jane Tanner's 'abductor' following the intervention of Gordon Brown ... who had been in personal contact wit the McCanns ( which resulted in the 'bundleman' photo-fit being released by Portuguese police, against usual practice )
Let's be fair here people, it was the McCanns who wanted Jane's sighting to take precedence over the Smiths' ... and they succeeded ... until now
Title: Re: The Mccanns PIs sat on the Smiths efits for years
Post by: AnneGuedes on October 17, 2013, 12:15:34 AM
The PJ should certainly have followed this up straight away, bit I seem to recall that they were under pressure, from embassy staff and perhaps others, not to look too closely at the McCanns, but to follow the abduction line.
Yes the abductor official sighting was overwhelming and imo they sent for the 3 Smiths in case they would recognize Mr Murat.
Title: Re: The Mccanns PIs sat on the Smiths efits for years
Post by: AnneGuedes on October 17, 2013, 01:51:44 AM
The Portuguese investigation failed to give priority to the most credible witness statement ( that of the Smith family ) ... and put all resources into Jane Tanner's ( less credible ) witness statement instead
Why ?
I might be wrong, but I seem to remember that the emphasis was put on Jane Tanner's 'abductor' following the intervention of Gordon Brown ... who had been in personal contact wit the McCanns ( which resulted in the 'bundleman' photo-fit being released by Portuguese police, against usual practice )
Let's be fair here people, it was the McCanns who wanted Jane's sighting to take precedence over the Smiths' ... and they succeeded ... until now
30 January 2008 Cover note Detective Branch Drogheda County Lough Re – Investigation into the disappearance of Madeleine McCann I took an additional statement from Mr Smith as requested. His wife does not want to make another statement. I showed him the video clip and he stated that it was not the clip that alerted him but the BBC news at 10 PM on 9th September 2007. He has been contacted by numerous tabloid press looking for stories. He has been contacted by Mr Brian Kennedy who is supporting the McCann family to take part in a photo fit exercise. He has given no stories or helped in any photo fits. He sent a solicitor’s letter to six papers in relation material that was printed that was misquoted. The Evening Herald paid his solicitor's fees and all papers printed an apology. His photograph appeared in another tabloid paper and this matter is being pursued at the moment.
I do not believe that Martin Smith is courting the press and my view his is a genuine person. He is known locally and is a very decent person.
Forwarded please
Sergeant
L*** H****
Title: Re: The Mccanns PIs sat on the Smiths efits for years
Post by: Lyall on October 17, 2013, 11:02:55 AM
Discovered by trawling through the files means that the original police had had them all along and chose to do nothing with it. Why no criticism of them Red? Not just you Red, but the bias of threads and posts by both sides here is getting intolerable. There is no chance of informed debate as the posts are shaped by the poster's already decided opinion of whether the McCanns are ogres or the opposite.
As I understand it the PIs (Metodo) had them, not the Portuguese police. Did Metodo pass them on to the PIs who replaced them?
Presumably the Met have had them for a while now and didn't do anything with them until Monday? That's a question they need to answer - when exactly did they find them? For all we know it was two years ago.
Title: Re: The Mccanns PIs sat on the Smiths efits for years
Post by: Lyall on October 17, 2013, 11:10:30 AM
A reasonable post, but why would an e-fit released by the McCanns carry the same weight as one released by the police. The decision on whether to release photo-fits or e-fits now is taken by the police. In this case, the original decision is the one that should get most heat unless there are good reasons not to do so. I can't see why that would happen unless it was thought that it would complicate matters.
that said they can become real red-herrings. There were two in the Lynette White Inquiry, which looked nothing like each other. One was featured on Crimewatch. The other wasn't and the one that was took the inquiry down the wrong path. By the way four years afterwards a man came forward claiming he was the man in the photofit. I interviewed him and I don't think he was. He looked like the man and was expecting to be talked to over it.
Fact remains police should never have believed the photofit was of the killer as it never made sense. It meant that the killer had waited at the scene for over 13 hours and then decided to leave in broad daylight having committed the crime in pitch black at night. Have the PJ explained why they did not release it? After that, let's see how the McCanns explain their decision.
They don't do explanations Dhingra, they do PR. That's one big reason for suspicion. Everything is always managed.
Title: Re: The Mccanns PIs sat on the Smiths efits for years
Post by: C.Edwards on October 17, 2013, 11:11:24 AM
A reasonable post, but why would an e-fit released by the McCanns carry the same weight as one released by the police. The decision on whether to release photo-fits or e-fits now is taken by the police. In this case, the original decision is the one that should get most heat unless there are good reasons not to do so. I can't see why that would happen unless it was thought that it would complicate matters.
that said they can become real red-herrings. There were two in the Lynette White Inquiry, which looked nothing like each other. One was featured on Crimewatch. The other wasn't and the one that was took the inquiry down the wrong path. By the way four years afterwards a man came forward claiming he was the man in the photofit. I interviewed him and I don't think he was. He looked like the man and was expecting to be talked to over it.
Fact remains police should never have believed the photofit was of the killer as it never made sense. It meant that the killer had waited at the scene for over 13 hours and then decided to leave in broad daylight having committed the crime in pitch black at night. Have the PJ explained why they did not release it? After that, let's see how the McCanns explain their decision.
Perhaps the PJ realised that e-fits generated from a sighting by a family where they pretty much said they didn't get a good look at the bloke's face were next to useless? Just saying. To paraphrase someone else, I see my postman every day. Have done for years. If you told me to generate an e-fit now, it would be bloody hopeless other than "male, slightly graying hair, nose, two eyes and a mouth"!
Out of curiosity, is there any record/statistics on how accurate e-fits are when perpetrators are actually caught?
Title: Re: The Mccanns PIs sat on the Smiths efits for years
Post by: jassi on October 17, 2013, 11:13:19 AM
A reasonable post, but why would an e-fit released by the McCanns carry the same weight as one released by the police. The decision on whether to release photo-fits or e-fits now is taken by the police. In this case, the original decision is the one that should get most heat unless there are good reasons not to do so. I can't see why that would happen unless it was thought that it would complicate matters.
that said they can become real red-herrings. There were two in the Lynette White Inquiry, which looked nothing like each other. One was featured on Crimewatch. The other wasn't and the one that was took the inquiry down the wrong path. By the way four years afterwards a man came forward claiming he was the man in the photofit. I interviewed him and I don't think he was. He looked like the man and was expecting to be talked to over it.
Fact remains police should never have believed the photofit was of the killer as it never made sense. It meant that the killer had waited at the scene for over 13 hours and then decided to leave in broad daylight having committed the crime in pitch black at night. Have the PJ explained why they did not release it? After that, let's see how the McCanns explain their decision.
Did the PJ ever do an e-fit with the Smiths, or was it just a verbal description? It appears that the Metodo 3 images were not available to them and presumably were handed to Edgar, who also chose to do nothing with them, either.
Edited to correct from Metodo 2 to 3 (blushes)
Title: Re: The Mccanns PIs sat on the Smiths efits for years
Post by: DCI on October 17, 2013, 11:21:52 AM
Did the PJ ever do an e-fit with the Smiths, or was it just a verbal description? It appears that the Metodo 2 images were not available to them and presumably were handed to Edgar, who also chose to do nothing with them, either.
Metodo 2? @)(++(*
Title: Re: The Mccanns PIs sat on the Smiths efits for years
Post by: jassi on October 17, 2013, 11:26:19 AM
Perhaps the PJ realised that e-fits generated from a sighting by a family where they pretty much said they didn't get a good look at the bloke's face were next to useless? Just saying. To paraphrase someone else, I see my postman every day. Have done for years. If you told me to generate an e-fit now, it would be bloody hopeless other than "male, slightly graying hair, nose, two eyes and a mouth"!
Out of curiosity, is there any record/statistics on how accurate e-fits are when perpetrators are actually caught?
So would I, but you certainly would recognize him in a parade. If the e-fits are 5 years old, they weren't requested by SY. Since Mr Smith declared to the gardaï, at the end of January 2008, that he had been contacted by Mr (double glass) Kennedy in order to make e-fits and had refused, I wonder what made him change his mind.
Title: Re: The Mccanns PIs sat on the Smiths efits for years
Post by: AnneGuedes on October 17, 2013, 12:13:29 PM
Title: Re: The Mccanns PIs sat on the Smiths efits for years
Post by: C.Edwards on October 17, 2013, 12:25:58 PM
Perhaps the PJ realised that e-fits generated from a sighting by a family where they pretty much said they didn't get a good look at the bloke's face were next to useless? Just saying. To paraphrase someone else, I see my postman every day. Have done for years. If you told me to generate an e-fit now, it would be bloody hopeless other than "male, slightly graying hair, nose, two eyes and a mouth"!
Out of curiosity, is there any record/statistics on how accurate e-fits are when perpetrators are actually caught?
I'm not sure about statistics on accuracy, but I did read something the other day that said in 70% of miscarriages of justice faulty witnesses were a contributing factor.
Title: Re: The Mccanns PIs sat on the Smiths efits for years
Post by: AnneGuedes on October 17, 2013, 12:54:35 PM
I'm not sure about statistics on accuracy, but I did read something the other day that said in 70% of miscarriages of justice faulty witnesses were a contributing factor.
Thank you. This is certainly an interesting point to examine.
Title: Re: The Mccanns PIs sat on the Smiths efits for years
Post by: AnneGuedes on October 17, 2013, 01:07:26 PM
They say the e-fits were done in September 2008. Since April 2008 Metodo 3 had stopped to work for the McCanns and Mr Kennedy had signed a contract with Oakley International (Halligen). This contract was broken precisely in September. Beginning of September, the McCanns were looking for retired police officers to search for Madeleine. So who ordered the e-fits to be made, what "based on" means, why do they look so virtual and what do the presumed sources think about them ?
Title: Re: The Mccanns PIs sat on the Smiths efits for years
Post by: DCI on October 17, 2013, 01:38:26 PM
As I understand it the PIs (Metodo) had them, not the Portuguese police. Did Metodo pass them on to the PIs who replaced them?
Presumably the Met have had them for a while now and didn't do anything with them until Monday? That's a question they need to answer - when exactly did they find them? For all we know it was two years ago.
I thought you knew all about the case, Lyall @)(++(*
Everyone seems to be under the illusion, Metodo3 got these efits done, WRONG!
Title: Re: The Mccanns PIs sat on the Smiths efits for years
Post by: Lyall on October 17, 2013, 01:40:06 PM
I thought you knew all about the case, Lyall @)(++(*
Everyone seems to be under the illusion, Metodo3 got these efits done, WRONG!
So who did, then ?
Title: Re: The Mccanns PIs sat on the Smiths efits for years
Post by: AnneGuedes on October 17, 2013, 02:07:38 PM
Opinion of a French retired-inspector on this "melodrama'" http://moreas.blog.lemonde.fr/2013/10/17/la-disparition-de-la-petite-maddie-tourne-au-melo/ (http://moreas.blog.lemonde.fr/2013/10/17/la-disparition-de-la-petite-maddie-tourne-au-melo/)
Title: Re: The Mccanns PIs sat on the Smiths efits for years
Post by: jassi on October 17, 2013, 02:18:28 PM
I see there is mention of a £20,000 reward for information. Is this common knowledge ?
Title: Re: The Mccanns PIs sat on the Smiths efits for years
Post by: jassi on October 17, 2013, 02:29:58 PM