UK Justice Forum 🇬🇧

Disappeared and Abducted Children and Young Adults => Madeleine McCann (3) disappeared from her parent's holiday apartment at Ocean Club, Praia da Luz, Portugal on 3 May 2007. No trace of her has ever been found. => Topic started by: imustpointout on November 05, 2013, 04:29:21 PM

Title: all logical considerations should be open to the investigation
Post by: imustpointout on November 05, 2013, 04:29:21 PM
stephen has posted today

Quote
In an open system, all logical considerations should be open to the investigation, and in the SY review it clearly isn't.

How can stephen or other posters say that without evidence?

This thread is an opportunity to provide the evidence one way or another.
Title: Re: all logical considerations should be open to the investigation
Post by: Aiofe on November 05, 2013, 07:16:15 PM
stephen has posted today

How can stephen or other posters say that without evidence?

This thread is an opportunity to provide the evidence one way or another.

Abduction is certainly a possibility, yet Stephen continually says it is not.

The reality is that in any investigation, all avenues are open, but some are more fruitful than others, some have been checked before, and some have no hope of being proved.

Both the Met and PJ seem to be concentrating on abduction now, which is why there is so much whistling in the dark going on.
Title: Re: all logical considerations should be open to the investigation
Post by: jassi on November 05, 2013, 07:20:19 PM
I wonder what SY will do if their investigations into an abduction come to nothing. Will they call it a day or look (again) at other possibilities ?
Title: Re: all logical considerations should be open to the investigation
Post by: BigFatBlonde on November 05, 2013, 07:31:05 PM
I wonder what SY will do if their investigations into an abduction come to nothing. Will they call it a day or look (again) at other possibilities ?

When the furore first started (about a week before the CW special) I posted here that it felt like an 'end game' to me. I.e. SY do this final bit of investigation, find nothing, the throw their arms in the air and say "that's it, we've exhausted every avenue of investigation"

They have spent a lot of money though and will have some awkward questions to answer if they get no results, so I'm probably barking up the wrong tree.

N
Title: Re: all logical considerations should be open to the investigation
Post by: Mr Gray on November 05, 2013, 07:39:31 PM
When the furore first started (about a week before the CW special) I posted here that it felt like an 'end game' to me. I.e. SY do this final bit of investigation, find nothing, the throw their arms in the air and say "that's it, we've exhausted every avenue of investigation"

They have spent a lot of money though and will have some awkward questions to answer if they get no results, so I'm probably barking up the wrong tree.

N
I don't think they will have any questions to answer whatever the outcome. It wasn't their idea to take the case on.It was Camerons . did they have a choice?
Title: Re: all logical considerations should be open to the investigation
Post by: jassi on November 05, 2013, 07:39:48 PM
We probably won't know until the investigations ends if they have any credible evidence of an abduction and I suppose we might never know how seriously they have looked at other options.
Title: Re: all logical considerations should be open to the investigation
Post by: ferryman on November 05, 2013, 07:42:48 PM
For a moment, suspend reality and indulge Amaral's fantasy.

According to it (Amaral's fantasy!) Kate found Madeleine.  He insists that because Eddie picked up certain items of her clothing in his mouth, an outright deleterious reaction from any police dog attending a crime scene (I digress).

Kate then, somehow, pulls herself together, strolls back to the restaurant, where Gerry is oblivious, relaxed, and unaware, breaks dreadful news to him without anyone else noticing; then Gerry casually strolls out of the restaurant, gathers up the remains of his beloved daughter and hides them (Amaral's exact words) on the beach.

Meanwhile, Kate once more absence herself from the restaurant, then re-enters to raise a fake alarm.

And I really do believe in fairies at the bottom of the garden, Father Christmas, and the tooth fairy ...
Title: Re: all logical considerations should be open to the investigation
Post by: jassi on November 05, 2013, 07:42:54 PM
I don't think they will have any questions to answer whatever the outcome. It wasn't their idea to take the case on.It was Camerons . did they have a choice?

An interesting point. Normally the police work independently of political direction, but I suppose when the PM says jump, its difficult to refuse.?
Title: Re: all logical considerations should be open to the investigation
Post by: BigFatBlonde on November 05, 2013, 07:54:07 PM
I don't think they will have any questions to answer whatever the outcome. It wasn't their idea to take the case on.It was Camerons . did they have a choice?

In these times of austerity will it matter if they had a choice or not? You can guarantee that the Govt. wont take any blame for the amount spent.

Consider benefit fraud, something we have heard so much about and how stamping out the cheats is going to save the economy. The truth is it counts for around 2% of the annual amount of fraud (within the UK economy) and is less than the amount paid out in error by the DWP (http://www.cas.org.uk/features/myth-busting-real-figures-benefit-fraud)

Now, it isn't hard to see that if you spend over 5 million and have no results - some political bright spark is going to start asking questions. To be honest I feel sorry for Andy Redwood because if they don't have anything apart from the e-fits there is a strong chance he's going to get his arse handed to him in a sling.

Abduction is a possibility, but there doesn't seem to be a lot of good evidence to support it. In fact there doesn't seem to be a lot of good evidence to support much of anything. So if the abduction line of enquiry dies a death what will they do? The options would seem to be give up or investigate a different line.

N

Title: Re: all logical considerations should be open to the investigation
Post by: Mr Gray on November 05, 2013, 08:04:22 PM
In these times of austerity will it matter if they had a choice or not? You can guarantee that the Govt. wont take any blame for the amount spent.

Consider benefit fraud, something we have heard so much about and how stamping out the cheats is going to save the economy. The truth is it counts for around 2% of the annual amount of fraud (within the UK economy) and is less than the amount paid out in error by the DWP (http://www.cas.org.uk/features/myth-busting-real-figures-benefit-fraud)

Now, it isn't hard to see that if you spend over 5 million and have no results - some political bright spark is going to start asking questions. To be honest I feel sorry for Andy Redwood because if they don't have anything apart from the e-fits there is a strong chance he's going to get his arse handed to him in a sling.

Abduction is a possibility, but there doesn't seem to be a lot of good evidence to support it. In fact there doesn't seem to be a lot of good evidence to support much of anything. So if the abduction line of enquiry dies a death what will they do? The options would seem to be give up or investigate a different line.

N

 I don't think anyone will blame Redwood..Isn't his fault. He took this job at the request of the govt and no one can expect him to work miracles. The fault lies with the poor initial investigation...and that quite rightly has come in for a lot of criticism
Title: Re: all logical considerations should be open to the investigation
Post by: jassi on November 05, 2013, 08:06:11 PM
Was Redwood appointed to lead the investigation by Cameron/May or by the Commissioner of the Met?
Title: Re: all logical considerations should be open to the investigation
Post by: Mr Gray on November 05, 2013, 08:08:55 PM
Was Redwood appointed to lead the investigation by Cameron/May or by the Commissioner of the Met?

 Theres no doubt he was instructed to take the case..the initial decision was Cameron who would have asked the home office to take the necessary steps
Title: Re: all logical considerations should be open to the investigation
Post by: BigFatBlonde on November 05, 2013, 08:13:08 PM
I don't think anyone will blame Redwood..Isn't his fault. He took this job at the request of the govt and no one can expect him to work miracles. The fault lies with the poor initial investigation...and that quite rightly has come in for a lot of criticism

I would say that as head of the investigation he is responsible for the money spent. If the initial investigation was so poor why didn't SY realise they were on a hiding to nothing after the initial review of the files? Why did they press on spending more money?

I have seen criticism of the initial investigation, but it has all come from the pro McCann camp or the tabloid press. I would happily accept it was rubbish if a reliable source provided the evidence for it being so.

N
Title: Re: all logical considerations should be open to the investigation
Post by: Wonderfulspam on November 05, 2013, 08:18:19 PM
I don't think anyone will blame Redwood..Isn't his fault. He took this job at the request of the govt and no one can expect him to work miracles. The fault lies with the poor initial investigation...and that quite rightly has come in for a lot of criticism
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=2765.0

Francisco Moita Flores is a retired Polícia Judiciária (PJ) Inspector, he is also a writer. 

1) Defence lawyers

a) Dr Santos de Oliveira, GA's lawyer, is the first to question the witness.

SO – What reason did you have to comment on this case?

MF says that first it is his job.  He does it professionally because he has experience of being a police inspector and has connections with the police. In this particular case he says that very early he claimed that the police were making errors.

SO – Why?

MF Because they should have considered all the possible hypotheses instead of restricting the investigation to the prefabricated idea of abduction.
Title: Re: all logical considerations should be open to the investigation
Post by: Mr Gray on November 05, 2013, 08:18:56 PM
I would say that as head of the investigation he is responsible for the money spent. If the initial investigation was so poor why didn't SY realise they were on a hiding to nothing after the initial review of the files? Why did they press on spending more money?

I have seen criticism of the initial investigation, but it has all come from the pro McCann camp or the tabloid press. I would happily accept it was rubbish if a reliable source provided the evidence for it being so.

N

And what would be  a reliable source
Title: Re: all logical considerations should be open to the investigation
Post by: Mr Gray on November 05, 2013, 08:20:29 PM
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=2765.0

Francisco Moita Flores is a retired Polícia Judiciária (PJ) Inspector, he is also a writer. 

1) Defence lawyers

a) Dr Santos de Oliveira, GA's lawyer, is the first to question the witness.

SO – What reason did you have to comment on this case?

MF says that first it is his job.  He does it professionally because he has experience of being a police inspector and has connections with the police. In this particular case he says that very early he claimed that the police were making errors.

SO – Why?

MF Because they should have considered all the possible hypotheses instead of restricting the investigation to the prefabricated idea of abduction.

 I am sure all amarals buddies will criticise
Title: Re: all logical considerations should be open to the investigation
Post by: ferryman on November 05, 2013, 08:20:57 PM
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=2765.0

Francisco Moita Flores is a retired Polícia Judiciária (PJ) Inspector, he is also a writer. 

1) Defence lawyers

a) Dr Santos de Oliveira, GA's lawyer, is the first to question the witness.

SO – What reason did you have to comment on this case?

MF says that first it is his job.  He does it professionally because he has experience of being a police inspector and has connections with the police. In this particular case he says that very early he claimed that the police were making errors.

SO – Why?

MF Because they should have considered all the possible hypotheses instead of restricting the investigation to the prefabricated idea of abduction.
How is Flores better qualified than Kate's counsellor? 
Title: Re: all logical considerations should be open to the investigation
Post by: jassi on November 05, 2013, 08:25:32 PM
And what would be  a reliable source

Is that not in the eye of the beholder? I seem to recall last night that you were unwilling to accept anything you considered to be an 'anti' source as acceptable.
Title: Re: all logical considerations should be open to the investigation
Post by: Redblossom on November 05, 2013, 08:26:46 PM
And what would be  a reliable source

Not the red tops or tony parsons, dodgy ex policemen or the tapas 9 or clarence mitchell!!
 @)(++(*


Title: Re: all logical considerations should be open to the investigation
Post by: Mr Gray on November 05, 2013, 08:29:41 PM
Not the red tops or tony parsons, dodgy ex policemen or the tapas 9 or clarence mitchell!!
 @)(++(*

 What about the Times ...2 weeks ago


What a hard week for Kate and Gerry McCann. Every fragment of hope from a new Scotland Yard lead comes with regret: if only six years ago Portuguese police had done their job.



Title: Re: all logical considerations should be open to the investigation
Post by: Redblossom on November 05, 2013, 08:35:06 PM
What about the Times ...2 weeks ago


What a hard week for Kate and Gerry McCann. Every fragment of hope from a new Scotland Yard lead comes with regret: if only six years ago Portuguese police had done their job.

The  Times didnt comment on the original investigation afaiaw

You carry  on despising and criticising the PJ though.....if it makes you happy......hndisght is SUCH a wonderful  thing as Kate Mccann says......
 >@@(*&)











Title: Re: all logical considerations should be open to the investigation
Post by: Mr Gray on November 05, 2013, 08:37:13 PM
The  Times didnt comment on the original investigation afaiaw

You carry  on despising and criticising the PJ though.....if it makes you happy......

 Im not ...the Times is..thats a copy and paste
Title: Re: all logical considerations should be open to the investigation
Post by: Redblossom on November 05, 2013, 09:13:23 PM
Im not ...the Times is..thats a copy and paste

no idea what you are talking about, perhaps extrapolate or link
Title: Re: all logical considerations should be open to the investigation
Post by: Mr Gray on November 05, 2013, 09:16:37 PM
no idea what you are talking about, perhaps extrapolate or link

 This is a quote from the Times..two weeks ago...criticising the original investigation


What a hard week for Kate and Gerry McCann. Every fragment of hope from a new Scotland Yard lead comes with regret: if only six years ago Portuguese police had done their job.
Title: Re: all logical considerations should be open to the investigation
Post by: Redblossom on November 05, 2013, 09:19:14 PM
This is a quote from the Times..two weeks ago...criticising the original investigation


What a hard week for Kate and Gerry McCann. Every fragment of hope from a new Scotland Yard lead comes with regret: if only six years ago Portuguese police had done their job.

Oh i see.....wouldnt mind a link....see who wrote the sycophantic  tripe ta....must go now check back tomorrow......
Title: Re: all logical considerations should be open to the investigation
Post by: BigFatBlonde on November 05, 2013, 09:22:55 PM
And what would be  a reliable source

The UK police, any independent watchdog?

N
Title: Re: all logical considerations should be open to the investigation
Post by: Mr Gray on November 05, 2013, 09:24:35 PM
The UK police, any independent watchdog?

N

 well you know you wont get that. isn't the Times any good now
Title: Re: all logical considerations should be open to the investigation
Post by: BigFatBlonde on November 05, 2013, 09:29:01 PM
well you know you wont get that. isn't the Times any good now

Go back through my posts and try to find a single post where I have mentioned The Times, with holding information or blamed the McCanns for anything other than leaving their children.

The truth is, you won't find one because I don't get involved in those discussions.


..... inappropriate comment removed ....
Title: Re: all logical considerations should be open to the investigation
Post by: stephen25000 on November 06, 2013, 10:45:03 AM
What about the Times ...2 weeks ago


What a hard week for Kate and Gerry McCann. Every fragment of hope from a new Scotland Yard lead comes with regret: if only six years ago Portuguese police had done their job.


Haven't you read through the current Met's chief view of the Portuguese  ?

Title: Re: all logical considerations should be open to the investigation
Post by: Redblossom on November 06, 2013, 11:37:21 AM

Haven't you read through the current Met's chief view of the Portuguese  ?

Just a reminder



http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zM-8GEHM9MA&feature=youtube_gdata_player


From 31.20
Title: Re: all logical considerations should be open to the investigation
Post by: Mr Gray on November 06, 2013, 11:39:57 AM

Haven't you read through the current Met's chief view of the Portuguese  ?

that's his public official view...we don't know his private view
Title: Re: all logical considerations should be open to the investigation
Post by: Mr Gray on November 06, 2013, 11:48:28 AM
As could be said of DCI Redwood !

that's a fair statement but Redwood can be seen to investigating an abduction and is keeping the MCcANNS fully involved. there has been massive criticism of the PJ under amaral in the country that has the most libel friendly laws.
why hasn't amaral sued?
Title: Re: all logical considerations should be open to the investigation
Post by: stephen25000 on November 06, 2013, 11:52:48 AM
that's his public official view...we don't know his private view


So what is wrong with his 'public view'  ?

In the extract I read which was on LBC, he said

"We don't like it when it happens to the Met, and I'm certainly not going to do it to the Portuguese. What I'm determined to do is to work together to make sure we've got the best chance to now try to get to the bottom of this terrible tragedy.''

Note the first sentence.