UK Justice Forum 🇬🇧

Disappeared and Abducted Children and Young Adults => Madeleine McCann (3) disappeared from her parent's holiday apartment at Ocean Club, Praia da Luz, Portugal on 3 May 2007. No trace of her has ever been found. => Topic started by: Miro on November 06, 2013, 12:47:53 PM

Title: Sticker Book Notes - Who was present and timing
Post by: Miro on November 06, 2013, 12:47:53 PM
Can someone confirm if its definite that the notes made in the sticker book were made prior the police arrival ; who was recorded as being present when the notes were made.........I have read that Russell O'Brien made the notes.
--------------
Timeline 1 (as per sticker book)
 
8:45. pm
 
Matt returns 9.00-9.05 - listened at all 3
                               - all shutters down
 
Jerry 9.10-9.15 in the room + all well
                      ? did he check
 
9.20/5 - Ella Jane checked 5D sees stranger & child
 
9.30 - Russ. Ella Matt check all 3
 
9.35 - Matt check see twins
 
9.50 - Russ returns
 
9.55 - Kate realised Madeleine
 
10pm - Alarm raised
 
Timeline 2 (as per sticker book)
 
8.45pm. all assembled at poolside for food
 
9.00pm. Matt Oldfield listens at all 3 windows 5A, B, D ALL shutters down
 
9:15pm Gerry McCann looks at room A ? Door open to bedroom
 
9:20pm Jane Tanner checks 5D - [sees stranger walking carrying a child]
 
9.30 Russell O'Brien in 5D. Poorly daughter
  l
9.55pm
 
10:00pm. Alarm raised after Kate
 
Gerald

---------
Thank you
Title: Re: Sticker Book Notes - Who was present and timing
Post by: Redblossom on November 06, 2013, 02:19:20 PM
Try reading the rogatory interviews, tortuous as they are, its in there somewhere.....I thnk, though may not be crystal clear.....
Title: Re: Sticker Book Notes - Who was present and timing
Post by: jassi on November 06, 2013, 02:37:24 PM
Try reading the rogatory interviews, tortuous as they are, its in there somewhere.....I thnk, though may not be crystal clear.....

Understatement of the year, I should say   @)(++(*
Title: Re: Sticker Book Notes - Who was present and timing
Post by: Miro on November 06, 2013, 02:45:47 PM
I don't think I have ever seen a case where the time line has been written down twice before its been prompted by a police officer......

Title: Re: Sticker Book Notes - Who was present and timing
Post by: Mr Gray on November 06, 2013, 02:53:44 PM
I don't think I have ever seen a case where the time line has been written down twice before its been prompted by a police officer......

You are not dealing with ordinary people..I was involved in an incident some years ago. While I was waiting for the police to arrive I made notes of everything that had happened whilst it was fresh in my mind. when the police arrived I had a concise report to refer to. The police were impressed. Scientific analytical background.
Title: Re: Sticker Book Notes - Who was present and timing
Post by: pathfinder73 on November 06, 2013, 02:54:13 PM
[9.35 - Matt check see twins]

Matt Oldfield Witness Statement 4 May

"At around 9.25pm, the interviewee went into his apartment and Madeleine's apartment to check on the children. He states that the door of the bedroom that was occupied by Madeleine and the twins, was open and that there was enough light in the bedroom for him to see the twins in their cots."

It doesn't take a genius to work out why Matt's timeline has been put back and subsequently the time of Kate's check/alarm being raised. This I believe is the connection to the Smith family sighting.
Title: Re: Sticker Book Notes - Who was present and timing
Post by: Carana on November 06, 2013, 02:57:34 PM
I don't think I have ever seen a case where the time line has been written down twice before its been prompted by a police officer......


How would you know?
Title: Re: Sticker Book Notes - Who was present and timing
Post by: icabodcrane on November 06, 2013, 03:21:12 PM
You are not dealing with ordinary people..I was involved in an incident some years ago. While I was waiting for the police to arrive I made notes of everything that had happened whilst it was fresh in my mind. when the police arrived I had a concise report to refer to. The police were impressed. Scientific analytical background.

I don't think it would have been necessary for the group to write down the times they had checked on their children while it was  'fresh in their minds'  ...  as if they were somehow likely to forget

I mean,  each couple had a  'checking regime'  did they not  ?  ... a regime which,  we are told,  they followed routinely and unchanged for the duration of the holiday

If they  knew,  for instance,  that they were checking on their children  (  as a matter of routine  )  every half hour,  then they would know precisely when their checks were made,  without the need for a  'timeline' 

They woud be able to say,  confidently,  "We got to the restaurant at 8.30pm,  checked the kids at 9.00pm,  then 9.30pm, then 10.00pm,  ...  and so on 

No memory prompts would be necessary
Title: Re: Sticker Book Notes - Who was present and timing
Post by: jassi on November 06, 2013, 03:34:01 PM
I don't think it would have been necessary for the group to write down the times they had checked on their children while it was  'fresh in their minds'  ...  as if they were somehow likely to forget

I mean,  each couple had a  'checking regime'  did they not  ?  ... a regime which,  we are told,  they followed routinely and unchanged for the duration of the holiday

If they  knew,  for instance,  that they were checking on their children  (  as a matter of routine  )  every half hour,  then they would know precisely when their checks were made,  without the need for a  'timeline' 

They woud be able to say,  confidently,  "We got to the restaurant at 8.30pm,  checked the kids at 9.00pm,  then 9.30pm, then 10.00pm,  ...  and so on 

No memory prompts would be necessary

Quite.  It all looks very contrived, whether it is or not.
Title: Re: Sticker Book Notes - Who was present and timing
Post by: AnneGuedes on November 06, 2013, 03:36:38 PM
I don't think it would have been necessary for the group to write down the times they had checked on their children while it was  'fresh in their minds'  ...  as if they were somehow likely to forget

I mean,  each couple had a  'checking regime'  did they not  ?  ... a regime which,  we are told,  they followed routinely and unchanged for the duration of the holiday

If they  knew,  for instance,  that they were checking on their children  (  as a matter of routine  )  every half hour,  then they would know precisely when their checks were made,  without the need for a  'timeline' 

They woud be able to say,  confidently,  "We got to the restaurant at 8.30pm,  checked the kids at 9.00pm,  then 9.30pm, then 10.00pm,  ...  and so on 

No memory prompts would be necessary
?{)(**
Title: Re: Sticker Book Notes - Who was present and timing
Post by: Cariad on November 06, 2013, 03:46:37 PM
I don't think it would have been necessary for the group to write down the times they had checked on their children while it was  'fresh in their minds'  ...  as if they were somehow likely to forget

I mean,  each couple had a  'checking regime'  did they not  ?  ... a regime which,  we are told,  they followed routinely and unchanged for the duration of the holiday

If they  knew,  for instance,  that they were checking on their children  (  as a matter of routine  )  every half hour,  then they would know precisely when their checks were made,  without the need for a  'timeline' 

They woud be able to say,  confidently,  "We got to the restaurant at 8.30pm,  checked the kids at 9.00pm,  then 9.30pm, then 10.00pm,  ...  and so on 

No memory prompts would be necessary

Well to be fair, davel might have been having the same accident on the same stretch of road for 5 nights in a row. we don't know....
Title: Re: Sticker Book Notes - Who was present and timing
Post by: Mr Gray on November 06, 2013, 03:53:35 PM
I don't think it would have been necessary for the group to write down the times they had checked on their children while it was  'fresh in their minds'  ...  as if they were somehow likely to forget

I mean,  each couple had a  'checking regime'  did they not  ?  ... a regime which,  we are told,  they followed routinely and unchanged for the duration of the holiday

If they  knew,  for instance,  that they were checking on their children  (  as a matter of routine  )  every half hour,  then they would know precisely when their checks were made,  without the need for a  'timeline' 

They woud be able to say,  confidently,  "We got to the restaurant at 8.30pm,  checked the kids at 9.00pm,  then 9.30pm, then 10.00pm,  ...  and so on 

No memory prompts would be necessary

I don't expect you to understand...just giving a logical explanation that may make  lot of sense ..obviously not to you as you reject everything that does not fit with your preconceived ideas
Title: Re: Sticker Book Notes - Who was present and timing
Post by: jassi on November 06, 2013, 03:57:28 PM
Surely the logical thing would have been for each person to have written their timelines separately - no confering
Title: Re: Sticker Book Notes - Who was present and timing
Post by: Mr Gray on November 06, 2013, 03:58:56 PM
Surely the logical thing would have been for each person to have written their timelines separately - no confering

might be to you...the whole point is to "Brainstorm" and recall as much information as possible collectively..its a recognised technique but one no one on here seems to understand
Title: Re: Sticker Book Notes - Who was present and timing
Post by: jassi on November 06, 2013, 04:00:08 PM
might be to you...

Indeed it would be to me.
Title: Re: Sticker Book Notes - Who was present and timing
Post by: pathfinder73 on November 06, 2013, 04:13:21 PM
[9:20pm Jane Tanner checks 5D - [sees stranger walking carrying a child]

Rachael Oldfield

"Jane went off at about ten past nine to check on Ella and Evie, erm and you know, and then you know yes she came back and everything was quiet there as well."

A pattern is emerging. Oldfield checks are done between meals (20/25 mins) rather than set 30 mins checks.
Title: Re: Sticker Book Notes - Who was present and timing
Post by: Cariad on November 06, 2013, 04:13:48 PM
might be to you...the whole point is to "Brainstorm" and recall as much information as possible collectively..its a recognised technique but one no one on here seems to understand

I don't think you're meant to talk to other witnesses before you're interviewed by the police davel. I think the police are meant to try and work out the discrepancies....
Title: Re: Sticker Book Notes - Who was present and timing
Post by: Mr Gray on November 06, 2013, 04:16:26 PM
I don't think you're meant to talk to other witnesses before you're interviewed by the police davel. I think the police are meant to try and work out the discrepancies....

 That is totally ridiculous Cariad...not one of your brightest posts
Title: Re: Sticker Book Notes - Who was present and timing
Post by: Redblossom on November 06, 2013, 04:17:25 PM
I don't think you're meant to talk to other witnesses before you're interviewed by the police davel. I think the police are meant to try and work out the discrepancies....

They were being proactive before PJ got there.....writing timelines, checking shutters,ringing media, letting every tom dick and harry into the crime scene.....laudable...think ive spelt that right, might be laudible, not sure
 @)(++(*

Title: Re: Sticker Book Notes - Who was present and timing
Post by: Cariad on November 06, 2013, 04:20:03 PM
That is totally ridiculous Cariad...not one of your brightest posts

I'm deadly serious actually. I honestly thought that you weren't meant to discuss the details. I know that if you're a witness in a court case, you're not allowed to talk to other witnesses about it, even if they're your own family.
Title: Re: Sticker Book Notes - Who was present and timing
Post by: Mr Gray on November 06, 2013, 04:22:34 PM
I'm deadly serious actually. I honestly thought that you weren't meant to discuss the details. I know that if you're a witness in a court case, you're not allowed to talk to other witnesses about it, even if they're your own family.

 Court cases are governed by Contempt laws...they don't cover the type of situation the MCCanns found themselves in