UK Justice Forum 🇬🇧
Alleged Miscarriages of Justice => Jeremy Bamber and the callous murder of his father, mother, sister and twin nephews. Case effectively CLOSED by CCRC on basis of NO APPEAL REFERRAL. => Topic started by: John on April 22, 2014, 09:26:22 AM
-
In relation to Sheila's ability to fire a second shot. One has to remember that the pathologist Vanezis never saw the body in situ at the farmhouse so was initially misled as to the blood smears on Sheila's neck. Later when he saw Bird's photographs he realised his inutial mistake. Sheila was not conscious after the first shot and anyone who thinks differently simply doesn't understand the forensic evidence.
-
In relation to Sheila's ability to fire a second shot. One has to remember that the pathologist Vanezis never saw the body in situ at the farmhouse so was initially misled as to the blood smears on Sheila's neck. Later when he saw Bird's photographs he realised his inutial mistake. Sheila was not conscious after the first shot and anyone who thinks differently simply doesn't understand the forensic evidence.
I don't understand your comment re the "blood smears on Sheila's neck" and would be grateful if you could explain.
I know I get stick for relying on links but that's all I can go on really. With regard to this point I rely on evidence contained in the CoA doc from 2002 and points 45 and 46 below. It states the lower of the two wounds must have been the first since it had led to haemorrhaging inside the neck and this would not have occurred to the same extent if the other wound, which would have been immediately fatal, had preceded it. Before this it states the lower of the two would have been a fatal injury but not one where death would have occurred immediately and a person having suffered such an injury may have been able to stand up and walk around for a little time. It then states that the lack of heavy blood staining to SC's nightdress suggest that she had not actually walked around although it was possible.
If you think this is incorrect I might write to the judges about it as I believe they are the authors of this document. Incidentally I never heard back from Dr Vanezis about the burns. I thought it unlikely but it was worth a try. Nothing ventured: nothing gained.
45. Sheila Caffell was also dressed in her nightwear and bare-footed. She had received two contact or near contact bullet wounds to her throat. The higher of the two wounds would have killed her almost instantaneously. The lower of the two would have been a fatal injury but not one where death would have occurred immediately and a person having suffered such an injury may have been able to stand up and walk around for a little time. The lack of heavy blood staining to Sheila Caffell's nightdress suggested that this had not happened here. The lower of the two injuries must have been the first since it had led to haemorrhaging inside the neck and this would not have occurred to the same extent if the other wound, which would have been immediately fatal, had preceded it. Dr Vanezis gave evidence that the nature of the blood stains to the nightdress suggested that Sheila Caffell was sitting up when she received both injuries. After the second injury she would have immediately fallen back. There was no evidence of any other mark or injury to Sheila Caffell's body such as might be suffered during a fight or in a scuffle.
46. From the pathological evidence alone, the pathologist could not say, one way or the other, whether Mrs Caffell had been murdered or had taken her own life.
http://www.homepage-link.to/justice/judgements/Bamber/index.html
-
Further to my post above I don't see why pro Bluies talk about SC moving herself from downstairs to upstairs having fired the first shot. Although it seems based on the pathological evidence this would be biologically possible; the state of SC's nightdress would seem to rule this out.
Imo for what it's worth I think the pathology evidence as contained in the CoA doc is stronger than the contradictory evidence regarding two bodies downstairs etc, etc which imo is likely to be an administrative error.
I think JB supporters harm his case by not sticking to one unifying narrative based on the evidence. They want to seize on any anomaly to the detriment of other evidence ie the lack of blood on SC's nightdress v reports of two bodies downstairs. It is perfectly feasible that SC inflicted the two wounds in the position she was found in as per the pathological evidence. Why they want to come up with bizarre stories re photos on the bed, moving around the house I have no idea 8-)(--)
-
I don't understand your comment re the "blood smears on Sheila's neck" and would be grateful if you could explain.
I know I get stick for relying on links but that's all I can go on really. With regard to this point I rely on evidence contained in the CoA doc from 2002 and points 45 and 46 below. It states the lower of the two wounds must have been the first since it had led to haemorrhaging inside the neck and this would not have occurred to the same extent if the other wound, which would have been immediately fatal, had preceded it. Before this it states the lower of the two would have been a fatal injury but not one where death would have occurred immediately and a person having suffered such an injury may have been able to stand up and walk around for a little time. It then states that the lack of heavy blood staining to SC's nightdress suggest that she had not actually walked around although it was possible.
If you think this is incorrect I might write to the judges about it as I believe they are the authors of this document. Incidentally I never heard back from Dr Vanezis about the burns. I thought it unlikely but it was worth a try. Nothing ventured: nothing gained.
45. Sheila Caffell was also dressed in her nightwear and bare-footed. She had received two contact or near contact bullet wounds to her throat. The higher of the two wounds would have killed her almost instantaneously. The lower of the two would have been a fatal injury but not one where death would have occurred immediately and a person having suffered such an injury may have been able to stand up and walk around for a little time. The lack of heavy blood staining to Sheila Caffell's nightdress suggested that this had not happened here. The lower of the two injuries must have been the first since it had led to haemorrhaging inside the neck and this would not have occurred to the same extent if the other wound, which would have been immediately fatal, had preceded it. Dr Vanezis gave evidence that the nature of the blood stains to the nightdress suggested that Sheila Caffell was sitting up when she received both injuries. After the second injury she would have immediately fallen back. There was no evidence of any other mark or injury to Sheila Caffell's body such as might be suffered during a fight or in a scuffle.
46. From the pathological evidence alone, the pathologist could not say, one way or the other, whether Mrs Caffell had been murdered or had taken her own life.
http://www.homepage-link.to/justice/judgements/Bamber/index.html
Who are you trying to kid? You ignore anything that dashes your claims. The appeal decision you claim to use clearly stated multiple times that the fatal shot was a contact shot to her throat. You had the audacity to insist is wasn't a contact shot and wouldn't produce spatter even though the appeal decision states that a shot in that location would be virtually certain to cause back spatter into the weapon.
Note where you ended, from the pathological evidence alone. What is the pathological evidence alone? The evidence of the autopsy all alone in isolation. But at trial the pathologist did not view such evidence alone in isolaion it was tied in to all the other evidence and thus his testimony at trial was that she didn't kill herself she was killed by someone else.
So you take an appeal decision that notes the expert testimony determined based on all the evidence she could not have killed herself and was murdered and you quote from a part about an isolated piece of the puzzle and try to pretend that there is no way to know whether she was killed by someone or killed herself. That is called spin and it fails miserably when one reads the entire opinion which concludes based on the evidence presented at trial that Jeremy did it.
-
Further to my post above I don't see why pro Bluies talk about SC moving herself from downstairs to upstairs having fired the first shot. Although it seems based on the pathological evidence this would be biologically possible; the state of SC's nightdress would seem to rule this out.
Imo for what it's worth I think the pathology evidence as contained in the CoA doc is stronger than the contradictory evidence regarding two bodies downstairs etc, etc which imo is likely to be an administrative error.
I think JB supporters harm his case by not sticking to one unifying narrative based on the evidence. They want to seize on any anomaly to the detriment of other evidence ie the lack of blood on SC's nightdress v reports of two bodies downstairs. It is perfectly feasible that SC inflicted the two wounds in the position she was found in as per the pathological evidence. Why they want to come up with bizarre stories re photos on the bed, moving around the house I have no idea 8-)(--)
If you read the entire document laying out all the evidence then it is clear that it was not possible for SC to inflict the wounds in question. Your suggestions are as bizarre as their and you are doing the same thing as them only to a lesser degree. Instead of tossing in the kitchen sink too you toss in everything but the kitchen sink. The only difference between you and them is the matter of degree.
The report notes that the fatal wound was a contact wound, that was the finding of the pathologist who examined her. You deny it was a contact wound without any basis to challenge his findings. You are doing the same thing as those on blue- denying relaity because it harms what you wish were the case.
The appeal court decision notes that if the fatal shot had been delivered without the suppressor attached it would be virtually certain to have blood inside the barrel but there was none thus indicating it was fired with a suppressor. It further discusses how the expected spatter was found in the suppressor including microscopic evidence found by the defense's own expert on the initial 8 baffles which he determined to be group A blood type.
You refuse to believe the findings and insist that the fatal wound would not produce back spatter without having any basis at all to contradict the findings. Any evidence that demolishes your claims you just dismiss without having any basis to do so.
Thus you even throw in the kitchen sink at times just like them. The notion that sticking a suppressor in a bucket of water with diluted blood from clothing could deposit blood chips and blood deposits on the first 8 baffles is absurd. The only rational argument that could be mad eis to claim someone used something to spray blood inside the suppressor to plant it. Even that is far fetched but theoretically possible unlike your wild claims about the bloody buckets. So at the end of the day you are just the kettle calling the pot black.
-
Who are you trying to kid? You ignore anything that dashes your claims. The appeal decision you claim to use clearly stated multiple times that the fatal shot was a contact shot to her throat. You had the audacity to insist is wasn't a contact shot and wouldn't produce spatter even though the appeal decision states that a shot in that location would be virtually certain to cause back spatter into the weapon.
Note where you ended, from the pathological evidence alone. What is the pathological evidence alone? The evidence of the autopsy all alone in isolation. But at trial the pathologist did not view such evidence alone in isolaion it was tied in to all the other evidence and thus his testimony at trial was that she didn't kill herself she was killed by someone else.
So you take an appeal decision that notes the expert testimony determined based on all the evidence she could not have killed herself and was murdered and you quote from a part about an isolated piece of the puzzle and try to pretend that there is no way to know whether she was killed by someone or killed herself. That is called spin and it fails miserably when one reads the entire opinion which concludes based on the evidence presented at trial that Jeremy did it.
Hello Scipio. How are you today? Debate nicely or I will simply ignore you and you will end up having no one to play with 8)><(
My post/response to John was about SC's ability to self-inflict a second gunshot wound not whether the gunshot wounds she received were contact or not.
As with much of this case the expert evidence is contradictory, which I might add is often a feature of MoJ's.
As you rightly pointed out the ballistics expert Malcolm Fletcher stated in the CoA doc that the upper wound to SC's throat was a contact shot:
62. Mr Fletcher also gave evidence of the range at which the shots had been fired. The lower (and not immediately fatal) of the injuries suffered by Sheila Caffell was caused when the muzzle of the gun was within three inches of the throat. The upper injury was a contact shot.
However the pathologist, Peter Vanenzis, stated in his autopsy report:
"There were two gun shot entry wounds which appear to have been fired at contact or near contact range"
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=199.0;attach=672
In the above scenario my understanding is that evidence from the pathologist will take precedence over that provided by ballistics. Stating "appear to have been fired at contact or near contact range" is not the same as stating they were contact. Please note the words "appear" and "or".
I have no intention of going round in circles on this point.
-
Holly, you asked me about the lack of blood smears on Sheila's neck. To best explain this I will post the original photo taken in the bedroom before she was moved.
When someone is shot in the face or neck with a relatively small calibre weapon the automatic response is to touch the wound thereby getting blood on their fingertips and leaving blood smears on the skin. None of this was present with Sheila.
Sheila never touched the wounds on her neck because to put it simply, she was incapacitated by the first shot.
(http://i.imgur.com/Y8fdcAm.jpg-Sheila_Caffell-neck_wounds-02a)
-
Good point John and another common sense sign that says Sheila couldnt have done it. Having just fired a bullet through her neck her hands would have been covered in her own blood, being conscious and able to have another go?
Or is this where his fans bring her drug induced state into it, she was so spaced out she didnt feel pain or know she had been shot
-
Hello Scipio. How are you today? Debate nicely or I will simply ignore you and you will end up having no one to play with 8)><(
My post/response to John was about SC's ability to self-inflict a second gunshot wound not whether the gunshot wounds she received were contact or not.
As with much of this case the expert evidence is contradictory, which I might add is often a feature of MoJ's.
As you rightly pointed out the ballistics expert Malcolm Fletcher stated in the CoA doc that the upper wound to SC's throat was a contact shot:
62. Mr Fletcher also gave evidence of the range at which the shots had been fired. The lower (and not immediately fatal) of the injuries suffered by Sheila Caffell was caused when the muzzle of the gun was within three inches of the throat. The upper injury was a contact shot.
However the pathologist, Peter Vanenzis, stated in his autopsy report:
"There were two gun shot entry wounds which appear to have been fired at contact or near contact range"
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=199.0;attach=672
In the above scenario my understanding is that evidence from the pathologist will take precedence over that provided by ballistics. Stating "appear to have been fired at contact or near contact range" is not the same as stating they were contact. Please note the words "appear" and "or".
I have no intention of going round in circles on this point.
The conclusion in the report is that it was either contact or near contact. The word "appears" merely notes it is his view which is not really necessary since he authored the report but some write that way anyway. His assessent was that it was contact or near contact. Based on other evidence he concluded it was contact and told such to the ballistics expert. You liek dot go by a report not the complete testimony because it is veyr harful to your cause. At trial the distance of close contact was discussed. So the court was told the shots were either contact or within a distance of less than 2mm. Based on this the appeal court made the factual finding that it was a contact wound and asserted such in its decision.
Saying the court was wrong and should have found the distance it was fired was either contact or within 2mm is nitpicking for nothing because it changes nothing.
If fired at 2mm or less it would result in drawback into the weapon.
In the meantime you insisted is wasn't a contact wound though he court found it was based on the testimony was that it was either a contact wound or under 2MM.
The court had a valid basis to find it was a contact wound. You had no valid basis to declare it wasn't.
You insisted that Nicholas was the only one that definitely suffered a contact shot. Yet the autopsy report makes so such claim. It doesn't state contact, near contact or anything.
The trial testimony was that they were close promity shots and maybe even contact. The testimony actually left open the possiblity for these shots to be further away than those suffered by Sheila. Sheila's were contact or near contact his were close proximity maybe even contact. Close proximity is further than near contact.
So the autopsy report said contact or near contact for Sheila's wounds but didn't say any such thing for Nicholas' wounds. You insisted anyway that his wounds were definitely contact while hers were not.
The court found his wounds were either contact or close proximity based on the testimony they heard and that her fatal wound was a contact wound.
I will go with their assessment not yours. They were being objective not playing games like you.
You are not in the least bit consistent. You say go by the autopsy report's words to the letter for Sheila but go to the trial testimony to Nicholas. In any event that testimony still is not great because it was close proximity and maybe even contact not definitely contact like you asserted. The testimony was that Sheila's was contact or less than 2mm and that at this range the wound in quesiton would have been virtually certain to result in back spatter.
It doesn't matter if it was contac tor not whether contact or there was a gap under 2mm either way back spatter would result and that is the issue at hand.
The rifle had no backspatter so either it had a suppressor attached, was cleaned by someone before it was inspected by the firearms expert, or the firearms expert lied about not finding any blood.
There is substantial evidence that the suppressor was used in the kitchen (broke the ceiling light shade, scratched the mantle and that it was not removed until after Sheila had been shot.
Nothing you have tossed out there dents this at all. You have to misrepresent to try to dent it and those misrepresentations get flagged by us whenever you raise them.
-
Holly, you asked me about the lack of blood smears on Sheila's neck. To best explain this I will post the original photo taken in the bedroom before she was moved.
When someone is shot in the face or neck with a relatively small calibre weapon the automatic response is to touch the wound thereby getting blood on their fingertips and leaving blood smears on the skin. None of this was present with Sheila.
Sheila never touched the wounds on her neck because to put it simply, she was incapacitated by the first shot.
Thank you John.
The pathologist makes no reference to the lack of smearing on SC's neck ie that had she have fired the first shot some involuntarily spasm/reflex would occur whereby her hand would go to her neck and smear the blood? I have absolutely no idea what happens. I can only go on what the pathologist states. He also states that in SC's case it was not immediately fatal and she might even have been capable of walking around for a while. Although he doesn't think she did walk around due to the lack of blood on her nightie.
-
Thank you John.
The pathologist makes no reference to the lack of smearing on SC's neck ie that had she have fired the first shot some involuntarily spasm/reflex would occur whereby her hand would go to her neck and smear the blood? I have absolutely no idea what happens. I can only go on what the pathologist states. He also states that in SC's case it was not immediately fatal and she might even have been capable of walking around for a while. Although he doesn't think she did walk around due to the lack of blood on her nightie.
When the pathologist first saw and examined Sheila she looked completely different to the photo above. Blood had been smeared all over her face and neck rendering analysis impossible. It was only later when he saw the crime scene photos that he realised that his analysis was not as it should have been. I will dig out the autopsy photo later when in the office and add it to this post.
I think the suggestion that Sheila walked around for a bit after having been shot in the neck is quite preposterous really. I'm glad that you recognise this, the blood trails certainly disprove it.
-
When the pathologist first saw and examined Sheila she looked completely different to the photo above. Blood had been smeared all over her face and neck rendering analysis impossible. It was only later when he saw the crime scene photos that he realised that his analysis was not as it should have been. I will dig out the autopsy photo later when in the office and add it to this post.
I think the suggestion that Sheila walked around for a bit after having been shot in the neck is quite preposterous really. I'm glad that you recognise this, the blood trails certainly disprove it.
Thank you. I will look out for the photo as and when.
I will only base my opinions etc on the expert evidence (albeit my interpretation!) and from the pathologist's reports it seems so unlikely that SC moved either of her own free will or by others that it can effectively be ruled out. I include in this downstairs to upstairs and/or bed to floor.
-
The mortuary photo.
Holly, I am quite sure you will agree that had you seen Sheila in this state at the beginning you would have formed a completely different opinion.
-
Looking at the two(?) blood smears (one above the other) around the top wound bullet hole, do these appear to have been the result of the end of the moderator, or a finger/thumb being wiped across the wound from the right side of her neck to the left ? (i.e. from left to right in the photo)
There's a large blob (darker) at the end of each which is what you might expect if something was dragged across in that direction, if it caught some of the blood oozing/streaming out of the wound. Could these have been caused by the assailant with the moderator end, or by the attending doctor or even a policeman who was trying to examine the wound more closely ?
(http://i.imgur.com/7KhBB1j.jpg)
-
The mortuary photo.
Holly, I am quite sure you will agree that had you seen Sheila in this state at the beginning you would have formed a completely different opinion.
Thanks.
The images are so distressing. I would be horrified if I was wrong 8(8-))
I don't think I can determine anything other than the two images look different. It appears there is more blood staining to the neck area in the autopsy image. Would this have come from the body bag/transit?
-
Thanks.
The images are so distressing. I would be horrified if I was wrong 8(8-))
I don't think I can determine anything other than the two images look different. It appears there is more blood staining to the neck area in the autopsy image. Would this have come from the body bag/transit?
The smell is far worse than the sight. I'm not squeamish but I would not want to cut open dead people for a living. It takes a special kind to want to play with bodies. Blood is nothing compared to other fluids and removal of organs and parts now that is damn gross. Disecting a pig or cat in biology class is nothing at all when you see a human parts. It's just plain weird. It wasn't cool to see, it was weird. You just feel awkward there is no real specific feeling from it. Just weird. Surreal in a way like is this real? Needless to say I think people in that line of work are strange cats. An history seems to bear hat out as there are tons of stories about coroners being pervetrted and into all sorts of stuff society frowns upon.
-
Looking at the two(?) blood smears (one above the other) around the top wound bullet hole, do these appear to have been the result of the end of the moderator, or a finger/thumb being wiped across the wound from the right side of her neck to the left ? (i.e. from left to right in the photo)
There's a large blob (darker) at the end of each which is what you might expect if something was dragged across in that direction, if it caught some of the blood oozing/streaming out of the wound. Could these have been caused by the assailant with the moderator end, or by the attending doctor or even a policeman who was trying to examine the wound more closely ?
(http://i.imgur.com/7KhBB1j.jpg)
I take it you are referring to the mirror image blood spots caused by her head being forward before falling back?
And yes, I do agree there appears to be a horizontal smear mark associated with the lower deposit of the upper wound...that is a strange one? It's as if someone drew their thumb across it before the mirror image blob was laid down.
-
I take it you are referring to the mirror image blood spots caused by her head being forward before falling back?
And yes, I do agree there appears to be a horizontal smear mark associated with the lower deposit of the upper wound...that is a strange one? It's as if someone drew their thumb across it before the mirror image blob was laid down.
Both look like blood trails.
A swipe would most likely have been in the down direction not sideways. You can see how the blood leaked to the side and then off the neck due to gravity.
Gravity has to always be taken into account with blood flow. We are told she had the gun under her chin for contact or near contact shots and yet no blood got in the weapon. That means the weapon would have had a good amount of blood on it but nope, no spatter on the weapon or her nightgown.
It harkens back to my cousin Vinny with the magic grits- did the laws of physics cease to exist in the house WHF?
-
Both look like blood trails.
A swipe would most likely have been in the down direction not sideways. You can see how the blood leaked to the side and then off the neck due to gravity.
Gravity has to always be taken into account with blood flow. We are told she had the gun under her chin for contact or near contact shots and yet no blood got in the weapon. That means the weapon would have had a good amount of blood on it but nope, no spatter on the weapon or her nightgown.
It harkens back to my cousin Vinny with the magic grits- did the laws of physics cease to exist in the house WHF?
I was referring to the smears 2 and 3 below. It looks like there were two rather than just the one because there is a thin gap between each and there are also two dark blobs, one at the end of each smear.
Arrow 1 indicates the direction of each stroke to create the dark coloured blobs at the end. For example, if you cut a thumb on the fingerprint side and then dragged it across a surface while blood was leaking from the cut, the blob would appear at the end of the smear (rather than at the beginning) as your thumb was lifted off that surface.
There is no smear at all around the lower non-fatal first wound, apart from specks of blood and faint gunpowder deposits.
(http://i.imgur.com/w6bPyFZ.jpg)
-
For lack of a better word your skin folds when you crimp your neck. The closer the fold is to the wound the less chance for the entire wound to touch. The further away you go the better the chance of the entire wound touching.
So a fold of skin touched th ewound and formed the half moon and then the wound touched skin a little further away. That is why there are 2 mirror images but one is only half.
If someone has blood on their fingers and this blood is transferred the place where the blood is heaviest is where the transfer began. (a swipe transfer)
If there is blood already on the body and a dry finger or the like drags the blood (wipe transfer pattern) then the blood will generally be lighter where the wipe begins.
The mirror images were caused by the wound pressing against skin not dragging though. The would pressed against neck skin and left a mirror image where it had been pressed.
-
I know we have looked at this before. I understood there to be consensus to the effect that mark 3 was caused by coming into contact with blood from wound 2 while the head was titled forward.
In the lower initial wound the staining can also be seen but to a lesser degree. Since her head was moved forward after the second shot and since no police officer has admitted to moving her, this would leave only one explanation.
-
I know we have looked at this before. I understood there to be consensus to the effect that mark 3 was caused by coming into contact with blood from wound 2 while the head was titled forward.
In the lower initial wound the staining can also be seen but to a lesser degree. Since her head was moved forward after the second shot and since no police officer has admitted to moving her, this would leave only one explanation.
I was just going to post about this being examined in the past although I think on the earlier forum (or even the blue), which I could have missed having come late to it.
I'm not sure that Sheila's head would have moved enough after the second shot for the wound to smear, unless it was deliberately positioned or lifted up by the assailant. According to the pathologist she would have been "stunned" after the first one. Looking at her closed eyelids I'm convinced she was asleep, had fainted or was comatose before the second shot was fired.
There's a similar photo somewhere with a line drawn on it showing the division between upper and lower smears, and they do appear to give the same effect you'd get with a Rorschach pattern using ink on paper. But since you put this up again I've had a long hard think to see if there could be other explanations. I'm not saying definitely that any policeman touched her neck to examine the wound more clearly to cause them without even thinking before any CS photo was taken, although I wouldn't rule out the examining doctor, or more likely the moderator end being played tentatively on her neck when the assailant was lining up the rifle to make sure the second bullet penetrated her brain. If the moderator's end had been coated with blood and was still moist from the first close/near contact neck shot as a result of backspatter (or whatever you want to call it) then I think it's possible this could have made the smears. Both 2 and 3 have different outlines... look at the bottom line of 3 - it's straight, which doesn't match the top line of 2 for it to be mirrored. And similarly the dark blobs at the end of 2 and 3 don't match position-wise for the smears to be mirrored.
-
Looking at the blood trails again, it is clear that Sheila was never in a vertical position as the blood from both wounds ran to the side of her neck. That also means the blood drops on the floor must have been the result of blood spurting out of the wound rather than running out.
There goes the walked about theory...sorry Holly. 8(8-))
-
Looking at the blood trails again, it is clear that Sheila was never in a vertical position as the blood from both wounds ran to the side of her neck. That also means the blood drops on the floor must have been the result of blood spurting out of the wound rather than running out.
There goes the walked about theory...sorry Holly. 8(8-))
The blood trails mirror each other, so there was hardly any movement between shots - Sheila was pulled down slightly for the second shot.
And aren't the blood drops on the floor from Ralph?
-
The blood trails mirror each other, so there was hardly any movement between shots - Sheila was pulled down slightly for the second shot.
And aren't the blood drops on the floor from Ralph?
Quite possibly spots from either or both - Sheila, if she was sitting or kneeling upright when she took the first neck shot, Nevill if he was standing at the foot of the bed when he received the shots to his jaw/arm. Some say June although I don't see her walking around to Nevill's side of the bed when she was mortally wounded.
-
Quite possibly spots from either or both - Sheila, if she was sitting or kneeling upright when she took the first neck shot, Nevill if he was standing at the foot of the bed when he received the shots to his jaw/arm. Some say June although I don't see her walking around to Nevill's side of the bed when she was mortally wounded.
I'm sure you're right - that blood wasn't from June. She managed to crawl as far as the door, and as the blood smears indicate, she was sitting slumped against it when Bamber returned to shoot her between the eyes.
As Holly says, extremely distressing to think about.
-
Looking at the blood trails again, it is clear that Sheila was never in a vertical position as the blood from both wounds ran to the side of her neck. That also means the blood drops on the floor must have been the result of blood spurting out of the wound rather than running out.
There goes the walked about theory...sorry Holly. 8(8-))
When she was vertical the blood dripped onto her gown. Once she was horizontal the blood leaked down the side.
-
It would be interesting to know whose blood was on the carpet and on the Bible beside Sheila. Has anyone ever seen a forensic report or any reference to ths?
-
Looking at the blood trails again, it is clear that Sheila was never in a vertical position as the blood from both wounds ran to the side of her neck. That also means the blood drops on the floor must have been the result of blood spurting out of the wound rather than running out.
There goes the walked about theory...sorry Holly. 8(8-))
John I have never claimed that SC walked about having suffered the first non-fatal wound. I don't think she was on the bed either. The limited blood trails and lack of staining to her nightie lead me to believe that having suffered the first non-fatal shot that she barely moved from the position she was found in.
I haven't really looked at arrow 2 and 3 but arrow 1 I see as blood that has dried and then cracked as bruising and swelling has occurred and pushed it apart? Her neck and jawline look swollen and I can see bruising too 8(8-)) Do you know what time the photos were taken?
-
It would be interesting to know whose blood was on the carpet and on the Bible beside Sheila. Has anyone ever seen a forensic report or any reference to ths?
The carpets were burned by EP. Here's the excerpt from CoA re bible:
52. The Bible found by Sheila Caffell's body, belonged to her mother and was normally kept in a cupboard to the right of her bed. It was examined for fingerprints. Many belonged to June Bamber and there were a small number of insufficient detail for comparison, save for one which appeared to have been made by a small child.
Why no ref to blood even if only to say insufficient to prevent grouping? Blood found on wallpaper in the hallway was tested.
-
John I have never claimed that SC walked about having suffered the first non-fatal wound. I don't think she was on the bed either. The limited blood trails and lack of staining to her nightie lead me to believe that having suffered the first non-fatal shot that she barely moved from the position she was found in.
I haven't really looked at arrow 2 and 3 but arrow 1 I see as blood that has dried and then cracked as bruising and swelling has occurred and pushed it apart? Her neck and jawline look swollen and I can see bruising too 8(8-)) Do you know what time the photos were taken?
Sheila's head was in more or less the same position for both shots, but there was obviously something under her shoulder before the first shot, which was moved before the second one.
-
Sheila's head was in more or less the same position for both shots, but there was obviously something under her shoulder before the first shot, which was moved before the second one.
I find it difficult to interpret/understand the soc images. Please can you explain the above?
-
I find it difficult to interpret/understand the soc images. Please can you explain the above?
I don't know what puggy is getting at either, unless she means a pillow or something similar which was disposed of afterwards because it was blood-stained ! What else don't you understand about the photos of Sheila, Holly ?
(http://i.imgur.com/FVOdgFT.jpg)
-
I don't know what puggy is getting at either, unless she means a pillow or something similar which was disposed of afterwards because it was blood-stained ! What else don't you understand about the photos of Sheila, Holly ?
(http://i.imgur.com/FVOdgFT.jpg)
Sorry, Holl, I missed your post (I noticed the word puggy!)...I can't say what was under Sheila's shoulder, but by the first blood trail, something was. Unless, as I've said before, she grabbed the barrel of the gun as it was pushed into her throat, which would bring her shoulder up.
-
I don't know what puggy is getting at either, unless she means a pillow or something similar which was disposed of afterwards because it was blood-stained ! What else don't you understand about the photos of Sheila, Holly ?
(http://i.imgur.com/FVOdgFT.jpg)
This image is very intereresting. A clear indentation of Ralph's head on the pillow, which Mike denied. No blood on the carpet, which would apparently have resulted from Sheila running about the bedroom after she'd shot herself in the kitchen. And the well-loved teddy in the bed. Possibly something that the boys wanted and planted, and June and Ralph went along with. Because they loved the boys so much.
So. Why would there be a loaded gun on the settle? When the boys were at the farm? Suddendly Ralph couldn't give a toss anymore?
Ralph was careful around guns. June hated guns. Sheila didn't understand guns.
But Bamber could hear rabbits, with his magic ears.
-
This image is very intereresting. A clear indentation of Ralph's head on the pillow, which Mike denied. No blood on the carpet, which would apparently have resulted from Sheila running about the bedroom after she'd shot herself in the kitchen. And the well-loved teddy in the bed. Possibly something that the boys wanted and planted, and June and Ralph went along with. Because they loved the boys so much.
So. Why would there be a loaded gun on the settle? When the boys were at the farm? Suddendly Ralph couldn't give a toss anymore?
Ralph was careful around guns. June hated guns. Sheila didn't understand guns.
But Bamber could hear rabbits, with his magic ears.
And, instead of being frantic with worry when he eventually rocked up at the house, slowly, he forgot about his family being in peril, and discussed the car he had his eye on.
I rest my case.
-
The bed has obviously been slept in on NB's side and what appears to be his clothing from the night before rests on the chair, which would suggest that he was in bed when the mayhem began, rather than in the kitchen reading a newspaper as one documentary stated (but we already know that anyway because all the bullets bar four were fired upstairs). What could be an old-fashioned paraffin or electric heater in the foreground, which was probably necessary for chilly mornings to warm the room up for dressing because I don't think the house was centrally heated in '85. There are no radiators or pipes against the walls in any of the available bedroom photos and the AGA only provided domestic hot water which was stored in a cylinder/tank upstairs.
What strikes me as odd is why she was positioned in the limited space at the side of the bed, with not much room to manoeuvre. I wonder if the door to the tiny box room was ajar when found or if it was opened and left open by the TFU when the property was searched ? If the former, this is one of the reasons I think that Sheila might have tried to hide in that room before she heard someone come back upstairs after the fight in the kitchen and was discovered in there. That's assuming she wasn't in such a soporific state from the medication she had to be led, dragged or carried from her own bedroom.
-
I don't know what puggy is getting at either, unless she means a pillow or something similar which was disposed of afterwards because it was blood-stained ! What else don't you understand about the photos of Sheila, Holly ?
It's not just the photos of SC; I find it difficult to decipher all the soc photos! Hence Myster you had to point out the obvious re the kitchen ie that it was clearly taken before the clean up!
-
Sorry, Holl, I missed your post (I noticed the word puggy!)...I can't say what was under Sheila's shoulder, but by the first blood trail, something was. Unless, as I've said before, she grabbed the barrel of the gun as it was pushed into her throat, which would bring her shoulder up.
Thanks. I'll take another look with this in mind.
-
The bed has obviously been slept in on NB's side and what appears to be his clothing from the night before rests on the chair, which would suggest that he was in bed when the mayhem began, rather than in the kitchen reading a newspaper as one documentary stated (but we already know that anyway because all the bullets bar four were fired upstairs). What could be an old-fashioned paraffin or electric heater in the foreground, which was probably necessary for chilly mornings to warm the room up for dressing because I don't think the house was centrally heated in '85. There are no radiators or pipes against the walls in any of the available bedroom photos and the AGA only provided domestic hot water which was stored in a cylinder/tank upstairs.
What strikes me as odd is why she was positioned in the limited space at the side of the bed, with not much room to manoeuvre. I wonder if the door to the tiny box room was ajar when found or if it was opened and left open by the TFU when the property was searched ? If the former, this is one of the reasons I think that Sheila might have tried to hide in that room before she heard someone come back upstairs after the fight in the kitchen and was discovered in there. That's assuming she wasn't in such a soporific state from the medication she had to be led, dragged or carried from her own bedroom.
I have seen another photo, on Blue I think, that gives the impression that NB's side of the bed hadn't been slept in. The raid team statements are a bit ambiguous on this too...
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=154.0;attach=72
"On looking further into the bedroom I saw a double bed the covers of which were pulled back on the side nearest the door. Near the pillow area on this side of the bed were red stains on the sheets which appeared to be blood".
-
The carpets were burned by EP. Here's the excerpt from CoA re bible:
52. The Bible found by Sheila Caffell's body, belonged to her mother and was normally kept in a cupboard to the right of her bed. It was examined for fingerprints. Many belonged to June Bamber and there were a small number of insufficient detail for comparison, save for one which appeared to have been made by a small child.
Why no ref to blood even if only to say insufficient to prevent grouping? Blood found on wallpaper in the hallway was tested.
You missed the blood excerpt:
407. Two further photographs of the Bible have been located by those advising the appellant. When they were taken and by whom they were taken is not known. It is clear from the photographs themselves that they were not taken at the scene. But must have been taken at some other location following the removal of the Bible as a potential exhibit by the police. The photographs record the blood staining on the Bible. From this staining it is immediately obvious that the Bible has been shut whilst the blood remained wet because marks on one page are mirrored on the adjoining page.
408. The pages on which the heavy staining appears in these photographs are pages including part or all of Psalms 51-55. It is said that these pages are significant and represented "Sheila Caffell's suicide note". A number of passages are highlighted and it will suffice if we give one example, taken from verse 14 of Psalm 51:
"Save me from blood guiltiness O God…"
409. The evidence suggests that the two photographs were not brought to the attention of the defence and Mr Turner once more submits that the only explanation for this is wilful concealment by the police
-
I have seen another photo, on Blue I think, that gives the impression that NB's side of the bed hadn't been slept in. The raid team statements are a bit ambiguous on this too...
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=154.0;attach=72
"On looking further into the bedroom I saw a double bed the covers of which were pulled back on the side nearest the door. Near the pillow area on this side of the bed were red stains on the sheets which appeared to be blood".
Oh I'm sorry I seem to be going off topic but just remembered PC Delgado didn't mention the blue socks found near SC >@@(*&)
-
You missed the blood excerpt:
407. Two further photographs of the Bible have been located by those advising the appellant. When they were taken and by whom they were taken is not known. It is clear from the photographs themselves that they were not taken at the scene. But must have been taken at some other location following the removal of the Bible as a potential exhibit by the police. The photographs record the blood staining on the Bible. From this staining it is immediately obvious that the Bible has been shut whilst the blood remained wet because marks on one page are mirrored on the adjoining page.
408. The pages on which the heavy staining appears in these photographs are pages including part or all of Psalms 51-55. It is said that these pages are significant and represented "Sheila Caffell's suicide note". A number of passages are highlighted and it will suffice if we give one example, taken from verse 14 of Psalm 51:
"Save me from blood guiltiness O God…"
409. The evidence suggests that the two photographs were not brought to the attention of the defence and Mr Turner once more submits that the only explanation for this is wilful concealment by the police
As usual you ignored the most important part:
"The fact that the defence made no play of the Bible's pages may very well have something to do with another aspect of the matter. The more each member of the court looked at the photographs in order to deal with this point, the more difficult we found it to reconcile the actual bloodstaining with the defence case. The largest area of blood seems to have got onto the Bible when it came into contact with a pool of blood beside the body. As already observed the Bible must have been shut whilst the blood was wet. It does not seem very likely that it was still wet hours after the event when the police might have handled it. If this is so, it was shut by someone and then reopened to lie beside the body after Sheila Caffell had been shot. These matters along with other considerations of a similar kind were placed before us by the prosecution on an application to call fresh evidence with which we will deal later. It did not, however, require fresh evidence for us to see that there was a potentially powerful point that might have been made in this regard by the prosecution at trial.
The explanation why the pages at which the Bible was open was not explored by the defence may be explicable by these matters. Counsel with the experience of Mr Rivlin QC, and with his acknowledged reputation for thoroughness, may well have decided that far from helping these matters might have presented a yet further major hurdle for the appellant to overcome and consequently decided to leave well alone. In any event we are satisfied that production of the original exhibit provided all the information that the photographs would have revealed and that there was no failure to disclose in this respect."
What does this mean? It means that the bible sat in a pool of blood and then someone picked it up and closed it while the blood was wet and then reopened it before the blood dried. If the blood had dried with it closed the pages would have been stuck together. Sheila was dead so she can't have reopened it. That means someone else was there. That is why the defense didn't try raising this at trial because it implicated their client.
Oops you goofed again
-
How dare you nick my CS photo, abs! 8()(((@#
Next time you come back home, I'll put you over my knee and paddle your big fat petite little bottom! 8**8:/:
-
How dare you nick my CS photo, abs! 8()(((@#
Next time you come back home, I'll put you over my knee and paddle your big fat petite little bottom! 8**8:/:
Ooops, but I nick ALL pictures I can get my hands on. I created the photothread over on blue, and if I hadn´t nicked right and left, there wouldn´t be much to show!
But you can spank me once for doing it! 8(>((
-
Ooops, but I nick ALL pictures I can get my hands on. I created the photothread over on blue, and if I hadn´t nicked right and left, there wouldn´t be much to show!
But you can spank me once for doing it! 8(>((
I was going to say see me in my room, but I'll let you off this time... only this time mind, and only because hubby might be watching. Any further indiscretions will require permanent detention, so you'll never be able to visit blue ever again!
(*thinks* - wonder if this moderating job has gone to my head 8-)(--) )
-
I was going to say see me in my room, but I'll let you off this time... only this time mind, and only because hubby might be watching. Any further indiscretions will require permanent detention, so you'll never be able to visit blue ever again!
(*thinks* - wonder if this moderating job has gone to my head 8-)(--) )
Hahaha, Myster, you are the best! 8(0(*
-
Hahaha, Myster, you are the best! 8(0(*
Hello Fab Ab
Looks like I might have some competition for Myster's affections 8)-))). Boys on Blue not enough for you?
-
Sheila's head was in more or less the same position for both shots, but there was obviously something under her shoulder before the first shot, which was moved before the second one.
Could this explain? PC Woodcock states SC's head was slightly raised against a bedside locker.
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=166.0;attach=251
-
Sheila's body was pulled towards the foot of the bed at some stage as shown by the double CS photo with her rucked up nightie, but this could have been simply to get a better view of the neck wounds if her head was jammed/propped up against the bedside cabinet. Both look like they were taken within a short space of time of each other from the same position. The shadows cast by her body and the bed seem to be different, but the flash might have been off-camera and held in a different position for each photo.
(http://i.imgur.com/r9xRvJ4.jpg)
-
Sheila's body was pulled towards the foot of the bed at some stage as shown by the double CS photo with her rucked up nightie, but this could have been simply to get a better view of the neck wounds if her head was jammed/propped up against the bedside cabinet. Both look like they were taken within a short space of time of each other from the same position. The shadows cast by her body and the bed seem to be different, but the flash might have been off-camera and held in a different position for each photo.
(http://i.imgur.com/r9xRvJ4.jpg)
Thank you Myster that all makes sense.
Although I believe SC took her life I have always found the location odd. If I am right then I think she must have been panicked into this location by noise/lights from outside and perhaps went looking for the bible to hold/read. If JB was responsible and he wanted to stage manage a suicide why not murder SC in her own room or in the room of her beloved boys. It makes no sense why she would end her life in her parents' room squeezed in a small space with her head ending up against a cabinet and a pair of blood stained socks by her side.