UK Justice Forum 🇬🇧

Disappeared and Abducted Children and Young Adults => Madeleine McCann (3) disappeared from her parent's holiday apartment at Ocean Club, Praia da Luz, Portugal on 3 May 2007. No trace of her has ever been found. => Topic started by: TitoMuzzy on September 02, 2015, 12:42:52 AM

Title: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: TitoMuzzy on September 02, 2015, 12:42:52 AM
ELEVEN MILLION POUNDS spent, and still no clue !!!

(http://ichef-1.bbci.co.uk/news/660/cpsprodpb/1306B/production/_85313977_sun.jpg)

http://www.thesun.co.uk/sol/homepage/news/6617444/11m-spent-on-Maddie-hunt.html?CMP=spklr-_-S9SunSocial-_-FBPAGE-_-TheSun-thesun-_-20150901-_-News-_-230499639 (http://www.thesun.co.uk/sol/homepage/news/6617444/11m-spent-on-Maddie-hunt.html?CMP=spklr-_-S9SunSocial-_-FBPAGE-_-TheSun-thesun-_-20150901-_-News-_-230499639)

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3219114/Bill-Scotland-Yard-investigation-Madeleine-McCann-disappearance-hits-11MILLION-no-arrests-former-police-chief-calls-end.html (http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3219114/Bill-Scotland-Yard-investigation-Madeleine-McCann-disappearance-hits-11MILLION-no-arrests-former-police-chief-calls-end.html)
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Mr Gray on September 02, 2015, 07:26:36 AM
I agree with him


You can’t keep chasing shadows. Chasing sightings all over the world. It depends on whether the detectives are making any real progress. For me it needs to be reviewed by a senior officer.

If they are making no progress ...wind it down......but it's obvious he doesn't know what progress is being made
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: pathfinder73 on September 02, 2015, 07:54:23 AM
You don't need to be chasing shadows to solve this case and where have I heard that expression before - my posts on here.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Lace on September 02, 2015, 08:57:58 AM
What ever they are doing shouldn't be made public,   watching someone for instance are they actually going to reveal that they are observing a suspect?
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: stephen25000 on September 02, 2015, 09:02:52 AM
What ever they are doing shouldn't be made public,   watching someone for instance are they actually going to reveal that they are observing a suspect?

Is that rather rather like having a list of suspects before, who knew they were going to be interviewed like Murat, and broadcasting it in the press and on TV. ?
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Lace on September 02, 2015, 09:05:50 AM
Is that rather rather like having a list of suspects before, who knew they were going to be interviewed like Murat, and broadcasting it in the press and on TV. ?

Interviewing maybe,  but not secret surveillance.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: carlymichelle on September 02, 2015, 09:09:27 AM
stephen us realistic   people have been saying for years   it needs to end   the mcanns  left the children and for whatever reason maddie  vanished never to be seen again that is the mcanns respnsibility to  pay    for maddie being looked for not the uk tax payers
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Lace on September 02, 2015, 09:13:52 AM
stephen us realistic   people have been saying for years   it needs to end   the mcanns  left the children and for whatever reason maddie  vanished never to be seen again that is the mcanns respnsibility to  pay    for maddie being looked for not the uk tax payers

Maddie is a British Citizen and has EVERY right to be searched for by the British police.

Stop using the 'McCann's left the children' mantra in your argument,   Madeleine is an innocent child it makes no difference what her parents did,   she needs to be found.

If SY were on the verge of arresting the McCann's you would no doubt change your tune,   it's all about beating the McCann's with you isn't it?
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: stephen25000 on September 02, 2015, 09:14:35 AM
stephen us realistic   people have been saying for years   it needs to end   the mcanns  left the children and for whatever reason maddie  vanished never to be seen again that is the mcanns respnsibility to  pay    for maddie being looked for not the uk tax payers

Indeed.  There is after all the 'fund', sitting doing nothing according to the supporters club.

Now let's wait for the mccann supporters to mention the Needham case.

Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: carlymichelle on September 02, 2015, 09:16:24 AM
Indeed.  There is after all the 'fund', sitting doing nothing according to the supporters club.

Now let's wait for the mccann supporters to mention the Needham case.

exactly why cant that fund be used to  pay for police etc?
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Mr Gray on September 02, 2015, 09:19:38 AM
exactly why cant that fund be used to  pay for police etc?

The article does not say Grange should close
Some people can't read
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Lace on September 02, 2015, 09:32:08 AM
exactly why cant that fund be used to  pay for police etc?

The fund is there to be used if Madeleine is not found by SY,   or if she is found to be given to charity.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Benice on September 02, 2015, 10:08:35 AM
stephen us realistic   people have been saying for years   it needs to end   the mcanns  left the children and for whatever reason maddie  vanished never to be seen again that is the mcanns respnsibility to  pay    for maddie being looked for not the uk tax payers

You must be very annoyed at the £3 million plus that it cost the UK taxpayer to discover what had happened to April Jones.    After all, her parents left her unsupervised too - and in a place where abduction was a far greater risk than if she was fast asleep in her own bed.    Do you think her parents should have been told to just get on with it and pay for the investigation themselves - because they were responsible for creating the situation where April was abducted?

I'm a UK taxpayer and have no objections.  So speak for yourself.     What sort of person  would want to deprive any missing child of every chance of being found - on the grounds that  (in their opinion)  the parents were to blame.   Even it they were - why would any normal decent person want to punish the missing child for that?   

Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Alice Purjorick on September 02, 2015, 10:09:30 AM
The fund is there to be used if Madeleine is not found by SY,   or if she is found to be given to charity.

That is not quite what the company's articles of association say. Why let a simple thing like that upset the applecart though.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Alfred R Jones on September 02, 2015, 10:13:33 AM
Why would "sceptics" want the investigation to close just when they're on the verge of catching the monkey after all these years?!
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: stephen25000 on September 02, 2015, 10:14:03 AM
Under the photo of the mccanns.

'Even though Madeleine's parents Kate and Gerry, pictured, live in Leicestershire, Scotland Yard was handed the investigation because of its expertise in investigating complex murder cases'

'Police chiefs ‘ring-fenced’ the inquiry to prevent officers working on other case, even though the force has been forced to make £600million in cuts over four years.'

Read more: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3219114/Bill-Scotland-Yard-investigation-Madeleine-McCann-disappearance-hits-11MILLION-no-arrests-former-police-chief-calls-end.html#ixzz3kZTo3wnw
Follow us: @MailOnline on Twitter | DailyMail on Facebook


and the comments section...................
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Benice on September 02, 2015, 10:23:54 AM
Why would "sceptics" want the investigation to close just when they're on the verge of catching the monkey after all these years?!

Exactly - I thought it was their firm belief that the clock was ticking and at some stage in the investigation the police would pounce on the McCanns and arrest them.

In that case - one would think they would be calling for the investigation to continue at all costs  - not close down.




Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Alice Purjorick on September 02, 2015, 10:26:51 AM
From the Mail Article:
Even though Madeleine's parents Kate and Gerry, pictured, live in Leicestershire, Scotland Yard was handed the investigation because of its expertise in investigating complex murder cases



Ooops!
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Alice Purjorick on September 02, 2015, 10:38:11 AM
Exactly - I thought it was their firm belief that the clock was ticking and at some stage in the investigation the police would pounce on the McCanns and arrest them.

In that case - one would think they would be calling for the investigation to continue at all costs  - not close down.

Could the more extreme in each camp handle the emotional shock of having nothing to post or name call about if it closed ? I suppose they would just decamp to wherever they could carry on doing the same sort of thing. Or maybe carry on posting about dogs ; that seems to have a lot legs left in it  8(>((

Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Carana on September 02, 2015, 10:38:34 AM
Under the photo of the mccanns.

'Even though Madeleine's parents Kate and Gerry, pictured, live in Leicestershire, Scotland Yard was handed the investigation because of its expertise in investigating complex murder cases'

'Police chiefs ‘ring-fenced’ the inquiry to prevent officers working on other case, even though the force has been forced to make £600million in cuts over four years.'

Read more: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3219114/Bill-Scotland-Yard-investigation-Madeleine-McCann-disappearance-hits-11MILLION-no-arrests-former-police-chief-calls-end.html#ixzz3kZTo3wnw
Follow us: @MailOnline on Twitter | DailyMail on Facebook


and the comments section...................

According to whom?
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: stephen25000 on September 02, 2015, 10:40:50 AM
According to whom?

Why don't you ask the writer of the article and the editor of the Mail ?
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Carana on September 02, 2015, 10:43:56 AM
Why are the Sun and the DM rehashing a story from March of this year?

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3001635/It-s-time-ended-search-Maddie-officers-focus-threats-public-says-police-union-chief.html

http://www.express.co.uk/news/uk/564729/Police-urged-shelve-Madeleine-McCann-hunt
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Brietta on September 02, 2015, 10:47:50 AM
Exactly - I thought it was their firm belief that the clock was ticking and at some stage in the investigation the police would pounce on the McCanns and arrest them.

In that case - one would think they would be calling for the investigation to continue at all costs  - not close down.

If the focus of the current investigation was was Madeleine McCann's parents and friends the 'truth seekers' would be apoplectic at any suggestion of closure.
In fact they would probably consult Ms Baulch (who I understand has time on her hands since PJGA took over her last appeal fund) about starting a GoFundMe appeal to finance it.

Might it be that "Justice for Madeleine" is not really as important as it has been made out to be ... particularly as the route to "Justice" appears to be directed firmly towards abductors who are strangers to her and her family??

The hypocrisy is breathtaking.   
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: ferryman on September 02, 2015, 10:50:33 AM
Why are the Sun and the DM rehashing a story from March of this year?

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3001635/It-s-time-ended-search-Maddie-officers-focus-threats-public-says-police-union-chief.html

http://www.express.co.uk/news/uk/564729/Police-urged-shelve-Madeleine-McCann-hunt

Well spotted.

Perhaps the question you should be asking is, why did it take them as long as 6 whole months to rehash the story? ...
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Carana on September 02, 2015, 10:59:55 AM
Well spotted.

Perhaps the question you should be asking is, why did it take them as long as 6 whole months to rehash the story? ...

Well, the first time it was in the run-up to elections in May... so wait a few months and run it again.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Brietta on September 02, 2015, 11:02:18 AM
Well spotted.

Perhaps the question you should be asking is, why did it take them as long as 6 whole months to rehash the story? ...

                                                Madeleine McCann sells newspapers.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Brietta on September 02, 2015, 11:06:05 AM
Well, the first time it was in the run-up to elections in May... so wait a few months and run it again.

Didn't it also coincide with the Police Federation seeking to highlight cuts affecting services and negotiations for remuneration on behalf of their members?
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Carana on September 02, 2015, 11:07:17 AM
                                                Madeleine McCann sells newspapers.

And attracts extra attention to any other agenda to be promoted...
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: G-Unit on September 02, 2015, 11:09:15 AM
From the Mail Article:
Even though Madeleine's parents Kate and Gerry, pictured, live in Leicestershire, Scotland Yard was handed the investigation because of its expertise in investigating complex murder cases



Ooops!

Murder? Who's been murdered then?
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Carana on September 02, 2015, 11:09:45 AM
Didn't it also coincide with the Police Federation seeking to highlight cuts affecting services and negotiations for remuneration on behalf of their members?

That seems to have been the gist the last time (IMO). Perhaps the negotiations haven't advanced as hoped for post-election?
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: G-Unit on September 02, 2015, 11:24:31 AM
From the Mail Article:
Even though Madeleine's parents Kate and Gerry, pictured, live in Leicestershire, Scotland Yard was handed the investigation because of its expertise in investigating complex murder cases



Ooops!

It also seems to have expertise in corruption;

A former senior officer, who recently retired from Scotland Yard, told The Independent: “Nothing has changed. The Met is still every bit as corrupt as it was back then.”
http://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/crime/exclusive-scotland-yards-rotten-core-police-failed-to-address-endemic-corruption-9050224.html

Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Benice on September 02, 2015, 11:29:49 AM
Murder? Who's been murdered then?

They could hardly employ officers with expertise in finding missing UK children abducted abroad as it was such a rare crime - no such specialised unit would exist.

Both the police and the McCanns know that Madeleine may have been murdered, but until evidence is found that she is dead they will continue to believe that she may be alive.

Any hopes that the mention of 'murder' is a coded message that the police think it was the McCanns wot dunnit - are doomed to be dashed imo.

In the meantime 'expertise' which didn't exist before -  will now be part of our police forces 'CV' - purely as a result of this investigation.   That means the chances of finding a missing child in future will be greatly improved - and another reason why this investigation is worth every penny IMO.



Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Brietta on September 02, 2015, 11:48:41 AM
They could hardly employ officers with expertise in finding missing UK children abducted abroad as it was such a rare crime - no such specialised unit would exist.

Both the police and the McCanns know that Madeleine may have been murdered, but until evidence is found that she is dead they will continue to believe that she may be alive.

Any hopes that the mention of 'murder' is a coded message that the police think it was the McCanns wot dunnit - are doomed to be dashed imo.

In the meantime 'expertise' which didn't exist before -  will now be part of our police forces 'CV' - purely as a result of this investigation.   That means the chances of finding a missing child in future will be greatly improved - and another reason why this investigation is worth every penny IMO.

Lessons will have been learned both here and in Portugal by the officers who conducted their separate reviews into the available evidence ... both teams concluding that Madeleine McCann had been the victim of abduction.

I am certain that working cooperatively with each other can only have been beneficial and like you think that if anything like Madeleine's case were to happen in the future, the groundwork has been laid to reach resolution very quickly and professionally.

It doesn't have to be the abduction of a British child in Portugal ... it could be a Portuguese child in Britain ... or any other sort of international criminality ... but we now have links and communications which were not in place before.

I really do wish people were capable of viewing the bigger picture.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: stephen25000 on September 02, 2015, 11:50:00 AM
Lessons will have been learned both here and in Portugal by the officers who conducted their separate reviews into the available evidence ... both teams concluding that Madeleine McCann had been the victim of abduction.

I am certain that working cooperatively with each other can only have been beneficial and like you think that if anything like Madeleine's case were to happen in the future, the groundwork has been laid to reach resolution very quickly and professionally.

It doesn't have to be the abduction of a British child in Portugal ... it could be a Portuguese child in Britain ... or any other sort of international criminality ... but we now have links and communications which were not in place before.

I really do wish people were capable of viewing the bigger picture.

'the bigger picture'.

i.e. unquestioning support of the mccanns.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: stephen25000 on September 02, 2015, 11:51:59 AM
stephs, Sheffield, United Kingdom, about 2 hours ago

So are there 31 detectives for every missing child?

VOTES IN REGARD TO COMMENT

428 YES

4 NO


Read more: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3219114/Bill-Scotland-Yard-investigation-Madeleine-McCann-disappearance-hits-11MILLION-no-arrests-former-police-chief-calls-end.html#ixzz3kZqK1kne
Follow us: @MailOnline on Twitter | DailyMail on Facebook
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Brietta on September 02, 2015, 11:58:46 AM
'the bigger picture'.

i.e. unquestioning support of the mccanns.

What a weird post.  Unquestioning support for the search for Madeleine McCann ~ stolen just before her fourth birthday over eight years ago ~ unquestioning support for any child of any Nationality in the same situation both past and future ~ but mainly prevention of such.

I do not view current events through the prism of one particular family or even antipathy towards particular individuals.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: stephen25000 on September 02, 2015, 12:02:00 PM
What a weird post.  Unquestioning support for the search for Madeleine McCann ~ stolen just before her fourth birthday over eight years ago ~ unquestioning support for any child of any Nationality in the same situation both past and future ~ but mainly prevention of such.

I do not view current events through the prism of one particular family or even antipathy towards particular individuals.


...but this is what you do every day.

Weird NO, accurate as regards you, YES.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Brietta on September 02, 2015, 12:09:27 PM

...but this is what you do every day.

Weird NO, accurate as regards you, YES.

I've had a quick glance at some of the comments, stephs, and have noticed referrals to 'all the hundreds of other missing children'.

Which is a common mantra ... but one which just isn't applicable for many reasons.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: ShiningInLuz on September 02, 2015, 12:16:24 PM
ELEVEN MILLION POUNDS spent, and still no clue !!!

http://www.thesun.co.uk/sol/homepage/news/6617444/11m-spent-on-Maddie-hunt.html?CMP=spklr-_-S9SunSocial-_-FBPAGE-_-TheSun-thesun-_-20150901-_-News-_-230499639 (http://www.thesun.co.uk/sol/homepage/news/6617444/11m-spent-on-Maddie-hunt.html?CMP=spklr-_-S9SunSocial-_-FBPAGE-_-TheSun-thesun-_-20150901-_-News-_-230499639)

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3219114/Bill-Scotland-Yard-investigation-Madeleine-McCann-disappearance-hits-11MILLION-no-arrests-former-police-chief-calls-end.html (http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3219114/Bill-Scotland-Yard-investigation-Madeleine-McCann-disappearance-hits-11MILLION-no-arrests-former-police-chief-calls-end.html)
It looks like the next article in this set will be in Apr 2016, when the bill is estimated at £12 million.  Or will they wait to the 9th anniversary?

I wonder why John O'Conner thinks this case is not being reviewed by a senior officer?  I would have bet money on a major review when DCI Nicola Wall took over.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: stephen25000 on September 02, 2015, 12:25:15 PM
I've had a quick glance at some of the comments, stephs, and have noticed referrals to 'all the hundreds of other missing children'.

Which is a common mantra ... but one which just isn't applicable for many reasons.

Wrong Babs.

Try again.  8**8:/:
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Carana on September 02, 2015, 12:27:46 PM
It looks like the next article in this set will be in Apr 2016, when the bill is estimated at £12 million.  Or will they wait to the 9th anniversary?

I wonder why John O'Conner thinks this case is not being reviewed by a senior officer?  I would have bet money on a major review when DCI Nicola Wall took over.

What's next on the UK political agenda? When's the EU referendum supposed to be taking place?

Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Mr Gray on September 02, 2015, 01:05:11 PM
It looks like the next article in this set will be in Apr 2016, when the bill is estimated at £12 million.  Or will they wait to the 9th anniversary?

I wonder why John O'Conner thinks this case is not being reviewed by a senior officer?  I would have bet money on a major review when DCI Nicola Wall took over.
TO me this is an indication that SY do have leads that they consider worth investigating
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Montclair on September 02, 2015, 01:22:09 PM
stephen us realistic   people have been saying for years   it needs to end   the mcanns  left the children and for whatever reason maddie  vanished never to be seen again that is the mcanns respnsibility to  pay    for maddie being looked for not the uk tax payers

Don't agree with either you or Stephen on this. No investigation should ever end until they find the guilty party. That is what justice and police work are about. I don't understand these people who insist that SY should pack up. What difference does it make to you that they are continuing the investigation? Don't you want to know what happened to her? I do.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Lace on September 02, 2015, 01:36:15 PM
stephs, Sheffield, United Kingdom, about 2 hours ago

So are there 31 detectives for every missing child?

VOTES IN REGARD TO COMMENT

428 YES

4 NO


Read more: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3219114/Bill-Scotland-Yard-investigation-Madeleine-McCann-disappearance-hits-11MILLION-no-arrests-former-police-chief-calls-end.html#ixzz3kZqK1kne
Follow us: @MailOnline on Twitter | DailyMail on Facebook


How many missing children have been -  1.  Abducted from their bed on holiday abroad.   2.   Their parents accused of faking the abduction and hiding the body.   3.   A Police Officer assigned to the case writes a   book accusing the parents.   Madeleine deserves another investigation,  it's a cold case and will take longer.

Why stop now,   all the money will definitely have been wasted if all the avenues haven't been investigated,  no one knows how the investigation is going.

edited to add -  I saw the call out to anti's to make comments,  so sad.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: G-Unit on September 02, 2015, 01:44:12 PM
Don't agree with either you or Stephen on this. No investigation should ever end until they find the guilty party. That is what justice and police work are about. I don't understand these people who insist that SY should pack up. What difference does it make to you that they are continuing the investigation? Don't you want to know what happened to her? I do.

It is unprecedented for a UK police force to investigate a crime committed in another country, I believe. Why not let the Portuguese authorities deal with it? After all. SY have no jurisdiction in Portugal anyway. They may find someone they want to arrest, but they can't do that if their suspect is in Portugal, it's for the Portuguese to arrest and try any suspects. If they were in charge of the investigation it might be worth carrying on, but they're not.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Montclair on September 02, 2015, 01:49:01 PM
It is unprecedented for a UK police force to investigate a crime committed in another country, I believe. Why not let the Portuguese authorities deal with it? After all. SY have no jurisdiction in Portugal anyway. They may find someone they want to arrest, but they can't do that if their suspect is in Portugal, it's for the Portuguese to arrest and try any suspects. If they were in charge of the investigation it might be worth carrying on, but they're not.

The PJ are also investigating. I believe that the British can investigate if the victim is British and especially if they believe that the culprits are British. I am suspicious of this call for an end to the investigation and most "[ censored word]" I know do not want the case to be closed.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Brietta on September 02, 2015, 02:02:46 PM
The PJ are also investigating. I believe that the British can investigate if the victim is British and especially if they believe that the culprits are British. I am suspicious of this call for an end to the investigation and most "[ censored word]" I know do not want the case to be closed.

Just my opinion ... but I think the PJ are as anxious as anyone to have this investigation done and dusted if not more so.

It has been rightly pointed out that Madeleine McCann's case is in their jurisdiction.  That alone makes it important for them to find the solution ... it is not in their interests to have criminals like that running loose ... if SY are conducting a parallel investigation, I am sure an exchange of ideas will be welcome on both sides.

IMO there are two types of people desperate to have the investigation derailed ... stupid ones ... and guilty ones.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: G-Unit on September 02, 2015, 02:19:25 PM
The PJ are also investigating. I believe that the British can investigate if the victim is British and especially if they believe that the culprits are British. I am suspicious of this call for an end to the investigation and most "[ censored word]" I know do not want the case to be closed.

The UK police have no power to conduct investigations overseas. In limited cases UK courts can prosecute people for crimes committed overseas. Usually investigations and prosecutions take place by and in the country where the crime was committed.
https://www.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/141958/mou-fco-acpo-coroners.pdf
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Carana on September 02, 2015, 02:37:58 PM
The UK police have no power to conduct investigations overseas. In limited cases UK courts can prosecute people for crimes committed overseas. Usually investigations and prosecutions take place by and in the country where the crime was committed.
https://www.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/141958/mou-fco-acpo-coroners.pdf


So what was the JIT between the French and the UK police over the Alps massacre about then?

Why does the concept of a JIT even exist?
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: stephen25000 on September 02, 2015, 02:41:54 PM
Don't agree with either you or Stephen on this. No investigation should ever end until they find the guilty party. That is what justice and police work are about. I don't understand these people who insist that SY should pack up. What difference does it make to you that they are continuing the investigation? Don't you want to know what happened to her? I do.

We can agree to differ.

Personally, this inquiry was never going to produce a result. It was done out of political expediency  by Cameron.

Nothing i have seen so far has changed my mind on that.

and what do most inquiries produce ?
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: G-Unit on September 02, 2015, 03:03:41 PM

So what was the JIT between the French and the UK police over the Alps massacre about then?

Why does the concept of a JIT even exist?

I have no idea why a JIT was established in the Alps case, have you? I assume that both countries agreed on that way forward. Clearly the Portuguese and British authorities didn't take that way forward in the McCann case. Hardly surprising really, given the criticism of the initial Portuguese investigation by certain elements in the UK.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Alice Purjorick on September 02, 2015, 03:30:41 PM

So what was the JIT between the French and the UK police over the Alps massacre about then?

Why does the concept of a JIT even exist?

Were a formal JIT maybe the nature of the crimes has a bearing on it.
Multiple shooting v inexplicable disappearance of a child.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Carana on September 02, 2015, 03:42:25 PM
Were a formal JIT maybe the nature of the crimes has a bearing on it.
Multiple shooting v inexplicable disappearance of a child.

Yes... in that case the evident tragic result of the crime (multiple murders) was evident. However, the fact is that a JIT was established even though the events happened in France.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Alice Purjorick on September 02, 2015, 03:45:21 PM
Yes... in that case the evident tragic result of the crime (multiple murders) was evident. However, the fact is that a JIT was established even though the events happened in France.

Was it a formal JIT or just an agreement of cooperation between British and French police forces?
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Anna on September 02, 2015, 04:06:38 PM
Was it a formal JIT or just an agreement of cooperation between British and French police forces?

Any help, Alice?

A spokesman for Surrey Police said it is "continuing to provide support" to the French investigation.

He added: "As part of the Joint Investigation Team (JIT), which was established following the deaths, officers from the Surrey and Sussex Major Crime Team have worked closely with the French authorities to progress a number of lines of inquiry in the UK.
"This is a complex inquiry, however Surrey Police remains committed to helping find answers to what happened and continuing to assist the French investigation wherever possible."

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/uknews/crime/11453905/French-Alps-murder-hunt-Motorcyclist-ruled-out-over-al-Hilli-shootings.html
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Alice Purjorick on September 02, 2015, 04:35:34 PM
Any help, Alice?

A spokesman for Surrey Police said it is "continuing to provide support" to the French investigation.

He added: "As part of the Joint Investigation Team (JIT), which was established following the deaths, officers from the Surrey and Sussex Major Crime Team have worked closely with the French authorities to progress a number of lines of inquiry in the UK.
"This is a complex inquiry, however Surrey Police remains committed to helping find answers to what happened and continuing to assist the French investigation wherever possible."

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/uknews/crime/11453905/French-Alps-murder-hunt-Motorcyclist-ruled-out-over-al-Hilli-shootings.html
Thanks Anna.
It appears the British police are assisting the French police with their investigation by investigating in UK as requested by the French who have primacy it would seem.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Eleanor on September 02, 2015, 05:03:41 PM
Thanks Anna.
It appears the British police are assisting the French police with their investigation by investigating in UK as requested by the French who have primacy it would seem.

It is still a Joint Investigation.  Although don't underestimate The French Police.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Anna on September 02, 2015, 05:08:40 PM
Thanks Anna.
It appears the British police are assisting the French police with their investigation by investigating in UK as requested by the French who have primacy it would seem.

I don't know much about this case Alice, but IIRC there was a couple of Brits living in the UK, who were under suspicion. The French guy has been ruled out(cyclist). I guess it comes down to who had a motive and the finger pointed to the UK.

...................................................................
The money being spent by operation Grange, in Portugal, on the Madeleine case, is at the cost of the British Government and the Portuguese would rule over any decisions made by SC, although there would be differences if a UK subject was involved.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Brietta on September 02, 2015, 05:09:07 PM
Any help, Alice?

A spokesman for Surrey Police said it is "continuing to provide support" to the French investigation.

He added: "As part of the Joint Investigation Team (JIT), which was established following the deaths, officers from the Surrey and Sussex Major Crime Team have worked closely with the French authorities to progress a number of lines of inquiry in the UK.
"This is a complex inquiry, however Surrey Police remains committed to helping find answers to what happened and continuing to assist the French investigation wherever possible."

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/uknews/crime/11453905/French-Alps-murder-hunt-Motorcyclist-ruled-out-over-al-Hilli-shootings.html

I imagine in a complex case such as that the bill for the on-going investigation must be quite a hefty one.

Do we know if anyone went to the bother of submitting a FOI request ... or is criticism of expenditure incurred as a result of a crime involving British Nationals abroad reserved for Madeleine McCann's case?
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Anna on September 02, 2015, 05:22:20 PM
I imagine in a complex case such as that the bill for the on-going investigation must be quite a hefty one.

Do we know if anyone went to the bother of submitting a FOI request ... or is criticism of expenditure incurred as a result of a crime involving British Nationals abroad reserved for Madeleine McCann's case?

No idea whether an FOI request was submitted or not. Brietta.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Carana on September 02, 2015, 05:57:46 PM
I don't know much about this case Alice, but IIRC there was a couple of Brits living in the UK, who were under suspicion. The French guy has been ruled out(cyclist). I guess it comes down to who had a motive and the finger pointed to the UK.

...................................................................
The money being spent by operation Grange, in Portugal, on the Madeleine case, is at the cost of the British Government and the Portuguese would rule over any decisions made by SC, although there would be differences if a UK subject was involved.

I haven't check this for accuracy yet, but it gives the general gist:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Annecy_shootings

It's hard to find accurate information without hunting and double-checking way back.

The latest idea appears to be that a local French Foreign Legion officer blew a fuse... or it could just be that the investigation has fizzled out.

http://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2015/may/25/alps-shootings-saad-hilli-french-foreign-legion-soldier-suspect
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Alice Purjorick on September 02, 2015, 06:11:12 PM
I don't know much about this case Alice, but IIRC there was a couple of Brits living in the UK, who were under suspicion. The French guy has been ruled out(cyclist). I guess it comes down to who had a motive and the finger pointed to the UK.

...................................................................
The money being spent by operation Grange, in Portugal, on the Madeleine case, is at the cost of the British Government and the Portuguese would rule over any decisions made by SC, although there would be differences if a UK subject was involved.
http://www.open.ac.uk/research/main/news/international-co-operation-crucial-for-solving-crimes-against-britons-abroad
A bit old but interesting.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Anna on September 02, 2015, 06:24:54 PM
I haven't check this for accuracy yet, but it gives the general gist:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Annecy_shootings

It's hard to find accurate information without hunting and double-checking way back.

The latest idea appears to be that a local French Foreign Legion officer blew a fuse... or it could just be that the investigation has fizzled out.

http://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2015/may/25/alps-shootings-saad-hilli-french-foreign-legion-soldier-suspect

Thanks,Carana.
                       I do remember a bit about it now. They thought the brother in Surrey was involved or a cyclist in france. Then they wanted to exhume the body of her ex husband, who died on the same day(heart attack). It was an arranged marriage for emigration purpose IIRC.
The motorbike chap was ruled out. I cant see anything past the May news, where a soldier was suspect.

....................................................................................


Somebody asked(Alice?) if it was a JIT? ..............It was.



In an attempt to speed up what is proving to be a laborious investigation, and in the absence of much progress, France and Britain agreed yesterday to cut through red-tape by implementing a rarely-used EU law. French magistrates and gendarmes will work with Surrey police officers and Crown Prosecution Service officials in a "joint investigation team" – only the second of its kind to be created by France and Britain since the principle was established by EU governments nine years ago.
http://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/crime/alps-murders-annecy-squad-to-join-forces-with-surrey-police-8163894.html
...........................................................................................

What has all this to do with Madeleine and the cost of Operation Grange? Have I missed something here?
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Anna on September 02, 2015, 06:28:45 PM
http://www.open.ac.uk/research/main/news/international-co-operation-crucial-for-solving-crimes-against-britons-abroad
A bit old but interesting.

Thanks Alice. It does look very interesting I will have a proper read later.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Lyall on September 02, 2015, 06:30:07 PM
O’Connor: "It’s about priorities". But I think it's also about accountability. Nobody knows better than an ex-top British cop that our police could spend 100m on an investigation but the public would still have no way of finding out what they'd done, or not done (including O'Connor now he's retired).

Police (and ex-police) know this makes them vulnerable PR-wise.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Mr Gray on September 02, 2015, 06:33:14 PM
O’Connor: "It’s about priorities". But I think it's also about accountability. Nobody knows better than an ex-top British cop that our police could spend 100m on an investigation but the public would still have no way of finding out what they'd done, or not done (including O'Connor now he's retired).

Police (and ex-police) know this makes them vulnerable PR-wise.

He says the investigation should be wound down if there is no progress and I agree with him... At the moment we just don't know
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Lyall on September 02, 2015, 06:35:21 PM
He says the investigation should be wound down if there is no progress and I agree with him... At the moment we just don't know

That's his point though. It's a rare (very rare) political investigation and he may think the Met top brass don't know what they're doing either.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Carana on September 02, 2015, 06:36:06 PM
O’Connor: "It’s about priorities". But I think it's also about accountability. Nobody knows better than an ex-top British cop that our police could spend 100m on an investigation but the public would still have no way of finding out what they'd done, or not done (including O'Connor now he's retired).

Police (and ex-police) know this makes them vulnerable PR-wise.

In that respect, I've found the Jersey Operation Havern to be interesting. In that case, however, there doesn't appear to be any onging investigation into any specific child who may still be missing.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: ferryman on September 02, 2015, 06:45:52 PM
In that respect, I've found the Jersey Operation Havern to be interesting. In that case, however, there doesn't appear to be any onging investigation into any specific child who may still be missing.

And also the Haut de la Garenne investigation brought about prosecutions.

Whether it so in respect of all crimes committed or alleged, I'm not sure ....
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Carana on September 02, 2015, 07:48:40 PM
That's his point though. It's a rare (very rare) political investigation and he may think the Met top brass don't know what they're doing either.

Whose point?
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Miss Taken Identity on September 02, 2015, 08:10:57 PM
I agree if there is no progress then whtever it was they are doing should be stopped by the UK police. Or as he suggests  a senior police officer should get involved and look to see savings can be made . I do not think they will bring anything new to the table, but that is just my opinion. The problem was they had nothing concrete to go on at all.

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3219114/Bill-Scotland-Yard-investigation-Madeleine-McCann-disappearance-hits-11MILLION-no-arrests-former-police-chief-calls-end.html
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Lyall on September 02, 2015, 09:13:20 PM
Whose point?

O’Connor's. His line "needs to be reviewed by a senior officer" might be code for "my contacts inside the Met don't know what Grange are doing either".
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: mercury on September 02, 2015, 09:26:25 PM
So Redwood or Hall are not senior? Oh.....
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Brietta on September 02, 2015, 09:27:00 PM
British cops say Madeleine McCann investigation "still live" despite calls for it to be wound down
20:10, 2 SEPTEMBER 2015 UPDATED 20:23, 2 SEPTEMBER 2015
BY GERARD COUZENS
Sources reveal police are still determined despite the case costing UK taxpayers £11 million

The British investigation into missing Madeleine McCann is still "live" and is not about to be wound down, sources have revealed.

The news comes after ex-Metropolitan Police officer John O'Connor yesterday questioned whether the hunt for the missing child was a good use of resources.

It has been claimed the Scotland Yard operation has already cost the taxpayer £11 million but there have not yet been any arrests.

But well-placed sources in Portugal insisted there was no evidence to suggest Operation Grange was going to be shelved in the short or medium term.

And they said they were expecting to receive a new international letter of request shortly from UK authorities - the second since DCI Nicola Wall took over from previous Operation Grange boss Andy Redwood at the end of last year but the first she will have been involved in preparing.

The regular meetings DCI Redwood held with his Portuguese counterparts in the Algarve city of Faro have been put on hold since the takeover.

Her successor is understood to have asked police in Portugal to put on hold some of the work they were undertaking while she reviewed outstanding requests and the way she wanted to progress in the future.

Responding to grumbles about the cost of Scotland Yard’s probe and fresh claims it should be wound down, the Portuguese source insisted: “Nothing is going to be shelved.

“Co-operation right now between the British and the Portuguese police is at a moment of great synchronisation.”

Portugal’s Attorney General’s Office, which in May confirmed it had so far received five British requests for international cooperation on the Madeleine McCann case including one in January 2015, did not respond to emails today.

But insiders said they were expecting to receive a new request shortly.

The Scotland Yard inquiry is running separately to a Portuguese probe into Madeleine’s May 3 2007 disappearance.

The Portuguese investigation was reopened in May 2014 at the request of the country’s Policia Judiciaria police force - more than five years after their original probe had been shelved.

The reopening of the probe coincided with news a former employee at the Ocean Club holiday resort where Madeleine disappeared had been identified as a suspect.

Recovering heroin addict Euclides Monteiro, a convicted burglar, died in a tractor accident in 2009.

His widow Luisa Rodrigues was interviewed by Portuguese detectives but insisted he was an innocent man and has been fighting to get authorities to confirm they have now ruled him out as a suspect.

Scotland Yard, tasked with investigating Madeleine’s disappearance after Madeleine’s family made a personal plea to David Cameron in 2011, have come to focus on the theory she was killed during a bungled burglary.

John O’Connor, ex-head of the Met Police’s Flying Squad said yesterday as it was revealed the hunt for Madeleine has cost British taxpayers almost £11 million: “You can’t keep chasing shadows.

“If there are no firm leads, and by that I mean no substantial operational things like active surveillance on suspects, then I’d have thought they should be considering winding it down now.”

His comments echoed those made in March by Met Police Federation chairman John Tully.

He said at the time: “We no longer have the resources to conduct specialist inquiries all over the world which have nothing to do with London.

“It is surprising to see an inquiry like the McCann investigation ring-fenced.

“I’ve heard a lot of rumblings of discontent about it from lots of sources.”

A source close to the McCanns was quoted as saying: “Kate and Gerry are eternally grateful to the Metropolitan Police for making Operation Grange possible.

“They are pleased so many officers are still looking for Madeleine.”

In May, Portugal’s Attorney General’s Office revealed: “Since August 2012, the Public Prosecution Service of Portimao has received five British requests for international cooperation in criminal matters, the last of which has been received on January 2015.

“Three of these requests have been already executed and their pieces of execution were returned to the requesting authorities. The execution of two of them is still pending.

The Prosecutor General’s Office does not provide information on the content of the requests presented by the British authorities.”
http://www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/british-cops-say-madeleine-mccann-6370080?
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Miss Taken Identity on September 02, 2015, 09:28:39 PM
O’Connor's. His line "needs to be reviewed by a senior officer" might be code for "my contacts inside the Met don't know what Grange are doing either".

Indeed that is how I read it. I wander who is auditing this budget?
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Carana on September 02, 2015, 09:29:11 PM
O’Connor's. His line "needs to be reviewed by a senior officer" might be code for "my contacts inside the Met don't know what Grange are doing either".

Particularly if his contacts, if he still has any, don't have any particular contact with Op Grange.

Who exactly is this O'Connor chap?

Is this the same person?

Wednesday, January 28, 1998 Published at 13:29 GMT

UK

Former commander defends Flying Squad honour
image: [ The Met has been accused of demoralising officers in the Flying Squad ]
The Met has been accused of demoralising officers in the Flying Squad


John O'Connor is worried about the management of the flying squad (2'25")
A former commander of London's elite police unit, the Flying Squad, has attacked its management for allowing the morale of officers to plummet.

His criticism follows the suspension on Tuesday of 12 detectives from the squad as a result of an anti-corruption probe.

The Flying Squad, nicknamed "the Sweeney", investigates serious crimes in the capital such as armed robbery.

[ image: The suspensions follow an investigation by the Met's Complaints Investigations Bureau]
The suspensions follow an investigation by the Met's Complaints Investigations Bureau

Its former commander, John O'Connor said judgement should be reserved because nothing had been proven against the suspended police officers.


http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/51350.stm
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Lyall on September 02, 2015, 09:30:22 PM
That's him %£&)**#
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Miss Taken Identity on September 02, 2015, 09:31:58 PM
Particularly if his contacts, if he still has any, don't have any particular contact with Op Grange.

Who exactly is this O'Connor chap?

Is this the same person?

Wednesday, January 28, 1998 Published at 13:29 GMT

UK

Former commander defends Flying Squad honour
image: [ The Met has been accused of demoralising officers in the Flying Squad ]
The Met has been accused of demoralising officers in the Flying Squad


John O'Connor is worried about the management of the flying squad (2'25")
A former commander of London's elite police unit, the Flying Squad, has attacked its management for allowing the morale of officers to plummet.

His criticism follows the suspension on Tuesday of 12 detectives from the squad as a result of an anti-corruption probe.

The Flying Squad, nicknamed "the Sweeney", investigates serious crimes in the capital such as armed robbery.

[ image: The suspensions follow an investigation by the Met's Complaints Investigations Bureau]
The suspensions follow an investigation by the Met's Complaints Investigations Bureau

Its former commander, John O'Connor said judgement should be reserved because nothing had been proven against the suspended police officers.


http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/51350.stm


If it is he sounds like he is on the ball to me!
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: mercury on September 02, 2015, 09:32:50 PM
O Connor was also the man dragged into TV studios (paid?) to slag off the Pj early days...hmmm
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Carana on September 02, 2015, 09:36:02 PM
O'Connor
“It is surprising to see an inquiry like the McCann investigation ring-fenced."

Who says it has been, aside from himself?
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: mercury on September 02, 2015, 09:39:24 PM
O'Connor
“It is surprising to see an inquiry like the McCann investigation ring-fenced."

Who says it has been, aside from himself?

The Home Office
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Miss Taken Identity on September 02, 2015, 09:42:23 PM
O'Connor
“It is surprising to see an inquiry like the McCann investigation ring-fenced."

Who says it has been, aside from himself?

He must know summint  as he won't know nuffink...

 He knows more than most what goes on in the Met. He was probably correct in questionig the pj's early investigating tactics.  So much was missed and too much sympathy for the family to avoid interogating them properly.  Oh when they did get round to it  Kate didn't like it much.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Carana on September 02, 2015, 09:43:03 PM
That's him %£&)**#

How long has been a rent-a-gob then?
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Carana on September 02, 2015, 09:44:13 PM
The Home Office
Citeypoo?
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Carana on September 02, 2015, 09:47:05 PM
British cops say Madeleine McCann investigation "still live" despite calls for it to be wound down
20:10, 2 SEPTEMBER 2015 UPDATED 20:23, 2 SEPTEMBER 2015
BY GERARD COUZENS
Sources reveal police are still determined despite the case costing UK taxpayers £11 million

The British investigation into missing Madeleine McCann is still "live" and is not about to be wound down, sources have revealed.

The news comes after ex-Metropolitan Police officer John O'Connor yesterday questioned whether the hunt for the missing child was a good use of resources.

It has been claimed the Scotland Yard operation has already cost the taxpayer £11 million but there have not yet been any arrests.

But well-placed sources in Portugal insisted there was no evidence to suggest Operation Grange was going to be shelved in the short or medium term.

And they said they were expecting to receive a new international letter of request shortly from UK authorities - the second since DCI Nicola Wall took over from previous Operation Grange boss Andy Redwood at the end of last year but the first she will have been involved in preparing.

The regular meetings DCI Redwood held with his Portuguese counterparts in the Algarve city of Faro have been put on hold since the takeover.

Her successor is understood to have asked police in Portugal to put on hold some of the work they were undertaking while she reviewed outstanding requests and the way she wanted to progress in the future.

Responding to grumbles about the cost of Scotland Yard’s probe and fresh claims it should be wound down, the Portuguese source insisted: “Nothing is going to be shelved.

“Co-operation right now between the British and the Portuguese police is at a moment of great synchronisation.”

Portugal’s Attorney General’s Office, which in May confirmed it had so far received five British requests for international cooperation on the Madeleine McCann case including one in January 2015, did not respond to emails today.

But insiders said they were expecting to receive a new request shortly.

The Scotland Yard inquiry is running separately to a Portuguese probe into Madeleine’s May 3 2007 disappearance.

The Portuguese investigation was reopened in May 2014 at the request of the country’s Policia Judiciaria police force - more than five years after their original probe had been shelved.

The reopening of the probe coincided with news a former employee at the Ocean Club holiday resort where Madeleine disappeared had been identified as a suspect.

Recovering heroin addict Euclides Monteiro, a convicted burglar, died in a tractor accident in 2009.

His widow Luisa Rodrigues was interviewed by Portuguese detectives but insisted he was an innocent man and has been fighting to get authorities to confirm they have now ruled him out as a suspect.

Scotland Yard, tasked with investigating Madeleine’s disappearance after Madeleine’s family made a personal plea to David Cameron in 2011, have come to focus on the theory she was killed during a bungled burglary.

John O’Connor, ex-head of the Met Police’s Flying Squad said yesterday as it was revealed the hunt for Madeleine has cost British taxpayers almost £11 million: “You can’t keep chasing shadows.

“If there are no firm leads, and by that I mean no substantial operational things like active surveillance on suspects, then I’d have thought they should be considering winding it down now.”

His comments echoed those made in March by Met Police Federation chairman John Tully.

He said at the time: “We no longer have the resources to conduct specialist inquiries all over the world which have nothing to do with London.

“It is surprising to see an inquiry like the McCann investigation ring-fenced.

“I’ve heard a lot of rumblings of discontent about it from lots of sources.”

A source close to the McCanns was quoted as saying: “Kate and Gerry are eternally grateful to the Metropolitan Police for making Operation Grange possible.

“They are pleased so many officers are still looking for Madeleine.”

In May, Portugal’s Attorney General’s Office revealed: “Since August 2012, the Public Prosecution Service of Portimao has received five British requests for international cooperation in criminal matters, the last of which has been received on January 2015.

“Three of these requests have been already executed and their pieces of execution were returned to the requesting authorities. The execution of two of them is still pending.

The Prosecutor General’s Office does not provide information on the content of the requests presented by the British authorities.”
http://www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/british-cops-say-madeleine-mccann-6370080?

Thanks, Brietta.

If at least some of that is accurate, it seems quite encouraging.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Lyall on September 02, 2015, 09:49:43 PM
How long has been a rent-a-gob then?

That's not fair I think. He's got every right to ask legitimate questions. It wasn't his decision to put them on the frontpage of The Sun.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Lyall on September 02, 2015, 09:53:51 PM
O Connor was also the man dragged into TV studios (paid?) to slag off the Pj early days...hmmm

He did also praise them on at least one occasion.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: mercury on September 02, 2015, 10:04:27 PM
Citeypoo?

they said there was no fund or time limit to the investigation, I can find the article if you believe I just make things up

 8**8:/:
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: mercury on September 02, 2015, 10:05:53 PM
He did also praise them on at least one occasion.

so a good chap at times, nice to know lol
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Lyall on September 02, 2015, 10:08:05 PM
so a good chap at times, nice to know lol

Not all ex-cop TV heads are the type who go traipsing around Welsh villages with the likes of Kay Burley 8)-)))
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Miss Taken Identity on September 02, 2015, 10:12:13 PM
Not all ex-cop TV heads are the type who go traipsing around Welsh villages with the likes of Kay Burley 8)-)))

Did I mis something here?  lyall? lol

Mercury I think he is a say it as he thinks kind of guy. we need people like him to challenge money wasters and idiots. Th Pj did make mistakes.  Assisted by team McCANN with there story telling skills or lack of as it turns out.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Carana on September 02, 2015, 10:12:53 PM
That's not fair I think. He's got every right to ask legitimate questions. It wasn't his decision to put them on the frontpage of The Sun.

I don't subscribe to The Sun, so I haven't seen it. His comments have been syndicated all over the place, so I can read those.

Yes, of course he has the right to ask legitimate questions.

My issue isn't so much with him... loads of ex-professionals become expert commentators, whether they are biased or not.

My current issue is why is this being regurgitated now? Has he actually said anything more than he'd said in the run up to the elections in March?
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: mercury on September 02, 2015, 10:13:00 PM
*&*%£

at my post being swiped. 

"rent agob" can describe Mitchell he was also paid!  that is the point I was making...but, anyway.  He is in a better position than most to challenge what is going on!  And good on im for that.

It is so annoyng when whole posts are "vanished" instead of being what they should be, just moderated. unless every word in it was libellous.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: mercury on September 02, 2015, 10:14:26 PM
Not all ex-cop TV heads are the type who go traipsing around Welsh villages with the likes of Kay Burley 8)-)))

Anyone traipsing around with her needs to get their badge removed......
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Anna on September 02, 2015, 10:17:20 PM
*&*%£

at my post being swiped.

"rent agob" can describe Mitchell he was also paid!  that is the point I was making...but, anyway.  He is in a better position than most to challenge what is going on!  And good on im for that.

What post was swiped?
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Carana on September 02, 2015, 10:18:37 PM
they said there was no fund or time limit to the investigation, I can find the article if you believe I just make things up

 8**8:/:

I've never said that I thought you made anything up.

http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=6587.msg268983#msg268983

It would seem that there are several assumptions flying around as to what is meant by "ring-fenced".
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Lyall on September 02, 2015, 10:21:26 PM
Did I mis something here?  lyall? lol

Mercury I think he is a say it as he thinks kind of guy. we need people like him to challenge money wasters and idiots. Th Pj did make mistakes.  Assisted by team McCANN with there story telling skills or lack of as it turns out.

There's another ex-cop - who I won't name - seen regularly on Sky News, who accompanied Burley while she behaved disgracefully during the April Jones searches.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Miss Taken Identity on September 02, 2015, 10:26:31 PM
There's another ex-cop - who I won't name - seen regularly on Sky News, who accompanied Burley while she behaved disgracefully during the April Jones searches.


Oh... no body tells me anything! but feel free to pm me with the news lol
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: mercury on September 02, 2015, 10:27:11 PM
I've never said that I thought you made anything up.

http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=6587.msg268983#msg268983

It would seem that there are several assumptions flying around as to what is meant by "ring-fenced".

Trust you Carana to split the infinitive when it's not even required.

We all know what Connor meant IE funds are not a problem. there is a Telegraph article that says money and time are no objects according to the Home Office...I can't be bothered to go look for it, but it exists, FACT...I will only look and copy and paste when a particularly intransigent poster says you're a liar


 8((()*/
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: stephen25000 on September 03, 2015, 07:33:13 AM

Madeleine McCann's parents ready to continue search if police end investigation into her disappearance


A spokesman said the couple accepted police could not continue to fund an investigation indefinitely and have set aside cash to continue the search themselves.
The parents of Madeleine McCann are preparing for the police probe into their daughter's disappearance to be shelved, their spokesman said today.

Kate and Gerry McCann continue to pump thousands of pounds into a special fund for use when the official investigation, codenamed Operation Grange and launched more than four years ago, finally ends.

Family spokesperson Clarence Mitchell said today: "They realise it cannot go on forever."

He added: "Kate and Gerry remain incredibly grateful to the Met Police for their continuing work and effort and are grateful to everyone who continues to make Operation Grange possible.

"The Government and police make the decision about funding, it is not Kate and Gerry's role."

He told how former GP Kate and heart doctor Gerry, both 37, of Rothley, Leics, had moved money from the publicly-backed Find Maddie Fund into a special account in anticipation of having to finance the hunt for their daughter themselves.

Mr Mitchell said: "In a common sense and practical move, they have kept some money back from the Find Madeleine Fund in case it is needed for an ongoing search."

A source close to the family said: "Kate and Gerry firmly believe Madeleine could still be alive and when the police investigation ends, they have vowed to continue looking for her.

"They don't know when this will be, there has been so suggestion yet, but they want to be ready and have set aside huge chunks of money for this reason."

Three-year-old Maddie was snatched during a family holiday in Portugal's Praia da Luz in May 2007. She would now be aged 12.

As Maddie's parents brace themselves for being told Operation Grange will end, the family source said: "Kate and Gerry know the investigation will come to an end at some point, especially with police budget cuts but they haven't been advised when."

A Home Office spokesperson said: "The Home Office remains committed to supporting the search for Madeleine McCann.

"Over the last four years we have given the Metropolitan Police the resources they say they need to investigate her disappearance, and we continue to do so."

Sources in Portugal today insisted there was no evidence to suggest Operation Grange was going to be shelved in the short or medium term.



http://www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/madeleine-mccanns-parents-ready-continue-6370581


Which makes me wonder have they already been told the till is about to close ?

Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Carana on September 03, 2015, 07:41:50 AM
The funding appears to be from a Home Office slush fund, which has nothing to do with London policing anyway. If patching up relations with PT is one of the broader objectives, it seems to be working...


A Scotland Yard spokesman said: 'The Metropolitan Police commenced Operation Grange at the request of the Home Office who fully fund it.

'As such, it does not impact on other operations in London.' 

(...)

Responding to grumbles about the cost of Scotland Yard's probe and fresh claims it should be wound down, a Portuguese source insisted: 'Nothing is going to be shelved.

'Co-operation right now between the British and the Portuguese police is at a moment of great synchronisation.'

Portugal's Attorney General's Office, which in May confirmed it had so far received five British requests for international cooperation on the Madeleine McCann case including one in January 2015, did not respond to emails yesterday.

But insiders said they were expecting to receive a new request shortly.

Read more: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3219114/Bill-Scotland-Yard-investigation-Madeleine-McCann-disappearance-hits-11MILLION-no-arrests-former-police-chief-calls-end.html#ixzz3keevi6Q3
Follow us: @MailOnline on Twitter | DailyMail on Facebook

Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: slartibartfast on September 03, 2015, 07:56:21 AM
Cynically and from a business perspective, having a number of staff being funded from an external source and possibly available for other work is desirable in order to ease pressure on budgets.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Carana on September 03, 2015, 08:44:50 AM
Cynically and from a business perspective, having a number of staff being funded from an external source and possibly available for other work is desirable in order to ease pressure on budgets.

Agreed, but some papers keep repeating the mantra that they are all working full-time exclusively on the case. I find that highly unlikely except possibly right at the beginning, then on an ad hoc basis according to skill sets, with a small core working full-time on it.

Some of them would otherwise have been made redundant, but I don't know whether the relative cost of that would have been more or less than simply keeping them on if they were nearing retirement anyway.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Brietta on September 03, 2015, 09:04:45 AM
Cynically and from a business perspective, having a number of staff being funded from an external source and possibly available for other work is desirable in order to ease pressure on budgets.

Sensible post.

I also think that the networking between the forces is invaluable.  I doubt if a couple of years ago the tone of the statement Carana has highlighted attributed to the Portuguese side would have expressed such positive sentiments.

It is like the hide the thimble game children used to play going from very cold > warmer > cooler > ... I think they may now be at hot or even very hot ... and I get the impression they do not want to stop at the eleventh hour.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: faithlilly on September 03, 2015, 10:28:30 AM
From today's Sun :

Today's Sun:


Maddie cops in 5-star hotels
EXCLUSIVE: £11m hunt waste

Maddie ... officers live it up in five-star hotels during investigation

COPS heading the hunt for Madeleine McCann stayed in five-star hotels with rooms costing up to £200 a night.

They included five luxury resorts where cheaper hotels were available nearer investigation scenes.

The officers were with Operation Grange, which The Sun revealed yesterday has cost £11million, without any arrests.

Last year they took 67 flights to Portugal, costing £16,000.

In July officers stayed at the £180 a night Ria Park as they quizzed suspects at Faro police station a 20-minute drive away.

There are two cheaper four-star hotels five minutes away.

Cops also stayed at the £200-a-night Hotel Dona Filipa near Ria Park. They are near some of Portugal’s best golf courses.

Scotland Yard said hotels were “booked by Met’s Travel Services in accordance with agreed Government rates which aim to ensure best value”.

The Sun Says

WHY are cops living in luxury as they hunt for Madeleine?

It is no wonder the bill has soared beyond £11million when they are blowing £200 a night on hotels.

The Government injected those millions to give police the best chance of finding out what happened to the girl.

Not to pay their bills at fancy golf resorts."

Seems SY have started to receive the verbal kicking from the media that Amaral endured all those long years ago. It does pose the question why ?



Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Montclair on September 03, 2015, 10:30:33 AM
Madeleine McCann's parents ready to continue search if police end investigation into her disappearance


A spokesman said the couple accepted police could not continue to fund an investigation indefinitely and have set aside cash to continue the search themselves.
The parents of Madeleine McCann are preparing for the police probe into their daughter's disappearance to be shelved, their spokesman said today.

Kate and Gerry McCann continue to pump thousands of pounds into a special fund for use when the official investigation, codenamed Operation Grange and launched more than four years ago, finally ends.

Family spokesperson Clarence Mitchell said today: "They realise it cannot go on forever."

He added: "Kate and Gerry remain incredibly grateful to the Met Police for their continuing work and effort and are grateful to everyone who continues to make Operation Grange possible.

"The Government and police make the decision about funding, it is not Kate and Gerry's role."

He told how former GP Kate and heart doctor Gerry, both 37, of Rothley, Leics, had moved money from the publicly-backed Find Maddie Fund into a special account in anticipation of having to finance the hunt for their daughter themselves.

Mr Mitchell said: "In a common sense and practical move, they have kept some money back from the Find Madeleine Fund in case it is needed for an ongoing search."

A source close to the family said: "Kate and Gerry firmly believe Madeleine could still be alive and when the police investigation ends, they have vowed to continue looking for her.

"They don't know when this will be, there has been so suggestion yet, but they want to be ready and have set aside huge chunks of money for this reason."

Three-year-old Maddie was snatched during a family holiday in Portugal's Praia da Luz in May 2007. She would now be aged 12.

As Maddie's parents brace themselves for being told Operation Grange will end, the family source said: "Kate and Gerry know the investigation will come to an end at some point, especially with police budget cuts but they haven't been advised when."

A Home Office spokesperson said: "The Home Office remains committed to supporting the search for Madeleine McCann.

"Over the last four years we have given the Metropolitan Police the resources they say they need to investigate her disappearance, and we continue to do so."

Sources in Portugal today insisted there was no evidence to suggest Operation Grange was going to be shelved in the short or medium term.



http://www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/madeleine-mccanns-parents-ready-continue-6370581


Which makes me wonder have they already been told the till is about to close ?

Wouldn't the McCanns love the investigation to be closed so that they could ask for more money for their search. I find it surprising that they aren't pleading for SY to keep the case open, they only say that they will continue searching themselves. No criticism of "hampering" the search. Didn't they accuse Ricardo Paiva of not following leads or tips? Now they don't seem to be at all upset at the possibility of Operation Grange closing.

You must ask yourselves who would most benefit from the case being closed. The perpetrator or perpetrators themselves, of course. I doubt that some petty burglar from the backwoods of Portugal would have the influence on the press to carry out this campaign. The only people I know who have the clout and money to get these stories out with the help of a PR man are a well known couple who holidayed in Portugal 8 years ago.

This is obviously a PR campaign in order to influence the public to try to close OG.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: faithlilly on September 03, 2015, 10:33:37 AM
Madeleine McCann's parents ready to continue search if police end investigation into her disappearance


A spokesman said the couple accepted police could not continue to fund an investigation indefinitely and have set aside cash to continue the search themselves.
The parents of Madeleine McCann are preparing for the police probe into their daughter's disappearance to be shelved, their spokesman said today.

Kate and Gerry McCann continue to pump thousands of pounds into a special fund for use when the official investigation, codenamed Operation Grange and launched more than four years ago, finally ends.

Family spokesperson Clarence Mitchell said today: "They realise it cannot go on forever."

He added: "Kate and Gerry remain incredibly grateful to the Met Police for their continuing work and effort and are grateful to everyone who continues to make Operation Grange possible.

"The Government and police make the decision about funding, it is not Kate and Gerry's role."

He told how former GP Kate and heart doctor Gerry, both 37, of Rothley, Leics, had moved money from the publicly-backed Find Maddie Fund into a special account in anticipation of having to finance the hunt for their daughter themselves.

Mr Mitchell said: "In a common sense and practical move, they have kept some money back from the Find Madeleine Fund in case it is needed for an ongoing search."

A source close to the family said: "Kate and Gerry firmly believe Madeleine could still be alive and when the police investigation ends, they have vowed to continue looking for her.

"They don't know when this will be, there has been so suggestion yet, but they want to be ready and have set aside huge chunks of money for this reason."

Three-year-old Maddie was snatched during a family holiday in Portugal's Praia da Luz in May 2007. She would now be aged 12.

As Maddie's parents brace themselves for being told Operation Grange will end, the family source said: "Kate and Gerry know the investigation will come to an end at some point, especially with police budget cuts but they haven't been advised when."

A Home Office spokesperson said: "The Home Office remains committed to supporting the search for Madeleine McCann.

"Over the last four years we have given the Metropolitan Police the resources they say they need to investigate her disappearance, and we continue to do so."

Sources in Portugal today insisted there was no evidence to suggest Operation Grange was going to be shelved in the short or medium term.



http://www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/madeleine-mccanns-parents-ready-continue-6370581


Which makes me wonder have they already been told the till is about to close ?

Thanks Stephen. Very strange article which raises more questions than it answers not lest of which is why move money from a fund set up to finance the search for Madeleine into a bank account set up to.......finance the search for Madeleine. Seems an utterly bizarre thing to do.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Alice Purjorick on September 03, 2015, 10:34:16 AM
Madeleine McCann's parents ready to continue search if police end investigation into her disappearance


A spokesman said the couple accepted police could not continue to fund an investigation indefinitely and have set aside cash to continue the search themselves.
The parents of Madeleine McCann are preparing for the police probe into their daughter's disappearance to be shelved, their spokesman said today.

Kate and Gerry McCann continue to pump thousands of pounds into a special fund for use when the official investigation, codenamed Operation Grange and launched more than four years ago, finally ends.

Family spokesperson Clarence Mitchell said today: "They realise it cannot go on forever."

He added: "Kate and Gerry remain incredibly grateful to the Met Police for their continuing work and effort and are grateful to everyone who continues to make Operation Grange possible.

"The Government and police make the decision about funding, it is not Kate and Gerry's role."

He told how former GP Kate and heart doctor Gerry, both 37, of Rothley, Leics, had moved money from the publicly-backed Find Maddie Fund into a special account in anticipation of having to finance the hunt for their daughter themselves.

Mr Mitchell said: "In a common sense and practical move, they have kept some money back from the Find Madeleine Fund in case it is needed for an ongoing search."

A source close to the family said: "Kate and Gerry firmly believe Madeleine could still be alive and when the police investigation ends, they have vowed to continue looking for her.

"They don't know when this will be, there has been so suggestion yet, but they want to be ready and have set aside huge chunks of money for this reason."

Three-year-old Maddie was snatched during a family holiday in Portugal's Praia da Luz in May 2007. She would now be aged 12.

As Maddie's parents brace themselves for being told Operation Grange will end, the family source said: "Kate and Gerry know the investigation will come to an end at some point, especially with police budget cuts but they haven't been advised when."

A Home Office spokesperson said: "The Home Office remains committed to supporting the search for Madeleine McCann.

"Over the last four years we have given the Metropolitan Police the resources they say they need to investigate her disappearance, and we continue to do so."

Sources in Portugal today insisted there was no evidence to suggest Operation Grange was going to be shelved in the short or medium term.



http://www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/madeleine-mccanns-parents-ready-continue-6370581


Which makes me wonder have they already been told the till is about to close ?

Odd to say the least.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Mr Gray on September 03, 2015, 10:35:26 AM
Wouldn't the McCanns love the investigation to be closed so that they could ask for more money for their search. I find it surprising that they aren't pleading for SY to keep the case open, they only say that they will continue searching themselves. No criticism of "hampering" the search. Didn't they accuse Ricardo Paiva of not following leads or tips? Now they don't seem to be at all upset at the possibility of Operation Grange closing.

You must ask yourselves who would most benefit from the case being closed. The perpetrator or perpetrators themselves, of course. I doubt that some petty burglar from the backwoods of Portugal would have the influence on the press to carry out this campaign. The only people I know who have the clout and money to get these stories out with the help of a PR man are a well known couple who holidayed in Portugal 8 years ago.

This is obviously a PR campaign in order to influence the public to try to close OG.

so the mccanns campaigned to get the case opened...now they are trying to get it closed...makes no sense
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Alice Purjorick on September 03, 2015, 10:36:13 AM
Thanks Stephen. Very strange article which raises more questions than it answers not lest of which is why move money from a fund set up to finance the search for Madeleine into a bank account set up to.......finance the search for Madeleine. Seems an utterly bizarre thing to do.

Our posts crossed Faith.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Mr Gray on September 03, 2015, 10:38:05 AM
Odd to say the least.

all depends on how accurate the reports of what the McCanns  aresaid and the context in which they were made..
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Carana on September 03, 2015, 10:39:42 AM
From today's Sun :

Today's Sun:


Maddie cops in 5-star hotels
EXCLUSIVE: £11m hunt waste

Maddie ... officers live it up in five-star hotels during investigation

COPS heading the hunt for Madeleine McCann stayed in five-star hotels with rooms costing up to £200 a night.

They included five luxury resorts where cheaper hotels were available nearer investigation scenes.

The officers were with Operation Grange, which The Sun revealed yesterday has cost £11million, without any arrests.

Last year they took 67 flights to Portugal, costing £16,000.

In July officers stayed at the £180 a night Ria Park as they quizzed suspects at Faro police station a 20-minute drive away.

There are two cheaper four-star hotels five minutes away.

Cops also stayed at the £200-a-night Hotel Dona Filipa near Ria Park. They are near some of Portugal’s best golf courses.

Scotland Yard said hotels were “booked by Met’s Travel Services in accordance with agreed Government rates which aim to ensure best value”.

The Sun Says

WHY are cops living in luxury as they hunt for Madeleine?

It is no wonder the bill has soared beyond £11million when they are blowing £200 a night on hotels.

The Government injected those millions to give police the best chance of finding out what happened to the girl.

Not to pay their bills at fancy golf resorts."

Seems SY have started to receive the verbal kicking from the media that Amaral endured all those long years ago. It does pose the question why ?

How did The Sun come up with those hotel prices? Is it the result of an FOI as to the negotiated price, or did someone just check the online booking rate?

Scotland Yard said hotels were “booked by Met’s Travel Services in accordance with agreed Government rates which aim to ensure best value”.


Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Montclair on September 03, 2015, 10:54:54 AM
so the mccanns campaigned to get the case opened...now they are trying to get it closed...makes no sense

The McCanns never campaigned to get the case opened. They only wanted a review, which meant they would get access to the evidence the police had. They never expected a full blown investigation.

They are obviously worried about OG getting wind of this special account with money taken from the fund.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: faithlilly on September 03, 2015, 11:06:48 AM
Our posts crossed Faith.

Great minds and all that Alice !
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: faithlilly on September 03, 2015, 11:11:00 AM
How did The Sun come up with those hotel prices? Is it the result of an FOI as to the negotiated price, or did someone just check the online booking rate?

Scotland Yard said hotels were “booked by Met’s Travel Services in accordance with agreed Government rates which aim to ensure best value”.

The price is not important Carana the fact that the Met are being criticised just as the PJ in their turn were, is. And we all know when that started.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: G-Unit on September 03, 2015, 11:17:28 AM
This has just been discussed on 'The Wright Stuff'. Many comments on the programme's FB page, most saying the investigation should end. Many reasons given, from 'the parents done it' to 'not fair to throw all this money at one missing child'.
https://www.facebook.com/officialwrightstuff?fref=ts
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: stephen25000 on September 03, 2015, 11:24:37 AM
Thanks Stephen. Very strange article which raises more questions than it answers not lest of which is why move money from a fund set up to finance the search for Madeleine into a bank account set up to.......finance the search for Madeleine. Seems an utterly bizarre thing to do.

Indeed.

One of the most suspicious things to emerge was how quickly the fund was set up.

There should have been other priorities.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Alice Purjorick on September 03, 2015, 11:47:07 AM
all depends on how accurate the reports of what the McCanns  aresaid and the context in which they were made..

You don't find it odd that the ages quoted are incorrect ?
According the article the McCanns said nothing but a spokesperson did.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Mr Gray on September 03, 2015, 11:50:07 AM
This has just been discussed on 'The Wright Stuff'. Many comments on the programme's FB page, most saying the investigation should end. Many reasons given, from 'the parents done it' to 'not fair to throw all this money at one missing child'.
https://www.facebook.com/officialwrightstuff?fref=ts

are they similar to the sort of people who watch Jeremy Kyle....
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Carana on September 03, 2015, 11:50:47 AM
This has just been discussed on 'The Wright Stuff'. Many comments on the programme's FB page, most saying the investigation should end. Many reasons given, from 'the parents done it' to 'not fair to throw all this money at one missing child'.
https://www.facebook.com/officialwrightstuff?fref=ts

The Wright Stuff
3 hrs ·

POLICE: END HUNT FOR MADELEINE McCANN?
And then I want to know if you're with the former top cop who says it's time to call off the the eight year hunt for missing tot Madeleine McCann?The Met's spent £11m on an intensive four year global search ordered by David Cameron - £11m is 4,500 times more than the police typically spend searching for missing children. But if we turn off the money supply now won't we also be turning off any hope of finding her?


£11m is 4,500 times more than the police typically spend searching for missing children


What on earth does that mean?

Obviously, if the majority of missing children are found within 48 hours, the cost will be less. Some will be reported as missing by a worried carer, but turn up just after the call, although technically the incident would presumably have been logged.


The April Jones investigation and search apparently cost over £8.5 million. Who begrudges that?

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/uknews/crime/10089320/April-Jones-murder-trial-Mark-Bridger-found-guilty.html
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Montclair on September 03, 2015, 11:54:15 AM
The price is not important Carana the fact that the Met are being criticised just as the PJ in their turn were, is. And we all know when that started.

All déjà vu! It's like reliving 2007 when the McCanns realised that the PJ had their sights on them.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: stephen25000 on September 03, 2015, 11:54:44 AM
are they similar to the sort of people who watch Jeremy Kyle....

Hardly original.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Mr Gray on September 03, 2015, 11:56:59 AM
Hardly original.

I should know...I've actually appeared on the Wright Stuff
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: stephen25000 on September 03, 2015, 11:58:17 AM
The Wright Stuff
3 hrs ·

POLICE: END HUNT FOR MADELEINE McCANN?
And then I want to know if you're with the former top cop who says it's time to call off the the eight year hunt for missing tot Madeleine McCann?The Met's spent £11m on an intensive four year global search ordered by David Cameron - £11m is 4,500 times more than the police typically spend searching for missing children. But if we turn off the money supply now won't we also be turning off any hope of finding her?


£11m is 4,500 times more than the police typically spend searching for missing children


What on earth does that mean?

Obviously, if the majority of missing children are found within 48 hours, the cost will be less. Some will be reported as missing by a worried carer, but turn up just after the call, although technically the incident would presumably have been logged.


The April Jones investigation and search apparently cost over £8.5 million. Who begrudges that?

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/uknews/crime/10089320/April-Jones-murder-trial-Mark-Bridger-found-guilty.html

Has anyone found data for exactly how many missing children or for that matter people in the UK, and for how long they have been missing for ?
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: stephen25000 on September 03, 2015, 11:59:29 AM
I should know...I've actually appeared on the Wright Stuff

You can of course cite evidence for that ?

Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: faithlilly on September 03, 2015, 12:01:15 PM
You don't find it odd that the ages quoted are incorrect ?
According the article the McCanns said nothing but a spokesperson did.

I think this is the most significant section :

"
Family spokesperson Clarence Mitchell said today: "They realise it cannot go on forever."

He added: "Kate and Gerry remain incredibly grateful to the Met Police for their continuing work and effort and are grateful to everyone who continues to make Operation Grange possible.

"The Government and police make the decision about funding, it is not Kate and Gerry's role."

He told how former GP Kate and heart doctor Gerry, both 37, of Rothley, Leics, had moved money from the publicly-backed Find Maddie Fund into a special account in anticipation of having to finance the hunt for their daughter themselves.

Mr Mitchell said: "In a common sense and practical move, they have kept some money back from the Find Madeleine Fund in case it is needed for an ongoing search."

A source close to the family said: "Kate and Gerry firmly believe Madeleine could still be alive and when the police investigation ends, they have vowed to continue looking for her.

"They don't know when this will be, there has been so suggestion yet, but they want to be ready and have set aside huge chunks of money for this reason."

Mitchell could have chosen just to express the McCann's disappointment at the potential closing of the investigation or indeed to simply say that the Fund would continue to finance the search once the investigation was stopped but he didn't. He chose to be quoted as saying that Kate and Gerry were moving large wedges of cash from the Fund to another bank account the details of which are obscure to say the least. Is it a private account, what is it's aims etc, we simply don't know.

Is it possible that the recent press reports around the cost of the investigation is simply to prepare for the real story, that large amounts of money are being transferred from the Fund ? Clarence Mitchell could have said nothing, he chose not to and I for one find that highly significant.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: G-Unit on September 03, 2015, 12:01:42 PM
Indeed.

One of the most suspicious things to emerge was how quickly the fund was set up.

There should have been other priorities.

Indeed! The priority seemed to be sorting out long term goals.

The speed with which the fund was set up and the refusal to take a little more time and make it a charitable fund.
The decision to set up a website for further donations and sale.
The decision by John McCann to give up his job or take a sabbatical or indefinite leave to manage the fund. Whatever, who paid him or had he sufficient savings to live without working.
The setting up of the ward of court application and requesting the disclosure order to enable access to evidence held by the police.

All done within a few weeks, when the child could have been found at any moment.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Mr Gray on September 03, 2015, 12:02:50 PM
You can of course cite evidence for that ?

yes of course..I've got  alovely photo of myself and Mathewin the MTV studios...that's where it was filmed at the studios in Camden about 13 years ago
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: G-Unit on September 03, 2015, 12:03:34 PM
I should know...I've actually appeared on the Wright Stuff

In which case you know what type of people it's audience are made up of, I assume.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Carana on September 03, 2015, 12:06:21 PM
Has anyone found data for exactly how many missing children or for that matter people in the UK, and for how long they have been missing for ?

 One recorded every two minutes - missing persons figures released

3 November 2014

Someone is recorded as missing in the UK every two minutes, according to new figures released by the National Crime Agency’s UK Missing Persons Bureau.

The statistics, which relate to all incidents recorded by police in England, Wales and Scotland for the year 2012-13, show that although the overall number fell slightly compared to the previous years, forces still dealt with 306,000 incidents – an average of 838 a day.

Analysis of the figures shows that most cases are likely to be resolved quickly, with 89 percent of those recorded as missing being found within 48 hours.

Additionally, the vast majority end with no harm coming to the individual, with almost 97 percent likely to be found safe and well.

But almost two thirds of cases (64 percent) involved children and young people, with the 15-17 age group being reported missing most frequently.

http://www.nationalcrimeagency.gov.uk/news/475-one-recorded-every-two-minutes-missing-persons-figures-released
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Mr Gray on September 03, 2015, 12:06:42 PM
In which case you know what type of people it's audience are made up of, I assume.

yes I do...it was a little more upmarket then
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Carana on September 03, 2015, 12:15:35 PM
Indeed! The priority seemed to be sorting out long term goals.

The speed with which the fund was set up and the refusal to take a little more time and make it a charitable fund.
The decision to set up a website for further donations and sale.
The decision by John McCann to give up his job or take a sabbatical or indefinite leave to manage the fund. Whatever, who paid him or had he sufficient savings to live without working.
The setting up of the ward of court application and requesting the disclosure order to enable access to evidence held by the police.

All done within a few weeks, when the child could have been found at any moment.

One point at a time... Kind people started sending in money, as they often do, when moved by a tragedy. That had to be handled somehow.

It could not have been set up as a charity, because a charity can't be for the purposes of finding a single child. And I doubt that a charity set up in the name of all children who disappeared from PdL on 3 May 2007 normally resident in Rothley, UK, would have qualified, either.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: stephen25000 on September 03, 2015, 12:21:58 PM
yes of course..I've got  alovely photo of myself and Mathewin the MTV studios...that's where it was filmed at the studios in Camden about 13 years ago

That's not evidence dave.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: faithlilly on September 03, 2015, 12:22:19 PM
One point at a time... Kind people started sending in money, as they often do, when moved by a tragedy. That had to be handled somehow.

It could not have been set up as a charity, because a charity can't be for the purposes of finding a single child. And I doubt that a charity set up in the name of all children who disappeared from PdL on 3 May 2007 normally resident in Rothley, UK, would have qualified, either.

So why the need for another account now ?
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Carana on September 03, 2015, 12:54:30 PM
So why the need for another account now ?

I'm lost.

A Mirror article appears to have done a cut and paste job, including listing Kate and Gerry as being 37.

There is no context to what Clarence or any "source" is actually talking about, nor even whether those comments are recent or date back to the last time there were rumblings about whether Op Grange was going to continue or not.

There's a not-for-profit company, which still has assets.

Once the Fund directors were sure that Op Grange was going ahead, some of the funds could have been transferred to an interest-earning account, with direct access blocked for x time.

What's odd about that?



Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Alfred R Jones on September 03, 2015, 01:00:44 PM
Clarence (who is obviously monitoring the online chatter about the McCanns) obviously felt that things on the Interweb had gone a bit flat recently and decide to throw the "sceptics" a bone to chew over for the next few weeks.  @)(++(*
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Montclair on September 03, 2015, 01:03:06 PM
One point at a time... Kind people started sending in money, as they often do, when moved by a tragedy. That had to be handled somehow.

It could not have been set up as a charity, because a charity can't be for the purposes of finding a single child. And I doubt that a charity set up in the name of all children who disappeared from PdL on 3 May 2007 normally resident in Rothley, UK, would have qualified, either.

I don't understand this thing about people spontaneously sending money to the McCanns. Has there ever been another case where the public just sent money to the parents of a missing child without being asked to?
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: stephen25000 on September 03, 2015, 01:05:45 PM
Clarence (who is obviously monitoring the online chatter about the McCanns) obviously felt that things on the Interweb had gone a bit flat recently and decide to throw the "sceptics" a bone to chew over for the next few weeks.  @)(++(*

You do have a vivid imagination alfred, if nothing else. 8)--))
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: faithlilly on September 03, 2015, 01:06:15 PM
I'm lost.

A Mirror article appears to have done a cut and paste job, including listing Kate and Gerry as being 37.

There is no context to what Clarence or any "source" is actually talking about, nor even whether those comments are recent or date back to the last time there were rumblings about whether Op Grange was going to continue or not.

There's a not-for-profit company, which still has assets.

Once the Fund directors were sure that Op Grange was going ahead, some of the funds could have been transferred to an interest-earning account, with direct access blocked for x time.

What's odd about that?

So perhaps you'd point out in the accounts where there are details of this transfer ?
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: faithlilly on September 03, 2015, 01:06:52 PM
Clarence (who is obviously monitoring the online chatter about the McCanns) obviously felt that things on the Interweb had gone a bit flat recently and decide to throw the "sceptics" a bone to chew over for the next few weeks.  @)(++(*

Or a preemptive strike ?
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: G-Unit on September 03, 2015, 01:07:49 PM
One point at a time... Kind people started sending in money, as they often do, when moved by a tragedy. That had to be handled somehow.

It could not have been set up as a charity, because a charity can't be for the purposes of finding a single child. And I doubt that a charity set up in the name of all children who disappeared from PdL on 3 May 2007 normally resident in Rothley, UK, would have qualified, either.

I think the reason for the Fund not being a charity is a little more complex than you think. It could have been a charity and the Charity Commission were working with BWB to iron out any problems when BWB were told to cease negotiations with the Charity Commission and go for the 'off the shelf' company option. A short wait and a Charity Fund could have been a possibility.

Impatience seems to have been a factor. BWB were engaged on the afternoon of 14th May. At 9.39pm that evening they sent draft documents to the Commision. The Commission promised to look at the draft and suggest some changes during a phone conversation during the morning of the 15th, but at 1.10pm the same day BWB e-mailed to say their clients had decided to have a limited company instead. The Commission had revised the documents and sent them anyway at 1,28pm, but the decision had been taken.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Alice Purjorick on September 03, 2015, 01:23:10 PM
I'm lost.

A Mirror article appears to have done a cut and paste job, including listing Kate and Gerry as being 37.

There is no context to what Clarence or any "source" is actually talking about, nor even whether those comments are recent or date back to the last time there were rumblings about whether Op Grange was going to continue or not.

There's a not-for-profit company, which still has assets.

Once the Fund directors were sure that Op Grange was going ahead, some of the funds could have been transferred to an interest-earning account, with direct access blocked for x time.

What's odd about that?

It would show in the company accounts filed at Companies House.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Alfred R Jones on September 03, 2015, 01:27:48 PM
Or a preemptive strike ?
Pre-empting what exactly?
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Eleanor on September 03, 2015, 01:27:55 PM
I don't understand this thing about people spontaneously sending money to the McCanns. Has there ever been another case where the public just sent money to the parents of a missing child without being asked to?

It is a fact that it happened.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Alfred R Jones on September 03, 2015, 01:38:00 PM
I don't understand this thing about people spontaneously sending money to the McCanns. Has there ever been another case where the public just sent money to the parents of a missing child without being asked to?
Yes, it happened in the April Jones case.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: G-Unit on September 03, 2015, 01:50:07 PM
I'm lost.

A Mirror article appears to have done a cut and paste job, including listing Kate and Gerry as being 37.

There is no context to what Clarence or any "source" is actually talking about, nor even whether those comments are recent or date back to the last time there were rumblings about whether Op Grange was going to continue or not.

There's a not-for-profit company, which still has assets.

Once the Fund directors were sure that Op Grange was going ahead, some of the funds could have been transferred to an interest-earning account, with direct access blocked for x time.

What's odd about that?

There would be nothing odd about opening a high interest account in the name of the Fund to ensure the money 'works' for the fund. This is odd, if true;

Mr Mitchell said: "In a common sense and practical move, they have kept some money back from the Find Madeleine Fund in case it is needed for an ongoing search."

As the primary aim of the Fund is to search, what is sensible and practical about holding money back from the Fund?
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: faithlilly on September 03, 2015, 01:53:42 PM
Pre-empting what exactly?

Who knows ! We may learn in the fullness of time
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Carana on September 03, 2015, 02:08:48 PM
I think the reason for the Fund not being a charity is a little more complex than you think. It could have been a charity and the Charity Commission were working with BWB to iron out any problems when BWB were told to cease negotiations with the Charity Commission and go for the 'off the shelf' company option. A short wait and a Charity Fund could have been a possibility.

Impatience seems to have been a factor. BWB were engaged on the afternoon of 14th May. At 9.39pm that evening they sent draft documents to the Commision. The Commission promised to look at the draft and suggest some changes during a phone conversation during the morning of the 15th, but at 1.10pm the same day BWB e-mailed to say their clients had decided to have a limited company instead. The Commission had revised the documents and sent them anyway at 1,28pm, but the decision had been taken.

In view of the Charity Commission's rules, how could it have been set up as a charity?
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Carana on September 03, 2015, 02:10:10 PM
It would show in the company accounts filed at Companies House.

Of which year? The McCanns are still 37...
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: faithlilly on September 03, 2015, 02:12:06 PM
In view of the Charity Commission's rules, how could it have been set up as a charity?

the Charity Commission certainly thought that with a little negotiation it could.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: G-Unit on September 03, 2015, 02:17:13 PM
In view of the Charity Commission's rules, how could it have been set up as a charity?

There is a 'public benefit' requirement for charities, which is presumably what the negotiations would have been about.
As the Charities Commission was prepared to discuss the problem I assume a solution was possible.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Alice Purjorick on September 03, 2015, 02:26:04 PM
Of which year? The McCanns are still 37...

It appears not to show up in any of the accounts thus far filed.
The comments attributed to Mitchell are rather curious imo.
If the money were put in a high interest account and remained the property of "The Company" one would expect to see a large chunk of income from investments showing up but it appears not to. The interest earned showing in the accounts is less than one would receive on 20 grand in The Halifax! If it were given to someone else it would also show in the accounts.
The only thing one knows for sure is that whatever is going on the supporters will say it's normal and the sceptics will say it isn't  8(0(*
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Carana on September 03, 2015, 02:37:58 PM
There is a 'public benefit' requirement for charities, which is presumably what the negotiations would have been about.
As the Charities Commission was prepared to discuss the problem I assume a solution was possible.

What type of solution?

if they'd wanted to start an entity to benefit a category of people, of whom Madeleine would hopefully have been one, then it might have been feasible. Some people, whose children have been murdered, have started charities in their chld's name to keep their names alive in some way. The Charities Commission wasn't to know exactly what they had in mind at the start and were no doubt trying to be of help.

They were in discussions as to what they wanted and what was possible under the regulations. They wanted the money (donated to them) to help find Madeleine, and hopefully bring whoever took her to justice.


Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Carana on September 03, 2015, 02:43:05 PM
It appears not to show up in any of the accounts thus far filed.
The comments attributed to Mitchell are rather curious imo.
If the money were put in a high interest account and remained the property of "The Company" one would expect to see a large chunk of income from investments showing up but it appears not to. The interest earned showing in the accounts is less than one would receive on 20 grand in The Halifax! If it were given to someone else it would also show in the accounts.
The only thing one knows for sure is that whatever is going on the supporters will say it's normal and the sceptics will say it isn't  8(0(*

LOL

I'm sceptical of the tabloid bandwaggon, and simply don't have enough information to make an informed opinion one way or another.

"Keeping money back" appears to have been interpreted in various ways (including starting a new fund). It may simply just an amount that's not intended for current ordinary expenditure (mailing, part-time support of whatever type).
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Eleanor on September 03, 2015, 02:47:30 PM
It appears not to show up in any of the accounts thus far filed.
The comments attributed to Mitchell are rather curious imo.
If the money were put in a high interest account and remained the property of "The Company" one would expect to see a large chunk of income from investments showing up but it appears not to. The interest earned showing in the accounts is less than one would receive on 20 grand in The Halifax! If it were given to someone else it would also show in the accounts.
The only thing one knows for sure is that whatever is going on the supporters will say it's normal and the sceptics will say it isn't  8(0(*

What a sensible observation.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Carana on September 03, 2015, 02:54:57 PM
I have a feeling that I've seen a comment by Clarence or someone else before... quite some time ago, and can't quite place it in order to search for it.

What question was he/other source actually asked that led to that comment?
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Alice Purjorick on September 03, 2015, 03:01:03 PM
LOL

I'm sceptical of the tabloid bandwaggon, and simply don't have enough information to make an informed opinion one way or another.

"Keeping money back" appears to have been interpreted in various ways (including starting a new fund). It may simply just an amount that's not intended for current ordinary expenditure (mailing, part-time support of whatever type).

Well not wishing to p**s on anyone's bonfire or kill off the thread there is the "Restricted Funds" column that shows up in the accounts! it could be in there.
But then according to The Mirror, Mitchell seems to have said monies were being transferred elsewhere rather than just "kept back".
Were there transparency we would know without having to guess, what?  8(0(*
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Eleanor on September 03, 2015, 03:08:23 PM

Are we supposed to assume that The McCanns are using this money to live the high life?  Does anyone think that this true?
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Carana on September 03, 2015, 03:33:58 PM
Well not wishing to p**s on anyone's bonfire or kill off the thread there is the "Restricted Funds" column that shows up in the accounts! it could be in there.
But then according to The Mirror, Mitchell seems to have said monies were being transferred elsewhere rather than just "kept back".
Were there transparency we would know without having to guess, what?  8(0(*

The direct quotes (of unsubstantiated dating) from Clarence and some family "source" in bold. In normal font is not.

Kate and Gerry McCann continue to pump thousands of pounds into a special fund for use when the official investigation, codenamed Operation Grange and launched more than four years ago, finally ends.

Family spokesperson Clarence Mitchell said today: "They realise it cannot go on forever."

He added: "Kate and Gerry remain incredibly grateful to the Met Police for their continuing work and effort and are grateful to everyone who continues to make Operation Grange possible.

"The Government and police make the decision about funding, it is not Kate and Gerry's role."


He told how former GP Kate and heart doctor Gerry, both 37, of Rothley, Leics, had moved money from the publicly-backed Find Maddie Fund into a special account in anticipation of having to finance the hunt for their daughter themselves.

Mr Mitchell said: "In a common sense and practical move, they have kept some money back from the Find Madeleine Fund in case it is needed for an ongoing search."

A source close to the family said: "Kate and Gerry firmly believe Madeleine could still be alive and when the police investigation ends, they have vowed to continue looking for her.

"They don't know when this will be, there has been so suggestion yet, but they want to be ready and have set aside huge chunks of money for this reason."



Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Carana on September 03, 2015, 03:37:04 PM
Which leaves these two statements by the Mirror, source unverifiable.

Kate and Gerry McCann continue to pump thousands of pounds into a special fund for use when the official investigation, codenamed Operation Grange and launched more than four years ago, finally ends.

(...)

He told how former GP Kate and heart doctor Gerry, both 37, of Rothley, Leics, had moved money from the publicly-backed Find Maddie Fund into a special account in anticipation of having to finance the hunt for their daughter themselves.


Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Alice Purjorick on September 03, 2015, 03:56:30 PM
Which leaves these two statements by the Mirror, source unverifiable.

Kate and Gerry McCann continue to pump thousands of pounds into a special fund for use when the official investigation, codenamed Operation Grange and launched more than four years ago, finally ends.

(...)

He told how former GP Kate and heart doctor Gerry, both 37, of Rothley, Leics, had moved money from the publicly-backed Find Maddie Fund into a special account in anticipation of having to finance the hunt for their daughter themselves.


The first is attributed to an unspecified spokesperson. The second by grammar is attributable to Mr Mitchell assuming there is not a vast tract missing.
Those caveats notwithstanding he appears to have said "money is being held back from the fund" which can be construed in several different ways any of which could be correct.
If the monies went into "The Fund" they will be properly accounted for. Whether we can see it is a different matter. If the monies are not in "The Fund" who knows?
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Carana on September 03, 2015, 04:20:07 PM
The first is attributed to an unspecified spokesperson. The second by grammar is attributable to Mr Mitchell assuming there is not a vast tract missing.
Those caveats notwithstanding he appears to have said "money is being held back from the fund" which can be construed in several different ways any of which could be correct.
If the monies went into "The Fund" they will be properly accounted for. Whether we can see it is a different matter. If the monies are not in "The Fund" who knows?

Without context, it's impossible to know.

I don't get the issue.

Ensuring that money will be available to continue their own search, if Op Grange were to shut up shop, is the point, isn't it?

Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: faithlilly on September 03, 2015, 04:41:14 PM
Without context, it's impossible to know.

I don't get the issue.

Ensuring that money will be available to continue their own search, if Op Grange were to shut up shop, is the point, isn't it?

The issue is why isn't the money raised by all means, public donations, libel settlements, Kate's book etc, and which were all raised to finance the search, in the same bank accountant instead of being moved into another account ?
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Alfred R Jones on September 03, 2015, 04:47:27 PM
The issue is why isn't the money raised by all means, public donations, libel settlements, Kate's book etc, and which were all raised to finance the search, in the same bank accountant instead of being moved into another account ?
Why is this an issue for you Faithlilly?  You seem very exercised by today's news.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: slartibartfast on September 03, 2015, 04:47:35 PM
Without context, it's impossible to know.

I don't get the issue.

Ensuring that money will be available to continue their own search, if Op Grange were to shut up shop, is the point, isn't it?

But why wouldn't it be available in the fund?
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Brietta on September 03, 2015, 04:49:56 PM
Without context, it's impossible to know.

I don't get the issue.

Ensuring that money will be available to continue their own search, if Op Grange were to shut up shop, is the point, isn't it?

I remember some discussion about this some time ago when it was sensibly pointed out that in the event of Madeleine's recovery who knows what rehabilitation will be required ... and on the other hand if the investigation were to be called off without resolution, money would be required to continue the search on a much reduced basis.

Whatever ... the money being discussed is earmarked for the benefit of a little girl who is missing.

Extraordinary therefore that there is so much bloody mindedness being expressed on the basis of a tabloid article when not a single poster has mentioned the GoFundMe appeal on behalf of Mr Amaral which has switched from Ms Baulch to Portimao PT.
If that isn't rank hypocrisy I've no idea what is.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Carana on September 03, 2015, 04:54:43 PM
But why wouldn't it be available in the fund?

What's "it"? And who says that whatever "it" is, isn't in the Fund, on what basis?

LOL I've no idea what the issue is...

Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: slartibartfast on September 03, 2015, 04:58:21 PM
What's "it"? And who says that whatever "it" is, isn't in the Fund, on what basis?

LOL I've no idea what the isse is...

It is money as your second sentence assumes. Until what is meant is clarified we don't really understand what the issue is.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Carana on September 03, 2015, 05:06:09 PM
But why wouldn't it be available in the fund?

LOL

What's it?

Money "kept back"?

That could mean anything: retained, set aside, not for everyday expenditure,...


Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Alice Purjorick on September 03, 2015, 05:24:21 PM
This thread must have set a new record.
11 pages and a bit before we get Amaral; GoFundMe and Leanne Baulch. We only need Eddie and Martin Grime for a nap hand.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Carana on September 03, 2015, 05:31:58 PM
This thread must have set a new record.
11 pages and a bit before we get Amaral; GoFundMe and Leanne Baulch. We only need Eddie and Martin Grime for a nap hand.

Count yourself lucky. At least we haven't had interminable arguments about chemistry yet.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: pathfinder73 on September 03, 2015, 05:34:19 PM
Which leaves these two statements by the Mirror, source unverifiable.

Kate and Gerry McCann continue to pump thousands of pounds into a special fund for use when the official investigation, codenamed Operation Grange and launched more than four years ago, finally ends.

(...)

He told how former GP Kate and heart doctor Gerry, both 37, of Rothley, Leics, had moved money from the publicly-backed Find Maddie Fund into a special account in anticipation of having to finance the hunt for their daughter themselves.


The age should be 47. They were older than 37 when their daughter disappeared.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Alfred R Jones on September 03, 2015, 05:48:15 PM
I exect the McCanns are trying to fool everyone about how old they really are now.  Or maybe the reason for the staged abduction was to con money out of the public to develop a new drug exclusively for their use to reverse ageing and that is why they are now ten years younger than they should be.  Yes, I'm sure that's a plausible explanation.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Carana on September 03, 2015, 05:50:10 PM
The age should be 47. They were older than 37 when their daughter disappeared.

They were born in '68.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: slartibartfast on September 03, 2015, 05:51:32 PM
LOL

What's it?

Money "kept back"?

That could mean anything: retained, set aside, not for everyday expenditure,...

See previous post.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Alice Purjorick on September 03, 2015, 05:59:44 PM
They were born in '68.

The year of the Tet Offensive, the Mexico Olympics and Herman van Springel losing the yellow jersey on the last day of the tour; boy was he desolate.
Sorry! off topic.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Carana on September 03, 2015, 06:44:56 PM
The year of the Tet Offensive, the Mexico Olympics and Herman van Springel losing the yellow jersey on the last day of the tour; boy was he desolate.
Sorry! off topic.


And the French uprisings.

Meanwhile... Sitting on the dock of the bay...
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Alfred R Jones on September 03, 2015, 06:49:17 PM

And the French uprisings.

Meanwhile... Sitting on the dock of the bay...
nah, Otis died in 1967.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Montclair on September 03, 2015, 07:52:29 PM

And the French uprisings.

Meanwhile... Sitting on the dock of the bay...

I was a student at the Sorbonne then and lived in the middle of all of the excitement in the Latin Quarter. Sous les pavés la plage.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Carana on September 03, 2015, 07:56:24 PM
nah, Otis died in 1967.

So he did. Must still be the McCanns fault somehow.

If tourism was bad for continental Europe in 2007-2008, then they must be responsible for the international banking crisis. Simples.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Alice Purjorick on September 03, 2015, 08:22:45 PM
Desmond Dekker and "Me Ears Are Alight"
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Carana on September 03, 2015, 09:07:50 PM
Desmond Dekker and "Me Ears Are Alight"

  @)(++(*
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: pathfinder73 on September 03, 2015, 09:26:32 PM
They were born in '68.

Correct they are 47 like I said.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Montclair on September 03, 2015, 09:28:51 PM
Correct they are 47 like I said.

Makes me feel really old to think that I was studying art history when they were born.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Carana on September 03, 2015, 09:57:33 PM
Makes me feel really old to think that I was studying art history when they were born.

On the other hand, you've lived through interesting tmes that others haven't.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: mercury on September 03, 2015, 10:53:53 PM
On the other hand, you've lived through interesting tmes that others haven't.

Most definitely!

I'd give my right arm to have been there in such world changing exciting times where the power of the human spirit superseded so many negatives

 8((()*/

Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Alfred R Jones on September 04, 2015, 06:19:44 PM
In a poll of round 5 and a half thousand people so far, 84% want the  investigation to continue looking for Madeleine... http://www.closeronline.co.uk/2015/09/have-your-say-should-we-continue-the-search-for-madeleine-mccann
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: stephen25000 on September 04, 2015, 06:32:22 PM
In a poll of round 5 and a half thousand people so far, 84% want the  investigation to continue looking for Madeleine... http://www.closeronline.co.uk/2015/09/have-your-say-should-we-continue-the-search-for-madeleine-mccann

Who set up this poll alfred ?

Perhaps one should be done on here.

There are of course other polls in relation to the mccanns.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Brietta on September 04, 2015, 06:48:42 PM
The British authorities and Scotland Yard know the direction they are taking ... the Portuguese authorities and the Polícia Judiciária know the direction the active investigation is taking.

The Portuguese authorities have taken the time to tell us that they are reacting to further requests although they haven't told us what the requests are.

Is there any good reason why a retired police officer should make a fool of himself by allowing remarks to be published regarding an active case about which he obviously knows absolutely nothing?
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: stephen25000 on September 04, 2015, 06:52:12 PM
The British authorities and Scotland Yard know the direction they are taking ... the Portuguese authorities and the Polícia Judiciária know the direction the active investigation is taking.

The Portuguese authorities have taken the time to tell us that they are reacting to further requests although they haven't told us what the requests are.

Is there any good reason why a retired police officer should make a fool of himself by allowing remarks to be published regarding an active case about which he obviously knows absolutely nothing?

How do you know he knows nothing about the case ?
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Brietta on September 04, 2015, 06:55:43 PM
How do you know he knows nothing about the case ?

If you haven't worked that out for yourself it is little wonder you appeared to be drooling at the thought of a non existent second fund.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: stephen25000 on September 04, 2015, 06:58:15 PM
If you haven't worked that out for yourself it is little wonder you appeared to be drooling at the thought of a non existent second fund.

We shall see.

and I'm not drooling. @)(++(* @)(++(* @)(++(*
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Alfred R Jones on September 05, 2015, 12:02:01 AM
Who set up this poll alfred ?

Perhaps one should be done on here.

There are of course other polls in relation to the mccanns.
I doubt you'll get 5.5k people to respond.  The poll appears to have been set up by Closer magazine, but you would have known that if you'd clicked on the link.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Alfred R Jones on September 05, 2015, 12:07:34 AM
7.5k have responded to the poll now and nearly 85% think the investigation should continue.  Oh dear Steve, looks like you're in the minority after all!
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: faithlilly on September 05, 2015, 12:18:27 AM
7.5k have responded to the poll now and nearly 85% think the investigation should continue.  Oh dear Steve, looks like you're in the minority after all!

I'm sure he is if you consider the demographic who read Closer magazine.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: pegasus on September 05, 2015, 12:18:34 AM
"Co-operation right now between the British and the Portuguese police is at a moment of great synchronisation"

"expecting to receive a new international letter of request shortly from UK authorities - the first she (NW) will have been involved in preparing"

http://www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/british-cops-say-madeleine-mccann-6370080

Things are looking very promising
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: stephen25000 on September 05, 2015, 07:16:43 AM
7.5k have responded to the poll now and nearly 85% think the investigation should continue.  Oh dear Steve, looks like you're in the minority after all!

I'm afraid girlie magazines are not listed in my reading matter.

Are they in yours alfred ?

Hardly representing a cross-section of society, are they ?

You could try typing 'mccann polls' on google and see what you come up with. ?{)(**

Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Alfred R Jones on September 05, 2015, 08:19:57 AM
I'm sure he is if you consider the demographic who read Closer magazine.
What demographic would that be?  Are you under the mistaken belief that only readers of Closer magazine are able to vote?
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Alfred R Jones on September 05, 2015, 08:21:38 AM
I'm afraid girlie magazines are not listed in my reading matter.

Are they in yours alfred ?

Hardly representing a cross-section of society, are they ?

You could try typing 'mccann polls' on google and see what you come up with. ?{)(**
girly mags are a bit more "top shelf" than Closer I believe.  Are you telling me that the views of "girlies" don't count?
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: stephen25000 on September 05, 2015, 08:27:00 AM
girly mags are a bit more "top shelf" than Closer I believe.  Are you telling me that the views of "girlies" don't count?

Girlies who don't know what the mccanns did, you mean.

How about a more cross representative sample of the population alfred ?

The comments section of the mail and the voting was far more reliable, wouldn't you agree ?

Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Alfred R Jones on September 05, 2015, 08:28:21 AM
Girlies who don't know what the mccanns did, you mean.

How about a more cross representative sample of the population alfred ?

The comments section of the mail and the voting was far more reliable, wouldn't you agree ?
link to the Mail poll on the same issue then.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: stephen25000 on September 05, 2015, 08:43:53 AM
link to the Mail poll on the same issue then.

It already has alfred, but just for you  8)-)))


http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3219114/Bill-Scotland-Yard-investigation-Madeleine-McCann-disappearance-hits-11MILLION-no-arrests-former-police-chief-calls-end.html

and pay attention to the comments section, as i said, more than reflective of opinion, than a girlie mag.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Mr Gray on September 05, 2015, 09:00:51 AM
Girlies who don't know what the mccanns did, you mean.

How about a more cross representative sample of the population alfred ?

The comments section of the mail and the voting was far more reliable, wouldn't you agree ?

Do you think the balance of the comments in the mail represent an accurate reflection of the view of the British public
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: stephen25000 on September 05, 2015, 09:06:17 AM
Do you think the balance of the comments in the mail represent an accurate reflection of the view of the British public

Well bearing in mind the papers 'helpful' attitude towards the mccanns.

Absolutely. 8((()*/
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Eleanor on September 05, 2015, 09:55:04 AM
What demographic would that be?  Are you under the mistaken belief that only readers of Closer magazine are able to vote?

I voted, and I have never seen a Closer Magazine.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: stephen25000 on September 05, 2015, 09:57:43 AM
I voted, and I have never seen a Closer Magazine.

Would you have known about the poll, other than from Alfred's link Eleanor ?
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Eleanor on September 05, 2015, 10:00:30 AM
Would you have known about the poll, other than from Alfred's link Eleanor ?

No.  Is there any reason why I should?  But you may be sure that I am not alone.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: stephen25000 on September 05, 2015, 10:03:50 AM
No.  Is there any reason why I should?  But you may be sure that I am not alone.

Have you seen the comments in the Mail and the votes ?

A far better cross section of opinion there, than for a girlie magazine.

Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Mr Gray on September 05, 2015, 10:06:51 AM
Well bearing in mind the papers 'helpful' attitude towards the mccanns.

Absolutely. 8((()*/
. Stephen talks a lot about statistics and I think it's important to point out that if he thinks the comments in the mail are a fair reflection of public opinion then he understands little about statistics
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Eleanor on September 05, 2015, 10:07:51 AM
Have you seen the comments in the Mail and the votes ?

A far better cross section of opinion there, than for a girlie magazine.

No.  I'll get to that shortly.  Although I'm not sure about The Mail's cross section.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: stephen25000 on September 05, 2015, 10:09:38 AM
. Stephen talks a lot about statistics and I think it's important to point out that if he thinks the comments in the mail are a fair reflection of public opinion then he understands little about statistics

Why aren't they.

The girlie magazine poll certainly isn't.

That as Faithlilly so rightly said is aimed at a very narrow group of people, and to put it mildly is totally unrepresentative of the population.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Mr Gray on September 05, 2015, 10:17:44 AM
Why aren't they.

The girlie magazine poll certainly isn't.

That as Faithlilly so rightly said is aimed at a very narrow group of people, and to put it mildly is totally unrepresentative of the population.

The articles are promoted on sceptic sites an d payers encouraged to post
To get a real idea of the view of the public would require preparation of a proper sample to question
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: stephen25000 on September 05, 2015, 10:19:09 AM
The articles are promoted on sceptic sites an d payers encouraged to post
To get a real idea of the view of the public would require preparation of a proper sample to question

You mean as in the girlie magazine dave ?  8)--))

So what form of sampling procedure would be most fair dave in those circumstances ?

and of course, rather more poignantly, what questions should be asked ?
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Eleanor on September 05, 2015, 10:21:05 AM

Let's keep it pleasant, Please.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: stephen25000 on September 05, 2015, 10:22:33 AM
Let's keep it pleasant, Please.

I'm doing mt best.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Eleanor on September 05, 2015, 10:27:20 AM
I'm doing mt best.

Yes, I think you probably are.  And thank you.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: faithlilly on September 05, 2015, 10:30:42 AM
What demographic would that be?  Are you under the mistaken belief that only readers of Closer magazine are able to vote?

No I'm assuming that only Closer readers would 1) notice the article and 2) be bothered to vote.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: G-Unit on September 05, 2015, 10:54:47 AM
The articles are promoted on sceptic sites an d payers encouraged to post
To get a real idea of the view of the public would require preparation of a proper sample to question

It would seem that the 'Closer' poll was promoted also. That's how Eleanor heard of it.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Eleanor on September 05, 2015, 11:18:25 AM
It would seem that the 'Closer' poll was promoted also. That's how Eleanor heard of it.

Some organised Sceptics promote anything that they think will make The McCanns look bad.   Including 11 Million Pounds spent on The Search for Madeleine.  Big Fail again.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: stephen25000 on September 05, 2015, 11:21:12 AM
Some organised Sceptics promote anything that they think will make The McCanns look bad.   Including 11 Million Pounds spent on The Search for Madeleine.  Big Fail again.

Why is it a big fall ?

Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: G-Unit on September 05, 2015, 11:25:18 AM
Some organised Sceptics promote anything that they think will make The McCanns look bad.   Including 11 Million Pounds spent on The Search for Madeleine.  Big Fail again.

Others promote anything that they think will make Amaral and/or the Pj look bad. Pots and kettles imo. 11 million pounds has been spent on investigating the disappearance of Madeleine McCann, not searching for her as far as I know (apart from some digging).
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Eleanor on September 05, 2015, 11:26:04 AM
Why is it a big fall ?

The majority voted in favour of continuing the search.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: stephen25000 on September 05, 2015, 11:32:55 AM
The majority voted in favour of continuing the search.

In a poll which represents a  very small cross section of people in the UK and therefore completely useless.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: faithlilly on September 05, 2015, 11:34:15 AM
The majority voted in favour of continuing the search.

It's not a search it's an investigation. There is a difference.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Eleanor on September 05, 2015, 11:38:01 AM
In a poll which represents a  very small cross section of people in the UK and therefore completely useless.

And what exactly is this Forum?
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Eleanor on September 05, 2015, 11:39:33 AM
It's not a search it's an investigation. There is a difference.

I don't think we actually know that.  The Investigation is certainly not going to ignore any pointers, and must be the ultimate purpose.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Alfred R Jones on September 05, 2015, 11:40:06 AM
No I'm assuming that only Closer readers would 1) notice the article and 2) be bothered to vote.
You do know that to assume makes an ass out of u and me don't you?
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: faithlilly on September 05, 2015, 11:41:03 AM
I don't think we actually know that.  The Investigation is certainly not going to ignore any pointers, and must be the ultimate purpose.

Oh I think we do Eleanor.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Alfred R Jones on September 05, 2015, 11:47:19 AM
Others promote anything that they think will make Amaral and/or the Pj look bad. Pots and kettles imo. 11 million pounds has been spent on investigating the disappearance of Madeleine McCann, not searching for her as far as I know (apart from some digging).
You know very little about the investigation or how much of it has involved searching do you?
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Eleanor on September 05, 2015, 11:48:19 AM
Oh I think we do Eleanor.

So they aren't looking for Madeleine?  Why ever not?
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Carana on September 05, 2015, 11:52:07 AM
It's not a search it's an investigation. There is a difference.

One being a prerequisite to the other, unless you have a different idea of how police should proceed.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: stephen25000 on September 05, 2015, 11:57:24 AM
One being a prerequisite to the other, unless you have a different idea of how police should proceed.

So another year down the line. or more and no results for the money spent.

What then ?
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Eleanor on September 05, 2015, 11:57:52 AM
One being a prerequisite to the other, unless you have a different idea of how police should proceed.

Exactly. 

And I think they have got a pretty good idea of where she is already.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: stephen25000 on September 05, 2015, 12:01:34 PM
Exactly. 

And I think they have got a pretty good idea of where she is already.

Do you mean alive ?

Bearing in mind BHH comments, when he let slip.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Eleanor on September 05, 2015, 12:03:52 PM
Do you mean alive ?

Bearing in mind BHH comments, when he let slip.

Yes, I believe Madeleine is alive.

The comment by BHH is of no importance.  He doesn't know.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: G-Unit on September 05, 2015, 12:07:08 PM
So they aren't looking for Madeleine?  Why ever not?

They are investigating the disappearance of Madeleine McCann. I assume they will investigate any information which suggests her possible location, but meanwhile their main task is surely to try to discover what happened, when it happened, and who did it. Hence the 'forensic' analysis of the timeline, their appeal for the identity of Smithman, and the digging.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: stephen25000 on September 05, 2015, 12:07:31 PM
Yes, I believe Madeleine is alive.

The comment by BHH is of no importance.  He doesn't know.

Well if they believed she was alive and knew where she was.............................

As to BHH, he let the truth slip in one of his off moments.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: stephen25000 on September 05, 2015, 12:08:31 PM
They are investigating the disappearance of Madeleine McCann. I assume they will investigate any information which suggests her possible location, but meanwhile their main task is surely to try to discover what happened, when it happened, and who did it. Hence the 'forensic' analysis of the timeline, their appeal for the identity of Smithman, and the digging.

Precisely.

The digging was to look for remains.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Eleanor on September 05, 2015, 12:11:28 PM

Such lack of hope.  Really depressing.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Carana on September 05, 2015, 12:20:13 PM
People have so many interpretations of what "searching" means...

Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: pegasus on September 05, 2015, 01:09:50 PM
The idea that SY and PJ currently have no clue is pure speculation.
It is quite possible they are close to solving the case.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: stephen25000 on September 05, 2015, 01:16:15 PM
The idea that SY and PJ currently have no clue is pure speculation.
It is quite possible they are close to solving the case.

We shall see.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Mr Gray on September 05, 2015, 01:23:16 PM
hopefully even if they do not solve it they will give a summary of their investigations which will exonerate the parents
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Alfred R Jones on September 05, 2015, 01:29:45 PM
hopefully even if they do not solve it they will give a summary of their investigations which will exonerate the parents
which in turn will be interpreted by the "sceptics" as "the McCanns dunnit but we can't say that as David Cameron won't let us" - or some such.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Alfred R Jones on September 05, 2015, 02:20:23 PM
It already has alfred, but just for you  8)-)))


http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3219114/Bill-Scotland-Yard-investigation-Madeleine-McCann-disappearance-hits-11MILLION-no-arrests-former-police-chief-calls-end.html

and pay attention to the comments section, as i said, more than reflective of opinion, than a girlie mag.
that's not a poll, that's just a few hundred moany comments.   The Closer poll samples a much larger number of individuals.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: stephen25000 on September 05, 2015, 02:29:53 PM
that's not a poll, that's just a few hundred moany comments.   The Closer poll samples a much larger number of individuals.

The sample tested belongs to what is called in Statistics a Cluster Sample of young female readers. I wonder how many of them take an interest in the case that posters on here do and are aware of what happened.

Whereas the Mail comments will come from a greater cross section of people.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Carana on September 05, 2015, 03:48:11 PM
The sample tested belongs to what is called in Statistics a Cluster Sample of young female readers. I wonder how many of them take an interest in the case that posters on here do and are aware of what happened.

Whereas the Mail comments will come from a greater cross section of people.

A professional polling agency phoning phone homelines might be more accurate, IMO. Setting up multiple socks and clearing cookies to spam a particular view isn't beyond the intelligence level of an average primary school kid with access to the Internet.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Carana on September 05, 2015, 03:51:38 PM
that's not a poll, that's just a few hundred moany comments.   The Closer poll samples a much larger number of individuals.

Wait until the "T&J" brigade alights...
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: faithlilly on September 05, 2015, 04:26:57 PM
One being a prerequisite to the other, unless you have a different idea of how police should proceed.

Not necessarily. It depends if they believe she is alive.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Brietta on September 05, 2015, 04:39:04 PM
One of the more unsavoury aspects displayed by the sceptics as far as I am concerned is the apparent need to pursue everything pertaining to Madeleine McCann for the sole purpose of submitting negative responses to every initiative on her behalf.

There is little to commend the recent red top speculation particularly when one considers the positive statements from the usually reticent Portuguese authorities ... yet there are those who are prepared to take comfort from the hope that the negative reports are true in preference to ignoring that the PJ and SY are working diligently on Madeleine's behalf.
Truly bizarre behaviour from those who pay what must surely be considered lip service to "Justice for Madeleine."
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Alice Purjorick on September 05, 2015, 04:46:56 PM
One of the more unsavoury aspects displayed by the sceptics as far as I am concerned is the apparent need to pursue everything pertaining to Madeleine McCann for the sole purpose of submitting negative responses to every initiative on her behalf.
  • constant bizarre FOI requests on every aspect of the search for a missing child is surely exceedingly odd and obsessive behaviour
  • it is very hard to take in that adults are prepared to organise and 'bomb' comment sections in newspapers whenever the opportunity presents itself
  • what kind of mindset is required for so called sceptics to attempt to derail the Crime Watch programme seeking information on a missing child

There is little to commend the recent red top speculation particularly when one considers the positive statements from the usually reticent Portuguese authorities ... yet there are those who are prepared to take comfort from the hope that the negative reports are true in preference to ignoring that the PJ and SY are working diligently on Madeleine's behalf.
Truly bizarre behaviour from those who pay what must surely be considered lip service to "Justice for Madeleine."

If there were no Red Top crap for the sceptics to pick over there would be no reason for you to harangue them over their ignorance and lack of good breeding. Look on the bright side it keeps part of your brain occupied.  8(>((
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Alfred R Jones on September 05, 2015, 05:33:10 PM
The sample tested belongs to what is called in Statistics a Cluster Sample of young female readers. I wonder how many of them take an interest in the case that posters on here do and are aware of what happened.

Whereas the Mail comments will come from a greater cross section of people.
Erm...I'm not a young female reader of Closer magazine but I voted.  What age is the average Closer reader anyway?  I thought it was aimed at the 'bored housewife' market, the very demographic that makes up a large part of the McCann "sceptic" community. 
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: John on September 05, 2015, 05:36:47 PM
One of the more unsavoury aspects displayed by the sceptics as far as I am concerned is the apparent need to pursue everything pertaining to Madeleine McCann for the sole purpose of submitting negative responses to every initiative on her behalf.
  • constant bizarre FOI requests on every aspect of the search for a missing child is surely exceedingly odd and obsessive behaviour
  • it is very hard to take in that adults are prepared to organise and 'bomb' comment sections in newspapers whenever the opportunity presents itself
  • what kind of mindset is required for so called sceptics to attempt to derail the Crime Watch programme seeking information on a missing child

There is little to commend the recent red top speculation particularly when one considers the positive statements from the usually reticent Portuguese authorities ... yet there are those who are prepared to take comfort from the hope that the negative reports are true in preference to ignoring that the PJ and SY are working diligently on Madeleine's behalf.
Truly bizarre behaviour from those who pay what must surely be considered lip service to "Justice for Madeleine."

To be honest Brietta they brought this down upon themselves the moment they took public money and promised absolute transparency.

There are just far too many questions and very few answers.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Alfred R Jones on September 05, 2015, 05:41:40 PM
To be honest Brietta they brought this down upon themselves the moment they took public money and promised absolute transparency.

There are just far too many questions and very few answers.
@)(++(* You think that the behaviour outlined by Brietta is because of a lack of fund transparency?!  Think again John, that's just one of the many, many sticks used by the "sceptic" community to beat the McCanns with.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: faithlilly on September 05, 2015, 05:46:53 PM
Erm...I'm not a young female reader of Closer magazine but I voted.  What age is the average Closer reader anyway?  I thought it was aimed at the 'bored housewife' market, the very demographic that makes up a large part of the McCann "sceptic" community.

Firstly you voted because you have an interest in the case, not, I would assume, because you are an avid Closer reader and secondly many sceptics, I for one, would like to see the investigation come to a conclusion.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Alfred R Jones on September 05, 2015, 05:52:28 PM
Firstly you voted because you have an interest in the case, not, I would assume, because you are an avid Closer reader and secondly many sceptics, I for one, would like to see the investigation come to a conclusion.
So you accept that the poll is a fair reflection of public opinion - or not?
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: sadie on September 05, 2015, 05:59:22 PM
Firstly you voted because you have an interest in the case, not, I would assume, because you are an avid Closer reader and secondly many sceptics, I for one, would like to see the investigation come to a conclusion.
Why?

Money alone?

Are you a scrouge?


Let's get it sorted if at all possible.   


Bring our children back, Portuguese and British, and lock the perps away so that our children can live safer lives.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Carana on September 05, 2015, 06:01:11 PM
To be honest Brietta they brought this down upon themselves the moment they took public money and promised absolute transparency.

There are just far too many questions and very few answers.

What would you have done differently if substantial amounts of money had flowed in to support you?
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: faithlilly on September 05, 2015, 06:07:04 PM
So you accept that the poll is a fair reflection of public opinion - or not?

I would accept it is a fair representation of a certain demographic who have little interest in the case further than a child is missing yes.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: stephen25000 on September 05, 2015, 06:10:24 PM
So you accept that the poll is a fair reflection of public opinion - or not?

It is very clear it isn't.

Haven't you worked that out yet ?
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Alfred R Jones on September 05, 2015, 06:10:51 PM
I would accept it is a fair representation of a certain demographic who have little interest in the case further than a child is missing yes.
which pretty much sums up the GBP wouldn't you say?
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: stephen25000 on September 05, 2015, 06:18:36 PM
which pretty much sums up the GBP wouldn't you say?

Would that be like those who admire Katie Price ?

Mind you, give her some respect.

Her books individually outsell kate mccanns. 8(*(
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: faithlilly on September 05, 2015, 06:19:11 PM
which pretty much sums up the GBP wouldn't you say?

I don't know Alfie, you'd have to ask them all.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Alfred R Jones on September 05, 2015, 06:19:23 PM
Would that be like those who admire Katie Price ?

Mind you, give her some respect.

Her books individually outsell kate mccanns. 8(*(
Pathetic observation. 
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: stephen25000 on September 05, 2015, 06:20:27 PM
Pathetic observation.

However, true.

and if you really think that poll is representative... @)(++(* @)(++(* @)(++(*
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Alfred R Jones on September 05, 2015, 06:21:11 PM
I don't know Alfie, you'd have to ask them all.
No need, there's a perfectly good poll sampling the opinions of around 9000 individuals which should be quite representative IMO.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: stephen25000 on September 05, 2015, 06:23:50 PM
No need, there's a perfectly good poll sampling the opinions of around 9000 individuals which should be quite representative IMO.

 @)(++(* @)(++(* @)(++(*

Are you a fan of 'Closer' then.

After all, it's one of the stalwarts of brilliant journalism. *&*%£
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: faithlilly on September 05, 2015, 06:46:02 PM
No need, there's a perfectly good poll sampling the opinions of around 9000 individuals which should be quite representative IMO.

So the over 20000 members of a certain McCann sceptic Facebook page could a also described as representative, right ?
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: jassi on September 05, 2015, 06:50:24 PM
@)(++(* @)(++(* @)(++(*

Are you a fan of 'Closer' then.

After all, it's one of the stalwarts of brilliant journalism. *&*%£


Closer ? Never heard of them.   What are they ?
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Alfred R Jones on September 05, 2015, 06:53:07 PM
So the over 20000 members of a certain McCann sceptic Facebook page could a also described as representative, right ?
No, they have come together to form an active pressure group against the McCanns, they're just one of many online groups on a wide variety of causes and subjects, bound by a common hatred that exist primarily to bitch, gossip and promulgate hateful propaganda on their subject.  In the same way that I wouldn't call a community of 20,000 online paedophiles representative of men in general.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: stephen25000 on September 05, 2015, 06:56:41 PM

Closer ? Never heard of them.   What are they ?

It's supposed to be a womans magazine Jassi, where according to Alfred it gives a fair representation of people's opinions in a poll as regards the SY investigation.

I use the word magazine carefully. 8**8:/:
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: jassi on September 05, 2015, 07:01:27 PM
Well if Alfie says it, it must be so  @)(++(*
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: stephen25000 on September 05, 2015, 07:07:35 PM
Well if Alfie says it, it must be so  @)(++(*

Indeed.

Though some might view Closer on a par with the Daily Sport,  a  great example of British journalistic splendour.  *&*%£
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: faithlilly on September 05, 2015, 07:11:17 PM
No, they have come together to form an active pressure group against the McCanns, they're just one of many online groups on a wide variety of causes and subjects, bound by a common hatred that exist primarily to bitch, gossip and promulgate hateful propaganda on their subject.  In the same way that I wouldn't call a community of 20,000 online paedophiles representative of men in general.

Whether you like it or not Alfie the Facebook group members come from every sphere of life whose only link is a distrust of the official McCann story and certainly more representative of public option than the readership of a woman's magazine.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: G-Unit on September 05, 2015, 07:12:55 PM
Indeed.

Though some might view Closer on a par with the Daily Sport,  a  great example of British journalistic splendour.  *&*%£

So Alfie reads Closer Magazine? Hmmm   &%+((£
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: stephen25000 on September 05, 2015, 07:13:40 PM
So Alfie reads Closer Magazine? Hmmm   &%+((£

Well I believe he gave the link. 8(0(*
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Alfred R Jones on September 05, 2015, 07:15:56 PM
Whether you like it or not Alfie the Facebook group members come from every sphere of life whose only link is a distrust of the official McCann story and certainly more representative of public option than the readership of a woman's magazine.
Yes, the link is their contempt for the McCanns - it is a shared interest and so they are all by default biased against the McCanns, they are not objective, they actively sought each other out to congregate online on the same Facebook page to pick holes in the objects of their contempt.  That is not quite the same as 9000 individuals many of whose common interest is celebrity gossip and diet tips, and who don't all share an avid interest in this case, and are therefore without a specific agenda.  Are you unable to see this??
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: stephen25000 on September 05, 2015, 07:19:16 PM
Yes, the link is their contempt for the McCanns - it is a shared interest and so they are all by default biased against the McCanns, they are not objective, they actively sought each other out to congregate online on the same Facebook page to pick holes in the objects of their contempt.  That is not quite the same as 9000 individuals many of whose common interest is celebrity gossip and diet tips, and who don't all share an avid interest in this case, and are therefore without a specific agenda.  Are you unable to see this??

and how much do the 9000 know about the investigation,  which has nothing to show for it, let alone what led to it ?

So you think that people who spend their lives reading about vacuous celebrities  reflect the country at large  ?
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Alfred R Jones on September 05, 2015, 07:20:55 PM
and how much do the 9000 know about the investigation,  which has nothing to show for it, let alone what led to it ?
They probably know as much about it as you or I do, ie: not a lot.  So what?
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: G-Unit on September 05, 2015, 07:27:25 PM
Yes, the link is their contempt for the McCanns - it is a shared interest and so they are all by default biased against the McCanns, they are not objective, they actively sought each other out to congregate online on the same Facebook page to pick holes in the objects of their contempt.  That is not quite the same as 9000 individuals many of whose common interest is celebrity gossip and diet tips, and who don't all share an avid interest in this case, and are therefore without a specific agenda.  Are you unable to see this??

There is another big difference between the two groups also. One group is fully informed on the case. They've looked at the evidence and decided the McCanns have questions to answer. The other group is not informed about the case. Their votes probably came from their hearts rather than their brains.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Alfred R Jones on September 05, 2015, 07:29:22 PM
There is another big difference between the two groups also. One group is fully informed on the case. They've looked at the evidence and decided the McCanns have questions to answer. The other group is not informed about the case. Their votes probably came from their hearts rather than their brains.
You seem to forget what they were voting about - whether or not the Met should keep going with the investigation. Why does that require any detailed knowledge of the case?
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Alfred R Jones on September 05, 2015, 07:30:00 PM
So Alfie reads Closer Magazine? Hmmm   &%+((£
What on earth gave you that impression?
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Mr Gray on September 05, 2015, 07:33:31 PM
There is another big difference between the two groups also. One group is fully informed on the case. They've looked at the evidence and decided the McCanns have questions to answer. The other group is not informed about the case. Their votes probably came from their hearts rather than their brains.

they might be informed but like many they have misunderstood the evidence...or believed amarals lies
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: G-Unit on September 05, 2015, 07:44:42 PM
You seem to forget what they were voting about - whether or not the Met should keep going with the investigation. Why does that require any detailed knowledge of the case?

The majority of the population, if asked to vote, would bring back hanging. That's because the majority of the population aren't aware of the issues. An uninformed vote is meaningless.

Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: stephen25000 on September 05, 2015, 07:50:14 PM
I wonder what feedback the 'sceptics' would get if the 'poll' had shown an inverted result and had been posted by a 'sceptic'.

Methinks the mccann supporters would be up in arms.


If you type in 'mccann polls'  on google, there are several which to say the least show how others view this case.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: G-Unit on September 05, 2015, 07:51:26 PM
they might be informed but like many they have misunderstood the evidence...or believed amarals lies

Is it not time for some people to realise that those who don't believe the McCanns are not all incapable of understanding evidence or are easily led? Believe it or not some of those who disbelieve the McCanns are perfectly capable of assessing evidence and thinking for themselves. They are also capable of telling the difference between evidence based debate and name-calling.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Brietta on September 05, 2015, 08:06:42 PM
To be honest Brietta they brought this down upon themselves the moment they took public money and promised absolute transparency.

There are just far too many questions and very few answers.

The prime mover in the speculation that the Drs McCann had set up a "fraudulent fund" was Mr Amaral ... the only extraordinary thing is that it has been kept going for over eight years subject to constant scrutiny which is ignored when it comes to the public funding received by Mr Amaral.

Sauce for the goose etc ... and perhaps initially the wrong questions were asked of the wrong people. 
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Mr Gray on September 05, 2015, 08:10:08 PM
Is it not time for some people to realise that those who don't believe the McCanns are not all incapable of understanding evidence or are easily led? Believe it or not some of those who disbelieve the McCanns are perfectly capable of assessing evidence and thinking for themselves. They are also capable of telling the difference between evidence based debate and name-calling.

from what I have seen of your posts your opinions are based on a misunderstanding  of the evidence. Both Sy and the PJ do not consider the parents suspects....you only have to look on amarals gofundme site to see how some people are so easily misled
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: stephen25000 on September 05, 2015, 08:12:53 PM
from what I have seen of your posts your opinions are based on a misunderstanding  of the evidence. Both Sy and the PJ do not consider the parents suspects....you only have to look on amarals gofundme site to see how some people are so easily misled

So your opinion counts more than any other ?

No it doesn't.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Brietta on September 05, 2015, 08:16:29 PM
There is another big difference between the two groups also. One group is fully informed on the case. They've looked at the evidence and decided the McCanns have questions to answer. The other group is not informed about the case. Their votes probably came from their hearts rather than their brains.

Having read the comments which have accompanied donations to Mr Amaral's fund I would class them as being ill informed ... I think many ordinary people would be dismayed to be associated with any of the sentiments expressed.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Mr Gray on September 05, 2015, 08:16:49 PM
So your opinion counts more than any other ?

No it doesn't.
you are a prime example...I haver never said my opinion counts more than any other...can't you get anything right...it seems not
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Mr Gray on September 05, 2015, 08:19:21 PM
Having read the comments which have accompanied donations to Mr Amaral's fund I would class them as being ill informed ... I think many ordinary people would be dismayed to be associated with any of the sentiments expressed.

extremely ill informed yet gunit thinks these are the type who have a good grasp of the evidence...bizarre
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: stephen25000 on September 05, 2015, 08:21:18 PM
you are a prime example...I haver never said my opinion counts more than any other...can't you get anything right...it seems not

Another inane comment and so, so predictable.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: stephen25000 on September 05, 2015, 08:22:51 PM
extremely ill informed yet gunit thinks these are the type who have a good grasp of the evidence...bizarre

You've just illustrated my point about you precisely.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Mr Gray on September 05, 2015, 08:28:10 PM
You've just illustrated my point about you precisely.

you might be impressed with "the dogs don't lie" brigade but I'm not
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Brietta on September 05, 2015, 08:29:10 PM
Is it not time for some people to realise that those who don't believe the McCanns are not all incapable of understanding evidence or are easily led? Believe it or not some of those who disbelieve the McCanns are perfectly capable of assessing evidence and thinking for themselves. They are also capable of telling the difference between evidence based debate and name-calling.

Then it is surely a pity that being so erudite they have singularly failed to understand that the eight year campaign conducted without let or hindrance directed entirely at named individuals is loathsome.

The fact that they have not let their opprobrium stand in the way of their interference in the efforts made on behalf of Madeleine McCann is a particularly distasteful stance to defend as well as being indefensible.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: G-Unit on September 05, 2015, 08:30:59 PM
from what I have seen of your posts your opinions are based on a misunderstanding  of the evidence. Both Sy and the PJ do not consider the parents suspects....you only have to look on amarals gofundme site to see how some people are so easily misled

From what i have seen of your posts your opinions are based on no evidence whatsoever.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Eleanor on September 05, 2015, 08:32:24 PM

Watch the insults, please.  No more warnings.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: stephen25000 on September 05, 2015, 08:33:09 PM
you might be impressed with "the dogs don't lie" brigade but I'm not

Irrelevant.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: stephen25000 on September 05, 2015, 08:34:53 PM
Then it is surely a pity that being so erudite they have singularly failed to understand that the eight year campaign conducted without let or hindrance directed entirely at named individuals is loathsome.

The fact that they have not let their opprobrium stand in the way of their interference in the efforts made on behalf of Madeleine McCann is a particularly distasteful stance to defend as well as being indefensible.

Well, what else would you say given your stance on the case.

You are hardly going to sing the praises of those who haven't swallowed the mccanns story.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: jassi on September 05, 2015, 08:36:53 PM
Then it is surely a pity that being so erudite they have singularly failed to understand that the eight year campaign conducted without let or hindrance directed entirely at named individuals is loathsome.

The fact that they have not let their opprobrium stand in the way of their interference in the efforts made on behalf of Madeleine McCann is a particularly distasteful stance to defend as well as being indefensible.

To you, maybe. Others might consider it justified.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: G-Unit on September 05, 2015, 08:37:19 PM
Having read the comments which have accompanied donations to Mr Amaral's fund I would class them as being ill informed ... I think many ordinary people would be dismayed to be associated with any of the sentiments expressed.

Of course you would, because anyone who disagrees with your opinions must be ill informed, mustn't they? Please define 'ordinary' people?
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: stephen25000 on September 05, 2015, 08:45:37 PM
Of course you would, because anyone who disagrees with your opinions must be ill informed, mustn't they? Please define 'ordinary' people?

In brietta's case, a very small band of people who support the mccanns.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: G-Unit on September 05, 2015, 08:48:46 PM
Then it is surely a pity that being so erudite they have singularly failed to understand that the eight year campaign conducted without let or hindrance directed entirely at named individuals is loathsome.

The fact that they have not let their opprobrium stand in the way of their interference in the efforts made on behalf of Madeleine McCann is a particularly distasteful stance to defend as well as being indefensible.

It's a pity that those who agree with the 'named individuals' are so convinced that they own the intellectual and moral high ground. The facts which support a different viewpoint are ignored or excused and those who point them out are dismissed as lacking in some way. What a weak basis for debate!
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: stephen25000 on September 05, 2015, 08:55:20 PM
It's a pity that those who agree with the 'named individuals' are so convinced that they own the intellectual and moral high ground. The facts which support a different viewpoint are ignored or excused and those who point them out are dismissed as lacking in some way. What a weak basis for debate!

Actually it's quite sad, and reflects the weakness of their position.

Those sentiments are clearly visible on the mccann supporter forums.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Mr Gray on September 05, 2015, 08:56:30 PM
It's a pity that those who agree with the 'named individuals' are so convinced that they own the intellectual and moral high ground. The facts which support a different viewpoint are ignored or excused and those who point them out are dismissed as lacking in some way. What a weak basis for debate!

you are  wrong again....your so called facts are easily explained...not ignored. IT was you who claimed there were no mistranslations in the files...a statement that is plainly bonkers
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: mercury on September 05, 2015, 09:00:05 PM
It's a pity that those who agree with the 'named individuals' are so convinced that they own the intellectual and moral high ground. The facts which support a different viewpoint are ignored or excused and those who point them out are dismissed as lacking in some way. What a weak basis for debate!

"Post of the Day"

 8((()*/
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: stephen25000 on September 05, 2015, 09:01:16 PM
"Post of the Day"

 8((()*/

Seconded.  8((()*/
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: G-Unit on September 05, 2015, 09:03:56 PM
Actually it's quite sad, and reflects the weakness of their position.

Those sentiments are clearly visible on the mccann supporter forums.

Hence the desperate attempts to silence any opposition by any means possible. That's always a sign of a weak position.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Mr Gray on September 05, 2015, 09:07:02 PM
Hence the desperate attempts to silence any opposition by any means possible. That's always a sign of a weak position.

Are you dreaming again
Everyone has their say on this forum
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: jassi on September 05, 2015, 09:07:54 PM
Hence the desperate attempts to silence any opposition by any means possible. That's always a sign of a weak position.

Indeed, the response to the 'extra fund' being a case in point
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: G-Unit on September 05, 2015, 09:08:26 PM
you are  wrong again....your so called facts are easily explained...not ignored. IT was you who claimed there were no mistranslations in the files...a statement that is plainly bonkers

As I recall we had a whole thread discussing mistranslations in the files. Only insignificant ones which didn't change the facts at all were found. Trying to discredit the files demonstrates that they cannot be rebutted imo.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Mr Gray on September 05, 2015, 09:13:57 PM
As I recall we had a whole thread discussing mistranslations in the files. Only insignificant ones which didn't change the facts at all were found. Trying to discredit the files demonstrates that they cannot be rebutted imo.

As there are no original tapes of the interviews we simply do not know how accurate the twice translated versions are
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: G-Unit on September 05, 2015, 09:22:52 PM
As there are no original tapes of the interviews we simply do not know how accurate the twice translated versions are

Perhaps the statements of the Portuguese staff at the Ocean Club, which were only translated once, are the most correct therefore. Aa few of them, for example, said the alarm was raised earlier than the tapas 9 said it was.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Mr Gray on September 05, 2015, 09:26:07 PM
Perhaps the statements of the Portuguese staff at the Ocean Club, which were only translated once, are the most correct therefore. Aa few of them, for example, said the alarm was raised earlier than the tapas 9 said it was.

I think you will find these statements contradict each other
As would be expected
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: G-Unit on September 05, 2015, 09:30:19 PM
I think you will find these statements contradict each other
As would be expected

None of the statements add up to a coherent story, but that's no reason to discard them all.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Mr Gray on September 05, 2015, 09:33:19 PM
None of the statements add up to a coherent story, but that's no reason to discard them all.
h

Who said to discard them all
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Alfred R Jones on September 05, 2015, 10:16:05 PM
The majority of the population, if asked to vote, would bring back hanging. That's because the majority of the population aren't aware of the issues. An uninformed vote is meaningless.
What issues are you talking about?
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Mr Gray on September 05, 2015, 10:25:45 PM
The majority of the population, if asked to vote, would bring back hanging. That's because the majority of the population aren't aware of the issues. An uninformed vote is meaningless.

And what are the general public uninformed about re hanging
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Alfred R Jones on September 05, 2015, 10:32:13 PM
And what are the general public uninformed about re hanging
Perhaps they don't realise that it causes death?
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: G-Unit on September 05, 2015, 10:33:51 PM
h

Who said to discard them all

Every statement I quote from is dismissed because it is mistranslated or the person didn't mean what they said or they forgot what they did or they were too stressed to remember. That suggests to me that certain people think none of the statements are of any use whatsoever.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Alfred R Jones on September 05, 2015, 10:34:29 PM
Seriously, how f..king superior do you have to consider yourself be to claim that the GBP don't understand what they're voting for when they vote to bring back the death penalty?
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: G-Unit on September 05, 2015, 10:39:36 PM
And what are the general public uninformed about re hanging

If they were fully informed they wouldn't vote to bring it back. Simple.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: G-Unit on September 05, 2015, 10:41:18 PM
Seriously, how f.....g superior do you have to consider yourself be to claim that the GBP don't understand what they're voting for when they vote to bring back the death penalty?

Not superior, Alfred, just informed.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: faithlilly on September 05, 2015, 10:41:50 PM
If they were fully informed they wouldn't vote to bring it back. Simple.

Unfortunately we are a nation of Sun readers G-Unit !
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: G-Unit on September 05, 2015, 10:46:47 PM
Unfortunately we are a nation of Sun readers G-Unit !

You mean when we're not voting in polls in trashy magazines?  @)(++(*
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Alfred R Jones on September 05, 2015, 10:51:50 PM
Not superior, Alfred, just informed.
you believe you are superior because you believe you are better informed.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Alfred R Jones on September 05, 2015, 10:52:43 PM
Unfortunately we are a nation of Sun readers G-Unit !
Another one with a superiority complex.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Brietta on September 05, 2015, 10:52:53 PM
To you, maybe. Others might consider it justified.

That is interesting.  Can you please give me the justification for using blind hatred of people never met or known to obstruct in whatever puny way possible the search for a little girl who was stolen from her bed and take pleasure from the thought that expense may curtail that search.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Alfred R Jones on September 05, 2015, 10:53:10 PM
If they were fully informed they wouldn't vote to bring it back. Simple.
What nonsense.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: faithlilly on September 05, 2015, 10:55:58 PM
Another one with a superiority complex.

I don't think I'm superior Alfie..........I know I am  @)(++(*
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: G-Unit on September 05, 2015, 11:02:53 PM
I don't think I'm superior Alfie..........I know I am  @)(++(*

That reminds me of my favourite reply when I used to be asked years ago if I was a 'women's libber'. It was 'why should I want to be equal to men? That would be a step down in so many ways.'
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Alfred R Jones on September 05, 2015, 11:04:34 PM
I don't think I'm superior Alfie..........I know I am  @)(++(*
I know you do, That's why I said it.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Alfred R Jones on September 05, 2015, 11:06:34 PM
That reminds me of my favourite reply when I used to be asked years ago if I was a 'women's libber'. It was 'why should I want to be equal to men? That would be a step down in so many ways.'
Sexist.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: G-Unit on September 05, 2015, 11:11:51 PM
Sexist.

No, that was the people patronising me because when they asked if i was a 'women's libber' it was an attempted put-down usually.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Alfred R Jones on September 05, 2015, 11:14:21 PM
No, that was the people patronising me because when they asked if i was a 'women's libber' it was an attempted put-down usually.
What has that got do do with your perceived superiority over our nation of "ill-informed Sun readers"?
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: slartibartfast on September 05, 2015, 11:14:27 PM
The sample tested belongs to what is called in Statistics a Cluster Sample of young female readers. I wonder how many of them take an interest in the case that posters on here do and are aware of what happened.

Whereas the Mail comments will come from a greater cross section of people.

...both self selecting of course.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: G-Unit on September 05, 2015, 11:17:21 PM
What has that got do do with your perceived superiority over our nation of "ill-informed Sun readers"?

I never claimed to be superior, I do wish you would stop putting words into my mouth. Informed was the word I used.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Alfred R Jones on September 05, 2015, 11:22:56 PM
I never claimed to be superior, I do wish you would stop putting words into my mouth. Informed was the word I used.
Who is superior - the informed or the ill-informed person?
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Alfred R Jones on September 05, 2015, 11:27:13 PM
I never claimed to be superior, I do wish you would stop putting words into my mouth. Informed was the word I used.
here's a measure of your conceit - you believe that if everyone knew as much as you do about the issues surrounding the death penalty they would all come to the same conclusion as you.  This is delusional reasoning on your part.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: faithlilly on September 05, 2015, 11:33:16 PM
here's a measure of your conceit - you believe that if everyone knew as much as you do about the issues surrounding the death penalty they would all come to the same conclusion as you.  This is delusional reasoning on your part.

Whereas you think that if every sceptic was as informed as you about the McCann case they would see the merit of your arguments against the couple's guilt. Pot, kettle and black my friend.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Alfred R Jones on September 05, 2015, 11:39:15 PM
Whereas you think that if every sceptic was as informed as you about the McCann case they would see the merit of your arguments against the couple's guilt. Pot, kettle and black my friend.
I have never said that.  I think you could do a PhD on the case and still be utterly convinced the McCanns dunnit.  I know that you are just as knowledgeable about the case as me, but you choose to interpret things differently.  Your choice - nothing to do with how informed you are, but more about your deep-seated prejudices and "gut-feel" I think. 
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: mercury on September 05, 2015, 11:48:11 PM
Who is superior - the informed or the ill-informed person?

NO one...only the insecure would want to deem themselves superior......the point that washes over your head is the illogical argument promulgated by you many of your "ilk" that all "question askers" are morally defunct and inferior.. A point superbly put in other words by GU on another thread...and proved by many many posts as well by people who just "don't do real debate"


You only have to tot up the facts and figures and blog you will be there


ETA blog =bingo
 ...must see to that autocorrect function



Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Alfred R Jones on September 05, 2015, 11:51:31 PM
NO one...only the insecure would want to deem themselves superior......the point that washes over your head is the illogical argument promulgated by you many of your "ilk" that all "question askers" are morally defunct and inferior.. A point superbly put in other words by GU on another thread...and proved by many many posts as well by people who just "don't do real debate"


You only have to tot up the facts and figures and blog you will be there
if you wish to accuse me of illogical argument then kindly refer to my specific posts, not to those made by my "ilk", thanks  8((()*/
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: faithlilly on September 05, 2015, 11:54:00 PM
I have never said that.  I think you could do a PhD on the case and still be utterly convinced the McCanns dunnit.  I know that you are just as knowledgeable about the case as me, but you choose to interpret things differently.  Your choice - nothing to do with how informed you are, but more about your deep-seated prejudices and "gut-feel" I think.

What 'deep-seated prejudices' do you feel would lead one to think a clearly innocent person guilty ?
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: mercury on September 05, 2015, 11:55:17 PM
if you wish to accuse me of illogical argument then kindly refer to my specific posts, not to those made by my "ilk", thanks  8((()*/

I'll start when you do, fairs fair

just in case you didn't understand that, once you stop referring to "sceptics" as an amorphous Borg and assigning all manner of ills to every one of them for the low to the lowest aka supporters of Peter sutcliffe .as well as "some" of your ilk, that is...

and be grateful that the said sceptics don't go around blaming you for every atrocious thing said by others in "your camp" .... hope that's sorted

And YES you very often name call people on a moral stance, though you are not the gold star winner, and no don't have to quote you at all, it's all there
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Brietta on September 06, 2015, 01:23:47 AM

It should be remembered that Portugal is 'doing it's bit' on behalf of the Madeleine McCann investigation ... and they certainly don't seem ready to wind anything down at the moment.

Wonder if Mr O'Conner is not slightly abashed now that it has been confirmed from Portuguese sources that the case is very active indeed with action due to be taken on yet another letter of request. 
It rather shows he really knows as much as we do about the progress being made in Madeleine's case, but appears to have less understanding about the time and money consuming formalities involved, such as letters of request.

**Snip
Here, PJ police are famous for playing their cards close to their chests. Last week national director Pedro do Carmo told the Resident that Portuguese costs in the hunt that began eight years ago “cannot be quantified”.

“We don’t have budgets for specific investigations”, he explained, adding that, unlike the UK - where Grange has a 30-strong team working full time - the PJ team in Porto running the Portuguese hunt is not exclusively working on the British toddler’s disappearance.

“It has other cases”, he told us. “Other disappearances. None of them children”.

Carmo said the Portuguese investigation was analysed regularly.

“If it comes to a point where there is nothing more that we think we can do, if there is no perpetrator of the crime to be found, then the next step would be to archive”, he agreed.
But for the time being, “there is no deadline”.

“We are still working with the Metropolitan Police”, he stressed, and there has been an “enormous effort” in terms of PJ resources in the joint police collaboration.

- See more at: http://portugalresident.com/second-british-police-source-slams-%E2%82%AC15-million-maddie-probe#sthash.m7Gu6SsD.VsEE2Hxc.dpuf
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: mercury on September 06, 2015, 01:36:07 AM
It should be remembered that Portugal is 'doing it's bit' on behalf of the Madeleine McCann investigation ... and they certainly don't seem ready to wind anything down at the moment.

Wonder if Mr O'Conner is not slightly abashed now that it has been confirmed from Portuguese sources that the case is very active indeed with action due to be taken on yet another letter of request. 
It rather shows he really knows as much as we do about the progress being made in Madeleine's case, but appears to have less understanding about the time and money consuming formalities involved, such as letters of request.

**Snip
Here, PJ police are famous for playing their cards close to their chests. Last week national director Pedro do Carmo told the Resident that Portuguese costs in the hunt that began eight years ago “cannot be quantified”.

“We don’t have budgets for specific investigations”, he explained, adding that, unlike the UK - where Grange has a 30-strong team working full time - the PJ team in Porto running the Portuguese hunt is not exclusively working on the British toddler’s disappearance.

“It has other cases”, he told us. “Other disappearances. None of them children”.

Carmo said the Portuguese investigation was analysed regularly.

“If it comes to a point where there is nothing more that we think we can do, if there is no perpetrator of the crime to be found, then the next step would be to archive”, he agreed.
But for the time being, “there is no deadline”.

“We are still working with the Metropolitan Police”, he stressed, and there has been an “enormous effort” in terms of PJ resources in the joint police collaboration.

- See more at: http://portugalresident.com/second-british-police-source-slams-%E2%82%AC15-million-maddie-probe#sthash.m7Gu6SsD.VsEE2Hxc.dpuf


Portugal did its bit at the time and is being gracious in doing extra bits for the benefit of two negligent parents, in order to help find their child, thanks for bringing it up
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: G-Unit on September 06, 2015, 07:25:21 AM
Who is superior - the informed or the ill-informed person?

They are different, no superiority involved.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: G-Unit on September 06, 2015, 07:43:21 AM
It should be remembered that Portugal is 'doing it's bit' on behalf of the Madeleine McCann investigation ... and they certainly don't seem ready to wind anything down at the moment.

Wonder if Mr O'Conner is not slightly abashed now that it has been confirmed from Portuguese sources that the case is very active indeed with action due to be taken on yet another letter of request. 
It rather shows he really knows as much as we do about the progress being made in Madeleine's case, but appears to have less understanding about the time and money consuming formalities involved, such as letters of request.

**Snip
Here, PJ police are famous for playing their cards close to their chests. Last week national director Pedro do Carmo told the Resident that Portuguese costs in the hunt that began eight years ago “cannot be quantified”.

“We don’t have budgets for specific investigations”, he explained, adding that, unlike the UK - where Grange has a 30-strong team working full time - the PJ team in Porto running the Portuguese hunt is not exclusively working on the British toddler’s disappearance.

“It has other cases”, he told us. “Other disappearances. None of them children”.

Carmo said the Portuguese investigation was analysed regularly.

“If it comes to a point where there is nothing more that we think we can do, if there is no perpetrator of the crime to be found, then the next step would be to archive”, he agreed.
But for the time being, “there is no deadline”.

“We are still working with the Metropolitan Police”, he stressed, and there has been an “enormous effort” in terms of PJ resources in the joint police collaboration.

- See more at: http://portugalresident.com/second-british-police-source-slams-%E2%82%AC15-million-maddie-probe#sthash.m7Gu6SsD.VsEE2Hxc.dpuf

How patronising to say Portugal is 'doing it's bit'. The case is not a UK case, it's a Portuguese case which the UK are helping with, not the other way round. Anyone arrested will be arrested by the PJ and any trial will take place in Portugal.

Operation Grange doesn't work exclusively on this case either. A Major Investigation Team (28 officers and 6 support staff)  and 3 Murder Review Officers are assigned to OG. Group numbers may change depending upon need. The MIT continues to investigate it's outstanding homicide cases also.
http://www.met.police.uk/foi/pdfs/disclosure_2012/april_2012/2011120000923.pdf
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Brietta on September 06, 2015, 07:45:07 AM
Portugal did its bit at the time and is being gracious in doing extra bits for the benefit of two negligent parents, in order to help find their child, thanks for bringing it up

Actually, the parents whatever you may think of their parenting skills have never really figured in the thinking of the present Portuguese investigation, once the evidence had been properly looked at and they were eliminated from the inquiry.

The Portuguese and the Brits reopened Madeleine's case only because both found new evidence to do so.

I think it speaks volumes that Heri has not been allowed access to the rest of the phone records of the time concerning calls made in the rest of Praia da Luz and I think that may because that is where some of the evidence which allowed Madeleine's case to be reopened is to be found.

Perhaps more concentration on these records at the time which were available to the original investigation and a little less on Madeleine McCann's parents and their friends calls might have paid the same dividend it has now.

Evidence could have been found which would have opened the inquiry up ... and who knows ... could have led to the apprehension of the perpetrator and perhaps even locating Madeleine.
Sad to think it might have been possible to do that eight long years ago if so much precious time had not been wasted following entirely the wrong theory.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Brietta on September 06, 2015, 07:52:46 AM
How patronising to say Portugal is 'doing it's bit'. The case is not a UK case, it's a Portuguese case which the UK are helping with, not the other way round. Anyone arrested will be arrested by the PJ and any trial will take place in Portugal.

Operation Grange doesn't work exclusively on this case either. A Major Investigation Team (28 officers and 6 support staff)  and 3 Murder Review Officers are assigned to OG. Group numbers may change depending upon need. The MIT continues to investigate it's outstanding homicide cases also.
http://www.met.police.uk/foi/pdfs/disclosure_2012/april_2012/2011120000923.pdf

I'm terribly sorry that yet again you find fault with what I have posted ... but nothing at all unusual there.  Since I appear to be such an irritant to you perhaps you should consider doing with me , what I am going to do with you ... and that is to ignore you entirely.

Less interesting that way but certainly less troublesome ... so bye for now.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: G-Unit on September 06, 2015, 07:57:49 AM
Actually, the parents whatever you may think of their parenting skills have never really figured in the thinking of the present Portuguese investigation, once the evidence had been properly looked at and they were eliminated from the inquiry.

The Portuguese and the Brits reopened Madeleine's case only because both found new evidence to do so.

I think it speaks volumes that Heri has not been allowed access to the rest of the phone records of the time concerning calls made in the rest of Praia da Luz and I think that may because that is where some of the evidence which allowed Madeleine's case to be reopened is to be found.

Perhaps more concentration on these records at the time which were available to the original investigation and a little less on Madeleine McCann's parents and their friends calls might have paid the same dividend it has now.

Evidence could have been found which would have opened the inquiry up ... and who knows ... could have led to the apprehension of the perpetrator and perhaps even locating Madeleine.
Sad to think it might have been possible to do that eight long years ago if so much precious time had not been wasted following entirely the wrong theory.

How do you know what the Portuguese investigation is doing? Are they informing you? Do you have a cite? Why should Heri or anyone else be allowed access to evidence in an ongoing investigation? How arrogant to even expect it. The rest of the post seems to be just more of the same old complaining about the original Portuguese investigation.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: G-Unit on September 06, 2015, 08:06:53 AM
I'm terribly sorry that yet again you find fault with what I have posted ... but nothing at all unusual there.  Since I appear to be such an irritant to you perhaps you should consider doing with me , what I am going to do with you ... and that is to ignore you entirely.

Less interesting that way but certainly less troublesome ... so bye for now.

If you checked your facts before posting there would be no need to correct them. You don't irritate me at all, I'm completely indifferent to you as a person. If I seem to spend more time replying to your posts than you feel comfortable with it could be because they are less than factual more often than other posts. It makes no difference to me whether you ignore me or not, it won't stop me from correcting false information.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Mr Gray on September 06, 2015, 08:12:46 AM
Portugal did its bit at the time and is being gracious in doing extra bits for the benefit of two negligent parents, in order to help find their child, thanks for bringing it up

what absolute tosh...Portugal is investigating a crime...not helping the parents...
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Mr Gray on September 06, 2015, 08:14:49 AM
How patronising to say Portugal is 'doing it's bit'. The case is not a UK case, it's a Portuguese case which the UK are helping with, not the other way round. Anyone arrested will be arrested by the PJ and any trial will take place in Portugal.

Operation Grange doesn't work exclusively on this case either. A Major Investigation Team (28 officers and 6 support staff)  and 3 Murder Review Officers are assigned to OG. Group numbers may change depending upon need. The MIT continues to investigate it's outstanding homicide cases also.
http://www.met.police.uk/foi/pdfs/disclosure_2012/april_2012/2011120000923.pdf

wrong again...SY are carrying out there own investigation with help from the Portuguese....if they were simply helping the Portuguese they would not need the ILORs
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Mr Gray on September 06, 2015, 08:19:06 AM
Actually, the parents whatever you may think of their parenting skills have never really figured in the thinking of the present Portuguese investigation, once the evidence had been properly looked at and they were eliminated from the inquiry.

The Portuguese and the Brits reopened Madeleine's case only because both found new evidence to do so.

I think it speaks volumes that Heri has not been allowed access to the rest of the phone records of the time concerning calls made in the rest of Praia da Luz and I think that may because that is where some of the evidence which allowed Madeleine's case to be reopened is to be found.

Perhaps more concentration on these records at the time which were available to the original investigation and a little less on Madeleine McCann's parents and their friends calls might have paid the same dividend it has now.

Evidence could have been found which would have opened the inquiry up ... and who knows ... could have led to the apprehension of the perpetrator and perhaps even locating Madeleine.
Sad to think it might have been possible to do that eight long years ago if so much precious time had not been wasted following entirely the wrong theory.

absolutely right
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: stephen25000 on September 06, 2015, 08:34:10 AM
It should be remembered that Portugal is 'doing it's bit' on behalf of the Madeleine McCann investigation ... and they certainly don't seem ready to wind anything down at the moment.

Wonder if Mr O'Conner is not slightly abashed now that it has been confirmed from Portuguese sources that the case is very active indeed with action due to be taken on yet another letter of request. 
It rather shows he really knows as much as we do about the progress being made in Madeleine's case, but appears to have less understanding about the time and money consuming formalities involved, such as letters of request.

**Snip
Here, PJ police are famous for playing their cards close to their chests. Last week national director Pedro do Carmo told the Resident that Portuguese costs in the hunt that began eight years ago “cannot be quantified”.

“We don’t have budgets for specific investigations”, he explained, adding that, unlike the UK - where Grange has a 30-strong team working full time - the PJ team in Porto running the Portuguese hunt is not exclusively working on the British toddler’s disappearance.

“It has other cases”, he told us. “Other disappearances. None of them children”.

Carmo said the Portuguese investigation was analysed regularly.

“If it comes to a point where there is nothing more that we think we can do, if there is no perpetrator of the crime to be found, then the next step would be to archive”, he agreed.
But for the time being, “there is no deadline”.

“We are still working with the Metropolitan Police”, he stressed, and there has been an “enormous effort” in terms of PJ resources in the joint police collaboration.

- See more at: http://portugalresident.com/second-british-police-source-slams-%E2%82%AC15-million-maddie-probe#sthash.m7Gu6SsD.VsEE2Hxc.dpuf

i.e. They have found nothing.

However, they are quite happy to continue this investigation in the vague chance something might turn up. 8)-)))
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Mr Gray on September 06, 2015, 08:36:02 AM
i.e. They have found nothing.

However, they are quite happy to continue this investigation in the vague chance something might turn up. 8)-)))

just your opinion....you have no knowledge of what SY have found and what they are working on.....
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: stephen25000 on September 06, 2015, 08:37:54 AM
just your opinion....you have no knowledge of what SY have found and what they are working on.....

Nope.

I judge by results.

Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Mr Gray on September 06, 2015, 08:39:41 AM
Nope.

I judge by results.

so its not your opinion...you think you know exactly what SY are doing
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: stephen25000 on September 06, 2015, 08:42:34 AM
so its not your opinion...you think you know exactly what SY are doing

I'm judged by results in my job.

and that is how I view the investigation.

Money spent, with nothing tangible to show for it.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: G-Unit on September 06, 2015, 08:42:57 AM
wrong again...SY are carrying out there own investigation with help from the Portuguese....if they were simply helping the Portuguese they would not need the ILORs

True, sorry. There are two separate investigations going on. It would seem they are not following the same path as there would be no need for ILOR's if both investigations were following the same leads. I wonder if any ILOR's have been sent from Portugal to the UK?

Whatever the UK investigators conclude they can't interview, arrest or try anyone in Portugal. They will have to leave that to the Portuguese to decide. More than 'a bit' will be required from the Portuguese it would seem.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Mr Gray on September 06, 2015, 08:46:05 AM
I'm judged by results in my job.

and that is how I view the investigation.

Money spent, with nothing tangible to show for it.

so what results do SY have...what have they achieved so far...you don't know
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: stephen25000 on September 06, 2015, 08:50:25 AM
so what results do SY have...what have they achieved so far...you don't know


Well that's easy.

They haven't found Madeleine, nor have they determined how she disappeared.

YET AGAIN, to remind you, beliefs aren't evidence.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Mr Gray on September 06, 2015, 08:52:49 AM

Well that's easy.

They haven't found Madeleine, nor have they determined how she disappeared.

YET AGAIN, to remind you, beliefs aren't evidence.

I don't know why I bother with you..you don't know what progress SY have made...you have an opinion...that's all
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: stephen25000 on September 06, 2015, 08:55:16 AM
I don't know why I bother with you..you don't know what progress SY have made...you have an opinion...that's all

Like i said, in my job I'm judged by results.

That principle i apply to others.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Mr Gray on September 06, 2015, 09:00:31 AM
Like i said, in my job I'm judged by results.

That principle i apply to others.

I'm sure SY are also judged by results
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: stephen25000 on September 06, 2015, 09:07:40 AM
I'm sure SY are also judged by results

and they have not solved this case.

That is why they continue to send requests to Portugal.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Alfred R Jones on September 06, 2015, 11:11:38 AM
What 'deep-seated prejudices' do you feel would lead one to think a clearly innocent person guilty ?
You seem to have a prejudice against doctors for a start, judging by your avatar.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Alfred R Jones on September 06, 2015, 11:13:43 AM
I'll start when you do, fairs fair

just in case you didn't understand that, once you stop referring to "sceptics" as an amorphous Borg and assigning all manner of ills to every one of them for the low to the lowest aka supporters of Peter sutcliffe .as well as "some" of your ilk, that is...

and be grateful that the said sceptics don't go around blaming you for every atrocious thing said by others in "your camp" .... hope that's sorted

And YES you very often name call people on a moral stance, though you are not the gold star winner, and no don't have to quote you at all, it's all there
your post is completely meaningless without evidence.  have I ever criticised your morals personally, or called you a name?  If so put up or shut up.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Mr Gray on September 06, 2015, 11:16:11 AM
You seem to have a prejudice against doctors for a start, judging by your avatar.

I've always felt that some of the nastiness towards the McCanns comes from people who have had issues with doctors...we all know the difference between God and a doctor
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Alfred R Jones on September 06, 2015, 11:17:25 AM
They are different, no superiority involved.
OK, let's put it this way: is an informed opinion superior to an uninformed opinion?  You have already told us that it is so wriggle out of that one!  You believe your opinion holds more worth than the majority of the GBP because you believe you know all there is to know about hanging, unlike them, and if only the GBP were as educated as you are they would share your opinion.  Ergo you believe you are a better person than the majority. 
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: faithlilly on September 06, 2015, 11:19:46 AM
You seem to have a prejudice against doctors for a start, judging by your avatar.

Is that it ? Really ?   

Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Mr Gray on September 06, 2015, 11:20:05 AM
OK, let's put it this way: is an informed opinion superior to an uninformed opinion?  You have already told us that it is so wriggle out of that one!  You believe your opinion holds more worth than the majority of the GBP because you believe you know all there is to know about hanging, unlike them, and if only the GBP were as educated as you are they would share your opinion.  Ergo you believe you are a better person than the majority.

There is a strong case for capital punishment and a strong case against
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Mr Gray on September 06, 2015, 11:21:26 AM
Is that it ? Really ?

you have a prejudice against the middle class...as a stalwart left winger
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: ShiningInLuz on September 06, 2015, 11:51:34 AM
...
I think it speaks volumes that Heri has not been allowed access to the rest of the phone records of the time concerning calls made in the rest of Praia da Luz and I think that may because that is where some of the evidence which allowed Madeleine's case to be reopened is to be found.
...
Access to phone records is restricted by European and Portuguese law to recognised judicial authorities.  Heriberto's request was turned down because he is not a representative of such an authority.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Brietta on September 06, 2015, 01:13:00 PM
Access to phone records is restricted by European and Portuguese law to recognised judicial authorities.  Heriberto's request was turned down because he is not a representative of such an authority.

Thanks for that, Shining, very logical and perfectly in line with respecting and protecting peoples rights to privacy.

Which makes it all the more regrettable that the phone records of the Drs McCann group ~ and other equally sensitive personal information ~ were not protected and their right to privacy invaded by their publication on the internet.

That is inclusive of witness statements, photographs, passport details and home addresses of people unconnected to Madeleine McCann or her parents ... who had no other locus in the case but as witnesses.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Eleanor on September 06, 2015, 01:15:54 PM

Thank you, Shining and Brietta.
Could the rest of us get back On Topic, please.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Alfred R Jones on September 06, 2015, 01:29:17 PM
I resent the fact that my attempt to bring the subject back on topic in my response to G-Unit has been removed from this thread, whilst her lecture on the death penalty above (which is completely off-topic) has been allowed to remain.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Alfred R Jones on September 06, 2015, 01:38:33 PM
In my opinion there is in some quarter a deep seated resentment of public money being spent to try and find the child of a middle class background, of a well-off pair of doctors.  How often have we heard "if she'd been the child of a pair of council house chavs we'd never have heard of her and no money would have been spent looking for her"?    I would say there is definitely a 'chip-on-the-shoulder' class resentment at play in the criticism of the McCanns and the investigation into their child's disappearance.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: faithlilly on September 06, 2015, 01:42:48 PM
Thanks for that, Shining, very logical and perfectly in line with respecting and protecting peoples rights to privacy.

Which makes it all the more regrettable that the phone records of the Drs McCann group ~ and other equally sensitive personal information ~ were not protected and their right to privacy invaded by their publication on the internet.

That is inclusive of witness statements, photographs, passport details and home addresses of people unconnected to Madeleine McCann or her parents ... who had no other locus in the case but as witnesses.

So are you now saying that the authorities refusal to divulge to Heri phone information which was not already in the public domain has no significance re the ongoing investigation.

I really do with you'd make your mind up !
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Alfred R Jones on September 06, 2015, 01:50:59 PM
This thread is about the amount of money being spent to look for their child, not the fact that they weren't prosecuted for neglect. 
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: faithlilly on September 06, 2015, 01:54:19 PM
In my opinion there is in some quarter a deep seated resentment of public money being spent to try and find the child of a middle class background, of a well-off pair of doctors.  How often have we heard "if she'd been the child of a pair of council house chavs we'd never have heard of her and no money would have been spent looking for her"?    I would say there is definitely a 'chip-on-the-shoulder' class resentment at play in the criticism of the McCanns and the investigation into their child's disappearance.

And I would say the majority of the McCanns support is split between rather obvious social climbers who believe support of 'their betters' will somehow bestow a certain moral and social standing on them and easily manipulated tabloid readers ( a section of the population who the McCanns have targeted with great effect ) who look no further than the fact that they are seemingly two parents who has had the worst thing happen to them.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: stephen25000 on September 06, 2015, 01:56:28 PM
This thread is about the amount of money being spent to look for their child, not the fact that they weren't prosecuted for neglect.

Yes we know Alfred.

and there is nothing at all to show for it.

Just more letters to Portugal.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Brietta on September 06, 2015, 01:56:58 PM


The Portuguese Prosecutor couldn't make it plainer that the Sun headlines are garbage when it comes to dealing with Madeleine McCann's case which is very much a live one on two fronts.

Neither the British nor the Portuguese authorities considered the Drs McCann guilty of neglecting their children it is extraordinary that you have taken it upon yourself to disagree with that.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: stephen25000 on September 06, 2015, 02:03:05 PM

The Portuguese Prosecutor couldn't make it plainer that the Sun headlines are garbage when it comes to dealing with Madeleine McCann's case which is very much a live one on two fronts.

Neither the British nor the Portuguese authorities considered the Drs McCann guilty of neglecting their children it is extraordinary that you have taken it upon yourself to disagree with that.

All there is is letters of request to Portugal.

Nothing more.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Brietta on September 06, 2015, 02:03:10 PM
Would she have disappeared if she and her siblings had been cared for and not left to fend for themselves ?

Yes or No will suffice.

Don't you have an opinion on the Sun article ... even criticism of the punctuation would be a start ... or are you just trying to obsessively derail yet another thread?
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: stephen25000 on September 06, 2015, 02:04:59 PM
Don't you have an opinion on the Sun article ... even criticism of the punctuation would be a start ... or are you just trying to obsessively derail yet another thread?

Yet another personal attack brietta.

Again par for the course from you.

Do you really believe that Madeleine will be found alive and well after all this time and yet, not a trace of her to date ?
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Alfred R Jones on September 06, 2015, 02:13:42 PM
And I would say the majority of the McCanns support is split between rather obvious social climbers who believe support of 'their betters' will somehow bestow a certain moral and social standing on them and easily manipulated tabloid readers ( a section of the population who the McCanns have targeted with great effect ) who look no further than the fact that they are seemingly two parents who has had the worst thing happen to them.
You really do have a superiority complex don't you?  You seem to have total contempt for "tabloid readers" and think they're all thick proles who are easily led and unable to hold a valid opinion on anything.  These are the salt-of-the earth working men and women of this country you are writing off with such contempt - Jeremy would be appalled!
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: jassi on September 06, 2015, 02:25:22 PM
You really do have a superiority complex don't you? You seem to have total contempt for "tabloid readers" and think they're all thick proles who are easily led and unable to hold a valid opinion on anything.  These are the salt-of-the earth working men and women of this country you are writing off with such contempt - Jeremy would be appalled!

I don't know if  Faith would fit into that category, but are are certainly a few on here with a grand opinion of themselves and their superior intellect.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Mr Gray on September 06, 2015, 02:41:37 PM
All there is is letters of request to Portugal.

Nothing more.

could you tell us exactly how you know what progress SY have made
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Alfred R Jones on September 06, 2015, 02:46:28 PM
I don't know if  Faith would fit into that category, but are are certainly a few on here with a grand opinion of themselves and their superior intellect.
I think Faith fits that description to a tee, personally.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: stephen25000 on September 06, 2015, 02:48:46 PM
could you tell us exactly how you know what progress SY have made

Have they found Madeleine ?

Have they solved her disappearance ?
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Eleanor on September 06, 2015, 02:49:55 PM
And I would say the majority of the McCanns support is split between rather obvious social climbers who believe support of 'their betters' will somehow bestow a certain moral and social standing on them and easily manipulated tabloid readers ( a section of the population who the McCanns have targeted with great effect ) who look no further than the fact that they are seemingly two parents who has had the worst thing happen to them.

I do so agree, at least when it comes to me.  I am a working class gutter snipe with pretentions, and hope by supporting The McCanns that I will somehow become middle class and attain the distinction that has somehow always eluded me.
Phfftt.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: jassi on September 06, 2015, 02:55:04 PM
I do so agree, at least when it comes to me.  I am a working class gutter snipe with pretentions, and hope by supporting The McCanns that I will somehow become middle class and attain the distinction that has somehow always eluded me.
Phfftt.

Sorry to disappoint you, but you can never be middle class, whatever your pretensions and aspirations.
However, your descendants might well be
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Alfred R Jones on September 06, 2015, 02:55:19 PM
I do so agree, at least when it comes to me.  I am a working class gutter snipe with pretentions, and hope by supporting The McCanns that I will somehow become middle class and attain the distinction that has somehow always eluded me.
Phfftt.
@)(++(*
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Alfred R Jones on September 06, 2015, 02:56:10 PM
Sorry to disappoint you, but you can never be middle class, whatever your pretensions and aspirations.
However, your descendants might well be
what class are the McCanns?
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: faithlilly on September 06, 2015, 02:58:09 PM
You really do have a superiority complex don't you?  You seem to have total contempt for "tabloid readers" and think they're all thick proles who are easily led and unable to hold a valid opinion on anything.  These are the salt-of-the earth working men and women of this country you are writing off with such contempt - Jeremy would be appalled!

Non, now Alfie do you really think that Jeremy is targeting his campaign at your average Sun/Mirror/Express/Star reader ?
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Mr Gray on September 06, 2015, 02:59:03 PM
And I would say the majority of the McCanns support is split between rather obvious social climbers who believe support of 'their betters' will somehow bestow a certain moral and social standing on them and easily manipulated tabloid readers ( a section of the population who the McCanns have targeted with great effect ) who look no further than the fact that they are seemingly two parents who has had the worst thing happen to them.

so which group does David Cameron fall into... plusanother couple of prime ministers....J K rowling...Richard Branson...Redwood......


don't you find it strange that amaral has no support from similar people in Portugal
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: jassi on September 06, 2015, 02:59:40 PM
Gerry is working class. Kate might be middle class. Their children are undoubtedly  middle class.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Mr Gray on September 06, 2015, 03:03:02 PM
Non, now Alfie do you really think that Jeremy is targeting his campaign at your average Sun/Mirror/Express/Star reader ?

without them he has no chance of winning an election. In fact now that labour has lost Scotland Labour has no chance of winning the election anyway. Labour's only chance of success is taking the middle ground...you think they would realise this.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: faithlilly on September 06, 2015, 03:04:32 PM
Gerry is working class. Kate might be middle class. Their children are undoubtedly  middle class.

Gerry comes from the less salubrious side of Galsgow though fair play to him he has pulled himself up by his bootstraps ( perhaps that's why he's done his damnedest to retain his position )
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: faithlilly on September 06, 2015, 03:06:55 PM
what class are the McCanns?

Working class made good....same as myself really  8(0(*
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Alfred R Jones on September 06, 2015, 03:07:44 PM
Non, now Alfie do you really think that Jeremy is targeting his campaign at your average Sun/Mirror/Express/Star reader ?
why wouldn't he be?  Does he think they're too dumb to understand what he's about?
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: jassi on September 06, 2015, 03:09:34 PM
Working class made guide....same as myself really  8(0(*


The same for many of us. I enjoy a comfortable middle class lifestyle, but still remain working class
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Alfred R Jones on September 06, 2015, 03:10:14 PM
Working class made guide....same as myself really  8(0(*
Made good, do you mean? We'll have to take your word for it that you made it as good as the McCanns did, won't we?  Clearly you're not  a doctor though!
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Alfred R Jones on September 06, 2015, 03:13:29 PM

The same for many of us. I enjoy a comfortable middle class lifestyle, but still remain working class
Then you are a social climber, same as Faith, same as the McCanns, whereas I was born middle class and remain so, therefore according to Faithliily's reasoning you should both be McCann supporters whilst I must be a thicko sheep, or something.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: jassi on September 06, 2015, 03:18:35 PM
Then you are a social climber, same as Faith, same as the McCanns, whereas I was born middle class and remain so, therefore according to Faithliily's reasoning you should both be McCann supporters whilst I must be a thicko sheep, or something.

I've never thought of myself as a Hyacinth Bucket, just as upwardly mobile due to a decent education.  ?{)(**
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Eleanor on September 06, 2015, 03:34:34 PM
Sorry to disappoint you, but you can never be middle class, whatever your pretensions and aspirations.
However, your descendants might well be

They already are.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Alfred R Jones on September 06, 2015, 03:38:13 PM
I've never thought of myself as a Hyacinth Bucket, just as upwardly mobile due to a decent education.  ?{)(**
me neither but apparently us McCann supporters are either working class social climbers or ignorant sheep, or so Faithlilly would have us believe.  I don't believe I fall into either category, which means I'm probably a shape-shifting lizard or something.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: jassi on September 06, 2015, 03:42:15 PM
me neither but apparently us McCann supporters are either working class social climbers or ignorant sheep, or so Faithlilly would have us believe.  I don't believe I fall into either category, which means I'm probably a shape-shifting lizard or something.


Could well be. Do you find you shed your skin on a regular basis?
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Alfred R Jones on September 06, 2015, 03:59:33 PM

Could well be. Do you find you shed your skin on a regular basis?
I used to but I have a cream for that now.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Mr Gray on September 06, 2015, 04:11:59 PM
Have they found Madeleine ?

Have they solved her disappearance ?

it seems you actually are under some sort of illusion that you know what progress SY have made.....another sceptic who does not know what is real and what is imaginary
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: stephen25000 on September 06, 2015, 04:48:20 PM
it seems you actually are under some sort of illusion that you know what progress SY have made.....another sceptic who does not know what is real and what is imaginary

I don' t believe on fantasy stories, do you ?
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Eleanor on September 06, 2015, 04:49:21 PM
I used to but I have a cream for that now.

 @)(++(* @)(++(*
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Mr Gray on September 06, 2015, 04:50:58 PM
I don' t believe on fantasy stories, do you ?

what fantasy story are you talking about
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: faithlilly on September 06, 2015, 04:55:33 PM
Made good, do you mean? We'll have to take your word for it that you made it as good as the McCanns did, won't we?  Clearly you're not  a doctor though!

Neither is Richard Branson I believe.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Mr Gray on September 06, 2015, 04:56:37 PM
so tell me Stephen..what is the probability in your opinion that the mccanns are telling the truth re not covering up an accident
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Mr Gray on September 06, 2015, 04:57:35 PM
Neither is Richard Branson I believe.

his daughter is
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: faithlilly on September 06, 2015, 04:58:24 PM
Then you are a social climber, same as Faith, same as the McCanns, whereas I was born middle class and remain so, therefore according to Faithliily's reasoning you should both be McCann supporters whilst I must be a thicko sheep, or something.

If the cap fits Alfie  8(0(*
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Eleanor on September 06, 2015, 04:59:32 PM
Oh, good.  Back On Topic.

Does Operation Grange in fact not have a clue?

Whoops.  Did I speak too soon?
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: jassi on September 06, 2015, 05:04:12 PM
I have no doubt that SY know what went down. Their difficulty will be in proving anything to the satisfaction of a court of law.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Mr Gray on September 06, 2015, 05:17:06 PM
I have no doubt that SY know what went down. Their difficulty will be in proving anything to the satisfaction of a court of law.

You have no doubt...I find that more than a little ridiculous...solved from the comfort of your armchair. I can't see how SY would spend 11 mill if they knew the parents dunit...which is what you are insinuating. if it can's be proved to a court...if there is not even enough evidence to bring it to court then that would suggest...there's a good word...the parents are innocent
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: jassi on September 06, 2015, 05:20:12 PM
Don't try to put words into my mouth.
I don't consider that I have solved the case, but I very much doubt that SY will be able to bring anything to court.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Mr Gray on September 06, 2015, 05:23:14 PM
Don't try to put words into my mouth.
I don't consider that I have solved anything, but I very much doubt that SY will be able to bring anything to court.

I don't need to put words into your mouth...you have made it quite clear you suspect the parents...or are you now suggesting SY have found the culprit in Portugal...I don't think so
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Alice Purjorick on September 06, 2015, 05:24:11 PM
Removed !
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: jassi on September 06, 2015, 05:29:34 PM
I don't need to put words into your mouth...you have made it quite clear you suspect the parents...or are you now suggesting SY have found the culprit in Portugal...I don't think so

I make no secret of my views and I don't believe they (SY) have anything to actually incriminate any culprit.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Mr Gray on September 06, 2015, 05:34:49 PM
I make no secret of my views and I don't believe they (SY) have anything to actually incriminate any culprit.

so you think they know the parents dunit based on gut feeling...and you have no doubt about this
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Eleanor on September 06, 2015, 05:41:16 PM
I make no secret of my views and I don't believe they (SY) have anything to actually incriminate any culprit.

Least of all The Abductor?  I wouldn't bank on that if I were you.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: stephen25000 on September 06, 2015, 05:58:05 PM
Least of all The Abductor?  I wouldn't bank on that if I were you.

Are yes, the fictional abductor.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Alfred R Jones on September 06, 2015, 06:05:15 PM
Neither is Richard Branson I believe.
??? Neither is he working class done good!
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: jassi on September 06, 2015, 06:06:16 PM
Least of all The Abductor?  I wouldn't bank on that if I were you.

I'll believe an abductor when I see him/her arrested and charged.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Mr Gray on September 06, 2015, 06:10:58 PM
I'll believe an abductor when I see him/her arrested and charged.

and I will believe the mccanns are involved once they are arrested and charged
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: stephen25000 on September 06, 2015, 06:11:18 PM
I'll believe an abductor when I see him/her arrested and charged.

Once in a Blue Moon. 8)-)))
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: stephen25000 on September 06, 2015, 06:12:14 PM
and I will believe the mccanns are involved once they are arrested and charged

They won't be, it's too late for that.

However, the case won't be solved either.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Alfred R Jones on September 06, 2015, 06:13:02 PM
If the cap fits Alfie  8(0(*
So you believe I'm of low intelligence and easily led.  Seriously?
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Alfred R Jones on September 06, 2015, 06:14:14 PM
I'll believe an abductor when I see him/her arrested and charged.
Not even then, I'll wager.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Mr Gray on September 06, 2015, 06:15:46 PM
So you believe I'm of low intelligence and easily led.  Seriously?

don't worry Alfred it seems I am as well...these sceptics are just so intuitive...and not easily fooled
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Mr Gray on September 06, 2015, 06:16:19 PM
Not even then, I'll wager.

you're absolutely right
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: jassi on September 06, 2015, 06:16:47 PM
Not even then, I'll wager.

Wrong. I'll be quite content with the verdict of a court of law.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Mr Gray on September 06, 2015, 06:20:12 PM
Wrong. I'll be quite content with the verdict of a court of law.

what about if the evidence was very weak and the accused of low intelligence...then the jury took 3 weeks to decide and the judge accepted a split decision
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: jassi on September 06, 2015, 06:21:56 PM
A court verdict must stand - unless it is later overturned by an appeal. That is how the system works.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Mr Gray on September 06, 2015, 06:23:02 PM
A court verdict must stand - unless it is later overturned by an appeal. That is how the system works.

I understand how the system works but do you think everyone who is found guilty is guilty
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: jassi on September 06, 2015, 06:25:27 PM
Probably not, but that's how the system works. If we don't accept the findings of the law, then we risk anarchy.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Mr Gray on September 06, 2015, 06:28:54 PM
Probably not, but that's how the system works. If we don't accept the findings of the law, then we risk anarchy.

but the law does not class the mccanns as suspects yet posters here do...anarchy
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: jassi on September 06, 2015, 06:32:52 PM
That might be so if the Law had pronounced on this case, which it hasn't. All we have had is the opiniont of a mid-ranking police officer, who has now retired.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: stephen25000 on September 06, 2015, 06:37:25 PM
That might be so if the Law had pronounced on this case, which it hasn't. All we have had is the pronouncement of a mid-ranking police officer, who has now retired.

Who is a believer.

and what does he believe...

Oh yes, Madeleine might be alive or dead.

and he believes in abduction, but BHH said the case, in his slip, was a murder investigation.

The case of the left hand not knowing what the right hand was doing.

Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Alfred R Jones on September 06, 2015, 06:46:21 PM
Wrong. I'll be quite content with the verdict of a court of law.
I seriously doubt that.  You weren't content when the McCanns weren't prosecuted for neglect, nor when the PT investigation concluded there was no evidence to suggest they were guilty of a heinous crime so what would change?
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Mr Gray on September 06, 2015, 06:46:25 PM
Who is a believer.

and what does he believe...

Oh yes, Madeleine might be alive or dead.

and he believes in abduction, but BHH said the case, in his slip, was a murder investigation.

The case of the left hand not knowing what the right hand was doing.

if the dogs had been reliable we would have known if maddie had died in the apartment or not
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Mr Gray on September 06, 2015, 06:48:47 PM
Who is a believer.

and what does he believe...

Oh yes, Madeleine might be alive or dead.

and he believes in abduction, but BHH said the case, in his slip, was a murder investigation.

The case of the left hand not knowing what the right hand was doing.

maddie could have been both abducted and murdered...try and think
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: jassi on September 06, 2015, 06:50:12 PM
I seriously doubt that.  You weren't content when the McCanns weren't prosecuted for neglect, nor when the PT investigation concluded there was no evidence to suggest they were guilty of a heinous crime so what would change?

Wrong again. You need to show me these posts where I express this  discontent.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: stephen25000 on September 06, 2015, 06:55:33 PM
maddie could have been both abducted and murdered...try and think

I can think perfectly well for myself without any guidance from you.

Never believed the abduction from early on.

Too many holes in the story.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Alfred R Jones on September 06, 2015, 06:56:13 PM
Wrong again. You need to show me these posts where I express this  discontent.
OK, so you were quite content that the McCanns weren't prosecuted for child neglect or charged with hiding their child's body by the PT authorities - who knew!  But it begs the question - why do you still seem quite keen for the McCanns to get what you believe is coming to them?  Or have I got the wrong impression of you?
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: jassi on September 06, 2015, 06:59:19 PM
OK, so you were quite content that the McCanns weren't prosecuted for child neglect or charged with hiding their child's body by the PT authorities - who knew!  But it begs the question - why do you still seem quite keen for the McCanns to get what you believe is coming to them?  Or have I got the wrong impression of you?


Yes, I am quite keen, but If I'm wrong and somebody else is convicted, so be it. Until then, I'll hold to my view with no explanation to anyone.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Alfred R Jones on September 06, 2015, 07:01:36 PM

Yes, I am quite keen, but If I'm wrong and somebody else is convicted, so be it. Until then, I'll hold to my view with no explanation to anyone.
You cannot be both content that the McCanns did not face earlier prosecution and keen that they face future prosecution - that doesn't make much sense does it?
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: jassi on September 06, 2015, 07:05:17 PM
You cannot be both content that the McCanns did not face earlier prosecution and keen that they face future prosecution - that doesn't make much sense does it?

It does if you take the philosophical view that one cannot change or influence these events. If the authorities chose to think differently to me, I can live with that without losing any sleep. That's one of the reasons I don't spend most my life on this site.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Alfred R Jones on September 06, 2015, 07:14:05 PM
It does if you take the philosophical view that one cannot change or influence these events. If the authorities chose to think differently to me, I can live with that without losing any sleep. That's one of the reasons I don't spend most my life on this site.
I didn't for one moment suggest that you wouldn't be able to live with the news that an abductor had been arrested and charged, just that you wouldn't gracefully accept that the McCanns were not guilty of all the crimes that you currently imagine they are guilty of.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: jassi on September 06, 2015, 07:19:35 PM
I didn't for one moment suggest that you wouldn't be able to live with the news that an abductor had been arrested and charged, just that you wouldn't gracefully accept that the McCanns were not guilty of all the crimes that you currently imagine they are guilty of.

Ah, but I would, I would accept my error and move on. There are far more important things in my life than the family McCann.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: stephen25000 on September 06, 2015, 07:20:39 PM
I didn't for one moment suggest that you wouldn't be able to live with the news that an abductor had been arrested and charged, just that you wouldn't gracefully accept that the McCanns were not guilty of all the crimes that you currently imagine they are guilty of.

and what of you alfred.

What if you are wrong ?
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Alfred R Jones on September 06, 2015, 07:22:14 PM
Ah, but I would, I would accept my error and move on. There are far more important things in my life than the family McCann.
We'll see...
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Alfred R Jones on September 06, 2015, 07:24:10 PM
and what of you alfred.

What if you are wrong ?
I will tar and feather myself and beg your humble forgiveness, then devote the rest of my miserable life to the welfare of retired cadaver dogs.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: jassi on September 06, 2015, 07:26:21 PM
I will tar and feather myself and beg your humble forgiveness, then devote the rest of my miserable life to the welfare of retired cadaver dogs.

 @)(++(*  We'll look forward to that.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Eleanor on September 06, 2015, 07:27:16 PM
If I am wrong I shall feel no shame at all.  I haven't spent the last eight years libelling and harassing  anyone.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: stephen25000 on September 06, 2015, 07:27:39 PM
I will tar and feather myself and beg your humble forgiveness, then devote the rest of my miserable life to the welfare of retired cadaver dogs.

Now that would be an interesting spectacle.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: jassi on September 06, 2015, 07:28:47 PM
If I am wrong I shall feel no shame at all.  I haven't spent the last eight years libelling and harassing  anyone.


No one?  What a blameless life you must have lived   ?{)(**
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Mr Gray on September 06, 2015, 07:36:51 PM
I can think perfectly well for myself without any guidance from you.

Never believed the abduction from early on.

Too many holes in the story.

The accident idea is totally impossible imo... Then there are loads more reasons to rule out the parents
That makes abduction highly probable
And that's  why I believe abduction happened
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Alfred R Jones on September 06, 2015, 07:36:59 PM
Now that would be an interesting spectacle.
Shame for you it's one that you will never, ever witness as there will never be a need for me to do any of those things.  I bet you wake up every morning to switch on your radio hoping to hear the news that the McCanns have been arrested don't you?
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Eleanor on September 06, 2015, 07:38:27 PM

No one?  What a blameless life you must have lived   ?{)(**

I have indeed on that score.  No one is perfect so I prefer not to judge.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: jassi on September 06, 2015, 07:39:27 PM
I'm just glad to wake up every morning   @)(++(*
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: stephen25000 on September 06, 2015, 07:47:50 PM
Shame for you it's one that you will never, ever witness as there will never be a need for me to do any of those things.  I bet you wake up every morning to switch on your radio hoping to hear the news that the McCanns have been arrested don't you?

No I don't.

Too much egg on too many faces for that to happen.

As it happens there is as much likelihood of you what you stated as there ever being an abductor.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Mr Gray on September 06, 2015, 07:53:11 PM
No I don't.

Too much egg on too many faces for that to happen.

As it happens there is as much likelihood of you what you stated as there ever being an abductor.

So you think the mccanns are being protected by those in power
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: slartibartfast on September 06, 2015, 09:39:30 PM
So you think the mccanns are being protected by those in power

I think in any situation in which so much has been invested it is very difficult for those who have invested to contemplate alternate causes.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: mercury on September 06, 2015, 11:57:41 PM
your post is completely meaningless without evidence.  have I ever criticised your morals personally, or called you a name?  If so put up or shut up.

Did it go over your head? you don't need to name any personally when you lump anyone and everyone in when you constantly deride "people who ask questions" as if it is any sort of crime!

Don't act dishonest or silly.

So, therefore, it's not at all a case of put up or shut up is it?

Don't answer that, no need.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: Alfred R Jones on September 07, 2015, 08:16:48 AM
Did it go over your head? you don't need to name any personally when you lump anyone and everyone in when you constantly deride "people who ask questions" as if it is any sort of crime!

Don't act dishonest or silly.

So, therefore, it's not at all a case of put up or shut up is it?

Don't answer that, no need.
So, no evidence of my crimes against inhumanity then?  LOL.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: faithlilly on September 07, 2015, 09:54:28 AM
So you believe I'm of low intelligence and easily led.  Seriously?

No I don't think you're of low intelligence Alfie.
Title: Re: £11,000,000 pounds spent and still no clue (according to The Sun)
Post by: mercury on September 07, 2015, 08:16:33 PM
So, no evidence of my crimes against inhumanity then?  LOL.

Yes, your spelling error has been noted!

I rest my case.

 8((()*/

But add the evidence is contained in scores of your posts as detailed in my reply.