UK Justice Forum 🇬🇧

Disappeared and Abducted Children and Young Adults => Madeleine McCann (3) disappeared from her parent's holiday apartment at Ocean Club, Praia da Luz, Portugal on 3 May 2007. No trace of her has ever been found. => Topic started by: John on October 30, 2015, 02:30:09 PM

Title: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: John on October 30, 2015, 02:30:09 PM
Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?

(http://i.imgur.com/2vpQOSN.jpg?1)

Given the news that the Scotland Yard investigation into the disappearance of Madeleine McCann has been wound down to some four officers, is it time to offer a substantial reward for either her safe return or information as to her whereabouts?

The SY investigation has failed to find any trace of Madeleine despite well over £10 million being spent on the investigation.  The McCanns continue to insist that in the face of no evidence to the contrary that Madeleine could still be alive.  Indeed, the opposite could be true, she could very well have died in Portugal and been hidden there a matter of hours after disappearing.  There is also the possibility however remote that she got out of the holiday apartment and fell down an excavation or a hole.

Madeleine's parents have nothing to lose by offering a substantial reward for information, there could very well be people out there who have the key to the mystery.  The parents must decide what is more important to them, knowing what happened to their daughter and quite possibly reaching a resolution or finding someone to prosecute.

I suggest now is the time for a substantial reward to be offered.

Please discuss.


210
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: stephen25000 on October 30, 2015, 02:47:29 PM
Surely a reward was on offer from the newspapers early on, and for some time.

There were no takers, which came as no surprise at all.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reactions_to_the_disappearance_of_Madeleine_McCann
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: G-Unit on October 30, 2015, 02:57:14 PM
Everyone has their price, it's said, so anyone who was motivated by money should have emerged at the beginning, when 2.5 million was on offer.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: stephen25000 on October 30, 2015, 02:58:25 PM
Everyone has their price, it's said, so anyone who was motivated by money should have emerged at the beginning, when 2.5 million was on offer.

Precisely.

Just one of the reasons I never believed in the abduction scenario.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: John on October 30, 2015, 03:12:01 PM
Surely a reward was on offer from the newspapers early on, and for some time.

There were no takers, which came as no surprise at all.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reactions_to_the_disappearance_of_Madeleine_McCann

Things change with the passing of time.  People die or change allegiances while otherrs develop a conscience etc...

I feel the time is right, they have nothing to lose but everything to gain.  If she is out there someone knows about it.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Anna on October 30, 2015, 03:43:29 PM
1. I think the culprits know by now that they are home and dry. Unless of course there is something that we do not know about in the still running investigation.

2. Nobody wants to get involved in this case, because of all the publicity that follows it.

3. Somebody out there must know what happened to Madeleine, but I doubt that money will bring them out of the woodwork IMO


4. Hasn’t there already been several rewards offered, with no results

5. I would think that Priorities are of the essence now, as to where the search money should be spent.

6. Since so many people have donated towards the search for Madeleine and the McCanns and friends have ploughed in all the proceeds from the libel cases and the money from Kate’s book, which IIRC started with one million when the book was published.
They need to use that money wisely now that the fund is low, IMO.



Just my thoughts on this topic and all just IMO
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Mr Gray on October 30, 2015, 04:23:50 PM
Things change with the passing of time.  People die or change allegiances while otherrs develop a conscience etc...

I feel the time is right, they have nothing to lose but everything to gain.  If she is out there someone knows about it.

I agree with John...what harm would it do...someone may well know something
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Brietta on October 30, 2015, 04:52:44 PM
I agree with John...what harm would it do...someone may well know something

Immunity from prosecution would have to go hand in hand with the reward as anyone who may know enough to claim one may have gained that knowledge through complicity before or after the face.

I don't see that happening as I doubt there is any chance of either Portuguese or British law being able to make that precedent for accommodation with a perpetrator.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: stephen25000 on October 30, 2015, 04:59:12 PM
I agree with John...what harm would it do...someone may well know something

So who would put up the money then ?

The mccanns ? 8(0(*
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Alfred R Jones on October 30, 2015, 05:35:22 PM
One thing that would almost certainly happen if a large reward were publicised is that there would be a surge in sightings around the world, I'm sure there would be plenty of clucks of disapproval if some other blonde kid's face made it into the papers because someone thought it might be Madeleine and had contacted the papers.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: ShiningInLuz on October 30, 2015, 06:13:30 PM
Immunity from prosecution would have to go hand in hand with the reward as anyone who may know enough to claim one may have gained that knowledge through complicity before or after the face.

I don't see that happening as I doubt there is any chance of either Portuguese or British law being able to make that precedent for accommodation with a perpetrator.
I think this is the problem with a reward.  You need to know something, but not be implicated in the disappearance, which is unlikely.

Is it the only way = are there other ways?  That's a really tough call.  To solve the case, quite possibly not.  To progress the case, definitely yes.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Admin on October 30, 2015, 06:47:45 PM
One thing that would almost certainly happen if a large reward were publicised is that there would be a surge in sightings around the world, I'm sure there would be plenty of clucks of disapproval if some other blonde kid's face made it into the papers because someone thought it might be Madeleine and had contacted the papers.

It sure would get people searching though.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: stephen25000 on October 30, 2015, 06:49:19 PM
It sure would get people searching though.

Searching for what exactly ?
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Alfred R Jones on October 30, 2015, 06:50:32 PM
It sure would get people searching though.
It wouldn't get me searching, but if I saw someone who looked a bit like Madeleine and it was a no-risk possibility that I could net £2m by reporting my sighting I might be tempted.  Multiply that by x million people and what have you got?  Thousands of new sightings but with no police force investigating, no real means of investigating them all. 
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: mercury on October 30, 2015, 06:55:50 PM
It sure would get people searching though.

If that were really the case surely the parents would have not taken down off their website the reward offer (2.6m) from the businessmen/news of the world in the first place. A rather strange decision but qualified by the reason that they had taken advice and rewards have their cons as well as pro s

http://www.gerrymccannsblogs.co.uk/Email_Reward.htm

Ps ...The reward is /was for concrete info leading to a safe return, not sightings, which reached around 9000 ! SY told a few days ago
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Admin on October 30, 2015, 06:56:33 PM
It wouldn't get me searching, but if I saw someone who looked a bit like Madeleine and it was a no-risk possibility that I could net £2m by reporting my sighting I might be tempted.  Multiply that by x million people and what have you got?  Thousands of new sightings but with no police force investigating, no real means of investigating them all.

In reality very few sightings are reported to police.  Isnt the whole point of the Madeleiene Fund to leave no stone unturned Alfred yet you suggest they should not explore this avenue?

If Madeleine McCann is still alive would it not be better to risk a few false hits rather than miss an opportunity to find her?
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Alfred R Jones on October 30, 2015, 07:02:47 PM
In reality very few sightings are reported to police.  Isnt the whole point of the Madeleiene Fund to leave no stone unturned Alfred yet you suggest they should not explore this avenue?

If Madeleine McCann is still alive would it not be better to risk a few false hits rather than miss an opportunity to find her?
My point is, if it were a substantial highly publicised reward it wouldn't be a few false hits, it would be thousands which would be totally counterproductive and impossible to investigate all sightings or suspicious characters thoroughly.  It could make things more difficult rather than less.    But if they have the resources in place to deal with this potential avalanche of new (but mostly false) leads, then why not?  I don't really have any strong views on it either way tbh.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Admin on October 30, 2015, 07:02:51 PM
Immunity from prosecution would have to go hand in hand with the reward as anyone who may know enough to claim one may have gained that knowledge through complicity before or after the face.

I don't see that happening as I doubt there is any chance of either Portuguese or British law being able to make that precedent for accommodation with a perpetrator.

Is it better then that Madeleine stays lost rather than missing an opportunity to send someone to jail for 7 years?
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Admin on October 30, 2015, 07:05:50 PM
My point is, if it were a substantial highly publicised reward it wouldn't be a few false hits, it would be thousands which would be totally counterproductive and impossible to investigate all sightings or suspicious characters thoroughly.  It could make things more difficult rather than less.    But if they have the resources in place to deal with this potential avalanche of new (but mostly false) leads, then why not?  I don't really have any strong views on it either way tbh.

We have provided a confidential hotline for several other cases which have been helpful and allowed us to pass information along to the proper authorities, we have resisted doing so in the Madeleine case but this could be about to change.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Brietta on October 30, 2015, 07:13:12 PM
Is it better then that Madeleine stays lost rather than missing an opportunity to send someone to jail for 7 years?

I would waive prosecution of the actual abductor if he or she were able to say what had happened to Madeleine and provide a lead to where she might be found, I would hand over the substantial reward without qualm ... but I am not the law of the land and do not have the duty of enforcement that the appointed law enforcement agencies do.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: mercury on October 30, 2015, 07:26:44 PM
I would waive prosecution of the actual abductor if he or she were able to say what had happened to Madeleine and provide a lead to where she might be found, I would hand over the substantial reward without qualm ... but I am not the law of the land and do not have the duty of enforcement that the appointed law enforcement agencies do.

Kate Mccanns mother actually said back in June 2007 (with the reward not in the equation either)  they were not interested in prosecution, just the safe return
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: pegasus on October 30, 2015, 09:19:40 PM
The Fund has only two aims - one is to search for the child - and the other is to bring the perp to justice.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: pathfinder73 on October 30, 2015, 09:52:38 PM
This is the lead they will be concentrating fully on now. SY found the patsy and released the 2008 efits many years later.

Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: G-Unit on October 30, 2015, 11:01:50 PM
It seems incredible but it can't be denied that SY arrived at the same place he was in at the time. He and his team had rejected the Tanner sighting and were focusing on the Smiths' one.

The Sunday Times was told that the efits had been passed to LP and the PJ 'by October 2009'. However, no mention of the report which accompanied the efits being handed over. Both were given to Operation Grange in 2011, but not willingly it seems;

Mr Exton said the legal threat had prevented them from handing over the report to Scotland Yard’s investigation until detectives had obtained written permission from the fund.
http://algarvenewswatch.blogspot.pt/2013/10/more-bizarre-twists-in-mccann-saga.html

Obviously the Fund paid Oakley, but did all the directors see the efits and report which was produced, or just the McCanns and Mr Kennedy? Was it the Fund which threatened the detectives legally or was it the parents? Did Operation Grange approach the McCanns for permission to get the information or did they ask the Fund directors?
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: slartibartfast on October 30, 2015, 11:07:01 PM
My point is, if it were a substantial highly publicised reward it wouldn't be a few false hits, it would be thousands which would be totally counterproductive and impossible to investigate all sightings or suspicious characters thoroughly.  It could make things more difficult rather than less.    But if they have the resources in place to deal with this potential avalanche of new (but mostly false) leads, then why not?  I don't really have any strong views on it either way tbh.

You mean like 8656 false hits?
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Miss Taken Identity on October 30, 2015, 11:24:29 PM
My point is, if it were a substantial highly publicised reward it wouldn't be a few false hits, it would be thousands which would be totally counterproductive and impossible to investigate all sightings or suspicious characters thoroughly.  It could make things more difficult rather than less.    But if they have the resources in place to deal with this potential avalanche of new (but mostly false) leads, then why not?  I don't really have any strong views on it either way tbh.

I agree with this Alfred, it would overwhelm a small team and cause a blow out.

I just wonder if SY and PJ know what happened, and who is responsible? they might do a deal with someone else who knows. family member or something just to find out her mortal state would be helpful to her parents and family.

You can rule out any assistance if it involves gypsies or paedos. Gypies have a code of 'honor among theives' type of thing.

Paedos will never, ever report on another paedo They like to share and tell stories; having access to Maddie/or her captor/killer would be a huge high for them.

They  also make millions already selling their wares online.

Ian Brady being one such cruel,murderous,nasty b******rd refuses to this day; to disclose the where abouts of the body of little Keith Bennet.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Alfred R Jones on October 30, 2015, 11:26:01 PM
You mean like 8656 false hits?
yes, if you like.  And...?
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Alfred R Jones on October 30, 2015, 11:28:30 PM
It seems incredible but it can't be denied that SY arrived at the same place he was in at the time. He and his team had rejected the Tanner sighting and were focusing on the Smiths' one.

The Sunday Times was told that the efits had been passed to LP and the PJ 'by October 2009'. However, no mention of the report which accompanied the efits being handed over. Both were given to Operation Grange in 2011, but not willingly it seems;

Mr Exton said the legal threat had prevented them from handing over the report to Scotland Yard’s investigation until detectives had obtained written permission from the fund.
http://algarvenewswatch.blogspot.pt/2013/10/more-bizarre-twists-in-mccann-saga.html

Obviously the Fund paid Oakley, but did all the directors see the efits and report which was produced, or just the McCanns and Mr Kennedy? Was it the Fund which threatened the detectives legally or was it the parents? Did Operation Grange approach the McCanns for permission to get the information or did they ask the Fund directors?
what has this post got to do with the question of a reward?
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Miss Taken Identity on October 30, 2015, 11:32:46 PM
It seems incredible but it can't be denied that SY arrived at the same place he was in at the time. He and his team had rejected the Tanner sighting and were focusing on the Smiths' one.

The Sunday Times was told that the efits had been passed to LP and the PJ 'by October 2009'. However, no mention of the report which accompanied the efits being handed over. Both were given to Operation Grange in 2011, but not willingly it seems;

Mr Exton said the legal threat had prevented them from handing over the report to Scotland Yard’s investigation until detectives had obtained written permission from the fund.
http://algarvenewswatch.blogspot.pt/2013/10/more-bizarre-twists-in-mccann-saga.html

Obviously the Fund paid Oakley, but did all the directors see the efits and report which was produced, or just the McCanns and Mr Kennedy? Was it the Fund which threatened the detectives legally or was it the parents? Did Operation Grange approach the McCanns for permission to get the information or did they ask the Fund directors?


I do find this whole thing strange! Why would they not hand over information to SY to hell with breach of confidence or whatever loop hole was in place you have a duty to report a crime or suspect a crime hqas been commited.

Maybe Exion didn't think it was GERRY?  very strange indeed.

AND i would do all this  as well:

quote
I would waive prosecution of the actual abductor if he or she were able to say what had happened to Madeleine and provide a lead to where she might be found, I would hand over the substantial reward without qualm ...
unquote

turn the corner give a hit man a nod and ...whoah huge accident !  dearie me! left living like a veg.

Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: G-Unit on October 30, 2015, 11:33:42 PM
As two investigations arrived at the same point maybe the answer is not to offer a reward but to investigate that sighting and the questions surrounding the report and the efits.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: G-Unit on October 30, 2015, 11:38:17 PM

I do find this whole thing strange! Why would they not hand over information to SY to hell with breach of confidence or whatever loop hole was in place you have a duty to report a crime or suspect a crime hqas been commited.

Maybe Exion didn't think it was GERRY?  very strange indeed.

AND i would do all this  as well:

quote
I would waive prosecution of the actual abductor if he or she were able to say what had happened to Madeleine and provide a lead to where she might be found, I would hand over the substantial reward without qualm ...
unquote

turn the corner give a hit man a nod and ...whoah huge accident !  dearie me! left living like a veg.

I would offer every penny left in the Fund for the return of my daughter. I would have done that on day 1 and kept on doing it to this day. No doubt they were advised not to do that because of the tricksters who would have emerged, but I wouldn't have cared.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Miss Taken Identity on October 30, 2015, 11:52:38 PM
As two investigations arrived at the same point maybe the answer is not to offer a reward but to investigate that sighting and the questions surrounding the report and the efits.

lol That is what I was hinting at. 8(0(*

They do know something, but missing a link of sorts. use the money to draw them/him/her/they out.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: ShiningInLuz on October 31, 2015, 07:23:16 AM
lol That is what I was hinting at. 8(0(*

They do know something, but missing a link of sorts. use the money to draw them/him/her/they out.
If this had been a minor case, a reward might have brought someone out of the woodwork with some involvement or knowledge.

I've had a look at the previous careers of DCI Andy Redwood and DCI Nicola Wall to get a handle on how both worked.  Looking at their previous cases, it appears to be common practice for the Met to offer a reward of £20,000 when the investigation is stalling.

I doubt that amount would get someone with real involvement/knowledge to risk their skin.

As has been noted, a greater reward runs the risk of false positives.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: John on November 01, 2015, 01:02:25 AM
If this had been a minor case, a reward might have brought someone out of the woodwork with some involvement or knowledge.

I've had a look at the previous careers of DCI Andy Redwood and DCI Nicola Wall to get a handle on how both worked.  Looking at their previous cases, it appears to be common practice for the Met to offer a reward of £20,000 when the investigation is stalling.

I doubt that amount would get someone with real involvement/knowledge to risk their skin.

As has been noted, a greater reward runs the risk of false positives.

This has been pointed out previously but it will do no harm to repeat it.  Tucked away in a pdf file in a far corner of the Met website the following is revealed.

Quote from: Metropolitan Police Service
REWARD

The Metropolitan Police Service is offering a reward of up to £20,000 for information leading to the identification, arrest and prosecution of the person(s) responsible for the abduction of Madeleine McCann from Praia da Luz Portugal on the 3rd May 2003.

http://content.met.police.uk/cs/Satellite?blobcol=urldata&blobheadername1=Content-Type&blobheadername2=Content-Disposition&blobheadervalue1=application%2Fpdf&blobheadervalue2=inline%3B+filename%3D%22683%2F875%2Ffinal+website+content+-+english.pdf%22&blobkey=id&blobtable=MungoBlobs&blobwhere=1283658176232&ssbinary=true


There you have it, the reward is not for the recovery of Madeleine McCann.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Brietta on November 01, 2015, 01:18:27 AM
This has been pointed out previously but it will do no harm to repeat it.  Tucked away in a pdf file in a far corner of the Met website the following is revealed.

http://content.met.police.uk/cs/Satellite?blobcol=urldata&blobheadername1=Content-Type&blobheadername2=Content-Disposition&blobheadervalue1=application%2Fpdf&blobheadervalue2=inline%3B+filename%3D%22683%2F875%2Ffinal+website+content+-+english.pdf%22&blobkey=id&blobtable=MungoBlobs&blobwhere=1283658176232&ssbinary=true


There you have it, the reward is not for the recovery of Madeleine McCann.

Reference to " ... the person(s) responsible for the abduction of Madeleine McCann" also resolves the question of whether or not Scotland Yard are looking for an abductor.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: John on November 01, 2015, 10:33:05 AM
Reference to " ... the person(s) responsible for the abduction of Madeleine McCann" also resolves the question of whether or not Scotland Yard are looking for an abductor.

...or alternatively, SY are covering their backsides just in case?
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Miss Taken Identity on November 01, 2015, 10:53:22 AM
Reference to " ... the person(s) responsible for the abduction of Madeleine McCann" also resolves the question of whether or not Scotland Yard are looking for an abductor.

Or that is what they were told to say because that was  the story all over the papers/TV from day one! because....SY did not state this from an investigation  outcome now did they?

And of course the fact that no one came forward says a lot. The sun newspaper also offered a lot more.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Brietta on November 01, 2015, 07:23:07 PM
...or alternatively, SY are covering their backsides just in case?

I don't think so, John.
They looked at what they had and went for abduction.  Just as the Policia Judiciaria went with what they had and decided they were looking for an abductor.

They have access to all the relevant information.
The Portuguese didn't require to spend much on translation and the translation SY have won't have the errors and bias of the ones we have seen.  So we don't know the full picture of what they were reviewing when all the information was collated ... including that which was sourced from the McCann Private Eyes.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: pegasus on November 03, 2015, 03:34:30 AM
To avoid the unnecessary nuisance of getting any useful response to a reward, it it should follow the example of the BBC Crimewatch appeal and should be prevented from being broadcast in portuguese language or in Portugal..
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Mr Gray on November 03, 2015, 10:44:06 AM
What would the reward be offered for
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: stephen25000 on November 03, 2015, 10:50:39 AM
£2.5 million didn't tempt anyone.

So £20,000 on offer certainly won't.

Basically,it's the last desperate throw of the dice by SY.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: ShiningInLuz on November 03, 2015, 11:11:30 AM
To avoid the unnecessary nuisance of getting any useful response to a reward, it it should follow the example of the BBC Crimewatch appeal and should be prevented from being broadcast in portuguese language or in Portugal..
Relevant point. 

I feel another page in Portuguese coming on for my blog.

£20k in Portugal is actually a large sum for the majority of people.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: John on November 03, 2015, 05:13:11 PM
I would waive prosecution of the actual abductor if he or she were able to say what had happened to Madeleine and provide a lead to where she might be found, I would hand over the substantial reward without qualm ... but I am not the law of the land and do not have the duty of enforcement that the appointed law enforcement agencies do.

Just catching up on some previous posts and I agree Brietta.  If it was my youngster I would want to see some sort of resolution as to his or her whereabouts with prosecutions being a secondary issue.  It would be interesting to know just what Scotland Yard's brief is in this renewed inquiry and not simply what consecutive SIO's have repeated in their Press briefings.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Mr Gray on November 03, 2015, 05:15:58 PM
Just catching up on some previous posts and I agree Brietta.  If it was my youngster I would want to see some sort of resolution as to his or her whereabouts with prosecutions being a secondary issue.  It would be interesting to know what exactly Scotland Yard's brief is and not what SIO's repeat in their Press briefings.

How would they be able to confirm the information given was correct without a prosecution
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: John on November 03, 2015, 05:17:53 PM
How would they be able to confirm the information given was correct without a prosecution

By immunity.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Mr Gray on November 03, 2015, 05:20:38 PM
By immunity.

Immunity for what
How could the informant prove his info was correct
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: John on November 03, 2015, 05:27:58 PM
I would offer every penny left in the Fund for the return of my daughter. I would have done that on day 1 and kept on doing it to this day. No doubt they were advised not to do that because of the tricksters who would have emerged, but I wouldn't have cared.

My feelings exactly, resolution is worth every penny.   Remember that SY have as much if not more interest in justifying their expenditure which requires a collar... any collar sometimes.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: John on November 03, 2015, 05:28:25 PM
Immunity for what
How could the informant prove his info was correct

Extremely easily.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Mr Gray on November 03, 2015, 05:31:25 PM
My feelings exactly, resolution is worth every penny.   Remember that SY have as much if not more interest in justifying their expenditure which requires a collar... any collar sometimes.

Are you talking about the McCanns offering to pay a ransom
Could SY give immunity
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: jassi on November 03, 2015, 05:39:36 PM
Are you talking about the McCanns offering to pay a ransom
Could SY give immunity

As the disappearance took place in Portugal, SY  may not be in a position to either  grant or withhold immunity from prosecution.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Mr Gray on November 03, 2015, 06:01:46 PM
As the disappearance took place in Portugal, SY  may not be in a position to either  grant or withhold immunity from prosecution.

I don't think this plan has been thought through
In what circumstances could a reward be offered
No police force would pay a ransom
What would the reward be offered for
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Mr Gray on November 03, 2015, 06:33:30 PM
Extremely easily.

tell us how....I don't think it's possible to offer any sort of reward without the arrest of the perp...anyone could claim anything.....
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: jassi on November 03, 2015, 06:57:00 PM
An informer might be able to reveal the whereabouts of Madeleine without identifying a guilty person.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Mr Gray on November 03, 2015, 07:15:35 PM
An informer might be able to reveal the whereabouts of Madeleine without identifying a guilty person.

that's one possible scenario but assumes Maddie is still alive.....wouldn't this be like paying a ransom which no police force would agree too....then there's all the problems with handing over the money...would the informer have to reveal their identity...
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: jassi on November 03, 2015, 07:35:10 PM
that's one possible scenario but assumes Maddie is still alive.....wouldn't this be like paying a ransom which no police force would agree too....then there's all the problems with handing over the money...would the informer have to reveal their identity...

I could have said 'remains or parts' but then people would complain that I was being negative.

Payment of any reward would obviously depend on what weasely wording lawyers  specified, but police wouldn't need to agree if the money was not being put up by them.  Any informer may genuinely not know the identity of any perpetrator.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Alfred R Jones on November 03, 2015, 07:40:31 PM
I could have said 'remains or parts' but then people would complain that I was being negative.

Payment of any reward would obviously depend on what weasely wording lawyers  specified, but police wouldn't need to agree if the money was not being put up by them.  Any informer may genuinely not know the identity of any perpetrator.
Anyone who knows were Madeleine's "parts" are buried is an accessory and would not come forward for a reward no matter how large IMO.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Mr Gray on November 03, 2015, 07:44:35 PM
So would the informer be investigated...it seems not...
so what is to stop the perp saying I know where Maddie is buried ....give us a million...but honestly I had nothing to do with it so don't investigate me...it can't work
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: stephen25000 on November 03, 2015, 09:12:52 PM
It is too late in the day for a reward.

As  I said earlier it just seems like the last throw of the dice by SY, who are clearly clutching at any straw.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: mercury on November 03, 2015, 11:22:06 PM
To avoid the unnecessary nuisance of getting any useful response to a reward, it it should follow the example of the BBC Crimewatch appeal and should be prevented from being broadcast in portuguese language or in Portugal..

Obviously both the BBC and the Met at the time thought it not important enough to be shown in the the most significant location of all...(if they did they would have bended their licensing rules for good reason) Portugal! IIRC  Redwood went to one of the scandinavian countries and did another show? Why did he not go to Portugal to do the same? Im sure I will be corrected if Im wrong.

As for a reward, I dont believe anyone would come forward...if they want to spill any beans they are free to anonymously, but their tracks will be covered if they go for the money, so whether innocent or guilty or half way in those two positions, its a non starter...unless offered immunity...but no force is going to do this even if the family agreed jmo
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: John on November 04, 2015, 05:16:01 PM
Obviously both the BBC and the Met at the time thought it not important enough to be shown in the the most significant location of all...(if they did they would have bended their licensing rules for good reason) Portugal! IIRC  Redwood went to one of the scandinavian countries and did another show? Why did he not go to Portugal to do the same? Im sure I will be corrected if Im wrong.

As for a reward, I dont believe anyone would come forward...if they want to spill any beans they are free to anonymously, but their tracks will be covered if they go for the money, so whether innocent or guilty or half way in those two positions, its a non starter...unless offered immunity...but no force is going to do this even if the family agreed jmo

It comes down to this, either the parents want resolution and closure or they don't.

There are plenty of people out there who would be willing to act as intermediaries.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: ShiningInLuz on November 04, 2015, 06:59:03 PM
Obviously both the BBC and the Met at the time thought it not important enough to be shown in the the most significant location of all...(if they did they would have bended their licensing rules for good reason) Portugal! IIRC  Redwood went to one of the scandinavian countries and did another show? Why did he not go to Portugal to do the same? Im sure I will be corrected if Im wrong.
...

Another IMO, but here it is.

OG wanted the continued co-operation of Portuguese judicial authorities.  Breaking the judicial secrecy law by airing Crimewatch in Portugal was like shooting themselves in the foot.

No, I can't prove this. It merely fits the little we know.

As for the BBC, if they sold the rights to a Portugal media source then it seems they would be breaking the "shall not investigate within Portugal" law, as Crimewatch definitely investigates.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Mr Gray on November 04, 2015, 07:02:25 PM
Another IMO, but here it is.

OG wanted the continued co-operation of Portuguese judicial authorities.  Breaking the judicial secrecy law by airing Crimewatch in Portugal was like shooting themselves in the foot.

No, I can't prove this. It merely fits the little we know.

As for the BBC, if they sold the rights to a Portugal media source then it seems they would be breaking the "shall not investigate within Portugal" law, as Crimewatch definitely investigates.

yes ...sounds right
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: mercury on November 04, 2015, 07:12:29 PM
It comes down to this, either the parents want resolution and closure or they don't.

There are plenty of people out there who would be willing to act as intermediaries.

True, there are always "ways and means" ..especially with all the contacts and connections made over the years


Another IMO, but here it is.

OG wanted the continued co-operation of Portuguese judicial authorities.  Breaking the judicial secrecy law by airing Crimewatch in Portugal was like shooting themselves in the foot.

No, I can't prove this. It merely fits the little we know.

As for the BBC, if they sold the rights to a Portugal media source then it seems they would be breaking the "shall not investigate within Portugal" law, as Crimewatch definitely investigates.

Do the laws of judicial secrecy apply in Portugal when a case is shelved?, in the same way as when it is an open live investigation?

I didn't see the Portuguese authorities complaining about the myriad of private investigators and other parties' activities and statements made in all the preceeding years both when the case was open and closed/shelved
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Mr Gray on November 04, 2015, 07:20:31 PM
It comes down to this, either the parents want resolution and closure or they don't.

There are plenty of people out there who would be willing to act as intermediaries.

who are these plenty of people...you are making a large but very vague claim......what you are claiming could happen is impossible...perhaps you could tell us exactly how it could work....first...how can you be sure any informant is genuine
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: ShiningInLuz on November 04, 2015, 07:24:10 PM
...
Do the laws of judicial secrecy apply in Portugal when a case is shelved?, in the same way as when it is an open live investigation?

I didn't see the Portuguese authorities complaining about the myriad of private investigators and other parties' activities and statements made in all the preceeding years both when the case was open and closed/shelved
Do the laws of judicial secrecy ....   I have not tracked both OG and the Porto case, but wasn't the Porto investigation started by the time Crimewatch 2013 aired? Whatever, I don't know so I cannot answer your question.

It remains a fact then and now that OG needs the co-operation of Portuguese authorities.

The private investigators did not have to care about this as they were never going to get the co-operation of the Portuguese authorities.

Hence the two situations are very different.  If OG shuts down and the McCanns revert to using PIs, co-operation from the Portuguese judicial authorities will be unimportant again, as they are not going to help PIs.  It just needs the PIs to stay legal, or not get caught.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Mr Gray on November 04, 2015, 07:25:45 PM
True, there are always "ways and means" ..especially with all the contacts and connections made over the years


Do the laws of judicial secrecy apply in Portugal when a case is shelved?, in the same way as when it is an open live investigation?

I didn't see the Portuguese authorities complaining about the myriad of private investigators and other parties' activities and statements made in all the preceeding years both when the case was open and closed/shelved

so you think the PJ would take kindly to SY going straight over their head and making an appeal for information in Portugal...yeah...sure
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: mercury on November 04, 2015, 07:28:32 PM
Do the laws of judicial secrecy ....   I have not tracked both OG and the Porto case, but wasn't the Porto investigation started by the time Crimewatch 2013 aired? Whatever, I don't know so I cannot answer your question.


Crimewatch was aired two weeks give or take a couple of  days before the case was reopened in Portugal and while OG was "just a review" but in reality, as you say, and also according to their remit was also partially investigative
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Mr Gray on November 04, 2015, 07:33:26 PM
Crimewatch was aired two weeks before the case was reopened in Portugal

so they did not want to upset the PJ as obviously the case was about to be re opened...simple
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: ShiningInLuz on November 04, 2015, 09:47:19 PM
Crimewatch was aired two weeks give or take a couple of  days before the case was reopened in Portugal and while OG was "just a review" but in reality, as you say, and also according to their remit was also partially investigative
Thank you for the clarification.  Obrigado!
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: John on December 07, 2015, 03:54:13 PM
All options should still be pursued and the failure to offer a no-strings-attached reward even now is in my opinion a dereliction by her parents.  They have the funds, there is nothing to lose by offering a reward, so why are they delaying?  There could very well be someone out there who can unlock this mystery and who might step up for a cash incentive.  Makng such a move would also create enormous publicity at a time when Madeleine is beginning to fade from the publc eye so it would be a win win situation.  Refusing outright or delaying such incentives certainly renders their no stone unturned boast a bit of a damp squid.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Brietta on December 07, 2015, 04:13:00 PM
All options should still be pursued and the failure to offer a no-strings-attached reward even now is in my opinion a dereliction by her parents.  They have the funds, there is nothing to lose by offering a reward, so why are they delaying?  There could very well be someone out there who can unlock this mystery and who might step up for a cash incentive.  Makng such a move would also create enormous publicity at a time when Madeleine is beginning to fade from the publc eye so it would be a win win situation.  It certainly renders their no stone unturned boast a bit of a damp squid.

Offer of a financial reward didn't work first time round.  Who knows, they may decide to go for broke and offer everything left in the kitty if the present investigations are suspended.
In my opinion if they do it will only attract similar people out to make a quick buck out of the case, but who actually know nothing, that the original offer of a reward did.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: John on December 07, 2015, 05:53:40 PM
Offer of a financial reward didn't work first time round.  Who knows, they may decide to go for broke and offer everything left in the kitty if the present investigations are suspended.
In my opinion if they do it will only attract similar people out to make a quick buck out of the case, but who actually know nothing, that the original offer of a reward did.

Sometimes the passage of time can have the desired effect.  People age and some die, allegiances fade etc...

At the end of the day the question as to what is more important has to be faced, getting resolution to Madeleine's disappearance and handing over a pile of cash to some anonymous somebody or remain in limbo with an  evergrowing fund which serves little or no purpose?  I know which one I would go for and without hesitation at that!

Apologies for going off topic, I have moved the offending posts to this thread.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: ShiningInLuz on December 07, 2015, 06:52:50 PM
Sometimes the passage of time can have the desired effect.  People age and some die, allegiances fade etc...

At the end of the day the question as to what is more important has to be faced, getting resolution to Madeleine's disappearance and handing over a pile of cash to some anonymous somebody or remain in limbo with an  evergrowing fund which serves little or no purpose?  I know which one I would go for and without hesitation at that!

Apologies for going off topic, I have moved the offending posts to this thread.
An alternative to this is to offer a reward for something that moves the case forward, even if it does not provide final resolution.

Sticking up that there is 25,000€ for leading to Smithman might do the trick, even it does not provide resolution (assuming Smithman is innocent).  It might motivate an innocent Smithman or a friend of an innocent Smithman.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Admin on December 07, 2015, 07:15:17 PM
An alternative to this is to offer a reward for something that moves the case forward, even if it does not provide final resolution.

Sticking up that there is 25,000€ for leading to Smithman might do the trick, even it does not provide resolution (assuming Smithman is innocent).  It might motivate an innocent Smithman or a friend of an innocent Smithman.

Good thinking ShiningInLuz.  It is innovative suggestions just like that which could very well unlock this case.   8((()*/
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Brietta on December 07, 2015, 07:46:06 PM
An alternative to this is to offer a reward for something that moves the case forward, even if it does not provide final resolution.

Sticking up that there is 25,000€ for leading to Smithman might do the trick, even it does not provide resolution (assuming Smithman is innocent).  It might motivate an innocent Smithman or a friend of an innocent Smithman.

It could also mean a person fitting the description with a light haired daughter of the requisite age who lived or had relations who live in the vicinity of the Smith sighting coming forward to claim the reward.

There would be no way of proving whether or not he was telling the truth or if he was in the vicinity of the sighting at the time.

25,000€ is a lot of money for some people.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: ShiningInLuz on December 07, 2015, 07:53:15 PM
It could also mean a person fitting the description with a light haired daughter of the requisite age who lived or had relations who live in the vicinity of the Smith sighting coming forward to claim the reward.

There would be no way of proving whether or not he was telling the truth or if he was in the vicinity of the sighting at the time.

25,000€ is a lot of money for some people.
You are right to add the caveat.

I was not proposing that someone says "I am Spartacus", and automatically gets a large reward.  The information would need to be corroborated.

But if evidence about who Smithman is could be brought forth and tested, and if found valid, would it be worth €25,000 to the fund?  Whether Smithman is innocent or guilty?

At the moment, Smithman has little incentive to step into the limelight and a lot of incentive to remain in the shadows.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Mr Gray on December 07, 2015, 07:59:46 PM
You are right to add the caveat.

I was not proposing that someone says "I am Spartacus", and automatically gets a large reward.  The information would need to be corroborated.

But if evidence about who Smithman is could be brought forth and tested, and if found valid, would it be worth €25,000 to the fund?  Whether Smithman is innocent or guilty?

At the moment, Smithman has little incentive to step into the limelight and a lot of incentive to remain in the shadows.

if smithman is innocent he comes forward and claims 25 K ...if he isnt he doesn't come forward...will that advance the investigation
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Admin on December 07, 2015, 08:34:08 PM
if smithman is innocent he comes forward and claims 25 K ...if he isnt he doesn't come forward...will that advance the investigation

I understand your concern davel but any verifiable information which opens the case up must surely be welcomed.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: misty on December 07, 2015, 08:55:58 PM
I understand your concern davel but any verifiable information which opens the case up must surely be welcomed.

I'm with Amaral on this issue. Justice works best in silence.
SY made their appeal re. Smithman over a year ago. Either they know who he is by now, or they don't. They have eliminated much & are now working on more focussed lines of enquiry. Why throw several spanners in the works by gambling that a million Euros will loosen the one right tongue as opposed to extending the investigation by another year or more?
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: mercury on December 07, 2015, 09:19:55 PM
if smithman is innocent he comes forward and claims 25 K ...if he isnt he doesn't come forward...will that advance the investigation

And he may be innocent and not come forward not for a mllion dollars if he deems the worlds press will have a field day on him and hs family or endanger him...and if any friends or family know/suspect it was him they probably feel the same, so a bit of a non starter either way
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: stephen25000 on December 07, 2015, 09:22:38 PM
And he may be innocent and not come forward not for a mllion dollars if he deems the worlds press will have a field day on him and hs family or endanger him...and if any friends or family know/suspect it was him they probably feel the same, so a bit of a non starter either way

There was a much larger reward on offer years ago, and that tempted no one to spill the beans.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: ShiningInLuz on December 07, 2015, 11:15:12 PM
if smithman is innocent he comes forward and claims 25 K ...if he isnt he doesn't come forward...will that advance the investigation
Looks like we are into the land of the double negative.  Let's not do anything in case it does not advance the investigation?

If a reward was offered for Smithman coming forward, or someone naming him,  and his identity remained unknown, I personally would be more inclined to think he was significant.

Please bear in mind the appeal for Smithman to come forward, within Portugal, is pretty close to zero.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Angelo222 on February 09, 2018, 02:26:04 PM
I am a great believer in offering incentives to achieve certain ends.  The Madeleine McCann mystery is in my opinion one of those situations where a reward could bring a result.  The old argument that offering a reward would in some way harm the search has now passed its sellby date.

Who agrees?
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: jassi on February 09, 2018, 02:58:46 PM
Throwing a large amount of money at yet another set of detectives if/when OG fails to come up with the goods seems a complete waste of time, so maybe a large reward might work.

Personally I think that will be a waste of time as well, but for some people, hope springs eternal.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: misty on February 09, 2018, 03:38:03 PM
I am a great believer in offering incentives to achieve certain ends.  The Madeleine McCann mystery is in my opinion one of those situations where a reward could bring a result.  The old argument that offering a reward would in some way harm the search has now passed its sellby date.

Who agrees?

When would a reward be paid - before or after a conviction?
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Eleanor on February 09, 2018, 03:47:24 PM
Throwing a large amount of money at yet another set of detectives if/when OG fails to come up with the goods seems a complete waste of time, so maybe a large reward might work.

Personally I think that will be a waste of time as well, but for some people, hope springs eternal.

What is wrong with Hope?  It is the mainstay of Life.  Perhaps you have none.  In which case you wouldn't understand.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Eleanor on February 09, 2018, 03:49:28 PM
When would a reward be paid - before or after a conviction?

Almost certainly after conviction, or the finding of Madeleine.  No point in paying out otherwise.  Anyone could lie about anything.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: misty on February 09, 2018, 03:57:39 PM
Almost certainly after conviction, or the finding of Madeleine.  No point in paying out otherwise.  Anyone could lie about anything.

Therein lies the problem. If there has been a massive cover-up & corruption at a high level, what ordinary person would risk breaking rank & then trust the authorities to ensure their (informant's) ongoing welfare?
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Eleanor on February 09, 2018, 04:11:11 PM
Therein lies the problem. If there has been a massive cover-up & corruption at a high level, what ordinary person would risk breaking rank & then trust the authorities to ensure their (informant's) ongoing welfare?

No one.  No one is going to admit to hiding evidence for Ten Years.  This would be Grossly Perverting the Course of Justice.  Although I suspect that someone knows.

Seven or eight years ago and they might have gotten away with it.  But not now.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: faithlilly on February 09, 2018, 04:45:33 PM
No one.  No one is going to admit to hiding evidence for Ten Years.  This would be Grossly Perverting the Course of Justice.  Although I suspect that someone knows.

Seven or eight years ago and they might have gotten away with it.  But not now.

Immunity could be offered at any stage.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Angelo222 on February 09, 2018, 05:01:44 PM
When would a reward be paid - before or after a conviction?

I would anticipate any reward would be collectable on achieving one or more of several aims which would have to be set out at the start. I am not proposing a simple payout on a prosecution because that might not solve the mystery.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Angelo222 on February 09, 2018, 05:04:35 PM
Immunity could be offered at any stage.

I suspect anyone coming forward would require certain guarantees.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: jassi on February 09, 2018, 05:06:30 PM
Could they do it anonymously through a lawyer or a journalist or some other 3rd party?
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Eleanor on February 09, 2018, 05:19:31 PM
Could they do it anonymously through a lawyer or a journalist or some other 3rd party?

Hardly.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: jassi on February 09, 2018, 05:24:05 PM
Why not?
A lawyer could bring forth details from the client without identifying client. If not a lawyer, then a priest - the confessional and all that. Following conviction the spondulas are handed over and everyone goes away happy.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Eleanor on February 09, 2018, 05:32:45 PM
Why not?
A lawyer could bring forth details from the client without identifying client. If not a lawyer, then a priest - the confessional and all that. Following conviction the spondulas are handed over and everyone goes away happy.

Information in such cases has to be proven with results, and whereby came the information.  This could be offered by The Abductor himself.

Would that be okay?  I don't think so.  This would be laughable.  "I abducted Madeleine McCann, so now pay me the reward because I told you what I did."
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Mr Gray on February 09, 2018, 05:42:04 PM
the uk police already pay informers but this is a portuguese investigation so its up to them
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Mr Gray on February 09, 2018, 05:52:19 PM
I suspect anyone coming forward would require certain guarantees.

Its a portugues investigation so only they can give any guarantee...according to sil the smithman sighting hasnt even been promoted in portugal never mind a reward being offered
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: jassi on February 09, 2018, 05:58:24 PM
I suppose in order to gain a conviction, they would first need to determine the crime.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Robittybob1 on February 09, 2018, 06:07:28 PM
I suppose in order to gain a conviction, they would first need to determine the crime.
If they offered total immunity and confidentiality to any and every person involved plus an enormous reward I wonder if that would be enough?
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Mr Gray on February 09, 2018, 06:11:34 PM
If they offered total immunity and confidentiality to any and every person involved plus an enormous reward I wonder if that would be enough?

thats not the way the police work...it would be like paying a ransom to a kidnapper
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: jassi on February 09, 2018, 06:14:49 PM
If they offered total immunity and confidentiality to any and every person involved plus an enormous reward I wonder if that would be enough?
Mmm depends on how many involved. If you were going to get the whole sum available, then maybe OK. If you had to share between say 9 or 10 maybe not OK
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Eleanor on February 09, 2018, 06:25:17 PM
Mmm depends on how many involved. If you were going to get the whole sum available, then maybe OK. If you had to share between say 9 or 10 maybe not OK

Gosh.  As many as that.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: jassi on February 09, 2018, 06:28:37 PM
Gosh.  As many as that.

Well you never know. There was talk of paedophile gangs and teams of burglars. Then there is the 'after market' Could be quite a few in the know.
Oh and I forgot that band of gypsies
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Eleanor on February 09, 2018, 06:34:15 PM
Well you never know. There was talk of paedophile gangs and teams of burglars. Then there is the 'after market' Could be quite a few in the know.
Oh and I forgot that band of gypsies

So No Chance then.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: jassi on February 09, 2018, 06:37:41 PM
Very little in my opinion.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Robittybob1 on February 09, 2018, 07:16:32 PM
So No Chance then.
They might have to up the offer.  "If they offered total immunity and confidentiality to any and every person involved plus an enormous reward Plus a holiday on the Algarve for everyone involved, I wonder if that would be enough?
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Carana on February 09, 2018, 07:43:31 PM
I am a great believer in offering incentives to achieve certain ends.  The Madeleine McCann mystery is in my opinion one of those situations where a reward could bring a result.  The old argument that offering a reward would in some way harm the search has now passed its sellby date.

Who agrees?

There's a section on the subject of rewards in "When your child is missing, a family survival guide". There are advantages and disadvantages. https://www.o[Name removed]dp.gov/pubs/childismissing/contents.html
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Carana on February 09, 2018, 07:59:54 PM
Immunity could be offered at any stage.

"Could" being the operative word... I haven't seen any offer of immunity from the PJ, so I'm not sure anyone who knew but chose to keep quiet would take the risk.

On the other hand, if someone simply had a suspicion, but didn't "think" to report it at the time, and then pursued that suspicion, that might be a different matter.

Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Alice Purjorick on February 09, 2018, 10:03:17 PM

http://www.ecba.org/extdocserv/conferences/brat2008/PleaBarg_CostaRamos.pdf
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: John on February 09, 2018, 10:53:48 PM
the uk police already pay informers but this is a portuguese investigation so its up to them

Actually not necessarily. Negotiations and any potential deal could be conducted outside of Portugal. The Portuguese are extrememly suspicious of their police forces and any informer would probably not wish them involved.

It could come down to solving the case but without prosecutions.  Surely knowing what happened to the child outweighs anything else?

If it was my child I would offer the remaining £750,000 in the Fund for the child's safe return, the McCanns have absolutely nothing to lose at this juncture but everything to gain.  Lets see if they do it!
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: slartibartfast on February 09, 2018, 11:32:57 PM
According to some supporters, Madeleine is with a loving family. Surely a large reward and immunity would attract that sort of abductor?
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: John on February 09, 2018, 11:44:28 PM
According to many supporters, Madeleine is with a loving family. Surely a large reward and immunity would attract that sort of abductor?

The way I see it is if there was an abductor, and that is a big IF, they have probably shared the knowledge with others.  Over time any loyality they might feel towards that person will dilute to the point that they may wish to come forward anonymously.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Erngath on February 10, 2018, 12:15:07 AM
According to many supporters, Madeleine is with a loving family. Surely a large reward and immunity would attract that sort of abductor?

Cite for many supporters believing Madeleine is with a loving family??
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: ShiningInLuz on February 10, 2018, 12:18:51 AM
I am a great believer in offering incentives to achieve certain ends.  The Madeleine McCann mystery is in my opinion one of those situations where a reward could bring a result.  The old argument that offering a reward would in some way harm the search has now passed its sellby date.

Who agrees?
It depends on the offer and where it is publicised.

Portugal does not appear to do rewards-for-information.  OG does not appear to offer for anything less than a complete solution.

But have a think.  If the 20k on offer from OG was merely offered to get Smithman to come forward, and it was publicised in Portugal as well as other countries, would it be worthwhile if Smithman came forward?

As far as I can tell, at £11m+ so far, 20k would be cheap to OG.

It would be cheap to the Find Madeleine fund.

It would be cheap to numerous media sources.

If 20k did nothing but explain the Smith sighting, I consider it would be 20k well spent.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Mr Gray on February 10, 2018, 08:44:24 AM
It depends on the offer and where it is publicised.

Portugal does not appear to do rewards-for-information.  OG does not appear to offer for anything less than a complete solution.

But have a think.  If the 20k on offer from OG was merely offered to get Smithman to come forward, and it was publicised in Portugal as well as other countries, would it be worthwhile if Smithman came forward?

As far as I can tell, at £11m+ so far, 20k would be cheap to OG.

It would be cheap to the Find Madeleine fund.

It would be cheap to numerous media sources.

If 20k did nothing but explain the Smith sighting, I consider it would be 20k well spent.

There is an ongoing  Portuguese investigation.... Two questions
Why are the pj not making any appeal in Portugal for smithman.... They seem to have, no interest
Do SY or The, Fund, have, the authority  to make an appeal in Portugal..... Interfering  with an ongoing investigation  and all that
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Mr Gray on February 10, 2018, 08:46:52 AM
According to many supporters, Madeleine is with a loving family. Surely a large reward and immunity would attract that sort of abductor?
You are mistaken... It's merely one of the possibilities... And very remote imo
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Eleanor on February 10, 2018, 08:51:28 AM

It would be against any Law to give immunity to Abductors.  What a stupid thing to suggest.

I'll just nip out and abducted a child, and then give the child back when they offer me a reward.

I think it's actually called Ransom.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Brietta on February 10, 2018, 08:56:57 AM
You are mistaken... It's merely one of the possibilities... And very remote imo

I think it is called hope, Davel.  I doubt there is anyone who is unaware of all the possibilities.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Carana on February 10, 2018, 09:42:31 AM
In the case of the little Swiss girl, Ylenia, who was abducted on her way back from the local swimming pool, the police offered a reward (CHF10k, from memory).

They already had a suspect (who committed suicide) and found his van with her clothes and bike helmet... but no sign of the child, despite numerous ground searches.

A university student decided to spend his weekends doing his own ground search... and eventually found her remains a few km away.

In that sad case, it obviously wasn't a question of bringing her alleged abductor to justice (as he was dead), but at least some closure for the family.

Whether or not he would have spent all that time searching for her without the prospect of a reward, only he knows.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Urs_Hans_von_Aesch

Not necessarily connected to the issue of rewards, but rather to appeals.

Other cases have been solved by carefully controlled appeals to the public, or simply the odd press reminder. One was the Australian little girl in the suitcase. Offhand, I can't recall any rewards being offered (but I'm not sure about that)... in any case, the response to appeals managed to unravel an extraordinarily complex case.

Another was a case (in France, Italy... ?) of relatives clearing out the home of an elderly relative who'd just died. In the attic, they found a suitcase with sufficiently odd contents in it (connected to a murder or a disappearance years prior) that they reported it to the police, as opposed to just chucking it in the dump.

There are, of course, often cases of walkers who happen to stumble on may or may not be humain remains and report it, unless they simply walk on by assuming that they probably belong to an animal.

In the Madeleine case, the Met's reward is:

REWARD

The Metropolitan Police Service is offering a reward of up to £20,000 for information leading to the identification, arrest and prosecution of the person(s) responsible for the abduction of Madeleine McCann from Praia da Luz Portugal on the 3rd May 2003.


(With thanks to John, as I'd forgotten about that one).

Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: jassi on February 10, 2018, 09:55:33 AM
Didn't the News of the World offer a much larger reward in the early than the rather paltry "up to" £20k  offered by the Met ?
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Carana on February 10, 2018, 10:36:06 AM
Didn't the News of the World offer a much larger reward in the early than the rather paltry "up to" £20k  offered by the Met ?

Yes, there were several. NotW, plus various anonymous benefactors (presumably pledges).
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: faithlilly on February 10, 2018, 11:09:51 AM
It would be against any Law to give immunity to Abductors.  What a stupid thing to suggest.

I'll just nip out and abducted a child, and then give the child back when they offer me a reward.

I think it's actually called Ransom.

Not the alleged abductor but someone close to them.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Robittybob1 on February 10, 2018, 11:12:48 AM
Not the alleged abductor but someone close to them.
Offer reward and immunity - but it is really just a sting operation.  Pure deception to bring out the truth.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: jassi on February 10, 2018, 11:16:53 AM
Not the alleged abductor but someone close to them.

Yeh but 'up to £20,000.  Peanuts. This case must be worth half a million for a solution.
After all OG has spent £12 milionl and appears no nearer a solution than it was at the beginning.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: faithlilly on February 10, 2018, 11:21:28 AM
Yeh but 'up to £20,000.  Peanuts. This case must be worth half a million for a solution.
After all OG has spent £12 milionl and appears no nearer a solution than it was at the beginning.

Agreed jassi.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Angelo222 on February 10, 2018, 11:33:59 AM
It would be against any Law to give immunity to Abductors.  What a stupid thing to suggest.

I'll just nip out and abducted a child, and then give the child back when they offer me a reward.

I think it's actually called Ransom.

A situation could arise where a choice has to be made.  Find Madeleine and give immunity or don't.  I know what my decision would be.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Mr Gray on February 10, 2018, 11:44:02 AM
A situation could arise where a choice has to be made.  Find Madeleine and give immunity or don't.  I know what my decision would be.

That's your personal choice....who has the power in this case to give immunity
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Angelo222 on February 10, 2018, 11:54:13 AM
That's your personal choice....who has the power in this case to give immunity

I used the term immunity but it doesn't have to be immunity in any legal sense.  Abductors and kidnappers are often paid if it achieves the return of the missing person.  Imo the police will never solve this case and bring anyone to trial, they have had ten years and spent almost £12m on it and achievd nothing. What is needed is a fresh initiative with an open mind.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Mr Gray on February 10, 2018, 11:55:51 AM
According to some supporters, Madeleine is with a loving family. Surely a large reward and immunity would attract that sort of abductor?

Cite for according to some supporters.... Which supporters, exactly
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Angelo222 on February 10, 2018, 12:00:11 PM
Cite for according to some supporters.... Which supporters, exactly

Sadie seems to think so. 
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: slartibartfast on February 10, 2018, 12:02:47 PM
Cite for according to some supporters.... Which supporters, exactly

If you say no supporters think she is with a loving family, fine, we will take that as a fact.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Mr Gray on February 10, 2018, 12:08:09 PM
If you say no supporters think she is with a loving family, fine, we will take that as a fact.

I never said that...its you who have posted and failed to provide a cite
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Mr Gray on February 10, 2018, 12:10:50 PM
I used the term immunity but it doesn't have to be immunity in any legal sense.  Abductors and kidnappers are often paid if it achieves the return of the missing person.  Imo the police will never solve this case and bring anyone to trial, they have had ten years and spent almost £12m on it and achievd nothing. What is needed is a fresh initiative with an open mind.

so what immunity do you mean...and who can give it. abductors who are payed...ask for a ransom...there dont seem to have been any requests
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Robittybob1 on February 10, 2018, 12:14:49 PM
A situation could arise where a choice has to be made.  Find Madeleine and give immunity or don't.  I know what my decision would be.
What would it be?
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: slartibartfast on February 10, 2018, 12:17:52 PM
I never said that...its you who have posted and failed to provide a cite

We have four possibilities:-


We can discount 1 and 4, as only an idiot would propose those.
So it is going to be 2 or 3, your choice.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Angelo222 on February 10, 2018, 12:21:19 PM
What would it be?

Are you serious?  I thought you were a parent but obviously not.  A parent's first and primary concern is to have their child returned to them, anything else pales into insignificance.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Brietta on February 10, 2018, 12:21:27 PM
Yeh but 'up to £20,000.  Peanuts. This case must be worth half a million for a solution.
After all OG has spent £12 milionl and appears no nearer a solution than it was at the beginning.

Unfortunately offers of reward have already attracted claims from the worst type of individuals possible whose only concern is how much they can enrich themselves from fraud.


Snip
 Police are continuing to question an Italian man and a Portuguese woman who allegedly tried to extort money from the parents of Madeleine McCann.
The couple were arrested near Algeciras in southern Spain after reportedly trying to contact the McCanns.

They had allegedly tried to claim more than £2.5m as a reward by giving bogus information about the disappearance of the four-year-old.

Police say there is no direct link between them and Madeleine's kidnap.

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk/6252160.stm
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Angelo222 on February 10, 2018, 12:23:33 PM
We have four possibilities:-

  • All supporters think she is with a loving family
  • Many supporters think she is with a loving families
  • Some supporters think she is with a loving family
  • No supporters think she is with a loving families

We can discount 1 and 4, as only an idiot would propose those.
So it is going to be 2 or 3, your choice.

I would like to think she is alive and well and being looked after but in the real world I doubt it very much.  I still believe she was hit by a car in the street outside 5a and carried off dead by a panick stricken motorist.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Angelo222 on February 10, 2018, 12:27:24 PM
Unfortunately offers of reward have already attracted claims from the worst type of individuals possible whose only concern is how much they can enrich themselves from fraud.


Snip
 Police are continuing to question an Italian man and a Portuguese woman who allegedly tried to extort money from the parents of Madeleine McCann.
The couple were arrested near Algeciras in southern Spain after reportedly trying to contact the McCanns.

They had allegedly tried to claim more than £2.5m as a reward by giving bogus information about the disappearance of the four-year-old.

Police say there is no direct link between them and Madeleine's kidnap.

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk/6252160.stm

This sort of extortion never works if proper safeguards are implemented.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Brietta on February 10, 2018, 12:28:22 PM
We have four possibilities:-

  • All supporters think she is with a loving family
  • Many supporters think she is with a loving families
  • Some supporters think she is with a loving family
  • No supporters think she is with a loving families

We can discount 1 and 4, as only an idiot would propose those.
So it is going to be 2 or 3, your choice.

What proof is there of Madeleine's death?  What is the range of sceptic thought on the criteria for that?  No answer expected or required ... just an illustration of the inadequacy of your little quiz if you think about it seriously.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: jassi on February 10, 2018, 12:31:30 PM
I would like to think she is alive and well and being looked after but in the real world I doubt it very much. I still believe she was hit by a car in the street outside 5a and carried off dead by a panick stricken motorist.

If this were the case what was the crime -  dangerous driving and illegal disposal of a body ?

Would there be a statute of limitation for those?
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: sadie on February 10, 2018, 12:34:39 PM
Sadie seems to think so.
No, I do not think that she was abducted just to be with a loving family per se.   
That might have been the intention initially but after all the publicity and photos of her eye, she probably became too easily identifiable .... and was kept elsewhere for a prolonged period

However, i think thta she will probably have been looked after by a family and with her winning ways she will have made a place for herself within the family/her carers and will probably have become part of the family now .... and loved as a family member.

Or, if she became too much of a "hot potato", maybe the initial recipient refused her and the chief abductor ended up doing the caring

I don't know this, but being in a family seems a good way of looking after her.  I certainly believe her to have been alive and looked after in 2012
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Angelo222 on February 10, 2018, 12:37:35 PM
No, I do not think that she was abducted just to be with a loving family per se.   
That might have been the intention initially but after all the publicity and photos of her eye, she probably became too easily identifiable .... and was kept elsewhere for a prolonged period

However, i think thta she will probably have been looked after by a family and with her winning ways she will have made a place for herself within the family/her carers and will probably have become part of the family now .... and loved as a family member.

Or, if she became too much of a "hot potato", maybe the initial recipient refused her and the chief abductor ended up doing the caring

I don't know this, but being in a family seems a good way of looking after her.  I certainly believe her to have been alive and looked after in 2012

The claim was that some supporters think Maddie is living with a loving family and I offered you as an example of one with such a belief.  I believe I am correct and I would add that I hope you are correct but history tells a different story unfortunately.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Mr Gray on February 10, 2018, 12:39:00 PM
We have four possibilities:-

  • All supporters think she is with a loving family
  • Many supporters think she is with a loving families
  • Some supporters think she is with a loving family
  • No supporters think she is with a loving families

We can discount 1 and 4, as only an idiot would propose those.
So it is going to be 2 or 3, your choice.

you have made both statements2 and 3......you have now withdrawn 2...you need to provide a cite for 3...you either can or cannot...your choice
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Mr Gray on February 10, 2018, 12:40:28 PM
The claim was that some supporters think Maddie is living with a loving family and I offered you as an example of one with such a belief.  I believe I am correct.

Sadie is using the word probably and not stating it as fact...and this is your only example.....
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Angelo222 on February 10, 2018, 12:41:39 PM
you have made both statements2 and 3......you have now withdrawn 2...you need to provide a cite for 3...you either can or cannot...your choice

What is your belief Dave?
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Robittybob1 on February 10, 2018, 12:44:49 PM
you have made both statements2 and 3......you have now withdrawn 2...you need to provide a cite for 3...you either can or cannot...your choice
They are just possibilities Davel.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Angelo222 on February 10, 2018, 12:45:49 PM
I have started a poll to see what members think.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Mr Gray on February 10, 2018, 12:50:14 PM
What is your belief Dave?

My belief is that Maddie is almost certainly deceased....but there is a very remote chance she is still alive
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Mr Gray on February 10, 2018, 12:52:01 PM
They are just possibilities Davel.

you need to read the post by slarti...it was posted some supporters believe...that is a statement of fact and requires a cite as per forum rules
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Robittybob1 on February 10, 2018, 01:05:37 PM
you need to read the post by slarti...it was posted some supporters believe...that is a statement of fact and requires a cite as per forum rules
Before that he says they are possibilities.  "We have four possibilities:-"
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: slartibartfast on February 10, 2018, 01:06:34 PM
What proof is there of Madeleine's death?  What is the range of sceptic thought on the criteria for that?  No answer expected or required ... just an illustration of the inadequacy of your little quiz if you think about it seriously.

Totally beside the point and a diversion.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: slartibartfast on February 10, 2018, 01:10:33 PM
you need to read the post by slarti...it was posted some supporters believe...that is a statement of fact and requires a cite as per forum rules

The four choices provide a cite. You may not like it but life’s like that.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Mr Gray on February 10, 2018, 02:00:54 PM
Before that he says they are possibilities.  "We have four possibilities:-"

its the previous post....please read all the posts in the exchange if you want to commnet

slarti posted.....According to some supporters, Madeleine is with a loving family. Surely a large reward and immunity would attract that sort of abductor?
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: slartibartfast on February 10, 2018, 02:48:02 PM
the four choices do not provide a cite...you have failed to provide a cite

I have proved it with logic so no cite required.

 I think you are just being argumentative for the sake of it. Please desist.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: sadie on February 10, 2018, 04:22:31 PM
We have four possibilities:-

  • All supporters think she is with a loving family
  • Many supporters think she is with a loving families
  • Some supporters think she is with a loving family
  • No supporters think she is with a loving families

We can discount 1 and 4, as only an idiot would propose those.
So it is going to be 2 or 3, your choice.
Cheers slarti

Seems we have similar views of each other (&^&
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: slartibartfast on February 10, 2018, 04:44:48 PM
Cheers slarti

Seems we have similar views of each other (&^&

I hope that isn’t goading. I’m not sure why saying some supporters think she is with a loving family is an issue.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Mr Gray on February 10, 2018, 04:45:44 PM
I have proved it with logic so no cite required.

 I think you are just being argumentative for the sake of it. Please desist.
#
YOU HAVE NOT PROVIDED A CITE YOU HAVE GIVEN YOUR OPINION
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Angelo222 on February 10, 2018, 05:26:47 PM
I agree with davel on this one.  I also believe Maddie is dead so NOT living with a loving family.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: slartibartfast on February 10, 2018, 05:39:52 PM
I agree with davel on this one.  I also believe Maddie is dead so NOT living with a loving family.

I personally don’t care what they believe but to suggest that all supporters think she is dead or in a worse situation is ridiculous. IMO
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: slartibartfast on February 10, 2018, 05:47:30 PM
I personally don’t care what they believe but to suggest that all supporters think she is dead or in a worse situation is ridiculous. IMO

P.S. see poll.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Mr Gray on February 10, 2018, 05:54:23 PM
I personally don’t care what they believe but to suggest that all supporters think she is dead or in a worse situation is ridiculous. IMO

Who has suggested that
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Eleanor on February 10, 2018, 05:54:50 PM
Totally beside the point and a diversion.

This not beside the point.  Or a diversion.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Eleanor on February 10, 2018, 05:59:20 PM

I believe that Madeleine is with a family because the method and planning that went into her abduction is way over the top for a Paedophile, who could have picked up any passing child without so much risk.

This is my opinion.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: sadie on February 10, 2018, 06:03:00 PM
I have started a poll to see what members think.
I dont do polls.  They are a nonsense IMO.  The initial wording can pre-emt the final score .... and an organised push from one side can ruin the veracity of the result.


I will repeat that I think that I saw a video of Madeleine in 2012. 
I believe it was her, not only because there was a likeness in facial bone structure  and general features, big wide eyes but also because I had worked out where in the World she was likely to be ... and she was precisely there .... EXACTLY there... I am talking less than 50 metres.  Now 50 metres is pretty close for anywhere (not thought of by others) in the world.       Also this little girl was clever and her mannerisms, energy levels, movements and body proportions were Madeleines ... except she appeared mentally subdued.  Her hair, generally well hidden under a hat was a soft reddish colour ...just like her mums at the same age

Oh, and she was in a foreign country, (not Portugal, Spain or the UK) obviously living there and she was wearing START-RIGHT shoes (made in Northampton UK, IIRC)

Start-right, are the shoes bought for their children by more affluent British parents.  They are personally fitted to a childs foot, rather than the other way around.


I believe this little girl was Madeleine ... and she was very much alive in 2012.

I think that she is likely to be alive and looked after in 2018


.... however ....

Knowing that there are so many ways that I could be wrong, I am never 100% sure



..... but PHEW !!!
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: sadie on February 10, 2018, 06:26:27 PM
I hope that isn’t goading. I’m not sure why saying some supporters think she is with a loving family is an issue.

It is well known that I believe that Madeleine is very possibly alive and possibly she has won her way and is well cared for.
....  in other words loved after a fashion and probably within a family, altho the abductor might have become her family, if she became too famous and he was left with her.
 
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Angelo222 on February 10, 2018, 06:33:27 PM
I dont do polls.  They are a nonsense IMO.  The initial wording can pre-emt the final score .... and an organised push from one side can ruin the veracity of the result.


I will repeat that I think that I saw a video of Madeleine in 2012. 
I believe it was her, not only because there was a likeness in facial bone structure  and general features, big wide eyes but also because I had worked out where in the World she was likely to be ... and she was precisely there .... EXACTLY there... I am talking less than 50 metres.  Now 50 metres is pretty close for anywhere (not thought of by others) in the world.       Also this little girl was clever and her mannerisms, energy levels, movements and body proportions were Madeleines ... except she appeared mentally subdued.  Her hair, generally well hidden under a hat was a soft reddish colour ...just like her mums at the same age

Oh, and she was in a foreign country, (not Portugal, Spain or the UK) obviously living there and she was wearing START-RIGHT shoes (made in Northampton UK, IIRC)

Start-right, are the shoes bought for their children by more affluent British parents.  They are personally fitted to a childs foot, rather than the other way around.


I believe this little girl was Madeleine ... and she was very much alive in 2012.

I think that she is likely to be alive and looked after in 2018


.... however ....

Knowing that there are so many ways that I could be wrong, I am never 100% sure



..... but PHEW !!!

With respect Sadie, you must hold the world record for wrongly identifying Maddie by now, does that not suggest to you that you would make a very poor detective?
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Angelo222 on February 10, 2018, 06:34:28 PM
I believe that Madeleine is with a family because the method and planning that went into her abduction is way over the top for a Paedophile, who could have picked up any passing child without so much risk.

This is my opinion.

What abduction?  What planning?

No loving family in the western world would touch Maddie with a bargepole for obvious reasons.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Robittybob1 on February 10, 2018, 06:47:30 PM
It is well known that I believe that Madeleine is very possibly alive and possibly she has won her way and is well cared for.
....  in other words loved after a fashion and probably within a family, altho the abductor might have become her family, if she became too famous and he was left with her
"only an idiot"  that is opinion and is spot on it is virtually a fact as pointed out.  - I'll let it go.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Lace on February 10, 2018, 07:15:05 PM
The only reason for abduction in my opinion was to sell her.

I hope she is with a loving family.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Lace on February 10, 2018, 07:16:50 PM
Maybe they could try a large reward again,   it has been ten years things may have changed,   such as loyalty, fear.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Brietta on February 10, 2018, 07:17:47 PM
Totally beside the point and a diversion.

Please do not dismiss my post out of hand without discussion or giving it deeper thought.

Why do you consider it a diversion in the context of the thread? 

Think about it.  If someone indicates a burial site which sadly proved to be accurate, I rather imagine that on their way to deposit a hefty cheque in their bank account they might feel the heavy hand of the law on their shoulder ... immunity or not ... interviews possibly starting with demands for an explanation of their heinous crime of parking on a bus stop and expanding into more pertinent questions regarding their intimate knowledge of deposition sites.

Hypothetically, Madeleine's fate solved but not the case which I imagine would focus differently. 

Do you seriously think that anyone with that sort of knowledge is going to spill the beans on it no matter how badly the money might be desired?  ... in my opinion it raises too many imponderables for them.

Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Lace on February 10, 2018, 07:25:34 PM
What abduction?  What planning?

No loving family in the western world would touch Maddie with a bargepole for obvious reasons.

In my opinion there was a lot of planning.   Men collecting for an orphanage that didn't exist,  a man even entered an apartment and was caught staring at a child.   Men watching 5a.

The people on the receiving end ten years ago wouldn't have been able to envisage how well known Madeleine would become.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: slartibartfast on February 10, 2018, 07:26:49 PM
Please do not dismiss my post out of hand without discussion or giving it deeper thought.

Why do you consider it a diversion in the context of the thread? 

Think about it.  If someone indicates a burial site which sadly proved to be accurate, I rather imagine that on their way to deposit a hefty cheque in their bank account they might feel the heavy hand of the law on their shoulder ... immunity or not ... interviews possibly starting with demands for an explanation of their heinous crime of parking on a bus stop and expanding into more pertinent questions regarding their intimate knowledge of deposition sites.

Hypothetically, Madeleine's fate solved but not the case which I imagine would focus differently. 

Do you seriously think that anyone with that sort of knowledge is going to spill the beans on it no matter how badly the money might be desired?  ... in my opinion it raises too many imponderables for them.

Maybe instead of attacking the poster you could read what I said in the first place.

To recap...

If, as some supporters think, Madeleine is with a loving family, then that type of abductor is more likely to be amenable to cooperating with the investigation and trying to get the reward as they haven’t “harmed” her.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Wonderfulspam on February 10, 2018, 07:43:28 PM
In my opinion there was a lot of planning.   Men collecting for an orphanage that didn't exist,  a man even entered an apartment and was caught staring at a child.   Men watching 5a.

The people on the receiving end ten years ago wouldn't have been able to envisage how well known Madeleine would become.

I lose count of the amount of men seen behaving suspiciously close to the McCann's apartment.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Brietta on February 10, 2018, 08:11:43 PM
Maybe instead of attacking the poster you could read what I said in the first place.

To recap...

If, as some supporters think, Madeleine is with a loving family, then that type of abductor is more likely to be amenable to cooperating with the investigation and trying to get the reward as they haven’t “harmed” her.

In my opinion discussion does not consist of constant repetition it flows ever onwards and hopefully upwards.  I read your post (above) which you have chosen to quote from but it is not the post to which I replied in the context of the general discussion and which attracted your usual dismissive response.

The discussion had progressed to your four points addressed to 'supporters'.  That is the post I answered and that is the post you chose to denigrate.

Quote :"Totally beside the point and a diversion."   Reply #153 on: Today at 01:06:34 PM

Check back over the responses you have made to my posts vis a vis personal attacks and think very carefully about who has provided a record of attacking and attempting to put down who ... both against forum rules by the way.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Alice Purjorick on February 10, 2018, 08:12:40 PM
I lose count of the amount of men seen behaving suspiciously close to the McCann's apartment.

Like Holborn Central Line at 1730 every weekday!

Was this carefully planned snatch on spec in the hope they could sell her on or a bespoke done to order job do you think ?
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Alice Purjorick on February 10, 2018, 08:20:59 PM

This is what the UK Police Code of Practice says.

"Rewards
Support from the public can be encouraged when rewards are offered to the public for information and this can be beneficial in order to reinvigorate media attention in the missing person’s case. However careful consideration should be given to accepting any offer because of the amount of resources that may be required to manage the response, as all information will need to be assessed".


As the crime if any would have been committed on Portuguese soil who knows what their attitude is toward rewards.
Just for the sake of argument let's say the child was abducted. Now let's not be mealy mouthed about this, that is kidnap with a side dish of false imprisonment which are pretty high up the totem pole of crime.
I don't see any justice system offering immunity for that.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Angelo222 on February 10, 2018, 08:33:27 PM
Maybe they could try a large reward again,   it has been ten years things may have changed,   such as loyalty, fear.

Totally agree but imo the McCanns will never offer the fund as a reward as they're too far .. .... ... .....
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: slartibartfast on February 10, 2018, 08:36:50 PM
In my opinion discussion does not consist of constant repetition it flows ever onwards and hopefully upwards.  I read your post (above) which you have chosen to quote from but it is not the post to which I replied in the context of the general discussion and which attracted your usual dismissive response.

The discussion had progressed to your four points addressed to 'supporters'.  That is the post I answered and that is the post you chose to denigrate.

Quote :"Totally beside the point and a diversion."   Reply #153 on: Today at 01:06:34 PM

Check back over the responses you have made to my posts vis a vis personal attacks and think very carefully about who has provided a record of attacking and attempting to put down who ... both against forum rules by the way.

So what did the range of sceptic thought on the criteria for Madeleine's death have to do with benign abduction?
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Mr Gray on February 10, 2018, 09:08:29 PM
Totally agree but imo the McCanns will never offer the fund as a reward as they're too far .. .... ... .....

I think a reward offered in Portugal for information  leading to the, whereabouts of Maddie would be a very good idea... But it would need to be promoted in Portugal... Is that possible
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: sadie on February 10, 2018, 09:58:49 PM
With respect Sadie, you must hold the world record for wrongly identifying Maddie by now, does that not suggest to you that you would make a very poor detective?
Oh, can we have a list of when I have wrongly identified Madeleine please ... and your reasons for making that accusation.  TY
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: sadie on February 10, 2018, 10:04:00 PM
"only an idiot"  that is opinion and is spot on it is virtually a fact as pointed out.  - I'll let it go.
You are wrong Rob, because apart from what I saw, there are several children abducted, then given up for dead, who have escaped and re-appeared.

Several.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: sadie on February 10, 2018, 10:08:33 PM
I lose count of the amount of men seen behaving suspiciously close to the McCann's apartment.
I can count above four ... no probs.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Brietta on February 10, 2018, 10:15:35 PM
You are wrong Rob, because apart from what I saw, there are several children abducted, then given up for dead, who have escaped and re-appeared.

Several.

Those are the ones we know about for one reason or another, either escape or some for something as mundane as requiring documentation in later years. 

How many abductees are there that we do not know about who have survived and are perhaps living in total ignorance that they were abducted and who will never know?
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Robittybob1 on February 10, 2018, 10:33:35 PM
You are wrong Rob, because apart from what I saw, there are several children abducted, then given up for dead, who have escaped and re-appeared.

Several.
But that is not what I'm talking about Sadie.  I was commenting on http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=6743.msg445896#msg445896
with the 4 possibilities.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: John on February 10, 2018, 11:54:18 PM
This is what the UK Police Code of Practice says.

"Rewards
Support from the public can be encouraged when rewards are offered to the public for information and this can be beneficial in order to reinvigorate media attention in the missing person’s case. However careful consideration should be given to accepting any offer because of the amount of resources that may be required to manage the response, as all information will need to be assessed".


As the crime if any would have been committed on Portuguese soil who knows what their attitude is toward rewards.
Just for the sake of argument let's say the child was abducted. Now let's not be mealy mouthed about this, that is kidnap with a side dish of false imprisonment which are pretty high up the totem pole of crime.
I don't see any justice system offering immunity for that.

That's just it and is crystal clear from Scotland Yard's own website some time back.  They didn't offer a reward for the return of the child but merely in the event of a prosecution.  Nice to see where SY's priorities lie.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: John on February 10, 2018, 11:57:23 PM
I think a reward offered in Portugal for information  leading to the, whereabouts of Maddie would be a very good idea... But it would need to be promoted in Portugal... Is that possible

It would have to be promoted worldwide but I don't see the nice PJ or even SY for that matter lending it any support whatsoever as they wouldn't want anyone else stealing their glory.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: John on February 11, 2018, 12:01:09 AM
Oh, can we have a list of when I have wrongly identified Madeleine please ... and your reasons for making that accusation.  TY

You have to admit Sadie, your insistence that certain children photographed on a lonely country road in Morocco were Madeleine and Joana was memorable for all the wrong reasons.  Not forgetting the girl outside the Belgium bank too of-course.  Here is a reminder.

(http://i.dailymail.co.uk/i/pix/2007/09_04/mccannlength2509_468x361.jpg)

(http://www.anorak.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/madeleine-in-brussels.jpg)

https://www.thesun.co.uk/archives/news/146885/five-false-sightings-of-madeleine-mccann/
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Eleanor on February 11, 2018, 02:59:39 AM

Immunity simply cannot be offered after all of this time.  Nor should anyone be allowed to collect a reward after withholding evidence, especially if Madeleine was killed.

It is always possible that anyone who might now have Madeleine alive doesn't actually know who she is, depending on a chain of events.

I suspect that we will have to wait for a bit yet before Madeleine herself becomes aware of who she is, if in fact this could ever happen.  Something as simple as a Social Security Number could expose this.  It has already happened before.

I make no apologies for living in hope.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Mr Gray on February 11, 2018, 08:46:34 AM
It would have to be promoted worldwide but I don't see the nice PJ or even SY for that matter lending it any support whatsoever as they wouldn't want anyone else stealing their glory.

It needs to be promoted in portugal who didnt show crimewatch....why was crimewatch not shown in portugal. Posters have been torn down...are the portuguese public anti maddie promotion.....it seems they are
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Mr Gray on February 11, 2018, 09:18:49 AM
I have proved it with logic so no cite required.

 I think you are just being argumentative for the sake of it. Please desist.



your proof  is only your opinion nothing more and is not a recognised cite imo. You have therefore failed to provide recognised cite imo. Im happy to leave it there now...
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: jassi on February 11, 2018, 09:22:51 AM
That's just it and is crystal clear from Scotland Yard's own website some time back.  They didn't offer a reward for the return of the child but merely in the event of a prosecution. Nice to see where SY's priorities lie.

Could be they are just being realistic and discount the idea of her being alive - though obviously they can't actually say that.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Wonderfulspam on February 11, 2018, 12:12:08 PM
It needs to be promoted in portugal who didnt show crimewatch....why was crimewatch not shown in portugal. Posters have been torn down...are the portuguese public anti maddie promotion.....it seems they are

I don't blame them, having to put up with the circus.

Perhaps the Portuguese public aren't so easily fooled by abduction claims anymore.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Eleanor on February 11, 2018, 02:11:36 PM
See poll results.

Three Supporters, of which I am one.

How many of the others are Supporters who believe Madeleine was abducted but that something else happened to her?
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: John on February 11, 2018, 02:11:59 PM


your proof  is only your opinion nothing more and is not a recognised cite imo. You have therefore failed to provide recognised cite imo. Im happy to leave it there now...

I think it goes without saying that many people including Madeleine's parents hope that the child is safe and well and being looked after by some loving family.  I too hope that is the case but I fear the truth is somewhat darker and more sinister.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: slartibartfast on February 11, 2018, 02:22:16 PM
Three Supporters, of which I am one.

How many of the others are Supporters who believe Madeleine was abducted but that something else happened to her?

What difference does it make?
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Eleanor on February 11, 2018, 02:23:58 PM
What difference does it make?

Think about it.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Miss Taken Identity on February 11, 2018, 02:35:20 PM
Three Supporters, of which I am one.

How many of the others are Supporters who believe Madeleine was abducted but that something else happened to her?

Yes. Interesting indeed. Considering the abduction story and the way it was told by the parents,(Jemmied Shutters-windows open for entry -exit) who implied that paedophiles were involved, it is highly unlikely IMHO that  a paedophile gang would hand over a live child to a 'loving' family.  Well maybe that did happen... who knows. The questions suggests some supporters like sceptics do not believe it.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: jassi on February 11, 2018, 02:48:12 PM
What difference does it make?

For the purposes of the poll, none at all.
The majority of respondents think that Madeleine is not enjoying a happy family life.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Eleanor on February 11, 2018, 03:04:07 PM
For the purposes of the poll, none at all.
The majority of respondents think that Madeleine is not enjoying a happy family life.

This is not the inference that will be taken and used by some.  In My Opinion.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: slartibartfast on February 11, 2018, 03:06:15 PM
This is not the inference that will be taken and used by some.  In My Opinion.

Why?
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Eleanor on February 11, 2018, 03:11:44 PM
Why?

Another pointless question.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Carana on February 11, 2018, 03:19:09 PM
I haven't voted, mainly because of the word "believe".

Obviously, the remote possibility that she might be is the best outcome that most people would wish for, whatever one's views. Except perhaps the few who might desperately hope that that will never turn out to be the case for reasons best known to themselves and their psychiatrists.

There HAVE been cases of children being abducted, dumped, and/or subject to fake adoptions and brought up by loving families, including in the US. However, at least amongst those eventually found or who discovered their own pasts, they are often children with little to no press coverage at the time. Rare, no doubt, but there may also be others who have simply chosen not to say anything for a variety of reasons.

So, while I don't totally discount the possibility, I can't say that I believe that this is the case concerning Madeleine.

Could she be alive, but not with a loving family? Back in my innocent days, I'd have thought that anyone claiming that kids could be held captive in dungeons must have been reading too many Stephen King novels... yet such cases exist.

Could she have died the night she disappeared? Yes, of course, that's a possibility.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: slartibartfast on February 11, 2018, 03:20:02 PM
Another pointless question.

No it isn’t, you made a statement which seems odd. People have a range of opinions as well to what Madeleine’s fate was. Some explaining would have helped.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Eleanor on February 11, 2018, 03:23:05 PM
No it isn’t, you made a statement which seems odd. People have a range of opinions as well to what Madeleine’s fate was. Some explaining would have helped.

And also left me open to a claim of Libel.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Miss Taken Identity on February 11, 2018, 03:29:05 PM
With regards to having money in a fund to search for their daughter, but not putting that money into a missing person pot and not demanding on behalf of missing persons the government chuck the same amount to other missing children; a case of I'm alright Jack?
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: slartibartfast on February 11, 2018, 03:29:51 PM
And also left me open to a claim of Libel.

I would suggest making cryptic comments to try and hide libel is not a good idea. It is either too cryptic and no one knows what you are talking about or not cryptic enough which lays you open to libel anyway.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Carana on February 11, 2018, 06:06:50 PM
Back to reflecting on the title of the thread... no, I don't think that a substantial reward is necessarily a good idea.

The idea of potentially "winning" a million or more (insert currency) is bound to bring forward people with $$$$ in their eyes.

On the other hand, the massive amount may have fuelled the initial media drive to some extent. As I posted earlier, there is a section in a help booklet for parents of a missing child on the topic of the advantages and disadvantages of offering a reward.

Back on the other side, a large reward might make someone break ranks with, e.g., a primarily drug-smuggling gang or similar... but then there is the risk of not living to cash in the money unless it offers the safety of a new life elsewhere. (And, no, I'm not thinking of this case in particular.)

I would hope that most people would take time to think and phone in if they genuinely thought they'd spotted her... except for those who were so convinced by the media that she was necessarily dead that if she'd turned up in front of them even in 2007-2008 they wouldn't have noticed.

Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: John on February 12, 2018, 11:33:44 PM
Back onto topic please. TY
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: John on February 13, 2018, 12:03:45 AM
Notice to all members:

It has been brought to our attention that some members registered on this forum have been making inappropriate derogatory and extremely distasteful comments on other sites attacking fellow members of this forum.  We take a dim view of such activities as it creates bad feeling and disharmony within this forum and that is something we cannot accept.

Going forward, any identifiable members who engage in such activity will be removed from this forum permanently.  There will be no appeal and no reinstatement to any member so removed.
Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: sadie on February 13, 2018, 01:50:03 AM
As I stated before, I dont do polls.  They are a nonsense IMO.  The initial wording can pre-emt the final score .... and an organised push from one side can ruin the veracity of the result.

Also I find this poll vulgar to be totally honest.  There is something distinctly unsavoury about having FUN, GUESSING whether a little missing girl is alive and in a happy family IMO.

I happen to have information that CONVINCES me that Madeleine was alive and healthy in 2012.  No-body else has that info, although a very few have seen it

Because of the Stockholm Syndrome ... and maybe other reasons, it is almost certain that Madeleine will have bonded herself to her carers  .... and they will probably have bonded themselves to Madeleine.  This, along with the fact that I believe that she was abducted for a purpose, (well gone over elsewhere), has decided me that she is likely to be alive today and being cared for.   I also do not believe that her abductors are murderers per se


Whether she is in a happy family place is another question and to answer it would be a crude unsubstantiated guess .... and i am not entering that territory


I am personally NOT INTO TOTAL GUESSES on such a senstive topic as this.


A poll taken on guesses and hunches alone, such as this with most of you, is nothing more, nor less, than a sham IMO.

Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: Miss Taken Identity on February 18, 2018, 09:52:48 PM
As I stated before, I dont do polls.  They are a nonsense IMO.  The initial wording can pre-emt the final score .... and an organised push from one side can ruin the veracity of the result.

Also I find this poll vulgar to be totally honest.  There is something distinctly unsavoury about having FUN, GUESSING whether a little missing girl is alive and in a happy family IMO.

I happen to have information that CONVINCES me that Madeleine was alive and healthy in 2012.  No-body else has that info, although a very few have seen it

Because of the Stockholm Syndrome ... and maybe other reasons, it is almost certain that Madeleine will have bonded herself to her carers  .... and they will probably have bonded themselves to Madeleine.  This, along with the fact that I believe that she was abducted for a purpose, (well gone over elsewhere), has decided me that she is likely to be alive today and being cared for.   I also do not believe that her abductors are murderers per se


Whether she is in a happy family place is another question and to answer it would be a crude unsubstantiated guess .... and i am not entering that territory


I am personally NOT INTO TOTAL GUESSES on such a senstive topic as this.


A poll taken on guesses and hunches alone, such as this with most of you, is nothing more, nor less, than a sham IMO.


I don't think people who voted saw it as a 'fun' thing. they based their answer on their information they received and understood I would guess.

you keep on about knowing who did make MBM disappear, fact is we all know it is you having a guess.

"I happen to have information that CONVINCES me that Madeleine was alive and healthy in 2012.  No-body else has that info, although a very few have seen it"

just because you sent this to SY doesn't mean they took it seriously.

Title: Re: Is offering a substantial reward the only way to solve the Maddie case?
Post by: sadie on February 18, 2018, 11:17:38 PM

I don't think people who voted saw it as a 'fun' thing. they based their answer on their information they received and understood I would guess.

you keep on about knowing who did make MBM disappear, fact is we all know it is you having a guess.

"I happen to have information that CONVINCES me that Madeleine was alive and healthy in 2012.  No-body else has that info, although a very few have seen it"

just because you sent this to SY doesn't mean they took it seriously.
They took it seriously alright, but despite several encouraging pointers from them, I dont know for certain that I have hit the nail on the head.  With so many things that i have found that fit together like a big jigsaw, I think I have tho. 

There are so many pointers that I feel sure that some bits will not be correct.  It would be too good if every single detail was correct.

Fingers crossed.   Which ever side of the discussion we are on, we all want her back .... and most of us will want the perps safely locked away