UK Justice Forum 🇬🇧
Alleged Miscarriages of Justice => Jeremy Bamber and the callous murder of his father, mother, sister and twin nephews. Case effectively CLOSED by CCRC on basis of NO APPEAL REFERRAL. => Topic started by: Caroline on March 07, 2017, 01:31:20 PM
-
I posted the following on the blue forum last night. Just wondered what members here thought?
Many people who believe Jeremy is innocent, just can't get their head around the notion that the police may have been in conversation with someone inside the 'farmhouse'.
That one line conjures up images of Sheila holding on to the rifle in a 'you'll never take me alive coppers' type scenario.
I have previously argued that Bonnett probably just wrote the wrong phrase when he used the words 'in conversation', until I noticed something that I hadn't rationalised before. Something gets repeated here so many times that we often take for granted what we believe is written and miss was is actually stated. I was under the assumption that Bonnett's log stated "Firearms team are in conversation with someone from inside the FARMHOUSE, however, what Bonnett actually wrote was "Firearms team are in conversation with someone from inside the FARM' not FARMHOUSE - just FARM. His next line is "Challenge to persons inside HOUSE met with no response". Bonnett distinguishes FARM from HOUSE and the distinction is important when compared with the various TFG statements. Just before the TFG approached the farm with the loud hailer, they WERE in conversation with someone, they were in conversation with Jeremy Bamber; Jeremy Bamber was someone FROM the farm; an inside man so to speak. I believe that the line "Firearms team are in conversation with someone from inside the FARM " is a reference to the conversation between Jeremy and the TFG as referenced below - (see Collins's partial statement below the relevant section of Bonnett's log). It's important because JUST AFTER the conversation with Jeremy, the TFG made their challenge to 'persons inside the HOUSE' which as we know was 'met with no response'. So no mystery after all as far as I am concerned - Bonnett's comment was in respect to the conversation with Jeremy! Hence the distinction between 'Farm' and 'House'.
31
-
Or Bonnett could simply have misheard the word "barn" (as per your second extract) and substituted "farm" instead, so should have written - "Firearms team are in conversation with someone, from inside the barn". In other words, Collins, Delgado and Bamber were all gathered together inside the barn and talking to each other.
-
My thoughts are simple- it is ambiguous.
He could have intentionally distinguished farm and house to distinguish between Jeremy and the house challenge like you suggest. You could be on the money. But he could have been referring to the challenge with both.
Consider the following- he is told they were speaking to those in the house- so he sloppily writes in conversation with those inside the farm. He is then given another message saying no one responded to the police communication so writes the second sentence.
The truth can be either of these. The only way to know what was intended would have been to ask Bonnet which of these two was the case. Either way it changes little since he freely admitted no one in the house responded.
Even if he had claimed he was told they were in communication with someone inside the house that would not be able to refute the accounts of the witnesses who say no one answered. The people at the scene carry the day, they are the witnesses/participants. That is the most important point of all.
This issue is purely used for propaganda by dishonest people. The defense knew that on the stand Bonnett would say he was told no one in the house answered. So it was of no use to the defense at all that he wrote in conversation when they knew he didn't mean someone in the house was speaking back.
Only dishonest people suggest someone was speaking back to police and are dishonest because there is zero support for that. The police at the scene say such did not occur, Bonnett was not told such occurred, and there is no medical evidence to support anyone being alive while police were there so no one who could have spoken to them.
I view this as invented hogwash just like the invented hogwash that Nevill called 999 and that Bonnett's report reflects such not a call from Jeremy. The same way they ignore that the report clearly states West was the one who called Bonnett and clearly details what Jeremy told West, they ignore the words no one in the house responded.
The bottom line is that you could be right but in the grand scheme of things it would not make a difference either way. No doubt some of the biased delusional sorts on blue will refuse to accept your suggestion as possible since they don't even accept that Bonnett said no one in the house responded. They will be wrong of course, it is quote plausible your suggestion is accurate.
-
I posted the following on the blue forum last night. Just wondered what members here thought?
Many people who believe Jeremy is innocent, just can't get their head around the notion that the police may have been in conversation with someone inside the 'farmhouse'.
That one line conjures up images of Sheila holding on to the rifle in a 'you'll never take me alive coppers' type scenario.
I have previously argued that Bonnett probably just wrote the wrong phrase when he used the words 'in conversation', until I noticed something that I hadn't rationalised before. Something gets repeated here so many times that we often take for granted what we believe is written and miss was is actually stated. I was under the assumption that Bonnett's log stated "Firearms team are in conversation with someone from inside the FARMHOUSE, however, what Bonnett actually wrote was "Firearms team are in conversation with someone from inside the FARM' not FARMHOUSE - just FARM. His next line is "Challenge to persons inside HOUSE met with no response". Bonnett distinguishes FARM from HOUSE and the distinction is important when compared with the various TFG statements. Just before the TFG approached the farm with the loud hailer, they WERE in conversation with someone, they were in conversation with Jeremy Bamber; Jeremy Bamber was someone FROM the farm; an inside man so to speak. I believe that the line "Firearms team are in conversation with someone from inside the FARM " is a reference to the conversation between Jeremy and the TFG as referenced below - (see Collins's partial statement below the relevant section of Bonnett's log). It's important because JUST AFTER the conversation with Jeremy, the TFG made their challenge to 'persons inside the HOUSE' which as we know was 'met with no response'. So no mystery after all as far as I am concerned - Bonnett's comment was in respect to the conversation with Jeremy! Hence the distinction between 'Farm' and 'House'.
Bonnett, the civilian operator in the police control room was most probably getting snippets of information from various sources and would have been listening to the radio transmissions emanating from the ICP set up at the farm. With the best will in the world messages do get construed sometimes, my own thoughts on this have always been that the police probably followed their training and attempted to contact anyone alive in the farmhouse but their efforts were met with silence. They were then forced to consider whether an armed person was hiding in the house thus their extreme caution when entering.
Had there been any conversation with someone within the farmhouse it would have been reported to Bonnett immediately and Jeremy would most certainly have known about it at the time. It would also have been reported in the statements of those officers who first entered the farmhouse had it occurred.
-
Bonnett makes a distinction between 'farm' and 'house' - I don't believe it's ambiguous at all. Collin's makes it clear that he was in conversation with Jeremy JUST prior to challenging the house. I don't believe there is any doubt that Bonnett's comment is in reference to Jeremy
-
Bonnett makes a distinction between 'farm' and 'house' - I don't believe it's ambiguous at all. Collin's makes it clear that he was in conversation with Jeremy JUST prior to challenging the house. I don't believe there is any doubt that Bonnett's comment is in reference to Jeremy
Makes sense to me.
There's absolutely no evidence whatsoever that police attempts to communicate with anyone inside were responded to.
Why don't you email Eric Allison @ The Guardian and fill him in!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=20J-xZrhArs
@ 3.30 in
-
Makes sense to me.
There's absolutely no evidence whatsoever that police attempts to communicate with anyone inside were responded to.
Why don't you email Eric Allison @ The Guardian and fill him in!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=20J-xZrhArs
@ 3.30 in
I wouldn't bother, he has his own agenda.
-
Makes sense to me.
There's absolutely no evidence whatsoever that police attempts to communicate with anyone inside were responded to.
Why don't you email Eric Allison @ The Guardian and fill him in!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=20J-xZrhArs
@ 3.30 in
No point, it's the official stance anyway, but the CT suggest that the reference in Bonnetts log can't mean Jeremy because
"he was referred to by his name or 'the son' and not as an unknown person. Nor was he 'inside the farm'. In all instances ‘inside the farm’ was repeatedly used by the police to mean ‘inside the farmhouse’."
However, this is rubbish, of course he was inside the farm, however, he wasn't 'inside the house'. I have looked through both logs and only see one reference to the word 'farm' the one where Bonnett mentioned that the firearms team were in conversation with someone from inside the farm - they were talking about Jeremy whatever the CT states. The notion that they only called him 'the son' etc. is ludicrous. Bonnett could only have referred to him as 'the son; if he was told that. Different messages were passed from different people and clearly they all couldn't have referred to Jeremy as the same thing, some may not have even known who he was.
This is written on the OS and is misleading for obvious reasons. It is supposed to be a quote from Bonnett's log but as you can see, it states 'farmhouse'.
Police were in conversation with someone inside the farmhouse at around 5.25am[11]
http://www.jeremy-bamber.co.uk/defence-case
-
No point, it's the official stance anyway, but the CT suggest that the reference in Bonnetts log can't mean Jeremy because
"he was referred to by his name or 'the son' and not as an unknown person. Nor was he 'inside the farm'. In all instances ‘inside the farm’ was repeatedly used by the police to mean ‘inside the farmhouse’."
However, this is rubbish, of course he was inside the farm, however, he wasn't 'inside the house'. I have looked through both logs and only see one reference to the word 'farm' the one where Bonnett mentioned that the firearms team were in conversation with someone from inside the farm - they were talking about Jeremy whatever the CT states. The notion that they only called him 'the son' etc. is ludicrous. Bonnett could only have referred to him as 'the son; if he was told that. Different messages were passed from different people and clearly they all couldn't have referred to Jeremy as the same thing, some may not have even known who he was.
This is written on the OS and is misleading for obvious reasons. It is supposed to be a quote from Bonnett's log but as you can see, it states 'farmhouse'.
Police were in conversation with someone inside the farmhouse at around 5.25am[11]
http://www.jeremy-bamber.co.uk/defence-case
The CT....BAH!
JB...BAH!
You can listen to JB here claiming the police saw someone moving around inside the house and were talking to someone inside @ 11.40. He believes the police know that he didn't murder his family %£&)**#
https://www.theguardian.com/uk/video/2011/jan/30/jeremy-bamber-new-evidence-video
Why didn't he put all this in his WS of 7th Aug ie police saw someone moving about and talking with someone inside the house? I honestly believe JB is thick.
-
The CT....BAH!
JB...BAH!
You can listen to JB here claiming the police saw someone moving around inside the house and were talking to someone inside @ 11.40. He believes the police know that he didn't murder his family %£&)**#
https://www.theguardian.com/uk/video/2011/jan/30/jeremy-bamber-new-evidence-video
Why didn't he put all this in his WS of 7th Aug ie police saw someone moving about and talking with someone inside the house? I honestly believe JB is thick.
Here's JB's WS of 7th Aug:
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=5631.0;attach=4566
He talks about the dogs sounding in a distressed state and the police advising everyone to move back. Nothing about any sounds or sights from within WHF. I don't need all of this to believe JB is innocent. It's immaterial.
-
The CT....BAH!
JB...BAH!
You can listen to JB here claiming the police saw someone moving around inside the house and were talking to someone inside @ 11.40. He believes the police know that he didn't murder his family %£&)**#
https://www.theguardian.com/uk/video/2011/jan/30/jeremy-bamber-new-evidence-video
Why didn't he put all this in his WS of 7th Aug ie police saw someone moving about and talking with someone inside the house? I honestly believe JB is thick.
Why didn't he indeed? I don't think he's thick, I think he's guilty and grasping at anything and anyone.
-
The CT....BAH!
JB...BAH!
You can listen to JB here claiming the police saw someone moving around inside the house and were talking to someone inside @ 11.40. He believes the police know that he didn't murder his family %£&)**#
https://www.theguardian.com/uk/video/2011/jan/30/jeremy-bamber-new-evidence-video
Why didn't he put all this in his WS of 7th Aug ie police saw someone moving about and talking with someone inside the house? I honestly believe JB is thick.
He is trying to get people to believe he is innocent. Lying morons he has surrounded himself with bring up the argument and use it to say they believe he is innocent. Since it "fools" his cabal he feels it can be used to fool the public at large. This is especially the case if the public at large is unaware of the evidence that proves this claim to be bunk. This was actually one of the selling points to get me to look at the case.
I was told:
1) That police saw Sheila moving
2) spoke with Sheila
3) shot and killed Sheila
4) there was phone records proving a call from WHF to Jeremy took place
5) police concealed a call from Nevill to police by pretending there was a single call to police
6) The family planted or police blood in the moderator
7) police used the moderator to scratch the mantle to frame Avery
8) police decided right away to blame Jeremy and doctor things and the family helped to get the inheritance
Of course after scrutinizing the case all these claims fell apart but not all people will inspect things they will just accept allegations. Moreover, some decide what they want to believe and then will never be moved no matter how much evidence is brought to bear to prove them wrong. Just look at the people on blue making the same disproved claims over and over.
-
I was told:
1) That police saw Sheila moving
2) spoke with Sheila
3) shot and killed Sheila
4) there was phone records proving a call from WHF to Jeremy took place
5) police concealed a call from Nevill to police by pretending there was a single call to police
6) The family planted or police blood in the moderator
7) police used the moderator to scratch the mantle to frame Avery
8) police decided right away to blame Jeremy and doctor things and the family helped to get the inheritance
Of course after scrutinizing the case all these claims fell apart but not all people will inspect things they will just accept allegations. Moreover, some decide what they want to believe and then will never be moved no matter how much evidence is brought to bear to prove them wrong. Just look at the people on blue making the same disproved claims over and over.
Number 1) and 4) are debatable. According to Julie Mugford. Jeremy told her that Mathew Mcdonald made a phone call from WHF to Jeremy's cottage via his answer machine. So a record of such call would be made. Since you believe what this woman says there you go. I on the hand don't. But since her testimony can only have come from either the police or the relatives. I postulate that they must have had evidence of such a call and thus got her to parrot an alternative explanation for it.
Number 6) Proven: muzzle-imprint abrasion and zone of searing and soot deposition around the contact wound's to Sheila's chin are all consistent with being made by the threaded end of the barrel absent of any silencer. This is supported by four ballistic experts. The typical kneejerk guilter rebuttal is that the CCRC reject this evidence. Indeed they did. In absence of a counter-expert.
Furthermore, Nicholas Caffell having suffered two contact wounds. They failed to discover any blood or tissue evidence of this within the silencer. Another incongruity that supports the evidence I mentioned above.
Evidence that was not discovered by the police but in a rather suspiciously convenient manner, does not cohere with big picture.
7) police used the moderator to scratch the mantle to frame Steven Avery??? Fascinating. please tell me more!
-
Why Bamber made up a proxy & what he said the proxy did has been well documented.
If Julie got everything from the police or relatives, why would either bring up MM for her ?
There was no blood inside the rifle end. Only inside the silencer.
-
Number 1 and 4) are debatable
It is not even remotely debatable. Police thought they might have seen some movement but later recognized it was just them moving their heads that gave the impression of such. Sheila was dead before they got there, there was no one inside to move.
and 4) are debatable. According to Julie Mugford. Jeremy told her that Mathew Mcdonald made a phone call from WHF to Jeremy's cottage via his answer machine. So a record of such call would be made. Since you believe what this woman says there you go. I on the hand don't. But since her testimony can only have come from either the police or the relatives. I postulate that they must have had evidence of such a call and thus got her to parrot an alternative explanation for it.
1) Believing that Jeremy fed her such lie doesn't in any way make Jeremy's lie true. MM had nothing to do with the murders.
2) Even if someone had called from WHF to Goldhanger there still would not have been any phone record proving it.
3) If someone had called Jeremy's answering machine pretending to be Nevill and the tape were turned over to police it would not prove the time of the call, could be used to prove the call wasn't Nevill's voice and worst of all would demolish Jeremy's claim he actually spoke to Nevill as opposed to his answering machine picking up. .
Number 6) Proven: muzzle-imprint abrasion and zone of searing and soot deposition around the contact wound's to Sheila's chin are all consistent with being made by the threaded end of the barrel absent of any silencer. This is supported by four ballistic experts. The typical kneejerk guilter rebuttal is that the CCRC reject this evidence. Indeed they did. In absence of a counter-expert.
Complete nonsense. There is no muzzle imprint except in the minds of fools. The argument that there is a muzzle imprint is pathetic it consists of saying that Vanezis description sounds like a muzzle imprint not a bullet abrasion like he assessed.
Furthermore, Nicholas Caffell having suffered two contact wounds. They failed to discover any blood or tissue evidence of this within the silencer. Another incongruity that supports the evidence I mentioned above.
Nonsense.
1) He suffered contact or near contact shots
2) You are making up that blood would have to get inside the moderator from any and all contact wounds no matter where located which is patently untrue. 22 shots to the head rarely result in backspatter. The reason why Sheila's wound was sure to create drawback was because of its location. She suffered a previous wound that caused her neck to fill with blood thus shooting her in the neck was sure to result in backspatter if a non-contact wound or drawback if a contact wound.
3) if your babble were true then instead of just Sheila's blood having to be in the rifle barrel then their blood would have to have been in it but no blood was inside it.
Evidence that was not discovered by the police but in a rather suspiciously convenient manner, does not cohere with big picture.
It coheres perfectly except in the mind of biased people bent on hiding from reality who would like to pretend the family knew 3 things they didn't have any clue about:
1) the family would have to know that her fatal wound was a contact wound
2) the family would have to know all about drawback and how to mimic it
3) the family would have to have a source of her blood to plant or would have to somehow know that Boutflour's blood had the same attributes.
Naturally here is no evidence of any of these let alone all of them. In addition to planting such evidence the family would have to arrange for someone to remove Sheila's blood from the rifle barrel because it would have been present had the moderator not been used. It would be useless to plant such evidence unless removing it from the barrel because that would prove that either the blood in the barrel or moderator was planted.
7) police used the moderator to scratch the mantle to frame Steven Avery??? Fascinating. please tell me more!
There is nothing to tell. There is just a barebones allegation that police used it to scratch the mantle and get paint on it. This doesn't come from the basis of evidence it is made up out of necessity to try to explain away the evidence.
-
It is not even remotely debatable. Police thought they might have seen some movement but later recognized it was just them moving their heads that gave the impression of such. Sheila was dead before they got there, there was no one inside to move.
Venezis could not establish a time of death. You have no evidence to nail a time of death before 3am.
Furthermore, how do you explain the lack of post mortem hypostasis in the photos of Sheila taken after 9.30am?
https://image.slidesharecdn.com/pmi-140425060727-phpapp01/95/post-mortem-interval-7-638.jpg?cb=1398406233 (https://image.slidesharecdn.com/pmi-140425060727-phpapp01/95/post-mortem-interval-7-638.jpg?cb=1398406233)
1) Believing that Jeremy fed her such lie doesn't in any way make Jeremy's lie true. MM had nothing to do with the murders.
2) Even if someone had called from WHF to Goldhanger there still would not have been any phone record proving it.
3) If someone had called Jeremy's answering machine pretending to be Nevill and the tape were turned over to police it would not prove the time of the call, could be used to prove the call wasn't Nevill's voice and worst of all would demolish Jeremy's claim he actually spoke to Nevill as opposed to his answering machine picking up. .
From Julies Testimony she seems to be implying that the record of the call would be established via the redial feature on the phone at WHF. That's the only way it could be recorded.
Complete nonsense. There is no muzzle imprint except in the minds of fools. The argument that there is a muzzle imprint is pathetic it consists of saying that Vanezis description sounds like a muzzle imprint not a bullet abrasion like he assessed.
Dr Fowler and Philip Boyce examined the autopsy photographs. Saying they just read Vanezis autopsy papers and misinterpreted his words is rubbish you made up.
If this evidence is so "pathetic" why did the CCRC fail to find a counter expert to challenge it? If this evidence is so "pathetic" why do you have make things up to refute it?
Nonsense.
1) He suffered contact or near contact shots
2) You are making up that blood would have to get inside the moderator from any and all contact wounds no matter where located which is patently untrue. 22 shots to the head rarely result in backspatter. The reason why Sheila's wound was sure to create drawback was because of its location. She suffered a previous wound that caused her neck to fill with blood thus shooting her in the neck was sure to result in backspatter if a non-contact wound or drawback if a contact wound.
Once again, you peddle un-scientific falsehoods.
It is well known that gunshot wounding can produce fine droplets of blood spattered in a forward direction. Under certain circumstances blood droplets can also be propelled backwards in a direction against the line of fire. Although the phenomenon of back spatter of blood is most commonly seen in contact gunshot wounds of the head
Stephens, B. and Allen, T., "Back Spatter of Blood from Gunshot Wounds—Observations and Experimental Simulation," Journal of Forensic Sciences, Vol. 28, No. 2, 1983, pp. 437-439,
The absence of any blood or tissue from Nicholas Caffell in the moderator. Is because the silencer was in the cupboard all night long.
It coheres perfectly except in the mind of biased people bent on hiding from reality who would like to pretend the family knew 3 things they didn't have any clue about:
1) the family would have to know that her fatal wound was a contact wound
2) the family would have to know all about drawback and how to mimic it
3) the family would have to have a source of her blood to plant or would have to somehow know that Boutflour's blood had the same attributes.
Naturally here is no evidence of any of these
1) With a rifle, how can it not be a contact wound? you cannot hold such weapon at a distance then shoot yourself.
2) Anyone can read a text book and learn about it. I have, you have. what's to preclude them from such knowledge?
3) They had Sheila's blood in their possession. They took her underwear stained with menstrual blood back with them when they found the silencer.
https://s28.postimg.org/rddeqf6z1/ae6677.jpg (https://s28.postimg.org/rddeqf6z1/ae6677.jpg)
In addition to planting such evidence the family would have to arrange for someone to remove Sheila's blood from the rifle barrel because it would have been present had the moderator not been used. It would be useless to plant such evidence unless removing it from the barrel because that would prove that either the blood in the barrel or moderator was planted.
I have shown you the extract from Dimao's book enough times. Another case of you ignoring forensic science.
From this post alone there are six forensic experts you stonewall due to your own stubborn refusal to admit you are wrong. Why did a deeper hole for yourself?
-
Venezis could not establish a time of death. You have no evidence to nail a time of death before 3am.
There is indeed evidence which proves she was killed before police arrived:
1) she was shot with a moderator that was subsequently put away
2) after she died and her blood pooled the Bible was placed in it
3) It any shots had been fired while police were present then the police would have heard them through the open window.
Furthermore, how do you explain the lack of post mortem hypostasis in the photos of Sheila taken after 9.30am?
1) The photos you are referring to are not high quality and worse don't show much of the body. There is no way to say whether any is present or not.
2) Furthermore post mortem hypostasis doesn't always develop. It is well documented that it doesn't develop in all people. The MOST COMMON reason for it not developing is when a victim hemorrhages. She didn't merely suffer from significant external bleeding there was much more extensive internal bleeding.
Bottom line you once again made up your own bogus rules - in this instance that she would have to have developed post mortem hypostasis unless she died shortly before police took the photos. You also make up that you can tell for sure she has none based on photos where most of her body is covered and the quality is not great. Others already previously dismantled this BS including Caroline. Rehashing the same disproved nonsense just renders you a copy of Mike.
From Julies Testimony she seems to be implying that the record of the call would be established via the redial feature on the phone at WHF. That's the only way it could be recorded.
Proving the last call was to Goldhanger would fail to prove the time it was made. It could have been made at 11:30 before going to bed.
Dr Fowler and Philip Boyce examined the autopsy photographs. Saying they just read Vanezis autopsy papers and misinterpreted his words is rubbish you made up.
No, what I said was they asserted the wound had a muzzle imprint on the basis of Vanezis's words. That they looked at the photos is meaningless because the photos demonstrated no marks they could identify as muzzle imprints. They relied upon Vanezis description of the wound to assert there was a muzzle imprint saying the description sounded like an imprint to them. That description though clearly is a bullet abrasion and dirt ring.
If this evidence is so "pathetic" why did the CCRC fail to find a counter expert to challenge it? If this evidence is so "pathetic" why do you have make things up to refute it?
They already had an experts who refuted it- those who testified at the trial. Vanezis said it was a bullet abrasion. Their speculation that he was wrong and tha tit was a muzzle imprint based on the sound of it means nothing at all. There is no need to rebut unsupported speculation that can't be the basis for overturning a verdict.
Why don't you post the full rejection by the CCRC so we can look in detail and the explanation for the rejection and then you can look like an even bigger fool.
Once again, you peddle un-scientific falsehoods.
You are the one doing such and as usual project your flaws onto others rather than face reality.
It is well known that gunshot wounding can produce fine droplets of blood spattered in a forward direction. Under certain circumstances blood droplets can also be propelled backwards in a direction against the line of fire. Although the phenomenon of back spatter of blood is most commonly seen in contact gunshot wounds of the head
Stephens, B. and Allen, T., "Back Spatter of Blood from Gunshot Wounds—Observations and Experimental Simulation," Journal of Forensic Sciences, Vol. 28, No. 2, 1983, pp. 437-439,
The absence of any blood or tissue from Nicholas Caffell in the moderator. Is because the silencer was in the cupboard all night long.
That description fails in any way to support your argument that Nicholas' blood would have to be in the moderator. All it says is that it is most commonly seen with gunshots to the head. In no way does it suggest that all or most shots to the head result in back spatter.
In the meantime it is wrong, it is commonly seen in several locations. Moreover it doesn't speak to what area of the head or discuss the caliber. We are talking about a 22LR bullet and they rarely result in drawback with shots to the head.
In the meantime the wound was not necessarily a contact shot it could have been a near contact.
Post a source that says 22LR shots to the head always result in drawback which is what you are arguing. You won't find any source that states such because it is fictional.
1) With a rifle, how can it not be a contact wound? you cannot hold such weapon at a distance then shoot yourself.
Yes you can, you simply can't hold it too far away given arms are only so long.
2) Anyone can read a text book and learn about it. I have, you have. what's to preclude them from such knowledge?
You are reading books on the internet and grossly distorting everything they say. Despite much more extensive resources than existed at the time there still is limited material about drawback. You never would have heard of drawback let alone be researching it if not for the fact that experts discussed its relevance in this trial. You did simply read a book and encounter a discussion about drawback. You looked up the issue because someone else told you about it. Most of the police didn't even know about it only the lab did.
Just saying well maybe they read a book about it is worthless speculation you need to prove they did read a book about it or present other evidence that proves that they knew about it but can't.
3) They had Sheila's blood in their possession. They took her underwear stained with menstrual blood back with them when they found the silencer.
Who is they? AE threw her panties in the garbage and took the garbage bag back with her but ultimately threw it away.
In the meantime suggesting that dry blood on her panties was able to be liquefied so they could plant it in the moderator is stupid even for you.
I have shown you the extract from Dimao's book enough times. Another case of you ignoring forensic science.
From this post alone there are six forensic experts you stonewall due to your own stubborn refusal to admit you are wrong. Why did a deeper hole for yourself?
Nothing in his book supports any of your contentions. No where does he suggest that shots to the head always result in back spatter or drawback let alone suggest that all shots to the head with 22LRs do so. There is no proof for sure that anyone except Sheila suffered a contact wound. In the meantime if your claim had been true then it would require Nicolas' blood to be in the rifle but it wasn't nor was Sheila's. The family had no ability to doctor the rifle since it was never in their possession.
If they actually knew all about drawback and knew she suffered a contact wound that would have to result in drawback then they would know her blood would be in the rifle and that planting blood int he moderator would be futile because it would be proven planted by her blood being in the rifle.
You ignore what science actually states and make up your own rules to try to pretend that Jeremy is innocent. in your post you made up that all shots to the head result in drawback and rely on a quote that merely states the most common location to result in backspatter is the head. That doesn't assert the only location nor does it assert all shots to the head result in drawback. You ignore what is written and make up your own rules . you did the same thing with post mortem hypostasis. Back when you first made the argument you quoted from a source that stated outright that it doe snot always occur in all people and specifically listed hemorrhaging as a factor against it. Despite such you made up that it would have to occur in all people and made up that we can tell in the photos that Sheila doesn't exhibit any.
-
1) she was shot with a moderator that was subsequently put away
2) after she died and her blood pooled the Bible was placed in it
3) It any shots had been fired while police were present then the police would have heard them through the open window.
1) Ballistic evidence says otherwise
2) The bible was originally found around 18 inches away from her body. This is the account of those first at the scene.
Dr Macdonnell argued for point 2) in 1992. However Dr Maconnell recanted his conclusions in 2009 when he received evidence of the police restaging the crime scene.
https://s8.postimg.org/be9jpmjp1/1419546970187.jpg (https://s8.postimg.org/be9jpmjp1/1419546970187.jpg)
3) PC Hall heard a loud noise. It was apparently Rozga in a location he never was.
1) The photos you are referring to are not high quality and worse don't show much of the body. There is no way to say whether any is present or not.
2) Furthermore post mortem hypostasis doesn't always develop. It is well documented that it doesn't develop in all people. The MOST COMMON reason for it not developing is when a victim hemorrhages. She didn't merely suffer from significant external bleeding there was much more extensive internal bleeding.
1) The photos are fine.
2) Indeed it does not always develop but in this case it did. Vanezis autopsy report of Sheila page 2 - quote. "Hypostasis was consistent with the position in which she was found and the scene"
Hypostasis was observed by Vanezis during autopsy after 3pm that afternoon as expected. Your argument is that it don't always develop thus doesn't need to be present. But it is present. Therefore, your argument is logically invalid.
It cannot be observed in photos from 9.30am but is apparent after 3pm the same day. Supports a time of death after 6am.
No, what I said was they asserted the wound had a muzzle imprint on the basis of Vanezis's words. That they looked at the photos is meaningless because the photos demonstrated no marks they could identify as muzzle imprints. They relied upon Vanezis description of the wound to assert there was a muzzle imprint saying the description sounded like an imprint to them. That description though clearly is a bullet abrasion and dirt ring.
Maybe you have trouble hearing? if so i have typed up the conversation word for word.
Mark Thomas: Now you've looked at the photograph's
Philip Boyce: I have.
Mark Thomas: These are of Sheila's Injuries.
Philip Boyce: I have.
Mark Thomas: Which would you say is the most likely to have occurred?
Philip Boyce: Based on my examination of the wounds in the photographs.And the tests that i have just done. I'm of the opinion that the contact wounds to Sheila's chin. Was contact without the silencer fitted.
They already had an experts who refuted it- those who testified at the trial. Vanezis said it was a bullet abrasion. Their speculation that he was wrong and tha tit was a muzzle imprint based on the sound of it means nothing at all. There is no need to rebut unsupported speculation that can't be the basis for overturning a verdict.
There is no mention of that in Bamber vs CCRC 2012. They failed to counter the evidence and fell back on scratch marks evidence.
That is why they resorted to the kitchen/paint evidence as justification for a non referral. And the COA has already made judgement on the paint evidence
2002 Appeal
The sound moderator had on any view been attached to the rifle during the fight with Nevill Bamber in the kitchen. But if Sheila Caffell had committed suicide it must have been removed before she shot herself
Had the appellant's sister murdered the other members of her family with the moderator attached to the gun and then discovered she could not reach the trigger to kill herself, the moderator would have been found next to her body. There would have been no reason for her to have removed it and returned it to the gun cupboard before going back upstairs to commit suicide in her parents' room.
Bamber vs CCRC 2012
That there was red paint on the curled end and a mark on the mantelpiece, which, given the other evidence, showed that the silencer must have been on.
The first is the fact that the evidence of Dr Fowler does not grapple with the evidence of the fight in the kitchen and the paint evidence
That question again has resolved into a narrow issue as to whether, when the fatal shot was fired in the kitchen at the father, Mr Bamber senior, the rifle used had on it a silencer, it being accepted that if there was a silencer on it at that time the prospects of the sister being the murderer were nil.
That description fails in any way to support your argument that Nicholas' blood would have to be in the moderator. All it says is that it is most commonly seen with gunshots to the head. In no way does it suggest that all or most shots to the head result in back spatter.
In the meantime it is wrong, it is commonly seen in several locations. Moreover it doesn't speak to what area of the head or discuss the caliber. We are talking about a 22LR bullet and they rarely result in drawback with shots to the head.
In the meantime the wound was not necessarily a contact shot it could have been a near contact.
Post a source that says 22LR shots to the head always result in drawback which is what you are arguing. You won't find any source that states such because it is fictional.
It's not just the the absence of blood it's also the absence of brain tissue and bone.
Test shots on live pigs destined for slaughter showed that bone particles are a feature of backspatter from close-range shots to heads. Contamination of nearby surfaces by bone fragments and bone-plus-bullet fragments, as well as other organic debris, appears to be quite heavy.
Burnett, B., "Detection of Bone and Bone-Plus-Bullet Particles in Backspatter from Close-Range Shots to Heads," Journal of Forensic Sciences, Vol. 36, No. 6, 1991, pp. 1745-1752,
Backspatter is most frequent in contact wounds to the head because the cranium leaves nowhere for the gas to go plus you have a temporary cavity causing the skull to fracture forcing even more biological tissue of the entrance wound. This is a huge contrast to the neck. Biological evidence of Sheila in moderator but sans Nicholas further indicates no silencer was used.
In the meantime suggesting that dry blood on her panties was able to be liquified so they could plant it in the moderator is stupid even for you.
The panties and blood was found soaked in water.
-
Mike must be Bamber's most dedicated supporter.
Wilkes's book mentions a fellow prisoner supporting Bamber. I assume this was Mike. As Wilkes's book was published in the mid 90's, Mike's been supporting Bamber well over 20 years & hasn't wobbled.
He created the Blue forum and for a long time was the only one posting and creating threads on it. Eventually other people joined and it became a pro Bamber site for a period. It's now got more guilters than supporters after a lot of people changed stance, however Mike still posts a lot & creates Youtube videos supporting Bamber. His posts do often include never seen before sources.
His determination should be admired.
The only other remaining supporter of a similar lenght I can think of is Lookout. Unlike Mike, she doesn't leave the Blue forum & supporting Bamber on just a 1986 'gut feeling' never posts anything worthwhile.
Grahame is another long term supporter although no longer posts. Jane J was a supporter since 1986 but changed stance recently.
-
Mike must be Bamber's most dedicated supporter.
Wilkes's book mentions a fellow prisoner supporting Bamber. I assume this was Mike. As Wilkes's book was published in the mid 90's, Mike's been supporting Bamber well over 20 years & hasn't wobbled.
He created the Blue forum and for a long time was the only one posting and creating threads on it. Eventually other people joined and it became a pro Bamber site for a period. It's now got more guilters than supporters after a lot of people changed stance, however Mike still posts a lot & creates Youtube videos supporting Bamber. His posts do often include never seen before sources.
His determination should be admired.
The only other remaining supporter of a similar lenght I can think of is Lookout. Unlike Mike, she doesn't leave the Blue forum & supporting Bamber on just a 1986 'gut feeling' never posts anything worthwhile.
Grahame is another long term supporter although no longer posts. Jane J was a supporter since 1986 but changed stance recently.
Caroline was a supporter for a year two. But had a change of heart after Jeremy forgot to answer a question she put to him. But later her did answer it for her. Having now seen part of this correspondence. I am not at all convinced this is the real reason. I suspect its probably something to do with Paul Harrison.
As for Jane J. Clearly, her love for Caroline outweighed her hatred of Julie's court outfit.
-
Caroline was a supporter for a year two. But had a change of heart after Jeremy forgot to answer a question she put to him. But later her did answer it for her. Having now seen part of this correspondence. I am not at all convinced this is the real reason. I suspect its probably something to do with Paul Harrison.
As for Jane J. Clearly, her love for Caroline outweighed her hatred of Julie's court outfit.
A little goading David? Seems it's all you're good for these days. Your above comment just shows what an utterly useless detective you are and your obsession with myself, Jane and PH just makes you a complete weirdo!
-
Caroline was a supporter for a year two. But had a change of heart after Jeremy forgot to answer a question she put to him. But later her did answer it for her. Having now seen part of this correspondence. I am not at all convinced this is the real reason. I suspect its probably something to do with Paul Harrison.
As for Jane J. Clearly, her love for Caroline outweighed her hatred of Julie's court outfit.
David !
It's no secret Jane J supported Bamber for 30 years because she didn't like Julie's court outfit. However other reasons people have given for supporting Bamber - 'gut feelings', 'two shots' are no better.
It's also no secret Jane J changed stance a couple of hours after Caroline did, & has always refused to discuss why.
At least Caroline has given a reason for a stance change & provided sources. Although the wallet was a surprising reason for a 360 degree turn considering all the incriminating forensic & circumstantial evidence that was already available.
-
Mike must be Bamber's most dedicated supporter.
Wilkes's book mentions a fellow prisoner supporting Bamber. I assume this was Mike. As Wilkes's book was published in the mid 90's, Mike's been supporting Bamber well over 20 years & hasn't wobbled.
He created the Blue forum and for a long time was the only one posting and creating threads on it. Eventually other people joined and it became a pro Bamber site for a period. It's now got more guilters than supporters after a lot of people changed stance, however Mike still posts a lot & creates Youtube videos supporting Bamber. His posts do often include never seen before sources.
His determination should be admired.
The only other remaining supporter of a similar length I can think of is Lookout. Unlike Mike, she doesn't leave the Blue forum & supporting Bamber on just a 1986 'gut feeling' never posts anything worthwhile.
Grahame is another long term supporter although no longer posts. Jane J was a supporter since 1986 but changed stance recently.
A fruitcake comes to mind. Have you not seen his rantings and his cloud wandering?
The word is obsessed, not dedicated. Even Bamber told him to do one!! @)(++(*
-
Mike must be Bamber's most dedicated supporter.
Wilkes's book mentions a fellow prisoner supporting Bamber. I assume this was Mike. As Wilkes's book was published in the mid 90's, Mike's been supporting Bamber well over 20 years & hasn't wobbled.
He created the Blue forum and for a long time was the only one posting and creating threads on it. Eventually other people joined and it became a pro Bamber site for a period. It's now got more guilters than supporters after a lot of people changed stance, however Mike still posts a lot & creates Youtube videos supporting Bamber. His posts do often include never seen before sources.
His determination should be admired.
The only other remaining supporter of a similar lenght I can think of is Lookout. Unlike Mike, she doesn't leave the Blue forum & supporting Bamber on just a 1986 'gut feeling' never posts anything worthwhile.
Grahame is another long term supporter although no longer posts. Jane J was a supporter since 1986 but changed stance recently.
This thread seems to be moving away from the title/OP to general discussions about supporters, or past supporters, so I'll move relevant posts to a new thread.
What's the definition of "most dedicated"? Does "most dedicated" = most effective?
How do we know who supports JB, what sort of contribution they have made over what time period? I don't think it necessarily follows that all supporters contribute to forums. Maybe some have been around pre conviction?
-
A fruitcake comes to mind. Have you not seen his rantings and his cloud wandering?
The word is obsessed, not dedicated. Even Bamber told him to do one!! @)(++(*
I agree. I sometimes wish I was more tolerant! Most on Blue, regardless of camp, seem to tolerate him in a way I don't think I could now. Apart from the fact he created the forum and uploaded the docs I can't think of anything else positive to say. 8(8-))
-
David !
It's no secret Jane J supported Bamber for 30 years because she didn't like Julie's court outfit. However other reasons people have given for supporting Bamber - 'gut feelings', 'two shots' are no better.
It's also no secret Jane J changed stance a couple of hours after Caroline did, & has always refused to discuss why.
At least Caroline has given a reason for a stance change & provided sources. Although the wallet was a surprising reason for a 360 degree turn considering all the incriminating forensic & circumstantial evidence that was already available.
Don't let David drag you down to his level.
-
I agree. I sometimes wish I was more tolerant! Most on Blue, regardless of camp, seem to tolerate him in a way I don't think I could now. Apart from the fact he created the forum and uploaded the docs I can't think of anything else positive to say. 8(8-))
Jane and I don't!
-
I posted the following on the blue forum last night. Just wondered what members here thought?
Many people who believe Jeremy is innocent, just can't get their head around the notion that the police may have been in conversation with someone inside the 'farmhouse'.
That one line conjures up images of Sheila holding on to the rifle in a 'you'll never take me alive coppers' type scenario.
I have previously argued that Bonnett probably just wrote the wrong phrase when he used the words 'in conversation', until I noticed something that I hadn't rationalised before. Something gets repeated here so many times that we often take for granted what we believe is written and miss was is actually stated. I was under the assumption that Bonnett's log stated "Firearms team are in conversation with someone from inside the FARMHOUSE, however, what Bonnett actually wrote was "Firearms team are in conversation with someone from inside the FARM' not FARMHOUSE - just FARM. His next line is "Challenge to persons inside HOUSE met with no response". Bonnett distinguishes FARM from HOUSE and the distinction is important when compared with the various TFG statements. Just before the TFG approached the farm with the loud hailer, they WERE in conversation with someone, they were in conversation with Jeremy Bamber; Jeremy Bamber was someone FROM the farm; an inside man so to speak. I believe that the line "Firearms team are in conversation with someone from inside the FARM " is a reference to the conversation between Jeremy and the TFG as referenced below - (see Collins's partial statement below the relevant section of Bonnett's log). It's important because JUST AFTER the conversation with Jeremy, the TFG made their challenge to 'persons inside the HOUSE' which as we know was 'met with no response'. So no mystery after all as far as I am concerned - Bonnett's comment was in respect to the conversation with Jeremy! Hence the distinction between 'Farm' and 'House'.
22
To get back on topic for a moment, the 'was in conversation with someone in the farmhouse' is just another false claim and forlorn hope by those who are desperate to believe that Jeremy Bamber is innocent. Had it occurred it would have been a crucial development and documented as such in great detail. If I recall from the police statements, warnings to anyone inside went unanswered and the only noise recorded on the open phone line was that of June Bamber's dog Crispy barking.
-
Jane and I don't!
You seem to give him an easier time than the one from the NW!
-
I agree. I sometimes wish I was more tolerant! Most on Blue, regardless of camp, seem to tolerate him in a way I don't think I could now. Apart from the fact he created the forum and uploaded the docs I can't think of anything else positive to say. 8(8-))
He's complaining about being burgled!! @)(++(*
I think my irony klaxon just exploded. 8(8-))
-
He's complaining about being burgled!! @)(++(*
I think my irony klaxon just exploded. 8(8-))
Lol. That'll be officialdom after his enigma machine @)(++(*
-
You seem to give him an easier time than the one from the NW!
Can you challenge the one from the NW re her claims over TOD ie it wasn't a hospital ward where patients are constantly monitored? For TOD to have any relevance in JB's case some medically qualified person would need to confirm SC died between the time JB was stood outside with EP and the time EP found SC presumed dead. An impossible task.
http://www.fsijournal.org/article/S0379-0738(96)02011-7/abstract
-
He's complaining about being burgled!! @)(++(*
I think my irony klaxon just exploded. 8(8-))
Mike did at least give a scenario on how Sheila committed the massacre. Saying 'by shooting them'.
Mike's scenario was a bit short. But I agree with him that a guilty Sheila would have shot everyone.
-
Mike did at least give a scenario on how Sheila committed the massacre. Saying 'by shooting them'.
Mike's scenario was a bit short. But I agree with him that a guilty Sheila would have shot everyone.
I like it when Mike pretends to be John Wayne on the toilet. AND when clappedout tells everyone how she bites her toilet seat!! Ha!!
Old people are funny! *&*%£
-
I like it when Mike pretends to be John Wayne on the toilet. AND when clappedout tells everyone how she bites her toilet seat!! Ha!!
Old people are funny! *&*%£
Not sure if Mike still believes in Bamber's innocence. However the amount & tone of his posts certainly have not changed over the years.
I have no doubt Lookout knows Bamber is guilty. There has simply been too many threads and posts highlighing Bamber's guilt. Most of which she posts on. But will never admit her 'gut feeling' was wrong. Previously saying 'hell would freeze over' before withdrawing support.
The only poster brave enough to admit she had been wrong for 30 odd years was Jane J, who Lookout spends all day in conversation with.