UK Justice Forum 🇬🇧

Alleged Miscarriages of Justice => Jeremy Bamber and the callous murder of his father, mother, sister and twin nephews. Case effectively CLOSED by CCRC on basis of NO APPEAL REFERRAL. => Topic started by: jackiepreece on January 06, 2013, 09:45:43 AM

Title: Questions for the Definately Guilty Posters
Post by: jackiepreece on January 06, 2013, 09:45:43 AM
Questions for the Bamber is Guilty Posters

1)
Colin Caffell guessed that Sheila had committed suicide when the police called to the house to tell him about the murders.  If Colin really believed Sheila's state of mind was so bad around that period why is it so hard to believe she would also kill her children/family.
Someone that would appear that ill surely does think rationally and I am sure if an expert had seen her around the last time Colin was with her she would have been sectioned to somewhere where she would be safe???

2)
Supposedly the police who dealt with the murders on the day were highly experienced.  I find it completely bizarre Sheila's clean condition was not questioned. As probably one of the biggest incidents most of the police had ever attended quite unbelievable ????

3)
Should it be ruled out when debating the case that Neville was forced by a third party to ring Jeremy  in the light of threats made to Neville by certain individuals and a panic alarm being fitted to WHF?
Could the murders have been committed by this third party and Jeremy doesn't even know and still believes it to be Sheila himself?

4)
Why was vital evidence destroyed from probably the biggest murder ever carried out in Essex when Jeremy made it clear from day one he would be appealing???

5)
Why did David Boutflour mislead the jury by saying Sheila had never used a gun????

Even back in 1986 it was known by most of the general public you could contaminate evidence. Why would the family remove the silencer and tamper with it and not call the police?

6)
PC mercer remains adamant his dog would have picked up firearms residue on Jeremy surely another strong point in Jeremy's favour?

7)
There seems to be no ACTUAL evidence that Jeremy hated Sheila/his family

8)
Jeremy had savings at the time of the murders and had a beautiful cottage furnished by his family from an expensive store in London. The landlord from the local pub where Jeremy ate most nights supported Jeremy and certainly never gave any evidence that Jeremy was unhappy with his family, job, lifestyle.

9)
Would Jeremy really have dumped Julie Mugford so soon after the murders if she really knew he was responsible?
Title: Re: Questions for the Definately Guilty Posters
Post by: puglove on January 06, 2013, 12:13:45 PM
Jac, you know Mercer, don't you? Doesn't he work in your local Co Op, or something? Was his dog a sniffer dog, trained for gun residue, or just a bog standard police dog?
Title: Re: Questions for the Definately Guilty Posters
Post by: Andrea on January 06, 2013, 12:29:15 PM
colin didnt believe Sheila's state of mind was bad at the time of the murders, he said she was quiet on the journey to WHF. He did believe that Sheila killed herself, but couldnt accept that she would shoot her boys or her father. Especially the way in which they were murdered.
Title: Re: Questions for the Definately Guilty Posters
Post by: goatboy on January 06, 2013, 03:01:08 PM
1)
Colin Caffell guessed that Sheila had committed suicide when the police called to the house to tell him about the murders.  If Colin really believed Sheila's state of mind was so bad around that period why is it so hard to believe she would also kill her children/family.
Someone that would appear that ill surely does think rationally and I am sure if an expert had seen her around the last time Colin was with her she would have been sectioned to somewhere where she would be safe???


 I don't doubt that Sheila had serious mental problems. I suspect when Colin was told it was merely explained that she had shot her children and parents then herself. I doubt if the police went into detail about the fact her nails appeared perfectly manicured, that she must have reloaded the rifle at least twice, and furthermore gone on a killing spree in a flimsy nightie with no pockets to keep extra ammo in. Finally they may not even have said she had two bullet wounds. All of this would have put doubts in Colin's head. Though I don't doubt she could have had suicidal impulses (though how can anybody know what goes on in someone's mind?) myself and many others feel it unlikely she would have killed her children at the Bamber residence, and furthermore that she would have delivered the final blow in a different room to her children. It's not enough just to say "she wasn't thinking straight because she was mad."
2)
Supposedly the police who dealt with the murders on the day were highly experienced.  I find it completely bizarre Sheila's clean condition was not questioned. As probably one of the biggest incidents most of the police had ever attended quite unbelievable ????

Not all of them did, remember, Stan Jones was doing his job properly in the face of much opposition from his colleagues. Bamber did a good job in painting the scene that the police would expect to find and the police initially saw no reason to doubt his story. Don't forget also that everyone, guilty and innocent camp alike, agrees the initial crime scene investigation was incredibly badly handled and EP were hauled over the coals for it subsequently. Anyone remember the newspaper headline showing a furious then Home Secretary Douglas Hurd stating "How did you let him fool you?"
3)
Should it be ruled out when debating the case that Neville was forced by a third party to ring Jeremy  in the light of threats made to Neville by certain individuals and a panic alarm being fitted to WHF?
Could the murders have been committed by this third party and Jeremy doesn't even know and still believes it to be Sheila himself?

Yes, it can be completely ruled out. Why would a third party decide to make it look like Sheila was the killer while simultaneously framing Bamber? It makes no sense. Also there were no signs of forced entry to/exit from the property, and only Jeremy himself knew a way of getting in and out undetected
4)
Why was vital evidence destroyed from probably the biggest murder ever carried out in Essex when Jeremy made it clear from day one he would be appealing???

See answer 2, EP badly mishandled the case. Remember they even disposed of bloodstained clothing and bedding at the scene, and contrary to what we have heard on the blue forum this was done by the police following a request from Bamber which they happily complied with, it was certainly not the police's decision to do this, and one of the many acts for which EP received criticism
5)
Why did David Boutflour mislead the jury by saying Sheila had never used a gun????

Even back in 1986 it was known by most of the general public you could contaminate evidence. Why would the family remove the silencer and tamper with it and not call the police?

If EP had done their job correctly they would have found the silencer, regardless of the integrity of the exhibit it is widely believed it was Sheila's bood inside. How did this get in there? Do you really believe somebody planted it there as they had samples of her period blood (this theory has been taken seriously on the blue forum believe it or not)? While it is possible Sheila may have handled a gun in her childhood it is not likely she had done so recently, and certainly not often enough to have competently handled the rifle as the killer had clearly done. I've no idea why David would have said never though.
6)
PC mercer remains adamant his dog would have picked up firearms residue on Jeremy surely another strong point in Jeremy's favour?

Two reasons: If Jeremy himself did the shootings he certainly would have worn gloves and protective clothing and disposed of these carefully to make sure he was forensically clean. Alternatively he didn't actually do any of the shooting himself as a hitman did it for him. This is working on the assumption that the dog definitely was trained to detect firearm residue. Why would they have needed such a dog at the scene anyway given what the police were expecting to find (namely a deranged woman with a rifle who may have killed four other people?
7)
There seems to be no ACTUAL evidence that Jeremy hated Sheila/his family
Plenty of people independently stated that he expressed hate for his parents. Were any of these comments written down or recorded on tape? I doubt it, but doesn't this build up a picture of a man who had enough hate in him to have committed the murders?
8)
Jeremy had savings at the time of the murders and had a beautiful cottage furnished by his family from an expensive store in London. The landlord from the local pub where Jeremy ate most nights supported Jeremy and certainly never gave any evidence that Jeremy was unhappy with his family, job, lifestyle.

That he was comparatively well off is not in question, that he stood to be a very wealthy man eventually had he not committed the murders also is true. So what was his motive? Purely and simply his own greed and impatience. He was young at the time, the young are not universally known for their patience.Why would he have confided his innermost feelings and plans to commit the perfect murder to a pub landlord?
9)
Would Jeremy really have dumped Julie Mugford so soon after the murders if she really knew he was responsible?

He was and probably still is a very arrogant man. He simply would have taken the view that she would be seen as a woman scorned who had made up the whole thing and her word against his, and guess what? A number of people still believe this so perhaps this was not as stupid a plan as you may think.
Title: Re: Questions for the Definately Guilty Posters
Post by: jackiepreece on January 06, 2013, 03:49:35 PM
Goatboy in relation to your answer to my question. 1) I am trying take away the argument Sheila would not shoot or harm her children.
Correct me if I am wrong but didn't ColinCaffell say to the police when they came to give him the news about the murders 'she's done it then' or something to that effect.
That statement made it sound like Colin Caffell would not be surprised if Sheila would decide to end her life.
If Sheila was in such a bad place she decided to end her own life I have no problem believing she could end the life of her children too. She would have not been thinking rationally at all about anything.

I think there are now plenty of studies that mothers do kill their children in exceptional circumstances
Title: Re: Questions for the Definately Guilty Posters
Post by: sika on January 06, 2013, 05:20:48 PM
Goatboy in relation to your answer to my question. 1) I am trying take away the argument Sheila would not shoot or harm her children.
Correct me if I am wrong but didn't ColinCaffell say to the police when they came to give him the news about the murders 'she's done it then' or something to that effect.
That statement made it sound like Colin Caffell would not be surprised if Sheila would decide to end her life.
If Sheila was in such a bad place she decided to end her own life I have no problem believing she could end the life of her children too. She would have not been thinking rationally at all about anything.

I think there are now plenty of studies that mothers do kill their children in exceptional circumstances
It seems very believable that Shelia was capable of suicide.
It even seems plausible that she might be capable of murder.
In this case those scenarios are rendered totally irrelevant, due to the mountain of evidence which clearly proves, beyond any reasonable doubt, that Shelia could not have carried out these murders.
Title: Re: Questions for the Definately Guilty Posters
Post by: sika on January 06, 2013, 05:25:11 PM
Jackie, in response to question 8.
I infer from your question that you believe Jeremy's explanation as to why he carried out the Caravan site robbery.
Title: Re: Questions for the Definately Guilty Posters
Post by: sika on January 06, 2013, 05:33:21 PM

Supposedly the police who dealt with the murders on the day were highly experienced.  I find it completely bizarre Sheila's clean condition was not questioned. As probably one of the biggest incidents most of the police had ever attended quite unbelievable ????

I agree that it was quite a staggering oversight, although I wouldn't go as far as to say 'unbelievable'.  In any case, how does this support Jeremy's case?
Are you suggesting that Shelia wasn't in the 'clean condition' that we have been led to believe?
Title: Re: Questions for the Definately Guilty Posters
Post by: Myster on January 06, 2013, 05:57:28 PM
Questions for the Bamber is Guilty Posters

1)
Colin Caffell guessed that Sheila had committed suicide when the police called to the house to tell him about the murders.  If Colin really believed Sheila's state of mind was so bad around that period why is it so hard to believe she would also kill her children/family.
Someone that would appear that ill surely does think rationally and I am sure if an expert had seen her around the last time Colin was with her she would have been sectioned to somewhere where she would be safe???

This is where a simple statement ("Oh no, then she finally did it!") about his first reaction to being told the news is blown up out of all proportion.

He also later stated that physically Sheila was extremely sluggish and nauseous as a result of the Haloperidol injections even after they had been reduced, so much so that she was incapable of making coffee without spilling either the granules or water everywhere, and she was not like that before she received them. He thought it even more unlikely that she was capable of using a rifle, let alone fire it accurately.

You have to consider not only the mental side but also the physical... and in this case the latter outweighs the former.

Have you read 'In search of...', Jackie?
Title: Re: Questions for the Definately Guilty Posters
Post by: Andrea on January 06, 2013, 06:19:01 PM
If sheila was worried she would lose her twins, she would have killed them at her own flat in Maida vale, then she would have lay at the side of them and killed herself.

No way would she take her mam and dad with her, what would have been the need in that. You believe this killing was an act of altruism, jackie? if that was the case, Neville and June would still be here.
Title: Re: Questions for the Definately Guilty Posters
Post by: Angelo222 on January 06, 2013, 10:44:14 PM
Goatboy in relation to your answer to my question. 1) I am trying take away the argument Sheila would not shoot or harm her children.
Correct me if I am wrong but didn't ColinCaffell say to the police when they came to give him the news about the murders 'she's done it then' or something to that effect.
That statement made it sound like Colin Caffell would not be surprised if Sheila would decide to end her life.
If Sheila was in such a bad place she decided to end her own life I have no problem believing she could end the life of her children too. She would have not been thinking rationally at all about anything.

I think there are now plenty of studies that mothers do kill their children in exceptional circumstances

If Colin had thought for a minute that Sheila would hurt the twins he would not have allowed them to stay over at the farm.  Sheila doing something silly to herself however was another issue.    8(0(*
Title: Re: Questions for the Definately Guilty Posters
Post by: Myster on February 21, 2013, 05:08:38 PM
The attached gives a bit more insight into the way guns were stored and left about at WHF

I have no idea if JB was telling the truth about where he left a gun as we have no way of proving this

I've replied to this in your own thread, Jackie.

*******************************************************

Jeremy Bamber claimed he left the rifle leaning against a pine settle, with a box of ammunition & full magazine clip on top of a blanket lying on it, opposite the den in the vestibule/rear hall adjacent to the kitchen (Wilkes).

The settle (9) can just be seen through the doorway from the office/den...,

(http://img189.imageshack.us/img189/3396/guncupboardplanh.jpg)

But whether he actually left them there is open to question. Granted it does seem slipshod to have firearms and ammunition unsecured (no lock visible on either the gun cupboard or office door) and the Pargeter rifle (with bolt removed) was apparently kept unlocked in the Shower room, but I suppose as Jeremy and Sheila were now adults, security was less of a priority.

Title: Re: Questions for the Definately Guilty Posters
Post by: Tim Invictus on February 21, 2013, 07:20:34 PM
Jackie your questions are puerile and very selective. For example, Colin was TOLD that Sheila had killed herself and her family and he initially accepted what he was told. He thought it was a shotgun spree; but the moment he was told the details of a couple of dozen aimed shots from a rifle reloaded at least twice he was totally convinced Sheila could not have committed the murders.

Colin is absolutely convinced Bamber is guilty and using his uninformed, initial reaction  n such a selective way is totally disingenuous!

I won't bother with all your other biased questions but as it's repeated in every post, you might try spelling the word 'definitely' correctly!
Title: Re: Questions for the Definately Guilty Posters
Post by: Andrea on February 21, 2013, 09:35:55 PM
And she just happens to do it when JB leaves a loaded gun on the settle!! On the very same night!

Dont forget, we only have JB's words for what happened at WHF, the discussion about they boys being fostered etc. All the other witnesses are dead.

Title: Re: Questions for the Definately Guilty Posters
Post by: Dillon on February 21, 2013, 09:58:15 PM
Andrea,I disagree with your assertion that Sheila would have commited suicide in London. Sheila appeared to be on a downward spiral and it is possible that talk of changes to her life,which she may have felt she had lost control over,may have just finally pushed her over the edge.She hated whf and was showing paranoia towards others,believing they were the devil etc.It is very possible Sheila suffered a breakdown whilst at whf.

I would be interested to know what evidence you have, Cheryl, to back up your theories. I know for a fact that Sheila had written an entirely normal and optimistic letter to a relative prior going down to WHF discussing arrangements for an outing with the twins and that this was backed up by a telephone conversation during the evening before the murders when she cheerfully confirmed arrangements for the following day. A police officer who interviewed the relative and took a copy of the letter from Sheila commented that it was clearly not written by someone who was ill and was surprised in view of the way the case at that point was being held to be suicide/murder.  Maybe all of this is held under PII ?  It was Jeremy who manipulated the situation and planted the idea in the heads of the Police that Sheila was seriously mentally ill and was responsible for the murders. Any rational consideration of the state of Sheila's body ( see the thread on her innocence )  makes it highly unlikely that she could have been the killer besides other evidence relating to her experience of guns,
character etc. You really should not blacken the memory of someone who was brutally murdered. All this business about the devil too has been distorted and in part reflects comments made by June on finding Sheila in a field having sex with Colin Cafell when she had only recently had a termination consequent on his earlier philandering. The psychiatrist, Ferguson, made much of this and IMO behaved disgracefully and unprofessionally when he wrote an account for the media after the murders when the suicide theory was being put out. 
Title: Re: Questions for the Definately Guilty Posters
Post by: John on February 21, 2013, 10:46:46 PM
Andrea,I disagree with your assertion that Sheila would have commited suicide in London. Sheila appeared to be on a downward spiral and it is possible that talk of changes to her life,which she may have felt she had lost control over,may have just finally pushed her over the edge.She hated whf and was showing paranoia towards others,believing they were the devil etc.It is very possible Sheila suffered a breakdown whilst at whf.

I would be interested to know what evidence you have, Cheryl, to back up your theories. I know for a fact that Sheila had written an entirely normal and optimistic letter to a relative prior going down to WHF discussing arrangements for an outing with the twins and that this was backed up by a telephone conversation during the evening before the murders when she cheerfully confirmed arrangements for the following day. A police officer who interviewed the relative and took a copy of the letter from Sheila commented that it was clearly not written by someone who was ill and was surprised in view of the way the case at that point was being held to be suicide/murder.  Maybe all of this is held under PII ?  It was Jeremy who manipulated the situation and planted the idea in the heads of the Police that Sheila was seriously mentally ill and was responsible for the murders. Any rational consideration of the state of Sheila's body ( see the thread on her innocence )  makes it highly unlikely that she could have been the killer besides other evidence relating to her experience of guns,
character etc. You really should not blacken the memory of someone who was brutally murdered. All this business about the devil too has been distorted and in part reflects comments made by June on finding Sheila in a field having sex with Colin Cafell when she had only recently had a termination consequent on his earlier philandering. The psychiatrist, Ferguson, made much of this and IMO behaved disgracefully and unprofessionally when he wrote an account for the media after the murders when the suicide theory was being put out.

Once we start deviating into speculations Cheryl, I fear all reality will be lost in this case.  We can all speculate on what may have been but for the sake of clarity lets concentrate on what we know as being fact.

I believe we should leave the theorising and the fantasy speculations to the blue forum members who have made it their mission in life to invent them endlessly in the hope that maybe, just maybe, someone some day might take them seriously and let poor innocent Jeremy free from his self-imposed living hell.
Title: Re: Questions for the Definately Guilty Posters
Post by: John on February 21, 2013, 11:14:59 PM
Evidence of what exactly? I have referred to Sheilas doctors statement with regards to how ill she was.Also,Sheila was NOT optimistic on the phone on the eve of the tragedy.Pamela Boutflour made a statement to the opposite effect? How have I blackened Sheilas memory? I haven't incinuated that she carried out the murders,I just gave my opinion to Andrea that if Sheila felt suicidal,then she would have acted on it wherever.I have read your many posts of claiming to be in "the know" regarding the Bamber family,so I am very surprised that you insist there was no talk of fostering that week at whf,as somebody VERY close to the Bambers has since admitted that there,in fact,was!

Colin Caffell had custody of the twins and would have to have been involved in any such formal discussions.  That's not to say it wasn't mentioned in passing at some stage.

Colin was very clear in his interview after the trial that he and Sheila were on good terms at their parting when he dropped her and the boys off at the farm.  He did not discount the possibility that they may have got back together again had she not been brutally murdered by Jeremy.

Without checking previous posts I believe Pamela commented that Sheila was quite subdued on the telephone as if she was half asleep or in a trance.  Undoubtedly her medication was effective.  Not exactly the raving maniac and killing machine that some would have us believe.
Title: Re: Questions for the Definately Guilty Posters
Post by: John on February 21, 2013, 11:25:03 PM
John,was Andrea not speculating then,when she stated that Sheila would not have commited suicide at whf,but would have done so in London? I would say she was giving her opinion and I gave her mine.I beg your pardon,I had thought this was a debating forum,not a forum where members with an open mind are simply sneered at.I will cancel my membership and move on.Thanks for having me.

Debating is fine but we must all try and keep to the facts where possible.   8((()*/
Title: Re: Questions for the Definately Guilty Posters
Post by: Dillon on February 21, 2013, 11:53:46 PM
Evidence of what exactly? I have referred to Sheilas doctors statement with regards to how ill she was.Also,Sheila was NOT optimistic on the phone on the eve of the tragedy.Pamela Boutflour made a statement to the opposite effect? How have I blackened Sheilas memory? I haven't incinuated that she carried out the murders,I just gave my opinion to Andrea that if Sheila felt suicidal,then she would have acted on it wherever.I have read your many posts of claiming to be in "the know" regarding the Bamber family,so I am very surprised that you insist there was no talk of fostering that week at whf,as somebody VERY close to the Bambers has since admitted that there,in fact,was!

I expect that you won't read this as you are resigning. I think that you are muddled. This was NOT the phone conversation with Pam Boutflour who if I recall correctly, described her as being a bit quiet. Perhaps Sheila was tired; looking after 2 energetic twins must be hard work . The telephone conversation I mentioned was with someone else. I did imply that medical evidence about Sheila's condition should be treated with caution.  If you read my post you will find that I did not insist that there was no talk of fostering . I don't know either.
I don't think that I have ever claimed to be in " the know " ! Possibly I may have created the impression that I have had an interest in the case since the murders happened. I do know how much the family have suffered and how much they have been defamed often at a distance by people with a purely theoretical knowledge of the case . I think that anyone implying that Sheila was guilty is blackening her memory. If I misinterpreted your post in that respect, I apologise. I am totally convinced that Sheila did not commit these murders. Hence, I stick up for her and also the family. Because of the alleged telephone call Jeremy states that he received from Nevill that makes him guilty by default unless some other 3rd party was responsible and that possibility has been debated at length and seems unlikely. I only continue to post on this site to try and counter the fantasy, lies and defamation endlessly poured out on Tesko's forum. Finally, and you may find this surprising , I am not sure that I really want to see Jeremy rot in prison until he dies. If he was prepared to admit his guilt, apologised to those he has harmed and showed some remorse then maybe he could be considered for release under strict licence conditions at say the 30 year point which is not too far off.   
Title: Re: Questions for the Definately Guilty Posters
Post by: John on February 21, 2013, 11:54:58 PM
Have you seen this video Cheryl?

Three years after the divorce, there was even talk of reconciliation.  She was feeling better, her future looked brighter.  Colin Caffell speaking about Sheila and the boys, "...it was nice to be a family because we hadn't actually done it together...I think there was a lot of hope for eventually getting something together again."

http://www.itnsource.com/shotlist//ITN/1986/10/28/AS281086004/?s=jeremy+bamber&st=0&pn=1


Remember that this was filmed before he wrote the book. 
Title: Re: Questions for the Definately Guilty Posters
Post by: John on February 22, 2013, 12:11:55 AM
Evidence of what exactly? I have referred to Sheilas doctors statement with regards to how ill she was.Also,Sheila was NOT optimistic on the phone on the eve of the tragedy.Pamela Boutflour made a statement to the opposite effect? How have I blackened Sheilas memory? I haven't incinuated that she carried out the murders,I just gave my opinion to Andrea that if Sheila felt suicidal,then she would have acted on it wherever.I have read your many posts of claiming to be in "the know" regarding the Bamber family,so I am very surprised that you insist there was no talk of fostering that week at whf,as somebody VERY close to the Bambers has since admitted that there,in fact,was!

I expect that you won't read this as you are resigning. I think that you are muddled. This was NOT the phone conversation with Pam Boutflour who if I recall correctly, described her as being a bit quiet. Perhaps Sheila was tired; looking after 2 energetic twins must be hard work . The telephone conversation I mentioned was with someone else. I did imply that medical evidence about Sheila's condition should be treated with caution.  If you read my post you will find that I did not insist that there was no talk of fostering . I don't know either.
I don't think that I have ever claimed to be in " the know " ! Possibly I may have created the impression that I have had an interest in the case since the murders happened. I do know how much the family have suffered and how much they have been defamed often at a distance by people with a purely theoretical knowledge of the case . I think that anyone implying that Sheila was guilty is blackening her memory. If I misinterpreted your post in that respect, I apologise. I am totally convinced that Sheila did not commit these murders. Hence, I stick up for her and also the family. Because of the alleged telephone call Jeremy states that he received from Nevill that makes him guilty by default unless some other 3rd party was responsible and that possibility has been debated at length and seems unlikely. I only continue to post on this site to try and counter the fantasy, lies and defamation endlessly poured out on Tesko's forum. Finally, and you may find this surprising , I am not sure that I really want to see Jeremy rot in prison until he dies. If he was prepared to admit his guilt, apologised to those he has harmed and showed some remorse then maybe he could be considered for release under strict licence conditions at say the 30 year point which is not too far off.   


Fair points Dillon.  I agree with your last point totally in that Jeremy should be given a chance if he was prepared to admit to what he did and apologised to all concerned.  I fear his pride will not allow him to do so however as he has become accustomed to being the 'wronged party' and relishes the attention.

If he were to admit to being a murderer at this stage I fear
his supporters would evaporate like ali bongo in the night.  @)(++(*
Title: Re: Questions for the Definately Guilty Posters
Post by: Dillon on February 22, 2013, 12:13:37 AM
John,was Andrea not speculating then,when she stated that Sheila would not have commited suicide at whf,but would have done so in London? I would say she was giving her opinion and I gave her mine.I beg your pardon,I had thought this was a debating forum,not a forum where members with an open mind are simply sneered at.I will cancel my membership and move on.Thanks for having me.

Debating is fine but we must all try and keep to the facts where possible.   8((()*/
What did I state that wasn't factual? I referred to documentation and gave my opinion,just the same as everyone else. I agree that Colin would never in a million years have given up his children,but the Bambers disliked him and clearly had other ideas that included bringing Sheila and the boys down from London permanently. And I do not know why Colin stated in an interview that he may have got back with Sheila,as in his book he revealed that he had moved on and was happy in another relationship and Sheila knew this.He was so frustrated with her illness that on the night of the murders he told his girlfriend that he wished Sheila were dead.Plus they were divorced.Its all contained in his book if you haven't read it. Of course,none of this proves that she killed herself or anyone else for that matter,and I am not saying that she did. But like you say,we must keep to the facts where possible!

By the way,how do I delete my account? Thanks in advance.

Finally, Cheryl, and before you go I have read Colin's book and he has suffered greatly with the loss of the twins.  I have heard that he was a good dad and also that his father was devoted to the twins. However, there is another side to this . I knew long before all this happened that Colin was un faithful to Sheila whilst she was still in hospital having had the twins. Looking after even one baby let alone two on your own is very tough and maybe Sheila was not all that well organised. However, despite Colin's behaviour she was determined that her twins should continue to have a relationship with Colin and his father and that I have heard was one reason why she stayed in London.
Unsurprisingly, the Bambers, who were pretty straight farming folk probably did not like Colin very much. To them, he probably seemed a feckless, promiscuous hippy.  Equally, I doubt if he cared for their moral standards. Chalk and cheese . Good night.
Title: Re: Questions for the Definately Guilty Posters
Post by: jackiepreece on February 22, 2013, 12:39:50 AM
Shona has always stood firm that she believes a third party was involved and I don't think she has ever waivered on this opinion.

If in fact a third party was involved it leaves the door open to lots of other possibilities.

I have always believed if a hit man had been used for the murders JB would have made sure he had an alibi like staying at Julie's.

The third party scenario is both interesting and complicated and you would have to look at ALL parties that had a motive for the murders

Maybe if JB had gone straight to the farm that night he would have been another dead member of the Bamber family.
Title: Re: Questions for the Definately Guilty Posters
Post by: jackiepreece on February 22, 2013, 01:11:33 AM
If I was given proof that JB was responsible for the murders (not Mugfords statements as I don't believe her or the tampered silencer evidence or trial by media) I don't think JB should ever be released.

I still believe we will find out one day for definate who was behind the murders at WHF
Title: Re: Questions for the Definately Guilty Posters
Post by: Andrea on February 22, 2013, 01:16:00 AM
The phone call RULES OUT a third party.
Bambers alibi was the phonecall, and that his sister was a 'nutter who could go mad at anything'. He primed the police from the off.
Title: Re: Questions for the Definately Guilty Posters
Post by: John on February 22, 2013, 02:35:25 AM
The phone call RULES OUT a third party.
Bambers alibi was the phonecall, and that his sister was a 'nutter who could go mad at anything'. He primed the police from the off.

There could very well have been third party involvement but it had to be with Jeremy's knowledge.  Whichever way you look at it Jeremy was involved in the murders.

The person who carried out the murders knew how to get into and out of the farmhouse undetected.  Only one person still alive had that knowledge and that person is Jeremy Bamber.

By implicating Sheila in the murders by virtue of a fake telephone call Jeremy effectively implicated himself.

Third party involvement can also mean someone who has given the killer material assistance without actually being present on the morning of the murders.  Third party involvement could also be someone who knew in advance of the killers intentions and did nothing about it.
Title: Re: Questions for the Definately Guilty Posters
Post by: goatboy on February 22, 2013, 08:14:38 AM
At the time of the murders Colin actually had custody of the children. The possibility of the Bambers discussing putting them up for fostering makes no sense as it would not have been their place to do so. And as already stated the only witnesses to this alleged conversation are dead, and Bamber may have made this up to give Sheila a possible motive in having her children taken away.

The allegations of June catching Colin and Sheila "at it" are totally erroneous according to Colin in his book. They were sunbathing naked he says, and June came to find them as they were late returning to the house. Colin states that Sheila had only recently had a termination. I know very little about the subject but I would imagine for a woman who had only just had an invasive operation to remove a foetus from her w..b sex would be the last thing on her mind.

Jackie has a good point about the hitman-if Jeremy wasn't involved at all he would have made sure he had a cast iron alibi (staying at Julie's for example). So I think we can discount the lone hitman theory. The third party we can consider but this would mean with Jeremy's involvement.
Title: Re: Questions for the Definately Guilty Posters
Post by: Dillon on February 22, 2013, 08:16:55 AM
If I was given proof that JB was responsible for the murders (not Mugfords statements as I don't believe her or the tampered silencer evidence or trial by media) I don't think JB should ever be released.

I still believe we will find out one day for definate who was behind the murders at WHF

I can understand why some people have problems with the credibility of JM's evidence and I suspect that she may have been coached by EP . Some of the issues relating to the silencer reflect the poor standard of the investigation by EP . However, IMO none of this evidence materially alters Sheila being innocent and hence JB implicated . It is pure speculation but I have long wondered whether JB did all this on his own or whether a partner in crime assisted in various ways, maybe even to the point of being at WHF during the killings, for example doing things like restraining Sheila . Maybe this will all come out one day and I think BC may know far more then he admitted. Perhaps another area where EP's investigation slipped up. If they had followed fundamental good practice in preserving the crime scene I doubt if we would be having this debate . Also, Jackie I am impressed that you are being controlled and polite in your posting these days even if I disagree with your perspective. 
Title: Re: Questions for the Definately Guilty Posters
Post by: Dillon on February 22, 2013, 08:32:37 AM
At the time of the murders Colin actually had custody of the children. The possibility of the Bambers discussing putting them up for fostering makes no sense as it would not have been their place to do so. And as already stated the only witnesses to this alleged conversation are dead, and Bamber may have made this up to give Sheila a possible motive in having her children taken away.

The allegations of June catching Colin and Sheila "at it" are totally erroneous according to Colin in his book. They were sunbathing naked he says, and June came to find them as they were late returning to the house. Colin states that Sheila had only recently had a termination. I know very little about the subject but I would imagine for a woman who had only just had an invasive operation to remove a foetus from her w..b sex would be the last thing on her mind.

Jackie has a good point about the hitman-if Jeremy wasn't involved at all he would have made sure he had a cast iron alibi (staying at Julie's for example). So I think we can discount the lone hitman theory. The third party we can consider but this would mean with Jeremy's involvement.

June was a person with high moral standards and a staunch Christian so she would have been pretty shocked to find them sun bathing naked soon after Sheila had had a termination . Sheila had been pregnant by Colin, not some farm labourer . Maybe they were not actually having sex but I can understand June being extremely cross and upset. She may well have called Sheila the Devil's child in the heat of the moment; something that preyed on Sheila's mind and subsequently got picked up by the psychiatrist.
Title: Re: Questions for the Definately Guilty Posters
Post by: Angelo222 on February 22, 2013, 09:33:53 AM
At the time of the murders Colin actually had custody of the children. The possibility of the Bambers discussing putting them up for fostering makes no sense as it would not have been their place to do so. And as already stated the only witnesses to this alleged conversation are dead, and Bamber may have made this up to give Sheila a possible motive in having her children taken away.

The allegations of June catching Colin and Sheila "at it" are totally erroneous according to Colin in his book. They were sunbathing naked he says, and June came to find them as they were late returning to the house. Colin states that Sheila had only recently had a termination. I know very little about the subject but I would imagine for a woman who had only just had an invasive operation to remove a foetus from her w..b sex would be the last thing on her mind.

Jackie has a good point about the hitman-if Jeremy wasn't involved at all he would have made sure he had a cast iron alibi (staying at Julie's for example). So I think we can discount the lone hitman theory. The third party we can consider but this would mean with Jeremy's involvement.

Good point about the alibi guys.  I agree completely,  Jeremy would have made dam sure he was away too or at Julie's as you suggest if he had contracted someone to do his dirty work for him.  In all fairness there aren't many sane people who would do what Jeremy did which raises many questions about his mental health in 1985.
Title: Re: Questions for the Definately Guilty Posters
Post by: jackiepreece on February 22, 2013, 02:44:18 PM
A question for John, Dillon and Goatboy

If you were sitting on the jury for the WHF murders and you knew Julie Mugford had a deal to collect money for a story if Jeremy Bamber were found guilty would it have made a difference as to if you believed her testimony or not in view of her history of dishonesty and deception re the cheque fraud?

I do take the point that JB had a newspaper deal organised too but that would only been available to him if he had been found  not guilty by the jury appointed

Julie decided to make the deal with the NOW even though she had carried out the cheque fraud, caravan robbery and allegedly known her boyfriend had committed the murders

Jeremy's deal would have been all about allegedly being wrongly convicted etc

Julie's deal was made knowing she was involved in covering up a major murder enquiry


If details of the NOW deal had been available how could the jury possibly know Julie's motives for her evidence against Jeremy?
Title: Re: Questions for the Definately Guilty Posters
Post by: John on February 22, 2013, 03:17:23 PM
A question for John, Dillon and Goatboy

If you were sitting on the jury for the WHF murders and you knew Julie Mugford had a deal to collect money for a story if Jeremy Bamber were found guilty would it have made a difference as to if you believed her testimony or not in view of her history of dishonesty and deception re the cheque fraud?

I do take the point that JB had a newspaper deal organised too but that would only been available to him if he had been found  not guilty by the jury appointed

Julie decided to make the deal with the NOW even though she had carried out the cheque fraud, caravan robbery and allegedly known her boyfriend had committed the murders

Jeremy's deal would have been all about allegedly being wrongly convicted etc

Julie's deal was made knowing she was involved in covering up a major murder enquiry


If details of the NOW deal had been available how could the jury possibly know Julie's motives for her evidence against Jeremy?

The deal with the newspaper is something which we all have become used to with the News of the World, indeed it was expected not so many years ago.  The fact that Julie had a deal for I think it was £25,000 while Jeremy wanted a similar deal for £40,000 would not have surprised me in the least had I been on that jury.

The deal would have had no input to my decision Jack, I would have listened to the evidence and taken it from there.

I agree the cheque fraud was silly and fraudulent Jack but students do many things in their youthful madness and when egged on by others.  Do remember that Suzie was in on it with her.
Title: Re: Questions for the Definately Guilty Posters
Post by: Tim Invictus on February 22, 2013, 04:24:51 PM
If the jury had known Julie's solicitor had made 'the best deal possible' with the press on his client's behalf, I wouldn't have been surprised if Bamber had convinced another juror he wasn't a psychopathic killer and he would literally have gotten away with murder!

Julie didn't have any deal when she walked into the police station to finally clear her conscience though did she Jackie?

I am getting a little sick of the worst stalking internet reclusive troll I have ever experienced constantly attacking a woman who is a wife and mother and who has been a hard working teacher for almost 30 years! I think Julie has fully redeemed herself both in court and her exemplary career since those dark days with Bamber.

I would support Julie over a vicious benefit scrounger any day of the week! What use have you ever been to society Jackie?

Title: Re: Questions for the Definately Guilty Posters
Post by: jackiepreece on February 22, 2013, 05:11:00 PM
Tim what do you think of Mugfords chances of being a teacher in the uk would have been?

Zilch!!!

If JB is in fact guilty I should think those bodies of those children will haunt her forever???

Remember the photos of dear Julie comforting Julie when he was allegedly responsible 'arranging' the murder of two babies
Remember the timing when she was dumped and wasn't going to be lady of the manor at WHF ??

You adore Julie all you like she was bad news and if its true and she knew about the murders 30 years does not change her behaviour

Keep up your personal insults you just show yourself up AGAIN !!!

Just like all the nasty comments you make about me and black people on you tube

Remember Sarah jakes downloaded the lot

I will continue debating the case thank you
Title: Re: Questions for the Definately Guilty Posters
Post by: Tim Invictus on February 22, 2013, 05:44:46 PM
You should have stuck to debating the case from day one Jackie but instead you stalked anyone and everyone who disagreed with you or dared to call Bamber what he is .... a vicious killer! Even Bamber has binned you because he was so disgusted with your stalking! Oh the irony!

John, Andy, Shona and many others have all had their private life's trawled by you and even children weren't out of bounds! You never bothered me for an instant but you did upset some good people and I will always treat you with the contempt you deserve!

Everyone knows you would still be posting all your bile if you could get away with it. Or are you saying you have realised that stalking people is illegal and cowardly and decided to amend your appalling behaviour?

Title: Re: Questions for the Definately Guilty Posters
Post by: Angelo222 on February 22, 2013, 06:12:00 PM
Jackie is a reformed character these days Tim.  She assures us she has put all that nonsense behind her for good.  She even apologised for some of it a bit back which took a bit of guts and a little bit of humble pie.  8@??)( 
Title: Re: Questions for the Definately Guilty Posters
Post by: goatboy on February 22, 2013, 07:59:31 PM
A question for John, Dillon and Goatboy

If you were sitting on the jury for the WHF murders and you knew Julie Mugford had a deal to collect money for a story if Jeremy Bamber were found guilty would it have made a difference as to if you believed her testimony or not in view of her history of dishonesty and deception re the cheque fraud?

I do take the point that JB had a newspaper deal organised too but that would only been available to him if he had been found  not guilty by the jury appointed

Julie decided to make the deal with the NOW even though she had carried out the cheque fraud, caravan robbery and allegedly known her boyfriend had committed the murders

Jeremy's deal would have been all about allegedly being wrongly convicted etc

Julie's deal was made knowing she was involved in covering up a major murder enquiry


If details of the NOW deal had been available how could the jury possibly know Julie's motives for her evidence against Jeremy?

I agree you probably have to question Julie's motives for testifying in court. Personally I think the police told her in no uncertain terms they would look to arrest her to unless she told what she knew. Self preservation was her motive. Whether or not she went along with it and wanted to be the lady of the manor I don't know, I couldn't rule it out. She could have been a Lady Macbeth figure encouraging Jeremy in his mad plans. Perhaps this is true, but if Jeremy were to admit her involvement he would then have to admit his. I certainly don't think she testified and perjured herself in a high profile murder case because she was a woman scorned. That is ridiculous.

If I was a juror I think the pivotal moment for me would have been when Jeremy, accused of lying, said "that is what you have to establish". Not the words of an innocent man. An innocent man would have been furious at such an accusation. And nothing the Bamber supporters can say can alter that.
Title: Re: Questions for the Definately Guilty Posters
Post by: John on February 22, 2013, 11:08:06 PM
My view is that Julie was between a rock and a hard place.  She was in love with Jeremy without a doubt but he didn't feel the same way about her.  I sometimes wonder if all  the talk about wanting to get engaged only to have June put her foot down and disallow it was all made up by Jeremy just to get out of a binding relationship.

When Julie realised that Jeremy could very well be implicated in the murders she just didn't know what to do for the best and that is when she started to confide in her college friends. Once the police got wind of it all there was no going back.  I have no doubt whatsoever that the police put considerable pressure on her to cough up the goods on Jeremy.  I also know that Julie found this very difficult to do since she still loved him.

In the end it was him or her and she chose to do the right thing and give him up.  She said in an interview after the trial that she felt sorry for him and I am quite sure she does and possibly still to this day.
Title: Re: Questions for the Definately Guilty Posters
Post by: Tim Invictus on February 22, 2013, 11:21:39 PM
Jackie is a reformed character these days Tim.  She assures us she has put all that nonsense behind her for good.  She even apologised for some of it a bit back which took a bit of guts and a little bit of humble pie.  8@??)(

Oh I didn't know that David .... I have had every aspect of my private and business life that Jackie could find out thoroughly stalked and no one has told me that Jackie is a 'reformed character'!

If you want to address this with me too Jackie with a view to burying the hatchet then I am quite willing to listen? Your choice.