Lol, they were not invited to the 'bezzy friends meeting' last week either...Oh but at least it is ok because they are ..not guilty of anything.
Not guilty but suspected?
When the Portugese authorities archived their investigation they said the McCanns lost the chance to prove their innocence when their friends refused to return to PdL for a reconstruction.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/LEGAL_SUMMARY.htmSo, the PJ had suspicions about the parents but no evidence was found to prove their guilt or anyone else's guilt so the process was archived.
The reconstruction may have allowed the McCanns to prove to the PJ that they were innocent, but it didn't happen because their friends refused to take part. The McCanns agreed to take part but seemed happy to accept the refusal by their friends. So, no proof that they were guilty and no proof that they were innocent as far as the PJ were concerned.
I have seen no statement from the PJ as to the remit of their reopened enquiry. I have seen no statement from them saying whether their review found anything to change the status of the McCanns as it stood when the case was archived.
Operation Grange, according to DCI Redwood in 2013 was not regarding the McCanns as suspects or persons of interest. Is that still the case? We don't know as I can't find any later statement on the matter from OG.
Crimewatch could have tested the windows of opportunity between checks but only showed the people who went into the apartment, thereby leaving approximately 30 minutes between Matthew Oldfield's check and Kate McCann's at 10pm. This, along with the elimination (probable, not certain) of Tannerman allowed them to promote Smithman as the perpetrator. He didn't have 30 minutes though.
Jane Tanner and Russell O'Brien passed the apartment during that 30 minutes. Unless a watching abductor/burglar knew they were partners they wouldn't have known that Jane was going to stay in her apartment; she didn't during her previous check, she came back out and returned to the Tapas Bar. It was Russell O'Brien who came out of the apartment instead this time between 9.50-9.55pm. We can assume that Jane passed between 9.45-9.50pm - ish then.
Matthew Oldfield and Russell O'Brien left the Tapas at 9.30pm and Matthew checked his child, then went to see Russell, then went round and checked G5A so he probably returned to the Tapas at 9.35-9-40pm. This leaves the windows of opportunity to be between 9.35pm and 9.45pm (ten minutes) or 9.50pm and 10,00pm (ten minutes).
If it was between 9,50pm and 10pm he still had to get to the place where the Smiths are supposed to have seen him at 10pm. Would a watching intruder risk making his move after MO's return to the Tapas? RO'B could have emerged from his apartment at any moment.
The group's statements leave very little time for an abductor to do anything unless they had knowledge of the apartment and knew which child they wanted and where she was sleeping. There would have been little time to sedate her and the twins also.
If the children weren't sedated an abductor was risking Madeleine waking up when he picked her up and all the children waking if he raised the shutters and opened the window. Also unsedated twins should have woken up when the bedroom was being searched around them or when they were moved out of the apartment I would have thought.
Raising the shutters and opening the window was a high risk thing to do also given the amount of to-ing and fro-ing. Matthew Oldfield did a listening check at the McCann's window at 9pm, so anyone raising the shutters from inside could have found themselves face to face with him or another checker. Had they raised them from the outside they could have been confronted by three screaming children.
If the intruder entered with a key, why open the shutters/window (high risk of waking children, being seen by someone listening at window or passing)
Ditto if intruder used the patio door. If a burglary, why not just run if a child woke up? If the burglar panicked and killed the child why take her with him and then walk the streets with her?
Most of the above questions arise because of the tight timeline. Was the frequency of the checks exaggerated? If so, why would the group do that? To save themselves from accusations of neglect? If they stuck to their timeline because they were afraid of being accused of neglect did that hamper the investigation? If it did should we assume that protecting themselves from accusations of neglect was more important than catching the abductor and finding a missing child?
All of the above timings are from the statements in the PJ files. The conclusions arising are all my opinion only.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/TRANSLATIONS.htm