Can a link to a video containing questionable content be considered defamatory?
This question has been raised by several members on another thread so I'm giving everyone the perfect opportunity to debate it.
The video concerned is the Correio da Manhã TV production entitled 'Gonçalo Amaral - O Enigma'. This recent production complete with English subtitles purports to look back at the Madeleine McCann mystery and the original investigation headed by Coordinator Gonçalo Amaral.
My own view is that it does not. Merely linking to material such as a banned book or a questionable video is not the same as publishing it.
Please note that this thread is not concerned with the specific content of the video but the claim that merely linking to it constitutes a defamation. I have attached a copy of The Defamation (Operators of Websites) Regulations 2013.
Please discuss.
I suspect that posting or linking to false information but claiming it is true would be defamatory.
That isn't what has happened here. We have two instances of videos with dubious content I can think of, both of them criticised here extensively.
If discussion were to be suppressed, it would merely mean the videos would continue to be widely available, but without challenge or analysis.
The document you have attached seems to indicate that the correct procedure for anyone aggrieved by such videos is to send a complaint to the host, typically YouTube. If YouTube supported the complaint, it would take the video down, and links to it would then fail.
On a purely personal basis, I prefer to be aware of the information that is circulating in the media. If we did not have links to these two videos, I would be reliant on descriptions by others. I prefer to be able to make my own judgement.
Admin has added a very clear note in the Enigma OP that linking does not mean or imply forum endorsement.
I think there is a good balance with adequate safety regulation already in place. But I reserve the right to change my position if someone comes up with a clear-cut improvement.