Too many assumptions and presumptions there. My answers in green.
Surely we didn't need DCI Redwood to spell it out in words of one syllable to the GBP that although they believe Madeleine was removed from 5a by a stranger, they had no way of knowing what had happened to her after that. Hence his comment that she could be alive or sadly dead. That's just common sense.
IIRC his later comments re whether Madeleine may not have been alive when she was taken from 5a were directly related to the appeal for any parents whose children had been assaulted in their beds to come forward, and not to assume that even if they had reported those assaults to the GNR - that SY would necessarily know about them.
IMO all those families will have been closely interviewed and IMO it may well be that because of what emerged during them (to which we are not privy) -about the intruder's MO during those attacks (for instance if he put his hand over their mouths) that death could have been the result.
I believe it is an accepted fact that the behaviour of serial offenders does escalate - therefore the ages and what happened in previous attacks is not a reason to eliminate this person.
I'm sure you will agree Mercury that even if he is not the perpetrator in the McCann case - he needs to be caught.
The reason for my last para - is because it seems to me that anything (even a slip of the tongue) which suggests Madeleine died in 5A is leapt upon by sceptics who think/hope this line of enquiry can only result in the arrest of the parents. That is mega wishful thinking IMO.
It seems crystal clear to me that if Madeleine died in 5a then SY definitely do not believe it was at the hands of her parents. They have never uttered a single word to suggest that it was - in fact they have done the complete opposite and ruled them out of the enquiry.
I'm not a conspiracy theorist - so I do not believe that SY are conducting an undercover operation to lull the McCanns into a false sense of security and at some stage are going to pounce on them. Not a chance IMO.