Cadaver dogs are unreliable - Eugene Zapata

[Wonderfulspam]

Hideho for a start.  The cherry picking, innuendo promoting liar of all time.

A hand full of ground up 100 year old bones.  I wonder whose funeral urn they came from, if they are indeed what he says they are.  No provenance supplied.

And No, Jersey isn't part of The UK.

How has Hideo altered this video IYO?

All she has done is hosted the clip from a series previously shown on ITV.

What IYO did Eddie locate if it wasn't human remains?

Sea Bass bones?

[barrier]

Probably contamination as in the Shannon Matthews case:

The properties the dogs searched contained a high level of second hand furniture bought from dwellings where someone had died.  This resulted in numerous indications that required further investigation to confirm whether they were connected to the investigation, or to previous owners of the furniture.

Page 25:

http://library.college.police.uk/docs/npia/Operation-Paris.pdf

How many persons died in 5a prior to the McCann arrival? given its a holiday let the chances are remote in the extreme imo,second hand furniture? in a holiday let? really.

[Holly Goodhead]

How many persons died in 5a prior to the McCann arrival? given its a holiday let the chances are remote in the extreme imo,second hand furniture? in a holiday let? really.

A set of grandparents resided in 5A permanently at one time.

I've no idea of the apartment's history along with the contents, do you?

And I've no idea how any odour transfers to inanimate objects and continues lingering even when the inanimate object is transferred elsewhere as above in the Shannon Matthews case.

[Wonderfulspam]

Maybe Kate's trousers were from a second hand shop & pig had died in the hire car.

[Eleanor]

How has Hideo altered this video IYO?

All she has done is hosted the clip from a series previously shown on ITV.

What IYO did Eddie locate if it wasn't human remains?

Sea Bass bones?

You tell me.

[Eleanor]

A set of grandparents resided in 5A permanently at one time.

I've no idea of the apartment's history along with the contents, do you?

And I've no idea how any odour transfers to inanimate objects and continues lingering even when the inanimate object is transferred elsewhere as above in the Shannon Matthews case.

If Eddie can smell human remains of 100 years old, imagine what he could do with yesterday's Urn.

[Holly Goodhead]

Maybe Kate's trousers were from a second hand shop & pig had died in the hire car.

Did the dog alert on Kate's trousers?  Kate was spending a lot of time in the PDL church where no doubt funerals were taking place. The hire car no doubt carried hundreds of drivers/passengers unless it was new to the fleet? 

If the Shannon Matthews case is anything to go by the odour is highly transferrable. 

[Holly Goodhead]

If Eddie can smell human remains of 100 years old, imagine what he could do with yesterday's Urn.

Quite.  In the Shannon Matthews case did the deceased actually die in contact with the furniture or does the scent somehow linger on inanimate objects? 

[Wonderfulspam]

Did the dog alert on Kate's trousers?  Kate was spending a lot of time in the PDL church where no doubt funerals were taking place. The hire car no doubt carried hundreds of drivers/passengers unless it was new to the fleet? 

If the Shannon Matthews case is anything to go by the odour is highly transferrable.

That's a new one.

Most corpses are already in a wooden box before they enter a church, as far as I'm aware.
Maybe the church at PDL was an exception, where bodies are placed upon the pews in some bizzare Portuguese ritual.

[Holly Goodhead]

That's a new one.

Most corpses are already in a wooden box before they enter a church, as far as I'm aware.
Maybe the church at PDL was an exception, where bodies are placed upon the pews in some bizzare Portuguese ritual.

KM is Catholic.  I thought they had some touchy-feely sort of send off?

A lot of the furniture in the Shannon Matthews case was contaminated. So it isn't just a case of the dog alerting to odour in the atmosphere its clearly transferrable from one location to another via inanimate objects.  Is secondary contamination possible? 

[Eleanor]

Quite.  In the Shannon Matthews case did the deceased actually die in contact with the furniture or does the scent somehow linger on inanimate objects?

I wish I knew.  But according to Martin Grime the death scent lingers any old where for God knows how long.

[misty]

That's a new one.

Most corpses are already in a wooden box before they enter a church, as far as I'm aware.
Maybe the church at PDL was an exception, where bodies are placed upon the pews in some bizzare Portuguese ritual.

http://www.talkdeath.com/cemetery-overcrowding-leading-europe-recycle-burial-plots/

Makes you wonder where the removed remains were placed during the grave recycling process....no opportunity for scent transference into that little church beside the cemetery?

[Wonderfulspam]

It's a wonder Eddie didn't skip 5a all together & go running straight for the church.

[misty]

If Eddie can smell human remains of 100 years old, imagine what he could do with yesterday's Urn.

In the Jersey video the ancient bone fragments Eddie detected were exposed in an open jar. IMO it would have added to his credibility if the jar had been buried in the sand with a permeable lid and he'd located it.

[Holly Goodhead]

It's a wonder Eddie didn't skip 5a all together & go running straight for the church.

Maybe he would have done without his 'handler'.