Cadaver dogs are unreliable - Eugene Zapata

[Robittybob1]

It was Eddie.  Of that there is no doubt.

I said "If the report does not name the dog ..."  No where in the report does it say "Eddie".  If Davel quotes the reort he shouldn't add in other bits of information.  I'm not saying "Mr Grime's dog" isn't Eddie.

ive never said i dont believe the papers

Well remind us what do you say?

[Eleanor]

I am beginning to get a bit cross now.  So please don't drive me too far.  Either of you.

[Vertigo Swirl]

Cross contamination? if the fragment had been handled previously and by how many hands?

LOL. 

[Mr Gray]

I said "If the report does not name the dog ..."  No where in the report does it say "Eddie".  If Davel quotes the reort he shouldn't add in other bits of information.  I'm not saying "Mr Grime's dog" isn't Eddie.
Well remind us what do you say?

eddie was in jersey with Grime...its widely reported...and it seems you agree

[Mr Gray]

I am beginning to get a bit cross now.  So please don't drive me too far.  Either of you.

again eleanor....Ive simply made posts and provide links to support them. its again Rob who wants to pick at every post I make...plesae point any post of mine  thats unnacceptable

[Robittybob1]

eddie alerts to bone.....to the smell of bone.....im making nothing up

Who said it smells like bone?  "Who" is a person not Eddie, so name that person.  So far it is only you saying that.

[Mr Gray]

Who said it smells like bone?  "Who" is a person not Eddie, so name that person.  So far it is only you saying that.

have you heard the expression...walks like a duck....im being  a little light hearted

[Robittybob1]

eddie was in jersey with Grime...its widely reported...and it seems you agree

That maybe so but it isn't in the Operation Rectangle report.

[Mr Gray]

That maybe so but it isn't in the Operation Rectangle report.

its in the report you gave  alink to from the sunday times ...

The cadaver dog that alerts to human remains, the same dog that nearly did for Kate and Gerry McCann after it alerted at the boot of their car


I dont know why you are arguing over the point

[Robittybob1]

its in the report you gave  alink to from the sunday times ...

The cadaver dog that alerts to human remains, the same dog that nearly did for Kate and Gerry McCann after it alerted at the boot of their car


I dont know why you are arguing over the point

Is that bolded bit from the Sunday Times?

[Mr Gray]

Is that bolded bit from the Sunday Times?

yes...

[Eleanor]

again eleanor....Ive simply made posts and provide links to support them. its again Rob who wants to pick at every post I make...plesae point any post of mine  thats unnacceptable

You think I don't know that. I am not completely stupid.

But I don't want to sanction Rob anymore than I do you.

[Mr Gray]

You think I don't know that. I am not completely stupid.

But I don't want to sanction Rob anymore than I do you.

sanction for what ....im simply answerring the accusations against me by a moderator

[Robittybob1]

sanction for what ....im simply answerring the accusations against me by a moderator

I said the report does not name Eddie - That is true.
I asked who said "Eddie smelt bone"?  - You never answered.

[Mr Gray]

I said the report does not name Eddie - That is true.
I asked who said "Eddie smelt bone"?  - You never answered.

The bdo report does not name eddie....I never claimed it did...i copy and pasted a part so my post is accurate


I  then went on the refer to the dog in question as eddie...because as most of us know...it was eddie

the smelling bone is  a bit of humor based on the "if it walks like a duck" saying....I did answer and explained it.

I dont think there is anymore to say