Is this new suspect revelation just too convenient given the 12th anniversary?

[jassi]

The argument been used by (many / some) sceptics is that child sex abuse victims would be better off dead, which really is a vile argument when you think about it.

Is it really? Who are you to decide  for the world in general that something is vile?

[Lace]

Is it really? Who are you to decide  for the world in general that something is vile?

If Madeleine was being held captive by a paedophile gang and Madeleine was YOUR child,  would you rather she died or be rescued?

[jassi]

If Madeleine was being held captive by a paedophile gang and Madeleine was YOUR child,  would you rather she died or be rescued?

Hypothetical situation. How would you KNOW she was in the hands of paedophiles ?

[Vertigo Swirl]

Is it really? Who are you to decide  for the world in general that something is vile?

Yes it really is vile to believe that victims of child sex abuse are better off dead, unless you can argue successfully why it is not? 

[Vertigo Swirl]

Hypothetical situation. How would you KNOW she was in the hands of paedophiles ?

As it’s a hypothetical question how you came to know is irrelevant.  Can you answer thr question? 

[jassi]

As it’s a hypothetical question how you came to know is irrelevant.  Can you answer thr question?

No. Why should I ?

[Vertigo Swirl]

No. Why should I ?

LOL, of course you can’t.  I thought as much.  For the record, if I thought my child had been abducted by a paedophile I’d prefer she came home alive rather than in a body bag, mad though that may seem to you.

[Mr Gray]

Is it really? Who are you to decide  for the world in general that something is vile?

After 12 years of moral judgement of the mccanns

[jassi]

LOL, of course you can’t.  I thought as much.  For the record, if I thought my child had been abducted by a paedophile I’d prefer she came home alive rather than in a body bag, mad though that may seem to you.

That's fine. I've not said you are mad, but I do object to your moralistic assumption that anyone who does agree with you must be bad.

[The General]

After 12 years of moral judgement of the mccanns

Yeh, come on now guys, let it drop, it's been 12 years FFS.

[Vertigo Swirl]

That's fine. I've not said you are mad, but I do object to your moralistic assumption that anyone who does agree with you must be bad.

What sort of a parent would prefer their child dead at the hands of a paedo than returned alive?  A good parent?

[jassi]

What sort of a parent would prefer their child dead at the hands of a paedo than returned alive?  A good parent?

Play your moralising game with someone else, I'm not interested.

[Vertigo Swirl]

Play your moralising game with someone else, I'm not interested.

Haha, you know I’m right you just can’t bring yourself to admit it.  Fair enough.

[The General]

Haha, you know I’m right you just can’t bring yourself to admit it.  Fair enough.

Someone wrong on the internet again? RESULT!

[Vertigo Swirl]

Someone wrong on the internet again? RESULT!

Yep, think I’ll go celebrate by putting the laundry away and putting on a new load of washing.  I know how to live me.