Can we judge a person's character by their stance on the case?

[G-Unit]

An interesting suggestion;

snip/
I think on this forum the overriding criterion in deciding whether one is open to learning, nice and wise is whether or not they believe Madeleine was abducted.
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=10927.msg550009#msg550009

Is that a sensible suggestion or is it as ridiculous as I think it is?

[barrier]

I'm with Pedro Do Carmo,he says in relation to whether Madeleine was abducted,"we don't know and have to be prepared to deal with different scenarios".Does that leave me open to learning with out a defined set of idea's?

[Robittybob1]

An interesting suggestion;

snip/
I think on this forum the overriding criterion in deciding whether one is open to learning, nice and wise is whether or not they believe Madeleine was abducted.
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=10927.msg550009#msg550009

Is that a sensible suggestion or is it as ridiculous as I think it is?

I think the really wise person will be the one who can explain the presence of cadaver odour in the apartment, explain how Madeleine left by the front door yet that door was found closed, and then explain how the tracker dogs tracked her to the car park opposite the secondary reception, then to explain how she gets abducted from there. 

[barrier]

I think the really wise person will be the one who can explain the presence of cadaver odour in the apartment, explain how Madeleine left by the front door yet that door was found closed, and then explain how the tracker dogs tracked her to the car park opposite the secondary reception, then to explain how she gets abducted from there.

Don't wise men keep their counsel.

[Mr Gray]

I think the really wise person will be the one who can explain the presence of cadaver odour in the apartment, explain how Madeleine left by the front door yet that door was found closed, and then explain how the tracker dogs tracked her to the car park opposite the secondary reception, then to explain how she gets abducted from there.

What cadaver odour... None has been confirmed.. Therefore not a very wise post

[jassi]

I think the really wise person will be the one who can explain the presence of cadaver odour in the apartment, explain how Madeleine left by the front door yet that door was found closed, and then explain how the tracker dogs tracked her to the car park opposite the secondary reception, then to explain how she gets abducted from there.

Blimey, no wonder OG haven't come up with the answer

[barrier]

Not another dog thread ye gods! (apologies to erngath)

[Robittybob1]

Don't wise men keep their counsel.

I thought that was ratepayers ....

But you are right.  wise men keep their counsel .... I wonder what that means?

Looking up Google that seems to come from a book on Freemasonry. Written in 1795  ....
"Freemason's Magazine, Or General and Complete Library, Volume 4" says:
"None but fools babble ; wise men keep their counsel. This is surely verified in the present times; and I am certain, if the world had been acquainted with the ...."

[G-Unit]

I think suggesting that all those who believe Madeleine was abducted are open to learning, wise and nice is not supported by the evidence.

In my experience some of those who believe in the abduction are completely closed to learning anything which casts doubt on that belief. They are often unwise enough to lash out with nasty attacks on others, too, which results in them being sanctioned IMO.

[Mr Gray]

Don't wise men keep their counsel.

Depends on the circumstances.. There is always a time to keep quiet and sometimes a time to speak

[Mr Gray]

I think suggesting that all those who believe Madeleine was anducted are open to learnung, wise and nice is not supported by the evidence.

In my experience sone of those who believe in the abduction are completely closed to learning anything which casts doubt on that belief. They are often unwise enough to lash out with nasty attacks on others, too, which results in them being sanctioned imo.

Of course I think you are totally wrong... Ive carefully considered all the evidence and reached my conclusions. I'd be happy to change if any new evidence comes along. As for lashing out...I don't lash out but refuse to be bullied and tend to speak my mind... Admirable qualities IMO.
I'm

My opinion is sceptics have misunderstood the evidence... That's my genuine opinion but I'm not sure I'm allowed to express it.. But you are allowed to voice yours

[Eleanor]

I think suggesting that all those who believe Madeleine was anducted are open to learnung, wise and nice is not supported by the evidence.

In my experience sone of those who believe in the abduction are completely closed to learning anything which casts doubt on that belief. They are often unwise enough to lash out with nasty attacks on others, too, which results in them being sanctioned imo.

This is a very narrow minded and biased comment.  As far as I can see, no one is very much worse than anyone else, regardless of what they believe.

And Supporters certainly don't have the franchise on lashing out with nasty attacks.

But what most Supporters do have is Hope.

[Eleanor]

Don't wise men keep their counsel.

This is a Discussion Forum.

[Mr Gray]

I think suggesting that all those who believe Madeleine was anducted are open to learnung, wise and nice is not supported by the evidence.

In my experience sone of those who believe in the abduction are completely closed to learning anything which casts doubt on that belief. They are often unwise enough to lash out with nasty attacks on others, too, which results in them being sanctioned imo.

You critise posters for being sanction but this is a post that really deserves sanction imo
It's all about opinion

[jassi]

Fortunately this forum is fairly liberal and allows a wide range of views and opinions