How Did JB Commit The Killings

[Vertigo Swirl]

I've no idea.  I only know broken pieces were found on the floor.

(As an aside I was looking to add something to a thread you started 'How Sheila.....' which seems to have disappeared?)

Nowt to do with me guv.

[barrier]

How does a piece of wood shearing off from the rifle butt point to JB and rule out SC?

How does it rule JB out?

[Nicholas]

Was it a concrete, rigid lampshade?

 

[Nicholas]

I've no idea.  I only know broken pieces were found on the floor.

(As an aside I was looking to add something to a thread you started 'How Sheila.....' which seems to have disappeared?)

Do they sell concrete lampshades in B&Q ?

[ISpyWithMyEye]

Even a rudimentary staging of the shooting would prove conclusive, if the sequence could be determined.

How?

They couldn’t conclude who the perpetrator was...

[ISpyWithMyEye]

Even a rudimentary staging of the shooting would prove conclusive, if the sequence could be determined.

They already know who/where everyone was shot

Forensics proved that, as did where their bodies were

The only thing they can’t prove in a reconstruction is who shot them all

Which is why a reconstruction of Sheila supposedly being the shooter and beating Nevill to a pulp would prove conclusive who didn’t do it...

[ISpyWithMyEye]

This never gets old, always watch it when I need a good  ...  https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yUueF_u7kYM

I like the way he pops up out of nowhere mid film, poring through a catalogue of scenarios made up by JB’s team, and saying in his high pitched voice while nodding his head emphatically   “This man could not have done it”

Year later he was dragged off to jail himself for impersonating a lawyer 🤥

[ISpyWithMyEye]

Holly doesn’t appear interested in facts

She probably misses them if she has multiple user accounts to run

And that’s without her jogging 

[ISpyWithMyEye]

Holly and likeminded supporters believe that the mess in the kitchen was created by the police on entry to the house.  How much confidence can there be therefore that easily moveable items like cartridge casings were left in exactly the same place as they fell (and that’s before we even consider the yappy dog that was loose in the house before the police entered).

Fabulous point!

You come out with some brilliant questions, VS!

Is that why Holly doesn’t respond?

[ISpyWithMyEye]

I think it more likely that NB stumbled into kitchen furniture.

In terms of the casings you're right research shows up to 25% deviation.

Would that have been after he was smashed so hard on his head that his brain was exposed?

[ISpyWithMyEye]

We're being led to believe Sheila was capable of this? edit that, some want to believe it was Sheila who was capable of this.

Yes, let’s see a reconstruction of Sheila beating Nevill to a pulp in the kitchen

Quietly pressing the phone down without a whisper, as she casually held the 4ft rifle in one hand while standing next to Nevill — and he put his arms up and allowed her to match him back upstairs to shoot him....

[ISpyWithMyEye]

How does a piece of wood shearing off from the rifle butt point to JB and rule out SC?

Strength

The power to smash the rifle so violently against a skull that the hard solid wood snaps and flies across the room

[ISpyWithMyEye]

That's true...

Gosh, I read a reporter saying how much he’d aged and looked years older (he’s what, about 60?) and had jowls, white hair etc, but he has aged incredibly! And he doesn’t get the sun!

[ISpyWithMyEye]

But you're making an assumption as to how the piece broke off and how the perp held the rifle thought to be the blunt instrument used to inflict NB's non-gsw's.

The butt might have collided with the lampshade with both breaking in the process. 

Afaik the shard piece wasn't forensically examined?

Oh, Holly....c’mon...

Wood is harder than glass 

[ISpyWithMyEye]

I said:

The butt might have collided with the lampshade with both breaking in the process.

Can you see how it can be ruled out?

So if you dropped a wine glass on a wooden coffee table which one would would smash and fly off?