New German suspect in Madeleine McCann mystery disappearance.

[Eleanor]

Is it worth pointing out that this an looks nothing like Martin Smith’s identification?
 

Blonde
30 but may look as young as 25
Six feet.


— Regarding the description of the individual who carried the child he states that: he was Caucasian, around 175 to 180m in height. He appeared to be about 35/40 years old. He had an average build, a bit on the thin side. His hair was short, in a basic male cut, brown in colour.

So if it isn’t the Smith’s sighting then we have two individuals carrying a little girl similar to Madeleine in pyjamas with bare feet around PDL on the same night....and figure in Tannerman, who doesn’t match the latest description either, and that makes three.

What a farce.

So you don't want this to be true anymore than I do.  But for entirely different reasons.  This could be really funny.  If only it were funny.

[Billy Whizz Fan Club]

And a bit shorter...and younger....and blonder....if the German is guilty.

If the German is involved and if the Smith’s saw a man carrying MM it does not follow that the Smith’s saw the German.

[Eleanor]

This:

So Doctors have unfriendly relationships with paedophiles?

[Brietta]

Is it worth pointing out that this an looks nothing like Martin Smith’s identification?
 

Blonde
30 but may look as young as 25
Six feet.


— Regarding the description of the individual who carried the child he states that: he was Caucasian, around 175 to 180m in height. He appeared to be about 35/40 years old. He had an average build, a bit on the thin side. His hair was short, in a basic male cut, brown in colour.

So if it isn’t the Smith’s sighting then we have two individuals carrying a little girl similar to Madeleine in pyjamas with bare feet around PDL on the same night....and figure in Tannerman, who doesn’t match the latest description either, and that makes three.

What a farce.

What makes you think this person has anything at all to do with the so called Smithman?

[Billy Whizz Fan Club]

So you don't want this to be true anymore than I do.  But for entirely different reasons.  This could be really funny.  If only it were funny.

You’re deliberately muddying the waters. The suggestion I offered as a plausible scenario, IMO, was:

Dog alerts correct - MM died in 5A

Person unknown seen by Smith family carrying (dead) MM to ANOTHER person with a vehicle who conceals body.

[Eleanor]

And a bit shorter...and younger....and blonder....if the German is guilty.

You are absolutely right, Faith.  It probably wasn't that German.  I mean, do come on.

[faithlilly]

So you don't want this to be true anymore than I do.  But for entirely different reasons.  This could be really funny.  If only it were funny.

What you and I want is a mute point now...what isn’t is that we now have a German, a Tannerman and a Smithman all running around PDL with a child that looks like Madeleine...it could be the start of a joke if it was the least bit funny.

TBH I now want the police to charge this individual and bring him to trial.

[Robittybob1]

What you and I want is a mute point now...what isn’t is that we now have a German, a Tannerman and a Smithman all running around PDL with a child that looks like Madeleine...it could be the start of a joke if it was the least bit funny.

TBH I now want the police to charge this individual and bring him to trial.

They will need more evidence first.

[faithlilly]

What makes you think this person has anything at all to do with the so called Smithman?

Because if he isn’t we have three individuals roaming around PDL with a girl that looks like Madeleine. Surely even you see the ridiculousness of that scenario ?

[Billy Whizz Fan Club]

What you and I want is a mute point now...what isn’t is that we now have a German, a Tannerman and a Smithman all running around PDL with a child that looks like Madeleine...it could be the start of a joke if it was the least bit funny.

TBH I now want the police to charge this individual and bring him to trial.

Tannerman has been accounted for according to Op Grange.

[Billy Whizz Fan Club]

No you haven’t drawn any conclusions.  You’ve hinted at stuff and talked alot about the McCanns friendship with Clement Freud.  What conclusions do you draw from this and the latest news?

I don’t draw any conclusions from either. I’m open minded to various possibilities. I personally do find the dog alerts and the Smith sighting compelling. IMO MM died in 5A and the Smith family witnessed someone carrying her away from the apartment. This evidence alone does not allow us to make a definitive conclusion.

With regards to the German was it the car or camper van whose registration details were changed the day after MMs disappearance?

[faithlilly]

Tannerman has been accounted for according to Op Grange.

He was still walking around with a child, who Tanner claimed, wore pyjamas similar to Madeleine and with bare feet. And then we have Martin Smith describing a similar child and now the German suspect.

Further there is the coincidence of the dogs only alerting in the McCann’s apartment and no other...if it does go to court it’ll be interesting to see how the prosecution explain that one away.

[faithlilly]

I don’t draw any conclusions from either. I’m open minded to various possibilities. I personally do find the dog alerts and the Smith sighting compelling. IMO MM died in 5A and the Smith family witnessed someone carrying her away from the apartment. This evidence alone does not allow us to make a definitive conclusion.

With regards to the German was it the car or camper van whose registration details were changed the day after MMs disappearance?

If the alerts are correct then Madeleine had to have been dead in the apartment for upwards of 90 minutes. How then could it have been the German ?

[Eleanor]

You’re deliberately muddying the waters. The suggestion I offered as a plausible scenario, IMO, was:

Dog alerts correct - MM died in 5A

Person unknown seen by Smith family carrying (dead) MM to ANOTHER person with a vehicle who conceals body.

Actually, I was talking to Faith.  We are old hands at this.  And it was a joke anyway.  Faith would have known this.

Not that you should not be allowed to intervene  if you so choose.

[Brietta]

What you and I want is a mute point now...what isn’t is that we now have a German, a Tannerman and a Smithman all running around PDL with a child that looks like Madeleine...it could be the start of a joke if it was the least bit funny.

TBH I now want the police to charge this individual and bring him to trial.

I think you are being deliberately obtuse ... you are so much more intelligent than that.