New German suspect in Madeleine McCann mystery disappearance.

[Billy Whizz Fan Club]

Ive tried on many occasions to show why the evidence points to abduction...no one will try to debate...so lets try you..

What are the odds the mccanns are involved

Odds are not evidence....  Where's the evidence that she was abducted?.... Smithman would be a good starting point - though sadly not for CM who ignored the sighting for weeks, imo.

[Vertigo Swirl]

OK but some others are getting it.

What is it you think they afe getting?  What exactly is this dilemma facing those who think Madeleine was abducted?

[Mr Gray]

Nothing!! But if you follow the story the Germans were reportedly saying they had sent two letters and that they had "proof" that Madeleine was dead. SY said they recieved no such thing.... so it can hardly be claimed that between them they've nailed "the real culprit", imo.

cite for proof maddie was dead...could you try and stick to the facts

[Mr Gray]

Odds are not evidence....  Where's the evidence that she was abducted?.... Smithman would be a good starting point - though sadly not for CM who ignored the sighting for weeks, imo.

its obvious im wasting my time with some one who doesnt understand evidence. there is no proof maddie is alive but the odds of her being alive are remote,,,,thats evidence

[Robittybob1]

as rob is accusing me of being in a dillemma ..I dont need an IMO...he does. His post is total nonsense

Where is your IMO after "His post is total nonsense"?   

What is it you think they afe getting?  What exactly is this dilemma facing those who think Madeleine was abducted?

No, I think the dilemma is in those who felt she wasn't abducted. 

[Billy Whizz Fan Club]

cite for proof maddie was dead...could you try and stick to the facts

I said "reportedly" claimed they had proof she was dead... I'm sure you read the media reports (there's numerous to choose from) such as:

"PROSECUTORS in Germany have written to Kate and Gerry McCann to tell them Madeleine is dead.

They have “concrete evidence” suspect Christian B killed her but cannot yet reveal details."

[Mr Gray]

Where is your IMO after "His post is total nonsense"?   
No, I think the dilemma is in those who felt she wasn't abducted.

Your post is nonsense because you claim to KNOW how I feel...you THINK im in  a dilemma....im not...so your post is nonsense..

[Mr Gray]

I said "reportedly" claimed they had proof she was dead... I'm sure you read the media reports (there's numerous to choose from) such as:

"PROSECUTORS in Germany have written to Kate and Gerry McCann to tell them Madeleine is dead.

They have “concrete evidence” suspect Christian B killed her but cannot yet reveal details."

Evidence is not proof........im sick of pointing that out to posters

[Anthro]

Potentially, it could be significant if the various sightings of Madeleine could be correlated with Brückner’s known movements.

[Billy Whizz Fan Club]

its obvious im wasting my time with some one who doesnt understand evidence. there is no proof maddie is alive but the odds of her being alive are remote,,,,thats evidence

It's highly unlikely that she is alive - but "rare stranger abduction" (Clarence Mitchell, LSE event, January 2008) is not the most likely scenario if you're just going on "odds".

I'll ask again - what evidence do you have that she was abducted?

[Brietta]

I’m guessing quite a few people on here are hoping he’s released.  I wonder how long before we know?

It is interesting that the 'Crimewatch' style programme broadcast in Germany featuring Madeleine was responsible for a viewer passing on information which brought Brueckner to the attention of the police.

So it looks to me that someone he knew had a valid reason for thinking he might be involved and did the right thing by getting him checked out,

[Mr Gray]

It's highly unlikely that she is alive - but "rare stranger abduction" (Clarence Mitchell, LSE event, January 2008) is not the most likely scenario if you're just going on "odds".

I'll ask again - what evidence do you have that she was abducted?

what are the odds the parents were involved...based on the EVIDENCE

[Robittybob1]

Your post is none=sense because you claim to KNOW how I feel...you THINK im in  adilemma....im not...so your post is nonsense..

I have not mentioned you in my posts till now.  What I said before does not apply to you.  You are not in a dilemma, you seem to be suffering from something else.

[Billy Whizz Fan Club]

Evidence is not proof........im sick of pointing that out to posters

"concrete evidence" would suggest they believe they have "proof" (as in beyond reasonable doubt)... but you do raise an important distinction. Good point, well made, my friend.

[barrier]

It is interesting that the 'Crimewatch' style programme broadcast in Germany featuring Madeleine was responsible for a viewer passing on information which brought Brueckner to the attention of the police.

So it looks to me that someone he knew had a valid reason for thinking he might be involved and did the right thing by getting him checked out,

When was this,the 2013 one was shown in Belgium and Germany,certainly took their time to try and get him,still no charges though,won't be long.