New German suspect in Madeleine McCann mystery disappearance.

[Eleanor]

You need to learn to let it go.

Tell that to Amaral.  He needs that advice more than I do.

[G-Unit]

The SC judged that amarals right to free speech outweighed the mccanns right to reputation..an opinion that is imo out of step with the ECHR legiislation that they claimed they abided by.

The SC judges examined the evidence provided by the claimant's lawyers and decided it didn't prove their case. Different evidence might have done so, but the judges could only judge what was offered.

[Eleanor]

The SC judged that amarals right to free speech outweighed the mccanns right to reputation..an opinion that is imo out of step with the ECHR legiislation that they claimed they abided by.

Thank You. 

Amaral is becoming an even bigger embarrassment to Portugal.

[Gertrude]

You seem to simply want to discredit the german police when in fact it seems CB wasnt properly investigated by the PJ. they called at his house once...he was out and amaral cant say if it was further followed up.

it seems the PJ dont want to released dna to the Germans...it seems the PJ according to the Germans arent cooperating because they still think the parents did it.
IMO CB is quite possibly guilty but the ineptitude of the PJ in the first investigation may allow a guilty man to go free.

I don't need to discredit them. They made a huge blunder in 2013. They have now had 7 years with which to gather evidence and they clearly haven't managed. They have not got very far and that's a fact as they are still at a very early stage.

And you say 'it seems' PJ are refusing to hand over DNA....isn't that just media spin? I thought we weren't supposed to trust that.

[Mr Gray]

The SC judges examined the evidence provided by the claimant's lawyers and decided it didn't prove their case. Different evidence might have done so, but the judges could only judge what was offered.

If you read the SC judgement it's totally Re freedom of speech versus right to reputation... Allied with the presumption of innocence. What evidence could the mccanns produce to support their right to reputation..

[Mr Gray]

I don't need to discredit them. They made a huge blunder in 2013. They have now had 7 years with which to gather evidence and they clearly haven't managed. They have not got very far and that's a fact as they are still at a very early stage.

And you say 'it seems' PJ are refusing to hand over DNA....isn't that just media spin? I thought we weren't supposed to trust that.

You say a huge blunder... How many huge blunders have the PJ made...Is their case.  Why wasn't CB looked closely at in 2007...even amaral says he's the perfect suspect.  It may well be  the Germans have actually solved the case

Why did it take the Germans to solve the rape case that CB was involved in...what were the PJ doing about it

[kizzy]

You say a huge blunder... How many huge blunders have the PJ made...Is their case.  Why wasn't CB looked closely at in 2007...even amaral says he's the perfect suspect.  It may well be  the Germans have actually solved the case

Why did it take the Germans to solve the rape case that CB was involved in...what were the PJ doing about it

That what he said so why keep twisting it to suit YOUR agenda D



'PERFECT SUSPECT'
Amaral has made numerous appearances on television since the emergence of Christian B as a suspect in the McCann case.

He has repeated his well-known criticism of the Brit youngster’s parents and their “Tapas Seven” holiday pals.

Amaral accused them of abandoning their children to eat out at night and lying to Portuguese police, and said Madeleine had been crying the night before she vanished on May 3, 2007.

He also branded Christian B a “scapegoat”, describing the 43-year-old as an “almost perfect suspect”.

Amaral first claimed last April that a German paedophile who was in prison would be accused over Madeleine’s disappearance.

He’s an almost perfect suspect. All that’s missing for him to become the perfect suspect is for him to be dead.”

[Mr Gray]

That what he said so why keep twisting it to suit YOUR agenda D



'PERFECT SUSPECT'
Amaral has made numerous appearances on television since the emergence of Christian B as a suspect in the McCann case.

He has repeated his well-known criticism of the Brit youngster’s parents and their “Tapas Seven” holiday pals.

Amaral accused them of abandoning their children to eat out at night and lying to Portuguese police, and said Madeleine had been crying the night before she vanished on May 3, 2007.

He also branded Christian B a “scapegoat”, describing the 43-year-old as an “almost perfect suspect”.

Amaral first claimed last April that a German paedophile who was in prison would be accused over Madeleine’s disappearance.

He’s an almost perfect suspect. All that’s missing for him to become the perfect suspect is for him to be dead.”

again...what do you think amaral means...he means he ticks all the boxes...hes the perfect supect.

It seems amaral is just spewing more baloney...where is the evidence and what is the motive for the germans to make CB  a scapegoat..you cant answer because there isnt any.

the germans seem better at solving portuguese cases than the portuguese....CB was found guilty of  arape in portugal...what were the PJ doing about it

[Gertrude]

You say a huge blunder... How many huge blunders have the PJ made...Is their case.  Why wasn't CB looked closely at in 2007...even amaral says he's the perfect suspect.  It may well be  the Germans have actually solved the case

Why did it take the Germans to solve the rape case that CB was involved in...what were the PJ doing about it

Why did the Germans solve the rape case? Surely you know, 2 associates of Bruckner stole a video of the rape in 2017, till then, many details of the rape were unknown because the victim couldn't see what was going on, so that conviction was the result largely of some luck with the video coming to light. Bruckner was named in 2013 to the Germans again by chance, so not sure why people want to believe they must have some compelling evidence they are holding back.
 You seem to want to want to discredit the PJ above all else, I never mentioned the rape but you brought it up. Both the German police force and Scotland yard haven't got any further with Bruckner than the PJ did in the McCann case and they had less time to look into him. 4 months vs. 7 years.

[Mr Gray]

Why did the Germans solve the rape case? Surely you know, 2 associates of Bruckner stole a video of the rape in 2017, till then, many details of the rape were unknown because the victim couldn't see what was going on, so that conviction was the result largely of some luck with the video coming to light. Bruckner was named in 2013 to the Germans again by chance, so not sure why people want to believe they must have some compelling evidence they are holding back.
 You seem to want to want to discredit the PJ above all else, I never mentioned the rape but you brought it up. Both the German police force and Scotland yard haven't got any further with Bruckner than the PJ did in the McCann case and they had less time to look into him. 4 months vs. 7 years.

Why wasnt CB prosecuted in portugal for the rape. There is another portuguese rape he is suspected of but the portuguese didnt keep the dna evidence. There is  a third violent rape in portugal where the convicted man was given  a suspended  sentence...what a disgrace.

There doesnt even seem to have been an  interview with CB in 2007 ...even though amaral describes him as  a perfect suspect...why was the case closed when all avenues had not been explored

[Anthro]

Why wasnt CB prosecuted in portugal for the rape. There is another portuguese rape he is suspected of but the portuguese didnt keep the dna evidence. There is  a third violent rape in portugal where the convicted man was given  a suspended  sentence...what a disgrace.

There doesnt even seem to have been an  interview with CB in 2007 ...even though amaral describes him as  a perfect suspect...why was the case closed when all avenues had not been explored

The PJ knocked on his door after Madeleine disappeared but he was not there. No follow-up. Negligent police force it seems.

[jassi]

The PJ knocked on his door after Madeleine disappeared but he was not there. No follow-up. Negligent police force it seems.

I thought he was living in a van at the time

[Vertigo Swirl]

I thought he was living in a van at the time

Oh that’s alright then.  How were the poor PJ supposed to know that?

[kizzy]

again...what do you think amaral means...he means he ticks all the boxes...hes the perfect supect.

It seems amaral is just spewing more baloney...where is the evidence and what is the motive for the germans to make CB  a scapegoat..you cant answer because there isnt any.

the germans seem better at solving portuguese cases than the portuguese....CB was found guilty of  arape in portugal...what were the PJ doing about it

Your spewing a lot of IYO nothing else D

[Brietta]

I thought he was living in a van at the time

The one Amaral was flashing photographs of by any chance ?