Is there more circumstantial evidence against the mccanns than there is CB

[Eleanor]

Has he not already served time for that, as it was found several years ago ?

Please may I have a Cite for that?

[jassi]

Please may I have a Cite for that?

As I posed it as a question, rather than as a fact, it doesn't need a cite from me

[G-Unit]

Has he not already served time for that, as it was found several years ago ?

Possibly;

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-8654423/Madeleine-McCann-prime-suspect-secret-stash-391-child-porn-photos-68-videos.html

[jassi]

Possibly;

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-8654423/Madeleine-McCann-prime-suspect-secret-stash-391-child-porn-photos-68-videos.html

Thank you, that's more or less what I remember.

From that article - "Police said the videos had been downloaded from the internet and stored on the camera’s memory card."

So not all his own work.

[Eleanor]

"Possibly" isn't good enough.

He seems to have served a sentence only for Abusing a Child and not for possessing Pornography.

[jassi]

"Possibly" isn't good enough.

He seems to have served a sentence only for Abusing a Child and not for possessing Pornography.

Clutching at straws. It's quite clear that the memory sticks and cards were raised during the trial as a major part of the evidence -
"The camera and its contents became the main evidence against Brueckner, 42, during two trials in which he was accused of sexually abusing the girl and possessing child pornography. "

[Mr Gray]

Clutching at straws. It's quite clear that the memory sticks and cards were raised during the trial as a major part of the evidence -
"The camera and its contents became the main evidence against Brueckner, 42, during two trials in which he was accused of sexually abusing the girl and possessing child pornography. "

You seem to be confusing two different incidents...there is one involving a camera and another re the buried memory sticks

[Eleanor]

Clutching at straws. It's quite clear that the memory sticks and cards were raised during the trial as a major part of the evidence -
"The camera and its contents became the main evidence against Brueckner, 42, during two trials in which he was accused of sexually abusing the girl and possessing child pornography. "

So you think he should go free?

[jassi]

So you think he should go free?

He should be punished for whatever he is found guilty of - but not twice for offences already dealt with.

[Eleanor]

He should be punished for whatever he is found guilty of - but not twice for offences already dealt with.

As far as I can see it was just images of the child he was convicted of abusing.

[Mr Gray]

He should be punished for whatever he is found guilty of - but not twice for offences already dealt with.

Isn't it strange that sceptics who had no problem with the PJ beating a confession out of Cipriano are now so concerned with justice

[jassi]

As far as I can see it was just images of the child he was convicted of abusing.

That's because that's what you want to see.
My opinion is that the child abuse and the porno pictures were all part of the same  charges.
Not that it matters, for having been part of the evidence at that trial, they cannot be used again  in a different trial.

[Eleanor]

That's because that's what you want to see.
My opinion is that the child abuse and the porno pictures were all part of the same  charges.
Not that it matters, for having been part of the evidence at that trial, they cannot be used again  in a different trial.

I think you could be wrong about this.

[Eleanor]

Isn't it strange that sceptics who had no problem with the PJ beating a confession out of Cipriano are now so concerned with justice

It would be hilarious.  If it was funny.

[Mr Gray]

That's because that's what you want to see.
My opinion is that the child abuse and the porno pictures were all part of the same  charges.
Not that it matters, for having been part of the evidence at that trial, they cannot be used again  in a different trial.

The memory cards founf under his dead dog haven't been used as part of any trial.