@Davel
“To this end, 117 participants were asked to write down one true and one fabricated statement about a recent negative event that happened in their lives. All statements were analysed using 11 criteria derived from SCAN. Results indicated that SCAN was not able to correctly classify true and fabricated statements. Lacking empirical support, the application of SCAN in its current form should be discouraged.”
The tests are flawed. They asked people to fabricate a story. The fabricated stories never happened so the fabricator didn’t experience the events. They were not recalling them but instead making them up. That is called fiction. The brain knows the story is fiction and it has no effect on the language used, there is no consequence to the speaker. There is a difference between a person pretending they murdered someone and person who actually murdered someone. The murderer’s brain knows it has committed the murder and has stored inside it all the exact details and emotions which went with it.
Your logic appears to be if you can find SA that was incorrect, that means all of SA is incorrect. That is like saying if one doctor makes an incorrect diagnosis then all the other doctors cannot make a correct diagnosis or if one police officer, judge etc… makes one incorrect conclusion then they all should be dismissed as obviously that would mean they are all the same. It doesn’t work like that.
In life to fully understand something complex takes time. How can someone make a judgement about something complex by internet searching a few pages? If someone says they studied something for a reasonable period of time but found it to be flawed, then supplied all the reasons why it is flawed from their own personal experience I can understand that. When someone does a few internet searches and says that they now all the answers I don’t believe them. Knowledge comes from study, and the more study the more knowledge and experience can be gained.
What you are saying is that people like Jack Schafer -
https://www.psychologytoday.com/gb/experts/jack-schafer-phdMark McClish -
https://www.statementanalysis.com/bio/to name a couple. Who are well respected in law enforcement, have got it all wrong. And you have drawn your conclusions from a couple of searches on Google. They have decades of experience with proven results from working in the field.
Adrian.