THE ALIBI.

[faithlilly]

Really? That she already knew that Jodi was dead, that she also asked if he were under arrest. Perhaps you are correct, perhaps Luke had told her earlier in the evening that he found Jodi, after dying from a breathing attack? Or had one whilst he was with her, and he panicked - is this why the alibi was born?

Unless we know the exact flow of that conversation we can’t possibly know when Corrine found out Jodi was dead. Do we have a transcript?

[mrswah]

I genuinely cannot believe, the stuff I read that comes out of this poster. They make it sound like, children that kill other children and others is a rare occurrence. There are many in the UK alone, over the years, that have not only killed, but showed very little to no emotion in doing so. There was one in Scotland only just a few years ago, with the brutal rape and murder of a minor from a 15yo heavy cannabis abuser. Hundred's more examples in the UK, and thousands of them in the US.

Do you actually do any research before you type?

I would think it's a rare occurrence that they go home and tell their mothers what they've done. That is what I was referring to, not whether or not children kill! You did not read my post properly.

Yes , I do my research. Do you?

[rulesapply]

I would think it's a rare occurrence that they go home and tell their mothers what they've done. That is what I was referring to, not whether or not children kill! You did not read my post properly.

Yes , I do my research. Do you?

But who else was going to help him? Who else could LM have expected to help him?

[mrswah]

But who else was going to help him? Who else could LM have expected to help him?

I don't think I'd be expecting any help from my family if I murdered someone!

[rulesapply]

I don't think I'd be expecting any help from my family if I murdered someone!

But if he had no option but to ask for help, who could that be? Where would he go?

[rulesapply]

I don't think I'd be expecting any help from my family if I murdered someone!

I believe he would go to his family. Where else?

[rulesapply]

Unless we know the exact flow of that conversation we can’t possibly know when Corrine found out Jodi was dead. Do we have a transcript?

So, who do you think stumbled upon poor Jodi's body and mutilated her post mortem?

[faithlilly]

So, who do you think stumbled upon poor Jodi's body and mutilated her post mortem?

I’m not with you. We are talking about how and when Corrine found out about Jodi’s murder.

[rulesapply]

Unless we know the exact flow of that conversation we can’t possibly know when Corrine found out Jodi was dead. Do we have a transcript?

Did Corinne initially know Jodi had been murdered on the night of the 30th? Genuine question because I don't know 

[rulesapply]

I’m not with you. We are talking about how and when Corrine found out about Jodi’s murder.

Corinne can't have been told Jodi had been murdered at that point in time because the police wouldn't have had the post mortem results. They obviously had strong reasons for thinking she had been murdered but did Corinne ask if her son had been arrested? Do you know?

[rulesapply]

So if he has no loyalty to his mother and brother why not clarify that his brother was not at home on the evening of the 30th? He could lout all this appeal, review etc nonsense to bed by simply speaking up. Isn’t that what anyone with any morals would do rather than taking the chance that a child killer may be freed?

Maybe Luke and Corinne didn't have any loyalty for Shane.

[rulesapply]

If he got changed between 18.30-19.20 why was he not wearing the fabled parka jacket but the bomber jacket he admitted wearing when seen by those witnesses earlier?

Changed after 18.30? Where did you get that from?

[rulesapply]

Changed after 18.30? Where did you get that from?

Do you think Luke had need to get changed at all? I have no idea what you believe, (well, a bit) but I have always believed that it's really straight forward.  One boy, two coats. With help.

[rulesapply]

You really don't have much idea of what was going on in 2003 do you? There's a very good reason AO's statement disappeared but you'll never work it out.

We now know AO spoke directly to the High Court at the time of LM's trial. It is comedy gold for those who think  comedy mixes well in chat with a murdered child and it is as simple as that. It's for all to see and all to decide what is in good taste and who is not.

[faithlilly]

Changed after 18.30? Where did you get that from?

It’s Mr Apples theory I believe.