Anectdotal witness evidence

[Icanhandlethetruth]

As regards the alert in a neighbours house..
If the handler was taken to ten empty houses and given no information.... And an alert was only made in the house where a child disappeared from

That would be significant

Isn't that just about what happened in Luz?

[Mr Gray]

Isn't that just about what happened in Luz?

Absolutely  not.. Read it again

What you show  is you don't read and understand carefully

[Icanhandlethetruth]

Absolutely  not.. Read it again

Lets see:
If the handler was taken to ten empty houses and given no information.... And an alert was only made in the house where a child disappeared from


ten empty houses:  5 empty apartments and two villas,
Given no information: was he informed which apartments he was in?
And an alert was only made in the house where a child disappeared from: Check

[Mr Gray]

Lets see:
If the handler was taken to ten empty houses and given no information.... And an alert was only made in the house where a child disappeared from


ten empty houses:  5 empty apartments and two villas,
Given no information: was he informed which apartments he was in?
And an alert was only made in the house where a child disappeared from: Check

Are you suggesting Grime did not know 5a, was the crime scene

[Icanhandlethetruth]

Are you suggesting Grime did not know 5a, was the crime scene

Has it ever been reported that he did. If it has please provide a cite. Otherwise its just pure conjecture.
Read what you posted again, its virtually a mirror of what happened in Luz.

If the handler was taken to ten empty houses and given no information.... And an alert was only made in the house where a child disappeared from

[Mr Gray]

Has it ever been reported that he did. If it has please provide a cite. Otherwise its just pure conjecture.
Read what you posted again, its virtually a mirror of what happened in Luz.

If the handler was taken to ten empty houses and given no information.... And an alert was only made in the house where a child disappeared from

What a silly post.. I made a statement which I stand by. 
If Grime did not know 5a was the crime scene then the alerts are highly significant and point to the McCanns guilt.
The question is the surely everyone knew which apt Maddie was abducted from.

[Icanhandlethetruth]

What a silly post.. I made a statement which I stand by. 
If Grime did not know 5a was the crime scene then the alerts are highly significant and point to the McCanns guilt.
The question is the surely everyone knew which apt Maddie was abducted from.

Why do you default to the position that Grime knew which apartment was which, where is any evidence that he was told before hand? He has expressed that he wasn't told which car was which so why would it be different for the apartments. Just let this sink in. You posted

If the handler was taken to ten empty houses and given no information.... And an alert was only made in the house where a child disappeared from

That would be significant

And you stand by this statement.

[Mr Gray]

Why do you default to the position that Grime knew which apartment was which, where is any evidence that he was told before hand? He has expressed that he wasn't told which car was which so why would it be different for the apartments. Just let this sink in. You posted

If the handler was taken to ten empty houses and given no information.... And an alert was only made in the house where a child disappeared from

That would be significant

And you stand by this statement.

Of course I stand by it.  Every statement I make is, reasoned.
It's a very good and important point

[Icanhandlethetruth]

Of course I stand by it.  Every statement I make is, reasoned.
It's a very good and important point

So where is the difference between your statement and the searches in Luz?

[G-Unit]

What a silly post.. I made a statement which I stand by. 
If Grime did not know 5a was the crime scene then the alerts are highly significant and point to the McCanns guilt.
The question is the surely everyone knew which apt Maddie was abducted from.

You appear to think that the dogs alerted to 5A only because Grime knew the McCanns stayed there. That's quite an accusation based on no evidence.

[Mr Gray]

So where is the difference between your statement and the searches in Luz?

I've explained... And you have, answered.

[Mr Gray]

You appear to think that the dogs alerted to 5A only because Grime knew the McCanns stayed there. That's quite an accusation based on no evidence.

I don't really care, what you think.. It's, of no importance.  I've explained a, scientific method that would give the, alerts, massive scientific credibility

[Icanhandlethetruth]

I've explained... And you have, answered.

So the difference is although you have no evidence to support it, you believe Grime was told before hand who had occupied the apartments.
He wasn't told who the cars belonged to ,but to you, they must have told him the which apartments were which.
Can you confirm it is only your opinion that Grime was told which apartment was which rather than a fact you can prove?

[Mr Gray]

So the difference is although you have no evidence to support it, you believe Grime was told before hand who had occupied the apartments.
He wasn't told who the cars belonged to ,but to you, they must have told him the which apartments were which.
Can you confirm it is only your opinion that Grime was told which apartment was which rather than a fact you can prove?

I can't really bother to reply to such a silly post.  On such an important point we need to deal in facts not speculation

Let me make it really simple for you.. If it was a blind search then the alerrs are highly significant... Strange no ones mentioned it was if that was, the case

[Mr Gray]

So the difference is although you have no evidence to support it, you believe Grime was told before hand who had occupied the apartments.
He wasn't told who the cars belonged to ,but to you, they must have told him the which apartments were which.
Can you confirm it is only your opinion that Grime was told which apartment was which rather than a fact you can prove?

My belief that grime knew the, apt was the crime scene is based on evidence.. It's my opinion.. It's of no importance. The important point is did he know