Perceptions of Madeleine's Abduction

[jassi]

I don't think it can be stated as a fact.
More like an unsubstantiated claim as no one else appears to have seen this person.

[Vertigo Swirl]

If Tanner got it wrong and he was travelling in the opposite direction, then it would make perfect  sense.

Perhaps this what Grange thought, but didn't wish to openly challenge Tanner, so chose to dismiss her sighting instead.

This is what I think happened.  Great minds think alike, eh Jassi? 

[Eleanor]

I don't think it can be stated as a fact.
More like an unsubstantiated claim as no one else appears to have seen this person.

Amaral believed her when he was trying to stitch up Robert Murat.

[barrier]

I don't think it can be stated as a fact.
More like an unsubstantiated claim as no one else appears to have seen this person.

No one saw CB out side 5a making a 30 minute phone call either.

[barrier]

If Tanner got it wrong and he was travelling in the opposite direction, then it would make perfect  sense.

Perhaps this what Grange thought, but didn't wish to openly challenge Tanner, so chose to dismiss her sighting instead.

Who ever it was and Redwood made no mention of names, he was almost certainly not the abductor, hence the time frame moved on to Smithman, he's the key and always as been imo.

[G-Unit]

If Tanner got it wrong and he was travelling in the opposite direction, then it would make perfect  sense.

Perhaps this what Grange thought, but didn't wish to openly challenge Tanner, so chose to dismiss her sighting instead.

It was said after the Crimewatch programme that Exton questioned JT's sighting in his report. No doubt OG read that report and perhaps they agreed with Exton's findings. They clearly preferred to concentrate on the Smith sighting rather than the Tanner one. Suddenly things changed and the McCann's were no longer in charge of the narrative.

[G-Unit]

Amaral believed her when he was trying to stitch up Robert Murat.

The PJ noticed Murat because of a British journalist, didn't they? They then had to investigate him, it had nothing to do with JT, unless she did identify him off the record. She, her husband and Fiona testified that he (and his mother) lied about his whereabouts that night too. It makes you wonder if some people were trying to stitch him up.

[jassi]

Amaral believed her when he was trying to stitch up Robert Murat.

I think we all know that Amaral got  certain things wrong.

[jassi]

The PJ noticed Murat because of a British journalist, didn't they? They then had to investigate him, it had nothing to do with JT, unless she did identify him off the record. She, her husband and Fiona testified that he (and his mother) lied about his whereabouts that night too. It makes you wonder if some people were trying to stitch him up.

Trying to throw investigators off the scent rather than a stitch-up.  IMO

[Vertigo Swirl]

The PJ noticed Murat because of a British journalist, didn't they? They then had to investigate him, it had nothing to do with JT, unless she did identify him off the record. She, her husband and Fiona testified that he (and his mother) lied about his whereabouts that night too. It makes you wonder if some people were trying to stitch him up.

Oooh, a conspiracy!  Do exapnd….

[Vertigo Swirl]

Trying to throw investigators off the scent rather than a stitch-up.  IMO

Ah right, so the Tapas group conspired to throw investigators off the scent that the McCanns dunnit,  by fingering Murat *checks calendar to see if it’s suddenly flipped back in time fifteen years*

[barrier]

Ah right, so the Tapas group conspired to throw investigators off the scent that the McCanns dunnit,  by fingering Murat *checks calendar to see if it’s suddenly flipped back in time fifteen years*

Well its where it all starts, the BKA weren't asking for witness's to the phone call of CB's alleged phone nor his vehicles just to pass time .

[G-Unit]

Oooh, a conspiracy!  Do exapnd….

What makes you think it was a conspiracy? That's about as likely as employees of the Ocean Club conspiring to hide where the Totman's apartment really was imo, by falsifying their records.

[Eleanor]

It was said after the Crimewatch programme that Exton questioned JT's sighting in his report. No doubt OG read that report and perhaps they agreed with Exton's findings. They clearly preferred to concentrate on the Smith sighting rather than the Tanner one. Suddenly things changed and the McCann's were no longer in charge of the narrative.

Tanner Man was Smith Man a bit later on.  In my opinion.

[Eleanor]

The PJ noticed Murat because of a British journalist, didn't they? They then had to investigate him, it had nothing to do with JT, unless she did identify him off the record. She, her husband and Fiona testified that he (and his mother) lied about his whereabouts that night too. It makes you wonder if some people were trying to stitch him up.

This is total rubbish and doesn't make sense.  In My Opinion.