The Evidence Madeleine Was Taken In A Criminal Act By A Stranger.

[Vertigo Swirl]

Its what happens when they have no answer, but feel compelled to post anyway.

The evidence has been repeated a thousand times, but is always rejected, scoffed at and denied by “your” side of the argument.  Fortunately “our” side of the argument includes those who are actually investigating a child abduction, the grown ups, and so I don’t feel I need to justify my opinion yet again to a troll who is only here on a wind up.

[barrier]

This Forum.  Whether you like it or not.

Nope you abuse your position, you have no idea that some suffer inadequacies.

[John]

But what about the open window, John? I'm sorry but there was absolutely no way Madeleine could have opened the window & shutters herself.

The window that only had Kate McCann's fingerprints on?

There is no third-party evidence the window was ever opened by a stranger or even open before 10pm.

It also wasn't seen to be open when Matt Oldfield did his alleged bedroom walkby to listen in on the three children.

[John]

McCann supporters are often keen to tell us that the three expert investigative forces believe Madeleine was taken in a criminal act by a stranger. That, in essence, the police have evidence which proves it completely impossible that the McCanns could be in any way involved in Madeleine's disappearance.

So, I'd like to hear from members...

What possible evidence could there be that Madeleine was taken in a criminal act by a stranger?

I'll start...

1) The McCanns claim Madeleine was abducted.


Members are invited to add to this list.

To answer the opening post, IMO the evidence is severely lacking and tissue thin at best.

Even Tannerman has been ruled out according to the police so as it stands there isn't a single sighting of a child being carried that night except for the Smith family which has still never been explained.

No wonder the case attracts so much interest nearly 16 years on.

[John]

That reminds me.

The Possible Evidence Madeleine Was Taken In A Criminal Act By A Stranger.

1) The McCanns claim that Madeleine was abducted.

2)The allegedly open window, that had Kate's prints on it.

Definitely neither of them.

[John]

Who stages an abduction by opening a window and leaving their finger prints on it?

It didn't necessarily have to be staged. Maybe she forgot she open it.

[John]

Do you believe that the police always tell the truth to the public?

I can assure you they don't 

[John]

The evidence has been repeated a thousand times, but is always rejected, scoffed at and denied by “your” side of the argument.  Fortunately “our” side of the argument includes those who are actually investigating a child abduction, the grown ups, and so I don’t feel I need to justify my opinion yet again to a troll who is only here on a wind up.

The problem is that there is no longer any evidence in the public domain that Madeleine was abducted by a stranger. No confirmed sightings of the child, no sign of a break-in, nothing disturbed in the apartment, no ransom note etc etc

[Vertigo Swirl]

The problem is that there is no longer any evidence in the public domain that Madeleine was abducted by a stranger. No confirmed sightings of the child, no sign of a break-in, nothing disturbed in the apartment, no ransom note etc etc

What do you mean by “no longer any evidence of abduction?”

[Brietta]

It didn't necessarily have to be staged. Maybe she forgot she open it.

Maybe the blow she received from the shutters when she stuck her head out of the window knocked it completely from her mind.  Although I tend to think she would have noticed.

[Brietta]

I can assure you they don't 

Some police officers are rapists.

Some police officers are murderers.

As far as the truth is concerned some police officers are proven liars and convicted perjurers.

Hopefully that is counterbalanced by those officers who do the best job they can in nailing criminals - even those who may be discovered to be sullying the uniform they wear.

[Brietta]

The problem is that there is no longer any evidence in the public domain that Madeleine was abducted by a stranger. No confirmed sightings of the child, no sign of a break-in, nothing disturbed in the apartment, no ransom note etc etc

There are sworn witness statements in the public domain.

Evidence was destroyed when the bedclothes were taken away by the cleaners to be washed.

[John]

Maybe the blow she received from the shutters when she stuck her head out of the window knocked it completely from her mind.  Although I tend to think she would have noticed.

We covered this some time ago. Dissociative amnesia can result from extreme shock or trauma.

[sadie]

Nope you abuse your position, you have no idea that some suffer inadequacies.

it is very obvious that some of you suffer inadequances ... so sad
Eleanor was just stating the obvious


Others are smart arzez ... guess they can't help it.

[sadie]

The window that only had Kate McCann's fingerprints on?

There is no third-party evidence the window was ever opened by a stranger or even open before 10pm.

It also wasn't seen to be open when Matt Oldfield did his alleged bedroom walkby to listen in on the three children.

Matts original check of the walkby was before Gerrys thorough check.   We know nothing had happened by then.