The Evidence Madeleine Was Taken In A Criminal Act By A Stranger.

[G-Unit]

No not how you feel but how Kate would have felt.   You are proving again that you have no idea how someone would react when finding their child missing.   You seem intent on making out the McCann's were destroying evidence when first of all Kate is supposed to have opened the window to stage an abduction but leaving her fingerprints on it,  then closing it!!  How is that staging an abduction?   People entered 5a including the Police with dogs the Police left ash everywhere.   I don't think it was the McCann's who destroyed evidence.

One of the possibilities was woke and wandered, but Kate's evidence suggested that was unlikely.

[jassi]

Now just a minute here, how is your reply any evidence to show Maddie was abducted

Your post again is just telling me how I should feel....just because you do .

You believe Maddie was abducted ...I don't ...hence lack of compassion.

My point was why she closed the window...when she got back and not before she left twins still inside [destroying evidence, it seems if there was any]

Why when she took over 10 mins to search the apartment and knew Maddie had been taken and let 20-plus people into the room what was the point/motive for that? [destroying any evidence it seems, if there was any]

If Kate had done even a half competent search, then there was no reason at all to let others into the apartment, other than perhaps Gerry, who no doubt  have insisted on looking for himself anyway.
Every one else, including OC staff could have remained outwith, there being no reason to enter until the police arrived

[kizzy]

If Kate had done even a half competent search, then there was no reason at all to let others into the apartment, other than perhaps Gerry, who no doubt  have insisted on looking for himself anyway.
Every one else, including OC staff could have remained outwith, there being no reason to enter until the police arrived

Exactly, well-put.

[Lace]

If Kate had done even a half competent search, then there was no reason at all to let others into the apartment, other than perhaps Gerry, who no doubt  have insisted on looking for himself anyway.
Every one else, including OC staff could have remained outwith, there being no reason to enter until the police arrived

Of course you are talking after the event.   If you were the mother of the missing child your brain wouldn't be on who as entering the apartment but worrying about where your child was.

[kizzy]

No not how you feel but how Kate would have felt.   You are proving again that you have no idea how someone would react when finding their child missing.   You seem intent on making out the McCann's were destroying evidence when first of all Kate is supposed to have opened the window to stage an abduction but leaving her fingerprints on it,  then closing it!!  How is that staging an abduction?   People entered 5a including the Police with dogs the Police left ash everywhere.   I don't think it was the McCann's who destroyed evidence.

so you think fag ash and dog prints destroyed any evidence to prove Maddie was abducted.  OK.

Or, adding to the 20-plus people who had been in before them

[kizzy]

Of course you are talking after the event.   If you were the mother of the missing child your brain wouldn't be on who as entering the apartment but worrying about where your child was.

Well, she knew she had been taken after all.....so as long as it makes sense to you.

[Vertigo Swirl]

Of course you are talking after the event.   If you were the mother of the missing child your brain wouldn't be on who as entering the apartment but worrying about where your child was.

Exactly.  People with a shred of empathy and understanding get this.

[Lace]

so you think fag ash and dog prints destroyed any evidence to prove Maddie was abducted.  OK.

Or, adding to the 20-plus people who had been in before them

What are you talking about?   You were the one who mentioned destroying evidence,  who were the 20 plus people who entered 5a before the police?

[Lace]

Can you imagine what the anti McCann's would be saying if Kate had said 'don't come in it's a crime scene'.   It would be Kate telling the Police it was a crime scene,  trying to get the police to think there's been a crime committed.  Kate just can't win.

[jassi]

Of course you are talking after the event.   If you were the mother of the missing child your brain wouldn't be on who as entering the apartment but worrying about where your child was.

Just because you might fall to pieces doesn't mean that every one would.

A group of highly intelligent people, mostly doctors trained to deal with trauma certainly wouldn't and at least one of them ought to have been thinking straight enough to keep people out until the police arrived.
Certainly one was sufficiently detached to start finding & printing pictures and another  to draw up a timeline.

IMO

[Lace]

Well, she knew she had been taken after all.....so as long as it makes sense to you.

I'm a parent,  if I found my Child's bed empty and she was nowhere to be found,  I would immediately think she had been abducted,  I think most parents would.

[Lace]

Just because you might fall to pieces doesn't mean that every one would.

A group of highly intelligent people, mostly doctors trained to deal with trauma certainly wouldn't and at least one of them ought to have been thinking straight enough to keep people out until the police arrived.
Certainly one was sufficiently detached to start finding & printing pictures and another  to draw up a timeline.

IMO

Drs are trained to deal with trauma,  but not if it's their own child.

Who exactly printed off pictures?   Who exactly drew up a timeline,  I don't think it was the McCann's

[barrier]

Why would Kate say the window was open if it hadn't been?

When asked, On May 3, 2007, around 22:00, when you entered the apartment, what did you see? What did you do? Where did you look? What did you touch?


She gave no comment. But this is about what evidence that Madeleine was taken by a stranger .

[jassi]

Can you imagine what the anti McCann's would be saying if Kate had said 'don't come in it's a crime scene'.   It would be Kate telling the Police it was a crime scene,  trying to get the police to think there's been a crime committed.  Kate just can't win.

Kate knew that Madeleine wouldn't/couldn't wander therefore she must have been taken
In her mind there had been a crime committed.

[Lace]

When asked, On May 3, 2007, around 22:00, when you entered the apartment, what did you see? What did you do? Where did you look? What did you touch?


She gave no comment. But this is about what evidence that Madeleine was taken by a stranger .
[/quote





Kate had already answered those questions.   After being interrogated and more or less told she was lying.   it was a perfectly good response to the questions as they would try to twist what she said.