Where Is Amaral's Ace He Promised

[muratfan]

He claimed he could produce the evidence that proved beyond any doubt that Kate and Gerry killed Madeleine...

Well 4 years later ...still waiting  8-)(--) 8-)(--) 8-)(--)

[icabodcrane]

He claimed he cold produce the evidence that proved beyond any doubt that Kate and Gerry killed Madeleine...

Well 4 years later ...still waiting  8-)(--) 8-)(--) 8-)(--)

Did he  ? 

I thought he believed that Madeleine died as the result of an accident that occured when the McCanns were absent

Can you bring us the quote where he said the McCanns  'killed' their daughter, and he could prove it  ?

[muratfan]

Shall we say involved then, for arguments sake, as I am about to go to bed soon.

You mean the fridge, or the church, or the beach, or the incinerator...maybe his theory on the scenic wheel well (which they don't have)

Where is his ace then

[Luz]

Play nicely, Luz.

[Redblossom]

thats why its called an ace, you dont get to see it till the end, no? Sleep well then MF!

[Luz]

Muratfan,

my darling (if you call me love I'm entitled to ), you don't expect Mr. Amaral to reveal anything before the trial that he is waiting for, do you?

You may not like him, but you have to acknowledge that he is intelligent, and not only that, he is a smart ass of a cop with more than 27 years dealing with criminals.

Do you think that he caught as many criminals as he has by reveling his data to smartasses like you?!

Grow up sweettty, and now brush your teeth put your jemmies and go to bed.

(Edited: Sorry, the corrector assumed you really needed a bath before bed, not my fault "à la Mcann")

[gilet]

And just why would he not reveal something of such relevance to the case as soon as possible?

Is there no crime of "withholding evidence" in Portugal?  Here you can receive very serious punishment by our courts for holding back evidence from the police. As an ordinary citizen surely it is Amaral's duty to give whatever evidence he has to the police as soon as he can?

Or does he not believe in duty, but just in saving evidence for his own trial to save his own neck?

[Redblossom]

Nothing to do with withholding evidence is it? more to do wih divulging it in public! And we all know what happened last time the mccanns were in court when things were divulged in public! Gerry got a hernia and went home!

kate never had a dream
Pj files say yes, its redorded which makes you wonder why he made a song and dance about it

[Luz]

And just why would he not reveal something of such relevance to the case as soon as possible?

Is there no crime of "withholding evidence" in Portugal?  Here you can receive very serious punishment by our courts for holding back evidence from the police. As an ordinary citizen surely it is Amaral's duty to give whatever evidence he has to the police as soon as he can?

Or does he not believe in duty, but just in saving evidence for his own trial to save his own neck?

To the likes of you?! What for?

You don't know what he has done with the information he has and that's what has been consuming you lot, hasn't it?! It's so funny to see you twist like little "lombrigas".

You may twist but you will not get the slightest shread of info.

Wait patiently and enjoy.

[gilet]

Please have some respect and read the posts you are replying to.

There is nothing in my post which suggests Amaral should reveal anything to me and you would know that if you bothered to read.

My post made it very clear that he should give his evidence to the police not hold it to the end as Redblossom claimed.  It is his duty as a citizen to report evidence about a crime to the police (if he has any).

Your post is a hysterical rant based on nothing at all that I posted.

[Redblossom]

Please have some respect and read the posts you are replying to.

There is nothing in my post which suggests Amaral should reveal anything to me and you would know that if you bothered to read.

My post made it very clear that he should give his evidence to the police not hold it to the end as Redblossom claimed.  It is his duty as a citizen to report evidence about a crime to the police (if he has any).

Your post is a hysterical rant based on nothing at all that I posted.

pls dont misquote me, i never said he held evidence back, as you pontificate, read the posts properly

[gilet]

Nothing to do with withholding evidence is it? more to do wih divulging it in public! And we all know what happened last time the mccanns were in court when things were divulged in public! Gerry got a hernia and went home!

kate never had a dream
Pj files say yes, its redorded which makes you wonder why he made a song and dance about it

Your suggestion that he is "holding it to the end" is clearly something to do with withholding evidence. Perhaps you should remember what you have just posted before because it makes you look foolish when you mess up like that.

As for a dream, what has that got to do with this thread? Are you trying to distract this thread now?

[gilet]

Please have some respect and read the posts you are replying to.

There is nothing in my post which suggests Amaral should reveal anything to me and you would know that if you bothered to read.

My post made it very clear that he should give his evidence to the police not hold it to the end as Redblossom claimed.  It is his duty as a citizen to report evidence about a crime to the police (if he has any).

Your post is a hysterical rant based on nothing at all that I posted.

pls dont misquote me, i never said he held evidence back, as you pontificate, read the posts properly

I did not even quote you, never mind misquote you.

What I accurately reported you as implying was that Amaral was holding his evidence till the end and therefore not revealing it even to the police which it is his duty to do.

Careful reading does pay dividends when you are seeking the truth.

[Redblossom]

Nothing to do with withholding evidence is it? more to do wih divulging it in public! And we all know what happened last time the mccanns were in court when things were divulged in public! Gerry got a hernia and went home!

kate never had a dream
Pj files say yes, its redorded which makes you wonder why he made a song and dance about it

Your suggestion that he is "holding it to the end" is clearly something to do with withholding evidence. Perhaps you should remember what you have just posted before because it makes you look foolish when you mess up like that.

As for a dream, what has that got to do with this thread? Are you trying to distract this thread now?

All I can say is learn to read

I am sure you are not that stupid  to understand what I posted, then again, if you have to ask questions, maybe

Holding an ace does not mean evidenxe is withheld
Secondly my point with the dream example was that evidence was always there but never made public, no ones ace here, just an example that something which is part of evidence can come out at any time, now do you see? Perhaps you can offer a reason why gerry bust a gut to say it was untrue when its recorded in the files, hmmm

[Redblossom]

Please have some respect and read the posts you are replying to.

There is nothing in my post which suggests Amaral should reveal anything to me and you would know that if you bothered to read.

My post made it very clear that he should give his evidence to the police not hold it to the end as Redblossom claimed.  It is his duty as a citizen to report evidence about a crime to the police (if he has any).

Your post is a hysterical rant based on nothing at all that I posted.

pls dont misquote me, i never said he held evidence back, as you pontificate, read the posts properly

I did not even quote you, never mind misquote you.

What I accurately reported you as implying was that Amaral was holding his evidence till the end and therefore not revealing it even to the police which it is his duty to do.

Careful reading does pay dividends when you are seeking the truth.

your post suggested that I said amaral had evidence that he never reported to the police, so therefore, yes, it was a misquote of what i posted earlier on in the thread, which WAS, not that he is withholdong evidence but that he is not TALKING about in in public,streugh like getting blood out of a stone

Your post

My post made it very clear that he should give his evidence to the police not hold it to the end as Redblossom claimed