The CCTV camera which Amaral claimed captured the image of the man carrying Madeleine.

[Angelo222]

Where have you heard that ?

Have you not read the article?  Why do you think he is standing there anyway?

[jassi]

Have you not read the article?  Why do you think he is standing there anyway?

You mean it's not photoshopped ? 

[Angelo222]

This was the story run by the Mirror.

http://www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/cctv-madeleine-mccann-snatcher-deleted-2467839


and the Daily Star.

http://www.dailystar.co.uk/news/latest-news/346071/Detective-admits-regret-at-deleted-CCTV-footage-of-Madeleine-McCann-snatcher


and the Daily Express.

http://www.express.co.uk/news/uk/210032/Madeleine-McCann-Did-the-camera-hold-vital-clue

[AnneGuedes]

Have you not read the article?  Why do you think he is standing there anyway?

I read it, I think, when it was published : typical tabloid work. When you're a very nice boy those things happen to you..

[AnneGuedes]

You mean it's not photoshopped ? 

[Mr Moderator]

Its called goading and is unacceptable behaviour wherever it comes from.

Yes and so is criticism of moderators by members who have a long history of warnings for inappropriate postings.

If a member doesn't want to answer a question that is their prerogative. Repeated bumping and goading will achieve nothing.

[Angelo222]

Paul Luckman, editor of 'The Portugal News', describes to Sky's Robert Nisbet the route Madeleine McCann's abductor is thought to have taken.



Quote re Goncalo Amaral...

"He is convinced that whoever was carrying the child walked down this road..."

"He was  furious that his officers never found that camera..."

[Angelo222]

Paul Luckman, editor of 'The Portugal News', describes to Sky's Robert Nisbet the route Madeleine McCann's abductor is thought to have taken.



Quote re Goncalo Amaral...

"He is convinced that whoever was carrying the child walked down this road..."

"He was  furious that his officers never found that camera..."

[AnneGuedes]

Paul Luckman, editor of 'The Portugal News', describes to Sky's Robert Nisbet the route Madeleine McCann's abductor is thought to have taken.



Quote re Goncalo Amaral...

"He is convinced that whoever was carrying the child walked down this road..."

"He was  furious that his officers never found that camera..."

Paul Luckman likely read the tabloids...
Right after the case was shelved, Gonçalo Amaral claimed it shouldn't be. He has been the only one to say so during quite a time.
Once he got back his right to express himself on the case, he made some attempts to suggest that there were leads to explore. I'm pretty sure however that Gonçalo Amaral doesn't know more than us.

[Angelo222]

Mr Amaral was very clear about the significance of the hotel CCTV camera and was angry that because the Smiths delayed in coming forward the delay resulted in the video footage being lost.  It wasn't his officers fault that the film was lost.

Where have you heard that ?

Have I answered your question Anne.  It came from Amaral.

[AnneGuedes]

Where have you heard that ?



Have I answered your question Anne.  It came from Amaral.

Well, no, sorry Angelo... I've never heard Mr Amaral saying this. I suppose he spoke of this camera but what did he say exactly ? Imo it sounds like the mystery of the pink blanket, the one that disappeared... in the country of apparitions..

[Angelo222]

Well he told Luckman that he was furious that his officers hadn't collected the video footage from the hotel CCTV.  Nobody, least of all him ever dreamt that the abductor walked that way until the Smiths report came in.  Thus if Amaral is furious with anyone it is with the Smiths.

[AnneGuedes]

Well he told Luckman that he was furious that his officers hadn't collected the video footage from the hotel CCTV.  Nobody, least of all him ever dreamt that the abductor walked that way until the Smiths report came in.  Thus if Amaral is furious with anyone it is with the Smiths.

Hum hum.. Are you sure GA spoke to Mr Luckman ?
And, no, he can't have been furious with the Smiths (I can't figure out this man as "furious", after having observed him during those court sessions). He could, yes, be furious with himself, because they should have done a reconstitution with the Smiths, taking into account the sound issue (sounds gain interest in the darkness).
Let's face it, the Smiths were called to PDL in the hope they would identify Mr Murat. Their denial should have opened a new and crucial lead, as their description of the little girl so well matched Madeleine. It didn't.

[Sherlock Holmes]

Hum hum.. Are you sure GA spoke to Mr Luckman ?
And, no, he can't have been furious with the Smiths (I can't figure out this man as "furious", after having observed him during those court sessions). He could, yes, be furious with himself, because they should have done a reconstitution with the Smiths, taking into account the sound issue (sounds gain interest in the darkness).
Let's face it, the Smiths were called to PDL in the hope they would identify Mr Murat. Their denial should have opened a new and crucial lead, as their description of the little girl so well matched Madeleine. It didn't.

Luckman says at the very start of the clip 'He walked me through the route'.

It appears they walked though the town together discussing the case.

[AnneGuedes]

Luckman says at the very start of the clip 'He walked me through the route'.

It appears they walked though the town together discussing the case.

Yes, thank you for making me look at the clip and sorry, Angelo, for not understanding why you sent the clip proving that GA met Mr Luckman !
But the furor seems to be Mr Luckman's interpretation.
Do you think the camera spots the point where Mr Luckman and the SkyNews journalist are at the very beginning ?