Poll - Scent Dogs Accuracy

[Redblossom]

I have just been sent this.......

'From his rogatory in 2008

In this case in particular, where the dogs alerted there was confirmation by positive results from the forensic examinations. It is the investigators' responsibility to apply the results of the forensic analysis to the suspects, witnesses and crime scenes.'

http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/MARTIN_GRIMES_RIGATORY.htm

Correct. I posted about this a couple weeks ago against misleading claims that Grime had stated the dog alerts had no value in this case, and got ignored, something he never actually never said, good post


 

[Lyall]

cant find that statement anywhere on that link

It's in there though

[Mr Gray]

Correct. I posted about this a couple weeks ago against misleading claims that Grime had stated the dog alerts had no value in this case, and got ignored, something he never actually never said, good post


 

The statement you have claimed does not exist on the link provided...could you provide the correct link...I think you are quoting out of context,....


The quotes I posted are taken directly from the mccannn files..these are GENUINE  grime quotes

[Mr Gray]

It's in there though

Sorry but you continue to avoid giving the correct link...lets have the full quote as well... I guarantee red is WRONG

[Sherlock Holmes]

What's the relevance of doggies to the opening of the investigation?

[Lyall]

Sorry but you continue to avoid giving the correct link...lets have the full quote as well... I guarantee red is WRONG

>@@(*&) How much are you wagering?

[Mr Gray]

What's the relevance of doggies to the opening of the investigation?

I agree its off topic but this claim cannot go unchallenged..imo red is seriously misleading posters

[Mr Gray]

Oh dear,  is someone having kittens in thread for some unfathomable reason?

no Im just asking for corroboration.  .but theres none...a bit like the dogs alerts

[Mr Gray]

Read the page

I've read the page..I don't see this statement....  .why don't you just copy the whole paragraph and not just one sentence...certainly blood was found on the key fob but the alerts re cadaver contaminant were not corroborated

[Mr Gray]

SO ..if we can recap  Grime said the dogs alerts had no evidential value...the alerts by the evrd dog were not corroborated....the one by the blood dog on the key fob was....conclusion..NO EVIDENCE OF A CADAVER IN 5A

[Lyall]

I've read the page..I don't see this statement....  .why don't you just copy the whole paragraph and not just one sentence...certainly blood was found on the key fob but the alerts re cadaver contaminant were not corroborated

It's only the third paragraph

[Mr Gray]

It's only the third paragraph

Thank you....so...which alerts were corroborated...all of them ...some of them....one of them...this is important as posters are accusing the McCanns of quite serious crimes

[Lyall]

Thank you....so...which alerts were corroborated...all of them ...some of them....one of them...this is important as posters are accusing the McCanns of quite serious crimes

Davel, you agree this was one of the most high-profile cases in the world, if not the most?

Do you really think Mr Grime or anyone else is going to go into detail in writing?

[Mr Gray]

Davel, you agree this was one of the most high-profile cases in the world, if not the most?

Do you really think Mr Grime or anyone else is going to go into detail in writing?

 I think grime could have been more straightforward but he was setting himself up in business...plus its his job to collect evidence not to comment on it...what I would say is that Grime said that the alerts had no evidential value without corroboration and there was no corroboration of the evrd dogs alerts

[Lyall]

  not sure I denied it..try not to do denial...I said I couldn't see it...I wanted someone to point out where it was and you did...the statement means nothing....Im going to look at the Portuguese tomorrow to see what it says

It means he was being very careful with his words, like everyone else involved in this case. For obvious reasons.

That's all we can say.

Because none of us are experts.