The Portuguese Police thought the dogs were 100% accurate.

[icabodcrane]

you don't s deal in facts at all ...you deal in suppositions

By the same argument you use no one can say with certainty that maddie was not abducted by the CIA on the orders of obama

What nonsense

The dog alerted in the apartment where a missing child was last seen alive  ...  that is beyond question

Neither you,   nor anyone else,  can claim that his alert was  not    because he detected the scent of the missing child's dead body

You know you can't

[Mr Gray]

What nonsense

The dog alerted in the apartment where a missing child was last seen alive  ...  that is beyond question

Neither you,   nor anyone else,  can claim that his alert was  not    because he detected the scent of the missing child's dead body

You know you can't

And you cant prove the CIA were not involved...justice is about what you can prove...not what you cant prove...its a celestial teapot argument

[ferryman]

What nonsense

The dog alerted in the apartment where a missing child was last seen alive  ...  that is beyond question

Neither you,   nor anyone else,  can claim that his alert was  not    because he detected the scent of the missing child's dead body

You know you can't

The dogs alerted in an apartment where a man cut himself shaving, bled for 45 minutes, paced the whole apartment during the time that the cut bled ...

And in the same investigation, the cadaver dog is known, definitely, to have erred with at least one, apparent, reaction -- to cuddle cat.

That, combined with the way the dog was deployed, casts a questionmark over the whole role of the dogs in that investigation.

[pathfinder73]

That weak DNA had 15 alleles that matched Madeleine - behind the sofa. That man was hiding behind the sofa with his razor.

[ferryman]

That weak DNA had 15 alleles that matched Madeleine - behind the sofa. That man was hiding behind the sofa with his razor.

Why were clothes, present in the villa during the inspection of the villa that weren't alerted to there, apparently, alerted to in the gym?

[pathfinder73]

Were the clothes bagged up? Where were Kate's trousers when they inspected the villa?

[ferryman]

Were the clothes bagged up? Where were Kate's trousers when they inspected the villa?

In the villa.

Unalerted to ...

[pathfinder73]

Those pants may have been in the suitcase. I can't see them on the villa video. Saw this book next to Interpretation of Murder:

Spirit Messenger, remarkable autobiography from Glasgow's world-respected medium, Gordon Smith. This, Gordon's first book provides a unique insight into the life of an ordinary person coming to terms with extraordinary gifts. Gordon discovered at a young age that he could communicate with dead people but it wasn't until he was in his mid-twenties that he actually accepted this exceptional power and realised the comfort it could bring to people who had lost their loved ones. Gordon has since brought comfort and healing to thousands of people in the messages he has delivered from the Other Side. Written in Gordon's humorous and down-to-earth manner, Spirit Messenger gives an enthralling account of his life communicating with spirits and shares Gordon's practical advice on avoiding tricksters to find true connection with the spirit world. With a foreward written by Prof. Archie E Roy, Emeritus Professor of Astronomy, Glasgow Universtiy who has studied Gordon's mediumship under scientific conditions, this book is a great read whether you are a sceptic, a believer or just want to know more

[Carana]

That weak DNA had 15 alleles that matched Madeleine - behind the sofa. That man was hiding behind the sofa with his razor.

???

Where did you find anything about 15 matching alleles behind the sofa?

[AnneGuedes]

Don't know anything about that flim flam

[pathfinder73]

???

Where did you find anything about 15 matching alleles behind the sofa?

Sorry my mistake it was the car boot.

[Sherlock Holmes]

Cute isn't it, Anne, the flim flam.  Never heard Bernard Russell called that before.

Point is that the matter is impossible to prove disprove either way, on current evidence at least.

[AnneGuedes]

Cute isn't it, Anne, the flim flam.  Never heard Bernard Russell called that before.

Point is that the matter is impossible to prove disprove either way, on current evidence at least.

Point is that Icabodcrane didn't call Bernard Russell "flim flam", however cute it is, but referred to Davel confounding his person with BR instead of disproving that Madeleine is orbiting the sun.

[icabodcrane]

Point is that Icabodcrane didn't call Bernard Russell "flim flam", however cute it is, but referred to Davel confounding his person with BR instead of disproving that Madeleine is orbiting the sun.

Thanks for defending my post Anne  (  much appreciated  )

The  'cute'  flim flam'  expression was related to davel's use of that well worn propaganda technique, Antirationalism 

 ... promoting the idea that there are no such things as valid, reliable facts, or hard evidence, just various conflicting opinions

It is a dodge  to avoid the truth that,  yes ...  we  can   know some things for sure

[Cariad]

the truth...your posts are full of may and may nots....I have to laugh when you talk about about the truth

I love Icadbods posts. S/he so often makes the points I'm trying to make, but in a much more articulate manner.

.