Ricardo Paiva, "Kate McCann had a dream where she saw Maddie on a hillside"

[Alfred R Jones]

I don't believe anything, I wasnt there, I have no idea what he was asked, it matters not, the only thing that matters is a)if Madeleine Mccann is dead or alive andb) who is responsible for both scenarios

What a cop out.  You have 'no opinion' on why Paiva cited a dream as a major turning point in the case because you know full well it's bloody absurd and you can't bring youself to admit it.   

[pathfinder73]

Did they hire Dani Krugel?
I was under the impression he did it pro bono.

Quote
All services Danie have provided this far have been free off charge. In the majority of cases Danie paid his own travel and accommodation expenses and sacrificed benefits provided by his employer. Unquote
http://www.daniekrugelfacts.com/

There is no doubt that Mr Krugel advertises his successes in finding living people ... and that is what the Drs McCann are looking for ... their live daughter.

The thought arises though ... if Madeleine's remains have been pin pointed ... why haven't they been retrieved?

I don't care if they hired but they requested him personally to come and search for a body. A missing child living on the beach or cliffs 3 months later.

[mercury]

Did they hire Dani Krugel?
I was under the impression he did it pro bono.

Quote
All services Danie have provided this far have been free off charge. In the majority of cases Danie paid his own travel and accommodation expenses and sacrificed benefits provided by his employer. Unquote
http://www.daniekrugelfacts.com/

There is no doubt that Mr Krugel advertises his successes in finding living people ... and that is what the Drs McCann are looking for ... their live daughter.

The thought arises though ... if Madeleine's remains have been pin pointed ... why haven't they been retrieved?

Well  lets just say the PJ didnt bring him in, the Mccanns did for "some reason"

[Brietta]

I don't care if they hired but they requested him personally to come and search for a body. A missing child living on the beach or cliffs 3 months later.

The point is that Dani Krugel advertised that he was able to prove success in locating and recovering missing people.

Since Madeleine went missing in Praia da Luz, that would be the obvious starting point to look for her.  There is nothing to say she might not have been living in one of the residences in the town or the outskirts.

Madeleine's parents were seeking assistance to find a living child.

You didn't answer my question ... if Mr Krugel's assessment was correct, why has there been no recovery?

[sadie]

Well  lets just say the PJ didnt bring him in, the Mccanns did for "some reason"

Yep, The Mccanns brought him in.

I would have thought that the reason for that was obvious.

if your child had gone missing, wouldn't you want everyone that might possibly help bought in?   Or wouldn't you bother?

[mercury]

Yep, The Mccanns brought him in.

I would have thought that the reason for that was obvious.

if your child had gone missing, wouldn't you want everyone that might possibly help bought in?   Or wouldn't you bother?

My post was in response to Brietta asking did the Mccanns hire Krugel?
So I answered yes they did, Ok?

[sadie]

My post was in response to Brietta asking did the Mccanns hire Krugel?
So I answered yes they did, Ok?

You said

Well  lets just say the PJ didnt bring him in, the Mccanns did for "some reason"

Intimating that the Mccanns must have had a nefarious reason for bringing him in.



Wouldn't you bring in anyone you could that might help if YOUR child was missing?
Or wouldn't you bother?

[mercury]

You said

Intimating that the Mccanns must have had a nefarious reason for bringing him in.



Wouldn't you bring in anyone you could that might help if YOUR child was missing?
Or wouldn't you bother?

The notion that I intimated something "nefarious" rests only in your imagination. My "some reason" comment merely referred to Krugel's wierd method of placing a missing person's hair into some  machine and miraculously finding them! And seeing as the Mccanns are of the scientific bent, I wondered why. OK now? That was all.

[G-Unit]

The notion that I intimated something "nefarious" rests only in your imagination. My "some reason" comment merely referred to Krugel's wierd method of placing a missing person's hair into some  machine and miraculously finding them! And seeing as the Mccanns are of the scientific bent, I wondered why. OK now? That was all.

Are they of a scientific bent I wonder? They seem very keen on physics and they're not scientifically verifiable.

[mercury]

Are they of a scientific bent I wonder? They seem very keen on physics and they're not scientifically verifiable.

There is reference in the files even for that, well remembered and noted

http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/BOATS_VISION.htm

But when it came to the dogs, Kate Mccann criticised them saying they weren't very scientific.

[Mr Gray]

There is reference in the files even for that, well remembered and noted

http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/BOATS_VISION.htm

But when it came to the dogs, Kate Mccann criticised them saying they weren't very scientific.

If the mccanns knew what had happened to maddie why check out the psychic
.....;

[mercury]

If the mccanns knew what had happened to maddie why check out the psychic
.....;

Why not?

[Mr Gray]

Why not?

Because it doesn't make any sense

[G-Unit]

If the mccanns knew what had happened to maddie why check out the psychic
.....;

The psychic who had the 'boat' vision was a friend of the Rothley Kennedy's. Kate wasn't going to say 'thanks, but no thanks' was she?

[Mr Gray]

The psychic who had the 'boat' vision was a friend of the Rothley Kennedy's. Kate wasn't going to say 'thanks, but no thanks' was she?

So are you now saying Kate didn't have any faith in the psychics