Statistically...what are the chances that Maddie was abducted..

[Mr Gray]

Credible ?

i.e. credible, if it doesn't lay the blame of Madeleine's disappearance where it belongs.

Pray tell why is sadie's theory any more credible than Birch, and you know what I think about him ?

The irony being, I know someone who believes Birch's theories.

Didnt say i agree with sadies theory
I do agree with her that posters rubbish other peoples theories but dont present one themselves.   ....

[Lyall]

Didnt say i agree with sadies theory
I do agree with her that posters rubbish other peoples theories but dont present one themselves.   ....

And you know very well why that is.

[stephen25000]

And you know very well why that is.

Indeed.

[Mr Gray]

And you know very well why that is.

  Do you mean your posts would be libellous because there is no evidence to support them

[Lyall]

  Do you mean your posts would be libellous because there is no evidence to support them

I am not a lawyer.

But this is somebody else's forum in any case.

[Cariad]

I'm with Sadie on this...many posters want to rubbish other posters ideas but don't come up with any credible scenarios themselves.

So it's not ok to say 'I don't know what happened to Madeleine' as I repeatedly have? I need to come up with a scenario of my own, which I have to believe is 100% accurate before I can express an opinion on this case?

Sorry, can't do that. There is practically no evidence to support anything! The best I can do is say that something is a bit iffy in my opinion. The best you can say is that you don't believe the parents were involved.

Demanding that I supply some theory based on nothing is pointless. See previous Elvis/unicorn/alternate dimension one is you do insist. It'll do as a stand in for now and isn't that incredible compared with some I've seen.

[Redblossom]

Not sure what you are on about.. but there is a list of UK  registered peados who were in PDL at the time.. Portugal at the time did not have such list.. but there were also people from other countries lists, for the countries that have a Register.  The unregistered we are not counting ;)

You sure about that? Only read there were some in Portugal

Which is a vastly wider space, happy to be corrected though....

[jassi]

You sure about that? Only read there were some in Portugal

Which is a vastly wider space, happy to be corrected though....

Ah, but don't you know, PDL is a veritable lodestone for paedophiles, attracting them from far and wide, just so they can lurk, upsetting the visitors. 

[Redblossom]

So it's not ok to say 'I don't know what happened to Madeleine' as I repeatedly have? I need to come up with a scenario of my own, which I have to believe is 100% accurate before I can express an opinion on this case?

Sorry, can't do that. There is practically no evidence to support anything! The best I can do is say that something is a bit iffy in my opinion. The best you can say is that you don't believe the parents were involved.

Demanding that I supply some theory based on nothing is pointless. See previous Elvis/unicorn/alternate dimension one is you do insist. It'll do as a stand in for now and isn't that incredible compared with some I've seen.

Well said!

[Redblossom]

Ah, but don't you know, PDL is a veritable lodestone for paedophiles, attracting them from far and wide, just so they can lurk, upsetting the visitors.

Well, we had the Portugal is "awash with paedophiles" headlines and Kate Mccann accusing Portugal of hiding things..., but PDL? Never heard such a thing! I guess no child was ever in PDL to attract one before Madeleine Mccan! *snortle*
then again it was a robbery gone wrong according to some theorists....,,,



 >@@(*&)

[Wonderfulspam]

Ah, but don't you know, PDL is a veritable lodestone for paedophiles, attracting them from far and wide, just so they can lurk, upsetting the visitors.

The Algarve is awash with paedophiles. And if weren't them what did it then it must be drug addicted burglars, failing that it could be alcoholics, tax evaders or illegal street traders.

[Redblossom]

The Algarve is awash with paedophiles. And if weren't them what did it then it must be drug addicted burglars, failing that it could be alcoholics, tax evaders or illegal street traders.

I cant recall anyone who couldnt be a suspect.......they all are

[Mr Gray]

So it's not ok to say 'I don't know what happened to Madeleine' as I repeatedly have? I need to come up with a scenario of my own, which I have to believe is 100% accurate before I can express an opinion on this case?

Sorry, can't do that. There is practically no evidence to support anything! The best I can do is say that something is a bit iffy in my opinion. The best you can say is that you don't believe the parents were involved.

Demanding that I supply some theory based on nothing is pointless. See previous Elvis/unicorn/alternate dimension one is you do insist. It'll do as a stand in for now and isn't that incredible compared with some I've seen.

 What I am saying is that it is irrrritating that when you state an opinion...as I have done...some posters like to ridicule you wheras they are unwilling to put their head above the parapet...I am certainly not deluded...do not have  a closed mind...am not in the pay of the McCanns ...am not a crap parent. I am used to  looking at evidence and assessing evidence...from what I have seen the McCanns are not criminally involved in Maddies disappearance... I think there is plenty of evidence to show that they are not the type of parent who would harm their daughter

[Wonderfulspam]

What I am saying is that it is irrrritating that when you state an opinion...as I have done...some posters like to ridicule you wheras they are unwilling to put their head above the parapet...I am certainly not deluded...do not have  a closed mind...am not in the pay of the McCanns ...am not a crap parent. I am used to  looking at evidence and assessing evidence...from what I have seen the McCanns are not criminally involved in Maddies disappearance... I think there is plenty of evidence to show that they are not the type of parent who would harm their daughter

They could have harmed her unintentionally.

[Redblossom]

They could have harmed her unintentionally.

Or she could have come to harm when they were out....the amount of people accusing others of saying they murdered her is ridiculous....when no one to my knowledge has ever said that.....