Statistically...what are the chances that Maddie was abducted..

[jassi]

Sorry that doesnt make sense....if he wanted to sight madeleine why not poke hs nose in instead of looking in other rooms?

Process of elimination - he never actually considered that one might be missing altogether.

[Redblossom]

Process of elimination - he never actually considered that one might be missing altogether.

but why bother go check in another room? In the first place

[jassi]

but why bother go check in another room? In the first place

So as not to disturb the sleeping beauties - if she wasn't anywhere else, she must be in her bed.

[Redblossom]

So as not to disturb the sleeping beauties - if she wasn't anywhere else, she must be in her bed.

Oh ok makes perfect sense, thanks jassi

 

[pathfinder73]

Sorry that doesnt make sense....if he wanted to sight madeleine why not poke hs nose in instead of looking in other rooms?

I don't know why he was being nosy looking in other rooms but he said it was quiet so presumed everything was fine. He could have put his head in to check but he would've found her missing if he did IMO. I still don't think it matters too much because he didn't move her out of the apartment. Unless he dyed his hair before the Smith sighting.

[Redblossom]

I don't know why he was being nosy looking in other rooms but he said it was quiet so presumed everything was fine. He could have put his head in to check but he would've found her missing if he did IMO. I still don't think it matters too much because he didn't move her out of the apartment. Unless his dyed his hair before the Smith sighting.

No I dont suspect Oldfield either at all, but I dont trust his video "performance" ..no doubt Gerry engineered, yawn

[AnneGuedes]

I'm not convinced he even entered 5A, personally. I think that it's more likely that the regular checks were fabricated to make them all look less negligent.

Neither am I. Suppress Mr Oldfield, and things look more every half hour manner. Mr McCann comes back at 21:15 and it's Mrs McCann's turn at 21:45.
As Mr Oldfield had listened at the shutters at 21 and as he really checked on his daughter at 21:30, he was asked to say he checked visually right after in order to reduce the negligence aspect.
Where was Madeleine at 21:30 ?

[pathfinder73]

No I dont suspect Oldfield either at all, but I dont trust his video "performance" ..no doubt Gerry engineered, yawn

Matt believes they are innocent but some of the info he has provided goes against the McCann's version. Fiona told him to go not Gerry. Another attempt for an alibi for Gerry in those very important first 10 minutes of the searches so he couldn't be seen to be somewhere else but Matt said it was Fiona who asked him and he should know as he went lol. Another alibi goes up in smoke just like the other alibi attempt of doing forensics on the shutters instead of searching with the others for his daughter - nobody believes that one either and is confirmed by Russell "Gerry said, Let's all split up and find her!" The other alibi of the night crèche is that nobody saw him there. It doesn't look good with all these desperate attempts of getting an alibi. The only one he has left is Kate - Gerry was with me. Funny Dianne said you were all alone when she was checking the shutters for you.

[Mr Gray]

Oh come on davel! Last night you said there was evidence to support abduction, I've asked you repeatedly to share that evidence. I understand that you have a life out side the forum and needed to do the school run ect, but to coming back almost 24 hours later and basically ask me the same question that I asked you, is pretty poor!

You stated that there is evidence of abduction, share it please!

maddie was put to bed and later disappeared...the shutter was forced up from the outside and the window opened...
enough to support the belief that Maddie was abducted.

[icabodcrane]

maddie was put to bed and later disappeared...the shutter was forced up from the outside and the window opened...
enough to support the belief that Maddie was abducted.

There is no evidence that  the shutter was   'forced up from the outside'   ...  there never was 

tsk tsk   

[Redblossom]

Matt believes they are innocent but some of the info he has provided goes against the McCann's version. Fiona told him to go not Gerry. Another attempt for an alibi for Gerry in those very important first 10 minutes of the searches so he couldn't be seen to be somewhere else but Matt said it was Fiona who asked him and he should know as he went lol. Another alibi goes up in smoke just like the other alibi attempt of doing forensics on the shutters instead of searching with the others for his daughter - nobody believes that one either and is confirmed by Russell "Gerry said, Let's all split up and find her!" The other alibi of the night crèche is that nobody saw him there. It doesn't look good with all these desperate attempts of getting an alibi. The only one he has left is Kate - Gerry was with me. Funny Dianne said you were all alone when she was checking the shutters for you.

I just hope SY have spent these last two and a half years going through everything with a fine comb

[Redblossom]

There is no evidence that  the shutter was   'forced up from the outside'   ...  there never was 

tsk tsk

Of course there isnt....its hearsay

[jassi]

I just hope SY have spent these last two and a half years going through everything with a fine comb

I bet they have. It'll all be in a file labelled 'Not to be opened until 2074'

[Mr Gray]

There is no evidence that  the shutter was   'forced up from the outside'   ...  there never was 

tsk tsk

of course there was..there is  a witness statement...that is evidence...that's why witnesses give EVIDENCE in the form of a witness statement in court

[Redblossom]

I bet they have. It'll all be in a file labelled 'Not to be opened until 2074'

Jesus Christ!!